In 2026, Rep. Joseph Elison and Sen. Brady Brammer brought H.B. 243.
- The idea: a "prop bet" is a bet on one thing happening, like a player's stats, instead of who wins. The bill says prop bets are gambling, and gambling is against Utah's Constitution.
- The one word: at first the bill covered only bets on sports. In the House committee, the Attorney General's office asked to take that limit out, so it covers bets on anything: the Fed, the Oscars, even a politician's tie. That is how betting apps like Kalshi work.
- Who presented it: Attorney General Derek Brown came to the Senate committee himself to back it. No one from the public spoke at either committee.
- What happened: it passed the House 63–9 and the Senate 25–0. It became law May 6, 2026. On Oct. 20, Brown sued Kalshi, and criminal charges followed Oct. 28. Neither filing names this bill, but both use the gambling laws it widened, and the lawsuit covers bets on elections and on what people say, not just sports.
- The money: Brown's campaign gave Sen. Brammer $2,000 on June 3. Brammer carried this bill and H.B. 591, a law that kept the AG's power to sue over a "public nuisance," which Brown used against Kalshi. The records show the gift and the date, not why.
- Gambling money is new here: gambling companies gave Utah candidates $10,500 from 2018 to 2024, and $92,800 in 2026 alone. Their registered lobbyists reported spending nothing on officials this year.
- Utah vs. the federal government: Utah often passes laws to push back on federal control. Here, Kalshi and the federal government say federal law decides, and Utah says its Constitution does. A federal court will decide.
- The donors don't all win: casino groups want betting apps like Kalshi stopped. But PrizePicks runs its app on Kalshi, and DraftKings and Underdog sell the same kind of product.
Never used a betting app? Here's the simple version
- Regular bet: you bet $5 on who wins the game. Utah has never allowed this.
- Prop bet: you bet on one small thing, like "Will the quarterback throw 3 touchdowns?" This bill says that is gambling too.
- Prediction market (Kalshi): an app sells "yes" or "no" tickets on almost anything, like a game or an election. A 60-cent "yes" ticket pays $1 if you're right; if not, you lose the 60 cents. The company says it's "trading," watched by federal regulators. Utah's AG says it's gambling.
- Sweepstakes casino (VGW): online slot-style games with two kinds of play money, and one kind can be traded for prizes. This bill doesn't cover them.
- Fantasy and pick'em apps (PrizePicks, Underdog): you pick players and win if they do well. This bill doesn't cover fantasy leagues.
- The big question: does federal law or Utah's Constitution decide? Courts are working on that now.
Our grade: D (hinders). A C means a law meets what Utah law already requires. A B or A means it went further for the public. A D means a public check got weaker. An F means a check was removed with nothing in its place. Looking at it as the public, this bill got D's across the board: the law was widened at the request of the office that enforces it, with no rule for how it picks its targets; the written record doesn't say who asked for the change; no one counted what enforcing it would cost; and no one from the public was heard.
Questions you can ask
- The Attorney General's office: Why did you ask to take sports out of the bill? How do you pick which betting companies to go after?
- Your legislator: Did a gambling company give to your campaign? Will you vote on a sweepstakes bill in 2027?