Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2020-200-PROP · Voter-passed laws

"May, But Is Not Required To": The Redistricting Replacement

Voters passed an independent redistricting commission in 2018. S.B. 200 repealed it and created a new commission whose maps the Legislature does not have to vote on. A judge later ruled the repeal unconstitutional.

Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

BillS.B. 200 (2020 General Session), "Redistricting Amendments"
Primary sponsorSen. Curtis S. Bramble
Floor sponsorRep. Carol Spackman Moss
Final votesSenate 25–0–4 (March 3, 2020); House 67–4–4 (March 11, 2020)
StatusLaw · Signed March 28, 2020

Graded by the collective rubric

FOverall · Hinders
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerFRepealed the Legislature's duty to act on commission maps and explain a rejection, and the citizens' right to sue; nothing binding replaced them (S.B. 200 enrolled text; Utah Code 20A-19-204 (2019), enacted by Proposition 4 (Justia)). A court later ruled the repeal unconstitutional (KUER, Aug. 25, 2025, "Judge tosses out Utah's congressional maps").
TransparencyDHeard in a committee in each chamber with recorded votes (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page). But it removed the seven-day public report Prop 4 required when the Legislature passed its own map (S.B. 200 enrolled text; Utah Code 20A-19-204 (2019), enacted by Proposition 4 (Justia)). The Senate passed it under a rules suspension (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page).
Financial accountabilityCA fiscal note was posted (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page; Fiscal note). The bill is about map-drawing rules, not spending. Meets the standard.
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactFVoters' map standards no longer bound the Legislature, and citizens lost the section that let them sue to enforce them (S.B. 200 enrolled text; Ballotpedia News, Aug. 29, 2025).

New grade, not previously published. S.B. 200 removed checks with nothing binding in their place (Power F, Community F). It kept a commission and a public presentation of its maps, and it had committee hearings, which is why Transparency is D, not F. Its five grades are the same as H.B. 185 (2020) and H.B. 2001 (2025), so its Overall is the same F, applied the same way. The 2025 court ruling is reported for the record; the grade is based on the bill text and process. A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Short quotes from the enrolled bill on le.utah.gov (S.B. 200 enrolled text) and from the Prop 4 section it repealed (Utah Code 20A-19-204 (2019), enacted by Proposition 4 (Justia)). Bill line numbers are shown.

Highlighted Provisions · line 25

repeals existing independent redistricting commission provisions.

The repealer lists all nine Prop 4 sections, 20A-19-101 through 20A-19-301 (S.B. 200 enrolled text).

Maps presented to the Legislature · lines 406–407

The committee or the Legislature may, but is not required to, vote on or adopt a map submitted to the committee or the Legislature by the commission.

(S.B. 200 enrolled text)

Commission standards · lines 354–365

The commission shall define and adopt redistricting standards for use by the commission that require that maps adopted by the commission, to the extent practicable, comply with the following, as defined by the commission: [items (a)–(e) omitted] (f) prohibiting the purposeful or undue favoring or disfavoring of: (i) an incumbent elected official; (ii) a candidate or prospective candidate for elected office; or (iii) a political party.

The standards apply to the commission's maps; the commission defines them (S.B. 200 enrolled text).

Partisan data · lines 366–368

The commission may adopt a standard that prohibits the commission from using any of the following, except for the purpose of conducting an assessment described in Subsection (8): (a) partisan political data;

"May," not "shall" (S.B. 200 enrolled text).

Repealed Prop 4 section 20A-19-204

issue to the public a detailed written report

Required within "seven calendar days after its enactment" if the Legislature passed a map other than the commission's. S.B. 200 repealed this section (S.B. 200 enrolled text; Utah Code 20A-19-204 (2019), enacted by Proposition 4 (Justia)).

Every version, and what changed

VersionDateWhat changed
IntroducedFeb. 27, 2020One version; no substitutes or amendments are listed (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page).
EnrolledSigned March 28, 2020Chapter 288, effective March 28, 2020 (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page).

The votes

DateWhereResultRecord
March 2, 2020Senate Business and Labor Committee7–0–1(S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page)
March 3, 2020Senate, 2nd and 3rd readings under suspension25–0–4(S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page)
March 6, 2020House Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee7–0–3(S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page)
March 11, 2020House, 3rd reading67–4–4(S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page)

The bill was first sent to the Senate Government Operations committee, then moved to Business and Labor the next day (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page). Roll-call names were not reviewed.

