The Hive bee sealUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
Transparency · TR 300.25← Transparency home · ← Hive library (every repo)
Transparency · Case File · Statewide

Holding Power: How the Rules Kept One Party in Charge

Maps, petition rules, voter-passed laws, the courts and new appointed boards: what the Legislature changed while one party held two-thirds of it, with the votes and each side's own words.

Statewide

CASE 2026-WGS-02 · Posted Nov. 8, 2026 · Updated Nov. 8, 2026

New to this? Read it in plain words About 500 words, with simple charts.
Transparency pages (33) · tap to open
  1. Transparency docketEvery case file, searchable
  2. Who Gets a Say · plain wordsUtah's primary and map rules, 2018–2026
  3. Holding Power · plain wordsHow the rules kept one party in charge
  4. Selling the Vote · plain wordsThe business of political marketing in Utah
  5. Lost Ideals · plain wordsWhat Utah promised its voters
  6. The Fracture · plain wordsWhy Utahns say no party represents them
  7. It Happened Before · plain wordsUtah controversies and how they ended
  8. The 2026 Amendments · plain wordsAmendments A and B on your ballot
  9. Amendment B: Myth vs. Fact · plain wordsClaims checked against the record
  10. Amendment B QuizTest what you know
  11. Who Sits at the Taxpayers Association's Table · plain wordsIts leaders, lobbyists, sponsors and their money
  12. Weber Housing Authority · plain wordsA commissioner, his wife and the authority that pays their company
  13. What the Privacy Office Can and Can't Do · plain wordsUtah's Chief Privacy Officer
  14. Counting the Jobs · plain wordsJob promises and what was reported
  15. Matt Brower · plain wordsThe board seat that never came up
  16. Ten Days · plain wordsThe Nilson Foundation's 501(c)(3) claim
  17. One Vote, Four Checks · plain wordsS.B. 258 and preliminary municipalities
  18. The Land Counties Can't Zone · plain wordsTrust land and county zoning
  19. SITLA: The Land Nobody Zones · plain wordsWho answers for trust land
  20. Tyson Leaves Eagle Mountain · plain wordsFive years after opening
  21. Behind the Bench · plain wordsJudge and lawyer complaints in Utah
  22. Wrong Room, Right Message · plain wordsA housing adviser in Heber City
  23. Every Weber County Property Tax Increase Since 2019 · plain wordsThe full list
  24. A New Line on the Bill · plain wordsRoy and Riverdale fire annexation
  25. Paying for the Next Station · plain wordsHow Weber Fire District funds growth
  26. Weber County's New Sales Tax · plain wordsA public vote, but no vote by the public
  27. Bills That Did the Opposite · plain wordsBait and switch, 2018 to 2026
  28. The Blank Box · plain wordsThree disclosure forms, one pattern
  29. Utah's Campaign-Finance Enforcement Gap · plain wordsComplaints filed, few penalties
  30. One Lake, Two Money Pots · plain wordsThe Great Salt Lake Trust Council
  31. Wells at the Top · plain wordsPowder Mountain's water
  32. Then vs. Now · plain wordsEarlier plans and later approvals in Ogden Valley
  33. West Haven's 6% Energy Tax · plain wordsA new line on the power bill
Still being checked
Built from public records, court records and news reports, and still going through fact checks. Seat counts before 2011 come from a secondary table and are being checked against official rosters. 2026 results are unofficial until the Nov. 23 canvass. This page reports what was done, with votes and dates; it does not claim to know anyone's motive.

The short version

1985
Republicans have held the governor's office since this year
61–14
House seats, Republicans to Democrats, before the 2026 election
50
House seats needed for two-thirds (veto override)
22
Legislative races with no general-election opponent in 2024

Who held the seats

PeriodWhat the record shows
1965Democrats held both chambers and the governor (Cal Rampton, 1965–77).
1967Republicans won large majorities in both chambers.
1977–85Democrat Scott Matheson was governor; Republicans held the Legislature from 1979.
1985 onRepublicans have held the governor's office since Norman Bangerter.
2001 onRepublicans held two-thirds of both chambers (Senate 20–9, House 51–24 in 2001). Sources differ on the exact start, from the late 1990s to 2001. Republicans have held the attorney general's office since 2001.
2025–26House 61–14; Senate 22 Republicans, 6 Democrats, 1 Forward.
Nov. 3, 2026Unofficial: Democrats and unaffiliated candidates on track to flip about 15 House seats and 2 Senate seats. The last comparable Democratic gain was 1986, during anger over tax increases (KUTV, 11/4/2026; Salt Lake Tribune).

Seat counts before 2011: Wikipedia's party-strength table, a secondary source being checked against official rosters. 2025–26: Deseret News, 11/4/2026.

Few contested races. In 2024, 20 of 75 House races and 2 of 15 Senate races had no general-election opponent (Utah News Dispatch, 10/21/2024). A 2017 Utah Foundation study found more than 60% of state races over seven cycles were noncompetitive (Salt Lake Tribune). In 2026, Democrats filed in 66 of 75 House races, by the party's count.

Drawing the maps, three times

YearWhat happenedEach side's words
2001The Legislature redrew Democrat Jim Matheson's 2nd District into eastern and southern Utah, keeping only the east side of Salt Lake City. About 684,000 Utahns were moved. Matheson did not sue and won in 2002 by 1,641 votes (Deseret News, 11/5/2001; Utah Data Points).Matheson: "I just don't think I would win." Legislative attorney: lawmakers used "the criteria accepted by the courts." A BYU analysis found the evidence doesn't clearly show the new lines made the district more Republican.
2011Five of six finalist maps were "pizza slice" plans splitting Salt Lake County's center. The final map passed Oct. 17, 2011, mostly along party lines; three Democrats voted for it and five Republicans against (KSL).Chair Ken Sumsion (R): "Is it the perfect map? No." Sen. Ben McAdams (D) said it accommodated "the egos of politicians." Gov. Herbert: representatives "are elected by the people of Utah."
2021After Prop 4, the Legislature set aside the commission's 12 maps and passed its own, splitting Salt Lake County four ways (HB2004). Courts later threw it out. Full story in Part 1.A Princeton Gerrymandering Project memo said "cracking" Salt Lake City "eliminates political competition." Sen. Scott Sandall said Princeton gave the maps an "A" (grade not confirmed).

Where voters said yes to Prop 4 in 2018

Share voting yes on Prop 4 by county. Statewide it passed 50.3% to 49.7%. Darker means more yes votes.

Cache: 45% Duchesne: 34% Davis: 48% Millard: 37% Wasatch: 48% Box Elder: 40% Weber: 49% Juab: 37% Sanpete: 38% Washington: 40% Grand: 61% Rich: 40% Carbon: 53% Daggett: 48% Beaver: 37% Sevier: 36% Garfield: 42% Tooele: 45% Summit: 65% Piute: 31% Uintah: 32% Iron: 39% Emery: 44% Wayne: 34% San Juan: 40% Morgan: 37% Kane: 43% Salt Lake: 58% Utah: 44% 45% 34% 48% 37% 48% 40% 49% 37% 38% 40% 61% 40% 53% 48% 37% 36% 42% 45% 65% 31% 32% 39% 44% 34% 40% 37% 43% 58% 44% 25% 35% 45% 55% 65% 75% Share voting yes on Prop 4 (2018)

Source: 2018 General Election Canvass (county totals add to the statewide 512,218 yes). Boundaries: Utah Geospatial Resource Center.

All 29 counties, highest yes share first
CountyYesNoYes share
Summit12,4856,83464.6%
Grand2,5211,61860.9%
Salt Lake232,453165,94558.3%
Carbon3,5943,15553.3%
Weber37,97139,46349.0%
Wasatch5,5405,90548.4%
Davis58,67362,67048.4%
Daggett19721348.0%
Tooele9,59011,75244.9%
Cache16,83720,99044.5%
Emery1,6492,08244.2%
Utah72,26691,96744.0%
Kane1,2541,67842.8%
Garfield8701,18342.4%
Box Elder7,46611,02440.4%
Washington23,09034,49140.1%
San Juan1,9332,90939.9%
Rich41162939.5%
Iron5,9699,14639.5%
Sanpete3,3835,62537.6%
Juab1,4582,44637.3%
Millard1,6692,81337.2%
Beaver7511,28037.0%
Morgan1,8313,14036.8%
Sevier2,5714,53836.2%
Duchesne1,9313,67334.5%
Wayne43685033.9%
Uintah3,2176,79932.1%
Piute20245630.7%

Six counties gave Prop 4 a majority or near it: Summit (65%), Grand (61%), Salt Lake (58%), Carbon (53%), Weber (49%) and Davis (48%). The statewide margin came from the most populous counties.

Who gets on the ballot: SB54 (2014)

When voters acted

The Hive's Bill-Tracker has graded each of these. Grades are from the case files.

BillOur gradeWhat it didHow it connects
H.B. 3001 (2018)
House 60-13-2 · Senate 22-4-3 · Signed Dec 3, 2018
D+The Medical Cannabis Replacement. Voters passed Proposition 2 in November 2018.Replaced voter-passed Prop 2 in a one-day special session.
S.B. 96 (2019)
Senate 22-7-0 · House 56-19-0 · Senate concurs 22-7-0 · Signed Feb 11, 2019
C-The Medicaid Expansion Rewrite. Voters passed Proposition 3 in 2018 for full Medicaid expansion paid for by a small sales tax.Rewrote voter-passed Prop 3.
S.B. 200 (2020)
Senate 25-0-4 · House 67-4-4 · Signed Mar 28, 2020
FThe Redistricting Replacement. Voters passed Proposition 4 in 2018, creating an independent redistricting commission.Replaced voter-passed Prop 4.
H.B. 133 (2019)
House 50-20-5 · Senate 22-5-2 · Signed Mar 25, 2019
C-When a Voter-Passed Law Starts. Moved the start date of most laws passed by statewide initiative to 60 days after the next general session of the Legislature, with set dates for tax changes.Moved when a voter-passed law starts.
H.B. 75 (2020)
House 71-0-4 · Senate 27-0-2 · Signed Mar 28, 2020
C-Repeal the Law, Void the Petition. Provided that a referendum petition is void if the Legislature repeals the law it challenges, and let the Lt.A referendum is void if lawmakers repeal the law it challenges.
S.B. 2001 (2019 2nd Spec.) + H.B. 185 (2020)
Full floor vote counts not yet confirmed for either bill
FBait-and-Switch: Repealed Before the Referendum Could Happen. Raised the grocery sales tax from 1.75% to 4.85% without a two-thirds majority, leaving it open to referendum.Repealed before the referendum vote.
H.B. 2001 (2025)
House 60-9-6; Senate 26-1-2 (both 12/9/25; the one Senate no vote was Sen. Todd Weiler) · Signed 12/11/2025
FRepealed Before the Vote: The Union Referendum. H.B. 267 (2025), sponsored by Rep.Repealed before the referendum vote.
S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) (2024)
Senate 20-8-1; House 54-21-0 (8/21/24) · Passed 8/21/2024; sent for filing 8/22/2024
D-Amendment D: Six Weeks After the Ruling. On July 11, 2024, the Utah Supreme Court ruled in the Prop 4 case that the Legislature's power to change certain voter-passed laws has limits.Would have let lawmakers change any initiative; voided by the courts.
35 laws, 2016–2026 (incl. H.B. 32 and H.B. 242 of 2026)
35 laws · see the page for each bill's final floor votes
CTen Years of Petition Laws, 2016–2026. A law-by-law, searchable reference to the 35 laws that changed Utah's citizen initiative and referendum rules from 2016 to 2026, every one written and passed by the Legislature.Every petition-rule change, 2016–2026, in one place.

The courts, 2024–2026

The boards and committees they made

The Hive's Committees repo tracks at least nine advisory boards and commissions created or restructured in the 2023–2026 sessions. Our research has found more. None of their members are elected by voters.

Published list: The Board Wave, 2023–2026

BoardCreated or changed byWhat it does
Prosecutor Conduct CommissionS.B. 318 (2025)Reviews misconduct complaints against county and city prosecutors. Scored net −16 on the Hive rubric.
Utah Privacy Governing BoardS.B. 231 / H.B. 444 (2023–2025)Oversees the Office of Data Privacy; the law's legislative sponsor sits on it.
Land Conservation BoardH.B. 62 (2024)Members appointed May 2026.
Federalism CommissionH.B. 170 (2022), expanded 2023–2026State-federal policy.
Utah Energy CouncilH.B. 514 (2026)Expanded scope and energy infrastructure financing powers.
Critical Minerals CouncilS.B. 254 (2026)State mineral-extraction strategy.
Economic Development Coordinating CouncilH.B. 475 (2026)Business recruitment; named oversight seats were removed before passage.
Medicaid Inspector General Advisory BoardS.B. 147 (2026)Advises the Medicaid inspector general.
Cybersecurity CommissionS.B. 123 (2026)Expanded mandate.

Source: The Board Wave, 2023–2026 (Committees repo, posted Aug. 30, 2026), which scores each board on seven measures.

Also in Hive research (being confirmed for the published list)

BodyCreated byWhat the record shows
Spaceport Exploration CommitteeS.B. 62 (2025)$1 million. One seat goes by law to "the president of the state's largest aerospace and defense industry group," held by 47G's CEO. Co-chaired by Sen. Ann Millner, a 47G board member. Ends July 1, 2027.
Joint informal executive and legislative working groupH.B. 373 (2024)Replaced the Air Quality Policy Advisory Board; industry members picked by the Senate President and Speaker.
Great Salt Lake Commissioner and advisory committeeH.B. 491 (2023)Coordinates Great Salt Lake water work; added a records exemption.
Nuclear consortium and advisory board2023–2026 nuclear billsSeveral people sit on more than one energy board (Nuclear Energy repo).
Nucleus InstituteBill being confirmedInnovation institute launched by Jefferson Moss; its fund was exempted from public records in 2025 (Unelected Power).
Utah Water WaysBill being confirmedPublic-private water group (GSL Votes).

Older appointed bodies in Hive case files: the Military Installation Development Authority (MIDA board, project areas, how MIDA grew), the Utah Inland Port Authority, the Point of the Mountain authority and the Federalism Commission. Three of MIDA's founding board members have served since 2008.

Also cut: in 2025, S.B. 277 replaced the seven-member State Records Committee, which had heard public-records appeals since 1992, with one director appointed by the governor (Bill-Tracker, graded C-; Seven Citizens, Then One Director).

Private groups with public seats: 47G

47G (formerly the Utah Aerospace & Defense Association) is a private nonprofit industry group, registered with the state since 2020. Its CEO, Aaron Starks, holds the Spaceport committee seat state law sets aside for "the state's largest aerospace and defense industry group." Its board, as listed on 47G's own site and in 2025 announcements, includes people who also hold public roles:

Person47G rolePublic role or other tie
Ann MillnerDirector (joined May 2025)State senator; co-chair of the Spaceport Exploration Committee
Jefferson MossDirector (joined May 2025)Executive director, Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity; MIDA (non-voting)
Nicole CottleDirectorMIDA's chief administrative and legal officer
Brad WilsonBoard chair (named April 2025)Former Utah House Speaker; sponsor of 2018's Amendment C
Aaron StarksPresident and CEOHolds the Spaceport committee's industry seat; brother of EDCUtah's Ryan Starks

Sources: 47G board page (read Sept. 2026); TechBuzz News (May 22, 2025; Apr. 23, 2025); S.B. 62 enrolled text. As state economic office director in January 2025, Ryan Starks signed a memorandum of understanding with 47G (Unelected Power).

Who sits where

People who appear on more than one of these bodies, from the sources above.

flowchart LR G["47G
private industry group"] SP["Spaceport
Exploration Committee"] M["MIDA"] GO["Governor's Office of
Economic Opportunity"] E["EDCUtah"] MI["Sen. Ann Millner"] --- G MI --- SP MO["Jefferson Moss"] --- G MO --- GO MO --- M AS["Aaron Starks"] --- G AS --- SP RS["Ryan Starks"] --- E RS -.->|"brother"| AS NC["Nicole Cottle"] --- G NC --- M

Other private groups with public roles are in Unelected Power: EDCUtah (nine public officials on its voting board) and Utah Rising (a $3.2 million state grant). The state's economic office was the subject of a 2026 audit that found $249 million in grants at risk (Audits repo, OLAG 2026-18).

How a seat on a new board is filled

Typical appointment paths in the bills above. None includes a public vote.

flowchart LR L["Legislature
passes the bill"] --> B["New board
or committee"] G["Governor"] -->|"appoints"| B S["Senate President
and Speaker"] -->|"appoint"| B I["Industry group
named in law"] -->|"holds a seat"| B V["Voters"] -.->|"no vote"| B

See the people behind these boards in Unelected Power and the Committees repo.

How does this measure up for the public?

The same four questions from Part 1, applied here.

ChangeProblem shown first?Who lost a say?Can taxpayers see the cost?
Replacing the 2018 initiativesLawmakers cited costs and workability (Prop 3) and constitutional authority (Prop 4)Voters who passed themPartly: fiscal notes are public; map legal fees known only through reporting
Petition-rule changesVaries by bill; see each case filePetition sponsors and signersYes, through fiscal notes
New appointed boardsVariesVoters, who elect none of the membersPartly; some records exempted
Court changesLeaders called them procedural updatesDisputed: the Bar says the judiciary; supporters say no oneNot yet reported

People in this part

Where each person appears elsewhere in the Hive. Being named here does not mean anyone did anything wrong.

WhoWhy they are hereOther Hive pages
Stuart AdamsSenate President (R); lost his 2026 primaryAdams Leadership PAC
Enforcement Gap
Mike SchultzHouse Speaker (R)HD-12 race file
House Speaker Leadership PAC
Schultz water rights
Stratos land
Spencer CoxGovernor (R)Biggest donors
Energy money
Data center industry money
Kirk CullimoreSenate Majority Leader (R); union-law sponsor; trailing in 2026 (unofficial)Senator profile
SD-19 race file
Jordan TeuscherRep. (R); primary sponsor of the party-switch laws and the union lawHouse profile
Checks & Balances PAC
Jerry StevensonSen. (R); S.B. 62 sponsor; MIDA board since 2008Senator profile
The Layton Shuffle
Ann MillnerSen. (R); 47G board; co-chairs the Spaceport Exploration CommitteeSD-5 race file
Jefferson MossHead of the Governor's Office of Economic Opportunity; 47G boardUnelected Power profile
Ryan StarksEDCUtah; former state economic office director; brother of 47G's CEOUnelected Power profile
EDCUtah
Utah Rising
Dan HemmertMIDA executive director; former senatorUnelected Power profile
MIDA hearing check
Mike OstermillerMIDA board since 2008Unelected Power profile
Jason KyleRep. (R); sponsored HJR5 on judicial nominationsHD-8 race file
GSL Votes
Diana HagenFormer Utah Supreme Court justice; resigned May 2026Behind the Bench, Part 2
Judges on your ballot

What the records do not show

Words to know

Tap a card to see what it means.

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Your legislatorsShould any new board with power to tax, bond or zone have at least one elected member?
Your legislatorsShould a law that changes a voter-passed initiative need a two-thirds vote?
Senate President and House SpeakerWhich industry groups hold seats set aside by law on state boards, and who asked for them?
The governor's officeWho decides appointments to the new boards, and are the meetings and records open?
YourselfWas your legislative race contested this year? Check your sample ballot.

Connected Hive work

Who Gets a SayPart 1: map and primary rules Unelected PowerThe people on Utah's appointed boards Ten Years of Petition LawsBill-Tracker: 35 laws Bills That Did the OppositeTransparency The Board Wave, 2023–2026Committees: boards scoredThe Nuclear Consortium and the PeopleNuclear Energy repoStratosData-Centers repo

Behind this piece

50
Records, court documents and reports read (estimate)
22
Graded bills and boards connected
29
County results mapped
60
Searches run (estimate)

Posted Nov. 8, 2026.

Full sources
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

Independent accountability journalism. Public records only. We report; you decide.

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Transparency home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack