Bill Tracker · CASE 2023-038-PET · Initiatives & referendums
H.B. 38 rewrote the initiative and referendum law "to create consistency," gave lawmakers 10 days' notice of initiative hearings, and spelled out how petition packets are bound.
Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026
| Bill | H.B. 38 (2023 General), "Initiative and Referendum Modifications" |
| Primary sponsor | Rep. Calvin R. Musselman |
| Floor sponsor | Sen. David G. Buxton |
| Final votes | Senate 25-0-4 (2/27/23); House 70-0-5 (concurrence 2/28/23) |
| Status | In effect · Signed 3/14/2023 |
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | C | Grade C. The bill mostly reorganizes and restates the rules and names who does each step. It does not add or remove a check on officials (H.B. 38 (2023) enrolled text). |
| Transparency | B | Grade B. Lawmakers, county officials and the Lieutenant Governor get 10 days' written notice of each pre-circulation hearing instead of three. The bill had committee hearings in both chambers (H.B. 38 (2023) enrolled text; Bill page and status (Chapter 107)). |
| Financial accountability | N/A | Not applicable. The bill does not change who pays. |
| Environmental impact | N/A | Not applicable. |
| Community impact | D | Grade D. Packets must be bound a set way, and a clerk "may not certify a signature" on a packet that was not verified. Our published grade ties this kind of packet rule to signatures thrown out in Summit County in 2025 (H.B. 38 (2023) enrolled text; Weber County Hive: The Rules Keep Changing, Part 2 (rubric); Weber County Hive: Two Referendums, Zero Votes). |
Grade as published in The Rules Keep Changing (Referendum docket). Grade as published on the Bill-Tracker research tracker. A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. These are the same grades as on Ten Years of Petition Laws. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.
Quoted from the enrolled bill (H.B. 38 (2023) enrolled text). Text in [brackets] was struck.
Highlighted provisions (lines 13–15)
amends provisions relating to initiatives and referenda to clarify provisions and requirements, to clarify who is responsible for certain requirements, and to use consistent terms;
Utah Code 20A-7-204.1(2) (line 681)
(a) before 5 p.m. at least [three] 10 calendar days before the date of the public hearing,
Sponsors' written notice of each hearing goes to the Lieutenant Governor and to the state lawmakers and county council or commission members from the region (H.B. 38 (2023) enrolled text).
Utah Code 20A-7-204(5) (lines 633–634)
The sponsors or an agent of the sponsors shall create the initiative packets by binding a copy of the initiative petition with the text of the proposed law
The text goes on: no more than 50 signature sheets, bound "together at the top"; packets do not need the same number of sheets (H.B. 38 (2023) enrolled text).
Utah Code 20A-7-206(5) (lines 855–857)
The county clerk may not certify a signature under Subsection (3): (a) on an initiative packet that is not verified in accordance with Section 20A-7-205;
Utah Code 20A-7-203(6) (lines 589–590)
If the forms described in this section are substantially followed, the initiative petitions are sufficient, notwithstanding clerical and merely technical errors.
This rule for petition forms appears in the same bill (H.B. 38 (2023) enrolled text).
| Version | Date | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| Introduced | Dec. 20, 2022 | Numbered and made public (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)). |
| House committee | Jan. 31, 2023 | House Government Operations Committee, favorable, 9–0–3 (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)). |
| Senate committee | Feb. 7, 2023 | Senate Government Operations and Political Subdivisions Committee, favorable, 6–0–2 (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)). |
| 1st Substitute (Sen. Daniel W. Thatcher) | Feb. 27, 2023 | Adopted on the Senate floor by voice vote, then passed (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)). |
| Enrolled | Signed March 14, 2023 | Chapter 107; effective May 3, 2023. The bill "provides a coordination clause" (H.B. 38 (2023) enrolled text; Bill page and status (Chapter 107)). |
| Date | Where | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan. 31, 2023 | House Government Operations Committee | 9–0–3 | (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)) |
| Feb. 3, 2023 | House, 3rd reading | 70–0–5 | (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)) |
| Feb. 7, 2023 | Senate Government Operations and Political Subdivisions Committee | 6–0–2 | (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)) |
| Feb. 9, 2023 | Senate, 2nd reading | 24–1–4 | (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)) |
| Feb. 27, 2023 | Senate, 3rd reading (1st Substitute) | 25–0–4 | (Senate roll call, Feb. 27, 2023) |
| Feb. 28, 2023 | House concurs | 70–0–5 | (House concurrence roll call, Feb. 28, 2023) |
One senator voted no on the Feb. 9 second reading; we did not open that roll call to see who (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)). No member voted no on final passage in either chamber (Senate roll call, Feb. 27, 2023; House concurrence roll call, Feb. 28, 2023). The bill had a committee hearing in each chamber (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)).
Built only from the records on this page.
flowchart TD A["Sponsors get the
fiscal impact estimate"] --> B["Written notice at least
10 days before each hearing
(was 3)"] B --> C["Seven public hearings
around the state"] C --> D["Packets bound: petition,
law text, up to
50 signature sheets"] D --> E["Signatures gathered
and packets verified"] E --> F{"Packet
verified?"} F -->|"No"| G["Clerk may not
certify signatures"] F -->|"Yes"| H["Signatures checked"]
Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.
The 10-day hearing notice is a real, if minor, transparency gain. But its packet-binding formalization is the same rule that, per the Summit County case in the companion piece, threw out a majority of otherwise-valid signatures over a formatting issue unrelated to whether the signers were real, registered voters.
— The Weber County Hive, published grade reason, The Rules Keep Changing, Part 2 (Weber County Hive: The Rules Keep Changing, Part 2 (rubric))
How this law builds on the ones before it, from How they stack.
| Person | Role in this record | Elsewhere on the Hive |
|---|---|---|
| Rep. Calvin R. Musselman | Primary sponsor; now a state senator (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)) | |
| Sen. David G. Buxton | Senate (floor) sponsor (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)) | |
| Sen. Daniel W. Thatcher | Sponsor of the 1st Substitute adopted on the Senate floor (Bill page and status (Chapter 107)) |
Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Bill status, sponsors, versions and votes read from the le.utah.gov bill page on Oct. 19, 2026. Bill text read from the enrolled web page through a text-extraction tool, which does not show underlining; quotes are words that appear in the enrolled text, and we do not say which were new unless brackets show a strike. The tool did not return the end of the bill (after about line 1354). The 2023 code was read from Justia's 2023 copy. The Summit County facts come from the Hive's own published referendum docket page.
Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.
Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism