The fights moved from who voters chose to the rules on who gets a say: the congressional map and who can vote in a party's primary. Here is what changed, what it changed, who paid, and what taxpayers paid.
StatewideCASE 2026-WGS-01 · Posted Nov. 8, 2026 · Updated Nov. 18, 2026
Each party decides who may vote in its primary. In the November general election, any registered voter can vote for anyone.
| Primary | Who can vote | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Republican | Registered Republicans only | KUER, 3/26/26 |
| Libertarian, Constitution, Green | Their own members only | Salt Lake County Clerk |
| Democratic, Independent American, Forward | Open; unaffiliated voters ask the clerk for that ballot | Salt Lake County Clerk |
Lt. Governor's registration statistics, updated Nov. 2, 2026.
HB197 (2021, primary sponsor Rep. Jordan Teuscher, R-South Jordan) set a deadline before primaries for voters switching from one party to another. Its stated aim was to stop "party raiding."
| Who | Before HB197 (through 2020) | After HB197 (2021 on) |
|---|---|---|
| A party member switching to another party | Could switch any time except from the day after the voter registration deadline through primary day. A switch before that deadline counted in that primary. | In even years, a switch received after March 31 (early January in presidential years, under HB365) doesn't take effect until the day after the primary. |
| An unaffiliated voter | Could join a party at the polls on primary day and vote in its primary. | Still can, unless the voter was in a party at any time from April 1 to the primary; then it takes effect after the primary. |
Source: struck and new language in the HB197 enrolled text (Utah Code 20A-2-107 and 20A-2-107.5).
The map and the primary rules moved in the same years. Oldest first.
Map steps on the left path, primary steps on the right.
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| Nov. 6, 2018 | Voters pass Prop 4 (50.3%): an independent commission and a ban on maps drawn to favor a party. |
| Mar. 28, 2020 | Gov. Herbert signs SB200 (Senate 25–0 on Mar. 3; House 67–4 on Mar. 11). It drops the ban on maps drawn to favor a party and the steps Prop 4 required before lawmakers adopted their own map. Under Prop 4, lawmakers could already reject the commission's maps, but only after voting on them, taking public comment and explaining in writing. Check SB200's exact text before quoting it. |
| June 2020 | Cox beats Huntsman in the GOP primary for governor by 6,319 votes. |
| Feb.–Mar. 2021 | HB197 passes: a deadline to switch parties before a primary. |
| Nov. 1, 2021 | The commission unanimously sends the Legislature 12 maps, three for Congress. |
| Nov. 9–12, 2021 | The Legislature passes its own map instead (HB2004: House 50–22 on Nov. 9, Senate 22–7 on Nov. 10; Gov. Cox signs Nov. 12), splitting Salt Lake County four ways. |
| Mar. 17, 2022 | League of Women Voters, Mormon Women for Ethical Government and seven voters sue. |
| Nov. 16, 2022 | Legislature hires Consovoy McCarthy by emergency procurement ($595–$700 an hour). |
| 2022 and 2024 | Republicans win all four U.S. House seats. |
| 2023 | HB365 sets today's switching deadlines. |
| July 11, 2024 | Utah Supreme Court rules unanimously that the Legislature can't gut a voter-passed government reform without a compelling reason. |
| Sept.–Oct. 2024 | A judge voids Amendment D, partly because its text wasn't published in newspapers; the Supreme Court agrees (Oct. 24). It stayed on printed ballots, but votes on it did not count. |
| Aug. 25, 2025 | Judge Dianna Gibson throws out the 2021 map. |
| Nov. 10, 2025 | Gibson adopts plaintiffs' Map 1: Salt Lake County split two ways; three GOP-leaning seats, one Democratic-leaning. |
| Feb. 20, 2026 | The Utah Supreme Court dismisses the Legislature's appeal as untimely and not final; the court map stays for 2026 (Loyola Law School docket). |
| Feb. 23, 2026 | A federal three-judge panel denies a request to block the court map for 2026. This was a preliminary injunction ruling, not a final judgment. The federal case was later voluntarily dismissed. |
| May 1, 2026 | The Prop 4 repeal initiative falls short in 2 of 26 required Senate districts. |
| Nov. 3, 2026 | Amendment A passes (removes the newspaper-publication requirement); Amendment B fails (the AP called it at 9:36 p.m., KPCW; vote shares official after the Nov. 23 canvass); McAdams (D) wins District 1 (unofficial). |
Official district lines from the Utah Geospatial Resource Center. Salt Lake County is outlined in orange. Numbers are district numbers.
Salt Lake County split among all four districts. Republicans won all four seats.
Most of Salt Lake County's core is in District 1, which McAdams (D) won (unofficial).
Source: UGRC, "Utah U.S. Congressional Districts 2022 to 2026" and "2026 to 2032" layers, downloaded Nov. 8, 2026.
How many congressional districts the county was divided into under each map.
The map change produced a measurable result. The party-switching law produced registration shifts but no documented change in who won.
Each side below is what that side says, not a finding.
Voters lean toward keeping a commission in the process, but many are unsure, and most say the parties don't represent them well. How a poll asks the question changes the answer.
| When | Who asked | What voters said |
|---|---|---|
| Nov. 6, 2018 | The ballot | Prop 4 passed with 50.3%. |
| Oct. 17–22, 2025 | Deseret News/Hinckley (809 voters) | Would support Prop 4 today: 44%; oppose 20%; don't know 36% (Deseret, 10/26/25). |
| Oct. 2025 | Sutherland Institute/Y2 Analytics (623 voters, ±3.9) | 71% want elected officials to decide maps, 8% judges; with Prop 4 explained, about 51% want a commission involved in some form (Deseret, 12/5/25). |
| Jan. 12–15, 2026 | Embold Research for Better Boundaries (online, 1,731 registered voters, ±2.5) | 64% support Prop 4. Question wording is in a separate methodology statement (public memo). |
| Feb. 11–14, 2026 | Deseret News/Hinckley | Repeal Prop 4: 27% yes, 32% no, 41% unsure (Deseret, 2/22/26). |
| Spring 2026 | Voters themselves | The repeal petition got 161,961 valid signatures, then fell short in 2 of 26 Senate districts after people removed their names (KPCW, 5/1/26). |
| Apr. 15–19, 2026 | Deseret News/Hinckley (815 voters, ±3) | 58% say the parties represent them poorly (KSL, 5/9/26). |
No recent Utah poll on the closed Republican primary or the switching deadline turned up. The newest found is from 2002 (Deseret News). The polls above asked different questions, so their numbers can't be compared directly.
| Question | One side | Other side |
|---|---|---|
| Does party raiding happen? | Teuscher: "overt, coordinated campaigns" in 2020; 39,000 Democrats and 134,000+ independents became Republican since 2020. | Princeton: growth came from new and unaffiliated voters; at most 2,509 primary voters later switched to Democrat. Sen. Dan McCay (R): "Mass party raiding did not occur in 2024" (KPCW, 8/19/24). |
| Is Map 1 a gerrymander? | Legislature's expert Sean Trende: Map 1 builds one safe Democratic seat. | Plaintiffs' expert Jowei Chen: the Legislature's Map C favored Republicans more than 99.94% of 10,000 simulated maps. |
| Do voters support Prop 4? | Hinckley (Feb. 2026): 27% repeal, 32% keep, 41% unsure. | Better Boundaries' Embold poll (Jan. 2026): 64% support. |
These are the questions each role would ask, built on the facts above. They are questions, not findings.
The National Conference of State Legislatures lists Utah as one of nine "partially closed" states, where each party decides whether unaffiliated voters may vote in its primary.
| System (NCSL label) | How it works | States |
|---|---|---|
| Partially closed | Each party decides whether unaffiliated voters may vote in its primary (Utah's system) | Connecticut, Idaho, Kansas, Maryland, Oklahoma, Oregon, South Dakota, Utah, West Virginia |
| Closed | Party members only | Delaware, Florida, Kentucky, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Wyoming |
| Partially open | Voters may cross party lines, but the choice may be public or count as joining that party | Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Nevada |
| Open to unaffiliated | Unaffiliated voters pick any party's primary; members stay in their own | Arizona, Colorado, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Carolina, Rhode Island |
| Open | Any voter picks a party's ballot privately | Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Hawaii, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, North Dakota, South Carolina, Texas, Vermont, Virginia, Wisconsin |
| Top-two / Top-four | One ballot for all; the top two (or four) advance | California, Washington / Alaska |
| Other | All-comers; nonpartisan legislature | Louisiana, Nebraska |
Source: NCSL, State primary election types.
Map commissions elsewhere. Arizona, California, Colorado and Michigan use commissions, but lawmakers still have a hand in some. In Arizona, House and Senate leaders appoint four of the five members from a 25-name list drawn up by the state's appellate court nominating commission (Citizens Clean Elections Commission). In Colorado, legislative leaders supply pools of candidates for some seats. In California, four legislative leaders may each strike two applicants from each 20-person group before the state auditor's random draw (wedrawthelines.ca.gov). In Michigan, four leaders may each strike up to five of 200 randomly drawn applicants (Voters Not Politicians). A FiveThirtyEight review of the 2021 maps found commission and court maps less tilted toward a party than legislature-drawn maps, but not clearly more competitive, and called them "no panacea" (FiveThirtyEight).
Each fight lined up with what the campaign-finance records show. Figures come from Utah disclosure filings or from news reports that cite them. Where no record was found, the table says so.
| Fight | Side and committee | What the records show | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prop 4, 2018 | For: Better Boundaries | Action Now Initiative (out of state) gave more than $500,000. More than 7,000 Utahns also donated. | KUER (2018); Salt Lake Tribune (2018) |
| Prop 4 repeal, 2025–26 | Repeal: Utahns for Representative Government (sponsors: GOP chair Rob Axson, AG Derek Brown, Sen. Mike Lee) | More than $4.3 million from Securing American Greatness, a nonprofit that helped fund the 2024 Trump campaign. The money went to Patriot Grassroots to recruit signature gatherers. Deseret News puts signature-gathering spending at $4.35 million. | Utah News Dispatch, 2/16/26; Deseret, 3/26/26 |
| Signature removal, 2026 | Keep Prop 4: Better Boundaries and other groups | Letters, texts, calls and prepaid-postage removal forms; nearly 1,000 District 15 signers removed their names. No dollar figure found. | Deseret; KUER, 3/26/26 |
| Amendment B, 2026 | No: Utahns Protecting Our Constitution (general manager Elizabeth Rasmussen, also Better Boundaries' executive director) | $1,279,889.83 raised, all years. 2026 cash $897,095.15, about 44% from out of state. Top 2026 givers: Utahns for Responsive Government (Better Boundaries' legal name) $165,000; Defend Utah's Ballot (Delaware) $150,000; Pivotal Next Gen (Washington) $100,000; Operating Engineers Local 3 $100,000; Charles Maggelet $100,000. Spent $388,238.45 in 2026 through 9/25 (filings we read). Newer, from its 2026 General report (Sept. 26–Oct. 22, filed Oct. 27): $2,291,860 raised and $2,754,467.36 spent in that period; 2026 totals $3,188,955.15 raised and $3,142,705.81 spent. The Fairness Project (Washington, D.C.) gave $1,599,000 in five checks, Unite America (Denver) $200,000 and the National Education Association $150,000; about 85% of that period's cash came from out of state. Viewpoint Media was paid about $2.09 million for advertising and Valkyrie Strategies about $410,000. KSL had reported "more than $3 million" spent (KSL, 10/30/2026). | Committee reports, disclosures.utah.gov (read Oct. 10, 2026) |
| Amendment B, 2026 | Yes: no registered Yes-on-B committee found | Taxpayer Shield PAC (chair Sen. Lincoln Fillmore, the S.J.R. 2 primary sponsor) took a $2,000 loan and spent $1,812.66, none on Amendment B. Americans for Prosperity Utah paid for a pro-B mailer; no Utah filing found for it. | PAC reports (read Oct. 7, 2026); FOX 13 |
| Lawmakers' campaigns | Utah Taxpayers Association PAC | Corporate and trade-group donors. Gave to S.J.R. 2 sponsors, including Fillmore $6,500, McCay $3,000 and Cullimore $1,500. | PAC reports (read Oct. 7, 2026) |
| Map lawsuit defense | Taxpayers: the Legislature's outside lawyers | Just over $1.859 million, Jan. 2023 to Apr. 2026, as reported; no running public report. | Utah Political Watch |
From the table above. Different fights and time periods, shown side by side.
Solid boxes are named in filings or reports. "Donors not public" means the law doesn't require those names.
Judged on transparency, financial accountability and the public good. The records here do not show that none of these changes served the public. A fair test asks four questions of each rule change:
| What happened | Transparency | Financial accountability | Public good |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ballot committees file in Utah's disclosure system | Works. Anyone can download who gave and who was paid. | Works. Totals can be checked against the filings. | Voters can see who is behind a measure. |
| Money passed through nonprofits (Securing American Greatness; Better Boundaries; Defend Utah's Ballot) | Gap. The committee is named, but the original donors are not. | Gap. No one can check where the money began. | Both sides use this route, so voters on both sides see only part of the picture. |
| Pro-B mailer by Americans for Prosperity Utah, no Utah filing found | Unclear. Whether the law required a filing is an open question. | Unclear. | A statewide mailer with no public spending record is hard for voters to weigh. |
| Legislature's legal fees | Gap. Known only through news reporting. | Partial. A reported total; no running report. | Taxpayers fund one side of a lawsuit about their own maps. |
| Paying people to remove signatures (HB242, 2026) | Rule clarified to cover prepaid postage. | — | Sets a clearer line for both sides in future drives. |
| Same people leading related groups (Rasmussen at Better Boundaries and No on B; Fillmore as S.J.R. 2 sponsor and PAC chair) | Works. The filings show it. | Works. | Disclosed overlap lets voters judge it for themselves. |
Bottom line. Utah's disclosure rules work well where money goes straight to a registered committee. They work less well when money passes through a nonprofit first, when a group spends without a Utah filing, and when public money is spent on legal fees with no running report. Those gaps show up on both sides of these fights.
Tap a card to see what the records show.
Approaches used or proposed elsewhere, listed for comparison, not as recommendations. Each has trade-offs.
Where each person appears elsewhere in the Hive. Being named here does not mean anyone did anything wrong.
| Who | Why they are here | Other Hive pages |
|---|---|---|
| Jordan Teuscher | Rep. (R); primary sponsor of the party-switch laws and the union law | House profile Checks & Balances PAC |
| Stuart Adams | Senate President (R); lost his 2026 primary | Adams Leadership PAC Enforcement Gap |
| Mike Schultz | House Speaker (R) | HD-12 race file House Speaker Leadership PAC Schultz water rights Stratos land |
| Rob Axson | Utah GOP chair; led the Prop 4 repeal | State Party Indicia H.B. 242 |
| Derek Brown | Attorney General (R); Prop 4 repeal sponsor | The Men Behind Lincoln Hill H.B. 243 H.B. 591 |
| Spencer Cox | Governor (R) | Biggest donors Energy money Data center industry money |
| Deidre Henderson | Lieutenant Governor (R); runs elections | Money in, money out |
| Kirk Cullimore | Senate Majority Leader (R); union-law sponsor; trailing in 2026 (unofficial) | Senator profile SD-19 race file |
| Blake Moore | U.S. Rep. (R); won his primary after the Speaker backed his opponent | UT-2 race file |
| Lincoln Fillmore | Sen. (R); S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) sponsor; chairs Taxpayer Shield PAC | Lincoln Hill Partners PAC Utah Taxpayers Association |
"The rules changed and results followed" is on the record. "They changed the rules to keep power" is a claim about motive the records don't prove.
Fixes made Nov. 8, 2026, before posting, checked against the sources:
Tap a card to see what it means.
Posted Nov. 8, 2026.
H.B. 197 (2021) bill history; H.B. 365 (2023) enrolled text; S.B. 200 (2020) bill history; H.B. 2004 (2021 2nd special session) bill history; Utah Code 20A-11-702 (2021 version via Justia).
Lt. Governor, current voter registration statistics (updated Nov. 2, 2026); 2024 Primary Election State Canvass; 2018 Utah Voter Information Pamphlet, Proposition 4 (vote.utah.gov); Salt Lake County Clerk, party affiliation; Legislature, legal procurement page.
Gardner v. Henderson, No. 2:26-cv-00084 (D. Utah, three-judge court), order denying preliminary injunction, Feb. 23, 2026 (PDF posted by Utah News Dispatch); League of Women Voters of Utah v. Utah State Legislature, complaint, Mar. 17, 2022; Utah Supreme Court opinion on Amendment D, Oct. 24, 2024; League of Women Voters of Utah, case timeline.
Utah campaign finance disclosures: Utahns Protecting Our Constitution reports for 2024, 2025 and 2026 (exports read Oct. 10, 2026); Taxpayer Shield PAC and Utah Taxpayers Association PAC reports (read Oct. 7, 2026).
Intellispect, Utahns for Responsive Government DBA Better Boundaries (EIN 82-1030846); Lucido Data, same organization; Issue One, Securing American Greatness donors (Feb. 26, 2026); Utah Republican Party, donation page for Utahns for Representative Government.
Embold Research for Better Boundaries, public memo (Jan. 2026); Princeton Electoral Innovation Lab, Utah memo (Feb. 22, 2021); Deseret News/Hinckley poll (Feb. 22, 2026); KSL on the same poll; Deseret News/Hinckley (Oct. 26, 2025); Sutherland/Y2 Analytics (Dec. 5, 2025); KSL on the April 2026 poll; Deseret News (2002); BYU Daily Universe (Mar. 31, 2022).
NCSL, State primary election types; Arizona Citizens Clean Elections Commission, redistricting; California Citizens Redistricting Commission, selection process; Voters Not Politicians, Michigan selection; FiveThirtyEight; KJZZ on Arizona Prop 211 (June 2026).
KSL (3/4/21); KUTV (2/12/21); Salt Lake Tribune (4/7/22); KSL/Deseret (7/5/23); KPCW (8/19/24); KPCW/Utah News Dispatch (7/25/24); Deseret News (12/26/24); Axios (11/6/24); Axios (7/11/24); KUER (11/11/25); KUER reactions (11/11/25); Utah Policy (8/25/25); TownLift/Utah News Dispatch (2/24/26); Utah News Dispatch via Daily Herald (2/16/26); Deseret News (3/26/26); KUER (3/26/26); KUER primaries (3/26/26); KPCW (5/1/26); Utah Political Watch, Bryan Schott (7/9/26); Salt Lake Tribune, Gehrke column (12/20/22); Salt Lake Tribune (10/18/26); FOX 13 on Amendment B; KUER (11/3/26); KSL (11/3/26); KSL on Stuart Adams' primary (6/24/26).
Some quotes were gathered through page summaries rather than full articles; each is being checked word for word against its source.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · JournalismThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.
Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us
Independent accountability journalism. Public records only. We report; you decide.
We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.
Transparency home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack