A social media post shared with The Weber County Hive in September 2026 makes a series of claims about Utah's courts: "Cox appoints the judges"; the judiciary is "exempt from FOIA and GRAMA laws"; the "Utah State Bar is a private corporation- not gov"; lawyer complaints are "hidden behind closed doors"; "judicial complaints and scandal are hidden from the people"; and "state judicial oversight" is "dominated by Utah State Bar Corp members."
Those claims can be checked against the Utah Constitution, state statutes, the Utah Supreme Court's own rules and the annual reports of the two offices that handle complaints. The record supports parts of them and contradicts others.
The claims, checked against the record
Tap a claim to see what the record shows
"Cox appoints the judges." Partly
Courts are "exempt from FOIA and GRAMA." Not accurate
The Bar is "a private corporation- not gov." Partly
Lawyer complaints are "hidden behind closed doors." Largely accurate
Judicial complaints are "hidden from the people." Largely accurate
Oversight is "dominated by Utah State Bar Corp members." Partly
Each answer is documented in the sections below.
The open-records and Bar claims are covered in Part 2: Open-records law and the courts and What the Utah State Bar is. The Hagen records release is in Part 2.
How judges are chosen and kept
Article VIII of the Utah Constitution sets the process. When a vacancy opens, the governor "shall fill the vacancy by appointment from a list of at least three nominees certified to the governor by the Judicial Nominating Commission." If the governor doesn't act within 30 days, the chief justice makes the appointment. The Senate must decide within 60 days, and approval takes "a majority of all members of the Senate."
From vacancy to retention vote
Added Oct. 17, 2026: the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot. The Salt Lake Tribune reported on Oct. 12, 2026 that 57 judges will appear on Utah ballots this year, and that the Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission recommended retaining all of them except one, Weber County Justice Court Judge Trent Nelson. The Tribune reported that some survey respondents said they had little confidence in his legal skills, and that Nelson responded that independent court observers were positive about his work. Each voter sees only the judges for their own area. The state elections office says a judge is kept only with more "yes" votes than "no" votes. JPEC's evaluations for every judge on the ballot are at judges.utah.gov. This page does not recommend a vote on any judge. Sources: Salt Lake Tribune, Oct. 12, 2026; vote.utah.gov.
Complaints about judges
Utah Code 78A-11-112 says complaints, papers, testimony and the record of the Judicial Conduct Commission's confidential hearing "may not be disclosed" until the Utah Supreme Court enters its final order. The statute allows exceptions, including disclosure on the Supreme Court's order, at the judge's request, for a criminal investigation, and to the Legislative Auditor General and the Senate's judicial confirmation committee. When a complaint is dismissed, the complainant is told.
What happens to a complaint about a judge
The JCC says it cannot overturn a judge's decisions, and that "a judge's decisions, even if erroneous, do not provide an adequate basis for a finding of judicial misconduct."
Judicial Conduct Commission, by fiscal year (July–June)
| Year | Complaints* | Warnings | Public sanctions |
|---|---|---|---|
| FY21 | 80 | 0 | 0 |
| FY22 | 85 | 2 | 0 |
| FY23 | scan only | no list posted | 0 |
| FY24 | 183 | 2 | 3 |
| FY25 | scan only | 5 | 0 |
| FY26 | scan only | 3 | 3 |
*Complaint counts from the JCC's annual reports. Since FY2019 the JCC counts each judge once even if named in several complaints. The readable reports give no breakdown by type of complaint or reason for dismissal, and don't explain the rise from 85 to 183. FY2021's warnings figure ("None") is from its annual report. Warnings from the JCC's yearly lists. Public sanctions from its public dispositions page: two censures and a reprimand in July 2023, and a reprimand and two censures in April and June 2026. "Scan only" means the FY2023, FY2025 and FY2026 reports are posted as scanned images, so their complaint totals could not be read. "Warnings" are dismissals with warning.
Added Oct. 17, 2026: The table above is unchanged. The JCC's dismissals-with-warnings page now also posts an FY2027 list (the year that began July 1, 2026). It has two entries, dated July 7 and Aug. 10, 2026, both about justice court judges in small claims trials, with no judge named. The JCC's public dispositions page, checked Oct. 17, 2026, lists no public sanction after June 10, 2026. Sources: JCC FY2027 list; JCC public dispositions.
Complaints about lawyers
The Utah Constitution gives the Supreme Court power, "by rule," to "govern the practice of law, including admission to practice law and the conduct and discipline of persons admitted to practice law." Under the court's Rule 1-561, lawyer discipline proceedings are confidential until the Office of Professional Conduct files a formal action. They become public "upon filing an Action." The rule allows earlier disclosure in some cases, including when allegations have already appeared in the news, involve a criminal conviction, or the lawyer waives confidentiality.
Added Oct. 17, 2026: On Aug. 4, 2026, the Utah courts posted proposed amendments to 23 of the lawyer-discipline rules, including Rule 1-561, for public comment through Sept. 18, 2026. The notice describes the changes as being for clarity and consistency, such as a new definition for sending documents and a "Complainant" definition that no longer includes the OPC. It does not describe a change to when lawyer complaints become public. Whether the Supreme Court has adopted the amendments was not confirmed in searches on Oct. 17, 2026. Source: Utah courts, rules for comment, Aug. 4, 2026.
Lawyer complaints, 2024 and 2025
From the OPC's annual reports. The two years use different categories (2024: dismissed before a screening panel; 2025: closed as dismissed or declined), and cases closed in a year are not always the ones opened that year, so the bars should not be read as percentages. The 2025 report attributes part of the rise to one lawyer who was the subject of 193 complaints. The OPC says its 2025 cases were against 808 individual lawyers, up from 509 in 2024, and that one lawyer alone was the subject of 193 complaints.
Public outcomes the OPC reported
| Outcome | 2024 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Public reprimand by a screening panel | 0 | 3 |
| Probation, by court order | 3 | 7 |
| Suspension, by court order | 5 | 3 |
| Delicensure (the most severe sanction) | 2 | 2 |
| Resigned with discipline pending | 2 | 1 |
Where 2025's 1,334 new cases came from, per the OPC: 1,310 from clients, opposing parties, lawyers or others; 7 from judges; 11 from lawyers reporting themselves; 6 opened by the OPC from news reports and court dockets.
In 2024, screening panels also imposed four private admonishments. In 2025 they imposed none. Individual public discipline is listed on the OPC's website.
Who sits on the oversight bodies
Utah Code 78A-11-103 sets the Judicial Conduct Commission's 11 seats. The statute guarantees a non-lawyer presence through its public seats, but it does not keep lawyers out of the legislative seats. The Speaker and the Senate President each appoint two legislators, with no more than one from their own party. The Supreme Court appoints two Bar members and two judges. The governor appoints three public members, with Senate confirmation, who may not be Bar members, no more than two from the governor's party. Terms are four years, capped at eight.
Judicial Conduct Commission: 11 seats
Seats from the statute. Commission minutes from November 2025 list the four legislative members below.
Current members by profession
| Seat | Profession |
|---|---|
| 2 attorney seats | Attorneys (required) |
| 2 judge seats | Judges (required) |
| Sen. Brady Brammer | Attorney, litigator at Spaulding Law |
| Rep. Grant Miller | Attorney, Salt Lake City public defender |
| Rep. Jordan Teuscher | Law degree, per his public biography; not confirmed as an active Bar member |
| Sen. Jen Plumb | Physician |
| 3 public seats | May not be Bar members (required) |
Professions from each legislator's firm, campaign or public biography. At least 6 of the 11 current members are attorneys or judges. Whether Rep. Teuscher is an active Bar member was not confirmed.
The Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission, which grades judges for voters, has 13 members, according to Ballotpedia's summary of the statute. They are appointed by the Senate, the House, the Supreme Court, the governor and the executive director of the Commission on Criminal and Juvenile Justice. No more than seven may be lawyers, and no more than half may be from one party.
Updates since this was posted
News and records found online after Sept. 24, 2026, or newer details on items this page listed as open, with dates. No published number on this page was changed.
- Oct. 12–13, 2026The Salt Lake Tribune reported that 57 judges will appear on Utah ballots on Nov. 3, 2026, and that the Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission recommended retaining all but one: Weber County Justice Court Judge Trent Nelson. The Tribune reported survey respondents' concerns and Nelson's response that independent court observers were positive about his work. JPEC's evaluations are at judges.utah.gov. This page does not recommend a vote on any judge.Source: Salt Lake Tribune, Oct. 12, 2026; KPCW, Oct. 13, 2026
- Ongoing (state elections office)The state's retention election page says a judge is kept only with more "yes" votes than "no" votes, and that each voter sees only the judges tied to their district.Source: vote.utah.gov
- Oct. 17, 2026 (Hive check of the JCC website)The JCC's dismissals-with-warnings page now posts an FY2027 list with two entries, dated July 7 and Aug. 10, 2026, both about justice court judges in small claims trials; no judge is named. The public dispositions page lists no public sanction after June 10, 2026.Source: JCC FY2027 list; JCC public dispositions
- Sept. 1 and Oct. 6, 2026The Judicial Conduct Commission held public meetings with a "Statistical Report" on each agenda, followed by closed sessions. Their public handouts are scanned images and could not be read for this update. The first H.B. 186 report, due before Nov. 1, 2026, was not found online as of Oct. 17. More in Part 2.Source: Sept. 1 notice; Oct. 6 notice
- Sept. 29, 2026 (memo for the Oct. 6 meeting)A staff memo for the Judicial Council on H.B. 540 recommends that lawmakers first see "the actual impacts of the changes from HB0540" before deciding on free court audio. It notes audio is available on request for a one-time fee of $10–$15. Whether the council adopted it was not found.Source: Judicial Council materials, Oct. 6, 2026 (text extraction)
- Aug. 4 to Sept. 18, 2026 (added for context)Proposed amendments to 23 lawyer-discipline rules, including Rule 1-561, were open for public comment. The courts' notice describes them as clarity and consistency changes. Whether they were adopted was not confirmed.Source: Utah courts, rules for comment
- Aug. 28 to Oct. 6, 2026 (added for context)Gov. Cox appointed Matthew Bell and Michael Menssen to the Supreme Court on Aug. 28; the Senate confirmed both 26–2 on Sept. 16. The Judicial Council's Oct. 6 agenda lists Jill Pohlman as Interim Chief Justice. No governor-appointed chief justice under S.B. 134 was found in searches on Oct. 17.Source: KPCW, Sept. 17, 2026; Judicial Council agenda
- Oct. 17, 2026 (what was searched)Searched: news on the Judicial Conduct Commission, JPEC and 2026 retention; the JCC's dispositions, warnings and annual-report pages; the JCC's and the Judicial Council's meeting notices; the Judiciary Interim Committee page; the Utah courts' rules pages; news on Supreme Court appointments. No new JCC public sanction, no H.B. 186 report and no adopted rule change on lawyer-complaint confidentiality were found.Source: Searches run Oct. 17, 2026 (web search, then the pages opened above)
Words to know
More terms, beyond the ones at the top. Tap a card to see what it means.
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
Questions readers can ask public bodies, in writing or at a public meeting. Nine more are in Part 2.
Connected Hive work
Behind this piece
Posted Sept. 24, 2026. Updated Oct. 17, 2026: split into two linked parts, new layout and White & navy colors, larger print, a short version for each part, a plain-words page, updates since posting (the Nov. 3 retention ballot and JPEC's recommendations, the JCC's new FY2027 warnings list, the pending H.B. 186 report, the H.B. 540 audio memo, proposed lawyer-discipline rule changes, Supreme Court appointments), dated notes next to related items, words to know, questions to ask, links to related Hive pages, and links added for sources that had none. No earlier facts, numbers or wording changed.
Sources
- Social media post shared with The Weber County Hive, Sept. 21, 2026 (author not named).
- Utah Constitution, Article VIII, Sections 4, 8 and 9 (le.utah.gov).
- Utah Code 78A-11-103 (commission membership) and 78A-11-112 (confidentiality); 78A-11-110 and -111 (public sanctions and Supreme Court review), le.utah.gov.Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Utah Code 78A-11-103 on le.utah.gov
- Utah Judicial Conduct Commission, Frequently Asked Questions; Public Dispositions; Dismissals with Warnings (FY2022, FY2024, FY2025, FY2026 lists); Annual Reports FY2021, FY2022, FY2024 (jcc.utah.gov).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Public Dispositions; Dismissals with Warnings; Annual Reports (FY2021, FY2022, FY2024)
- Utah Judicial Conduct Commission, minutes, Nov. 10, 2025, Utah Public Notice Website (member list).
- Utah Supreme Court Rules of Professional Practice, Rule 1-561, "Accessing disciplinary information," effective Dec. 15, 2020.
- Office of Professional Conduct, 2024 and 2025 annual reports, in the Supreme Court's OPC Oversight Committee meeting materials (legacy.utcourts.gov).
- Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, Open Government Guide: Utah (GRAMA's application to the judiciary; Code of Judicial Administration Rules 4-201 to 4-206).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: RCFP Open Government Guide: Utah
- Ballotpedia, "Utah Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission" (membership limits).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Ballotpedia page
- Spaulding Law, attorney profile of Brady Brammer; Grant Miller for House District 24, campaign biography; Ballotpedia, "Jennifer Plumb"; Jordan Teuscher campaign biography (law degree).
- Utah Legislature, H.B. 186 (2026), "Judicial Conduct Commission Amendments," enrolled copy and bill status history (House 70–0–5, Feb. 3; Senate 25–1–3, Feb. 13; signed March 23; effective May 6, 2026).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: H.B. 186 on le.utah.gov
- Utah Supreme Court, "Utah Supreme Court releases statement on allegations involving Justice Hagen," April 17–18, 2026.Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Utah courts news release, April 17, 2026
- Utah News Dispatch, Katie McKellar: "Utah Supreme Court says affair allegations against justice were 'inappropriately' released," April 17, 2026; "Was the Utah House's release of a Supreme Court justice complaint 'unlawful'?" April 20, 2026; "Amid affair allegations, Utah Supreme Court Justice Diana Hagen resigns," May 8, 2026.Link added Oct. 17, 2026: April 17; April 20; May 8
- Utah Legislature, S.B. 233 (2026), "Judicial Performance Evaluation Amendments," enrolled copy, Section 78A-12-105 (closed discussion; public vote; protected individual votes).
- The Weber County Hive's collective rubric (power, transparency, financial accountability, environmental impact, community impact).
- Utah Judicial Conduct Commission home page (contact information); Office of Professional Conduct contact and complaint pages; Utah House contact information.
- The Weber County Hive, Judiciary committee page (committees repo) and Senate District 21 case file (candidates2026 repo).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Judiciary committee page; Senate District 21 case file
- Utah Legislature bill records (le.utah.gov) for H.B. 392, H.B. 366, S.J.R. 5, S.B. 233, H.B. 540 and S.B. 134 (2026).
- Utah State Bar, "History and Purpose" (1931 establishment); Utah Division of Corporations registration record, entity #1125137-0140, filed June 24, 1991.Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Utah State Bar, History and Purpose
Added Oct. 17, 2026
- The Salt Lake Tribune, Jessica Schreifels, on how voters can learn about the 57 judges on Utah ballots, Oct. 12, 2026 (also republished by KPCW, Oct. 13, 2026).
- Utah Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission, judges.utah.gov (official site; it did not load as readable text on Oct. 17, 2026, so no figure on this page is taken from it).
- Utah Lieutenant Governor's Office, "Learn about Judicial Retention Elections," vote.utah.gov (more "yes" than "no" votes to keep a judge).
- Judicial Conduct Commission, FY2027 dismissals with warnings list (two entries, July 7 and Aug. 10, 2026). Read as text.
- Judicial Conduct Commission meeting notices, Utah Public Notice Website, including the Sept. 1, 2026 and Oct. 6, 2026 agendas. Their public handouts are scanned images and were not read.
- Utah courts, "Supreme Court Rules of Professional Practice – Comment Period Closes September 18, 2026," posted Aug. 4, 2026.
- Judicial Council, Oct. 6, 2026 meeting notice and agenda, and its meeting materials (Tab 7, H.B. 540 memo dated Sept. 29, 2026). Read via text extraction.
- Utah News Dispatch via KPCW, "Senate confirms 2 more Utah Supreme Court justices," Sept. 17, 2026.
Public records only. No comment requested.
