Transparency · Conflict of Interest · Weber County
The Checkbox: Who Decides What Voters See
A 2025 state law lets officials whose household includes an at-risk government employee have their employer removed from the public copy of their conflict-of-interest form. Here is the law, how it reached Weber County, and what a records appeals board decided on Oct. 13, 2026.
A 2025 state law, H.B. 504, lets an official or candidate ask that their employer information be removed from the public copy of their conflict-of-interest form if they, or their spouse, are an “at-risk government employee.” It took effect May 7, 2025.
When the request is made, the filing officer “shall redact.” Weber County's records appeals board called that “mandatory language triggered by receipt of a redaction request.” The board's decision does not describe any check of whether the official qualifies. At the Oct. 12, 2026 hearing, the county said it does not check whether an official qualifies, because the statute does not require it. The box was checked, and the county redacted.
On Oct. 12, 2026, the board heard the Hive publisher's appeal over Commissioner Gage Froerer's forms. Its Oct. 13 decision kept his 2026 employer lines redacted and ordered his 2025 lines released, because the 2025 form was filed before the law existed.
Of eight 2026 Weber County forms the Hive compared, three had employer lines redacted: Commissioner Froerer, Commissioner Harvey and County Attorney Allred. County attorneys are a named category in the law. County commissioners are not.
Added Oct. 18, 2026: Froerer's forms have changed over the years. His 2018 House form listed Nordic Valley Land Associates without a percentage; a November 2022 special disclosure, filed after an Ogden Valley resident complained to the county attorney and state auditor, showed a family trust's 16% interest; his 2025 county form listed the company and his 2026 form, filed a week before it was dissolved, did not. His Weber Housing Authority trusteeship was not listed on either county form.
Added Oct. 18, 2026: Under state law the $100 fine and class B misdemeanor apply when an official does not file, or does not correct a form within seven days after notice. Whether a form is accurate is examined only after a written complaint. In the one review the Hive has documented, in 2022, the result was an updated form and no public penalty.
The law still points to Section 63G-2-303 for the at-risk definition. The board noted that section was renumbered in 2026 and “no longer exists.”
May 7, 2025
H.B. 504's redaction rule took effect
3–0
Appeals board vote, Oct. 12, 2026
3 of 8
2026 Weber County forms compared with employer lines redacted
0
Checks of eligibility described in the board's decision
What this page does and does not say
This page reports what the law says, what the county did and what the appeals board decided. It does not say any official acted improperly. The law allows the request, and the board found the county was required to honor it.
What the checkbox is
Elected officials file a conflict-of-interest form so voters can see who pays them and what businesses they are tied to. Since May 7, 2025, part of that form can be removed from the public copy.
Item 1 of the form asks for the official's current and recent employers and a short description of the job. Under the 2025 change, an official whose household includes an at-risk government employee can ask the filing officer to take that information out. This is the law, as quoted in the appeals board's decision:
“(7)(a) In making the disclosure described in Subsection (6)(b) or (h), if a regulated officeholder or regulated officeholder's spouse is an at-risk government employee, as that term is defined in Subsection 63G-2-303(1)(a), the regulated officeholder may request the filing officer to redact from the conflict of interest disclosure: (i) the regulated officeholder's employment information under Subsection (6)(b); and (ii) the regulated officeholder's spouse's name and employment information under Subsection (6)(h).
(b) A filing officer who receives a redaction request under Subsection (7)(a) shall redact the disclosures made under Subsection (6)(b) or (h) before the filing officer makes the conflict of interest disclosure available for public inspection.”
The definition lists named jobs, then adds a general category. The named jobs are peace officers; state and federal judges and court commissioners; military judges; federal and military prosecutors; and “law enforcement officials,” a term that includes county attorneys, district attorneys, the attorney general and city prosecutors (Utah Code 53-5a-311). Sheriffs are peace officers under Utah Code 53-13-103. The last item, the one quoted by the board, covers everyone else:
“(ix) state, federal, or local government employee who, because of the unique nature of the employee's regular work assignments or because of one or more recent credible threats directed to or against the employee, would be at immediate and substantial risk of physical harm if the employee's personal information is disclosed.”
In plain words: a county commissioner is not one of the named jobs. A commissioner could still fit item (ix) if their work or a recent credible threat puts them at real risk of harm. The public copy of the form does not show which part of the definition an official relied on.
The bill's own summary says the request is open to candidates too. H.B. 504 permits “the candidate or officeholder making the disclosure to request the redaction of certain personally identifiable information from the disclosure if the candidate, officeholder, or the candidate's or officeholder's spouse is an at-risk government employee” (H.B. 504 enrolled copy, highlighted provisions). Because the test is about being a government employee, a candidate who does not work for a government would not qualify.
An elected official, a list he is not on, and a box no one checks
Added Oct. 18, 2026. This is the center of the case, step by step, from the law and the Oct. 13, 2026 decision.
He holds a county job because voters elected him. His 2025 form lists his current employer as “Weber County Corp. 2017 to present” and his job as “Weber County Commissioner” (2025 form, Items 1A–1B). The at-risk definition's named categories are other kinds of jobs: peace officers; state and federal judges and court commissioners; military judges; federal and military prosecutors; and “law enforcement officials” as defined in Section 53-5a-311 (Utah Code 63A-19-408(1)(a)(i)–(viii), read Oct. 18, 2026).
County commissioners are not a named category. The only route is the catch-all in item (ix), which the board quoted in finding 6: a “state, federal, or local government employee who, because of the unique nature of the employee's regular work assignments or because of one or more recent credible threats directed to or against the employee, would be at immediate and substantial risk of physical harm if the employee's personal information is disclosed.”
Both routes depend on facts. Item (ix) needs either unusual work duties or recent credible threats. The 2026 form's box asked him to state that he was “an at-risk government employee . . . as that term is defined in Subsection 63G-2-303(1)(a)” (finding 7). It does not ask which route. At the Oct. 12, 2026 hearing, the county said it does not check whether an official qualifies, because the statute does not require it. The box was checked, and the county redacted.
The checkmark decides it. The board found the filing officer had to redact because the law “uses mandatory language triggered by receipt of a redaction request” (finding 8); the law says the filing officer “shall redact.” Separately, the written decision describes no review step. The county, the board and the public do not see what the claim rests on.
What is covered is more than the government job. His county job is already public. The redaction covers the full employer lines, including outside employers. On his 2025 form, those lines included “Rescom, Inc. and or Gage Froerer & Assoc. Inc. 1977-Present.”
How one checkmark decides it
From Utah Code 63A-19-408(1)(a), the Oct. 13, 2026 Decision and Order (findings 6–8) and the county's statement at the Oct. 12 hearing.
flowchart TD
A["Elected by voters county commissioner"] --> B["Not a named job on the at-risk list"]
B --> C["Only route: item ix needs unique duties or recent credible threats"]
C --> D["Box checked no review employer lines blacked out"]
What the records show: The records reviewed do not show which part of the definition was relied on, or whether any threat was reported. Nothing in the law as the board read it, in the form, or in the decision requires anyone to find out.
This is about how the law works
Commissioner Harvey also checked the box on his 2026 form (see Who checked the box). The same steps apply to any official who checks it. Nothing on this page says any official is or is not at risk; the records do not say either way.
How it got here
The checkbox came from H.B. 504 (2025), “Financial and Conflict of Interest Disclosures by Candidates Amendments.”
The primary sponsor was Rep. Lisa Shepherd. The Senate sponsor was Sen. Ronald M. Winterton (both as printed on the enrolled bill). LegiScan also lists Rep. Paul Cutler as a sponsor. Most of the bill was about something else: it requires county, city and special district candidates to file conflict-of-interest forms when they file for office, and it sets rules for filling midterm vacancies. The at-risk redaction was one item in its list of changes.
Vote
Date
Yes
No
Absent
House Government Operations Committee
Feb. 26, 2025
8
0
5
House, third reading
Feb. 28, 2025
65
0
10
Senate Government Operations and Political Subdivisions Committee
Yes votes in blue; the only no votes in dark navy. Committee and floor votes have different numbers of members.
House committee, yes
8
House floor, yes
65
Senate committee, yes
7
Senate floor, yes
26
Senate floor, no
2
House concurrence, yes
71
The bill moved through both chambers with public committee hearings and recorded floor votes, the regular process for a Utah bill.
The Oct. 12 appeal and the Oct. 13 decision
The Hive's publisher, Shauna Miller, asked Weber County for unredacted copies of Commissioner Gage Froerer's 2025 and 2026 conflict-of-interest forms (records request #26-1348). The county said no. She appealed.
From the form to the decision
Dates from the Decision and Order and Froerer's 2025 form.
flowchart TD
A["Jan. 24, 2025 2025 form filed no at-risk option"] --> B["May 7, 2025 H.B. 504 rule takes effect"]
B --> C["2026 form at-risk box filled in"]
C --> D["Records request 26-1348 county denies both unredacted forms"]
D --> E["Oct. 12, 2026 appeals board hearing"]
E --> F["Oct. 13, 2026 decision 2026: redaction upheld 2025: must be released"]
Why the county said no
The county relied on “Utah Code Ann. § 20A-11-1604(7)(a) and Utah Code Ann. § 63A-19-408(1),” which it said “required redaction of information regarding current and previous employment and information regarding other individuals in Commissioner Froerer's household” (Decision, finding 2).
At the hearing, the county said the 2025 form was first posted unredacted, then redacted after the records request “to make them both consistent” with the 2026 form (The Weber County Hive, Oct. 13, 2026).
What the board decided
The board met in closed session twice, for about 40 minutes and then about 15 minutes, and voted 3–0 (The Weber County Hive, Oct. 13, 2026). Its written decision, signed by Chair Tanya Strong and dated Oct. 13, 2026, split the request in two.
Form
Board's finding
Result
2026 form
Froerer “filled in the box, making the request for that information to be redacted” (finding 7). The law “uses mandatory language triggered by receipt of a redaction request” (finding 8).
Redaction upheld
2025 form
Dated Jan. 24, 2025, it “did not give him the option to request redaction” (finding 10). There was “no legal basis for the County to apply new § 20A-11-1604(7) retroactively” (finding 12).
Ordered released
“The County's decision to deny access to Commissioner Froerer's 2025 conflict of interest disclosure is reversed, and the County is ordered to provide an unredacted copy of that record to the Appellant promptly after the period to appeal this order has expired.”Decision and Order, Order paragraph 4 (read the full decision, PDF)
One board member told the publisher, “You make some compelling argument, and I don't disagree with many of the points you're making,” but said the board was bound by the statute (The Weber County Hive, Oct. 13, 2026).
What the county said at the hearing: at the Oct. 12, 2026 hearing, the county said it does not check whether an official qualifies as an at-risk government employee, because the statute does not require it. The box was checked, and the county redacted (as reported by the appellant, who attended the public hearing; see also The Weber County Hive, Oct. 13, 2026).
What the decision does and does not cover: the board ruled on what the law required the county to do once the box was filled in. Separately, the written decision does not describe any review of whether Commissioner Froerer is an at-risk government employee, and the law as quoted does not ask the filing officer to make one.
Why the 2025 form was redacted too
Added Oct. 18, 2026. The county redacted the 2025 form because of the 2026 checkbox, so the two would match. In order:
The 2025 form, dated Jan. 24, 2025, had no at-risk box (finding 10) and was first posted unredacted.
After the 2026 box was checked and the records request came in, the county redacted the 2025 form too, “to make them both consistent,” as the county said at the Oct. 12 hearing (The Weber County Hive, Oct. 13, 2026).
The board found “there was no legal basis for the County to apply new § 20A-11-1604(7) retroactively, so it should not have redacted portions of Commissioner Froerer's 2025 conflict of interest disclosure” (finding 12), and ordered it released.
How the 2025 form came to be redacted, and released
From the Oct. 12, 2026 hearing as reported by the Hive and the Decision and Order, findings 10–12.
flowchart TD
A["2025 form: no at-risk box first posted unredacted"] --> B["2026 box checked, records request county redacts 2025 form too #quot;to make them both consistent#quot;"]
B --> C["Board: no legal basis to apply the law retroactively 2025 form ordered released"]
Appeal rights
The decision lists three paths: ask the state's government records ombudsman to mediate; appeal to the director of the Utah Government Records Office; or file for review in district court. “In most cases, the appeal deadline is 30 days after the date of this order,” and the deadline pauses during mediation (Decision, Appeal Rights Information, page 5).
The 2025 form, now released
These are Items 1A and 1B of Froerer's 2025 Weber Elections Conflict of Interest form, dated Friday, January 24, 2025 — the employer lines the board ordered released. The form has no at-risk checkbox, which matches the board's finding 10.
Item
What the form says
1A Current Employer(s)
“Weber County Corp. 2017 to present” “Rescom, Inc. and or Gage Froerer & Assoc. Inc. 1977-Present”
The form's signature line reads: “I, the regulated officeholder or candidate, believe this form is true and accurate to the best of my knowledge.”
What has been on, and off, his forms over the years
Added Oct. 18, 2026. What Commissioner Froerer's conflict-of-interest forms listed, year by year, as shown in the forms the Hive has read and in news reports.
Date
Form
What was listed
What was not listed
Source
2018
Utah House conflict-of-interest form
Nordic Valley Land Associates, LLC
Its holdings and his share (“It didn’t specify” per UPR)
Item 2A: Nordic Valley Land Assoc. LLC, with six other entities. Item 5A: Weber Basin Water District, Central Weber Sewer District, Weber County Corp. Item 8 (spouse’s employer): “None.”
Weber Housing Authority trusteeship; MIDA and LMSA seats (per the Housing Authority case). The Hive’s Oct. 13 report notes his wife’s professional profile lists her as a property manager at the family businesses.
The 2025 form was read as rendered page images on Oct. 18, 2026. The 2018 form and the November 2022 disclosure were not read directly; what they listed comes from the news reports named. The 2026 items come from the Hive's Oct. 13 report and the Housing Authority case's Item 5A table, not a new reading of the 2026 form. Spouse lines on the 2026 form are covered by the at-risk redaction, so blank spouse lines there are not counted as left off. Earlier House forms (2014, 2016) were not found in the sources read for this update and are not included.
Two points from the records, side by side. The March 2023 handwritten note said he was no longer an owner as of February 2023 (Standard-Examiner). His January 2025 county form still listed Nordic Valley Land Assoc. LLC in Item 2A, which asks for any entity in which he “is an owner or officer, or was an owner or officer during the preceding year.” The form does not say whether that listing was as an owner or an officer. Follow the Deed Case 05 reports the company was managed by two entities that listed Froerer as manager, and that it was dissolved Jan. 20, 2026 (Follow the Deed Case 05).
Key dates, 2018 to 2026
From the news reports, forms and Hive case files listed in the table.
flowchart TD
A["2018 House form lists Nordic Valley Land Associates, no share"] --> B["Aug. 16, 2022 recuses from code-change vote"]
B --> C["Oct. 2022 resident complaint to the state auditor"]
C --> D["Nov. 20, 2022 special disclosure 16% family trust"]
D --> E["Jan. 27, 2023 land transferred for zero dollars"]
E --> F["March 2023 note no longer owner as of February"]
F --> G["Jan. 2025 county form lists the company no Housing Authority"]
G --> H["Jan. 13, 2026 form company not listed employer redacted"]
H --> I["Jan. 20, 2026 company dissolved"]
Board seats and entities not on the county forms
Weber Housing Authority (trustee). Not on his 2025 or 2026 county form. The Authority paid $19,623 to two companies bearing the Froerer name, 2023–2025 (What his own form leaves out; What the payments were).
Military Installation Development Authority (MIDA). Not listed on his disclosures, per the Housing Authority case.
Little Mountain Service Area (LMSA). Not listed on his disclosures, per the Housing Authority case.
Highlander NP Housing, a now-dissolved nonprofit he once directed, registered in the same building as the Housing Authority, and C.K.R. Construction LLC, where his wife holds a role (Who sits where).
What was on the forms matters too: the 2025 form listed his family real estate companies, seven entities in Item 2A and two water and sewer boards, and he filed a special disclosure in 2022 once the question was raised.
What the news reported
Added Oct. 18, 2026. Each article below was opened and read for this update. Oldest first.
Aug. 16, 2022Standard-Examiner (Tim Vandenack), “Weber County officials OK code changes for Nordic Valley ski village.” Commissioners voted 2–0 on code changes, “with Commissioner Gage Froerer recusing himself.” It reported he had been involved in the trust that owns the land “for 20 or so years.”Source: Read the article
Dec. 19, 2022Standard-Examiner (Tim Vandenack), “As Nordic Valley ski village plans edge ahead, Froerer’s involvement scrutinized.” A family trust held a 16% stake in Nordic Valley Land Associates; Froerer said his interest in the trust was 20%, a personal stake of about 3.3%. It said the stake had been public knowledge “at least since 2018.” County Attorney Chris Allred wrote: “The law anticipates that one who has made the disclosure may continue to participate in discussing and voting on the matter.”Source: Read the article
Dec. 26, 2022KSL.com (NewsRadioKSL), “Ski village with homes and commercial space coming to Nordic Valley.” It reported Froerer “did not cast any votes for the project” and “also released a formal disclosure detailing any potential conflicts of interest,” filed with the county on Nov. 20.Source: Read the article
Apr. 4, 2023Standard-Examiner (Tim Vandenack), “Weber County commissioner reports he no longer holds stake in ski village land.” A handwritten note dated March 20 on his disclosure read “Disclosed no longer owner as of February 2023.” A county attorney said state law is “all about disclosure” and does not require recusal.Source: Read the article
June 2023The Salt Lake Tribune (Jacob Scholl), “In Weber County, officials say a commissioner’s financial disclosure was appropriate. Others disagree.” The county attorney’s office said Froerer followed state law: “once a matter is presented before the deciding body, that’s when the obligation is triggered.” A BYU law professor said, “He eventually disclosed, he did recuse, so good on him for that.”Source: Read the article
June 13, 2023Utah Public Radio (Jacob Scholl), “A Weber County commissioner’s former land ownership draws scrutiny.” “NVLA is included in Froerer’s 2018 conflict of interest disclosure when he served in the Utah House as a representative,” without his share. It reported he said “he was one of five people in the trust.” A county attorney said “state law also doesn’t require someone to recuse themselves, as Froerer did,” and that the state auditor’s office said “there is no active investigation and the matter is now considered closed.”Source: Read the article
Oct. 13, 2026The Weber County Hive, “Elected by Voters, Hidden by a Checkbox.” The records appeal over his 2025 and 2026 county forms, and the item-by-item comparison of what the forms list.Source: Read the article
In plain words: the county attorney's office told reporters in 2022 and 2023 that state law required him to disclose the interest, but did not require him to recuse; his recusals were his own choice. Reporters also noted he did recuse from the votes.
No news coverage of H.B. 504 or of at-risk redactions on officials' forms, in Weber County or statewide, was found in searches on Oct. 18, 2026. Searched: “at-risk” government employee conflict of interest redact employer H.B. 504 news; Utah officials conflict of interest forms employer redacted at-risk checkbox (Tribune, Deseret News, KSL); Gage Froerer disclosure 2026.
What happens when a form is incomplete
Added Oct. 18, 2026. The rules as written, then what has happened in practice. This describes the rules and outcomes, not anyone's motives.
The rules as written
The penalty is for not filing or not responding. The top of Froerer's 2025 county form says: “An elected officer who fails to respond to the notice is guilty of a class B misdemeanor and the county clerk must impose a civil fine of $100.” (2025 form, page 1.)
The state law sets the same steps. Utah Code 20A-11-1605 (posted version effective May 7, 2025, read Oct. 18, 2026 through a text copy) calls for a review “Within 60 calendar days” after the filing deadline; notice to an officeholder who did not file or whose form does not meet Section 1604, with a direction to file an amended report; and, for anyone who does not file or amend “within seven calendar days after the day on which the regulated officeholder receives the notice,” a class B misdemeanor and “a civil fine of $100.” The section names the lieutenant governor as the reviewing officer; the Hive's Housing Authority case describes the same steps for county forms.
Accuracy is examined after a written complaint. Under the same section, a “written complaint alleging a violation of Section 20A-11-1604” leads to “notice and an opportunity to be heard” before a decision. In the text read, no separate penalty is listed for a form found to be inaccurate; the listed penalties apply to not filing or not amending within seven days. (Checked from a text copy of the posted section, not page images.)
The checkbox has no review step. The filing officer “shall redact” once the request is made (finding 8). At the Oct. 12, 2026 hearing, the county said it does not check whether an official qualifies, because the statute does not require it.
Disclosure, not recusal. The county attorney's office told reporters the law required disclosure, not recusal (Standard-Examiner, 2023; UPR, 2023). The county's ethics act itself (Utah Code 17-16a) would not load on Oct. 18, 2026, so this page relies on those published statements.
The county act's stronger penalty. Weber County's acknowledgment of the County Officers and Employees Disclosure Act says knowingly and intentionally violating it is a class A misdemeanor and requires removal from office (Housing Authority case).
What has happened in practice
The Hive's Enforcement Gap case found the same path in three Utah cases: question → complaint → review → updated or defended report → no public penalty. For Froerer in 2022, it reported: “Froerer filed an updated disclosure in November 2022. The Weber County Attorney's Office subsequently said the updated disclosure satisfied state law.”
The 2022 Nordic Valley question, start to finish
From the Enforcement Gap case and the news reports above.
flowchart TD
A["Question raised Ogden Valley resident"] --> B["Complaint county attorney and state auditor"]
B --> C["County attorney meets with him"]
C --> D["Updated form Nov. 20, 2022"]
D --> E["Matter closed no public penalty"]
The Hive's Oct. 13 report describes the 2022 county review as the only formal review it cites, and it was about the Nordic Valley disclosure (The Weber County Hive, Oct. 13, 2026). No review of his 2025 or 2026 county forms was found in the sources read for this update.
Where the process worked: he filed a special disclosure in November 2022 and recused from the Nordic Valley votes on the record; the county attorney and state auditor responded to the complaint; and in 2026 the appeals board heard the records appeal in public and ordered the 2025 employer lines released.
Who checked the box in Weber County
The Hive compared the 2026 conflict-of-interest forms of eight Weber County elected officials posted by the county (as reported in The Weber County Hive, Oct. 13, 2026).
Official
Job named on the at-risk list?
2026 employer line
Sheriff Arbon
Yes — peace officer
Shown in full
County Attorney Allred
Yes — county attorney
Redacted
Commissioner Froerer
No
Redacted
Commissioner Harvey
No
Redacted
Commissioner Bolos
No
Shown in full
Assessor Preisler
No
Shown in full
Recorder Rahimzadegan
No
Shown in full
Treasurer Jensen
No
Shown in full
2026 employer lines, eight Weber County officials
From the comparison above.
Shown in full
5 of 8 forms
Redacted
3 of 8 forms
County Attorney Allred's redaction matches a named category: county attorneys are “law enforcement officials” under Utah Code 53-5a-311.
Sheriff Arbon holds a named job (sheriffs are peace officers) and chose not to redact.
Commissioners Froerer and Harvey hold a job that is not a named category. Item (ix) could still apply; the public forms do not say.
Commissioner Harvey's 2025 form, dated Jan. 2, 2025, showed “Weber County” and “Weber County Commissioner – seat C” with nothing removed. That form, like Froerer's, was filed before the law took effect.
Fair reading
Checking the box is allowed by law. Not checking it is also allowed. Nothing on this page says any official acted improperly; it shows where the box was used and what the public copy no longer shows.
The same information elsewhere
Froerer also sits as a trustee of the Weber Basin Water Conservancy District, which posts its own trustee conflict-of-interest forms.
His “Annual Trustee Conflict of Interest Disclosure,” completed Jan. 12, 2026, lists his employer as “Weber County Corp” with the job “County Commissioner,” and lists real estate entities described as “Real estate brokerage and management.” Nothing on it is redacted, and it has no at-risk box (Weber Basin Water Conservancy District, posted form).
At the hearing, the county said the water district “probably did not get a form” claiming at-risk status (The Weber County Hive, Oct. 13, 2026).
Why it matters: the same employer information for the same official, from the same month, is redacted on one government's website and posted in full on another's. The redaction law applies to the filing officer who receives the request.
How these forms are checked
The only person who fills out a conflict-of-interest form is the official it describes. Here is what happens to the at-risk box after the form is turned in.
The path of a checked box
From Utah Code 20A-11-1604(7), the Oct. 13, 2026 Decision and Order, and Utah Code 20A-11-1605.
flowchart TD
A["The official fills out and signs the form"] --> B["The official checks the at-risk box"]
B --> C["Filing officer #quot;shall redact#quot;"]
C --> D["The public sees blacked-out employer lines"]
D --> E["Only path to review: a records request and an appeal"]
The official signs; no one else confirms. The form asks the official to state that it is “true and accurate to the best of” their knowledge (Utah Code 20A-11-1604; the same words appear on Froerer's 2025 form).
The review checks that forms were filed, not whether they are right. The filing officer reviews whether each required person filed and whether the form has the required information (Utah Code 20A-11-1605).
The box triggers a duty, not a review. The appeals board found the filing officer had to redact because the law “uses mandatory language triggered by receipt of a redaction request” (Decision, finding 8). The decision does not describe a step where anyone checks eligibility, and at the Oct. 12, 2026 hearing the county said it does not check whether an official qualifies, because the statute does not require it.
Accuracy is examined only after a complaint. A written complaint leads to notice and a hearing before the filing officer decides whether there was a violation (Utah Code 20A-11-1605). The Hive's Weber Housing Authority case walks through this in more detail.
The out-of-date cross-reference
The checkbox law borrows its definition of “at-risk government employee” from another part of the code. That other part moved.
Where the definition points
From the Decision and Order, finding 3, and H.B. 450 (2026).
flowchart TD
A["Checkbox law 20A-11-1604(7)(a)"] -->|"still points to"| B["Section 63G-2-303 #quot;no longer exists#quot;"]
B -->|"renumbered May 6, 2026"| C["Section 63A-19-408 same definition"]
At the Oct. 12, 2026 hearing, the appellant told the board she could not find the section the law cites for the at-risk definition, Section 63G-2-303. The board's written decision explains why. The board wrote: “Section 63A-19-408 was renumbered from 63G-2-303 as of May 6, 2026, but it appears that the Legislature has not yet updated § 20A-11-1604(7)(a) to reflect that numbering change; § 20A-11-1604(7)(a) still refers to § 63G-2-303, which no longer exists. The applicable portions of § 63A-19-408 have remained the same at all times relevant to this appeal” (Decision, finding 3).
Froerer's 2026 form uses the old reference too. The board's finding 7 says the form's box stated he was “an at-risk government employee . . . as that term is defined in Subsection 63G-2-303(1)(a).”
Because the wording of the definition stayed the same, the board quoted and applied the definition as it now appears in Section 63A-19-408(1) (“formerly found in § 63G-2-303(1)”, finding 6). The out-of-date number did not change the outcome: the board upheld the 2026 redaction.
In plain words: it is like a sign that gives an old street address. The building moved, the people inside did not change, and the board read the law as meaning the new address.
Where the move came from. The renumbering was done by H.B. 450 (2026), “Data Privacy Amendments” — primary sponsor Rep. David Shallenberger, Senate sponsor Sen. Kirk A. Cullimore, signed March 19, 2026 (LegiScan). One earlier draft, the 5th Substitute, also updated the checkbox law to point to the new section. The enrolled (final) copy's list of amended sections, read Oct. 17, 2026, does not include 20A-11-1604. The record read for this page does not say why that change was dropped.
What this means for voters
The form is still filed. Every official in the comparison filed a 2026 form. What changes with the box is how much of Item 1 the public copy shows.
The rule is the same for everyone who qualifies. The law applies to officials and candidates whose household includes an at-risk government employee, in every county and city covered.
Some information can still be found. Other filings, such as business entity listings on the same form or forms for other boards, may still show it. The Weber Basin trustee form is one example.
Old forms are covered by old rules. The board found the law cannot be applied to forms filed before May 7, 2025.
Changes to the law are up to the Legislature. The appeals board said it was bound by the statute as written.
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
These are questions any reader can ask at a public meeting or by contacting the office.
Weber County Clerk/Auditor and elections officeWhen an official checks the at-risk box, is any record kept of which part of the definition they relied on? Is the redaction reviewed again each year?
Weber County CommissionWould the commission support a county policy that explains publicly, without personal details, which category an official is relying on when they redact?
Lt. Governor's elections officeDoes the state give county and city filing officers any guidance on the at-risk box, and does it apply the same rule to statewide and legislative forms?
Your state legislatorsShould the checkbox law be updated to point to Section 63A-19-408? Should a filing officer be able to ask for a short statement of the basis for a redaction?
Utah Government Records OfficeHow have records appeals involving redacted conflict-of-interest forms been decided elsewhere in the state?
Your state legislators (added Oct. 18, 2026)Should elected officials be able to use the at-risk redaction, and if so, who should confirm the risk?
Your state legislators (added Oct. 18, 2026)Why can employer lines, the purpose of the form, be redacted?
Your state legislators (added Oct. 18, 2026)When will the out-of-date section number in 20A-11-1604(7)(a) be corrected?
Your state legislators (added Oct. 18, 2026)The $100 fine and class B misdemeanor apply when a form is not filed or not corrected after notice. Should there also be a consequence when a filed form is later shown to leave out a board seat or business interest?
Your state legislators (added Oct. 18, 2026)Should filing officers compare conflict-of-interest forms against public records, such as corporate filings and board rosters, instead of waiting for a written complaint?
Updates since Oct. 12
Oct. 13, 2026The Weber County GRAMA Appeals Board issued its written Decision and Order (dated Oct. 13, 2026, signed by Chair Tanya Strong): 2026 redaction upheld; 2025 redaction reversed, with release after the appeal period.Source: Decision and Order, appeal re: GRAMA request #26-1348 (PDF)
Oct. 17, 2026 (Hive records check)The current state copy of Section 63A-19-408 shows it was “Renumbered and Amended by Chapter 202, 2026 General Session,” effective May 6, 2026. The enrolled copy of H.B. 450 (2026) does not list 20A-11-1604 among the sections it amends, which matches the board's finding that the cross-reference was not updated.Source: Utah Code 63A-19-408; H.B. 450 enrolled copy
Oct. 18, 2026: searches again found no outside news coverage of the hearing or of at-risk redactions statewide; earlier news on Froerer's disclosures (2022–2023) is now in What the news reported.
No outside news coverage of the Weber County hearing, and no 2027 bill file or interim committee item on 20A-11-1604 or 63A-19-408, was found in searches on Oct. 17, 2026. Searched: “at-risk government employee” conflict of interest redaction 2026; Weber County Froerer conflict of interest form GRAMA appeal; Utah interim committee 2026 conflict of interest 20A-11-1604 redaction 2027; “63A-19-408” at-risk; Utah officials redact employer at-risk checkbox news; Weber County GRAMA appeals board October 2026.
Words to know
Tap a card to see what it means.
Connected Hive work
People named on this page and where else they appear: Commissioner Gage Froerer is the official whose forms were appealed; his board seats and the Housing Authority payments are in the Weber Housing Authority case; the 2022 Nordic Valley disclosure review is in the Enforcement Gap case; the land and entity records are in Follow the Deed Case 05. Commissioner Harvey also checked the at-risk box in 2026. Rep. Lisa Shepherd was H.B. 504's primary sponsor. Chair Tanya Strong signed the decision.
Added Nov. 10, 2026: Commissioner Gage Froerer moved to approve the Winston Park contract and its $7,500-per-home park donation on Aug. 20, 2024. At the Nov. 2, 2026 work session, he said the money should also be able to pay for roads. That case file also lists his seat on the Little Mountain Service Area board, the West Weber sewer district, which his 2025 and 2026 disclosure forms don't list. See $7,500 a Home: Who Gets the West Weber Parks Money? (PIDS-Utah PD 200.11).
Primary records read page by page (decision, 2025 form)
8
2026 county forms compared
7
State code sections and bill copies opened
1
Water district form checked
6
Searches run for updates (estimate)
3
Vote records checked
6
News articles opened and read (added Oct. 18)
3
State code sections opened Oct. 18 (one would not load)
8
Searches run for the Oct. 18 update (estimate)
3
Hive case files reused (Housing Authority, Enforcement Gap, Follow the Deed)
Posted Oct. 17, 2026. Updated Oct. 17, 2026: first version, with the Oct. 13 decision and the released 2025 form. No earlier facts changed.
Updated Oct. 18, 2026: added “An elected official, a list he is not on, and a box no one checks,” why the 2025 form was redacted too, a year-by-year table of what his forms listed, what the news reported, and what happens when a form is incomplete; added the county's statement at the Oct. 12 hearing that it does not check whether an official qualifies; new words, questions and sources. No earlier facts or figures changed.
Sources
Open every source (tap)
Primary records
Weber County GRAMA Appeals Board, Decision and Order, Shauna Miller v. Weber County, appeal re: GRAMA request #26-1348; hearing Oct. 12, 2026; signed by Chair Tanya Strong, dated Oct. 13, 2026 (5 pages, read as rendered pages).
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism
The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.