The Hive bee sealUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
Transparency · TR 300.29← Transparency home · ← Hive library (every repo)
Transparency · Case File · Statewide

Lost Ideals: What Utah Promised Its Voters

Utah's constitution and laws promise that power belongs to the people, that elections are free and that government works in the open. Here is each promise in its own words, and what has changed.

Statewide

CASE 2026-WGS-04 · Posted Nov. 8, 2026 · Updated Nov. 8, 2026

New to this? Read it in plain words About 500 words, with simple charts.
Transparency pages (33) · tap to open
  1. Transparency docketEvery case file, searchable
  2. Who Gets a Say · plain wordsUtah's primary and map rules, 2018–2026
  3. Holding Power · plain wordsHow the rules kept one party in charge
  4. Selling the Vote · plain wordsThe business of political marketing in Utah
  5. Lost Ideals · plain wordsWhat Utah promised its voters
  6. The Fracture · plain wordsWhy Utahns say no party represents them
  7. It Happened Before · plain wordsUtah controversies and how they ended
  8. The 2026 Amendments · plain wordsAmendments A and B on your ballot
  9. Amendment B: Myth vs. Fact · plain wordsClaims checked against the record
  10. Amendment B QuizTest what you know
  11. Who Sits at the Taxpayers Association's Table · plain wordsIts leaders, lobbyists, sponsors and their money
  12. Weber Housing Authority · plain wordsA commissioner, his wife and the authority that pays their company
  13. What the Privacy Office Can and Can't Do · plain wordsUtah's Chief Privacy Officer
  14. Counting the Jobs · plain wordsJob promises and what was reported
  15. Matt Brower · plain wordsThe board seat that never came up
  16. Ten Days · plain wordsThe Nilson Foundation's 501(c)(3) claim
  17. One Vote, Four Checks · plain wordsS.B. 258 and preliminary municipalities
  18. The Land Counties Can't Zone · plain wordsTrust land and county zoning
  19. SITLA: The Land Nobody Zones · plain wordsWho answers for trust land
  20. Tyson Leaves Eagle Mountain · plain wordsFive years after opening
  21. Behind the Bench · plain wordsJudge and lawyer complaints in Utah
  22. Wrong Room, Right Message · plain wordsA housing adviser in Heber City
  23. Every Weber County Property Tax Increase Since 2019 · plain wordsThe full list
  24. A New Line on the Bill · plain wordsRoy and Riverdale fire annexation
  25. Paying for the Next Station · plain wordsHow Weber Fire District funds growth
  26. Weber County's New Sales Tax · plain wordsA public vote, but no vote by the public
  27. Bills That Did the Opposite · plain wordsBait and switch, 2018 to 2026
  28. The Blank Box · plain wordsThree disclosure forms, one pattern
  29. Utah's Campaign-Finance Enforcement Gap · plain wordsComplaints filed, few penalties
  30. One Lake, Two Money Pots · plain wordsThe Great Salt Lake Trust Council
  31. Wells at the Top · plain wordsPowder Mountain's water
  32. Then vs. Now · plain wordsEarlier plans and later approvals in Ogden Valley
  33. West Haven's 6% Energy Tax · plain wordsA new line on the power bill
Still being checked
Constitution and statute text is quoted from le.utah.gov. Historical quotes are as quoted in the Utah Supreme Court's 2024 opinion or the 1895 convention record. Some news quotes come from page summaries and are being checked word for word.

The short version

71%
Voted yes for initiative and referendum, 1900
1960
First statewide initiative to pass
17+
Special sessions listed, 2018–2025
80%
Adults who voted for president in Utah, 1960 (highest in the nation)

What Utah promised, in its own words

Utah Constitution, Article I, Section 2 (1895)
"All political power is inherent in the people; and all free governments are founded on their authority for their equal protection and benefit, and they have the right to alter or reform their government as the public welfare may require." (le.utah.gov)
Article I, Section 17 (1895)
"All elections shall be free, and no power, civil or military, shall at any time interfere to prevent the free exercise of the right of suffrage." (le.utah.gov)
Article IV, Section 1 (1895)
"Both male and female citizens of this State shall enjoy equally all civil, political and religious rights and privileges." (le.utah.gov)
Open and Public Meetings Act, Utah Code 52-4-102
"The state, its agencies and political subdivisions, exist to aid in the conduct of the people's business... take their actions openly; and conduct their deliberations openly." (le.utah.gov)
Government Records Access and Management Act (GRAMA), Utah Code 63G-2-102
"Promote the public's right of easy and reasonable access to unrestricted public records... favor public access when, in the application of this act, countervailing interests are of equal weight." (le.utah.gov)

At the 1895 convention, delegate Heber Wells said it was "very pertinent to provide that all political power is inherent in the people" (as quoted in the Utah Supreme Court's 2024 opinion). Equal suffrage passed the convention 75–14 on April 5, 1895 (Utah Women's History).

1900: the people's lawmaking power

Utah was the second state, after South Dakota, to give voters initiative and referendum.

Both sides in 1900. For: with adoption, "the people of the State would be rulers of the State, which they were not now" (Kate S. Hilliard, Salt Lake Tribune, Oct. 28, 1900). Against: the amendment would "cause a great departure from our legislative system" (Deseret Evening News, Nov. 3, 1900). Both as quoted in 2024 UT 21.

The promise and what changed

The promiseWhat changedThe pushback
Voters can make laws (Art. VI, Sec. 1)All three 2018 initiatives changed or replaced (H.B. 3001, S.B. 96, S.B. 200). In 2024, lawmakers proposed Amendment D to let them change any initiative.The Utah Supreme Court (July 2024): the people's reform power is "protected from government infringement." Courts voided Amendment D.
Voters can send a law to a vote (referendum)Some local land use laws made not referable (H.B. 462, 2022; S.B. 199, 2023). A referendum is void if lawmakers repeal the law first (H.B. 75, 2020).Referendum drives led lawmakers to repeal laws in 2011, 2020 and 2025.
"Easy and reasonable access" to records (GRAMA)2011 HB477 restricted records access. 2025: the seven-member State Records Committee replaced by one director the governor appoints (S.B. 277); court costs for winning records appeals limited to "bad faith" cases (H.B. 69); university president finalists kept private (S.B. 282). New exemptions in H.B. 61, H.B. 491 and H.B. 575.HB477 repealed March 25, 2011 (House 60–3, Senate 19–5). The Society of Professional Journalists gave the Legislature its 2025 "Black Hole Award."
Actions taken openly (Open Meetings Act)A fix for public infrastructure district board meetings left a new loophole (H.B. 17, 2026).Bills to post PID board disclosures (H.B. 422) and bar secret data-center deals (S.B. 318) died in 2026.
A part-time citizen Legislature (45-day session, Art. VI, Sec. 16)2018 Amendment C (about 63% yes) let lawmakers call themselves into session with two-thirds for an emergency. At least 17 special sessions are listed from 2018 to 2025.Gov. Herbert opposed Amendment C: "They can define 'emergency' themselves." Sponsor Brad Wilson said it would "probably be very rarely used."
Public noticeInitiative hearing notices left the newspaper (S.B. 43, 2023). Amendment A (passed Nov. 3, 2026) removes the newspaper-publication requirement for amendments.Amendment D was voided in 2024 partly because its text wasn't published in newspapers.
Local voters decide local mattersA handful of landowners can form a new town with no county say (S.B. 258, 2024). Small unincorporated islands join a city with no resident vote (H.B. 457, 2026).A 2026 county-oversight reform (H.B. 510) failed in the Senate by one vote.

Sources: the bill case files below; HB477 and its repeal; Deseret News (3/14/2025); KSL on H.B. 69; Daily Herald (3/23/2025); KUER on Amendment C; le.utah.gov sessions list.

Who voted, then and now

Utah turnout for president, share of adults

Voting-age population through 2008; eligible voters for 2020 and 2024. The two measures are close but not identical.

1960
80.1%
1964
nearly 79%
1976
70%
1992
67%
1996
52%
2008
50%
2020
67.2%
2024
64.7%

Sources: 1960/1964 news item via Utah Digital Newspapers (Utah was highest in the nation); Utah Foundation Report 710 (1972–2008; 2008 was "a four-decade low"); UF Election Lab (2020, 2024).

Each side, in its own words

The court (2024). "The people's constitutional right to alter or reform their government is protected from government infringement" (2024 UT 21).
Legislative leaders. On the Amendment D ruling, Senate President Stuart Adams and Speaker Mike Schultz called it "unprecedented and troubling" (Deseret News, 9/25/2024). Later, Schultz: "I made some mistakes, and I'll own that." Adams: "we all can do better" (Utah News Dispatch, 11/8/2024).
Voters' groups. Katharine Biele, League of Women Voters of Utah: "I hope the legislature understands they represent us." Emma Petty Addams, Mormon Women for Ethical Government: "constitutional checks and balances exist for a reason" (Deseret News, 9/25/2024).
A legislator on raising the bar for lawmakers. Rep. Norm Thurston (R) wrote in a public comment on Oct. 9, 2026: "I do agree that the Legislature should also have a higher bar." He said that if Amendment B passed, he would pursue a two-thirds vote for tax increases in both chambers. Amendment B failed.
On records (2011 and 2025). Gov. Herbert on repealing HB477: "It was the right thing to do as a first step to restore public confidence" (KSL). Rep. Stephanie Gricius said H.B. 69 "does not restrict access"; the Utah Media Coalition said it "weakens GRAMA" (KSL, 2/19/2025).

Bills we've graded

Grades are from each Bill-Tracker case file.

BillOur gradeWhat it didHow it connects
S.B. 277 (2025)
Senate 21–8–0 · House 44–23–8 · Senate concurs 18–6–5 · Signed Mar 27, 2025
C-Seven seats became one. S.B. 277 repealed the seven-member State Records Committee, which had heard public records appeals since 1992, and gave those appeals to one director appointed by the governor with Senate consent.Records appeals moved from a seven-member committee to one appointed director.
H.B. 61
Committee 9–0–2 · Signed Mar 23, 2026
—Less Detail, No Records. A new GRAMA exemption closes off public records on how the Navajo Trust Fund invests its money — and the Navajo Nation's own annual report gets less detailed too, with no record of tribal consultation before the bill advanced.New records exemption for the Navajo Trust Fund.
H.B. 491 (2023)
House Cmte 12–0–2 · Senate Cmte 5–0–3 · Signed Mar 14, 2023
FBait-and-Switch: The Great Salt Lake Bill That Helped Its Own Sponsor. Created the Great Salt Lake Commissioner position and a new GRAMA exemption for the Commissioner's water-related records — added in the Senate substitute Sen.New records exemption for the Great Salt Lake Commissioner.
H.B. 575 (2026)
House 67–2–6 · Senate 24–1–4 · Signed Mar 23, 2026
DA Gas Tax Cut, and Refinery Numbers Sealed Off. Cut the state gas tax to a flat $0.319 a gallon for the second half of 2026.Refinery reports made confidential.
H.B. 17
House 70–0–5 · Senate 26–0–3 · Signed May 6, 2026
FThe Loophole That Replaced the Loophole. A rule requiring public infrastructure district board meetings inside their own district looked like a real fix once the old "annual retreat" exception was removed — but what replaced it lets a board meet anywhere in the much larger city or county that created it, with no limit on how often, and nothing that requires anyone to say when they've used it.Open-meetings fix for PID boards with a new loophole.
H.B. 457
House 62–2 · Senate 25–1 · House concurrence 61–6 · Signed Mar 26, 2026
DCounty Islands and the County Auditor. Small unincorporated islands in second-class counties, including Weber, join the surrounding city on July 1, 2027 with no resident vote, unless the county commission exempts them.Islands join a city with no resident vote.
S.B. 258
Senate 29–0–0 · House 71–1–3 · Signed Mar 21, 2024
DMunicipal Incorporation Amendments. Lets as few as one landowner turn their own land into a brand-new town, no county approval required.New towns with no county approval.
S.B. 43 (2023)
House 67-0-8 · Senate 26-0-3 · Signed Mar 20, 2023
C-Hearing Notices Leave the Newspaper. Created class A and class B public notices.Hearing notices leave the newspaper.
H.B. 119 (2019)
House 64-7-4 (3/5/19); Senate 21-1-7 (3/14/19); House concurred 59-12-4 (3/14/19) · Signed 3/25/2019; effective 5/14/2019 (Chapter 203)
DThe Rewrite: Local Initiatives and Referendums After 2018. H.B. 119 (2019), primary sponsor Rep.Rewrote local initiative and referendum rules after 2018.
S.B. 199 (2023)
Senate committee 4-1-1 (2/13/23); Senate 18-6-5 (2nd reading, 2/14/23) and 19-5-5 (3rd reading, 2/17/23); House committee 5-4-2 (2/22/23); House 55-15-5 after a floor amendment (3/1/23); Senate concurred 16-9-4 (3/2/23) · Signed 3/23/2023
DTwo-Thirds, Then Unanimous: The Land Use Referendum Rule. As introduced, S.B. 199 (2023) made any local land use law passed by a two-thirds vote not referable to voters.Limited referendums on some local land use laws.
H.B. 462 (2022)
House 56-18-1 (3/1/22); Senate 24-3-2 (3/3/22); House concurred 61-11-3 (3/3/22) · Signed 3/24/2022
DAdded on the Floor: The Transit-Area Referendum Limits. H.B. 462 (2022) was a large housing bill: station area plans around transit stops, moderate income housing plans, a Rural Housing Fund and more.Transit-area land use referendum limits added on the floor.

Bills that would have widened access, and died

BillOur gradeWhat it didHow it connects
S.B. 318 (2026)
No committee hearing · No votes · Died Mar 6, 2026
A-No Secret Deals with Data Centers. Would have barred state agencies, cities, towns and counties from signing non-disclosure agreements with prospective data centers of 20 megawatts or more, made such agreements void, required them to be posted online, and let any Utah resident sue.Would have barred secret deals with data centers.
H.B. 422 (2026)
House 66-1-8 · Senate committee 5-0-2 · No Senate floor vote · Died Mar 6, 2026
APID Board Disclosures, and a Way to Close a PID. Would have required appointed public infrastructure district board members to file and post conflict-of-interest disclosures on the Utah Public Notice Website, and required a district to dissolve once its debts were paid and its projects handed over.Would have required PID board disclosures.
H.B. 120 (2006)
House committee 8-0-3 · House 27-46-2 · Died Feb. 13, 2006
BHold the Law Until the Vote. Would have kept a city or county law from taking effect while a referendum against it was pending, replacing a code sentence that said the law stays in effect until voters repeal it.Would have paused a local law while its referendum was pending.
S.B. 66 (2013)
Senate 27-1-1 · House: enacting clause struck, no vote · Died Mar. 14, 2013
BPassed the Senate, Never Voted On in the House. Would have kept a challenged city or county law on hold until voters approved it, and required a budget officer's fiscal and legal estimate of repeal plus a public hearing.Same idea; passed the Senate, never voted on in the House.

People in this part

Where each person appears elsewhere in the Hive. Being named here does not mean anyone did anything wrong.

WhoWhy they are hereOther Hive pages
Stuart AdamsSenate President (R); lost his 2026 primaryAdams Leadership PAC
Enforcement Gap
Mike SchultzHouse Speaker (R)HD-12 race file
House Speaker Leadership PAC
Schultz water rights
Stratos land
Matt MacPhersonRep. (R); House sponsor of the 2025 GRAMA intent changeHD-26 race file
Calvin MusselmanSen. (R); Senate sponsor of H.B. 242Utah Political Watch v. Musselman
Jordan TeuscherRep. (R); primary sponsor of the party-switch laws and the union lawHouse profile
Checks & Balances PAC

What the records do not show

Words to know

Tap a card to see what it means.

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Your legislatorsShould changing a voter-passed initiative require a two-thirds vote?
Your legislatorsShould the State Records Committee's seven seats be restored?
The governor's officeHow many records appeals has the new Government Records Office decided, and how many for the public?
Senate President and House SpeakerWhich special sessions since 2018 did the Legislature call itself, and for what emergency?
YourselfRead Article I, Section 2 of the Utah Constitution. What does "inherent in the people" mean to you?

Connected Hive work

Who Gets a SayPart 1 Holding PowerPart 2 Ten Years of Petition LawsBill-Tracker The 2026 AmendmentsTransparency: Amendments A and B The CheckboxTransparency: disclosure redactions Seven Citizens, Then One DirectorThen and NowThe GRAMA GapSurveillance repoTwo Referendums, Zero VotesReferendums repo

Behind this piece

55
Constitution sections, statutes, court opinions, convention records and reports read (estimate)
15
Graded bills connected
90
Searches run (estimate)

Posted Nov. 8, 2026.

Full sources
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

Independent accountability journalism. Public records only. We report; you decide.

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Transparency home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack