Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerTen Years of Petition LawsMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2024-401-PET · Initiatives & referendums

Amendment D: Six Weeks After the Ruling

A proposed constitutional amendment on the Legislature's power over voter-passed laws, written in a one-day special session and voided by the courts.

Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

BillS.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) (2024 4th Special), "Proposal to Amend Utah Constitution – Voter Legislative Power"
Primary sponsorSen. Kirk A. Cullimore
Floor sponsorRep. Jordan D. Teuscher
Final votesSenate 20-8-1; House 54-21-0 (8/21/24)
StatusVoided by the courts · Passed 8/21/2024; sent for filing 8/22/2024

Graded by the collective rubric

D−Overall · Hinders
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerFWould have removed the limit on the Legislature's power over voter-passed laws, retroactively, with nothing in its place (S.J.R. 401 enrolled (XML)).
TransparencyFMade public Aug. 20 and passed Aug. 21 in a special session with no committee hearing; the courts found the ballot language misleading and the newspaper notice unpublished (S.J.R. 401 bill status page; KSL, Sept. 25, 2024 (Supreme Court order); FOX 13, Oct. 24, 2024).
Financial accountabilityCFiscal note: $8,600 one-time for the Governor's Office to submit it, which the office could absorb (Fiscal note).
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactDVoters' ability to pass laws the Legislature could not simply undo would have been reduced (S.J.R. 401 enrolled (XML)).

A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. These are the same grades as on Ten Years of Petition Laws. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Quoted from the enrolled resolution (S.J.R. 401 enrolled (XML)).

Proposed Article VI, Section 1(4)

Notwithstanding any other provision of this Constitution, the people's exercise of their Legislative power as provided in Subsection (2) does not limit or preclude the exercise of Legislative power, including through amending, enacting, or repealing a law, by the Legislature, or by a law making body of a county, city, or town, on behalf of the people whom they are elected to represent.

(S.J.R. 401 enrolled (XML))

Proposed Article VI, Section 1(3)

(a) Foreign individuals, entities, or governments may not, directly or indirectly, influence, support, or oppose an initiative or a referendum.

(S.J.R. 401 enrolled (XML))

Section 5, retrospective operation

The actions affecting Article I, Section 2 and Article VI, Section 1, Subsection (4) have retrospective operation.

(S.J.R. 401 enrolled (XML))

Every version, and what changed

VersionDateWhat changed
Introduced (Sen. Kirk Cullimore)Aug. 20–21, 2024Numbered Aug. 20; introduced Aug. 21 (S.J.R. 401 bill status page; S.J.R. 401 as introduced).
1st Substitute (Rep. Brett Garner)Not adoptedWould have barred the Legislature from superseding a voter-passed law unless it "furthers the purpose of the initiative" and three-fourths of each house agreed (1st Substitute (Rep. Brett Garner, not adopted)).
2nd Substitute (Sen. Nate Blouin)Not adoptedWould have banned foreign influence in elections more broadly (2nd Substitute (Sen. Nate Blouin, not adopted)).
Senate Floor Amendment 4 (Cullimore)Aug. 21, 2024, adoptedStruck "legislative" from the Article I, Section 2 language and fixed a cross-reference (S.J.R. 401 amended text (Senate Floor Amendment 4)).
Senate Floor Amendment 3 (Blouin)Aug. 21, 2024, failedWould have removed the retroactive clause (S.J.R. 401 bill status page).
EnrolledAug. 22, 2024Sent to the Lt. Governor; a constitutional amendment does not go to the governor (S.J.R. 401 bill status page).

The votes

DateWhereResultRecord
Aug. 21, 2024Senate, under suspension20–8–1(Senate roll call, Aug. 21, 2024)
Aug. 21, 2024House54–21–0(House roll call, Aug. 21, 2024)

Senate no votes: Sens. Blouin, Escamilla, Harper, Kwan, Pitcher, Plumb, Riebe and Thatcher (Senate roll call, Aug. 21, 2024). House no votes included Reps. Dunnigan, Eliason, Loubet and MacPherson (House roll call, Aug. 21, 2024).

The timeline

  1. July 11, 2024 Utah Supreme Court rules in League of Women Voters v. Utah State Legislature (Utah News Dispatch, Oct. 24, 2024).
  2. Aug. 19, 2024 Senate President Adams and Speaker Schultz call a special session (Utah Senate release, Aug. 19, 2024).
  3. Aug. 21, 2024 Amendment D passes both chambers the same evening (Senate roll call, Aug. 21, 2024; House roll call, Aug. 21, 2024).
  4. Sept. 12, 2024 Third District Judge Dianna Gibson voids it: "Amendment D is void and shall be given no effect" (Salt Lake Tribune, Sept. 12, 2024).
  5. Sept. 25, 2024 Utah Supreme Court affirms (KSL, Sept. 25, 2024 (Supreme Court order)).
  6. Oct. 24, 2024 Full opinion by Justice Diana Hagen: "Amendment D changes rather than clarifies" (Utah News Dispatch, Oct. 24, 2024; FOX 13, Oct. 24, 2024).
  7. Nov. 5, 2024 On the ballot, but votes not counted (KSL, Sept. 25, 2024 (Supreme Court order)).
  8. 2025 Lawmakers pass Amendment A (H.J.R. 10), which would remove the newspaper rule that was one reason Amendment D was voided (Transparency: The Amendments on Your Ballot, Part 1).

From ruling to void, 2024

Built only from the records on this page.

flowchart TD
  A["July 11: Supreme Court
Prop 4 ruling"] --> B["Aug. 21: Amendment D passes
in one-day special session"] B --> C["Sept. 12: judge voids it"] C --> D["Supreme Court agrees:
no newspaper notice,
misleading ballot language"] D --> E["Votes not counted"]

In their own words

Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.

The Utah Supreme Court's new interpretation created uncertainty and ambiguity.

— Senate President J. Stuart Adams and Speaker Mike Schultz, Utah Senate release, Aug. 19, 2024 (Utah Senate release, Aug. 19, 2024)

over 100 years of representative democracy in Utah without the voice of the people

— Adams and Schultz, on the July ruling, Utah News Dispatch, Oct. 24, 2024 (Utah News Dispatch, Oct. 24, 2024)

It's an opportunity to let the people of Utah decide the direction of their government.

— Sen. Kirk Cullimore, primary sponsor, KSL, Aug. 21, 2024 (KSL, Aug. 21, 2024)

This strips their rights.

— Rep. Jennifer Dailey-Provost, KSL, Aug. 21, 2024 (KSL, Aug. 21, 2024)

We simply cannot read the word 'newspaper' out of the Publication Clause.

— Utah Supreme Court opinion, Oct. 24, 2024, FOX 13 (FOX 13, Oct. 24, 2024)

What happened next

Where it fits

How this law builds on the ones before it, from How they stack.

The Legislature and voter-passed laws

  1. 2019 H.B. 133 C−
    changed when a law passed by statewide initiative takes effect
  2. 2019 H.B. 195 C
    thresholds based on active voters; no "substantially similar" initiative within two years
  3. 2024 S.J.R. 401 (Amendment D) D−
    the Legislature's power to amend or repeal voter-passed laws; voided by the courts
  4. 2024 S.B. 4003 B−
    would have extended the referendum deadline from 40 to 60 days; tied to Amendment D, never took effect

Where it ended up: The biggest change in this chain, Amendment D, was voided, and the one piece that would have given citizens more time went with it.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Sen. Kirk A. CullimorePrimary sponsor; offered Floor Amendments 1 and 4 (S.J.R. 401 bill status page)Candidates 2026: SD-19
Rep. Jordan D. TeuscherHouse sponsor (S.J.R. 401 bill status page)Petition laws: sponsored 6 of the 35
Senate President J. Stuart Adams and Speaker Mike SchultzCalled the session; wrote the ballot language (Utah Senate release, Aug. 19, 2024; KSL, Sept. 25, 2024 (Supreme Court order))Candidates 2026: HD-12 (Schultz)
Rep. Brett GarnerOffered the 1st Substitute (1st Substitute (Rep. Brett Garner, not adopted))—
Sen. Nate BlouinOffered the 2nd Substitute and Floor Amendment 3; voted no (2nd Substitute (Sen. Nate Blouin, not adopted); Senate roll call, Aug. 21, 2024)—
Judge Dianna M. GibsonVoided Amendment D (Salt Lake Tribune, Sept. 12, 2024)—
Justice Diana HagenWrote the Supreme Court opinion (Utah News Dispatch, Oct. 24, 2024)—

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Your state legislatorsDo you plan to bring back a version of Amendment D, and would it get a committee hearing first?
The Lieutenant Governor's elections officeWhat did it cost counties to print Amendment D on the 2024 ballot?
Senate President Adams and Speaker SchultzWho drafted the Amendment D ballot language, and what review did it get?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

18
sources listed
2
votes recorded
6
versions compared
5
statements quoted

Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Built from the S.J.R. 401 research packet; court rulings quoted through news coverage.

Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: quotes from floor debate beyond KSL's report (audio not reviewed); any quote from Rep. Teuscher; the exact printed ballot title (two sources differ by one word); any costs or legal fees tied to Amendment D.

Sources

Show all 18 sources
  1. S.J.R. 401 bill status page: https://le.utah.gov/~2024S4/bills/static/SJR401.html
  2. S.J.R. 401 as introduced: https://le.utah.gov/~2024S4/bills/sbillint/SJR401.htm
  3. S.J.R. 401 amended text (Senate Floor Amendment 4): https://le.utah.gov/~2024S4/bills/sbillamd/SJR401.htm
  4. S.J.R. 401 enrolled (XML): https://le.utah.gov/~2024S4/bills/xmlEnrolled/SJR401.xml
  5. 1st Substitute (Rep. Brett Garner, not adopted): https://le.utah.gov/~2024S4/bills/sbillint/SJR401S01.pdf
  6. 2nd Substitute (Sen. Nate Blouin, not adopted): https://le.utah.gov/~2024S4/bills/sbillint/SJR401S02.pdf
  7. Senate roll call, Aug. 21, 2024: https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2024S4&voteid=12&house=S
  8. House roll call, Aug. 21, 2024: https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2024S4&voteid=3&house=H
  9. Fiscal note: https://le.utah.gov/lfa/fnotes/2024S4/SJR401.fn.pdf
  10. KSL, Aug. 21, 2024: https://www.ksl.com/article/news/politics/utah-senate-house-approve-proposal-to-put-question-to-voters-on-ballot-initiative-process/51106118
  11. Utah Senate release, Aug. 19, 2024: https://senate.utah.gov/?p=3376
  12. Salt Lake Tribune, Sept. 12, 2024: https://sltrib.com/news/politics/2024/09/12/amendment-d-utah-judge-strikes
  13. Deseret News, Sept. 12, 2024: https://www.deseret.com/politics/2024/09/12/ruling-on-ballot-initiative-amendment/
  14. KSL, Sept. 25, 2024 (Supreme Court order): https://www.ksl.com/article/news/utah/police-and-courts/utah-supreme-court-upholds-lower-court-ruling-to-void-amendment-d/51139038
  15. Utah News Dispatch, Oct. 24, 2024: https://utahnewsdispatch.com/2024/10/24/amendment-d-ballot-language-was-misleading-utah-supreme-court-decision/
  16. FOX 13, Oct. 24, 2024: https://www.fox13now.com/news/politics/utah-supreme-court-issues-formal-ruling-in-amendment-d-case
  17. ABC4, Feb. 25, 2026: https://www.abc4.com/news/politics/inside-utah-politics/legislature-special-session-constitution-initiatives/amp/
  18. Transparency: The Amendments on Your Ballot, Part 1: https://weber-county-hive.github.io/Transparency/utah-amendments-2026.html
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

People

Elsewhere on the Hive

None found yet.

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism