The short version
- A page from the Utah Republican Party's Operations Manual, last revised Feb. 7, 2025, lets candidates mail on the party's nonprofit postage permit. The candidate pays the printer and donates the postage "plus an additional amount about 10%" to the party before the mailer is approved.
- USPS rules say a state party may mail only its own material at nonprofit prices, and must pay the postage "with no reimbursement from the candidates." Money earmarked for one candidate's mailer is treated as the candidate's money.
- In 2026, Republican candidates and PACs reported paying the party $441,267.67, and the party reported 39 payments to USPS totaling $305,345.98, mostly in the weeks before the June primary and the November general.
- Rep. Doug Fiefia's report names the program: "Utah Republican Party State Indicia." Rep. Jim Alvey's report lists "State Inicia" with no address, and no business by that name was found.
- A campaign vendor, Tactical Campaigns LLC, is listed as giving the party $71,600 in 14 entries in 2026 (Jan. 1 – June 15), while candidates and PACs paid it $117,151.77 (the party itself paid it another $1,350; $118,501.77 from all payers). The manual says the party works with certain mail vendors who "know the process." Whether any vendor money paid for candidates' postage is not shown by the records.
- No filing on either side uses the word postage. The 10% can't be checked from these records. The Utah Democratic Party reported no USPS payments in 2026.
How this was checked
- Candidate and PAC payments to the party: disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search, Expenditures, 2026, payee "Utah Republican Party" (includes "State Indicia") and payee "State Inicia." Results pages copied Nov. 4–5, 2026.
- The party's payments to USPS: same search, payee "USPS," all six results pages, Nov. 5, 2026. Searches for "Postmaster" and "postage" were also run.
- The party's own receipts: the Utah Republican Party's 2026 Primary report (April 14 – June 11, 2026), as pasted into the Hive's research on June 27, 2026 and logged in the Hive's GOP 2026 Primary tracker. The original report was not re-read for this page. Tran's three entries were confirmed on Nov. 5, 2026 with a disclosures.utah.gov Contributions search.
- Payments to Tactical Campaigns: disclosures.utah.gov, Expenditures, 2026, payee "Tactical Campaigns," Nov. 5, 2026.
- Not included: county-level candidates (they file with their county), the party's federal (FEC) filings, and anything filed after Nov. 5, 2026. The October figures stop at the party's last reported USPS payment, Oct. 21.
- Duplicates: where results pages overlapped, a repeated row was counted once. Two identical $4,793.24 party payments on Oct. 6 and 7 are both counted, as filed.
- Sorting: filers were sorted into candidates or PACs by how the filer's name was entered.
What the manual page says
The page is headed "State Party Indicia" and is marked "Last Updated 2/7/25." The copy posted publicly carries a "Confidential" watermark. Under the party's bylaws, the Operations Manual must be available to State Central Committee members at party headquarters.
- When the party subsidizes mailers. Two cases are listed: a general election in support of the Republican nominee, and a Republican primary where one candidate won outright at convention (state or county).
- What the mailer can't contain. Inaccurate or false information, or an attack on another Republican candidate.
- The process. The party approves the graphic, which must say "Postage paid for by the Utah Republican Party" with the party's address and permit #1863. The campaign sends the graphic and mail list to the printer and pays the printer for printing.
- The donation.
- Timing. The donation must reach the party before the mailer is authorized. Then "the USPS will automatically withdraw the postage amount from the state acct."
The manual page does not say what the extra 10% is for. This page calls it "the extra amount about 10%," in the manual's own words.
What USPS rules say
Federal law lets a state committee of any political party mail at nonprofit prices (39 U.S.C. 3626(e)). USPS spells out the limits in its Domestic Mail Manual, section 703.1.6, in Customer Support Ruling PS-055 (updated January 2017), and in Publication 417.
Tap a card to see what each rule says.
Under Pub 417 section 4-4, if USPS finds a mailing wasn't eligible, it may bill the organization the difference between nonprofit and regular postage. This page doesn't say any mailing was ineligible. That is USPS's call, and no USPS finding about 2026 was found.
How the money moves, under the manual
Drawn from the State Party Indicia manual page, Steps 1–3
What the 2026 records show
These figures come from disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search (Expenditures, 2026), run Nov. 5, 2026, for three payees: "Utah Republican Party," "State Inicia" and "USPS." Each row is reported by the filer, not by the party, except the USPS rows, which the party reported.
Money into the party, and the party's postage out
General-window candidate total includes Rep. Jim Alvey's $10,210 to "State Inicia" and House Speaker Mike Schultz's $35,975 filed as "Donations." Without Schultz's line, candidates paid $139,545.34. One more party USPS payment, $1,794.80 on Feb. 5, falls outside both windows.
| Window | Candidates paid party | PACs/committees paid party | Party paid USPS |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary (May 18 – June 23) | $56,995.63 | $58,833.73 | $158,429.79 |
| General (Aug. 20 – Oct. 27) | $175,520.34 | $129,710.00 | $145,121.39 |
| All 2026 USPS payments by the party | $305,345.98 |
The party's payments to USPS, month by month
Source: disclosures.utah.gov, payee "USPS," filer Utah Republican Party (State), 2026. Last payment found: Oct. 21.
What the numbers show
- Primary: the party paid USPS almost three times what candidates paid the party. PAC money, including Adams Leadership PAC's $48,603.73 on May 20, and the party's own funds would cover the rest.
- General: candidates paid the party more than the party paid USPS. Without Schultz's $35,975 "Donations" line, the two sides are close: $139,545.34 in, $145,121.39 out.
- The labels: filers reported these payments as Advertising, Campaign Expense, Supplies, Donations or Political Support. The party reported its USPS payments as "Other" (through June 10, and again from Oct. 5) or "Campaign Expense" (June 15 – Sept. 23). Candidates and parties can write their own purpose; Summit County Republican Party wrote "Post Office box rental" on a USPS line.
All 73 lines paid to the Utah Republican Party in 2026 (click to open)
Highlighted rows name the State Indicia program, or "State Inicia."
| Date | Filer | Payee as filed | Purpose as filed | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/22/2026 | Dunnigan, Jim | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $3,367.97 |
| 01/26/2026 | Utah Credit Union Political Action Committee | Utah Republican Party | Political Support | $10,000.00 |
| 02/04/2026 | Utah House Republican Election Committee | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $2,400.00 |
| 03/02/2026 | Weber County Republican Party | Utah Republican Party | Supplies | $150.00 |
| 04/03/2026 | Knotwell, John | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $300.00 |
| 04/03/2026 | Birch, Sheldon | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $300.00 |
| 04/06/2026 | Hess, Braden | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $300.00 |
| 04/06/2026 | Knotwell, John | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $1,000.00 |
| 04/06/2026 | Monson, Logan | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $300.00 |
| 04/06/2026 | Monson, Logan | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $600.00 |
| 04/06/2026 | Adams Leadership PAC | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $1,800.00 |
| 04/06/2026 | House Speaker Leadership PAC | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $1,800.00 |
| 04/07/2026 | Hess, Braden | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $600.00 |
| 04/08/2026 | Fiefia, Douglas | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $1,800.00 |
| 04/08/2026 | Hollist, Stephanie | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $1,050.00 |
| 04/12/2026 | Searle, Luke | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $750.00 |
| 04/18/2026 | Waddoups, Michael | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $250.00 |
| 04/20/2026 | Oaks, Marlo | Utah Republican Party | Other | $300.00 |
| 04/22/2026 | Pierce, Wilfred | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $300.00 |
| 04/24/2026 | Searle, Luke | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $1,050.00 |
| 05/19/2026 | Fiefia, Douglas | Utah Republican Party State Indicia | Campaign Expense | $4,865.00 |
| 05/20/2026 | Croft, Darren | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $2,490.00 |
| 05/20/2026 | Adams Leadership PAC | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $48,603.73 |
| 05/20/2026 | Brammer, Brady | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $9,750.00 |
| 05/20/2026 | Fiefia, Douglas | Utah Republican Party State Indicia | Campaign Expense | $3,329.00 |
| 05/21/2026 | Prosperous Utah Communities | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $2,965.00 |
| 05/22/2026 | Prosperous Utah Communities | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $3,085.00 |
| 05/22/2026 | Fiefia, Douglas | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $71.00 |
| 05/28/2026 | Brammer, Brady | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $12,280.00 |
| 06/01/2026 | Teuscher, Jordan | Utah Republican Party | Supplies | $6,390.63 |
| 06/02/2026 | Searle, Luke | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $3,270.00 |
| 06/03/2026 | Searle, Luke | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $2,100.00 |
| 06/03/2026 | Fiefia, Douglas | Utah Republican Party State Indicia | Campaign Expense | $4,250.00 |
| 06/09/2026 | Teuscher, Jordan | Utah Republican Party | Supplies | $3,388.37 |
| 06/09/2026 | Prosperous Utah Communities | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $2,680.00 |
| 06/11/2026 | Teuscher, Jordan | Utah Republican Party | Supplies | $186.63 |
| 06/16/2026 | Croft, Darren | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $1,625.00 |
| 06/18/2026 | Teuscher, Jordan | Utah Republican Party | Supplies | $3,000.00 |
| 06/22/2026 | Adams Leadership PAC | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $1,500.00 |
| 07/28/2026 | Utah Republican Party (State) | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $2,000.00 |
| 09/09/2026 | Thompson, Jason | Utah Republican Party via American Express | Political Support | $2,000.00 |
| 09/20/2026 | Searle, Luke | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $4,800.00 |
| 09/21/2026 | Alvey, Jim | State Inicia | Supplies | $3,140.00 |
| 09/29/2026 | Searle, Luke | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $4,800.00 |
| 09/30/2026 | Sandall, Scott | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $10,635.00 |
| 09/30/2026 | Croft, Darren | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $5,015.00 |
| 10/02/2026 | Dunnigan, Jim | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $3,130.05 |
| 10/02/2026 | Searle, Luke | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $3,135.00 |
| 10/02/2026 | Defay, Ariel | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $3,135.00 |
| 10/02/2026 | Monson, Logan | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $4,205.00 |
| 10/05/2026 | Ketcham, Monique | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $3,137.94 |
| 10/05/2026 | Dunnigan, Jim | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $46.60 |
| 10/06/2026 | Whyte, Stephen | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $5,640.00 |
| 10/07/2026 | Ketcham, Monique | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $137.65 |
| 10/07/2026 | Ketcham, Monique | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $43.63 |
| 10/07/2026 | Croft, Darren | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $4,735.00 |
| 10/08/2026 | Ketcham, Monique | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $3,275.28 |
| 10/09/2026 | Hall, Katrina | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $3,865.00 |
| 10/12/2026 | Gibson, Katrina | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $100.00 |
| 10/13/2026 | Schultz, Mike | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $35,975.00 |
| 10/13/2026 | Utah House Republican Election Committee | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $91,210.00 |
| 10/13/2026 | Alvey, Jim | State Inicia | Campaign Expense | $3,925.00 |
| 10/13/2026 | Alvey, Jim | State Inicia | Advertising | $3,145.00 |
| 10/15/2026 | Cullimore, Kirk | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $32,450.00 |
| 10/15/2026 | Vickers, Evan | Utah Republican Party | Donations | $250.00 |
| 10/15/2026 | Sandall, Scott | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $10,635.00 |
| 10/16/2026 | Cullimore, Kirk | Utah Republican Party | Campaign Expense | $2,400.00 |
| 10/19/2026 | Croft, Darren | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $5,000.00 |
| 10/22/2026 | Utah Republican Senate Campaign Committee | Utah Republican Party | Political Support | $18,500.00 |
| 10/22/2026 | Teuscher, Jordan | Utah Republican Party | Supplies | $10,134.19 |
| 10/23/2026 | Croft, Darren | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $3,745.00 |
| 10/26/2026 | Hall, Katrina | Utah Republican Party | Advertising | $2,885.00 |
| 10/27/2026 | Utah Credit Union Political Action Committee | Utah Republican Party | Political Support | $20,000.00 |
| 73 lines | $451,477.67 | |||
All 39 USPS payments reported by the Utah Republican Party (State) in 2026 (click to open)
| Date | Purpose as filed | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| 02/05/2026 | Other | $1,794.80 |
| 05/18/2026 | Other | $1,716.78 |
| 05/19/2026 | Other | $4,738.29 |
| 05/26/2026 | Other | $6,857.90 |
| 05/28/2026 | Other | $6,390.89 |
| 05/29/2026 | Other | $9,204.66 |
| 06/02/2026 | Other | $2,792.37 |
| 06/02/2026 | Other | $9,210.71 |
| 06/02/2026 | Other | $12,570.03 |
| 06/03/2026 | Other | $21,086.01 |
| 06/04/2026 | Other | $14,265.53 |
| 06/08/2026 | Other | $2,937.61 |
| 06/08/2026 | Other | $9,658.65 |
| 06/09/2026 | Other | $1,092.99 |
| 06/10/2026 | Other | $3,826.23 |
| 06/10/2026 | Other | $4,740.38 |
| 06/15/2026 | Campaign Expense | $7,984.88 |
| 06/16/2026 | Campaign Expense | $535.80 |
| 06/16/2026 | Campaign Expense | $9,290.62 |
| 06/17/2026 | Campaign Expense | $12,816.73 |
| 06/18/2026 | Campaign Expense | $15,580.81 |
| 06/23/2026 | Campaign Expense | $1,131.92 |
| 08/20/2026 | Campaign Expense | $134.71 |
| 09/09/2026 | Campaign Expense | $568.61 |
| 09/23/2026 | Campaign Expense | $2,793.12 |
| 10/05/2026 | Other | $2,253.84 |
| 10/06/2026 | Other | $4,793.24 |
| 10/07/2026 | Other | $4,793.24 |
| 10/08/2026 | Other | $2,814.20 |
| 10/09/2026 | Other | $1,576.76 |
| 10/14/2026 | Other | $23,353.85 |
| 10/14/2026 | Other | $4,791.54 |
| 10/14/2026 | Other | $9,263.51 |
| 10/15/2026 | Other | $15,346.99 |
| 10/16/2026 | Other | $11,307.80 |
| 10/19/2026 | Other | $8,283.75 |
| 10/20/2026 | Other | $14,871.98 |
| 10/20/2026 | Other | $6,695.71 |
| 10/21/2026 | Other | $31,478.54 |
| 39 lines | $305,345.98 | |
Do both sides match?
Each payment shows up twice: once on the candidate's report as money paid out, and once on the party's report as money received. When the two match, it confirms the record. The party's 2026 Primary report (April 14 – June 11) was checked against the candidates' own reports.
| Candidate | Party's report says it received | Candidate's report says it paid the party | Match? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jordan Teuscher (HD-44) | $9,965.63 | $9,965.63 $6,390.63 + $3,388.37 + $186.63 | Yes, to the penny |
| Brady Brammer (SD-21) | $19,695.00 | $22,030.00 | No, $2,335 apart |
| Doug Fiefia (SD-18) | $12,444.00 + $71.00 5/19 $4,865.00, 5/20 $3,329.00, 6/3 $4,250.00 ("Fiefia For Utah"); 5/21 $71.00 | $12,444.00 ("State Indicia") + $71.00 | Yes, to the penny |
| Brent Bowles (Utah County Commission) | $33,230.00 | Files with Utah County, not checked | — |
| Tami Tran (SD-6) | $12,745.00 5/28 $4,310.00, 5/28 $4,310.00, 6/11 $4,125.00 (filed as "Vote Tami Tran") | No matching payment to the party found under payee "Utah Republican Party" | Not settled yet |
Bowles and Tran don't appear in the state search used for the charts above, so the primary-window candidate total there is at least $45,975 too low. Bowles won outright at his county convention (64.69%), one of the two cases the manual lists.
The party's Primary report also lists payments to printers and mail houses, including Precision Mail and RB Printing (at least $15,000 each, per the Hive's tracker). The manual has the candidate pay the printer. The records don't say which mailers these were for.
The convention check
The manual lists only two cases: the general election, or a primary where one candidate won outright at convention (60% or more). Six Republicans paid the party during the primary window. Here is how each did at convention.
Convention vote, with the 60% line
Sources: Daily Herald (SD-21), Salt Lake County GOP results (HD-41, HD-44), Park Record (HD-59), Deseret News (SD-18, "nearly 59%"), Utah County GOP voter page (Bowles).
| Candidate | Race | Convention result | Won outright? | Paid party, May 18 – June 23 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brady Brammer | SD-21 | 68.22% (191–89 over Kelly Smith) | Yes | $22,030.00 |
| Jordan Teuscher | HD-44 | 62.5% (40–24 over Scott Stephenson) | Yes | $12,965.63 |
| Doug Fiefia | SD-18 | nearly 59% vs. Sen. Dan McCay | No | $12,515.00 |
| Darren Croft | HD-41 | 49% (25–26, Eryn Russo 51%) | No | $4,115.00 |
| Luke Searle | HD-59 | 56.5% vs. Jeffrey Pierce's 43.5% | No | $5,370.00 |
| Brent Bowles | Utah County Commission | 64.69% vs. Michelle Kaufusi's 35.32% | Yes | $33,230.00 (party's report) |
- Fiefia, Croft and Searle paid the party a combined $22,000 during the primary, in races where no one won outright at convention.
- Fiefia's lines name the program ("State Indicia"). Croft's and Searle's are labeled "Advertising," so they could be for something other than postage.
- The party's own rule may answer this. Bylaws Section 8.3 A gives equal access to party services to all Republican candidates, except those who reached the primary without going through convention. All three were convention finalists. The manual page lists fewer cases than the bylaws allow.
"State Inicia" and "State Indicia"
Rep. Jim Alvey, HD-10
- 9/21/2026 — $3,140.00, Supplies
- 10/13/2026 — $3,925.00, Campaign Expense
- 10/13/2026 — $3,145.00, Advertising
- Payee: "State Inicia", no address
- Total: $10,210.00, general-election window
Rep. Doug Fiefia, SD-18
- 5/19/2026 — $4,865.00, Campaign Expense
- 5/20/2026 — $3,329.00, Campaign Expense
- 6/3/2026 — $4,250.00, Campaign Expense
- Payee: "Utah Republican Party State Indicia", no address
- Total: $12,444.00, primary window
- No 2026 filer other than Alvey reported a payee named "State Inicia," and no filings under that name were found back to 2021.
- No business named "State Inicia" was found in the Utah Division of Corporations, OpenCorporates or a web search.
- "Inicia" is one letter off "Indicia," the manual page's title. Alvey's report also lists Bell Printing ($11,142.17) as a separate vendor, the way the manual has the candidate pay the printer directly.
- Not confirmed: that "State Inicia" means the party's program. Nothing on Alvey's report says so.
A question the records raise: a campaign vendor paying the party
The manual page ends with a list of "printing and mailing companies that we have auto withdrawal with," and adds: "They know the process." In the copy posted publicly, the company names are blacked out.
That line matters. It means the party works directly with certain vendors on candidate mailers. If a vendor pays the party for a candidate's postage, the money would take a different path through the records than when the candidate pays the party directly.
Path A: the candidate pays the party
Anyone reading either report can see the candidate and the party are connected.
Path B: a vendor pays the party
The candidate's name isn't on the party's report, and the party's name isn't on the candidate's report.
What the records show about one vendor
- Tactical Campaigns LLC (Provo; Utah Division of Corporations entity #10395907-0160, formed May 30, 2017; members Michael Adam Melendez and William Joseph DeBose) is listed as a contributor on the party's 2026 reports: $71,600 in 14 entries, Jan. 1 – June 15, 2026 (disclosures.utah.gov, Contributions, "Tactical," pulled Nov. 8, 2026). An earlier Hive tracker counted $49,185 for Jan. 1 – June 12; the filings show $48,945 for that window.
- In 2026, candidates and PACs reported paying Tactical Campaigns $117,151.77 in 18 payments, and the Utah Republican Party (State) reported paying it $1,350 in one more (19 payments, $118,501.77 in all; disclosures.utah.gov, payee "Tactical Campaigns," pulled Nov. 5, 2026, and rechecked Nov. 8, 2026):
| Paid Tactical Campaigns in 2026 | Payments | Total |
|---|---|---|
| Grant Pace | 3 | $26,825.00 |
| Trevor Lee | 2 | $26,243.90 |
| Tamara (Tami) Tran | 4 | $24,900.56 |
| Adams Leadership PAC | 5 | $18,262.73 |
| John Knotwell | 2 | $13,514.59 |
| Prosperous Utah Communities | 1 | $4,904.99 |
| Brady Brammer (filed as "Tactical Campaign") | 1 | $2,500.00 |
| Utah Republican Party (State) | 1 | $1,350.00 |
| Total | 19 | $118,501.77 |
- Several of the same names also paid the party directly: Tran ($12,745 on the party's report), Prosperous Utah Communities ($8,730), Brammer ($22,030), Adams Leadership PAC ($51,903.73) and Knotwell ($1,300).
Why it matters if the answer is yes
- Voters couldn't trace it. Someone reading a candidate's report would see a payment to a consultant, not to the party, and couldn't tell the party's postage permit was used.
- The party's report would name the vendor as the giver, not the candidate whose mailer it was.
- Under USPS ruling PS-055, money earmarked for one candidate's mailer is the candidate's money no matter who hands it over. Passing it through a vendor wouldn't change how USPS treats it.
- Under state disclosure, it raises the question of who the contribution is really from, which is a question for the Lieutenant Governor's elections office.
What would settle it
- The blacked-out list of "printing and mailing companies" on the manual page.
- The purpose the party records for each vendor contribution, and whether any are tied to a candidate.
- The Audit Committee's review of those records, which it can request under bylaws 2.4 B.
The Democratic side
The same searches were run for payee "Utah Democratic Party" (about 10 pages of results). Any state party committee may get a nonprofit permit; this section shows what the Democratic records show in 2026.
| Sept. 1 – Nov. 2, 2026 | Amount |
|---|---|
| Democratic candidates paid the Utah Democratic Party | $111,311.14 |
| — Celeste Johnson (HD-59), 13 payments, most Oct. 19 – Nov. 2 | $54,853.21 |
| — Michael Finch (HD-26), largest $16,934.55 on Oct. 14, "Advertising" | $32,060.85 |
| Groups and PACs paid the party (incl. Elevate PAC $200,000, "Donations") | $251,250.80 |
| "Utah Democratic State Party" paid "Utah Democratic Party" (16 lines, "Other") | $287,910.56 |
| Utah Democratic Party (State) payments to USPS in 2026, state reports | None found |
| Utah State Democratic Committee, federal account (FEC), payments to USPS in 2026 (added Nov. 19, 2026) | $11,471.69 |
- Earlier in the year, Democratic candidates' payments to the party were mostly small and repeated at set amounts ($180, $198, $477.50, $483.75, $500, $516.45, $772.71), which looks like set fees for a party service. The records don't say what the service is.
- Where results pages overlapped, a repeated row was counted once (Johnson's $5,115.00 on Oct. 20).
- Records don't show what Johnson's or Finch's payments bought. With no state Democratic USPS payments, they don't show postage under the Democratic Party's permit.
- Added Nov. 19, 2026: the party's federal account (FEC committee C00105973) reported six payments to USPS in 2026, $11,471.69 in all. Some lines from Oct. 6 to Oct. 14 describe the purpose as "candidate's mailers postage." The federal report doesn't name the candidates. See New records checked Nov. 19.
How the two sides differ
Republican records
- Candidate and PAC money went to the party in the same weeks the party paid USPS.
- One payee line names the program: "State Indicia."
- The candidate gets nonprofit postage rates. In the 1992 Utah case, the nonprofit rate was about 45% lower than the regular bulk rate; today's gap wasn't checked.
- The party gets the extra amount (about 10%, per the manual) and its name on the mail.
- In a primary, convention finalists can use it; signature-only candidates can't (bylaws 8.3).
Democratic records
- Candidate and group money also went to the party, heavily in October.
- No payee line names a postage program.
- The state party reported no USPS payments on its state reports, so those records don't tie these payments to postage.
- Its federal account reported $11,471.69 to USPS, some described as "candidate's mailers postage" (added Nov. 19, 2026).
- What the money bought (staff, canvassing, data, ads) isn't stated.
Under the law, neither party has an advantage: any state party committee can hold a nonprofit permit, and the Utah Democratic Party used theirs this way in 1992. In the 2026 state records, only the Republican side shows candidate money in and party postage out. Added Nov. 19, 2026: the Democrats' federal report lists postage for candidates' mailers in October.
New records checked Nov. 19, 2026
A public post by Michael Clara (X, Nov. 10, 2026) made several claims about the program. We checked them against federal reports (fec.gov), state reports (disclosures.utah.gov) and USPS rulings. Here is what we found, and what we couldn't find.
Found in the records
- The USPS rule. Ruling PS-055 says a state committee may not lend its permit, and that money earmarked for one candidate is treated as the candidate's money. (Already on this page, in "What USPS rules say.")
- The party's USPS total. State reports show the Utah Republican Party (State) paid payees named "USPS" $305,345.98 in 2026, the same figure published on this page. No other postal-named payees were found for the party.
- Maloy money on the party's federal account (FEC committee C00089482). The party received from "Maloy, Celeste" $300 (April 1), $7,500 (April 6), $1,400 (April 7) and $2,350 (April 14, 2026). It refunded $300 to Maloy on May 15. On June 15, 2026 it paid $17,750 to Celeste for Congress, labeled "Transfer to authorized committee." The reports don't say what any of these payments were for, or whether the April money came from Maloy personally or from a campaign committee.
- Federal limits, for context (FEC chart, 2025–2026): a state party committee may give a candidate committee $5,000 per election, and the primary and general count as separate elections. An individual may give a state party $10,000 per year. The records don't show whether these payments were refunds, money earmarked for a candidate, or party spending made together with a campaign, which are counted differently. Whether any limit applies is the FEC's call, and no FEC finding was found.
- No USPS payments on the Republican federal account in 2026.
- Democratic federal account (C00105973): six USPS payments in 2026, $11,471.69, some described as "candidate's mailers postage" (Oct. 6–14).
- Sun Print. No payments to Sun Print from the Utah Republican Party or from Maloy were found in 2024–2026 state reports. The Utah Democratic State Party paid "Sun Print Solution" $6,121.55 (Oct. 8 and Oct. 22, 2026).
- Lyman, 2024. The party received $6,000 and $4,276 from "Phil Lyman for Utah" (March 21, 2024) and $6,000 from "Lyman For Gove" (June 25, 2024). Lyman's campaign reported $6,000 to the party on March 20, 2024 as "Campaign Expense." The reports don't say what the payments were for.
Not found
- The figure $348,333.63. State reports show $305,345.98 to USPS.
- Any 2025–2026 FEC enforcement case (MUR) or alternative dispute resolution case involving the Utah Republican Party. The most recent public ones are MUR 7330 (closed 2021) and ADR 855 (closed 2018).
- Any record that Sun Print was barred from party work.
- A full video of the Oct. 24, 2026 State Central Committee meeting. A short clip circulates online; the party's website posts minutes only through the third quarter of 2025.
Checked Nov. 19, 2026: fec.gov receipts and disbursements pages read in a browser; disclosures.utah.gov expenditure searches, all results pages read. Not found means not found in these searches, not proof that something doesn't exist.
What isn't known
Which payments were for postage
No 2026 line on either side says "postage." Only Fiefia's payee names the program.
Whether the 10% was charged
Candidates pay on the printer's estimate and USPS draws the actual postage, so single payments don't line up. The party's own mail also runs through the same permit. The totals can't prove or disprove the 10%.
A test, where same-day amounts exist: Fiefia paid $4,865.00 on May 19, and the party paid USPS $4,738.29 that day, 2.7% more. Teuscher's $6,390.63 vs. the party's $6,390.89 (next item) is essentially 0%. Neither pairing is proven, but neither shows 10%.
Two Tran entries of $4,310.00 on the same day
The party's report lists two $4,310.00 entries from "Vote Tami Tran" on May 28. That may be two mailers, or one entry recorded twice.
Stuart Adams for Senate's payments to the party
The Hive's tracker of the party's Primary report lists five transfers of about $7,800 each on May 20, totaling either $31,375 or $39,175; the tracker gives both. Adams Leadership PAC also paid the party $48,603.73 the same day. What they were for isn't stated.
A near-match: $6,390.89 and $6,390.63
The party paid USPS $6,390.89 on May 28. Rep. Jordan Teuscher paid the party $6,390.63 on June 1, labeled "Supplies." They're 26 cents apart. Nothing on either report ties them together, so this is not a finding.
Two identical USPS payments
The party paid USPS $4,793.24 on Oct. 6 and again on Oct. 7. That may be two mailings, or one payment entered twice.
Whether the manual page was approved
No State Central Committee minutes found show approval or ratification of the Feb. 7, 2025 revision.
The party's own rules
- Bylaws 5.0 (amended Nov. 15, 2025). The State Party Officers keep a written Operations Manual, available to State Central Committee members at headquarters. The State Executive Committee reviews it the same year after each nominating convention. Changes go to the Executive Committee for review and to the State Central Committee for approval. New policies adopted in between must be ratified at the next State Central Committee meeting.
- Bylaws 2.4 B. The Audit Committee has access, by request approved by a majority of the committee, to the party's financial documents and reports, shared only with State Central Committee members.
- Bylaws 8.3 A. Party officers and staff give equal access to party services to all Republican candidates, except those who reached the primary without going through convention.
- Sept. 6, 2025. The State Central Committee passed an "Amendment to Update Operations Manual Timeline," 118 yes, 12 no, 8 present. The minutes don't give its text.
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
- The Lieutenant Governor's elections office: When a candidate mails on a party's nonprofit permit, should the difference between regular and nonprofit postage be reported as an in-kind contribution from the party? Should payments for postage be labeled as postage?
- Your State Central Committee members: When was the State Party Indicia section approved or ratified? Does it match bylaws 8.3, which list more candidates than the manual does?
- The Utah Republican Party Audit Committee: Has it requested the records for the State Indicia donations and the party's USPS payments under bylaws 2.4 B?
- The Utah Republican Party Audit Committee: Which printing and mailing companies are on the manual's list, and were any contributions from those companies made for a candidate's mailer?
- The Lieutenant Governor's elections office: If a vendor pays a party for a candidate's postage, whose contribution is it, and how should each side report it?
- USPS Mailing Standards: Does a candidate donation made under this process, before the party approves that candidate's mailer, meet ruling PS-055?
- The Utah Republican Party Audit Committee: What were the April 2026 Maloy payments to the party's federal account for, and what was the $17,750 "Transfer to authorized committee" on June 15, 2026?
- The Federal Election Commission (fec.gov, Information Division): How are a candidate's payments to a state party, and the party's later transfer back to that candidate's committee, counted against the per-election limits?
People named in the records
Each person is named only for what the records show. Pages with more on them are linked.
- Robert Axson — Utah Republican Party chair; described the program to The Salt Lake Tribune (July 31, 2025).
- Michael Clara — posted the manual page on Facebook (Oct. 28, 2026).
- Rep. Jim Alvey (HD-10) — $10,210 to "State Inicia."
- Rep. Doug Fiefia (SD-18) — $12,444 to "State Indicia" during the primary; beat Sen. Dan McCay in the June primary.
- Sen. Brady Brammer (SD-21) — $22,030 to the party during the primary; won outright at convention.
- Rep. Jordan Teuscher (HD-44) — $23,099.82 to the party in 2026, labeled "Supplies"; won outright at convention.
- Darren Croft (HD-41) — $22,610 to the party in 2026, labeled "Advertising."
- Luke Searle (HD-59) — $19,905 to the party in 2026.
- Sen. Kirk Cullimore (SD-19) — $34,850 to the party in October.
- Sen. Scott Sandall (SD-1) — $10,635 twice (Sept. 30 and Oct. 15).
- House Speaker Mike Schultz (HD-12) — $35,975 to the party on Oct. 13, labeled "Donations"; the record doesn't say what it paid for.
- Celeste Johnson (HD-59, Democrat) and Michael Finch (HD-26, Democrat) — the largest Democratic candidate payments to their party.
Words to know
Tap a card to see what it means.
Behind this piece
Posted Nov. 5, 2026. Disclosure figures are a snapshot of disclosures.utah.gov as of Nov. 5, 2026. Later filings will be added as new data with their dates. Corrected Nov. 8, 2026: Tactical Campaigns figures (see the note at the top).
Updates since this was posted
- Nov. 5, 2026This page posted.
- Nov. 18, 2026Added a link to the How We Found It trail for Tactical Campaigns. No figures on this page changed.
- Nov. 19, 2026Added "New records checked Nov. 19": federal (FEC) reports for both state parties, Sun Print, Lyman 2024, and what we could not find. Added the Democrats' federal USPS payments ($11,471.69) next to the state-report finding, which is unchanged. No earlier figures changed.
New updates will be added here with their dates. Earlier entries are not changed.
Connecting stories
- How we found it: Tactical Campaigns, the PAC and the party (HW 100.01)The step-by-step trail behind this page's Tactical figures, with the records for each step.
- The State Party Indicia, in plain words (UP 100.14)The short, plain-language companion to this page.
- HD-10: Lesser vs. Alveycandidates2026: Alvey's full 2026 money, including "State Inicia."
- SD-18: Fiefia vs. Andersoncandidates2026: Fiefia's primary spending, including the State Indicia lines.
Sources
Sources — click to open (with links)
- Utah Republican Party, Operations Manual, "State Party Indicia" page (last revised 2/7/25), as posted publicly by Michael Clara on Facebook, Oct. 28, 2026 (screenshot)
- USPS Customer Support Ruling PS-055, State Committee of a Political Party (updated January 2017)
- USPS Publication 417, 5-4.2 Maintaining Committee Control
- USPS Publication 417, 5-4 Political Committee Mailings
- USPS Publication 417, 4-4 Postage Liability
- USPS Judicial Officer, P.S. Docket Nos. PF-74 and PF 94-6, initial decision (Aug. 29, 1995)
- The Salt Lake Tribune, Riverton mayoral candidate mailer (July 31, 2025)
- Utah Republican Party, Candidates page (Postage Discount Form)
- Utah Republican Party Bylaws, amended Nov. 15, 2025 (Sections 2.4, 5.0, 8.3)
- Utah Republican Party, State Central Committee minutes, Sept. 6, 2025
- disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search, Expenditures, 2026, payees "Utah Republican Party," "USPS," "Postmaster," "postage" and "Utah Democratic Party," results pages captured Nov. 5, 2026; payee "State Inicia," Nov. 4, 2026
- Salt Lake County Republican Party, 2026 convention results (HD-41, HD-44)
- Daily Herald, Utah County Republican convention results (SD-21), Apr. 18, 2026
- The Park Record, HD-59 convention (Apr. 28, 2026)
- Deseret News, state convention (Apr. 25, 2026): Fiefia "nearly 59%"
- FEC, Utah Republican Party federal account (C00089482), 2025–2026 receipts and disbursements, read Nov. 19, 2026
- FEC, Utah State Democratic Committee federal account (C00105973), 2025–2026 disbursements, read Nov. 19, 2026
- FEC, Contribution limits for 2025–2026 (chart, January 2025)
- FEC enforcement and ADR case search, Utah Republican Party, read Nov. 19, 2026
- disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search, Expenditures 2024–2026, payees "USPS," "Postal," "Post Office," "Postmaster," "Postage" and "Sun Print"; Lyman 2024 reports; all results pages read Nov. 19, 2026
- Michael Clara, public post on X, Nov. 10, 2026 (claims checked)
- Congressional Research Service, FY2024 U.S. Postal Service Appropriations