The timeline

  1. Nov. 6, 2018 Voters approve Proposition 4, 50.3% to 49.7% (Ballotpedia News, Aug. 29, 2025).
  2. Feb. 27, 2020 S.B. 200 made public, about two weeks before the session ends (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page).
  3. March 2–11, 2020 Committee hearings in both chambers; passes the Senate 25–0–4 and the House 67–4–4 (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page).
  4. March 28, 2020 Gov. Gary Herbert signs it (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page).
  5. July 11, 2024 The Utah Supreme Court rules government-reform initiatives are protected from "unfettered" legislative repeal and sends the case back to district court (Ballotpedia News, Aug. 29, 2025; KJZZ, July 11, 2024, on the Utah Supreme Court ruling).
  6. Aug. 25, 2025 Third District Judge Dianna Gibson rules the repeal of Prop 4 and S.B. 200 unconstitutional and blocks the 2021 congressional map (KUER, Aug. 25, 2025, "Judge tosses out Utah's congressional maps").
  7. Nov. 10, 2025 Judge Gibson picks a plaintiffs' congressional map (FOX 13, Nov. 2025, "Judge picks a new congressional map").
  8. Feb. 20, 2026 The Utah Supreme Court dismisses the Legislature's appeal; the court-chosen map is set for 2026 (Salt Lake Tribune, Feb. 20, 2026).
  9. April 30, 2026 A citizen initiative to repeal Prop 4 falls short in two Senate districts and does not make the ballot (KPCW, May 1, 2026, "Effort to repeal Utah anti-gerrymandering law officially fails").

Who has to act on the commission's maps

Built only from the records on this page.

flowchart TD
  A["Commission draws maps"] --> B{"Which law?"}
  B -->|"Prop 4 (2018)"| C["Legislature enacts
or rejects them"] C --> D["If it passes its own map:
public report in 7 days"] B -->|"S.B. 200 (2020)"| E["Maps presented at
a public meeting"] E --> F["Legislature may, but is
not required to, vote"]

In their own words

Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.

government-reform initiatives are constitutionally protected from unfettered legislative amendment, repeal, or replacement

— Utah Supreme Court, July 11, 2024, Ballotpedia News (Ballotpedia News, Aug. 29, 2025)

The repeal of Proposition 4 and the enactment of S.B. 200 was unconstitutional.

— Third District Judge Dianna Gibson, KUER, Aug. 25, 2025 (KUER, Aug. 25, 2025, "Judge tosses out Utah's congressional maps")

We will carefully review the ruling and consider our next steps.

— Senate President J. Stuart Adams and House Speaker Mike Schultz, KUER, Aug. 25, 2025 (KUER, Aug. 25, 2025, "Judge tosses out Utah's congressional maps")

However, the 30 days to appeal passed, and no appeal was filed.

— Chief Justice Matthew Durrant, Salt Lake Tribune, Feb. 20, 2026 (Salt Lake Tribune, Feb. 20, 2026)

Whether now or in the future, by litigation or initiative, we will repeal Prop 4.

— Utah GOP Chair Rob Axson, KPCW, May 1, 2026 (KPCW, May 1, 2026, "Effort to repeal Utah anti-gerrymandering law officially fails")

What happened next

Where it fits

Bills that changed the same rule, oldest first. This bill is highlighted.

Bills that change the same rule

  1. 2018 Proposition 4
    Voters pass an independent redistricting commission, standards binding the Legislature, a public report if the Legislature rejects the commission's maps, and a right to sue.
  2. 2020 S.B. 200
    Repeals Prop 4; creates a new commission whose maps the Legislature may, but is not required to, vote on.
  3. 2024 S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D)
    Proposed constitutional amendment on the Legislature's power over initiatives; voided by a court before the vote.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Sen. Curtis S. BramblePrimary sponsor (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page)
Rep. Carol Spackman MossFloor sponsor in the House (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page)
Gov. Gary R. HerbertSigned the bill (S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page)
Judge Dianna M. GibsonThird District judge who ruled the repeal unconstitutional (KUER, Aug. 25, 2025, "Judge tosses out Utah's congressional maps")
Justice Paige PetersenWrote the 2024 Utah Supreme Court opinion (KJZZ, July 11, 2024, on the Utah Supreme Court ruling)
Chief Justice Matthew DurrantWrote the 2026 order dismissing the Legislature's appeal (Salt Lake Tribune, Feb. 20, 2026)
Sen. J. Stuart Adams and Rep. Mike SchultzLegislative leaders who responded to the 2025 ruling (KUER, Aug. 25, 2025, "Judge tosses out Utah's congressional maps")
Lt. Gov. Deidre M. HendersonDeclared the 2026 repeal initiative insufficient (KPCW, May 1, 2026, "Effort to repeal Utah anti-gerrymandering law officially fails")

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Your state representative and senatorShould the Legislature be required to vote on the commission's maps and explain in writing if it picks a different one?
The Utah Independent Redistricting CommissionWhere are your maps and reports posted, and which standards did you adopt?
The Lieutenant Governor's elections officeWhich district map will be used for the next election, and where can voters see it?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

11
sources listed
4
votes recorded
2
versions compared
5
statements quoted

Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Status, sponsors, votes and dates from the le.utah.gov status page, read Oct. 19, 2026. Bill quotes from the enrolled HTML on le.utah.gov, read through a text-extraction tool in short pieces; the repealer list was read as a summary. The repealed Prop 4 section was read from Justia's 2019 Utah Code copy. Court rulings from Ballotpedia News, KUER, KJZZ, FOX 13 and the Salt Lake Tribune; the rulings themselves were not read. Committee minutes and floor audio were not reviewed.

Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: whether Prop 4's sponsor, Better Boundaries, took part in or supported S.B. 200 (not checked against a source); how Prop 4's commission appointments compared with S.B. 200's; the fiscal note's contents; whether S.B. 200 keeps public hearing requirements for the commission (not read); the name of the 2025 special-session law the judge also blocked (FOX 13 refers to "S.B. 1011" but does not confirm it); the outcome of the federal challenge by Reps. Owens and Maloy after Feb. 2026.

Sources

Show all 11 sources
  1. S.B. 200 (2020) bill status page: https://le.utah.gov/~2020/bills/static/SB0200.html
  2. S.B. 200 enrolled text: https://le.utah.gov/~2020/bills/sbillenr/SB0200.htm
  3. Utah Code 20A-19-204 (2019), enacted by Proposition 4 (Justia): https://law.justia.com/codes/utah/2019/title-20a/chapter-19/part-2/section-204/
  4. Ballotpedia News, Aug. 29, 2025: https://news.ballotpedia.org/2025/08/29/utah-district-court-rules-legislature-unconstitutionally-repealed-proposition-4-strikes-down-2021-congressional-map/
  5. KUER, Aug. 25, 2025, "Judge tosses out Utah's congressional maps": https://www.kuer.org/politics-government/2025-08-25/judge-tosses-out-utahs-congressional-maps-in-long-fought-redistricting-case
  6. KJZZ, July 11, 2024, on the Utah Supreme Court ruling: https://kjzz.com/news/politics/utah-supreme-court-ruling-july-11-2024-2018-voter-initiative-gerrymandering-repeal-replace-legislature-prop-4-sb-200-gov-spencer-cox
  7. Salt Lake Tribune, Feb. 20, 2026: https://www.sltrib.com/news/politics/2026/02/20/gerrymandering-utah-supreme-court
  8. FOX 13, Nov. 2025, "Judge picks a new congressional map": https://www.fox13now.com/news/politics/judge-picks-a-new-congressional-map-in-redistricting
  9. KPCW, May 1, 2026, "Effort to repeal Utah anti-gerrymandering law officially fails": https://www.kpcw.org/state-regional/2026-05-01/effort-to-repeal-utah-anti-gerrymandering-law-officially-fails-lieutenant-governor-says
  10. Bill Tracker case file, S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D, 2024): weber-hive-2024-sjr401.html
  11. Fiscal note: https://le.utah.gov/lfa/fnotes/2020/SB0200.fn.pdf
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

People

Elsewhere on the Hive

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism