Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2026-591-NUI · Courts, nuisance & the AG

The Nuisance Law That Kept One Lawsuit for the AG

H.B. 591 ended most common-law nuisance lawsuits in Utah, kept one that only the Attorney General can bring, and said permitted or licensed activities are not a nuisance. It passed in the last hour of the 2026 session. Seven months later, the AG used that one lawsuit against Kalshi.

Posted Nov. 4, 2026 · Updated Nov. 4, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

The story in 5 steps

1. What's a nuisance?If your neighbor's dog barks all night, every night, that's a nuisance. If a factory's smoke covers the whole town, that's a nuisance too. For hundreds of years, a judge could make it stop if you, your town or the state asked.
2. What the new law didIt changed who is allowed to ask. You and your neighbors still can, but the rules are much stricter. Your town can only if the whole problem is inside town lines. If the government gave something a permit, it doesn't count as a nuisance anymore. Only the Attorney General keeps the old, easier way.
3. The part the House didn't seeThe House voted yes first, on a bill where nobody kept the old way, not even the Attorney General. Then, while the bill was in the Senate, a new version added the special power for him. That version is listed under the House sponsor, Rep. Jack. It was going to end in 2035; later they took the end date out.
4. The last nightJust before midnight, the bill went back to the House. The sponsor said the change was about the governor. He did not mention the Attorney General's special power. The House said yes at 11:26 PM, 34 minutes before they had to stop.
5. What happened nextIn October, the Attorney General used that special power to sue Kalshi, a betting app.
The moneyThe Attorney General's campaign gave $2,000 to the Senate sponsor and $300 to the House sponsor. A lawyers' group that was against the bill gave the Senate sponsor $1,750. The records show the gifts and dates, not why anyone gave.
Who pays the lawyersIn June, the AG hired a Chicago law firm for gambling cases. It gets a share of any money the state wins, and the state pays back its costs.

Every step is backed by the records further down this page (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text; H.B. 591 as introduced; 1st Substitute H.B. 591 (file dated Mar. 3, 2026, 7:09 PM); House floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (concurrence on 3rd Sub. H.B. 591); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14); United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026; disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026; disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search, 2025 and 2026 contributions, searched for 'Association for Justice' and 'Chamber' (read Nov. 4, 2026)).

Short version

ItemDetail
BillH.B. 591 (2026 General Session), "Nuisance Amendments"
Primary sponsorRep. Colin Jack (R)
Senate sponsorSen. Brady Brammer (R)
Final votesHouse 60–9–6 (Feb. 27); Senate 21–6–2 (Mar. 6, 10:55 PM); House agreed to Senate changes 47–14–14 (Mar. 6, 11:26 PM)
StatusLaw. Signed March 25, 2026; in effect May 6, 2026 (H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, bill page and status, le.utah.gov)
Utah CodeTitle 78B, Chapter 6a (nuisance), including 78B-6a-102, -202 and -203
Fiscal note$0 to the state; no direct local cost; no change in regulatory burden (Fiscal note, 3rd Sub. H.B. 591, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst, dated Mar. 5, 2026)

New to this? "Nuisance," explained simply

A private nuisanceYour neighbor's dog barks all night, every night, and you can't sleep. It hurts you and your home. For hundreds of years, courts have let people sue over that.
A public nuisanceA factory's smoke covers a whole town, or a business blocks a public road. It hurts everyone. Cities, counties, the state, and sometimes a person hurt in a special way could sue to stop it.
"Common law"Rules judges built up case by case, not written by lawmakers. Before H.B. 591, much of Utah's nuisance law worked this way.
What H.B. 591 didIt replaced the judge-made rules with written ones. Under the written rules, fewer people can sue, and anything a permit or license allows is not a nuisance. One person keeps the old judge-made power: the Attorney General.
Why people argued about itSupporters said lawsuits were being used to make policy that lawmakers should make. Opponents said permitted polluters and big companies get a shield, and neighbors lose a tool.
How it touches betting appsIn October, the AG declared online gambling a public nuisance and sued Kalshi using the one power this bill kept for him.

Graded by the collective rubric

D−Overall · Hinders
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerFBefore, you, your town or the state could ask a judge to stop a nuisance the old way. Now only one person can: the Attorney General, and he decides for himself when the harm is big enough. If something has a government permit, nobody can call it a nuisance at all (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text).
TransparencyFThe House voted yes on a bill with no special power for the Attorney General. A new version added it after the bill reached the Senate; it is listed under the House sponsor. When the bill came back to the House at 11:26 PM on the last night, the sponsor said the change was about the governor and did not mention the Attorney General. No House committee ever heard that part (H.B. 591 as introduced; 1st Substitute H.B. 591 (file dated Mar. 3, 2026, 7:09 PM); House floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (concurrence on 3rd Sub. H.B. 591); Senate floor: motion to substitute 3rd Sub., voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:52 PM; Senate passage on 2nd and 3rd reading under suspension of the rules, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:55 PM (21-6-2); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14); 3rd Substitute H.B. 591 as amended on the Senate floor, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:08 PM).
Financial accountabilityDThe cost estimate says $0. It does not count what people and towns pay when they can no longer sue: money you spend dealing with a nuisance no longer counts as a harm, and towns cannot sue over a problem that crosses their lines (Fiscal note, 3rd Sub. H.B. 591, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst, dated Mar. 5, 2026; H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text).
Environmental impactDIf a government permit allows it, it is not a nuisance, even if it pollutes. Harm to what a lake or river means to people does not count either. Supporters said cases about land, air and water still work; the trial lawyers said the permit rule protects "polluting entities" (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee video, Mar. 4, 2026; House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026).
Community impactDPeople on both sides spoke in committee, including a member of the public and a county commissioner. But nobody heard from the public on the final version, and the House had about half an hour with it (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026; House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee video, Mar. 4, 2026; House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14)).

New grade, Nov. 4, 2026, graded from the public's side. Power is F: the old way to stop a nuisance was taken from everyone but the AG. Transparency is F: the House was never told about the AG's special power. Money, environment and community are D: costs were not counted, permitted polluters are left out, and the public never saw the final version. Average 0.6 = D− (F=0, D=1; anything from 0.5 up rounds to D−).

How a grade can change: repealing the AG-only exception, or giving cities and people the same standard, would raise Power; a hearing on the final text before a vote would raise Transparency; a fiscal note that counts costs shifted to residents and towns would raise Financial accountability; narrowing the permit-and-license exclusion would raise Environmental impact. The AG must report to the Judiciary Interim Committee before Oct. 1, 2029, and the committee will consider repealing the exception then (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text).

A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 0.6 is D−. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Quoted from the final, enrolled bill (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text).

78B-6a-102, the AG exception

substantial ongoing harm to a significant number of the citizens of Utah

The AG may bring a common-law nuisance action when he determines this, acting for the state or as parens patriae (on behalf of the people).

78B-6a-102(3)

A person other than the attorney general may not bring a common law civil right of action

Definitions: what is not a nuisance

authorized, approved, licensed, or mandated by statute, ordinance, regulation, permit, license, order, rule…

An action or condition that is lawful, or approved this way, is not a "public nuisance" or "private nuisance."

How wide is the AG's power?

In simple words: the law took the old way of stopping a nuisance away from everyone else and kept it for one person. Here is what limits him, and what doesn't, from the words of the law (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text; H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026).

What the law saysWhat that means
He may use it when "the attorney general determines" there is "substantial ongoing harm to a significant number of the citizens of Utah."He decides. The bill does not define "substantial," "ongoing" or "significant number."
It is not limited to a topic.It can be used on anything he finds meets that test: gambling apps, or something else.
He must act for the state, a state office or a town, or for the people of Utah (parens patriae).He brings it for the state or the people of Utah, not for a private party.
The governor may direct him to bring one.The governor can push for a case.
He reports to the Judiciary Interim Committee before Oct. 1, 2029, then every four years.The first look by lawmakers comes about three and a half years after the law took effect. The 2035 end date was taken out.
(Courts)A judge still decides whether he wins each case. The law limits who may ask, not what a judge may decide.

Supporters said the change stops courts from being used to make policy; Brammer told the Senate policy decisions "belong to the people and their elected representatives" (Senate floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (3rd Sub. H.B. 591); House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026). The bill keeps the old way for one elected official. Readers can weigh both.

Who can sue, before and after

In simple words: green is how it was. Pink is how it is now.

Before May 6, 2026After H.B. 591
You or a neighborCould sue over a public nuisance under the old court-made (common-law) rules if it hurt you in a special wayOnly under the new statute's rules. "Special injury" leaves out harm based on a lake, river, park or road's spiritual, cultural or emotional meaning, and money spent responding
A city or countyCould sueOnly if the nuisance is entirely inside its own borders; otherwise only the AG
The Attorney GeneralCould sueKeeps the old court-made power when he finds "substantial ongoing harm to a significant number of the citizens of Utah"; the governor may direct him to
Anyone, about a permitted or licensed activityCould argue a permitted activity was still a nuisanceNot a nuisance under the new definitions if it is "authorized, approved, licensed, or mandated" by a statute, ordinance, permit, license or rule
Who can bring a nuisance lawsuit, before and after. Read from the enrolled bill: Utah Code 78B-6a-102, -202 and -203 and the definitions.

Every version, and what changed

In simple words: a bill gets rewritten as it moves. Each rewrite is called a "substitute." The table shows what each rewrite added or took away. The big one is the 1st Substitute, which added the Attorney General's special power after the House had already voted.

VERSIONTHE AG'S SPECIAL POWERIntroducedFeb. 20Introduced: None. Ends the old way for everyone, the AG tooNone. Ends the old way for everyone, the AG tooHouse committee and full House vote yes (Feb. 25, 27)1st SubstituteMar. 31st Substitute: AG keeps the old way. Ends Jan. 1, 2035AG keeps the old way. Ends Jan. 1, 2035Written after the House vote. No vote on this version2nd SubstituteMar. 42nd Substitute: Same, plus the governor may direct the AGSame, plus the governor may direct the AGSenate committee votes yes3rd SubstituteMar. 5–63rd Substitute: AG keeps it with no end date. Review in 2029AG keeps it with no end date. Review in 2029Senate votes yes 10:55 PM; House agrees 11:26 PMFinal lawMar. 25Final law: Same as the 3rd Substitute, small wording fixesSame as the 3rd Substitute, small wording fixesSigned by the governor
The bill's path, version by version. Gray = no special power for the AG. Gold = special power with an end date. Orange = special power with no end date. From the Legislature's text files and vote records.

We compared the text files of every version word by word. The Legislature's bill data lists which lawmaker each version is under; the drafting attorney was Jacqueline Carlton (H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026; H.B. 591 action history (le.utah.gov bill data)).

VersionDateWhat changed
IntroducedFeb. 20, 2026Ended every common-law nuisance lawsuit: "This chapter abrogates any common law civil right of action for a public nuisance or a private nuisance in this state." No AG exception. Already had the permit-and-license exclusion, the "special injury" limits and the city-and-county border rule. This is the version the House committee recommended (Feb. 25) and the House passed (Feb. 27) (H.B. 591 as introduced; House committee vote, Feb. 25, 2026 (9-1-2); House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (60-9-6); H.B. 591 action history (le.utah.gov bill data)).
1st SubstituteFile dated Mar. 3, 7:09 PM. Listed under Rep. JackAdded the AG exception ("substantial ongoing harm to a significant number of the citizens of Utah") and the bar on everyone else, with a repeal date: the exception would end Jan. 1, 2035 (1st Substitute H.B. 591 (file dated Mar. 3, 2026, 7:09 PM); H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026).
2nd SubstituteFile dated Mar. 4, 12:36 PM; listed under Rep. Jack; adopted in Senate committee that afternoon, 6–0–3Added that the governor may direct the AG to bring a nuisance action. Kept the 2035 end date (2nd Substitute H.B. 591; Senate committee vote to adopt 2nd Substitute, Mar. 4, 2026 (6-0-3); H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026).
3rd SubstituteFile dated Mar. 5, 10:55 AM; listed under Sen. Brammer; swapped in on the Senate floor Mar. 6, 10:52 PMRemoved the 2035 end date. In its place: the AG reports to the Judiciary Interim Committee before Oct. 1, 2029, and every four years, and the committee decides whether the exception should be repealed. Also kept nuisance claims that "accrued, or is pending in a court, before May 6, 2026" (3rd Substitute H.B. 591; Fiscal note, 3rd Sub. H.B. 591, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst, dated Mar. 5, 2026; Senate floor: motion to substitute 3rd Sub., voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:52 PM; H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026).
Senate floor amendment #1Mar. 6, 10:53 PMSen. Brammer called it "a small amendment." Between the 3rd Substitute and the final law we found only wording changes, such as starting the ban with "Except as provided in Subsection (2)" (Senate floor amendment #1, voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:53 PM; 3rd Substitute H.B. 591 as amended on the Senate floor, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:08 PM; H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text; Senate floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (3rd Sub. H.B. 591)).
Enrolled (final)Signed Mar. 25, 2026The law as it stands (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text; H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, bill page and status, le.utah.gov).
From the records: the House voted on H.B. 591 twice. The first time (Feb. 27), the bill had no AG exception. The second time (Mar. 6, 11:26 PM), it had the exception, with no end date. No House committee heard the version with the exception (H.B. 591 as introduced; 1st Substitute H.B. 591 (file dated Mar. 3, 2026, 7:09 PM); House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (60-9-6); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14); H.B. 591 action history (le.utah.gov bill data)).

The votes

House committee, Feb. 25House committee, Feb. 25: 9 yes9 yesHouse committee, Feb. 25: 1 noHouse committee, Feb. 25: 2 absent2 absent1 noHouse floor, Feb. 27House floor, Feb. 27: 60 yes60 yesHouse floor, Feb. 27: 9 no9 noHouse floor, Feb. 27: 6 absent6 absentSenate committee, Mar. 4Senate committee, Mar. 4: 7 yes7 yesSenate committee, Mar. 4: 2 absent2 absentSenate floor, Mar. 6Senate floor, Mar. 6: 21 yes21 yesSenate floor, Mar. 6: 6 no6 noSenate floor, Mar. 6: 2 absent2 absentHouse agrees to Senate version, Mar. 6House agrees to Senate version, Mar. 6: 47 yes47 yesHouse agrees to Senate version, Mar. 6: 14 no14 noHouse agrees to Senate version, Mar. 6: 14 absent14 absent
Every recorded roll call on H.B. 591. Dark = yes, orange = no, light = absent. The Senate's switch to the 3rd Substitute and its floor amendment were voice votes, so no names were recorded. Names are in the table below.
DateWhereResultNames
Feb. 25, 2026House Public Utilities and Energy Committee9–1–2Yes: Albrecht, Chew, Jack, Moss, Peck, Peterson, Shelley, Shipp, Watkins. No: Dominguez. Absent: Brooks, Snider (House committee vote, Feb. 25, 2026 (9-1-2))
Feb. 27, 2026House, 3rd reading60–9–6No: Arthur, Dominguez, Hayes, Hollins, Matthews, Miller, Nguyen, Owens, Romero. Absent: Burton, Dailey-Provost, Elison, Fiefia, Sawyer, Snider (House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (60-9-6))
Mar. 4, 2026Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee2nd Sub. adopted 6–0–3; recommended 7–0–2Yes: Balderree, Brammer, Escamilla, Fillmore, Musselman, Pitcher, Weiler. Absent: Cullimore, McKell (Senate committee vote to adopt 2nd Substitute, Mar. 4, 2026 (6-0-3); Senate committee favorable vote, Mar. 4, 2026 (7-0-2))
Mar. 6, 2026, 10:52–10:53 PMSenate floor3rd Sub. and floor amendment adopted by voice voteNo names recorded (Senate floor: motion to substitute 3rd Sub., voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:52 PM; Senate floor amendment #1, voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:53 PM)
Mar. 6, 2026, 10:55 PMSenate, 2nd and 3rd reading under suspension of the rules21–6–2No: Blouin, Escamilla, Kwan, Pitcher, Plumb, Riebe. Absent: McKell, Weiler (Senate passage on 2nd and 3rd reading under suspension of the rules, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:55 PM (21-6-2))
Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PMHouse agrees to Senate changes47–14–14No: Arthur, Dailey-Provost, Dominguez, Fitisemanu, Hayes, Hollins, Matthews, Mauga, Miller, Moss, Nguyen, Owens, Romero, Stoddard (House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14))

Sen. Brammer, the Senate sponsor, sits on the Senate committee that heard the bill and voted for it there. Sens. Escamilla and Pitcher voted yes in committee and no on the floor after the bill was changed (Senate committee favorable vote, Mar. 4, 2026 (7-0-2); Senate passage on 2nd and 3rd reading under suspension of the rules, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:55 PM (21-6-2)).

The last hour

In simple words: lawmakers must finish by midnight on the last night. Normally a bill is read and voted on over different days. "Suspension of the rules" means they skipped that and did it all at once.

11:00 PM11:30 PMmidnight10:52 to 10:55 PM: Senate swaps, amends and passes it1–311:26 PM: House agrees to the Senate version, 47–14–14412:00 PM: Session ends at midnight5110:52 PM Senate swaps in the 3rd Substitute (voice vote)210:53 PM Floor amendment #1 adopted (voice vote)310:55 PM Senate passes it 21–6–2, 2nd and 3rd reading at once, under suspension of the rules411:26 PM House agrees to the Senate version, 47–14–14512:00 AM Session ends at midnight
The last 70 minutes of the 2026 session, March 6. Times are from the Legislature's vote records. The 3rd Substitute's text and fiscal note were posted the day before (fiscal note dated March 5, 12:15 PM). The amended bill's file is time-stamped 11:08 PM, after the Senate vote and 18 minutes before the House vote.
From the records: the version of H.B. 591 that became law was put in front of the Senate, amended and passed in about three minutes, under suspension of the rules, which lets the Senate vote on 2nd and 3rd reading at once. The House had it for about half an hour before agreeing. The records do not show any public hearing on the final text (Senate floor: motion to substitute 3rd Sub., voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:52 PM; Senate floor amendment #1, voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:53 PM; Senate passage on 2nd and 3rd reading under suspension of the rules, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:55 PM (21-6-2); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14)).

In their own words

Quotes from the official hearing and floor videos' auto-generated captions, read Nov. 4, 2026. Captions can get words and names wrong (they spell Roger Gibboni "Jabon" and "Gioni"), so each speaker is matched to the official minutes, and each quote should be checked against the video before it is reused.

House committee, Feb. 25, 2026

parties are trying to use courts to make laws

— Rep. Colin Jack, sponsor (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026)

impenetrable jungle

— Attorney General Derek Brown, describing nuisance law (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026)

lawmaking through lawmakers rather than lawsuits

— Attorney General Derek Brown (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026)

prevents policymaking through… litigation

— Roger Gibboni, U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026; House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026)

Jennie Hoppie of the Utah Association for Justice opposed the bill and asked the committee to remove the exclusion for licensed and permitted activities. A member of the public, Jimmy McKee, opposed it and compared it to the inland port. Beaver County Commissioner Tammy Pearson, for the Utah Association of Counties, supported it. Rep. R.P. Shipp moved it out (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026; House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026).

Senate committee, Mar. 4, 2026

nebulous legal concepts, lawyers thrive and make a lot of money

— Rep. Colin Jack, sponsor (Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee video, Mar. 4, 2026)

and we said, no.

— Rep. Colin Jack, saying chemical companies had asked for an exemption (Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee video, Mar. 4, 2026)

Hoppie again opposed it, citing exclusions for "polluting entities." Gibboni said claims over interference with land, air and water are unchanged. Sen. Musselman asked about the end date on the AG exception; Jack described it as a review and reauthorization (Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee video, Mar. 4, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee minutes, Mar. 4, 2026).

House floor, Feb. 27, 2026 (the version with no AG exception)

This is a simple little 50 page bill... really what it is, is mostly a re codification

— Rep. Colin Jack (House floor video, Feb. 27, 2026 (H.B. 591))

so don't worry, all of your favorite public nuisances are still there

— Rep. Colin Jack, listing abandoned horses, brothels, drug houses and party houses (House floor video, Feb. 27, 2026 (H.B. 591))

Jack named lawsuits elsewhere that the bill would guard against: San Francisco's climate suits against oil companies, Buffalo's and New Jersey's suits against gun makers, suits against soda and plastic-bottle makers, and city suits against a carmaker over cars that are easy to steal. No one debated the bill; it passed 60–9–6 (House floor video, Feb. 27, 2026 (H.B. 591); House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (60-9-6)).

Senate floor, Mar. 6, 2026, about 10:51 PM

This, uh, removes a Sunset for statutory provision in one instance and then it also creates a reporting requirement to the judiciary Interim committee regarding an exception for the Attorney General

— Sen. Brady Brammer, explaining the 3rd Substitute (Senate floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (3rd Sub. H.B. 591))

in Utah, policy decisions belong to the people and their elected representatives, not to whoever files the most creative lawsuit

— Sen. Brady Brammer (Senate floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (3rd Sub. H.B. 591))

No senator asked a question or spoke on the bill. Brammer called the floor amendment "a small amendment" (Senate floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (3rd Sub. H.B. 591)).

House floor, Mar. 6, 2026, about 11:25 PM

the only thing we really did is the governor has in statute the ability to declare a public nuisance. But what we did is we added that, uh, extra clarification into this bill

— Rep. Colin Jack, asking the House to agree to the Senate's changes (House floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (concurrence on 3rd Sub. H.B. 591))

Jack did not mention the AG exception, the bar on everyone else, or the removed 2035 end date. No one asked about the changes. The House agreed 47–14–14 (House floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (concurrence on 3rd Sub. H.B. 591); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14)).

How it connects

Each line is a public record named on this page. A line between two boxes is not a claim that anyone acted together.

flowchart TD HV["House passes H.B. 591
Feb. 27
no special AG power"] --> SV["New versions in the Senate
Mar. 3-5
AG keeps the old way"] SV --> LN["Last night, Mar. 6
Senate 10:55 PM
House agrees 11:26 PM"] LN --> LAW["H.B. 591 is law
May 6, 2026"] CH["U.S. Chamber legal-reform group
and AG Derek Brown
present the bill"] --> HV UAJ["Utah Association for Justice
opposed the bill"] -- "$1,750 in 2026" --> BR["Sen. Brady Brammer
Senate sponsor"] CAMP["Derek Brown's campaign"] -- "$2,000, June 3" --> BR CAMP -- "$300, Oct. 27" --> JACK["Rep. Colin Jack
House sponsor"] BR --> SV JACK --> HV LAW --> EDEL["June 22: AG hires
Edelson PC for
gambling cases"] LAW --> SUIT["Oct. 20: AG declares gambling
a public nuisance, sues Kalshi"] B243["H.B. 243
prop bets = gambling"] --> SUIT

Sources: H.B. 591 and H.B. 243 bill pages, minutes and video (le.utah.gov); Brown campaign and Utah Association for Justice gifts as filed in recipients' reports (disclosures.utah.gov); Edelson PC contract (attorneygeneral.utah.gov); U.S. and CFTC v. Utah complaint; KUTV and Deseret News, Oct. 20, 2026.

The timeline

  1. Feb. 20, 2026 H.B. 591 is numbered and made public (H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, bill page and status, le.utah.gov).
  2. Feb. 25, 2026 House committee: AG Brown and the U.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform present with Jack; recommended 9–1–2 (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026; House committee vote, Feb. 25, 2026 (9-1-2)).
  3. Feb. 27, 2026 House passes it 60–9–6 (House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (60-9-6)).
  4. Mar. 3, 2026, 7:09 PM 1st Substitute file dated: the AG exception appears for the first time, ending Jan. 1, 2035 (1st Substitute H.B. 591 (file dated Mar. 3, 2026, 7:09 PM); H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026).
  5. Mar. 4, 2026 Senate committee adopts the 2nd Substitute and recommends it 7–0–2 (Senate committee vote to adopt 2nd Substitute, Mar. 4, 2026 (6-0-3); Senate committee favorable vote, Mar. 4, 2026 (7-0-2)).
  6. Mar. 5, 2026 3rd Substitute file dated 10:55 AM, without the 2035 end date; fiscal note dated 12:15 PM (3rd Substitute H.B. 591; Fiscal note, 3rd Sub. H.B. 591, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst, dated Mar. 5, 2026).
  7. Mar. 6, 2026, 9:45 PM Senate Rules Committee releases H.B. 591 to the floor (H.B. 591 action history (le.utah.gov bill data)).
  8. Mar. 6, 2026, 10:52–11:26 PM Senate swaps in the 3rd Substitute, amends it and passes it 21–6–2; House agrees 47–14–14 (Senate floor: motion to substitute 3rd Sub., voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:52 PM; Senate floor amendment #1, voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:53 PM; Senate passage on 2nd and 3rd reading under suspension of the rules, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:55 PM (21-6-2); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14)).
  9. Mar. 25, 2026 Gov. Cox signs H.B. 591 and H.B. 243 (H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, bill page and status, le.utah.gov; H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, Weber County Hive Bill-Tracker).
  10. May 6, 2026 Both take effect (H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, bill page and status, le.utah.gov).
  11. June 3, 2026 Derek Brown's campaign gives Sen. Brammer $2,000 (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026).
  12. Oct. 20, 2026 Brown declares online gambling a public nuisance and sues Kalshi; the nuisance count cites 78B-6a-102(2), this bill's AG exception (KUTV, Utah Attorney General declares online gambling public nuisance in lawsuit against Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026; Deseret News, Dennis Romboy, Utah sues Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026; United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026).
  13. Oct. 26, 2026 The United States and the CFTC sue Utah and Brown in federal court (No. 2:26-cv-01055) (United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026).
  14. Oct. 27, 2026 Derek Brown's campaign gives Rep. Jack $300 (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026).
  15. Before Oct. 1, 2029 First AG report due to the Judiciary Interim Committee, which then weighs repealing the AG exception (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text).

Money and lobbyists around this bill

From the records: Derek Brown's AG campaign gave $2,000 to Sen. Brady Brammer on June 3, 2026 and $300 to Rep. Colin Jack on Oct. 27, 2026, as filed. Brown presented this bill with Jack in both committees. Jack's gift came seven days after Brown used the bill's AG exception against Kalshi. The records show the gifts and the dates; they do not show why they were given (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026; House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee minutes, Mar. 4, 2026; United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026).

Gifts from the groups that testified

FromToDateAmount
Utah Association for Justice (opposed the bill)Sen. Brady BrammerJan. 16, 2026$1,000
Utah Association for JusticeSen. Brady BrammerJune 5, 2026$750
U.S. Chamber of Commerce or its Institute for Legal ReformBrammer or Jack2025–2026None found
Utah Association for JusticeRep. Colin Jack2025–2026None found

Searched by contributor name in the state's 2025 and 2026 contribution records, as the recipients filed them (disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search, 2025 and 2026 contributions, searched for 'Association for Justice' and 'Chamber' (read Nov. 4, 2026); disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026). The trial lawyers' group gave to the Senate sponsor both before and after the session; the records do not show why.

Registered Utah lobbyists for groups that testified

GroupPosition at hearingsLobbyists on the registry (read Nov. 4, 2026)
U.S. Chamber of Commerce (its Institute for Legal Reform presented the bill)ForRobert Axson, registered since Feb. 2, 2025. Earlier: Page Faulk (2024–2025) and others whose licenses ended
Utah Association for Justice (trial lawyers)AgainstCasey Hill (since Dec. 17, 2025); Nathaniel Sechrest (since Jan. 2, 2026); Leslie Carpenter (through June 10, 2026)

(lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist search by organization (read Nov. 4, 2026); lobbyist.utah.gov, Advanced Search: 2026 quarterly lobbyist reports and the 'All Lobbyist 2026' download (read Nov. 4, 2026)) We did not find Roger Gibboni or Jennie Hoppie listed as Utah lobbyists. We have not yet checked these lobbyists' 2026 spending reports; under Utah Code 36-11-201, a lobbyist who spends nothing on an official in a quarter does not have to file (Utah Code 36-11-201, lobbyist financial reports (le.utah.gov)).

Who is paying the lawyers?

In simple words: the AG's office hired a private law firm from Chicago to help with gambling cases. The firm gets paid a share of any money the state wins. If the state wins nothing, the firm gets no share. The state pays back the firm's costs, like travel and experts, when they are agreed to ahead of time. Everything below is from the posted contract (Legal Services Agreement GN26-16, Gambling Prohibition Enforcement, Office of the Utah Attorney General and Edelson PC, effective June 22, 2026 (posted on the AG's website; 22 pages, read as rendered pages Nov. 4, 2026)).

State wins $1 millionState wins $1 million: firm share up to $0.25 millionup to $250KState wins $10 millionState wins $10 million: firm share up to $2.50 millionup to $2.50MState wins $20 millionState wins $20 million: firm share up to $4.25 millionup to $4.25MState wins $50 millionState wins $50 million: firm share up to $7.25 millionup to $7.25MState wins $100 millionState wins $100 million: firm share up to $12.25 millionup to $12.25MState wins $250 millionState wins $250 million: firm share up to $27.25 millionup to $27.25MState wins $500 millionState wins $500 million: firm share up to $50.00 millionup to $50M
The most Edelson PC could be paid, by how much the state wins, using the caps in Section 6.2 of the contract (25% of the first $10 million, then 20%, 15% and 10%, never more than $50 million). The firm's actual bid percentage is not in the posted contract, so its real share may be lower. Costs the state pays back are on top of this.
What the contract saysWhere
The AG's office hired Edelson PC, 350 North LaSalle St., Chicago, for "Gambling Cases." Effective June 22, 2026, seven weeks after H.B. 591 and H.B. 243 took effect. Signed by Douglas Crapo for the AG's office (June 22) and Jimmy Rock for Edelson (June 23). Contract number GN26-16, chosen through a request for proposalsPage 1, signature page
"Gambling Cases" means cases against makers of online sweepstakes games, social casinos or promotional contests "that allow a user to bet upon the outcome of a future contingent event not under his or her control," where a prize can be redeemed for something of valueSection 1.4(E)
"Unlawful Conduct" includes violations of "state and federal constitutional, statutory, common law, or equitable claims"Section 1.4(N)
The firm's share is capped at 25% of the first $10 million, stepping down to 10% above $20 million, with a top limit of $50 million. "Actual percentages will be based upon the Lawyers' Cost Proposal," which is not attached to the posted contractSection 6.2
The share is figured on money paid to the state "for restitution, disgorgement, or actual damages, including any fines or civil penalties"Section 6.3
Costs and expenses are "reimbursed by the OAG at no more than 100% of the amount actually incurred." The firm may be paid "only from designated funds or accounts identified by the OAG"Sections 5.1, 8.4
If the AG ends the contract, the firm still gets a share of later wins, from 10% of its fee once pleadings start up to 100% after trialSection 6.7
The contract runs until every gambling case is resolvedSection 11.1
The AG keeps control: no lawsuit may be filed and no settlement made without the state's written approvalSection 2.4
Side by side: the contract counts "fines or civil penalties" toward the firm's share (Section 6.3). Utah Code 67-5-33(5)(c) says a contingent fee "may not be based on the imposition or amount of a penalty or civil fine." The same law says a contract term that does not match it is invalid unless the AG, the state treasurer and the state auditor approve it by majority before signing (Legal Services Agreement GN26-16, Gambling Prohibition Enforcement, Office of the Utah Attorney General and Edelson PC, effective June 22, 2026 (posted on the AG's website; 22 pages, read as rendered pages Nov. 4, 2026); Utah Code 67-5-33, Contingent fee contracts (le.utah.gov)). We did not find a record of such an approval. Readers can ask.

Followed the law: the contract was posted on the AG's website June 29, within the five business days Utah Code 67-5-33(7) requires. The same law also requires posting the AG's written finding that the contract is "cost-effective and in the public interest." The contract says that finding was made. We did not find it posted: we searched the AG website's file library for "determination," "GN26," "contingen" and "gambling" on Nov. 4, and the 22-page contract file does not include it (Legal Services Agreement GN26-16, Gambling Prohibition Enforcement, Office of the Utah Attorney General and Edelson PC, effective June 22, 2026 (posted on the AG's website; 22 pages, read as rendered pages Nov. 4, 2026); Utah Code 67-5-33, Contingent fee contracts (le.utah.gov)).

Not confirmed: whether Edelson PC works on the Kalshi lawsuit (the contract's definition names sweepstakes and social casinos; the news reports we read did not name outside lawyers), and what the state has paid in costs so far. The AG must report contingent-fee contracts and fees paid to legislative leaders each year between July 1 and Sept. 1 (Utah Code 67-5-33, Contingent fee contracts (le.utah.gov)).

What happened next

People in this record

PersonRole in this record
Rep. Colin JackPrimary sponsor; presented in both committees; received $300 from Brown's campaign Oct. 27, 2026 (H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, bill page and status, le.utah.gov; House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee minutes, Mar. 4, 2026; disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026)
Sen. Brady BrammerSenate sponsor of H.B. 591 and H.B. 243; voted for it in committee; received $2,000 from Brown's campaign June 3, 2026 (H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, bill page and status, le.utah.gov; Senate committee favorable vote, Mar. 4, 2026 (7-0-2); disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026)
Attorney General Derek BrownPresented with the sponsor in both committees; used the AG exception against Kalshi Oct. 20 (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee minutes, Mar. 4, 2026; United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026)
Roger GibboniU.S. Chamber Institute for Legal Reform; presented for the bill in both committees (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee minutes, Mar. 4, 2026)
Jennie HoppieUtah Association for Justice; spoke against in both committees (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee minutes, Mar. 4, 2026)
Tammy PearsonBeaver County Commissioner, Utah Association of Counties; spoke for it (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026)
Jimmy McKeeMember of the public; spoke against it (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026)

What an auditor would look at, top to bottom

In simple words: an auditor checks whether what people were told matches the paperwork, and whether the money and timing line up. Here is the list, with what we found.

What to checkWhat we foundStatus
1. Who wrote it. Who drafted each version?Drafting attorney: Jacqueline Carlton. The 1st and 2nd Substitutes, which added the AG power, are listed under Rep. Jack; the 3rd, which removed the 2035 end date, under Sen. Brammer (H.B. 591 action history (le.utah.gov bill data))Found
2. Who asked for the AG power.Not in the records we read. The House version had no AG power; it first appears March 3 (H.B. 591 as introduced; 1st Substitute H.B. 591 (file dated Mar. 3, 2026, 7:09 PM))Open
3. Did both chambers vote on the same thing?No. The House passed a bill with no AG power, then agreed to the Senate version with it (House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (60-9-6); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14); H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026)Found
4. Were lawmakers told what changed?In the House, the sponsor described the change as about the governor and did not mention the AG power (House floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (concurrence on 3rd Sub. H.B. 591))Found
5. Timing. Was there time to read it?3rd Substitute posted March 5; swapped in, amended and passed in the Senate 10:52–10:55 PM March 6; House agreed 11:26 PM (3rd Substitute H.B. 591; Senate passage on 2nd and 3rd reading under suspension of the rules, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:55 PM (21-6-2); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14))Found
6. Was the public heard on the final version?No hearing after the 2nd Substitute (March 4) (H.B. 591 action history (le.utah.gov bill data))Found
7. Cost. Does the fiscal note match reality?Note says $0. Seven weeks after the law took effect, the AG hired Edelson PC on a contingent fee for gambling cases, with costs reimbursed by the AG's office. See Who is paying the lawyers? (Fiscal note, 3rd Sub. H.B. 591, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst, dated Mar. 5, 2026; Legal Services Agreement GN26-16, Gambling Prohibition Enforcement, Office of the Utah Attorney General and Edelson PC, effective June 22, 2026 (posted on the AG's website; 22 pages, read as rendered pages Nov. 4, 2026))Partly found: costs paid so far not found
7b. Does the lawyer contract follow the law?Posted on time. The fee counts "fines or civil penalties," which Utah Code 67-5-33(5)(c) says a fee may not be based on. The required cost-effectiveness finding was not found posted (Legal Services Agreement GN26-16, Gambling Prohibition Enforcement, Office of the Utah Attorney General and Edelson PC, effective June 22, 2026 (posted on the AG's website; 22 pages, read as rendered pages Nov. 4, 2026); Utah Code 67-5-33, Contingent fee contracts (le.utah.gov))Open
8. Money to the people who carried it.Brown's campaign: $2,000 to Brammer (June 3), $300 to Jack (Oct. 27). Utah Association for Justice: $1,750 to Brammer. None found from the U.S. Chamber (disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026; disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search, 2025 and 2026 contributions, searched for 'Association for Justice' and 'Chamber' (read Nov. 4, 2026))Found
9. Lobbyists.Registered for the U.S. Chamber and the Utah Association for Justice; their 2026 spending reports not yet checked (lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist search by organization (read Nov. 4, 2026))Partly open
10. How the power has been used.Kalshi suit, Oct. 20, 2026. No other use found in the news (United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026; KUTV, Utah Attorney General declares online gambling public nuisance in lawsuit against Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026)Open until the 2029 report
11. Who benefits from the permit rule?Anyone holding a permit or license. The U.S. Chamber's legal-reform group presented the bill; the trial lawyers said it shields "polluting entities" (H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text; House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee video, Mar. 4, 2026)Found
12. Are the key words defined?"Substantial," "ongoing" and "significant number" are not defined in the bill (H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026)Found

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Rep. Colin Jack and Sen. Brady Brammer (le.utah.gov)Who wrote the bill's first draft, and who asked for the AG-only exception?
Sen. Brady BrammerWho asked to add the AG-only exception after the House passed the bill, and who asked to remove its 2035 end date?
Rep. Colin JackWhen you asked the House to agree to the Senate changes, why did you not mention the AG exception?
AG Derek Brown's office (attorneygeneral.utah.gov)When you presented this bill, did you plan to use the exception against prediction markets? What standard does your office use to find "substantial ongoing harm"?
AG Derek Brown's officeBesides Kalshi, have you used the exception? Will you publish each use before the 2029 report?
Your city or countyHas H.B. 591 stopped you from suing over a nuisance that crosses your borders?
Utah Division of Environmental QualityWhich permitted activities could no longer be challenged as a nuisance under the new definitions?
The Judiciary Interim CommitteeWill you hear from the public, not only the AG, before deciding in 2029 whether to keep the exception?
The Attorney General's office (attorneygeneral.utah.gov)Is Edelson PC working on the Kalshi lawsuit? How much has the state paid the firm in costs and expenses so far?
The Attorney General's officeWhere is the written finding that the Edelson contract is "cost-effective and in the public interest," which Utah Code 67-5-33 says must be posted?
The Attorney General's officeSection 6.3 of the contract counts "fines or civil penalties" toward the firm's fee. Utah Code 67-5-33(5)(c) says a fee may not be based on a penalty or civil fine. Was this term approved by the AG, treasurer and auditor, as the law requires for a term that differs?
The Attorney General's officeWhat percentage did Edelson PC actually bid in its Cost Proposal?
State Auditor (auditor.utah.gov) and State TreasurerDid your office vote on any part of the AG's gambling-case contract with Edelson PC?
Senate President and House SpeakerDid you receive the AG's 2026 contingent-fee report (due by Sept. 1), and will you post it?
Every legislatorShould a bill that changes who can sue get a public hearing on its final text before the vote?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

37
sources listed
8
votes recorded
5
hearings and floor debates read
5
versions compared
12
statements quoted

Posted Nov. 4, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Bill text, status and roll calls read on le.utah.gov in the publisher's browser on Nov. 4, 2026. Committee hearings read from the official videos' auto-generated captions on Nov. 4. Floor debates read from the official videos' captions Nov. 4. All five versions compared word by word from le.utah.gov's text files Nov. 4. Fiscal note read Nov. 4. Contributions searched on disclosures.utah.gov Nov. 4. Lobbyist registrations read on lobbyist.utah.gov Nov. 4. Brown campaign gifts as filed in recipients' reports on disclosures.utah.gov.

Not confirmed as of Nov. 4, 2026: which change in the final law came from the Senate floor amendment itself, since the amendment sheet was not read separately (we compared the 3rd Substitute to the final law); who asked for the AG exception to be added in the 1st Substitute; the lobbyists' 2026 spending reports; whether the AG has used the exception in a case not reported in the news; the state lawsuit itself (its nuisance count is as described in the federal complaint).

Sources

Show all 37 sources
  1. H.B. 591 enrolled (final) text: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0591.pdf
  2. H.B. 591 as introduced: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/introduced/HB0591.pdf
  3. 1st Substitute H.B. 591 (file dated Mar. 3, 2026, 7:09 PM): https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/introduced/HB0591S01.pdf
  4. House floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (concurrence on 3rd Sub. H.B. 591): https://www.utleg.gov/event-streaming/floor/marker/136749
  5. House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14): https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2026GS&voteid=1673&house=H
  6. United States and CFTC v. State of Utah and Derek Brown, No. 2:26-cv-01055 (D. Utah), complaint filed Oct. 26, 2026: https://www.cftc.gov/media/14796/OGC_UtahComplaint102626/download
  7. disclosures.utah.gov, candidate and PAC filings and 'Download Data by Year' files, 2018-2026: https://disclosures.utah.gov/
  8. disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search, 2025 and 2026 contributions, searched for 'Association for Justice' and 'Chamber' (read Nov. 4, 2026): https://disclosures.utah.gov/Search/AdvancedSearch
  9. House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026: https://www.utleg.gov/event-streaming/committee/timeline/300550
  10. House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2026/pdf/00001937.pdf
  11. H.B. 591 (2026) Nuisance Amendments, bill page and status, le.utah.gov: https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0591.html
  12. Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee minutes, Mar. 4, 2026: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2026/pdf/00002065.pdf
  13. H.B. 591 bill text files (introduced, 1st, 2nd and 3rd Substitutes, enrolled), le.utah.gov, compared word by word Nov. 4, 2026: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0591.xml
  14. House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (60-9-6): https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2026GS&voteid=1015&house=H
  15. Senate floor: motion to substitute 3rd Sub., voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:52 PM: https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2026GS&voteid=2220&house=S
  16. Senate floor amendment #1, voice vote, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:53 PM: https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2026GS&voteid=2221&house=S
  17. Senate passage on 2nd and 3rd reading under suspension of the rules, Mar. 6, 2026, 10:55 PM (21-6-2): https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2026GS&voteid=2222&house=S
  18. KUTV, Utah Attorney General declares online gambling public nuisance in lawsuit against Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026: https://kutv.com/newsletter-daily/utah-attorney-general-online-gambling-sports-betting-legal-action-ban-restrictions-lotteries-game-of-chance-prediction-markets-kalshi
  19. Deseret News, Dennis Romboy, Utah sues Kalshi, Oct. 20, 2026: https://www.deseret.com/utah/2026/10/20/utah-sues-kalshi-prediction-market-sports-betting-online-gambling/
  20. Fiscal note, 3rd Sub. H.B. 591, Office of the Legislative Fiscal Analyst, dated Mar. 5, 2026: https://pf.utleg.gov/public-web/sessions/2026GS/fiscal-notes/HB0591S03.fn.pdf
  21. 3rd Substitute H.B. 591 as amended on the Senate floor, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:08 PM: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/amended/AV_HB0591S03_2026-03-06_23-08-30.pdf
  22. Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee video, Mar. 4, 2026: https://www.utleg.gov/event-streaming/committee/timeline/303415
  23. Senate floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (3rd Sub. H.B. 591): https://www.utleg.gov/event-streaming/floor/marker/136712
  24. H.B. 591 action history (le.utah.gov bill data): https://le.utah.gov/data/2026GS/HB0591.json
  25. House committee vote, Feb. 25, 2026 (9-1-2): https://le.utah.gov/mtgvotes.jsp?voteid=41054
  26. 2nd Substitute H.B. 591: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/introduced/HB0591S02.pdf
  27. Senate committee vote to adopt 2nd Substitute, Mar. 4, 2026 (6-0-3): https://le.utah.gov/mtgvotes.jsp?voteid=41787
  28. 3rd Substitute H.B. 591: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/introduced/HB0591S03.pdf
  29. Senate committee favorable vote, Mar. 4, 2026 (7-0-2): https://le.utah.gov/mtgvotes.jsp?voteid=41788
  30. House floor video, Feb. 27, 2026 (H.B. 591): https://www.utleg.gov/event-streaming/floor/marker/135512
  31. H.B. 243 (2026) Gambling Revisions, Weber County Hive Bill-Tracker: https://weber-county-hive.github.io/Bill-Tracker/weber-hive-2026-hb243.html
  32. lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist search by organization (read Nov. 4, 2026): https://lobbyist.utah.gov/Search/LobbyistByPrincipal
  33. lobbyist.utah.gov, Advanced Search: 2026 quarterly lobbyist reports and the 'All Lobbyist 2026' download (read Nov. 4, 2026): https://lobbyist.utah.gov/Search/AdvancedSearch
  34. Utah Code 36-11-201, lobbyist financial reports (le.utah.gov): https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title36/Chapter11/36-11-S201.html
  35. Legal Services Agreement GN26-16, Gambling Prohibition Enforcement, Office of the Utah Attorney General and Edelson PC, effective June 22, 2026 (posted on the AG's website; 22 pages, read as rendered pages Nov. 4, 2026): https://attorneygeneral.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/GN26-16-Gambling-Prohibition-Enforcement-Legal-Services-Agreement-signed.pdf
  36. Utah Code 67-5-33, Contingent fee contracts (le.utah.gov): https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title67/Chapter5/67-5-S33.html
  37. State of Utah v. KalshiEX, LLC, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, Criminal Information and Declaration of Probable Cause, Third District Court, Salt Lake County, dated Oct. 28, 2026 (AGO No. 9465862), posted by Utah News Dispatch: https://utahnewsdispatch.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Kalshi-charges.pdf
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

People

  • Rep. Colin Jack
  • Sen. Brady Brammer
  • AG Derek Brown

Hive pages

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism