Ads, mail, texts, polls and paid signature gatherers: what Utah campaigns spent, what the law makes them disclose, and what stays out of view.
StatewideCASE 2026-WGS-03 · Posted Nov. 8, 2026 · Updated Nov. 8, 2026
| Race | What was reported | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 general, all Utah races | Super PACs spent about $3 million on KSL, KSTU, KTVX and KUTV ads. Two Utah-only groups spent about $820,000. Named spenders include Defending Our Values, Defend American Jobs, New Democrat Majority, Utahns Protecting Our Constitution and Utah Donor Collaborative. | FOX 13, 10/19/2026 |
| 2026 congressional primaries | Defending Our Values PAC spent nearly $880,000 in one week for Rep. Celeste Maloy (CD3). Think Big PAC reserved $450,000 in TV ads for Ben McAdams (CD1). | Deseret News, 6/9/2026 |
| Amendment B, 2026 | The No committee reported $3,142,705.81 spent in 2026 through Oct. 22 (its General report); KSL reported "more than $3 million." Supporters "haven't raised nearly as much money" (KSL). | KSL, 10/30/2026 |
| 2024, all Utah races | Republicans spent $18.2 million on ads ($10 million outside groups, $7.9 million campaigns), 98% of the total. Democrats spent $443,004 (Jan. 1–Oct. 31). | Axios, 11/12/2024 |
| 2024 U.S. Senate | Outside groups spent more than $7.7 million supporting John Curtis; Conservative Values for Utah PAC alone spent close to $5 million. Gov. Cox's campaign reported spending $3,782,382.19. | Deseret News, 11/14/2024 |
For scale: national ad spending in the 2026 cycle passed $10 billion (AdImpact, via the Deseret News), and groups that don't disclose donors put more than $1.9 billion into 2024 federal races (Brennan Center, using OpenSecrets data).
The Utah Republican Party lists "postage discounts for mailers" as a resource for its candidates. The Hive's case file on it is in Unelected Power.
Campaign reports name the first company paid, not the companies it hires. No Utah rule requiring campaigns to report those second-level vendors was found.
| Example | What the records or reports show |
|---|---|
| House District 10 campaign (2026) | Largest vendors: Roost $19,687.99, Bell Printing $11,142.17, "State Inicia" $10,210 (no address on any line; no other 2026 filer paid it), Reagan Outdoor $5,011.24. About 87% of the campaign's money came from party and leadership committees. From the campaign's own filings, read Nov. 4, 2026. |
| Majorities Matter PAC (2026) | A Democratic firm, Fulcrum Campaigns, was the PAC's only donor (nearly $11,000) and ran "Republicans Against the Stratos Project Data Center" mailers against Box Elder commissioners (KSL, 6/6/2026). |
| Make Liberty Win (2026) | A $100,000 mail, text and call campaign against Senate President Stuart Adams, funded by Young Americans for Liberty, with at least five mailers using AI-made images (KSL, 6/13/2026). |
| Governing Group PAC (2025) | Took $100,000 from "America Leads." A complaint said no 501(c)(4) by that name could be found; the Lt. Governor's office found "no violation of election code" (KUER, 10/29/2025). |
| Utahns Protecting Our Constitution (No on B, 2026) | Through Sept. 25: Divergus Digital $203,834 (ads, Feb.–Mar.), Guidant Polling $33,750, plus three law firms (filings read Oct. 10, 2026). Sept. 26–Oct. 22: Viewpoint Media about $2.09 million, Valkyrie Strategies about $410,000, Divergus Digital $85,230, SB Digital $85,000, Guidant Polling $30,000 (General report, read Nov. 8, 2026). |
Who runs the committees that pay vendors. The Hive's PAC and Ledger repos trace the leadership committees and the firms behind them: Lincoln Hill PAC, Lincoln Hill Partners PAC, The Men Behind Lincoln Hill, House Speaker Leadership PAC, Adams Leadership PAC, the Senate Republican campaign committee, NUPAC, Election Hive and Irish Elk, and the biggest donors. On the Yes side of Amendment B, see Taxpayer Shield PAC and the Utah Taxpayers Association.
Marketing doesn't stop at elections. These Bill-Tracker case files graded bills whose name or first version promised one thing while the final law did another. Grades are from each case file.
| Bill | Our grade | What it did | How it connects |
|---|---|---|---|
| H.B. 60 (2026) House Cmte 7–2–5 · House 54–17–4 · Senate Cmte 5–1–1 · Senate 2nd 15–7–7 · Senate 3rd 18–7–4 | D | Bait-and-Switch: Narrowing Who Can Object to a Water Application. Narrowed the "public welfare" standard a state engineer can use to deny a water application from a broad standard (recreation, stream environment, general welfare) to only quantity/quality/availability — cutting the exact ground the Utah Rivers Council had used to protest. | The title says "public welfare"; the change narrowed who can object to a water application. |
| H.B. 236 (2026) Floor vote counts not yet confirmed | D | Bait-and-Switch: The Tax Comparison That Got Quietly Dropped. Early versions of "Truth in Taxation Amendments" required taxing entities to build two budgets — one without a proposed tax increase, one with — proving the increase was actually needed. | A two-budget comparison promised under "Truth in Taxation" was dropped. |
| H.B. 273 (2026) House Cmte 10-0-5 · House 68-1-6 · Senate Cmte 3-2-2 · Senate 17-9-3 · House concurred 62-6-7 · Signed Mar 18, 2026 | D | Bait-and-Switch: Loosening the Classroom Tech Standard From the Inside. The standard for what counts as approved classroom instructional technology was weakened via a floor amendment from the bill's own Senate sponsor — from software "designed specifically for instructional use" to merely "demonstrated to have significant educational value," opening the door to general-purpose AI tools the bill was otherwise meant to guardrail. | The classroom tech standard was loosened by the bill's own sponsor. |
| H.B. 475 (2026) See case-file page for full vote chain | D | Bait-and-Switch: The Oversight Work Group That Vanished Two Minutes Before Passage. Created an economic-development work group with named oversight seats, then had those seats quietly stripped in a floor substitute adopted just before final passage. | Oversight seats were removed two minutes before passage. |
| S.B. 254 Senate Committee 4–1–2 · Senate 28–1–0 · House Committee 9–0–5 · House 60–12–3 | D | Renamed, Recut, and Redirected in Nine Hours. A critical-minerals bill passed both chambers' floors under one name and one set of numbers — then, in a roughly nine-hour window the same day, was retitled, had its tax-credit caps cut, and had its funding stream redirected to a broader account, without ever going back through a floor vote on what actually changed. | Renamed, recut and redirected in about nine hours. |
| H.B. 491 (2023) House Cmte 12–0–2 · Senate Cmte 5–0–3 · Signed Mar 14, 2023 | F | Bait-and-Switch: The Great Salt Lake Bill That Helped Its Own Sponsor. Created the Great Salt Lake Commissioner position and a new GRAMA exemption for the Commissioner's water-related records — added in the Senate substitute Sen. | A Great Salt Lake bill added a records exemption. |
| H.B. 492 House 66–5–4 · Senate 27–0–2 (final substitute) · Signed Mar 25, 2026 | C- | The Loan That Lost Its Label. An $18 million loan introduced as prison-construction money and a promised merger of two housing boards into one both quietly changed in the same unexplained committee substitute — the loan lost its label, and the merger became a second board instead. | An $18 million loan changed its stated purpose. |
| H.B. 330 House 65–0 · Senate 17–7 · House concurrence 50–15 · Signed Mar 18, 2026 | D | A Defense for Permitted Conduct. A new defense in civil lawsuits for conduct a permit, license or law authorized. | The House's exception for negligent, reckless or deceptive conduct was removed in the Senate. |
| Bill | Our grade | What it did | How it connects |
|---|---|---|---|
| H.B. 136 (2021) House 42-22-11 (concurrence) · Senate 22-7-0 · Signed Mar 23, 2021 | C- | Badges and Hourly Pay for Gatherers. Banned paying initiative and referendum gatherers per signature and required hourly pay. | Hourly pay and badges for paid gatherers. |
| H.B. 242 (2026) House 57-12-6 (concurrence 3/6/26); Senate 21-7-1 (3/6/26) · Signed 3/7/2026 | C+ | Rules for Taking Signatures Back. H.B. 242 (2026), primary sponsor Rep. | The same rules for removal gatherers. |
| H.B. 32 (2026) House 56-11 (2/12/26); Senate 22-7-0 (3/4/26); House concurrence 70-0-5 (3/5/26) · Signed 3/23/2026 | C+ | Training for Every Signature Gatherer. H.B. 32 (2026), primary sponsor Rep. | Training for every gatherer. |
| S.B. 107 (2024) Senate 29-0-0 (3rd reading, 1/29/24); House 69-1-5 (2/14/24); final passage after a conference committee: House 67-0-8 (2/21/24), Senate 23-1-5 (2/22/24) · Signed 2/28/2024 | C+ | The Residency Rule That Went Away. S.B. 107 (2024) began as a bill about deadlines for independent candidates ("Unaffiliated Candidate Amendments"). | Ended the Utah-residency rule for some gatherers. |
| S.B. 53 (2025) Senate 25-1-3 · House 67-0-8 · Effective May 7, 2025 | B- | The Residency Rule, Part Two. An omnibus election bill that dropped the Utah residency rule for people gathering signatures for party candidates and new parties, finishing what S.B. 107 (2024) started. | Finished dropping the residency rule. |
| H.B. 167 (2026) Held in House committee 5-2-5 (Feb 3) · Died Mar 6, 2026 | B- | Posting Who Signed a Candidate's Petition. Would have posted the names and signing dates of voters on candidate nomination petitions on the lieutenant governor's website, and required election officials to tell the county or district attorney when someone says they did not sign. | Would have posted who signed a candidate's petition; died. |
Also: S.B. 258 / H.B. 510, where a 2026 reform failed by one vote; the case file found four of the no votes came from senators who had taken checks from a homebuilder using the 2024 law.
| What happened | Transparency | Financial accountability |
|---|---|---|
| Campaign and committee spending reports | Works. First-level payees are public. | Partial. Second-level vendors aren't reported. |
| Poll sponsor disclosure | Works on paper; $100 fine. | Unclear how often it's enforced. |
| Party postage for candidates | Partial. Party and candidate reports must be matched by hand. | USPS rules depend on who decides and who pays. |
| Nonprofit and outside spending | Gap. Original donors often aren't public. | Gap. |
| Paid signature gathering | Works. Badges name who pays. | Partial. Clerks check signatures; fraud referrals go to county attorneys. |
Where each person appears elsewhere in the Hive. Being named here does not mean anyone did anything wrong.
| Who | Why they are here | Other Hive pages |
|---|---|---|
| Rob Axson | Utah GOP chair; led the Prop 4 repeal | State Party Indicia H.B. 242 |
| Jim Alvey | 2026 House District 10 candidate; party postage and vendor payments | HD-10 race file State Party Indicia |
| Doug Fiefia | 2026 Senate District 18 candidate; named on the postage permit page | SD-18 race file |
| Brady Brammer | Sen. (R); asked for review of a PAC's late reports | Senator profile SD-21 race file |
| Casey Hill and Lincoln Shurtz | Lincoln Hill Partners lobbyists; PAC officers | The Men Behind Lincoln Hill Lincoln Hill PAC |
| Kyle Palmer | Treasurer for several leadership PACs; Irish Elk LLC | NUPAC Senate GOP campaign committee Follow the money: Election Hive, Irish Elk |
| Mike Schultz | House Speaker (R) | HD-12 race file House Speaker Leadership PAC Schultz water rights Stratos land |
| Stuart Adams | Senate President (R); lost his 2026 primary | Adams Leadership PAC Enforcement Gap |
| Lincoln Fillmore | Sen. (R); S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) sponsor; chairs Taxpayer Shield PAC | Lincoln Hill Partners PAC Utah Taxpayers Association |
Tap a card to see what it means.
Posted Nov. 8, 2026.
USPS Pub. 417, 2-3; Pub. 417, 5-4.2; USPS PS-055; H.B. 136 (2021); H.B. 242 (2026); Utah Code 20A-11-905 and 20A-11-901 (FindLaw copies); Utah GOP candidates page.
Campaign and committee reports at disclosures.utah.gov: House District 10 candidate (read Nov. 4, 2026); Utahns Protecting Our Constitution (read Oct. 10, 2026).
FOX 13 (10/19/2026); Deseret (6/9/2026); KSL (10/30/2026); Axios (11/12/2024); Deseret (11/14/2024); Deseret (10/19/2026); Brennan Center (5/7/2025); KUER (10/23/2025); Democracy Docket (2/9/2026); KPCW (2/6/2026); KSL (2/12/2026); KSL (2/17/2026); KSL (6/6/2026); KSL (6/13/2026); KUER (10/29/2025); Utah Investigative Journalism Project (10/18/2020); KPCW (11/16/2025).
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · JournalismThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.
Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us
Independent accountability journalism. Public records only. We report; you decide.
We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.
Transparency home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack