Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Transparency Docket The Weber County Hive
CASE 2026-AMB-01 · ELECTIONS & BALLOT MEASURES · UPDATED OCT. 6, 2026

Amendment B: Myth vs. Fact

Part 2 of 2: History, related bills and questions

CASE 2026-AMB-01 · Posted Oct. 6, 2026 · Updated Oct. 17, 2026

New to this? Read it in plain words One short page covering both parts, with simple charts.
Short version
Transparency pages (27) · tap to open
  1. Transparency docketEvery case file, searchable
  2. The 2026 Amendments · plain wordsAmendments A and B on your ballot
  3. Amendment B: Myth vs. Fact · plain wordsClaims checked against the record
  4. Amendment B QuizTest what you know
  5. Who Sits at the Taxpayers Association's Table · plain wordsIts leaders, lobbyists, sponsors and their money
  6. Weber Housing Authority · plain wordsA commissioner, his wife and the authority that pays their company
  7. What the Privacy Office Can and Can't Do · plain wordsUtah's Chief Privacy Officer
  8. Counting the Jobs · plain wordsJob promises and what was reported
  9. Matt Brower · plain wordsThe board seat that never came up
  10. Ten Days · plain wordsThe Nilson Foundation's 501(c)(3) claim
  11. One Vote, Four Checks · plain wordsS.B. 258 and preliminary municipalities
  12. The Land Counties Can't Zone · plain wordsTrust land and county zoning
  13. SITLA: The Land Nobody Zones · plain wordsWho answers for trust land
  14. Tyson Leaves Eagle Mountain · plain wordsFive years after opening
  15. Behind the Bench · plain wordsJudge and lawyer complaints in Utah
  16. Wrong Room, Right Message · plain wordsA housing adviser in Heber City
  17. Every Weber County Property Tax Increase Since 2019 · plain wordsThe full list
  18. A New Line on the Bill · plain wordsRoy and Riverdale fire annexation
  19. Paying for the Next Station · plain wordsHow Weber Fire District funds growth
  20. Weber County's New Sales Tax · plain wordsA public vote, but no vote by the public
  21. Bills That Did the Opposite · plain wordsBait and switch, 2018 to 2026
  22. The Blank Box · plain wordsThree disclosure forms, one pattern
  23. Utah's Campaign-Finance Enforcement Gap · plain wordsComplaints filed, few penalties
  24. One Lake, Two Money Pots · plain wordsThe Great Salt Lake Trust Council
  25. Wells at the Top · plain wordsPowder Mountain's water
  26. Then vs. Now · plain wordsEarlier plans and later approvals in Ogden Valley
  27. West Haven's 6% Energy Tax · plain wordsA new line on the power bill

Cut here, raised there: 2022–2026

The state income-tax rate came down every year from 2022 to 2026. This table shows, year by year, what went up or was newly allowed during the same period. It lists only items found in the records cited.

2026: one state cut next to local increases

Dollars per year. The local figures were proposed, and not every increase is approved; they also fall on different taxpayers.

State income-tax cut, 4.50% to 4.45% (S.B. 60)
$101M less
Local property-tax increases sought by 67 entities
$93.58M more
Proposed; Truth in Taxation hearings ran through Aug. 27, 2026
Weber County's new 0.20% sales tax
$13.1M
Adopted by the County Commission; effective Oct. 1, 2026

Sources: Utah House, "Utah's Tax Cut Streak" (house.utleg.gov); KSL, Aug. 4, 2026; Weber County, July 1, 2026 release (CASE 2026-STAX-01).

YearCut by the LegislatureWent up, or newly allowed
2022Income tax 4.95% to 4.85% (S.B. 59); state earned income tax credit createdNone found in the records reviewed for this page.
2023Income tax 4.85% to 4.65% (H.B. 54); child tax credit created; gas tax cut for July–Dec. from 36.4¢ to 34.5¢ a gallonWeber County approved a 7.25% property-tax increase for 2024 after a Truth in Taxation hearing (Nov. 28, 2023), its first general-fund increase since 2016
2024Income tax 4.65% to 4.55% (S.B. 69, $167M a year)Salt Lake City allowed a sales tax of up to 0.5% for the Delta Center district (S.B. 272) · Fairpark district (UFAIR) allowed energy tax up to 6%, telecom up to 3.5% and accommodations up to 15% (H.B. 562) · MIDA 15% accommodations tax with no end date (S.B. 169) · new zones keeping up to 60% of property-tax growth (S.B. 268, S.B. 168)
2025Income tax 4.55% to 4.50% (H.B. 106, $103M a year)Gas tax rose 2¢, from 36.5¢ to 38.5¢ a gallon, on Jan. 1, 2025, under automatic indexing set by H.B. 362 (2015) · Salt Palace zone may keep 100% of local and 50% of state sales-tax growth for 30 years (S.B. 26) · Weber Fire District 23.58% increase proposed at a November 2025 hearing
2026Income tax 4.50% to 4.45% (S.B. 60, $101M a year); gas tax set to 31.9¢ for July–Dec. (H.B. 575)Alternative-fuel tax (CNG, LNG, hydrogen) rose from a 16.5¢ cap to 21.2¢ (H.B. 575) · Weber County 0.20% sales tax, about $13.1M a year · optional County Energy Excise Tax created (H.B. 507) · 67 local entities sought $93.58M in property-tax increases, including Roy 54.9%, Ogden Valley 512.6%, North View Fire 9.7%, Weber Basin Water 7% and South Ogden 10.3% (its fourth straight year)

For balance: in 2025, the State Tax Commission denied property-tax increases from 35 cities, school districts and other entities ($49.87 million) for not following new procedure rules (S.B. 202 and S.B. 29). (Deseret News, Oct. 2, 2025) The Legislature also expanded the Social Security tax credit each year from 2021 to 2025. (Utah House) Amendment B would not change any item in the right-hand column; it applies only to statewide citizen initiatives.

The full list of tax tools the Legislature created is on the amendments page.

How a citizen initiative gets to your ballot

Every step below exists today. Amendment B changes only the last box, for tax initiatives.

flowchart TD A["Sponsors file with
the Lt. Governor"] --> B["Legal review
(can be rejected)"] B --> C["Official cost estimate
by the Legislature's
fiscal analyst"] C --> D["7 public hearings
in 7 regions"] D --> E["~140,000 signatures
in 26 of 29
Senate districts"] E --> F["County clerks
verify signatures"] F --> G["Voter pamphlet:
arguments for
and against"] G --> H{"Vote needed
to pass"} H -->|"No tax"| I["Simple majority"] H -->|"Includes a tax increase"| J["Today: simple majority
If B passes: 60%"] I --> K["Legislature can still amend it
(limits on government-reform
initiatives since 2024)"] J --> K

Sources: vote.utah.gov, "Instructions for a Statewide Initiative"; S.B. 73 (2025); S.J.R. 2 (2025).

History: initiatives and the Legislature

flowchart TD T1["Nov. 2018
Voters pass Props 2, 3, 4"] --> T2["Dec. 2018
Prop 2 replaced
(H.B. 3001)"] T2 --> T3["Feb. 2019
Prop 3 replaced
(S.B. 96)"] T3 --> T4["2020
Prop 4 rewritten
(S.B. 200)"] T4 --> T5["Jan. 2020
Legislature repeals its
own tax reform after a
citizen referendum qualifies"] T5 --> T6["2023 and 2024
Earlier versions of the
60% resolution fail"] T6 --> T7["July 2024
Utah Supreme Court limits
changes to reform initiatives"] T7 --> T8["Sept. 2024
Amendment D voided
(misleading ballot language)"] T8 --> T9["March 2025
S.B. 73 signed;
S.J.R. 2 passes"] T9 --> T10["Nov. 3, 2026
Amendment B on the ballot"]

Sources: KUTV; Ballotpedia; Salt Lake Tribune; KSL, Jan. 28, 2020 and Jan. 30, 2025; Utah News Dispatch; le.utah.gov.

Where taxes are decided without a public vote

Amendment B raises the bar for citizen tax initiatives. These documented tax decisions in Utah involved no public vote, and B does not change them.

Click a marker for the record. Locations are approximate.

What the text allows: hypothetical examples

These are not pending proposals. Each applies the actual wording of S.J.R. 2 to a hypothetical initiative.

HYPOTHETICAL

Equalizing an energy tax

Citizens propose charging data center campuses the same 6% energy tax other users pay in a MIDA project area, instead of "at least 0.5%." That is "an increase in an existing tax rate" (item C): 60%. (MIDA–Box Elder interlocal agreement §6(a))

HYPOTHETICAL

A tax swap that saves money

An initiative drops a $500 million tax and adds a $400 million one, a $100 million net cut. It "includes" a new tax (item A): it appears to need 60%.

HYPOTHETICAL

Property-tax relief that isn't "enough"

Citizens propose cutting a property-tax rate by 1% when current law would have cut it 2%. That is a rate that decreases "less than it would under current law" (item D): 60%.

HYPOTHETICAL

Ending a special exemption

Citizens propose ending a sales-tax exemption that only one industry receives. That applies a tax to "additional items or transactions" (item B): 60%.

What supporters say

The primary sponsor, Sen. Lincoln Fillmore, argued that 50.1% of voters shouldn't be able to raise taxes on the other 49.9%, and that lawmakers answer to voters at elections. He and Rep. Jason Kyle said B "leaves the decision with Utah voters while requiring broader agreement." The Utah Taxpayers Association supports it. (Utah News Dispatch, Sept. 28, 2026)

What opponents say

Utahns Protecting Our Constitution calls B an unnecessary, permanent change that weakens a tool citizens use to hold government accountable, noting the Legislature keeps a simple majority. (Utah News Dispatch, Sept. 28, 2026)

Related bills and measures

Legislation on initiatives, referendums and voter-approved taxes, from this project's research. Status is as recorded on le.utah.gov unless noted.

Bill / measureWhat it didOutcome
S.J.R. 2 (2025) — Fillmore / KyleAmendment B: 60% for citizen initiatives that include a tax increase, as S.J.R. 2 defines itPassed Senate 21–8, House 55–17–3; on Nov. 3, 2026 ballot
S.B. 73 (2025) — FillmoreInitiatives must describe funding and any new tax; added publication rules (est. ~$1.4M) from 2027Signed March 24, 2025
Earlier 60% resolutions (2023, 2024)Same idea as S.J.R. 2Failed (KSL, Jan. 30, 2025)
H.B. 3001 (2018 special session)Replaced Prop 2, medical cannabisSigned, Dec. 2018
S.B. 96 (2019)Replaced Prop 3, Medicaid expansion; kept its sales taxSigned, Feb. 2019
S.B. 200 (2020)Made Prop 4's redistricting commission advisoryPassed; limited by Utah Supreme Court ruling, July 2024
S.B. 181 (2020) — Fillmore"Local Referenda Amendments" (text not reviewed)Enacting clause struck; died March 12, 2020
2019 tax reform lawStatewide tax changesRepealed by the Legislature, Jan. 2020, after a citizen referendum qualified
H.B. 23 (2021) — Nelson"Voter Referendum Amendments": changed referendum ballot timing and land-use referendum deadlinesSee le.utah.gov
Amendment D (2024)Would have let the Legislature amend or repeal any initiativeVoided by courts, Sept. 2024
S.B. 100 (2024) — BalderreeExtended signature window for revenue-bond referendums, 30 to 45 daysSigned March 19, 2024 (29–0, 70–0–5)
H.B. 354 (2024) — ClancyWould have required voter approval of property-tax increasesOutcome not confirmed
S.B. 37 (2025) — FillmoreWould have routed school districts' minimum basic levy through a state fundVetoed by Gov. Cox
S.B. 65 (2026) — FillmoreSame idea as S.B. 37Passed Senate 18–11; died in House Education unheard
S.B. 188 (2025) — GroverExempted reorganized school districts' lease revenue bonds from the cap (no vote)Signed March 17, 2025
H.B. 332 (2026) — AuxierWould have required a vote before school lease revenue bondsEnacting clause struck; died March 6, 2026
Amendment A (2026)Changes how proposed amendments are publishedOn Nov. 3, 2026 ballot

Who's connected to the record

Sen. Lincoln Fillmore

Primary sponsor of S.J.R. 2 and S.B. 73 (2025); sponsor of S.B. 181 (2020), S.B. 37 (2025) and S.B. 65 (2026). Listed as Chairman of Taxpayer Shield PAC (created Dec. 1, 2025), which is backing Amendment B (state PAC filing; Axios, Oct. 7, 2026). Primary sponsor of S.B. 168 (2024), which created Home Ownership Promotion Zones (a tax increment tool), and Senate sponsor of H.B. 562 (2024), the Fairpark district, which can levy energy, telecom and accommodations taxes. The Utah Taxpayers Association PAC gave his campaign $6,500 (2023–2026).

Bill-Tracker · Taxation

Rep. Jason B. Kyle

House sponsor of S.J.R. 2. Huntsville (Ogden Valley).

candidates2026

Taxpayer Shield PAC

Backing Amendment B (Axios, Oct. 7, 2026). Registered Dec. 1, 2025, Provo. State filing lists Sen. Lincoln Fillmore as Chairman, Russell "Rusty" Cannon (president, Utah Credit Unions Association) as Vice-Chairman, Brian K. Chapman as Executive Director and Treasurer, and Howard Headlee and William "Billy" Hesterman as board members. Money reported (state export downloaded Oct. 7, 2026, five transactions, all in the Primary report): one $2,000 contribution marked as a loan from Brian Chapman, the PAC's treasurer (April 18, 2026); $1,812.66 spent: $1,050 to UTGOP for advertising, $737.66 to BIVIO Resources for supplies and advertising, and $25 to BCR Political for "Association Expense" (Chapman's firm, per the filing's email domain). The export shows no Amendment B spending yet.

Sources: Taxpayer Shield PAC Statement of Organization and transaction export (DEX), disclosures.utah.gov (folder 1423862).

Utah Taxpayers Association PAC

Named with Taxpayer Shield PAC as backing Amendment B (Axios, Oct. 7, 2026). Registered Dec. 22, 2008, affiliated with the Utah Taxpayers Association; President and treasurer Billy Hesterman (also a Taxpayer Shield board member), VP Malah Armstrong. Money reported, Nov. 2021 to Oct. 7, 2026 (six state exports): $56,135.96 in, $57,125 out. About 38% of what came in was from the association itself ($16,547 in 2023, $5,000 in 2024). The rest came from companies and trade groups, including Rocky Mountain Power, Intermountain Power, Dominion Energy, Enbridge, Chevron, Merit Medical, Maverik, Deer Valley Resort Co. and banks and credit unions. No individual donors are listed.

Given to the amendment sponsors: Sen. Lincoln Fillmore $6,500; Rep. Anthony Loubet $500; Rep. Jason Kyle $200. To sponsors of tax tools on this page: Sen. Dan McCay $3,000; Sen. Kirk Cullimore $1,500; Rep. Ryan Wilcox $1,500; Sen. Wayne Harper $1,000; Rep. Jim Dunnigan $600; Rep. Jon Hawkins $200. Gov. Spencer Cox's campaign received $1,875. The exports show no money to or from Taxpayer Shield PAC and no Amendment B spending.

Sources: Utah Taxpayers Association PAC Statement of Organization and transaction exports (DEX, 2021–2026), disclosures.utah.gov, downloaded Oct. 7, 2026.

Utah Taxpayers Association

Supports Amendment B; president Billy Hesterman urged lawmakers to pass it in 2025.

Utahns Protecting Our Constitution

Political issues committee opposing B; executive director Elizabeth Rasmussen, who also leads Better Boundaries (2018 Prop 4). About $593,000 raised as of Sept. 2026.

MIDA

State authority with an appointed board; Stratos project area energy-tax terms set without a public vote.

MIDA disclosures · Unelected-Power

UIPA (Inland Port)

State authority with an appointed board; Tooele Valley project area tax terms set without a public vote.

S.B. 225 water standard · Counting the Jobs

PIDs

About $5.267 billion in statewide debt, none approved by voters (State Auditor Tina Cannon).

PIDS-Utah · Nordic Village

Weber County Commission

Imposed the 0.20% county sales tax by commission vote, no ballot question.

CASE 2026-STAX-01 · Tax increases since 2019

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

The collective questions

Applied to Amendment B only, from the record above.

Words to know

Initiative

A law proposed by citizens, put on the ballot by signature petition, and adopted by voters.

Referendum

A citizen challenge to a law the Legislature or a local body already passed, put to voters by petition.

Constitutional amendment

A change to the Utah Constitution. In Utah, only the Legislature can propose one, with two-thirds of each house; voters then approve it by simple majority.

Simple majority

More than half of the votes cast on the question.

Truth in Taxation

Utah's process requiring notice and a public hearing before a taxing entity collects more property tax than its certified rate would generate. No public vote is required.

PID

Public Infrastructure District: a special district that can levy assessments and issue bonds for infrastructure inside its boundary.

More words, tap a card to see what it means:

Updates since this was posted (this part)

The full list of updates is on Part 1.

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

17
Bills and measures in the table
10
People and bodies connected to the record
6
Places on the map
7
State campaign-finance exports read
5
Years of tax changes, 2022–2026

Posted Oct. 6, 2026. Updated Oct. 17, 2026: split into two linked parts with one plain-words page; added a short version, on-this-page links, words to know, questions to ask, connected Hive work, updates since posting and links for sources that had none. Links to sections now on the other part point there. To match the White & navy colors, the "Partly true" label changed from amber to teal and two cream and gold highlights changed to blue. No earlier facts or wording changed.

Sources

Sources (click to open)
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism