Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerLegislative docketMaster index

Bill Tracker · Reference file · Initiatives & referendums

Ten Years of Petition Laws, 2016–2026

How Utah's rules for citizen initiatives and referendums changed, law by law.

Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

  • From 2016 to 2026 we found 35 laws that changed how Utahns use initiatives and referendums. 30 took effect (some only for a time), 2 were repeals that ended a pending referendum, 1 never took effect, 1 (Amendment D) was voided by the courts, and 1 (Amendment B) is on the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot.
  • By what they did: 10 added requirements, 3 removed requirements, 20 were mixed, and the 2 repeals changed no process rule. 7 apply to local measures, 11 to statewide measures and 17 to both.
  • The 30 laws that took effect average 1.98 (C) on the Hive's rubric. None got an A or an F. The lowest grade among them is D. Two repeals that ended referendums, H.B. 185 (2020) and H.B. 2001 (2025), got an F.
  • 2016 and 2017 were the highest years (C+). 2023 was the lowest year among those with laws in effect (1.65, C−).
  • H.B. 32 (2026) requires online training for anyone gathering signatures, rejects packets from untrained gatherers, and starting July 1, 2027 tells signers whether their signature counted. Grade: C+.

How grades work. A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place.

Overall = the average of Power, Transparency, Financial accountability and Community impact (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0; Environmental is N/A and left out); letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+.

Four grades on this page are copied as published in The Rules Keep Changing (Referendum docket): H.B. 119 (2019), H.B. 218 (2022), H.B. 38 (2023) and S.B. 199 (2023). H.B. 185 (2020) is graded as published in the Hive's Bill-Tracker case file on S.B. 2001 and H.B. 185, and H.B. 2001 (2025), which did the same thing, gets the same grades. Published grades stand. For the averages, those published letters are counted as D = 1.0, C = 2.0, C− = 1.75 and F = 0, so the in-effect average here is 1.98 (C); all 35 together average 1.84 (C).

On Oct. 19, 2026, four grades were tightened after a check against the rubric's own words: H.B. 462 (Transparency C → D), H.B. 75 (Power C → F), H.B. 242 (Transparency B → D) and S.B. 43 (Financial C → D). The reason is in each law's grade details.

Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to each bill's own summary and text. They are not legal conclusions.

The big counts

35
laws, 2016–2026
30
took effect
2
repeals that ended a referendum
1
never took effect
1
voided by the courts
1
on the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot
10
added requirements
3
removed requirements
20
mixed
1.98
average grade of laws in effect (C)

Grade count, all 35: B− 4 · C+ 11 · C 8 · C− 6 · D 3 · D− 1. No A. Effect labels describe the change, not a judgment: "adds requirements" means a new step, limit, threshold or condition for citizens or sponsors, or less that can be referred; "removes requirements" means a step or limit dropped, or wider access; "mixed" means some of both, or mainly procedural.

Helps, hinders or neutral

Each law's label comes straight from its grade on our rubric: helps = B− or higher, neutral = C−, C or C+ (about the same as before), hinders = D+ or lower. The label describes the effect on citizens' use of initiatives and referendums. It is not a statement about anyone's intent.

Helps

4 of 35B− or higher: more access or more information for citizens
2016H.B. 10
B−
2017S.B. 69
B−
2024H.B. 79
B−
2024S.B. 4003
B−

Hinders

6 of 35D+ or lower: a public check weakened, or a referendum ended
2019H.B. 119
D
2020H.B. 185
F
2022H.B. 462
D
2023S.B. 199
D
2024S.J.R. 401
(Amendment D)
D−
2025H.B. 2001
F

Neutral

25 of 35C−, C or C+: about the same as before
2016H.B. 198
C+
2017H.B. 255
C+
2019H.B. 133
C−
2019H.B. 145
C
2019H.B. 195
C
2019S.B. 151
C+
2020H.B. 75
C−
2020S.B. 47
C+
2020S.B. 143
C
2021H.B. 23
C+
2021H.B. 136
C−
2021H.B. 211
C
2022S.B. 38
C+
2022H.B. 218
C
2023H.B. 38
C−
2023H.B. 68
C
2023H.B. 69
C
2023S.B. 43
C−
2024S.B. 100
C+
2024S.B. 107
C+
2024S.B. 4002
C
2025S.B. 73
C+
2025S.J.R. 2
(Amendment B)
C−
2026H.B. 242
C+
2026H.B. 32
C+

Use the Effect filter in the searchable table to see the full record for each group.

When it widened, when it tightened

This lines up what citizens and courts did with what lawmakers passed next. We say "stated" only when a sponsor, legislative leaders or the bill's own effect ties a law to a citizen measure, and "timing only" when just the dates line up. We do not guess at anyone's reasons.

When it widened. The laws graded "helps": H.B. 10 (2016), S.B. 69 (2017), H.B. 79 (2024), and S.B. 4003 (2024), which never took effect. Two more opened access without reaching a B: S.B. 107 (2024) dropped the gatherer residency rule, and S.B. 100 (2024) opened some revenue-bond decisions to referendum.

When it tightened. All six "hinders" grades are from 2019 or later. Four came within weeks or months of citizens winning something: H.B. 119 (the session after the 2018 votes), H.B. 185 (the day a referendum qualified), Amendment D (six weeks after the Prop 4 ruling) and H.B. 2001 (after a referendum qualified). For S.B. 199, the sponsor gave a general reason: that the referendum process was "being weaponized to hurt developers and cities." For H.B. 462 we found only timing, no stated link.

2018

Six initiatives gathering signatures, then three pass

Citizens and courts

While six initiatives were gathering signatures, the Utah Patients Coalition submitted medical cannabis signatures on April 16, 2018 (ULCT Board minutes, April 25, 2018 (PDF page 5)). On May 29, 2018, the Lieutenant Governor declared Props 2, 3 and 4 "Sufficient" for the ballot; the Direct Primary Election initiative was declared "Insufficient" (Lt. Governor, 2018 ballot initiative results, May 29, 2018). Count My Vote stayed off the ballot after the Keep My Voice signature-removal campaign (KUER, Aug. 24, 2018). On Nov. 6, voters passed Props 2, 3 and 4, and Holladay voters rejected the old Cottonwood Mall development by referendum, "with 58 percent against" (KSL, Nov. 28, 2018).

What lawmakers did next

Feb.–March 2018: H.B. 471 (Daw), to delay when voter-approved initiatives take effect, passed the House and died in the Senate, as did H.B. 225 (H.B. 471 (2018) bill page; H.B. 225 (2018) bill page). Dec. 3, 2018: H.B. 3001 replaced Prop 2 in a special session (NORML, Dec. 6, 2018). Feb. 11, 2019: S.B. 96 changed Prop 3 (Ballotpedia News, Feb. 12, 2019). Then the 2019 session passed five petition laws: H.B. 119, H.B. 133, H.B. 145, H.B. 195 and S.B. 151.

H.B. 119 D H.B. 133 C− H.B. 145 C H.B. 195 C S.B. 151 C+

2020

The food-tax referendum

Citizens and courts

About 152,000 signatures were filed against S.B. 2001 (2019) on Jan. 21, 2020, and the referendum qualified Jan. 28 (Ballotpedia News, Jan. 29, 2020).

What lawmakers did next

Jan. 28, 2020, the same day: H.B. 185 repealed S.B. 2001, and the referendum did not go on the ballot (Ballotpedia News, Jan. 29, 2020; KUER, Jan. 2020). Later that session, H.B. 75 wrote into law that "a referendum petition is void if the Legislature repeals the proposed law."

H.B. 185 F H.B. 75 C−

2018–2023

Local land-use referendums

Citizens and courts

Holladay, 2018 (KSL, Nov. 28, 2018); Coalville, where a rezoning referendum qualified in February 2020 (KSL, Feb. 2020). In 2023, Mountain Green residents filed a referendum on a Morgan County rezone; the newspaper tied the filing to S.B. 199 and reported the commission vote was 4–1 (Morgan County News, May 15, 2023). S.B. 199's unanimous-vote rule, as passed, applies to a "municipal land use law." The code section it points to for that term (20A-7-101) does not define it, so whether the rule reaches county votes is unsettled (Justia, 2023 and 2025 copies of 20A-7-101).

What lawmakers did next

2022: H.B. 462 made transit-area land-use laws passed by a two-thirds council vote not referable, and raised the signatures needed for the others. 2023: S.B. 199, as introduced, would have done the same for any land-use law passed by a two-thirds vote; a House floor amendment on March 1 narrowed it to a "municipal land use law" passed "by a unanimous vote of the local legislative body."

H.B. 462 D S.B. 199 D

2024

The Prop 4 ruling and Amendment D

Citizens and courts

July 11, 2024: the Utah Supreme Court ruled that the Legislature's power to change certain initiatives has limits (Utah News Dispatch, Oct. 24, 2024).

What lawmakers did next

Aug. 21, 2024, six weeks later: the Legislature put Amendment D (S.J.R. 401) on the ballot (S.J.R. 401 (2024) bill page). A judge voided it Sept. 12, 2024, and the Utah Supreme Court upheld that (Utah News Dispatch, Oct. 24, 2024), for two reasons: the required newspaper notice was not published, and the ballot language was misleading (Hive, The Amendments on Your Ballot, Part 1). The next year, the Legislature passed Amendment A (H.J.R. 10, 2025), which would remove that newspaper rule; it is on the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot.

S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) D− S.B. 4002 C S.B. 4003 B−

2025

Amendment B and the union referendum

Citizens and courts

About 320,000 signatures were submitted against H.B. 267, the public-union law, in April 2025; 251,590 were verified, well over the 140,748 needed, and the referendum qualified for the 2026 ballot (Deseret News, April 16, 2025; Ballotpedia News, June 25, 2025; Deseret News, June 21, 2025).

What lawmakers did next

Jan.–March 2025: S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) passed; similar resolutions had failed in 2023 and 2024 (KUER, Jan. 29, 2025; Ballotpedia News, March 10, 2025). Dec. 9, 2025: H.B. 2001 repealed H.B. 267, and the referendum ended (Ballotpedia News, Dec. 11, 2025).

S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) C− H.B. 2001 F

2026

The Prop 4 repeal initiative

Citizens and courts

Feb. 2026: the Prop 4 repeal initiative, a citizen initiative backed by the state GOP chairman's committee, filed more than 200,000 signatures, and Better Boundaries ran a signature-removal drive (Ballotpedia News, Feb. 18, 2026). April 30, 2026: the Lieutenant Governor found the petition short, meeting the threshold in 24 of the 26 Senate districts needed (KPCW, May 1, 2026).

What lawmakers did next

March 6, 2026, at about 10:56 p.m.: the Senate adopted a substitute of H.B. 242, proposed by Sen. Brady Brammer, that bans signature-removal requests mailed with prepaid postage (the substitute was posted the night before). It passed the Senate 21–7 and the House 57–12, and Gov. Cox signed it the next morning (KPCW, March 10, 2026). H.B. 32 was signed March 23.

H.B. 242 C+ H.B. 32 C+

How they stack

Most of these laws build on earlier ones. Each chain below follows one part of the process in order, with each law's grade and label.

Local land-use referendums

  1. 2016 H.B. 10 B− Helps
    widened "local law" so residents can refer more kinds of local action
  2. 2019 H.B. 119 D Hinders
    added a step to decide whether a measure is "legally referable to voters," and land-use rules
  3. 2021 H.B. 23 C+ Neutral
    changed the definition of a land-use law and same-year ballot timing
  4. 2022 H.B. 462 D Hinders
    some transit-area land-use laws not referable after a two-thirds council vote; higher signature counts for the rest
  5. 2023 S.B. 199 D Hinders
    introduced as two-thirds for any land-use law; passed as "municipal" land-use laws not referable after a unanimous vote
  6. 2024 S.B. 100 C+ Neutral
    opened some revenue-bond decisions to local referendum

Where it ended up: It started wider in 2016. Since 2019, three of these laws (H.B. 119, H.B. 462 and S.B. 199) set conditions that keep some land-use laws off the ballot. S.B. 100 added a kind of decision that is not a land-use law.

Repeal ends the referendum

  1. 2020 H.B. 185 F Hinders
    repealed the food-tax law the day its referendum qualified (about 152,000 signatures)
  2. 2020 H.B. 75 C− Neutral
    wrote it into law: a referendum petition "is void if the Legislature repeals the proposed law"; also added a temporary stay
  3. 2025 H.B. 2001 F Hinders
    repealed the union law; the referendum with more than 320,000 signatures ended

Where it ended up: Twice, referendums that had qualified ended without a vote. Each repeal got an F. The rule in between, H.B. 75, gets a Power F for the same reason; it lands at C− overall because it also added a temporary stay.

Signature gatherers

  1. 2019 H.B. 145 C Neutral
    new crimes, including paying for a referendum signature or its removal
  2. 2021 H.B. 136 C− Neutral
    gatherer rules with penalties; no per-signature pay
  3. 2024 S.B. 107 C+ Neutral
    dropped the in-state residency rule for gatherers
  4. 2026 H.B. 32 C+ Neutral
    online training before gathering; packets from untrained gatherers rejected; kept hourly-only pay

Where it ended up: Each round added rules for gatherers except 2024, which removed one.

Taking your signature back

  1. 2019 H.B. 145 C Neutral
    changed the form for removing a signature
  2. 2021 H.B. 211 C Neutral
    made state and local forms and steps the same, including removals
  3. 2023 H.B. 68 C Neutral
    put the rules for gathering and removing signatures in one place
  4. 2024 H.B. 79 B− Helps
    added a way for people with a disability to sign or remove a signature
  5. 2026 H.B. 242 C+ Neutral
    rules for people who gather removals: badges, a notice, hourly pay, no prepaid postage

Where it ended up: Removal rules grew from one form in 2019 to their own set of gatherer rules in 2026.

Tax and money initiatives

  1. 2017 H.B. 255 C+ Neutral
    the percentage of a proposed tax increase must be shown on the petition and in voter materials
  2. 2019 S.B. 151 C+ Neutral
    applications must state "funding sources for the proposed law"
  3. 2020 S.B. 143 C Neutral
    changed the fiscal impact statement
  4. 2025 S.B. 73 C+ Neutral
    the application and fiscal statement must say how a proposed law is funded
  5. 2025 S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) C− Neutral
    would require 60% to pass a tax initiative; on the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot

Where it ended up: The first four changed what voters are told about cost. Amendment B would change the vote needed to pass.

The Legislature and voter-passed laws

  1. 2019 H.B. 133 C− Neutral
    changed when a law passed by statewide initiative takes effect
  2. 2019 H.B. 195 C Neutral
    thresholds based on active voters; no "substantially similar" initiative within two years
  3. 2024 S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) D− Hinders
    the Legislature's power to amend or repeal voter-passed laws; voided by the courts
  4. 2024 S.B. 4003 B− Helps
    would have extended the referendum deadline from 40 to 60 days; tied to Amendment D, never took effect

Where it ended up: The biggest change in this chain, Amendment D, was voided, and the one piece that would have given citizens more time went with it.

What voters are told

  1. 2016 H.B. 198 C+ Neutral
    rules for arguments for and against ballot measures
  2. 2017 S.B. 69 B− Helps
    voters must be told about local ballot measures
  3. 2022 S.B. 38 C+ Neutral
    a short ballot title and summary replaced the long title
  4. 2023 H.B. 69 C Neutral
    dropped the separate ballot measure insert when the same information is on the ballot
  5. 2023 S.B. 43 C− Neutral
    pre-circulation hearing notices for initiatives moved from the newspaper to class A notice
  6. 2025 Amendment A (H.J.R. 10) Not graded here
    on the Nov. 3, 2026 ballot: would remove the Constitution's rule that proposed amendments be printed in a newspaper in every county, and let the Legislature set the method by statute

Where it ended up: S.B. 43 moved initiative hearing notices out of the newspaper by statute in 2023. Amendment A would make the same kind of move for constitutional amendments, in the Constitution itself. In 2024, the missing newspaper notice was one of the two reasons the Utah Supreme Court gave for voiding Amendment D. Amendment A is not one of the 35 petition laws and is not graded here; see The Amendments on Your Ballot, Part 1.

How the repeal chain works

From the bills and the Ballotpedia News reports linked in the timeline.

flowchart TD
  A["Citizens gather signatures
against a new law"] --> B["Referendum qualifies"] B --> C["Legislature repeals the law
(H.B. 185 in 2020, H.B. 2001 in 2025)"] C --> D["H.B. 75 rule: the petition
is void"] D --> E["No vote is held"]

Who brought these changes forward

Every primary and floor sponsor of the 35 laws, from le.utah.gov bill pages. Most routine changes came from different lawmakers. These names came up two or more times:

LawmakerCountLaws (role, grade)
Jordan D. Teuscher6H.B. 136 (2021, primary) C−; H.B. 218 (2022, primary) C; S.B. 107 (2024, floor) C+; S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) (2024, floor) D−; S.B. 4002 (2024, floor) C; H.B. 2001 (2025, primary) F
Curtis S. Bramble5H.B. 255 (2017, floor) C+; H.B. 119 (2019, floor) D; H.B. 133 (2019, floor) C−; H.B. 145 (2019, floor) C; H.B. 79 (2024, floor) B−
Norman K. Thurston4H.B. 145 (2019, primary) C; H.B. 75 (2020, primary) C−; H.B. 211 (2021, primary) C; S.B. 43 (2023, floor) C−
Calvin R. Musselman3H.B. 38 (2023, primary) C−; H.B. 69 (2023, primary) C; H.B. 242 (2026, floor) C+
Deidre M. Henderson3S.B. 151 (2019, primary) C+; H.B. 75 (2020, floor) C−; S.B. 143 (2020, primary) C
Jason B. Kyle3S.B. 4003 (2024, floor) B−; S.B. 73 (2025, floor) C+; S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) (2025, floor) C−
Kirk A. Cullimore3S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) (2024, primary) D−; S.B. 4003 (2024, primary) B−; H.B. 2001 (2025, floor) F
A. Cory Maloy2S.B. 69 (2017, floor) B−; S.B. 151 (2019, floor) C+
Brad M. Daw2H.B. 119 (2019, primary) D; H.B. 133 (2019, primary) C−
Daniel McCay2H.B. 255 (2017, primary) C+; H.B. 195 (2019, floor) C
David G. Buxton2H.B. 38 (2023, floor) C−; H.B. 69 (2023, floor) C
Jacob L. Anderegg2S.B. 69 (2017, primary) B−; H.B. 462 (2022, floor) D
Jerry W. Stevenson2H.B. 136 (2021, floor) C−; H.B. 218 (2022, floor) C
Lincoln Fillmore2S.B. 73 (2025, primary) C+; S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) (2025, primary) C−

Who sponsored the six that hinder

Rep. Jordan Teuscher and Sen. Kirk Cullimore sponsored two of the six together, Amendment D and H.B. 2001. They were also the sponsors of H.B. 267 (2025), the union law that H.B. 2001 repealed to end the referendum against it (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2025). Deidre Henderson sponsored three of the 35 as a state senator; she is now Lieutenant Governor, the office that oversees petitions statewide. A sponsorship is public record; it does not tell you why a lawmaker carried a bill.

Petition forgery allegations and signature safeguards

These cases are about who actually signed, who swore they gathered the signatures, and how gatherers were paid; none shows fraud in an election result. We have not verified each defendant's court outcome, and "not verified" does not mean a case is still pending. The state's 2026 Candidate Manual says more than 20 people have faced charges and pleaded guilty to felonies and misdemeanors tied to signature gathering in recent years, mostly for fraud and forgery, without naming them (2026 Candidate Manual, p. 18).

WhenWhat happenedPetitionStatus
Charged April 5, 202413 people charged over signature gathering for the 2023 2nd District special election. Charging documents allege Nevada residents gathered signatures while Utah required gatherers to live here, that petitions were turned in under Utah residents' names, and that a crew member was told to forge signatures "because they would get paid per signature." The company, Battleground USA LLC, is solely owned by one of those charged (KSL, April 5, 2024). Timothy Mooney, who signed contracts with gatherers in that effort, was charged separately before the 13 were.CandidateIndividual outcomes not verified here
Charged March 2025The Attorney General charged 11 people over 2024 candidate petitions; five were identified as Gathering Inc. employees. In one case "only 84 signatures matched" out of 2,243. No company was charged (Utah News Dispatch, March 11, 2025).CandidateIndividual outcomes not verified here
Feb. 2026Utah County Clerk Aaron Davidson turned petition packets over to the county attorney; the Tribune reported 27 packets with hundreds of signatures flagged as possibly falsified, and more than 90% of signatures on the suspect packets were rejected. The campaign had ended its contract with the gatherers in December 2025 (Salt Lake Tribune, Feb. 7, 2026).Prop 4 repeal initiativeNo charges located in the sources we reviewed, as of Oct. 19, 2026
Plea May 24, 2026In a separate Uintah County case, Chadwick Kluttz, a North Carolina man, pleaded no contest to two third-degree felony forgery charges over Prop 4 repeal signatures. The pleas are held in abeyance for two years; if he pays a $1,000 fee, appears as required and commits no other crimes, the charges will be dismissed. Prosecutors dropped 20 other charges (KSL, June 9, 2026).Prop 4 repeal initiativeNo-contest plea, held in abeyance

A rule that helps catch forged signatures is different from a rule that raises how much support a petition needs. Forgery cases do not show that every limit on petitions prevents fraud, so we grade those questions separately.

Every law, searchable

Type a bill, name or word, or tap a filter. Tap a grade to see all five rubric grades and the reasons. Bill numbers link to the Legislature's page or LegiScan.

Year
Applies to
Direction
Effect
Status

YearBillTitlePrimary / floor sponsorFinal votesWhat it changedOverall

Reading method: descriptions come from each bill's enrolled "Highlighted Provisions," read through a web text extraction, not rendered PDF pages. Where a substitute or Ballotpedia was used instead, the reasons say so. Vote format is yes-no-absent as listed on le.utah.gov or LegiScan. Abbreviations in the grade box: Financial = Financial accountability; Community = Community impact.

Year by year

Each year's laws with their overall grades, and that year's major initiative and referendum events. † = graded but left out of the average (repeal, never took effect, voided, or still on the ballot).

  1. 2016

    2 laws: H.B. 10 B−, H.B. 198 C+

    Average (in effect): 2.38 C+

    • None confirmed. (H.B. 11, a referendum deadline bill by Rep. Fred Cox, failed on the House floor 32-38.)
  2. 2017

    2 laws: H.B. 255 C+, S.B. 69 B−

    Average (in effect): 2.38 C+

    • None confirmed.
  3. 2018

    0 laws: No process law found

    No average

    • No process law found for 2018 (H.B. 225 passed the House but did not become law).
    • Nov. 2018: Prop 2 (medical marijuana) and Prop 3 (Medicaid expansion) were called as passing, at 52.75% and 53.63% at the time (Deseret News, Nov. 9, 2018). Prop 4 (redistricting) passed after the final tally (KSL).
    • Dec. 3, 2018: H.B. 3001 replaced Prop 2 (Ballotpedia).
  4. 2019

    5 laws: H.B. 119 D, H.B. 133 C−, H.B. 145 C, H.B. 195 C, S.B. 151 C+

    Average (in effect): 1.80 C

    • Feb. 11, 2019: Gov. Herbert signed S.B. 96, which the Legislature passed to "repeal and replace Proposition 3" (Ballotpedia News, Feb. 12, 2019; House 56-19, Senate 22-7, LegiScan). Not graded: its text was not read.
    • Dec. 18, 2019: S.B. 2001 (tax restructuring, including the food tax) signed; a referendum against it followed (Ballotpedia).
  5. 2020

    4 laws: H.B. 185 F†, H.B. 75 C−, S.B. 47 C+, S.B. 143 C

    Average (in effect): 2.00 C

    • Jan. 28, 2020: both chambers passed H.B. 185, repealing S.B. 2001 (signed Jan. 29). About 152,000 signatures had been submitted (115,869 needed); the Lt. Governor said the referendum would not go on the ballot (Ballotpedia).
    • March 2020: S.B. 200 (Sen. Curtis S. Bramble / Rep. Carol Spackman Moss) repealed nine sections "as enacted by Statewide Initiative -- Proposition 4" and re-created the commission, whose maps the Legislature "may, but is not required to, vote on or adopt." Senate 25-0-4, House 67-4-4; signed March 28, 2020. Graded separately, not in the 35: C− (LegiScan).
  6. 2021

    3 laws: H.B. 23 C+, H.B. 136 C−, H.B. 211 C

    Average (in effect): 1.92 C

    • None confirmed.
  7. 2022

    3 laws: S.B. 38 C+, H.B. 218 C, H.B. 462 D

    Average (in effect): 1.75 C−

    • None confirmed.
  8. 2023

    5 laws: H.B. 38 C−, H.B. 68 C, H.B. 69 C, S.B. 43 C−, S.B. 199 D

    Average (in effect): 1.65 C−

    • None confirmed.
  9. 2024

    6 laws: H.B. 79 B−, S.B. 100 C+, S.B. 107 C+, S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) D−†, S.B. 4002 C, S.B. 4003 B−†

    Average (in effect): 2.25 C+

    • July 11, 2024: League of Women Voters v. Utah State Legislature (Prop 4): the Utah Supreme Court held that the Legislature's power to amend initiatives has limits.
    • Aug. 21, 2024: the Legislature passed S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D).
    • Sept. 12, 2024: a district court voided Amendment D; the Supreme Court upheld that, and its opinion followed Oct. 24, 2024 (Utah News Dispatch).
  10. 2025

    3 laws: S.B. 73 C+, S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) C−†, H.B. 2001 F†

    Average (in effect): 2.25 C+

    • Spring 2025: the H.B. 267 union referendum gathered more than 320,000 signatures (ABC4; KSL).
    • Aug. 2025: the Third District Court ruled the Legislature unconstitutionally repealed Prop 4 in 2020 (le.utah.gov 2025 2nd Special Session analysis).
    • Dec. 9, 2025: H.B. 2001 repealed H.B. 267, and the referendum ended.
  11. 2026

    2 laws: H.B. 242 C+, H.B. 32 C+

    Average (in effect): 2.25 C+

    • March 2026: H.B. 242 and H.B. 32 signed.
    • Aug. 2026, Eagle Mountain: residents filed a referendum against a 183% property tax increase (Daily Herald, Aug. 13). On Aug. 18 the council repealed it and approved a rate of 0.000900, "a 69.81% increase from its 2026 rate of .000530" (Daily Herald, Aug. 20). A second referendum was filed against Resolution 62-2026 (city Proposition Information Pamphlet). Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: whether the second referendum is on the Nov. 3 ballot, its proposition number, signature counts or any court action.
    • Oct. 13, 2026, Roy: Proposition 10, the referendum on the 34.25% property tax increase, met the requirements and goes on the Nov. 3 ballot (KSL; 1,786 signatures needed; the number collected was "not publicly released").
    • Nov. 3, 2026: Amendment B (S.J.R. 2) is on the ballot.

Average grade by year, laws in effect only

A = 4, B = 3, C = 2, D = 1, F = 0. No law was found for 2018. Uses the four published grades (see the note above).

2016
2.38 C+
2017
2.38 C+
2019
1.80 C
2020
2.00 C
2021
1.92 C
2022
1.75 C−
2023
1.65 C−
2024
2.25 C+
2025
2.25 C+
2026
2.25 C+

H.B. 32 (2026) in full

H.B. 32 (2026), "Signature Gathering and Verification Amendments," changes how signatures are gathered and counted for every initiative and referendum in Utah, statewide and local. Rep. Paul A. Cutler was the primary sponsor and Sen. Ronald M. Winterton the floor sponsor. Our grade: C+ (Power D · Transparency B · Financial C · Environmental N/A · Community B).

Every requirement

What it also adds for signers and sponsors

How a packet moves under H.B. 32

Built only from the bill sections quoted above.

flowchart TD
  A["Gatherer finishes online
Lt. Governor training"] --> B["Gatherer signs the
verification sheet"] B --> C{"Clerk reviews
the packet"} C -->|"Checked No or
left incomplete"| D["Packet rejected"] C -->|"Complete"| E["Signatures checked"] E --> F["Signer told by email or text
(from July 1, 2027)"] E --> G["Packets kept at
least 22 months"]

The votes

DateVoteResultRoll call
Feb. 12, 2026House, 3rd reading56–11RC 2026GS-406-H
March 4, 2026Senate, final22–7–0RC 2026GS-1766-S
March 5, 2026House agrees to Senate changes70–0–5RC 2026GS-1260-H

In the Senate's final vote the seven no votes were Sens. J. Stuart Adams, Heidi Balderree, Don Ipson, Mike McKell, Calvin Musselman, Keven Stratton and Evan Vickers. The other 22 senators, including Sen. Brady Brammer, voted yes; none were absent. Gov. Spencer Cox signed it March 23, 2026 (LegiScan). Most of it took effect May 6, 2026 (le.utah.gov H.B. 32 bill page).

The fiscal note

The fiscal note, revised Jan. 16, 2026, estimates $59,500 one-time and $24,000 a year for the Lieutenant Governor's office, and about $4,000 every two years across all local governments, for clerks' added notification, certification and record-keeping work.

Two checkboxes, side by side

Sen. Winterton was also the Senate sponsor of H.B. 504 (2025), the law that created the "at-risk" checkbox on conflict-of-interest forms. LegiScan lists Rep. Cutler as a sponsor of that bill too, along with Rep. Lisa Shepherd (LegiScan, H.B. 504 (2025)). See The Checkbox case file.

H.B. 504 (2025)H.B. 32 (2026)
Who it applies toOfficials and candidates filing conflict-of-interest formsCitizens gathering signatures on a petition
The checkbox"At-risk government employee""I completed the signature gatherer training"
What the box doesChecked: the filing officer "shall redact" the employer linesMarked "No": the clerk must reject the packet
Who checks itAt the Weber County GRAMA Appeals Board hearing on Oct. 12, 2026, the county said it does not check whether the official qualifies, because the statute doesn't require it (decision issued Oct. 13, 2026)The clerk reviews every packet before counting signatures

The record shows what each law does, and who it applies to. This page does not say either law was written for a reason other than the one its sponsors gave.

The lawmakers who talked to us

Public comments are quoted exactly as recorded in the publisher's logs. Each vote was confirmed by opening the le.utah.gov roll call linked next to it. "Not on roll call" means the person's name is not on that chamber's list. Grades are overall grades from the table above.

Rep. Norm Thurston (R-Provo, HD-62)

Comment (Oct. 9, 2026, on Amendment B): "If this passes, I will pursue legislation to require tax increases to pass with a 2/3 vote in both chambers." Source: public Facebook comment on the publisher's Amendment B thread, Oct. 9, 2026 (publisher's legislator comment log).

Laws sponsored (of the 35): 4 laws: H.B. 145 (2019, primary) C; H.B. 75 (2020, primary) C−; H.B. 211 (2021, primary) C; S.B. 43 (2023, floor sponsor) C−. Average 2.0, C. Sources: H.B. 145, H.B. 75, H.B. 211, S.B. 43 bill pages.

Votes (le.utah.gov roll calls):

Rep. Jason Kyle (R-Huntsville, HD-8), House sponsor of S.J.R. 2 2026 race case file

Comment (about Oct. 6–10, 2026): "The groups that are fighting against Amendment B, are the people that want to raise your taxes." Source: public Facebook post in the "2019 Tax Referendum.....and Onward!" group, about Oct. 6–10, 2026 (publisher's legislator comment log).

Laws sponsored (of the 35): 3 laws, all as floor sponsor: S.B. 4003 (2024) B− (never took effect); S.B. 73 (2025) C+; S.J.R. 2 (2025, Amendment B) C−. Average 2.08, C. Sources: S.B. 4003, S.B. 73, S.J.R. 2.

Votes (le.utah.gov roll calls):

Rep. Tiara Auxier (R, HD-4)

Comment (Oct. 12, 2026): she said Medicaid expansion unaltered "would've bankrupted our state" and called initiatives "mob rule." Source: public Facebook comment on Amendment B, Oct. 12, 2026 (publisher's legislator comment log).

Laws sponsored (of the 35): None of the 35. She was primary sponsor of H.J.R. 20 (2026), a proposal to require voter approval for most tax increases; LegiScan shows it filed in the House "bills not passed" file March 6, 2026 (LegiScan, H.J.R. 20). Not re-checked Oct. 19, 2026: the detail that it died in House Rules comes from earlier research.

Votes (le.utah.gov roll calls):

Rep. Karianne Lisonbee (R, HD-14)

Comment (shared with the Hive Oct. 15, 2026): "I support Amendment B. Initiatives are direct democracy and were the brainchild of progressives around 1900. Only a minority of states have an initiative process. Our founders warned against the dangers of direct democracy. Amendment B requires a 60% threshold only for tax increases, l've attached the actual language so you can verify. I was at a town hall last night and the legislators were talking about the bill they are working on to require the same 60% threshold for the legislature to raise taxes. Chief Justice John Marshall said, "The power to tax is the power to destroy." That power should be difficult to exercise." Source: public Facebook group comment on the publisher's Amendment B thread, pasted to the Hive Oct. 15, 2026 (group name not recorded). Quoted exactly as written, including "l've".
Record notes: In McCulloch v. Maryland (1819), Marshall's opinion reads "That the power to tax involves the power to destroy" (The Founders' Constitution, University of Chicago). Ballotpedia shows 21 states with citizen-initiated state statutes and 18 with citizen-initiated constitutional amendments, and says "There are 26 states that provide citizens with the power of initiative, referendum, or both" (Ballotpedia). No bill setting a 60% threshold for the Legislature was looked up for this page.

Laws sponsored (of the 35): None of the 35 (sponsor columns of the source table).

Votes (le.utah.gov roll calls):

Sen. Brady Brammer 2026 race case file

Comments (August 2026, about disclosures; neither was about referendums or initiatives):
About Aug. 10, 2026: "Pretty standard incumbent disclosures. And he discloses everything in accordance with the law. I think your concern speaks more to who those with vested interests in our economy believe will win and not to the candidates. The difference in fundraising has much more to do with the "D" after her name and less to do with your preferred candidate." Source: public Facebook comment on the publisher's HD-8 fundraising post, about Aug. 10, 2026.
Aug. 11, 2026, on S.B. 230: "The issue was brought to me by the banking community." Source: public Facebook comment, Aug. 11, 2026.

Laws sponsored (of the 35): 1 law: S.B. 143 (2020, floor sponsor, as a representative) C. Sources: enrolled text; LegiScan.

Votes (le.utah.gov roll calls):

Speaker Mike Schultz 2026 race case file

Contact: a message to the publisher, about June 30–July 1, 2026, about Stratos land; not about these laws. Source: publisher's log.

Laws sponsored (of the 35): 1 law: S.B. 199 (2023, floor sponsor) D (grade as published in The Rules Keep Changing). Source: S.B. 199 bill page.

Votes (le.utah.gov roll calls):

Rep. Judy Weeks Rohner

Record: Ballotpedia lists "Judy Rohner" among the filers of the 2019 referendum against S.B. 2001. Source: Ballotpedia, "Utah Changes to State Tax Code Referendum (2020)."

Laws sponsored (of the 35): 1 law: H.B. 68 (2023, primary) C. Source: enrolled text.

Votes (le.utah.gov roll calls):

Proposals that did not pass

Checked and not counted in the 35. Grades on bills that died are content-only, as published in The Rules Keep Changing; the others were not graded.

BillWhat it would have doneSponsorsWhat happenedGradeSource
H.B. 225 (2018)Initiatives, Referenda, and Other Political ActivitiesRep. Brad M. Daw / Sen. Margaret DaytonPassed the House 69-0-6 on 3/2/2018 as 4th substitute; the Senate struck the enacting clause and it was filed as not passed 3/8/2018.Not gradedle.utah.gov bill page
H.B. 11 (2016)Referendum application deadlineRep. Fred CoxFailed on the House floor 32-38.Not gradedSource table
H.B. 488 (2016)——Did not pass.Not gradedSource table
S.B. 181 (2020)Local Referenda AmendmentsFillmore / PierucciDid not pass.Not gradedSource table
H.B. 372 (2023)School district tax referendaCobbDid not pass.Not gradedSource table
H.B. 170 (2025)—Dailey-ProvostDid not pass.Not gradedSource table
H.B. 498 (2025)Statewide Referenda ModificationsStoddardDid not pass.Not gradedSource table
H.B. 408 (2025)School Board Referendum AmendmentsShipp / BrammerOur source table: passed the House 40-33, failed in Senate committee 3-4. The Rules Keep Changing: "Passed the House 40-33-2, then died when the Senate struck its own enacting clause on March 7, 2025." The two accounts of how it ended in the Senate are not reconciled here.B (content-only) · as published in The Rules Keep ChangingSource table; The Rules Keep Changing
H.B. 170 (2026)School Board Referendum AmendmentsShipp / FillmorePassed the House 50-21, failed in the Senate 9-15.Not gradedSource table
H.B. 120 (2006)Would have stayed a referred local law while its referendum was pendingRep. David HogueDied 27-46 on the House floor (as published in The Rules Keep Changing).B (content-only; graded with S.B. 66) · as published in The Rules Keep ChangingThe Rules Keep Changing
S.B. 66 (2013)The same stay-pending-referendum fixSen. Stuart ReidPassed the Senate 27-1; the House struck the enacting clause with no floor vote (as published in The Rules Keep Changing).B (content-only; graded with H.B. 120) · as published in The Rules Keep ChangingThe Rules Keep Changing
H.B. 185 (2022)Would have lowered the 2019 land-use referendum thresholds (a different bill from H.B. 185 of 2020)Rep. Adam RobertsonPassed committee 7-4, then the House struck its own enacting clause; died 3/4/2022 (as published in The Rules Keep Changing).B− (content-only) · as published in The Rules Keep ChangingThe Rules Keep Changing

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Ask your state legislatorsWhat problem with signature gathering was the H.B. 32 training requirement meant to fix, and will the Legislature publish the verification statistics it now collects? Find your legislators at le.utah.gov.
Ask your state legislatorsA gatherer's "No" gets a packet rejected, while an official's "at-risk" checkbox is accepted without review. Should the at-risk redaction have the same kind of check that petition packets now get?
Ask the Lieutenant Governor's elections officeWhen will the online gatherer training be posted, and where will signers find the QR-code law text for a condensed packet?
Ask your city or county clerkHow will you tell signers whether their signature counted once the July 1, 2027 notice rule starts, and how long do you keep verified packets?
Ask your state legislatorsRep. Norm Thurston has said publicly that if Amendment B passes, he will pursue a two-thirds vote for tax increases in the Legislature. Will others support holding the Legislature to a higher bar too?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

35
laws graded, 2016–2026
11
roll calls opened on le.utah.gov
7
lawmakers' records checked
12
proposals that did not pass, listed
146
linked sources
4
grades taken from the published series

Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Built from the Hive's graded table of 35 laws, its source table and the H.B. 32 research file (all compiled Oct. 19, 2026), plus the published grades in The Rules Keep Changing. Public records only; no comment was requested.

Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: whether Eagle Mountain's second referendum is on the Nov. 3 ballot, its proposition number or any court action; the number of signatures collected for Roy Prop 10 ("not publicly released"); S.B. 96's bill text; H.B. 3001 (2018) was not reopened; how H.B. 408 (2025) ended in the Senate (two accounts above).

Sources

Show every source, grouped by bill (146 links)

H.B. 10 (2016 General)

H.B. 198 (2016 General)

H.B. 255 (2017 General)

S.B. 69 (2017 General)

H.B. 119 (2019 General)

H.B. 133 (2019 General)

H.B. 145 (2019 General)

H.B. 195 (2019 General)

S.B. 151 (2019 General)

H.B. 185 (2020 General)

H.B. 75 (2020 General)

S.B. 47 (2020 General)

S.B. 143 (2020 General)

H.B. 23 (2021 General)

H.B. 136 (2021 General)

H.B. 211 (2021 General)

S.B. 38 (2022 General)

H.B. 218 (2022 General)

H.B. 462 (2022 General)

H.B. 38 (2023 General)

H.B. 68 (2023 General)

H.B. 69 (2023 General)

S.B. 43 (2023 General)

S.B. 199 (2023 General)

H.B. 79 (2024 General)

S.B. 100 (2024 General)

S.B. 107 (2024 General)

S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) (2024 4th Special)

S.B. 4002 (2024 4th Special)

S.B. 4003 (2024 4th Special)

S.B. 73 (2025 General)

S.J.R. 2 (Amendment B) (2025 General)

H.B. 2001 (2025 2nd Special)

H.B. 242 (2026 General)

H.B. 32 (2026 General)

Related bills and events

H.B. 504 (2025) and the checkbox comparison

Local referendums, 2026

Fact checks on comments

Lawmakers' comments (public Facebook, as recorded in the publisher's comment log)

  • Rep. Norm Thurston, comment on the Amendment B thread, Oct. 9, 2026 (no link in our files)
  • Rep. Jason Kyle, post in the "2019 Tax Referendum.....and Onward!" group, about Oct. 6–10, 2026 (no link in our files)
  • Rep. Tiara Auxier, comment on Amendment B, Oct. 12, 2026 (no link in our files)
  • Rep. Karianne Lisonbee, group comment, shared with the Hive Oct. 15, 2026 (no link in our files)
  • Sen. Brady Brammer, comments about Aug. 10 and Aug. 11, 2026 (no link in our files)
  • Speaker Mike Schultz, message to the Hive, about June 30–July 1, 2026 (no link in our files)

Timeline: what citizens and courts did, and what lawmakers did next

Published grades used on this page

All roll calls cited (le.utah.gov)

Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

People

None found yet.

Elsewhere on the Hive

None found yet.

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism