In their own words
Quotes from the official hearing and floor videos' auto-generated captions, read Nov. 4, 2026. Captions can get words and names wrong (they spell Roger Gibboni "Jabon" and "Gioni"), so each speaker is matched to the official minutes, and each quote should be checked against the video before it is reused.
House committee, Feb. 25, 2026
Jennie Hoppie of the Utah Association for Justice opposed the bill and asked the committee to remove the exclusion for licensed and permitted activities. A member of the public, Jimmy McKee, opposed it and compared it to the inland port. Beaver County Commissioner Tammy Pearson, for the Utah Association of Counties, supported it. Rep. R.P. Shipp moved it out (House Public Utilities and Energy Committee video, Feb. 25, 2026; House Public Utilities and Energy Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026).
Senate committee, Mar. 4, 2026
Hoppie again opposed it, citing exclusions for "polluting entities." Gibboni said claims over interference with land, air and water are unchanged. Sen. Musselman asked about the end date on the AG exception; Jack described it as a review and reauthorization (Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee video, Mar. 4, 2026; Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement, and Criminal Justice Committee minutes, Mar. 4, 2026).
House floor, Feb. 27, 2026 (the version with no AG exception)
Jack named lawsuits elsewhere that the bill would guard against: San Francisco's climate suits against oil companies, Buffalo's and New Jersey's suits against gun makers, suits against soda and plastic-bottle makers, and city suits against a carmaker over cars that are easy to steal. No one debated the bill; it passed 60–9–6 (House floor video, Feb. 27, 2026 (H.B. 591); House 3rd reading roll call, Feb. 27, 2026 (60-9-6)).
Senate floor, Mar. 6, 2026, about 10:51 PM
This, uh, removes a Sunset for statutory provision in one instance and then it also creates a reporting requirement to the judiciary Interim committee regarding an exception for the Attorney General
— Sen. Brady Brammer, explaining the 3rd Substitute (Senate floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (3rd Sub. H.B. 591))
No senator asked a question or spoke on the bill. Brammer called the floor amendment "a small amendment" (Senate floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (3rd Sub. H.B. 591)).
House floor, Mar. 6, 2026, about 11:25 PM
Jack did not mention the AG exception, the bar on everyone else, or the removed 2035 end date. No one asked about the changes. The House agreed 47–14–14 (House floor video, Mar. 6, 2026 (concurrence on 3rd Sub. H.B. 591); House concurrence roll call, Mar. 6, 2026, 11:26 PM (47-14-14)).