A tip about one housing nonprofit led to a Republican political committee that took in $360,000 and spent $370,350, including $110,000 returned to two donors — with a treasurer whose own firm was paid by the committee, and a Washington DC Super PAC attorney's name.
Posted Aug. 25, 2026 · Updated Sept. 30, 2026 · figures re-checked against state filings · Page look updated Nov. 2, 2026
A public tweet started this: a claim that the Utah Legislature funded a nonprofit whose registered agent is also the Governor's own campaign manager. Every part of that claim checks out against primary sources — and following the money past it leads through both chambers of the Utah GOP's own campaign committees, a $25,000 payment to Irish Elk LLC, a company of UHREC treasurer Kyle Palmer, and a Washington DC attorney whose name keeps reappearing across Utah's political money network. Here's the trail, one confirmed step at a time.
Think of it like this. Your state government has a jar of tax money set aside to help people afford housing. Instead of giving that money straight to a housing project, lawmakers gave $2 million of it to a brand-new group — one that didn't exist a few months earlier — to run TV ads about housing.
The people running that new group are the same people who run the Governor's campaigns and consult for the Attorney General.
That group paid $75,000 to one of those same people's own private company — for the ads.
Meanwhile, a separate committee took in $360,000 — including $150,000 from the Utah House and Senate Republicans' campaign committees and a $100,000 gift from an out-of-state individual — then paid that same private company again, paid a national polling firm and a national PR firm, and sent $25,000 to Irish Elk LLC, a company of Kyle Palmer, treasurer of the House GOP's PAC.
That committee was set up by a Washington DC lawyer who has built five other similar Utah groups — all connected to the same small circle of donors and officials.
The filings reviewed here do not show a violation of law. But they show how a small circle of people can move public and political money back and forth to each other, through groups the public can't easily see into. That's what "follow the money" means here — and below is the paper trail, sourced document by document.
Utah's sitting Governor. Election Hive is his campaign's single largest documented vendor, and several people in this story sit inside his administration or his personal political circle.
Founder of Election Hive, a political consulting firm that runs Gov. Cox's campaign. Also runs a second firm, Honey Communications, and is UWHA's registered agent.
Holds a paid state job as Gov. Cox's Senior Advisor for Housing Strategy — while also sitting on UWHA's board, the nonprofit that got the $2 million.
The state's sitting AG. Was a director of UWHA starting the same month he opened his own campaign for Attorney General.
Treasurer of UHREC (House GOP) with sole authority over what it pays out, and holds treasurer or officer roles at other Utah PACs. His company, Irish Elk LLC, received $25,000 from the committee at the center of this story.
Filed the paperwork that created Utahns for Balanced Government — the same lawyer behind five other Utah political groups tied to this same circle.
UWHA — a nonprofit incorporated just weeks before the 2024 legislative session — received $1 million in direct, no-bid legislative appropriations in 2024, then another $1 million in FY25-26. No competing bidder. Matt Lusty, founder of the political consulting firm Election Hive and on record as "the campaign spokesperson" for Gov. Spencer Cox, is UWHA's registered agent and has been described as its executive director. Steve Waldrip — Cox's own Senior Advisor for Housing Strategy — sits on UWHA's board while holding that state role at the same time.
Source: Utah Legislature appropriations records; Fox 13 (7/29/2025); UWHA's own board listingUWHA paid at least $75,000 to Honey Communications — Matt Lusty's second firm — for its "Demand More Supply" ad campaign. When UWHA's own leadership was asked to name a single house built as a result of the campaign, the answer was a pause and "that's a great question."
Source: UWHA financial disclosures; Fox 13 (7/29/2025)A completely different filer, "Utahns for Balanced Government," paid Honey Communications $8,950 in October 2024 — a single payment, but one piece of a much larger operation this filer was running that same year.
Source: disclosures.utah.gov, DEX filing dataUtahns for Balanced Government is registered as a Political Issues Committee (PIC) — a different category than a PAC under Utah law, and one that doesn't appear in a standard PAC-only search or directory browse. It files real reports under this category. Its full 2023–2026 ledger, pulled directly from the state's DEX filing system, shows $360,000 in contributions and $370,350 in expenditures.
Source: disclosures.utah.gov DEX filing exports, Utahns for Balanced GovernmentKyle Palmer is Treasurer of UHREC — the House GOP PAC that gave this committee $100,000 — and also serves as treasurer of other Utah PACs, including NUPAC, House Speaker Leadership PAC, and UCL PAC. On 4/3/2025, this same committee paid $25,000 to Irish Elk LLC, Palmer's own consulting company — a payment from a committee that the PAC he serves as treasurer helped fund.
Source: disclosures.utah.gov DEX filing exports; Utah PAC officer registrationsOn 10/17/2024, the committee returned $100,000 in full to the Utah Bankers Association and $10,000 in full to Spring Canyon Capital LLC — both labeled "Return of a Contribution." The filing doesn't say why. It could reflect a donor's own request, a compliance concern, or a change of plans — the record doesn't specify, and neither should any characterization of it until it does.
Source: disclosures.utah.gov DEX filing exportsThe committee's official officer filing lists Executive Director Marty Carpenter's email at the domain "24nine.com" — and the very first expenditure in the ledger is $10,000 paid to 24NINE on 8/28/2023, labeled "Constituent Services." Separately, the filing lists Mike McCauley as the committee's Treasurer — and "McCauley & Associates," the recurring small-dollar vendor throughout the ledger, has drawn about $6,225 across several payments since 2024. Treasurers charging their own committees compliance fees isn't unusual on its own. Along with the Executive Director's firm and the payment to Kyle Palmer's company above, that makes three firms tied to people in officer or treasurer roles that the committee's filings show it paid.
Source: disclosures.utah.gov PIC officer filing; DEX filing exportsThe person who filed Utahns for Balanced Government's paperwork in 2018 was Matthew T. Sanderson of Caplin & Drysdale — a national Super PAC attorney who is also the incorporator of five other Utah political entities: All In For Utah Foundation, All In For Utah PAC, the Utah Doers Network, the Pioneer Trail Foundation, and a federal Defending Utah Values Super PAC. The committee's Executive Director is Marty Carpenter — former campaign manager to Gov. Gary Herbert — alongside Advisor Brad Taylor and Secretary Tyler Carpenter. Carpenter originally formed the group in 2018 to oppose a ballot measure, funded almost entirely by Herbert's own PAC; it reported little activity between 2018 and 2023, before this 2024 reactivation.
Source: Utah Division of Corporations, Articles of Incorporation; Salt Lake Tribune (10/30/2018)Derek Brown — the sitting Attorney General — was also a UWHA director, starting the same month he opened his AG campaign. Gov. Cox's own campaign is Election Hive's single largest client, paying it more than $244,000 across two single-day payments. A tip about one nonprofit and three names connects outward into the same donor and PAC network that funds the Governor, the Attorney General, and House and Senate leadership all at once.
Source: Utah campaign finance disclosures; UWHA board recordsEvery person in this story sits inside a wider network of PACs, state jobs, and campaign money. Here's the fuller picture, one person at a time.
Utah's sitting Governor. Election Hive — Matt Lusty's firm — is Cox's single largest documented campaign vendor, paid $127,000+ in a single day (1/3/2024) and $117,000+ in a single day (1/15/2025). Cox has also received $82,500+ from Lincoln Hill Partners PAC (2022-2025) and $97,500+ directly from three energy companies (PacifiCorp, Chevron, EnergySolutions) between 2018 and 2026.
Founded Election Hive in 2018 and still runs it today. Before going independent, he served as Deputy Chief of Staff for the Utah House of Representatives (Jan-Nov 2019) under then-newly-elected Speaker Brad Wilson — who is now also an Election Hive client. Lusty co-founded a second firm, Honey Communications, in 2024. He is UWHA's registered agent and, per Fox 13, its executive director.
Has held Gov. Cox's Senior Advisor for Housing Strategy and Innovation role since December 2023 — and, as of July 2026, also heads a brand-new state Division of Housing and Community Development overseeing a $100 million infrastructure fund. He holds an Executive Board Member seat on UWHA at the same time, a role UWHA's own press materials publicly paired with his state title.
Won the AG race in November 2024, took office January 2025. Was a UWHA director starting November 20, 2023 — the same month he opened his AG exploratory committee. Election Hive is his campaign's regular vendor: his own campaign paid it $127,680 across the 2024 cycle and $68,212 in 2025.
Simultaneously holds Treasurer or officer roles on at least five Utah PACs — including UHREC, the House GOP PAC that gave Utahns for Balanced Government $100,000. He operates through his own company, Irish Elk LLC, which has drawn over $207,000 in fees from just four of those PACs since 2022 — and, separately, a direct $25,000 payment from Utahns for Balanced Government itself in April 2025.
An attorney at Caplin & Drysdale, Chtd. in Washington DC, where he heads the Political Law Group. Filed the Articles of Incorporation for Utahns for Balanced Government in 2018. Career highlights include serving as General Counsel to Rand Paul's 2016 presidential campaign, outside counsel to Rick Perry's 2012 campaign, counsel to Mitt Romney's Commonwealth PACs, and finance counsel to John McCain's 2008 campaign. He is the incorporator of six documented Utah political entities in total.
Tap a card to see who actually runs each one.
Marty Carpenter (Executive Director, Herbert's former campaign manager), Brad Taylor (Advisor), Tyler Carpenter (Secretary), Wesley Smith (Director), Mike McCauley (Treasurer).
$360,000 in, $370,350 out (2023-2026) — including $150K from the House and Senate GOP PACs, a $25,000 payment to Kyle Palmer's own firm, two full refunds the same day, and payments to both the Executive Director's and Treasurer's own firms.
Directors Luke Johnson, Owen Fuller, and Tiffany Yen-Louie — same Cottonwood Heights address cluster as Fuller's other entities.
Contributed $50,000 to All In For Utah PAC on 4/17/2026; the PAC reported no spending during the primary.
Owen Fuller (Chair) and Dan Hemmert (Treasurer) — a former state senator turned lobbyist.
This is the filing that directly connects Fuller's Cox-circle network to Hemmert's separate Election Hive/Lincoln Hill Partners network.
A 22-member board weighted heavily with sitting officials and party officers — including a Utah County board chaired by a sitting state senator's own wife.
Incorporated after roughly $70,000 had already gone out the door to legislative candidates under the "Doers Network" name — the paperwork caught up to the money, not the other way around.
Nobody named on the state filing. Sanderson is the only person listed. The Deseret News (Apr. 2026) names chairman Ryan Beck and director Alex Burton.
Named in H.B. 2 (2026) for up to $10 million in state grants for a downtown Salt Lake City walking trail.
The federal sister committee to the state-level Defending Utah Values PAC, per the group's own website — Owen Fuller-led, per press coverage.
Paid Election Hive $38,000 directly for 2026 primary ad buys — the same firm run by Matt Lusty, at the center of this entire piece.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · JournalismThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.
Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us
We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.
The Ledger home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack