Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2019-96-PROP · Voter-passed laws

Smaller First: The Medicaid Expansion Rewrite

Voters passed full Medicaid expansion with a sales tax to pay for it. Lawmakers kept the tax but started with a smaller, capped plan that needed federal waivers.

Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

BillS.B. 96 (2019 General Session), "Medicaid Expansion Adjustments"
Primary sponsorSen. Allen M. Christensen
Floor sponsorRep. James A. Dunnigan
Final votesSenate 22–7–0 (Feb. 4, 2019); House 56–19–0 (Feb. 8, 2019); Senate concurrence 22–7–0 (Feb. 11, 2019)
StatusLaw · Signed Feb. 11, 2019

Graded by the collective rubric

C−Overall · Neutral
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerDReplaced a voter-passed law before it was carried out, and gave the state power to close enrollment (S.B. 96 enrolled text). The fallback kept a path to the coverage voters chose, so the check was weakened, not removed (S.B. 96 enrolled text).
TransparencyCHeard in a Senate and a House committee, with recorded votes and posted fiscal notes (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page; Fiscal note, 4th Substitute). Six substitutes were drafted and the final one was adopted on the House floor (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page). Meets what the law requires.
Financial accountabilityCThe voters' sales tax was kept and put in a named fund; the new hospital assessment is written in the bill (S.B. 96 enrolled text). The fiscal note stated the state savings plainly, and the Deseret News reported the federal money given up (Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion"; Fiscal note, 4th Substitute).
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactDAdults between 100% and 138% of the poverty level waited until federal approval in December 2019 (Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)"; Utah Medicaid, "Medicaid Expansion" page). Enrollment could be closed (S.B. 96 enrolled text). Voters' yes was changed before it took effect (Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)").

New grade, not previously published. Graded on its own record: S.B. 96 kept the voters' sales tax and goal and wrote in a fallback to fuller coverage, with committee hearings in both chambers. That is why it is not an F like H.B. 185 (2020) or H.B. 2001 (2025). It is still a D on Power and Community because it narrowed and delayed what voters passed. Average 1.5 = C−. A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Short quotes from the enrolled bill on le.utah.gov (S.B. 96 enrolled text). Bill line numbers are shown. Bracketed text is struck.

Section 26-18-3.9 · line 186

below 95% of the federal poverty level;

The waiver plan's income line. The bill summary says 100% (S.B. 96 enrolled text).

Section 26-18-3.9 · lines 206–208

according to a per capita cap developed by the department that includes an annual inflationary adjustment

(S.B. 96 enrolled text)

Section 26-18-3.9 · lines 219–220

If CMS does not approve a waiver to expand the Medicaid program in accordance with Subsection (4)(a)

The fallback. Expansion then begins by "July 1, 2020" at the latest (lines 232–241) (S.B. 96 enrolled text).

Sales tax section · line 1095

The rate specified in this subsection is 0.15%.

The voters' sales tax, kept and sent to the Medicaid Expansion Fund (line 1101) (S.B. 96 enrolled text).

Hospital share · lines 576–577

Beginning July 1, 2020, the hospital share is capped at no more than [$25,000,000] $15,000,000 annually.

(S.B. 96 enrolled text)

Every version, and what changed

VersionDateWhat changed
IntroducedJan. 25, 2019Original bill (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
1st SubstituteJan. 29, 2019Adopted in Senate Health and Human Services Committee, 7–0–1 (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
2nd SubstituteJan. 30, 2019Offered on the Senate floor; failed on a voice vote (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
3rd SubstituteFeb. 4, 2019Adopted on the Senate floor. The Deseret News reported this version ended expansion if waivers were denied (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page; Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion").
House Committee Amendment 2Feb. 6, 2019Adopted in House Business and Labor Committee, 14–0–1 (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
4th SubstituteFeb. 8, 2019Adopted on the House floor by voice vote. A 6th Substitute failed 20–54–1; the 5th was not adopted (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
EnrolledSigned Feb. 11, 2019Chapter 1, effective Feb. 11, 2019. Includes the fallback quoted above (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page; S.B. 96 enrolled text).

The votes

DateWhereResultRecord
Jan. 29, 2019Senate Health and Human Services Committee6–2–0(S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page)
Jan. 30, 2019Senate, 2nd reading22–7–0(S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page)
Feb. 4, 2019Senate, 3rd reading22–7–0(S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page)
Feb. 6, 2019House Business and Labor Committee9–6–0(S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page)
Feb. 8, 2019House, 3rd reading56–19–0(S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page)
Feb. 11, 2019Senate concurs with House changes22–7–0(S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page)

Senate no votes on Feb. 4: all six Democrats and Sen. Todd Weiler, R-Woods Cross (Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion"). House roll-call names were not reviewed.

The timeline

  1. Nov. 6, 2018 Voters approve Proposition 3, 53.32% to 46.68% (Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)").
  2. Jan. 25, 2019 S.B. 96 made public (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
  3. Jan. 29, 2019 Senate committee hearing; 1st Substitute adopted (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
  4. Feb. 4, 2019 Senate passes it 22–7 (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page; Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion").
  5. Feb. 6, 2019 House committee hearing; amendment adopted (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
  6. Feb. 8, 2019 House adopts a 4th Substitute and passes it 56–19 (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page).
  7. Feb. 11, 2019 Senate concurs; Gov. Gary Herbert signs it (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page; Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)").
  8. April 1, 2019 Enrollment opens for the smaller "Bridge Plan," up to 100% of the poverty level (Utah Medicaid, "Medicaid Expansion" page).
  9. Aug. 2019 Federal officials tell the state parts of its plan will not be approved (Deseret News, Aug. 22, 2019, on full expansion after federal rejection).
  10. Dec. 23, 2019 Federal officials authorize full Medicaid expansion in Utah (Utah Medicaid, "Medicaid Expansion" page).
  11. Aug. 10, 2021 Federal officials withdraw approval of Utah's work requirement (Utah Medicaid, "Medicaid Expansion" page).

How S.B. 96 changed the path to expansion

Built only from the records on this page.

flowchart TD
  A["Prop 3 passes
138% of poverty line
0.15% sales tax"] --> B["S.B. 96 signed
Feb. 11, 2019"] B --> C["Smaller plan first
caps, work path
needs waivers"] C --> D{"Waivers
approved?"} D -->|"No"| E["Fallback:
expand by July 1, 2020"] D -->|"Yes"| F["Capped plan"] E --> G["Full expansion authorized
Dec. 23, 2019"]

In their own words

Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.

SB96 balances Utah's sense of compassion and frugality.

— Gov. Gary Herbert, Ballotpedia (Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)")

This is a dark day for democracy in Utah.

— Utah Decides Healthcare, the Prop 3 campaign, Ballotpedia (Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)")

not play games

— Sen. Gene Davis, on what voters asked for, Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019 (Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion")

Why can't we just proceed to phase four, which is what the voters approved

— Rep. Marie Poulson, Deseret News, Aug. 22, 2019 (Deseret News, Aug. 22, 2019, on full expansion after federal rejection)

What happened next

Where it fits

Bills that changed the same rule, oldest first. This bill is highlighted.

Bills that change the same rule

  1. 2018 Proposition 3
    Voters pass Medicaid expansion to 138% of the poverty level and a 0.15% sales tax to pay for it.
  2. 2019 S.B. 96
    Replaces the plan with a smaller, capped, waiver-based plan; keeps the tax; adds a hospital assessment and a fallback.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Sen. Allen M. ChristensenPrimary sponsor (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page)
Rep. James A. DunniganFloor sponsor and sponsor of the 4th Substitute (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page)
Gov. Gary R. HerbertSigned the bill (S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page; Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)")
Sen. Todd D. WeilerThe one Republican no vote in the Senate on Feb. 4 (Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion")
Sen. Daniel HemmertArgued in debate that the forgone federal money figure was misleading (Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion")
Nate CheckettsState Medicaid director in 2019 (Deseret News, Aug. 22, 2019, on full expansion after federal rejection)
Utah Decides HealthcareThe Prop 3 campaign (Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)"; Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion")

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Your state representative and senatorWhen voters pass an initiative with its own funding, should lawmakers change it before it takes effect?
The Department of Health and Human Services, MedicaidHow much has the Medicaid Expansion Fund collected from the 0.15% sales tax and from hospitals each year since 2019?
The Legislative Fiscal AnalystWhat did the April–December 2019 smaller plan cost the state compared with full expansion?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

8
sources listed
6
votes recorded
7
versions compared
4
statements quoted

Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Status, sponsors, votes and dates from the le.utah.gov status page, read Oct. 19, 2026. Bill quotes from the enrolled HTML on le.utah.gov, read through a text-extraction tool in short pieces. Fiscal figures from the 4th Substitute fiscal note. Prop 3 vote and terms from Ballotpedia. Debate and later events from the Deseret News and the Utah Medicaid expansion page. Committee minutes and floor audio were not reviewed.

Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: which version first added the July 1, 2020 fallback to expansion (the 4th-vs-3rd Substitute comparison document could not be read; the server rate-limited it); why the bill body says 95% while its summary says 100%; the exact date full 138% coverage began (Utah Medicaid gives the Dec. 23, 2019 authorization date only); roll-call names; committee testimony.

Sources

Show all 8 sources
  1. S.B. 96 (2019) bill status page: https://le.utah.gov/~2019/bills/static/SB0096.html
  2. S.B. 96 enrolled text: https://le.utah.gov/~2019/bills/sbillenr/SB0096.htm
  3. Ballotpedia, "Utah Proposition 3, Medicaid Expansion Initiative (2018)": https://ballotpedia.org/Utah_Proposition_3,_Medicaid_Expansion_Initiative_(2018)
  4. Deseret News, Feb. 4, 2019, "Utah Senate OKs replacement for Medicaid expansion": https://www.deseret.com/2019/2/4/20665186/utah-senate-oks-replacement-for-medicaid-expansion
  5. Fiscal note, 4th Substitute: https://le.utah.gov/lfa/fnotes/2019/SB0096S04.fn.pdf
  6. Deseret News, Aug. 22, 2019, on full expansion after federal rejection: https://www.deseret.com/utah/2019/8/22/20828699/utah-full-medicaid-expansion-after-latest-federal-government-rejection
  7. Utah Medicaid, "Medicaid Expansion" page: https://medicaid.utah.gov/expansion
  8. Hive Taxation repo, Utah tax bills 2015–2026 (S.B. 96 entry): https://weber-county-hive.github.io/Taxation/utah-tax-bills-2015-2026.html
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

People

Elsewhere on the Hive

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism