Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2026-243-GAM · Gambling & prediction markets

The Prop-Bet Bill the AG's Office Asked to Widen

H.B. 243 made proposition bets gambling in Utah. In committee, the sponsor said the Attorney General's office asked to take out the words that limited it to sports. That October, the AG used Utah's gambling laws to sue and charge Kalshi.

Posted Nov. 4, 2026 · Updated Nov. 4, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

ItemDetail
BillH.B. 243 (2026 General Session), "Gambling Revisions"
Primary sponsorRep. Joseph Elison (R)
Senate sponsorSen. Brady Brammer (R)
CosponsorsReps. Steve Eliason, Stephen L. Whyte, Ariel Defay, Raymond P. Ward
Final votesHouse 63–9–3 (Feb. 10, 2026); Senate 25–0–4 (Feb. 27, 2026)
StatusLaw. Signed March 25, 2026; in effect May 6, 2026 (H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov)
Utah Code76-9-1401 (gambling definitions)
Fiscal noteNo material change in state revenue or spending; no local cost estimated (H.B. 243 fiscal note, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst)

New to this? Betting apps, explained simply

Most of us have never used these apps. Here is what each kind is, in everyday words.

A regular betYou and a friend each put in $5 on who wins the big game. Whoever picks the winner gets the $10. Utah's Constitution has never allowed this kind of betting.
A prop bet ("proposition bet")Instead of betting on who wins, you bet on one small thing: "Will the quarterback throw more than 2 touchdowns?" or "Will the coach say a certain word in his interview?" It is still a bet. You win money or lose it. H.B. 243 says these count as gambling in Utah.
A prediction market (like Kalshi)An app sells "yes" and "no" tickets on almost anything: a game, an election, whether the Fed changes interest rates. If a "yes" ticket costs 60 cents and the answer turns out to be yes, it pays $1; if not, you lose your 60 cents. The companies call this "trading," like the stock market, and say federal regulators (the CFTC), not states, are in charge of them. Utah's AG calls it gambling: "a distinction without a difference."
A sweepstakes casino (like VGW's Chumba)An online slot-machine style site that uses two kinds of play money. One kind can be traded for real prizes. The companies say it is not gambling because "no purchase is necessary." People in Utah have sued some of them, and those suits are not decided. H.B. 243 does not deal with these.
Fantasy sports and "pick'em" apps (like PrizePicks, Underdog)You pick players and win if they do well. Some states call it skill, some call it gambling. H.B. 243's sponsor said the bill does not deal with fantasy leagues. Some of these companies now also sell prediction-market tickets.
Why this fight mattersIf federal law covers these apps, Utah may not be able to stop them, even though its Constitution bans gambling. That question is now in federal court, and Utah's case is part of it.
You pay 60¢ for one "yes" ticket It happensIt doesn't happen You get $1.0040¢ more than you paid You get $0your 60¢ is gone
How a prediction-market ticket works. The price (60¢ here, a made-up example) moves up and down as people buy and sell. Utah's AG says this is betting; the companies call it trading.

Example amounts are made up to show how it works. The descriptions of each company come from the sources on this page.

Graded by the collective rubric

DOverall · Hinders
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerDThe bill widens a criminal definition at the request of the office that enforces it. It sets no standard for which apps, companies or bets the AG pursues first, and it adds no reporting on how that choice is made. The public check it keeps: it changes a definition only; penalties stay where the Legislature set them (H.B. 243 enrolled (final) text; House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45)).
TransparencyDA member of the public reading the written record would not know who asked for the change. The minutes say only that Rep. Cutler moved Amendment #1; that the AG's office asked for it is said only on the video. The sponsor also said "a company" offered him a bet on his own bill, and did not name it (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026; House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45); House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42)).
Financial accountabilityDThe fiscal note estimates no material cost. It does not count enforcement or court costs, and the bill was presented as a tool for AG legal action; the state is now in federal and state court over this kind of betting (H.B. 243 fiscal note, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst; House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42); Deseret News, Dennis Romboy, Utah sues Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026).
Environmental impactN/ANo effect on water, land or wildlife.
Community impactDThe people the bill reaches, mostly young adults who use betting apps, were never heard. No member of the public testified in either committee; the Senate chair asked and no one came forward. The bill was presented by the office that enforces it, and the public saw no outside view before a four-word cut ("during an athletic event") widened a criminal definition (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026; Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12)).

New grade, Nov. 4, 2026, graded from the public's side of the record. This grades the bill: the introduced text, the committee amendment and the final law. Power is D: a criminal definition was widened at the request of the office that enforces it, with no standard for how it is applied. Transparency is D: the written record does not show who asked for the change. Financial accountability is D: the cost of enforcing it was not estimated, though the bill was presented as a tool for AG lawsuits. Community impact is D: no one from the public was heard. Environment is N/A. Average 1.0 = D.

How a grade can change: a published AG enforcement policy for prediction markets would raise Power; a minutes entry or public statement naming who requested the amendment would raise Transparency; a fiscal note or report that counts enforcement and court costs would raise Financial accountability; a future hearing with public testimony on these bills would raise Community impact.

A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; exactly halfway counts toward the higher letter with a minus. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Quoted from the final, enrolled bill (H.B. 243 enrolled (final) text).

Utah Code 76-9-1401, "Gambling" includes

(i) a lottery; and (ii) a proposition bet.

Utah Code 76-9-1401, new definition

"Proposition bet" means a gambling bet on an individual action, statistic, occurrence, or non-occurrence.

That is the whole change. The bill reprints the rest of the definitions section, but the rules about fringe gaming devices, sweepstakes and promotions were already law; they came from earlier bills (see Where it fits) (H.B. 243 enrolled (final) text).

What it does not do: it adds no new crime or penalty, and it does not address sweepstakes casinos or fantasy sports. Rep. Elison said on the House floor that fantasy leagues are "not" addressed by the bill (House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42)). The penalties for gambling already sit elsewhere in Utah Code Title 76, Chapter 9, Part 14.

Utah's Constitution already says the Legislature "shall not authorize any game of chance, lottery or gift enterprise" (Utah Constitution, Article VI, Section 27). On the House floor, Rep. Elison said the AG's office told him that without this bill, a prop bet "most likely in a court of law, it would still be considered, um, not gambling" (House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42)).

Every version, and what changed

VersionDateWhat changed
IntroducedJan. 13, 2026Added "proposition bet" to the gambling definition, limited to bets during an athletic event (H.B. 243 as introduced).
House committee Amendment #1 (moved by Rep. Paul Cutler)Jan. 30, 2026Took out the athletic-event limit, so the definition covers any "individual action, statistic, occurrence, or non-occurrence." Adopted 8–0–2 (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026; House committee vote, Jan. 30, 2026 (8-0-2); H.B. 243 as amended in House committee (Feb. 2, 2026)).
Enrolled (final)March 2026Same as the amended bill. No further changes in the Senate (H.B. 243 enrolled (final) text; H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov).

As introduced (Jan. 13)

a bet on an individual action, statistic, occurrence, or non-occurrence during an athletic event

Final law (after the Jan. 30 amendment)

a gambling bet on an individual action, statistic, occurrence, or non-occurrence. (the sports limit is gone, so it covers bets on anything)

The four words that came out. The introduced wording is from the amendment record and the hearing; the final wording is quoted from the enrolled bill.
The change that matters. With the word "athletic" in it, the bill covered sports prop bets. Without it, the bill covers bets on anything, which is how prediction-market apps work. The AG's chief deputy said so in the hearing: "by taking out the word athletic, it, it broadens it to anything else that we would find in those apps" (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45)).

The votes

House committee, Jan. 30House committee, Jan. 30: 8 yes8 yesHouse committee, Jan. 30: 2 absent2 absentHouse floor, Feb. 10House floor, Feb. 10: 63 yes63 yesHouse floor, Feb. 10: 9 no9 noHouse floor, Feb. 10: 3 absent3 absentSenate committee, Feb. 19Senate committee, Feb. 19: 5 yes5 yesSenate committee, Feb. 19: 3 absent3 absentSenate floor, Feb. 27Senate floor, Feb. 27: 25 yes25 yesSenate floor, Feb. 27: 4 absent4 absent
Every recorded vote on H.B. 243. Dark = yes, orange = no, light = absent. Names are in the table below.
DateWhereResultNames
Jan. 30, 2026House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee8–0–2 (amendment and bill)Yes: Cutler, Fiefia, Hansen, Hawkins, Jack, Mauga, Miller, Shelley. Absent: Owens, Shallenberger (House committee vote, Jan. 30, 2026 (8-0-2))
Feb. 10, 2026House, 3rd reading63–9–3No: Gricius, Gwynn, Koford, Lee, MacPherson, Monson, Pierucci, Shallenberger, Teuscher. Absent or not voting: Dailey-Provost, Lisonbee, Wilcox (House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 10, 2026 (63-9-3))
Feb. 19, 2026Senate Business and Labor Committee5–0–3Yes: Ipson, Musselman, Pitcher, Vickers, Weiler. Absent: Cullimore, McCay, Sandall (Senate committee vote, Feb. 19, 2026 (5-0-3))
Feb. 25–26, 2026Senate, 2nd readingCircled Feb. 25, uncircled Feb. 26, passed 19–0–10The record does not say why it was circled (H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov)
Feb. 27, 2026Senate, 3rd reading25–0–4Absent or not voting: Cullimore, McKell, Sandall, Stevenson (Senate 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (25-0-4))

No one spoke against the bill in either committee or on the House floor. The nine House members who voted no did not explain their votes on the record we read (House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42)).

In their own words

Quoted from the official hearing video's auto-generated captions, read Nov. 4, 2026. Auto-captions can get words and names wrong (they call Rep. Elison "Monson" and "Lyon" in places), so each speaker below is matched to the official minutes, and each quote should be checked against the video before it is reused.

House committee, Jan. 30, 2026

there is an amendment... What that amendment does is that just simply, it's not just exclusive to sports. 'cause as, you know, prop betting can be, you know, Donald Trump is going to wear an orange tie, yes or no

— Rep. Joseph Elison, sponsor (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45))

So actually the Attorney General's office asked for this amendment for that very reason. 'cause they said, wait a minute, this needs to go beyond just sports betting. This needs to go into all prop bedding [betting] across the board.

— Rep. Joseph Elison, sponsor (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45))

there are apps out there, and if you get into there, you can find all sorts of interesting things to bet on whether or not the Fed will change in March. Who's gonna win the best pitcher [picture] for the Oscar? Um, Grammys... it's also illegal. And so by taking out the word athletic, it, it broadens it to anything else that we would find in those apps.

— Daniel Burton, Chief Deputy Attorney General and General Counsel (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45); House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026)

we have, uh, been looking at a lot of these companies... how they're trying to set themselves up as being regulated by the feds and not the states. And we've been working to push back on those efforts. I think you'll also see more direct, uh, efforts in the next, uh, while

— Daniel Burton, Office of the Attorney General (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45))

House floor, Feb. 10, 2026

I had a, uh, a company reach out to me and asked if I wanted to place a bet whether or not this bill was going to pass.

— Rep. Joseph Elison (House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42))

The enforcement mechanism is the Attorney General's office can send a letter of cease and desist to any company who is breaking our law. If they choose not to stop acting this way in the state of Utah, then we can take legal action against them.

— Rep. Joseph Elison, answering Rep. Maloy (House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42))

they know that these companies are reaching out to teenagers and especially to our young men, uh, to get involved in prediction markets, trading futures, fantasy betting groups like Robinhood and Calci [Kalshi]

— Rep. Melissa Ballard (House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42))

Senate committee, Feb. 19, 2026

I am Derek Brown. I work in the office of the Attorney General.

— Attorney General Derek Brown (Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12); Senate Business and Labor Committee minutes, Feb. 19, 2026)

he got a targeted social media ad from, uh, from a company that obviously knows these laws very, very well. It's the largest one in the country. And it said it is legal to make money on football in all 50 states.

— Attorney General Derek Brown, describing an ad his son received on Super Bowl Sunday (Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12))

Now if that sounds like a distinction without a difference, it, it absolutely is in my mind, and it is gambling.

— Attorney General Derek Brown (Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12))

Our state constitution prohibits all forms of gambling, and the only way to change that is by a vote of the people.

— Sen. Todd Weiler (Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12))

Brown did not name the company in the hearing. No member of the public testified (Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12); Senate Business and Labor Committee minutes, Feb. 19, 2026).

How it connects

Each line is a public record named on this page. A line between two boxes is not a claim that anyone acted together.

flowchart TD AG["AG's office
asks to widen H.B. 243
(Jan. 30, 2026)"] --> B243["H.B. 243
prop bets = gambling
in effect May 6"] B591["H.B. 591
AG keeps nuisance lawsuit power
in effect May 6"] BR["Sen. Brady Brammer
Senate sponsor of both"] --> B243 BR --> B591 CAMP["Derek Brown's campaign"] -- "$2,000, June 3" --> BR CAMP -- "$300, Oct. 27" --> JACK["Rep. Colin Jack
H.B. 591 sponsor"] B243 --> SUIT["Oct. 20: AG sues Kalshi
(nuisance count uses H.B. 591)
Oct. 28: criminal charges"] B591 --> SUIT DON["Gambling-industry gifts
$92,800 in 2026"] --> CAMP

Sources: H.B. 243 and H.B. 591 bill pages and video (le.utah.gov); Brown campaign gifts as filed in recipients' reports (disclosures.utah.gov); KUTV and Deseret News, Oct. 20, 2026; The Ledger, Case 17.

The timeline

  1. Oct. 25, 2018 Las Vegas Sands gives $5,000 to then-AG Sean Reyes, the first gambling-industry gift in the state files from 2018 on (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)).
  2. 2018–2024 Five gambling-industry gifts to Utah candidates in seven years, $10,500 in all (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)).
  3. Nov. 2025 About 15 class-action suits are filed in Utah courts against sweepstakes casino companies; VGW and Arb Gaming are among those named. These are allegations, not findings (Covers, Utah becomes hotspot for sweepstakes casino class actions, Nov. 4, 2025).
  4. Nov. 2025 PrizePicks launches prediction markets through Kalshi (PrizePicks press release, PrizePicks launches prediction markets offering with Kalshi). DraftKings and FanDuel leave the American Gaming Association over prediction markets (GamesHub, FanDuel and DraftKings leave the American Gaming Association).
  5. Jan. 13, 2026 H.B. 243 is numbered and made public (H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov).
  6. Jan. 16–19, 2026 Arb Gaming gives Brown $5,000; Stacie Stern (Underdog, per news reports) gives $10,000 (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)).
  7. Jan. 20, 2026 Lincoln Shurtz of Lincoln Hill Partners registers as VGW's Utah lobbyist (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive); lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist search by organization (read Nov. 4, 2026)).
  8. Jan. 30, 2026 House committee takes out the athletic-event limit at the AG's request, 8–0–2 (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026; House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45)).
  9. Feb. 10, 2026 House passes H.B. 243, 63–9–3 (House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 10, 2026 (63-9-3)).
  10. Feb. 19, 2026 AG Derek Brown presents H.B. 243 in the Senate committee; 5–0–3 (Senate Business and Labor Committee minutes, Feb. 19, 2026; Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12)).
  11. Feb. 26, 2026 Kalshi sues Gov. Cox and the AG's office in federal court to stop Utah from enforcing its gambling laws against it (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)).
  12. Feb. 27, 2026 Senate passes H.B. 243, 25–0–4 (Senate 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (25-0-4)).
  13. March 25, 2026 Gov. Cox signs H.B. 243 (H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov).
  14. Apr. 21, 2026 Las Vegas Sands gives Brown $50,000 (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)).
  15. May 6, 2026 H.B. 243 and H.B. 591 take effect (H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov; H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, le.utah.gov (Utah Code 78B-6a-102)).
  16. June 3, 2026 Derek Brown's campaign gives Sen. Brady Brammer $2,000 (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026).
  17. July 30, 2026 Chase Everton of Lincoln Hill Partners registers as Kalshi's Utah lobbyist (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive); lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist search by organization (read Nov. 4, 2026)).
  18. Aug. 2026 A federal judge rules for Utah in Kalshi's case; on Sept. 8 the 10th Circuit declines to pause that ruling (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)).
  19. Aug. 31–Oct. 29, 2026 VGW gives to 22 Utah candidates, $27,800 in all. Seventeen of the 21 legislators had voted for H.B. 243 (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)).
  20. Oct. 8, 2026 The American Gaming Association asks the U.S. Supreme Court to take New Jersey's Kalshi case; its brief cites Utah's federal court ruling (American Gaming Association amicus brief, Flaherty v. KalshiEX, No. 26-299, U.S. Supreme Court, Oct. 8, 2026).
  21. Oct. 20, 2026 Brown sues Kalshi, two Susquehanna firms and others in Third District Court (No. 260908356) and declares gambling a public nuisance, finding "significant and substantial ongoing harm" to a "significant number" of Utahns, as KUTV reported (KUTV, Utah Attorney General declares online gambling public nuisance in lawsuit against Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026; Deseret News, Dennis Romboy, Utah sues Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026).
  22. Oct. 27, 2026 Derek Brown's campaign gives Rep. Colin Jack, H.B. 591's sponsor, $300 (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026).
  23. Oct. 26, 2026 The United States and the CFTC sue Utah and Brown in federal court (No. 2:26-cv-01055), saying federal law, not Utah's, covers these markets (United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026).
  24. Oct. 28, 2026 Criminal charges against KalshiEX and its founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara are dated: 14 counts, including online gambling promotion and a pattern of unlawful activity (State of Utah v. KalshiEX, LLC, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, Criminal Information and Declaration of Probable Cause, Third District Court, Salt Lake County, dated Oct. 28, 2026 (AGO No. 9465862), posted by Utah News Dispatch).

Money and lobbyists around this bill

The AG's campaign and the sponsors

From the records: Derek Brown's AG campaign gave $2,000 to Sen. Brady Brammer on June 3, 2026, as filed. Brammer was the Senate sponsor of H.B. 243 and also of H.B. 591, the nuisance law whose AG exception matches the test Brown used against Kalshi. The campaign also gave $300 to Rep. Colin Jack, H.B. 591's House sponsor, on Oct. 27, seven days after the Kalshi suit (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026; H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov; H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, le.utah.gov (Utah Code 78B-6a-102); KUTV, Utah Attorney General declares online gambling public nuisance in lawsuit against Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026). The records show the gifts and the dates. They do not show why.
PersonRoleMoney from Brown's campaign, 2026Gambling-industry money
Rep. Joseph ElisonH.B. 243 House sponsorNone in the list of Brown's 2026 giftsNone. His 2025 and 2026 reports list 10 donors, $6,550 in all, among them Realtors, home builders, Johnson & Johnson, energy, health care, title and the House Republican caucus PAC (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026)
Sen. Brady BrammerSenate sponsor of H.B. 243 and H.B. 591$2,000 (June 3)None in the state files, 2018–2026 (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive))
Rep. Colin JackH.B. 591 House sponsor; voted yes on H.B. 243 in committee$300 (Oct. 27)None in the state files (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive))

Brown's campaign made 22 gifts to other candidates and parties in 2026, $9,840.43 in all. Four went to House members who voted no on H.B. 243: Gricius ($300), Koford ($250), MacPherson ($480.30) and Teuscher ($364.90). So the gifts did not go only to supporters (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026; House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 10, 2026 (63-9-3)).

Gambling-industry money, by year

$0$25K$50K$75K$100K2018: $5,0002018$5,0002019$02020$02021$02022$02023: $2,5002023$2,5002024: $3,0002024$3,0002025: $12,5002025$12,5002026: $92,8002026$92,800
Gambling-industry money to Utah candidates, by year. 2026 (gold) is more than the eight years before it combined, four times over. Source: The Ledger, Case 17, from state disclosure files.
$0$25K$50KNov 25DecJan 26: $15,000$15,000Jan 26FebMarApr: $50,000$50,000AprMayJunJulAug: $2,000$2,000AugSep: $22,800$22,800SepOct: $3,000$3,000Oct12345671Nov 25: Class-action suits vs. sweepstakes sites2Jan 26: H.B. 243 filed; AG asks to widen it3Feb: House + Senate pass; Kalshi sues Utah4Mar: Cox signs5May: H.B. 243 + H.B. 591 in effect6Jun: Brown gives Brammer $2,0007Oct: AG sues and charges Kalshi
Gambling-industry gifts by month (gold bars) next to what was happening (navy dots). The records show the timing, not the reasons. Sources: The Ledger, Case 17; le.utah.gov; news reports on this page.
AG Derek BrownAG Derek Brown: $83,000$83,00021 legislators (all from VGW)21 legislators (all from VGW): $22,800$22,800Then-AG Sean ReyesThen-AG Sean Reyes: $7,500$7,500Gov. Spencer CoxGov. Spencer Cox: $2,500$2,500
Who got the $115,800, 2018–2026. Brown received 72%. Source: The Ledger, Case 17.
YearsGiftsAmount
2018–20245$10,500
20254$12,500
2026 (to Oct. 29)25$92,800

From The Ledger, Case 17, built from the state's "Download Data by Year" files: 655,619 transactions searched by donor name. 80% of the gambling money since 2018 came in 2026 (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive); disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026).

Registered Utah lobbyists

CompanyLobbyistFirmReported spending on officials, 2026
KalshiChase Everton (since July 30, 2026)Lincoln Hill PartnersNone reported
VGW (VGW Corporate Services Australia Pty Ltd)Lincoln Shurtz (since Jan. 20, 2026)Lincoln Hill PartnersQ1: $0.00; nothing after
PrizePicks (Sideprize LLC d/b/a PrizePicks)Greg Hartley; Jeffrey Hartley; Greg HughesSage Solutions; Sage Government Solutions; TSC LLCNone reported
DraftKingsJodi Hart; Robert JolleyRRJ ConsultingNone reported
Underdog, Arb Gaming, Las Vegas Sands, American Gaming Association, FanDuel, Crypto.com, Robinhood, PolymarketNo current registration found——

(lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist search by organization (read Nov. 4, 2026); lobbyist.utah.gov, Advanced Search: 2026 quarterly lobbyist reports and the 'All Lobbyist 2026' download (read Nov. 4, 2026); The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)) One firm, Lincoln Hill Partners, lobbies for both Kalshi and VGW. Derek Brown is listed with that firm after its 2021 merger, and a "Brown, Derek" lobbyist record ran from 2017 to 2023 (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive)). A Greg Hughes was Utah House Speaker from 2015 to 2018; the registration does not say whether this is the same person, so we have not said so.

Why "none reported" is not a red flag by itself: under Utah Code 36-11-201, a lobbyist who spends nothing on an official in a quarter does not have to file. Statewide, 10 of the 1,992 lobbyist names on the registry reported any spending in 2026: 46 items, $8,676.21 in all (Utah Code 36-11-201, lobbyist financial reports (le.utah.gov); lobbyist.utah.gov, Advanced Search: 2026 quarterly lobbyist reports and the 'All Lobbyist 2026' download (read Nov. 4, 2026)). The money around this bill shows up as campaign gifts, not lobbyist meals or gifts.

Who gains if Kalshi is blocked? Each donor's position, on the record

The donors are not on one side. This table shows what each has said or done in public, not why it gave.

DonorGave in UtahPublic position on prediction marketsIf Kalshi is blocked
Las Vegas Sands$55,000, all to Utah AGs ($50,000 to Brown, Apr. 21, 2026)A casino company and member of the American Gaming Association, which told U.S. senators in May 2026 that prediction markets "function as sports betting in every meaningful sense" (The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive); Public Gaming Research Institute, AGA tells U.S. senators prediction markets are backdoor betting, May 22, 2026)Could gain, nationally. Utah has no legal betting to protect, but Utah's case tests whether states can stop these markets
American Gaming Association$2,500 to Gov. CoxAsked the U.S. Supreme Court on Oct. 8, 2026, to take up New Jersey's Kalshi case (American Gaming Association amicus brief, Flaherty v. KalshiEX, No. 26-299, U.S. Supreme Court, Oct. 8, 2026)Could gain, the same way
PrizePicks$9,500Partner of Kalshi; has offered prediction markets through Kalshi since Nov. 2025 (PrizePicks press release, PrizePicks launches prediction markets offering with Kalshi)Loses: its product runs on Kalshi
DraftKings$5,000Building its own prediction product; left the AGA over the issue (GamesHub, FanDuel and DraftKings leave the American Gaming Association)Mixed: loses a competitor, but is reached by the same law
Underdog (per news reports, via Stacie Stern)$11,000Launched sports prediction markets with Crypto.com in 2025 (The Block, Crypto.com and Underdog team up to launch sports prediction markets)Mixed or loses: same kind of product
VGW and Arb Gaming$27,800 and $5,000Sweepstakes casinos, a different product. H.B. 243 does not address sweepstakes. VGW's giving in other states came where sweepstakes bans were being weighed (Sweepsy, Tracking VGW political donations; Covers, Utah becomes hotspot for sweepstakes casino class actions, Nov. 4, 2025)No clear link to Kalshi

What happened next

What the AG's cases cite

Did the AG use H.B. 243 against Kalshi? Here is what the filings show.

CaseWhat it saysH.B. 243 or H.B. 591?
Lawsuit: Brown v. Kalshi Inc., et al., No. 260908356, Third District Court, filed Oct. 20, 2026Seeks to stop Kalshi from offering event contracts in Utah in categories including "Elections," "Politics," "Culture," "Sports" and "Mentions." Relies on Utah's gambling laws (Utah Code 76-9-1402, -1403, -1405, -1407, -1408), the election-wagering law (20A-1-606) and a public-nuisance count under 78B-6a-102(2) (United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026)H.B. 591: yes. The nuisance count uses the AG exception H.B. 591 created. H.B. 243: not by name. The gambling laws it relies on use the definition H.B. 243 changed
Criminal charges: State v. KalshiEX, LLC, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, Third District Court, dated Oct. 28, 202614 counts: one pattern of unlawful activity (2nd-degree felony), 12 counts of online gambling promotion (3rd-degree felonies), one general gambling promotion (Class A misdemeanor). The 12 bets an AG agent placed, Sept. 13–24, 2026, include game winners and bets on the first quarter, fourth quarter, final score, and passing and rushing yards (State of Utah v. KalshiEX, LLC, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, Criminal Information and Declaration of Probable Cause, Third District Court, Salt Lake County, dated Oct. 28, 2026 (AGO No. 9465862), posted by Utah News Dispatch)Not by name. It cites the gambling laws "Utah Code § 76-9-1401 et. seq.," the part H.B. 243 amended
What this shows: neither filing, as we read it, names H.B. 243. Both rely on the gambling laws whose definition H.B. 243 widened. The lawsuit's "Mentions," "Culture" and "Politics" categories are bets on things other than sports, the kind the Jan. 30 amendment reached. Some charged bets, like a quarterback's passing yards, are prop bets. The lawsuit's nuisance count uses H.B. 591 directly (United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026; State of Utah v. KalshiEX, LLC, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, Criminal Information and Declaration of Probable Cause, Third District Court, Salt Lake County, dated Oct. 28, 2026 (AGO No. 9465862), posted by Utah News Dispatch; House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026).

The criminal filing was read in full from the copy Utah News Dispatch posted. The lawsuit itself was not read; its laws and categories are as quoted and cited in the federal government's Oct. 26 complaint. Charges are accusations, not findings.

Where it fits: Utah vs. federal authority

Utah lawmakers often pass laws to push back on federal control. This case is that same fight, from a new direction.

The usual Utah patternThis case
Utah says federal agencies reach too far, and passes laws to claim state control, for example over public lands and federal money. The Legislature's Federalism Commission recommends many of these bills; see S.B. 44 (2026), H.B. 249 (2026) and H.B. 546 (2026) on the Bill-Tracker (Utah Legislature, Federalism Commission meeting record (le.utah.gov))Kalshi and the federal government say federal law controls these betting markets, so Utah cannot stop them. Utah says its Constitution and its own gambling laws come first (United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026; Utah Constitution, Article VI, Section 27)
Utah builds its case with new state laws, then goes to court.Utah widened its gambling definition (H.B. 243), kept a nuisance lawsuit only the AG can bring (H.B. 591), then sued and charged Kalshi using both kinds of law (H.B. 243 enrolled (final) text; H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, le.utah.gov (Utah Code 78B-6a-102); United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026; State of Utah v. KalshiEX, LLC, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, Criminal Information and Declaration of Probable Cause, Third District Court, Salt Lake County, dated Oct. 28, 2026 (AGO No. 9465862), posted by Utah News Dispatch)
how they're trying to set themselves up as being regulated by the feds and not the states. And we've been working to push back on those efforts.

— Daniel Burton, Office of the Attorney General, House committee, Jan. 30, 2026, nine months before the Kalshi lawsuit (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45))

AG Derek Brown is also listed as a speaker at the Legislature's first National Federalism Summit in September 2025, titled "Rebalancing the State-Federal Relationship" (UVU Center for Constitutional Studies, Inaugural National Federalism Summit program, 'Rebalancing the State-Federal Relationship,' Sept. 2025). The Kalshi fight now sits in the same place as Utah's public-lands and federal-funds fights: a federal court deciding where federal power ends and state power begins (United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026).

This box lines up the records. Whether Utah is using state law to get around federal law, or defending its Constitution from federal overreach, is for the reader to decide.

Where it fits

Bills that built Utah's gambling and enforcement laws, oldest first. This bill is highlighted. Pages for each are being added to the Bill-Tracker.

Bills that change the same rules

  1. 2012 H.B. 40
    Gambling Amendments; changed the promotional-activity exemption from fringe gambling.
  2. 2012 H.B. 108
    Internet Gambling; addressed online gambling.
  3. 2019 H.B. 23
    Gambling Machines Amendments; fringe gaming devices and pre-reveal features.
  4. 2020 S.B. 214
    Gambling Machine and Sweepstakes Amendments; sweepstakes rules, penalties, seizure and civil actions.
  5. 2023 S.B. 120
    Property and Contraband Amendments; seizure and forfeiture cross-references.
  6. 2025 H.B. 21
    Criminal Code Recodification; moved the gambling laws to Title 76, Chapter 9, Part 14.
  7. 2026 H.B. 243
    This bill. Proposition bets are gambling, not limited to sports.
  8. 2026 H.B. 591
    Nuisance Amendments; kept a common-law nuisance lawsuit for the AG.

Bill histories for the older bills are from le.utah.gov bill pages and are being checked bill by bill as their own pages are built.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Rep. Joseph ElisonPrimary sponsor; presented the bill in both chambers (H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov; House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026; Senate Business and Labor Committee minutes, Feb. 19, 2026)
Sen. Brady BrammerSenate sponsor of H.B. 243 and H.B. 591; received $2,000 from Brown's campaign June 3, 2026 (H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov; H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, le.utah.gov (Utah Code 78B-6a-102); disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026)2026 candidate files
Attorney General Derek BrownPresented the bill in the Senate committee; sued Kalshi Oct. 20; criminal charges dated Oct. 28 (Senate Business and Labor Committee minutes, Feb. 19, 2026; Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12); Deseret News, Dennis Romboy, Utah sues Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026; State of Utah v. KalshiEX, LLC, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, Criminal Information and Declaration of Probable Cause, Third District Court, Salt Lake County, dated Oct. 28, 2026 (AGO No. 9465862), posted by Utah News Dispatch)The Ledger, Case 17
Daniel BurtonChief Deputy Attorney General and General Counsel; assisted in the House committee (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026)
Rep. Paul CutlerMoved Amendment #1, which took out the athletic-event limit (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026)
Rep. Colin JackH.B. 591 primary sponsor; moved H.B. 243 out of committee; received $300 from Brown's campaign Oct. 27 (House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026; H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, le.utah.gov (Utah Code 78B-6a-102); disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026)
Lincoln Shurtz, Chase EvertonLincoln Hill Partners lobbyists for VGW and Kalshi (lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist search by organization (read Nov. 4, 2026))The Ledger, Case 17

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

AG Derek Brown's office (attorneygeneral.utah.gov)Why did your office ask to take "athletic event" out of H.B. 243, and which kinds of bets did you have in mind?
AG Derek Brown's officeHow does your office decide which companies to act against? Kalshi was charged; PrizePicks, DraftKings and Underdog offer prediction products and gave to your campaign.
AG Derek Brown's officeWill your campaign keep or return the gambling-industry money?
Rep. Joseph Elison and Sen. Brady Brammer (le.utah.gov)Did the AG's office write any of H.B. 243's language?
Sen. Brady BrammerWere H.B. 243 and H.B. 591 meant to work together?
Your legislator, if VGW gave to them (le.utah.gov)Did VGW or its lobbyist ask you for anything, and will you vote on a sweepstakes bill in 2027?
VGWDo your sites take players in Utah, and why start giving to Utah candidates in 2026?
The Legislative Fiscal AnalystWhat has enforcing H.B. 243 cost the state so far, including the Kalshi and CFTC cases?
Every legislatorUtah has no limit on campaign gifts and no rule that keeps an AG off a case involving donors. Should there be one?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

34
sources listed
5
votes recorded
3
hearings read
12
statements quoted
7
lobbyists checked

Posted Nov. 4, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Bill text, status and roll calls read on le.utah.gov in the publisher's browser on Nov. 4, 2026. Hearings read from the official video's auto-generated caption files on Nov. 4. Lobbyist registrations and 2026 reports read on lobbyist.utah.gov on Nov. 4. Rep. Elison's 2025 and 2026 reports read from state exports; Brown's gifts to other candidates from a disclosures.utah.gov search, Nov. 4.

Not confirmed as of Nov. 4, 2026: the introduced bill's exact wording (taken from the amendment record and the AG's hearing remarks); why the Senate circled the bill Feb. 25; the Senate floor debate (not yet read); the state lawsuit itself (its laws are as described in the federal complaint); whether Greg Hughes the lobbyist is the former House Speaker.

Sources

Show all 34 sources
  1. H.B. 243 enrolled (final) text: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0243.pdf
  2. House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee minutes, Jan. 30, 2026: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2026/pdf/00001147.pdf
  3. House committee vote, Jan. 30, 2026 (8-0-2): https://le.utah.gov/mtgvotes.jsp?voteid=39190
  4. House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee video, Jan. 30, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:36-0:45): https://www.utleg.gov/event-streaming/committee/timeline/291752
  5. Senate Business and Labor Committee minutes, Feb. 19, 2026: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2026/pdf/00001823.pdf
  6. Senate Business and Labor Committee video, Feb. 19, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 1:03-1:12): https://www.utleg.gov/event-streaming/committee/timeline/298947
  7. H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, bill page and status, le.utah.gov: https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0243.html
  8. House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 10, 2026 (63-9-3): https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2026GS&voteid=329&house=H
  9. Senate 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (25-0-4): https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2026GS&voteid=1372&house=S
  10. H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, le.utah.gov (Utah Code 78B-6a-102): https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0591.html
  11. disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026: https://disclosures.utah.gov/
  12. KUTV, Utah Attorney General declares online gambling public nuisance in lawsuit against Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026: https://kutv.com/newsletter-daily/utah-attorney-general-online-gambling-sports-betting-legal-action-ban-restrictions-lotteries-game-of-chance-prediction-markets-kalshi
  13. Deseret News, Dennis Romboy, Utah sues Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026: https://www.deseret.com/utah/2026/10/20/utah-sues-kalshi-prediction-market-sports-betting-online-gambling/
  14. United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026: https://www.cftc.gov/media/14796/OGC_UtahComplaint102626/download
  15. State of Utah v. KalshiEX, LLC, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, Criminal Information and Declaration of Probable Cause, Third District Court, Salt Lake County, dated Oct. 28, 2026 (AGO No. 9465862), posted by Utah News Dispatch: https://utahnewsdispatch.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Kalshi-charges.pdf
  16. The Ledger, Case 17: Casino Money and the Attorney General (Weber County Hive): https://weber-county-hive.github.io/-weber-county-hive-ledger/gambling-money-utah.html
  17. lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist search by organization (read Nov. 4, 2026): https://lobbyist.utah.gov/Search/LobbyistByPrincipal
  18. lobbyist.utah.gov, Advanced Search: 2026 quarterly lobbyist reports and the 'All Lobbyist 2026' download (read Nov. 4, 2026): https://lobbyist.utah.gov/Search/AdvancedSearch
  19. H.B. 243 fiscal note, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst: https://pf.utleg.gov/public-web/sessions/2026GS/fiscal-notes/HB0243.fn.pdf
  20. House floor video, Feb. 10, 2026 (H.B. 243 at about 0:33-0:42): https://www.utleg.gov/event-streaming/floor/marker/133809
  21. Utah Constitution, Article VI, Section 27: https://le.utah.gov/xcode/ArticleVI/Article_VI,_Section_27.html
  22. H.B. 243 as introduced: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/introduced/HB0243.pdf
  23. H.B. 243 as amended in House committee (Feb. 2, 2026): https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/amended/AV_HB0243_2026-02-02_11-08-18.pdf
  24. Senate committee vote, Feb. 19, 2026 (5-0-3): https://le.utah.gov/mtgvotes.jsp?voteid=40605
  25. Covers, Utah becomes hotspot for sweepstakes casino class actions, Nov. 4, 2025: https://www.covers.com/industry/utah-becomes-hotspot-for-sweepstakes-casino-class-actions-nov-4-2025
  26. PrizePicks press release, PrizePicks launches prediction markets offering with Kalshi: https://www.prizepicks.com/press-news/prizepicks-launches-prediction-markets-offering-with-kalshi
  27. GamesHub, FanDuel and DraftKings leave the American Gaming Association: https://www.gameshub.com/?p=2843219
  28. American Gaming Association amicus brief, Flaherty v. KalshiEX, No. 26-299, U.S. Supreme Court, Oct. 8, 2026: https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/26/26-299/429019/20261008221540870_26-299%20AGA%20Amicus%20Brief%20ISO%20Petitioners.pdf
  29. Utah Code 36-11-201, lobbyist financial reports (le.utah.gov): https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title36/Chapter11/36-11-S201.html
  30. Public Gaming Research Institute, AGA tells U.S. senators prediction markets are backdoor betting, May 22, 2026: https://publicgaming.com/news-categories-m/sports-betting-daily-fantasy-sports/15864-aga-tells-u-s-senators-prediction-markets-are-backdoor-betting-operations-threatening-regulated-gaming
  31. The Block, Crypto.com and Underdog team up to launch sports prediction markets: https://www.theblock.co/post/369042/crypto-com-underdog-sports-prediction-markets
  32. Sweepsy, Tracking VGW political donations: https://www.sweepsy.com/news/tracking-vgw-political-donations-florida-kentucky-tennessee/
  33. Utah Legislature, Federalism Commission meeting record (le.utah.gov): https://le.utah.gov/Interim/2025/html/00003980.htm
  34. UVU Center for Constitutional Studies, Inaugural National Federalism Summit program, 'Rebalancing the State-Federal Relationship,' Sept. 2025: https://www.uvu.edu/ccs/constitutional-federalism/docs/summits/2025-program.pdf
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

  • H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments
  • S.B. 214 (2020), H.B. 23 (2019), H.B. 108 and H.B. 40 (2012)

People

  • Rep. Joseph Elison, primary sponsor.
  • Sen. Brady Brammer, Senate sponsor of H.B. 243 and H.B. 591.

Elsewhere on the Hive

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism