Utah's constitution and laws promise that power belongs to the people, that elections are free and that government works in the open. Here is each promise in its own words, and what has changed.
StatewideCASE 2026-WGS-04 · Posted Nov. 8, 2026 · Updated Nov. 8, 2026
At the 1895 convention, delegate Heber Wells said it was "very pertinent to provide that all political power is inherent in the people" (as quoted in the Utah Supreme Court's 2024 opinion). Equal suffrage passed the convention 75–14 on April 5, 1895 (Utah Women's History).
Utah was the second state, after South Dakota, to give voters initiative and referendum.
| The promise | What changed | The pushback |
|---|---|---|
| Voters can make laws (Art. VI, Sec. 1) | All three 2018 initiatives changed or replaced (H.B. 3001, S.B. 96, S.B. 200). In 2024, lawmakers proposed Amendment D to let them change any initiative. | The Utah Supreme Court (July 2024): the people's reform power is "protected from government infringement." Courts voided Amendment D. |
| Voters can send a law to a vote (referendum) | Some local land use laws made not referable (H.B. 462, 2022; S.B. 199, 2023). A referendum is void if lawmakers repeal the law first (H.B. 75, 2020). | Referendum drives led lawmakers to repeal laws in 2011, 2020 and 2025. |
| "Easy and reasonable access" to records (GRAMA) | 2011 HB477 restricted records access. 2025: the seven-member State Records Committee replaced by one director the governor appoints (S.B. 277); court costs for winning records appeals limited to "bad faith" cases (H.B. 69); university president finalists kept private (S.B. 282). New exemptions in H.B. 61, H.B. 491 and H.B. 575. | HB477 repealed March 25, 2011 (House 60–3, Senate 19–5). The Society of Professional Journalists gave the Legislature its 2025 "Black Hole Award." |
| Actions taken openly (Open Meetings Act) | A fix for public infrastructure district board meetings left a new loophole (H.B. 17, 2026). | Bills to post PID board disclosures (H.B. 422) and bar secret data-center deals (S.B. 318) died in 2026. |
| A part-time citizen Legislature (45-day session, Art. VI, Sec. 16) | 2018 Amendment C (about 63% yes) let lawmakers call themselves into session with two-thirds for an emergency. At least 17 special sessions are listed from 2018 to 2025. | Gov. Herbert opposed Amendment C: "They can define 'emergency' themselves." Sponsor Brad Wilson said it would "probably be very rarely used." |
| Public notice | Initiative hearing notices left the newspaper (S.B. 43, 2023). Amendment A (passed Nov. 3, 2026) removes the newspaper-publication requirement for amendments. | Amendment D was voided in 2024 partly because its text wasn't published in newspapers. |
| Local voters decide local matters | A handful of landowners can form a new town with no county say (S.B. 258, 2024). Small unincorporated islands join a city with no resident vote (H.B. 457, 2026). | A 2026 county-oversight reform (H.B. 510) failed in the Senate by one vote. |
Sources: the bill case files below; HB477 and its repeal; Deseret News (3/14/2025); KSL on H.B. 69; Daily Herald (3/23/2025); KUER on Amendment C; le.utah.gov sessions list.
Voting-age population through 2008; eligible voters for 2020 and 2024. The two measures are close but not identical.
Sources: 1960/1964 news item via Utah Digital Newspapers (Utah was highest in the nation); Utah Foundation Report 710 (1972–2008; 2008 was "a four-decade low"); UF Election Lab (2020, 2024).
Grades are from each Bill-Tracker case file.
| Bill | Our grade | What it did | How it connects |
|---|---|---|---|
| S.B. 277 (2025) Senate 21–8–0 · House 44–23–8 · Senate concurs 18–6–5 · Signed Mar 27, 2025 | C- | Seven seats became one. S.B. 277 repealed the seven-member State Records Committee, which had heard public records appeals since 1992, and gave those appeals to one director appointed by the governor with Senate consent. | Records appeals moved from a seven-member committee to one appointed director. |
| H.B. 61 Committee 9–0–2 · Signed Mar 23, 2026 | — | Less Detail, No Records. A new GRAMA exemption closes off public records on how the Navajo Trust Fund invests its money — and the Navajo Nation's own annual report gets less detailed too, with no record of tribal consultation before the bill advanced. | New records exemption for the Navajo Trust Fund. |
| H.B. 491 (2023) House Cmte 12–0–2 · Senate Cmte 5–0–3 · Signed Mar 14, 2023 | F | Bait-and-Switch: The Great Salt Lake Bill That Helped Its Own Sponsor. Created the Great Salt Lake Commissioner position and a new GRAMA exemption for the Commissioner's water-related records — added in the Senate substitute Sen. | New records exemption for the Great Salt Lake Commissioner. |
| H.B. 575 (2026) House 67–2–6 · Senate 24–1–4 · Signed Mar 23, 2026 | D | A Gas Tax Cut, and Refinery Numbers Sealed Off. Cut the state gas tax to a flat $0.319 a gallon for the second half of 2026. | Refinery reports made confidential. |
| H.B. 17 House 70–0–5 · Senate 26–0–3 · Signed May 6, 2026 | F | The Loophole That Replaced the Loophole. A rule requiring public infrastructure district board meetings inside their own district looked like a real fix once the old "annual retreat" exception was removed — but what replaced it lets a board meet anywhere in the much larger city or county that created it, with no limit on how often, and nothing that requires anyone to say when they've used it. | Open-meetings fix for PID boards with a new loophole. |
| H.B. 457 House 62–2 · Senate 25–1 · House concurrence 61–6 · Signed Mar 26, 2026 | D | County Islands and the County Auditor. Small unincorporated islands in second-class counties, including Weber, join the surrounding city on July 1, 2027 with no resident vote, unless the county commission exempts them. | Islands join a city with no resident vote. |
| S.B. 258 Senate 29–0–0 · House 71–1–3 · Signed Mar 21, 2024 | D | Municipal Incorporation Amendments. Lets as few as one landowner turn their own land into a brand-new town, no county approval required. | New towns with no county approval. |
| S.B. 43 (2023) House 67-0-8 · Senate 26-0-3 · Signed Mar 20, 2023 | C- | Hearing Notices Leave the Newspaper. Created class A and class B public notices. | Hearing notices leave the newspaper. |
| H.B. 119 (2019) House 64-7-4 (3/5/19); Senate 21-1-7 (3/14/19); House concurred 59-12-4 (3/14/19) · Signed 3/25/2019; effective 5/14/2019 (Chapter 203) | D | The Rewrite: Local Initiatives and Referendums After 2018. H.B. 119 (2019), primary sponsor Rep. | Rewrote local initiative and referendum rules after 2018. |
| S.B. 199 (2023) Senate committee 4-1-1 (2/13/23); Senate 18-6-5 (2nd reading, 2/14/23) and 19-5-5 (3rd reading, 2/17/23); House committee 5-4-2 (2/22/23); House 55-15-5 after a floor amendment (3/1/23); Senate concurred 16-9-4 (3/2/23) · Signed 3/23/2023 | D | Two-Thirds, Then Unanimous: The Land Use Referendum Rule. As introduced, S.B. 199 (2023) made any local land use law passed by a two-thirds vote not referable to voters. | Limited referendums on some local land use laws. |
| H.B. 462 (2022) House 56-18-1 (3/1/22); Senate 24-3-2 (3/3/22); House concurred 61-11-3 (3/3/22) · Signed 3/24/2022 | D | Added on the Floor: The Transit-Area Referendum Limits. H.B. 462 (2022) was a large housing bill: station area plans around transit stops, moderate income housing plans, a Rural Housing Fund and more. | Transit-area land use referendum limits added on the floor. |
| Bill | Our grade | What it did | How it connects |
|---|---|---|---|
| S.B. 318 (2026) No committee hearing · No votes · Died Mar 6, 2026 | A- | No Secret Deals with Data Centers. Would have barred state agencies, cities, towns and counties from signing non-disclosure agreements with prospective data centers of 20 megawatts or more, made such agreements void, required them to be posted online, and let any Utah resident sue. | Would have barred secret deals with data centers. |
| H.B. 422 (2026) House 66-1-8 · Senate committee 5-0-2 · No Senate floor vote · Died Mar 6, 2026 | A | PID Board Disclosures, and a Way to Close a PID. Would have required appointed public infrastructure district board members to file and post conflict-of-interest disclosures on the Utah Public Notice Website, and required a district to dissolve once its debts were paid and its projects handed over. | Would have required PID board disclosures. |
| H.B. 120 (2006) House committee 8-0-3 · House 27-46-2 · Died Feb. 13, 2006 | B | Hold the Law Until the Vote. Would have kept a city or county law from taking effect while a referendum against it was pending, replacing a code sentence that said the law stays in effect until voters repeal it. | Would have paused a local law while its referendum was pending. |
| S.B. 66 (2013) Senate 27-1-1 · House: enacting clause struck, no vote · Died Mar. 14, 2013 | B | Passed the Senate, Never Voted On in the House. Would have kept a challenged city or county law on hold until voters approved it, and required a budget officer's fiscal and legal estimate of repeal plus a public hearing. | Same idea; passed the Senate, never voted on in the House. |
Where each person appears elsewhere in the Hive. Being named here does not mean anyone did anything wrong.
| Who | Why they are here | Other Hive pages |
|---|---|---|
| Stuart Adams | Senate President (R); lost his 2026 primary | Adams Leadership PAC Enforcement Gap |
| Mike Schultz | House Speaker (R) | HD-12 race file House Speaker Leadership PAC Schultz water rights Stratos land |
| Matt MacPherson | Rep. (R); House sponsor of the 2025 GRAMA intent change | HD-26 race file |
| Calvin Musselman | Sen. (R); Senate sponsor of H.B. 242 | Utah Political Watch v. Musselman |
| Jordan Teuscher | Rep. (R); primary sponsor of the party-switch laws and the union law | House profile Checks & Balances PAC |
Tap a card to see what it means.
Posted Nov. 8, 2026.
Utah Constitution Art. I, Sec. 2, Art. I, Sec. 4, Art. I, Sec. 17, Art. IV, Sec. 1, Art. VI, Sec. 1, Art. VI, Sec. 2, Art. VI, Sec. 16; Utah Code 52-4-102; Utah Code 63G-2-102.
1900 amendment notice, Utah Digital Newspapers; Ballotpedia, 1900 vote; Ballotpedia, history; Initiative & Referendum Institute; 1895 convention record, Day 27 and Day 30; Utah Women's History; Deseret (1/29/2020); Deseret (7/11/2024).
League of Women Voters of Utah v. Utah State Legislature, 2024 UT 21.
HB477 (2011); HB1001 (2011 S1); KSL (3/25/2011); KSL (2/19/2025); Deseret (3/14/2025); Daily Herald (3/23/2025); le.utah.gov sessions list; KUER (11/23/2018).
Utah Digital Newspapers (1964–65 item); Utah Foundation Report 710; UF Election Lab.
Deseret (9/25/2024); Utah News Dispatch via Standard-Examiner (11/8/2024).
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · JournalismThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.
Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us
Independent accountability journalism. Public records only. We report; you decide.
We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.
Transparency home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack