Who is Matt Brower?
Matt Brower has been Heber City Manager since 2018, appointed — not elected — by the City Council. City Managers in Utah's council-manager form of government run daily operations: staff, budget, contracts, and what makes it onto the Council's own agenda.
Before Heber, Brower held city manager posts in Lincoln, California (2015–18), Ocala, Florida (2008–14), and Santa Clara, Utah (2000–08). He describes himself as having "23 years" of city management experience.
What is CAMS?
The Community Alliance for Main Street (CAMS) is a Heber City nonprofit that programs downtown events — the Heber Market on Main, Halloween Feast, Old Fashioned Christmas, and more. Its own bylaws describe it, oddly, as "this advisory committee," even though it now operates and contracts as an independent 501(c)(3) corporation.
CAMS's board as of January 2026: Tom Stone (Chair), Matt Brower, Dallin Koecher, Jeff Bradshaw (Treasurer), Ryan Fritzsche, Kelsey Berg, Erik Rowland, and Nicole Ferguson. Its one paid employee is Executive Director Rachel Kahler. Tap a card.
Tom Stone
Matt Brower
Dallin Koecher
Jeff Bradshaw
Ryan Fritzsche
Kelsey Berg
Erik Rowland
Nicole Ferguson
Rachel Kahler
The timeline
| Oct. 21, 2025 | City Council holds a lengthy discussion about contracting with CAMS for downtown event programming; directs staff to draft an agreement. |
| Jan. 13, 2026 | CAMS's own board — including Brower — unanimously approves the Professional Services Agreement at CAMS's board meeting. One week before the City even votes. |
| Jan. 20, 2026 | City Council approves the agreement 5–0. The staff report, authored under Brower's name, lists him only inside a routine board roster — no standalone conflict-of-interest disclosure. Meeting minutes record "no conflicts disclosed." |
| (undated) | An undisclosed person files a complaint with the Utah State Auditor, alleging Brower didn't adequately disclose his CAMS seat and that the City didn't strictly follow its own procurement process. |
| April 14, 2026 | City Council votes 4–2 to renew Brower's contract through May 2029, the same day a petition with 300+ signatures asking for non-renewal is submitted. |
| April 21, 2026 | City Council formally ratifies the CAMS agreement a second time, after the City re-noticed it as a "sole source" procurement to address the auditor complaint. |
How the contract moved
From the timeline above and the signed agreement.
Heber City Manager"] MB --> CB["CAMS board
approves deal, Jan. 13"] MB --> SR["Staff report to Council
under Brower's name"] SR --> CC["City Council
approves 5–0, Jan. 20"] CB --> PSA["Contract: $39,900 a year
for 3 years"] CC --> PSA PSA --> SIG["Signed for the City
by Brower only"] SIG --> AUD["Complaint to the
Utah State Auditor"] AUD --> RAT["Council ratifies again
3–2, April 21"]
The signature nobody expected
The final, signed Professional Services Agreement contains a standard recital: "City caused this Agreement to be signed by its mayor and attested by its city recorder."
The actual signature block that follows has no line for the Mayor at all. It has one line: Matt Brower, City Manager.
What CAMS's own rules say about this
CAMS's bylaws, signed 2023, list among the powers reserved to its full Board of Directors: "Approve any self-dealing transaction, except as provided pursuant to Law."
In other words, CAMS's own governing document anticipated exactly this kind of situation — a board member with a competing interest in a CAMS transaction — and built a required approval step for it. Whether the Heber City contract was ever formally treated and approved as a "self-dealing transaction" under that provision is not shown in any document obtained so far.
What the contract itself pays CAMS
$39,900 per year, paid quarterly, for a term running through 2028–29 with automatic annual renewal, increasing each year by CPI. CAMS also keeps most event-sponsorship revenue, splits Heber Market on Main sponsorships 50/50 with the City, and can pursue additional TAP tax grants on top of the contract. The City throws in police services, insurance, marketing support, and storage space in a former city administration building.
The money that doesn't add up yet
CAMS's 2024 financials show a single expense line — "Main Street Beautification" — that made up roughly 90% of that year's entire budget. That line collapsed to a fraction of its size in 2025. What the 2024 figure actually funded has not yet been identified in any document obtained. Separately, CAMS's "Program Support" line jumped more than 20-fold from 2024 to 2025 — a year total revenue fell sharply.
CAMS's 2024 money: three figures from its own papers
From CAMS's 2024 Form 990-EZ, its balance sheet and its 2024 financials, as listed in the questions below.
The public response
A petition titled "Petition of No Confidence," submitted April 14, 2026 by resident Bridget Whiting on behalf of "concerned residents of Heber Valley," collected 335 online signatures plus additional paper signatures — north of 300 total. It asked the Council to decline to renew Brower's contract, citing early renewal timing, salary increases, agreements with outside organizations, and declining public confidence. It explicitly did not allege criminal conduct.
Public comment emails submitted the same week raised additional, more specific concerns:
Not everyone opposed renewal — at least one resident, Larry Saylor, wrote in support, calling Brower "honest and trustworthy and loyal." Opposition was organized and vocal, but not unanimous.
What a 501(c)(3) can't do politically
CAMS's own materials describe its work as "community advocacy" — a January 2024 CAMS blog post is titled "CAMS Advocacy Initiatives," and its stated mission includes "community advocacy and education." That word choice matters more than it might seem, because of what CAMS became later that same year.
CAMS was not always under these rules. Its original classification — a 501(c)(6) business league — has real latitude for political activity: lobbying is essentially unrestricted, and even some campaign-related activity is allowed, so long as it runs through a segregated fund rather than the organization's general treasury. The 2024 conversion to 501(c)(3) status didn't just change CAMS's tax treatment — it fundamentally tightened what the organization is legally permitted to do, and when.
Whether CAMS's own "advocacy" activities — under either classification, before or after the 2024 conversion — have ever touched a candidate or a campaign is not addressed in any document obtained so far. It's a fair, specific question: what does "advocacy" mean in practice for an organization whose board includes a sitting City Manager (Matt Brower)?
Two entities, not one
CAMS describes itself as "now in its twenty-second year." The state's own corporate records tell a different story.
As of today, September 3, 2026, that current entity's status with the Utah Division of Corporations is listed as Active, but Delinquent. This is a live status, checked directly, not historical data.
Added Oct. 17, 2026: "Delinquent" is the Utah Division of Corporations' own status label, as its registry showed it when checked on Sept. 3, 2026. It is a state filing status. The status may have changed since then; the Division of Corporations' business entity search shows the current status.
The missing federal filings
CAMS's history describes years of operation as a 501(c)(6) organization before its 2024 conversion to a 501(c)(3). No federal tax filings from that earlier period turn up anywhere — not on ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer, not indexed anywhere online. CAMS's first-ever Form 990-EZ, for fiscal year 2024, is marked "Initial Return." That label is consistent with an organization that either never held a formal federal exemption before, or lost one to automatic revocation for failing to file — the IRS automatically revokes tax-exempt status after three consecutive years without a required filing.
Questions worth asking directly
- Is CAMS currently in good standing with the Utah Division of Corporations — if not, how long has it been delinquent, and why did the City sign a $119,700 contract with an entity that isn't? (Status as checked Sept. 3, 2026; it may have changed.)
- CAMS claims "22 years" of continuous existence, but the original 2005 entity was administratively dissolved in 2006 and a wholly new entity wasn't formed until 2019 — which entity actually signed the City's contract, and does the City vet whether its contracted vendors are in good standing?
- What did the $347,465.54 "Main Street Beautification" expense in 2024 actually pay for, and why isn't it itemized anywhere public?
- Why did that spending collapse 99% the very next year, the same year CAMS's total income also fell 73%?
- CAMS's own 990-EZ shows $193,966 in 2024 gross receipts; its own balance sheet shows roughly $387,933 for the same year — which is accurate, and why don't CAMS's own documents agree with each other?
- Why did CAMS's "Program Support" line increase more than 20-fold in a single year while total revenue was falling?
- Was the City's contract ever formally reviewed and approved as a "self-dealing transaction" under CAMS's own bylaws, given a sitting City Manager (Matt Brower) sat on both sides of it?
- The contract states the Mayor was to sign for the City — why does the actual signature page show only the City Manager (Matt Brower), with no Mayor's line at all?
- CAMS's board approved this contract a week before the City Council did — was that sequencing disclosed to the Council before its own vote?
- CAMS's current public board list doesn't match the board named in the City's own staff reports one day earlier — has the board actually changed, when, and why wasn't that reported?
- If CAMS operated as a 501(c)(6) for years before 2024 as it claims, where are its federal tax filings from that period — was its exempt status ever automatically revoked by the IRS for failing to file?
- Did the City know, when it signed this contract, that CAMS had not yet received IRS 501(c)(3) recognition — and does the City verify tax-exempt status before contracting with nonprofits at all?
Whom to ask
These are questions for readers to raise with public bodies, for example during public comment at a council meeting.
What's still unconfirmed
The Sid Ostergaard conflict-of-interest claim, the Park Record/Lincoln CA contradiction claim, what the 2024 CAMS "Beautification" expense actually bought, and whether CAMS's board ever formally treated the City contract as a "self-dealing transaction" under its own bylaws — none of these are resolved by any document obtained so far. They are documented here as claims and open questions, not established facts.
Updates since this was posted
News and records found online, with dates. Items marked "added for context" are dated before Sept. 3, 2026 but were not on the original page.
- April 16, 2026 (added for context)The Park Record reported the April 14 renewal vote on Brower's contract was 4–2, with Mayor Heidi Franco and Councilor Yvonne Barney voting no. The new three-year contract runs to 2029. The paper reported the online petition had about 400 signatures by the meeting.Source: Park Record, April 16, 2026
- April 22 and 24, 2026 (added for context)The Council ratified the CAMS contract 3–2 on April 21; Councilors Barney and Morgan Murdock voted no. KPCW reported the city asked two other groups, the Park Silly Sunday Market and the Historic Park City Alliance, for price quotes, and both came in "significantly higher than $40,000." The Park Record reported the contract pays $39,900 a year with no benefits and requires at least 50 days of downtown events a year. It also reported that CAMS board members are volunteers, and that the State Auditor's office confirmed an investigation but declined further comment.Source: KPCW, April 22, 2026; Park Record, April 24, 2026
- Sept. 1, 2026 (added for context)The Heber City Council's work session agenda listed a 2026 Heber Market on Main season summary presented by Rachel Kahler, CAMS Executive Director. Added Oct. 17, 2026: the city's draft minutes of that meeting say Kahler presented visitor numbers, vendor fees and sales tax revenue; feedback was generally positive, especially about the free concert series; concerns raised included little shade and limited ADA parking; and vendors did well, with a waitlist for next season. The minutes were still marked draft when read and do not give the figures.Source: Utah Public Notice Website, Heber City Council agenda, Sept. 1, 2026; Heber City Council draft minutes, Sept. 1, 2026
- Sept. 2, 2026Write-in filing closed Aug. 28. CAMS board member Erik Rowland, previously uncontested for Wasatch County Council Seat C, now faces write-in Alex Folmer. CAMS Executive Director Rachel Kahler faces Democrat Robert McNeill and write-ins Jami Hewlett and Shawn Taylor for Seat A.Source: KPCW, Sept. 2, 2026
- Sept. 11 and 14, 2026The Utah State Tax Commission found Heber City did not meet all of the state's new public notice rules for its planned 4.2% property tax increase, so the increase must be rescinded; the city said it will not appeal. Previewing the next council meeting, Brower said the city sent notices to property owners and put the statement in staff reports, but did not post it on its website. This is not about CAMS; it is included because it concerns the City Manager's office.Source: KPCW, Sept. 11, 2026; KPCW, Sept. 14, 2026
- Oct. 17, 2026 (Hive search)No public result of the State Auditor's review of the Heber City complaint was found in web searches on Oct. 17, 2026 (searches for the State Auditor with Heber City, the events contract and Community Alliance for Main Street; KPCW and Park Record Heber City coverage; and Heber City agendas on the Utah Public Notice Website). The newest auditor mention found is the Park Record's April 24, 2026 report that the office confirmed an investigation. No October 2026 Heber City Council item about CAMS was found. CAMS's current state registration status could not be rechecked: the state business search and its mirrors (OpenCorporates showed a browser check) did not open for this update, so the Sept. 3, 2026 status stands as of that date.Source: Hive web searches, Oct. 17, 2026
Words to know
Tap a card to see what it means.
Connected Hive work
Behind this piece
Posted Sept. 3, 2026. Updated Oct. 17, 2026: new layout and colors, a short version, a diagram of how the contract moved, a chart of CAMS's 2024 figures, a plain-words page, updates, words to know, whom to ask, links to related Hive pages and a sources list. Added a note that "Delinquent" is the state registry's label for CAMS as checked Sept. 3, 2026, and may have changed. No earlier facts changed.
Sources
Show all sources (tap to open)
Records behind the original page (Sept. 3, 2026)
- Heber City Council staff reports and minutes, Jan. 6, Jan. 20 and April 21, 2026
- CAMS Professional Services Agreement with Heber City (signed agreement)
- CAMS bylaws, signed 2023
- CAMS financial statements and balance sheet; CAMS Form 990-EZ for fiscal year 2024 (marked "Initial Return")
- "Petition of No Confidence," submitted April 14, 2026
- Public comment emails to the Heber City Council, April 14, 2026
- Utah Division of Corporations entity records for Community Alliance for Main Street (formed 2005) and Community Alliance for Main Street, Inc. (formed 2019), checked Sept. 3, 2026
- ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer (searched for earlier federal filings)
- CAMS blog post "CAMS Advocacy Initiatives," January 2024
Added Oct. 17, 2026
- "Heber City Council renews city manager's contract after prolonged evaluation, mass civic engagement," Park Record, April 16, 2026
- "Heber City narrowly finalizes downtown events contract," KPCW, April 22, 2026
- "Heber City ratifies event programming contract in light of state auditor complaint," Park Record, April 24, 2026
- Heber City Council agenda, Sept. 1, 2026, Utah Public Notice Website
- "Write-in candidates jump into Wasatch County races," KPCW, Sept. 2, 2026
- "Heber City can't raise taxes after failing to meet new state rule," KPCW, Sept. 11, 2026
- "Heber City Council to roll back 4.2% tax increase for FY2027," KPCW, Sept. 14, 2026
- Heber City Council draft minutes, Sept. 1, 2026, Utah Public Notice Website
- The Weber County Hive, The Blank Box (related CAMS disclosure forms)
