The Hive bee sealUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
Transparency · TR 300.33← Transparency home · ← Hive library (every repo)
Transparency · Case File · Statewide

It Happened Before: Cox's Two Races, Utah Controversies and How They Ended

How the rules in this series played out in Gov. Spencer Cox's 2020 and 2024 races, the controversies of the past 25 years with how each one ended, and the earlier times Utah has fought these same fights.

Statewide

CASE 2026-WGS-06 · Posted Nov. 8, 2026 · Updated Nov. 8, 2026

New to this? Read it in plain words About 500 words, with simple charts.
Transparency pages (33) · tap to open
  1. Transparency docketEvery case file, searchable
  2. Who Gets a Say · plain wordsUtah's primary and map rules, 2018–2026
  3. Holding Power · plain wordsHow the rules kept one party in charge
  4. Selling the Vote · plain wordsThe business of political marketing in Utah
  5. Lost Ideals · plain wordsWhat Utah promised its voters
  6. The Fracture · plain wordsWhy Utahns say no party represents them
  7. It Happened Before · plain wordsUtah controversies and how they ended
  8. The 2026 Amendments · plain wordsAmendments A and B on your ballot
  9. Amendment B: Myth vs. Fact · plain wordsClaims checked against the record
  10. Amendment B QuizTest what you know
  11. Who Sits at the Taxpayers Association's Table · plain wordsIts leaders, lobbyists, sponsors and their money
  12. Weber Housing Authority · plain wordsA commissioner, his wife and the authority that pays their company
  13. What the Privacy Office Can and Can't Do · plain wordsUtah's Chief Privacy Officer
  14. Counting the Jobs · plain wordsJob promises and what was reported
  15. Matt Brower · plain wordsThe board seat that never came up
  16. Ten Days · plain wordsThe Nilson Foundation's 501(c)(3) claim
  17. One Vote, Four Checks · plain wordsS.B. 258 and preliminary municipalities
  18. The Land Counties Can't Zone · plain wordsTrust land and county zoning
  19. SITLA: The Land Nobody Zones · plain wordsWho answers for trust land
  20. Tyson Leaves Eagle Mountain · plain wordsFive years after opening
  21. Behind the Bench · plain wordsJudge and lawyer complaints in Utah
  22. Wrong Room, Right Message · plain wordsA housing adviser in Heber City
  23. Every Weber County Property Tax Increase Since 2019 · plain wordsThe full list
  24. A New Line on the Bill · plain wordsRoy and Riverdale fire annexation
  25. Paying for the Next Station · plain wordsHow Weber Fire District funds growth
  26. Weber County's New Sales Tax · plain wordsA public vote, but no vote by the public
  27. Bills That Did the Opposite · plain wordsBait and switch, 2018 to 2026
  28. The Blank Box · plain wordsThree disclosure forms, one pattern
  29. Utah's Campaign-Finance Enforcement Gap · plain wordsComplaints filed, few penalties
  30. One Lake, Two Money Pots · plain wordsThe Great Salt Lake Trust Council
  31. Wells at the Top · plain wordsPowder Mountain's water
  32. Then vs. Now · plain wordsEarlier plans and later approvals in Ogden Valley
  33. West Haven's 6% Energy Tax · plain wordsA new line on the power bill
Read this first
This page lists allegations only together with how they ended: charges, acquittals, dismissals, audits or no action. An allegation is not a finding. Each person's own response is included where it was reported. Some vote totals come from secondary summaries and are being checked against official canvasses.

The short version

Cox's two runs, side by side

Step20202024
ConventionCox 55.0%, Greg Hughes 45.0% in the final round; short of the 60% needed to avoid a primary.Phil Lyman 67.54%, Cox 32.46% in the final round. Cox was booed.
Path to the primarySignatures and convention. Jon Huntsman Jr. and Jeff Burningham also tried signatures; Huntsman and Thomas Wright qualified that way.Signatures.
Party-switch deadlineNone. Switches up to the registration deadline counted.In effect (Jan. 9 for party-to-party switches; unaffiliated could still join a party).
PrimaryCox 36.15%, Huntsman 34.95%, Hughes 21.02%, Wright 7.88%. Margin over Huntsman: 6,319 votes.Cox 54.40% (232,164), Lyman 45.60% (194,639). Official canvass.
GeneralCox 62.98%, Chris Peterson (D) 30.35%.Cox 52.89%, Brian King (D) 28.46%, Lyman write-in 13.57%.
Spending (reported)Not found.Cox spent $3.78 million (as of Oct. 14, 2024); Lyman spent $1.05 million (as of June 13).

Sources: 2020 and 2024 Wikipedia summaries citing state canvasses (secondary; being checked); 2024 primary canvass; AP via the Washington Times (4/26/2020).

Cox's primary share, both runs

2020 primary (4 candidates)
36.15%
2024 primary (2 candidates)
54.40%

Where Cox and Lyman won the 2024 primary

Cox's share of the two-candidate vote by county. Darker means a larger Cox share; under 50% means Lyman carried the county. Cox carried 14 of 29 counties, including Salt Lake, Utah, Davis and Weber; Lyman carried the other 15, including Washington County.

Cache: 59% Duchesne: 44% Davis: 60% Millard: 43% Wasatch: 53% Box Elder: 52% Weber: 53% Juab: 41% Sanpete: 51% Washington: 41% Grand: 43% Rich: 62% Carbon: 52% Daggett: 53% Beaver: 45% Sevier: 46% Garfield: 58% Tooele: 52% Summit: 59% Piute: 44% Uintah: 41% Iron: 46% Emery: 47% Wayne: 42% San Juan: 22% Morgan: 49% Kane: 49% Salt Lake: 62% Utah: 51% 59% 44% 60% 43% 53% 52% 53% 41% 51% 41% 43% 62% 52% 53% 45% 46% 58% 52% 59% 44% 41% 46% 47% 42% 22% 49% 49% 62% 51% 30% 38% 46% 54% 62% 70% Cox share of the Cox–Lyman primary vote, 2024 (50% = tie)

Source: 2024 Primary Election State Canvass (county totals add to 232,164 and 194,639). Boundaries: Utah Geospatial Resource Center.

All 29 counties, highest Cox share first
CountyCoxLymanCox share
Salt Lake70,94242,59562.5%
Rich50931262.0%
Davis32,26021,16360.4%
Summit2,9572,06158.9%
Cache10,6077,48558.6%
Garfield69651357.6%
Weber15,59213,56753.5%
Wasatch2,9952,64953.1%
Daggett13612352.5%
Carbon1,4011,29052.1%
Box Elder5,3174,97451.7%
Tooele4,3684,09651.6%
Utah47,08944,57651.4%
Sanpete2,9362,86250.6%
Morgan1,4541,49549.3%
Kane9841,02649.0%
Emery1,0321,15147.3%
Iron4,5285,21846.5%
Sevier2,2212,64545.6%
Beaver65681444.6%
Duchesne1,8102,26544.4%
Piute22328643.8%
Grand55473143.1%
Millard1,3901,87642.6%
Wayne34448441.5%
Washington14,95521,38141.2%
Uintah2,7153,89141.1%
Juab1,0251,47541.0%
San Juan4681,63522.3%

Did the rules change the outcome?

The 2024 challenges and audits

Since then

Deseret News/Hinckley polls put Cox at 50% approve in November 2025, 52% in February 2026 and 41% approve, 49% disapprove in August 2026, the first time underwater in that poll (Deseret News). After the Nov. 2025 map ruling, Democrats' approval of Cox fell from 37% to 22%. Cox signed S.B. 134 (adding two justices) and HB392 (a three-judge constitutional court) in 2026.

Controversies and how they ended

Officials of both parties. Allegations are listed with their outcomes.

YearWhoWhat was alleged or foundHow it ended
2010Rep. Kevin Garn (R), House majority leaderPublicly admitted a 1985 hot-tub incident with a then-15-year-old and a 2002 payment of $150,000 to her.Resigned Mar. 14, 2010. No charges reported (Deseret).
2011The Legislature (HB477)Restricted public access to government records; signed hours after referendum papers were filed.Repealed in a special session Mar. 25, 2011 after public outcry (Ballotpedia).
2013–17AGs John Swallow and Mark Shurtleff (R)Bribery and corruption allegations; a 2013 special-counsel report found Swallow violated campaign disclosure laws (administrative finding).Swallow resigned in 2013; charged in 2014; acquitted on all counts in 2017. Shurtleff's charges were dismissed in 2016. Zero convictions (Salt Lake Tribune).
2022Sen. Gene Davis (D)An investigation hired by the Senate President found conduct that "likely violated Senate policies."Removed from committees; lost his primary (UPR).
2023–25AG Sean Reyes (R)A legislative audit found a lack of transparency and a perceived conflict of interest in his ties to Operation Underground Railroad.Did not seek reelection; no charges reported. His office said the audit "validated" its culture (FOX 13).
2024Rep. Phil Lyman (R)An outside investigator found his conduct at a state land agency meeting "unprofessional and inappropriate," with no violation of law or policy.Lyman called it a "cancel report" and denied the account (Deseret).
2024State School Board member Natalie ClineA post questioning a student's gender.Censured by the Legislature; lost reelection.
2026Justice Diana HagenAlleged inappropriate relationship with an attorney for the redistricting plaintiffs. The Judicial Conduct Commission dismissed the complaint; the governor, Speaker and Senate President then announced an investigation.Resigned May 8, 2026, maintaining she never had a conflict; she had recused from the case in 2025. No finding of wrongdoing reported (KUER; Behind the Bench, Part 2).
2026Prop 4 repeal signature gathererA North Carolina gatherer was charged with 22 counts in Uintah County; nine people interviewed said they did not sign.Pleaded no contest to two felony forgery counts; the plea is held in abeyance and 20 counts were dropped. The campaign itself was not accused (KSL).
2026Rep. Trevor Lee (R)Two businessmen alleged unpaid debts and altered checks; the Speaker referred the matter to the attorney general.Open or unknown; no charges. Lee denies wrongdoing and lost his primary (Salt Lake Tribune).
2026Governor's Office of Economic OpportunityA legislative audit found $249 million in grants at risk; past management couldn't consistently show how some money was spent.The agency accepted the recommendations (KSL; Hive audit page).
2026Sen. Kathleen Riebe (D)The Senate Democratic caucus said an investigation found conduct "likely motivated by race, national origin, or ethnicity."Removed from the caucus, which called for her resignation. Riebe disputes it: "I am not going to resign" (KUER).
2026Senate President Stuart Adams (R)Faced criticism over a Box Elder data center project his challenger made an issue.Lost his primary to Stephanie Hollist; called his service "one of the greatest honors of my life" (KSL). The Hive's Stratos coverage: Data-Centers repo.

Has this happened before?

Today's fightEarlier times in Utah
Lawmakers changing voter-passed laws2000: voters passed an asset-forfeiture initiative with 69%; a 2013 bill labeled a recodification removed many of its protections, passing unanimously (per Libertas Institute, an advocacy group). 2018: all three initiatives (Props 2, 3, 4) were changed or replaced.
Referendums forcing repeal2007: voters repealed the school-voucher law, 62% to 38%. 2011: HB477 repealed after referendum papers were filed. 2020: the food-tax law repealed after its referendum qualified (117,154 valid signatures). 2025: the collective bargaining ban repealed in special session after its referendum qualified.
Fights over maps2001: Matheson's district redrawn; he chose not to sue. 2011: "pizza slice" maps; no lawsuit is listed in the Loyola Law School redistricting docket. 2021–26: the 2022 lawsuit overturned the 2021 map. The Utah Supreme Court dismissed the Legislature's appeal on Feb. 20, 2026, and a federal challenge to the court's map was later dropped.
Court and Legislature clashes1984: voters approved a new Judicial Article (55.86%) creating the Judicial Council and Judicial Conduct Commission. 2025: a truce paused bills on judicial retention. 2026: four former justices objected to the court bills; Justice Zimmerman said lawmakers were "legislating because you're an unhappy litigant." Leaders said the bills promote accountability.
Leaders losing at home2026: Senate President Adams, Rep. Trevor Lee and Sen. Dan McCay lost primaries. 1986: Democrats gained 14 House seats amid anger over tax increases.
BillOur gradeWhat it didHow it connects
H.B. 3001 (2018)
House 60-13-2 · Senate 22-4-3 · Signed Dec 3, 2018
D+The Medical Cannabis Replacement. Voters passed Proposition 2 in November 2018.2018: replaced Prop 2.
S.B. 96 (2019)
Senate 22-7-0 · House 56-19-0 · Senate concurs 22-7-0 · Signed Feb 11, 2019
C-The Medicaid Expansion Rewrite. Voters passed Proposition 3 in 2018 for full Medicaid expansion paid for by a small sales tax.2019: rewrote Prop 3.
S.B. 200 (2020)
Senate 25-0-4 · House 67-4-4 · Signed Mar 28, 2020
FThe Redistricting Replacement. Voters passed Proposition 4 in 2018, creating an independent redistricting commission.2020: replaced Prop 4.
S.B. 2001 (2019 2nd Spec.) + H.B. 185 (2020)
Full floor vote counts not yet confirmed for either bill
FBait-and-Switch: Repealed Before the Referendum Could Happen. Raised the grocery sales tax from 1.75% to 4.85% without a two-thirds majority, leaving it open to referendum.2020: repealed before the referendum vote.
H.B. 2001 (2025)
House 60-9-6; Senate 26-1-2 (both 12/9/25; the one Senate no vote was Sen. Todd Weiler) · Signed 12/11/2025
FRepealed Before the Vote: The Union Referendum. H.B. 267 (2025), sponsored by Rep.2025: repealed before the referendum vote.

People in this part

Where each person appears elsewhere in the Hive. Being named here does not mean anyone did anything wrong.

WhoWhy they are hereOther Hive pages
Spencer CoxGovernor (R)Biggest donors
Energy money
Data center industry money
Deidre HendersonLieutenant Governor (R); runs electionsMoney in, money out
Derek BrownAttorney General (R); Prop 4 repeal sponsorThe Men Behind Lincoln Hill
H.B. 243
H.B. 591
Sean ReyesFormer Attorney General (R)Benitez v. Reyes
Gambling money
Diana HagenFormer Utah Supreme Court justice; resigned May 2026Behind the Bench, Part 2
Judges on your ballot
Stuart AdamsSenate President (R); lost his 2026 primaryAdams Leadership PAC
Enforcement Gap
Stephanie HollistDefeated Senate President Adams in the 2026 primarySD-7 race file
Bob StevensonDefeated Rep. Trevor Lee in the 2026 primaryHD-16 race file
The Layton Shuffle

What the records do not show

Words to know

Tap a card to see what it means.

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

The Lt. Governor's OfficeWhich of the 2024 audit's seven signature-checking recommendations are in place now?
Your legislatorsShould "substantially similar" signatures have a written standard in law?
The Utah Republican PartyShould convention results and primary results be closer, and how?
The attorney general's officeWhat is the status of the referral about Rep. Trevor Lee?
YourselfWhen you read about a scandal, check how it ended before you share it.

Connected Hive work

Who Gets a SayPart 1: before and after the party-switch rule Holding PowerPart 2: maps, petitions, courts and boards Behind the BenchTransparency: judge and lawyer complaints Utah's Campaign-Finance Enforcement GapTransparency AuditsState and county auditsGovernment in CourtStatewide docketDeidre Henderson, Money In, Money OutLedger

Behind this piece

45
Court records, audits and reports read (estimate)
13
Controversies traced to their outcome
80
Searches run (estimate)

Posted Nov. 8, 2026.

Full sources
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

Independent accountability journalism. Public records only. We report; you decide.

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Transparency home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack