Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2024-502-LND · Land use & mining

The Zoning Override That Became a Study

As introduced, H.B. 502 would have required every city and county to allow mining by the end of 2024. What passed was a $500,000 state study.

Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

BillH.B. 502 (2024 General Session), "Critical Infrastructure and Mining"
Primary sponsorRep. Casey Snider
Floor sponsorSen. Kirk A. Cullimore
Final votesHouse 57–16–2 · Senate 19–9–1 · House concurs 54–17–4
StatusLaw · Signed Mar. 12, 2024

Graded by the collective rubric

BOverall · Helps
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerCThe introduced bill would have overridden local zoning, including overlay zones. The enacted bill leaves local zoning as it was (H.B. 502 as introduced; H.B. 502 enrolled text).
TransparencyBThe substitute was adopted in an open, posted committee hearing with named witnesses. The $500,000 appropriation was added on the Senate floor the same day the bill passed under suspension of the rules (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov; Compare: 2nd Substitute vs. 1st Substitute; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024).
Financial accountabilityBThe fiscal note states the $500,000 one-time cost plainly and says no direct, measurable costs for local governments. The study section repeals July 1, 2026 (H.B. 502 enrolled text; Fiscal note, 2nd Substitute).
Environmental impactCThe enacted bill is a study only. It changes no mining or land-use rule (H.B. 502 enrolled text).
Community impactALocal officials and residents testified in both committees, including opposition in the Senate. Local zoning authority was kept (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024; Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502)).

Grade as published on the Bill-Tracker research tracker: B (design failed, outcome held). The five questions are filled to match it. Power and environment are C because the enacted law keeps the status quo. Community impact is an A: the override was replaced in an open hearing where a mayor, the League of Cities and Towns and residents were on the record, and local zoning stayed in local hands. Average 2.8 = B. A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Quoted from the introduced bill (H.B. 502 as introduced) and the enrolled bill (H.B. 502 enrolled text).

Proposed Utah Code 17-41-402.2(1)(a), introduced

shall allow critical infrastructure materials operations and mining operations as a permitted or conditional use

Deadline: Dec. 31, 2024 (H.B. 502 as introduced).

Proposed Utah Code 17-41-402.2(1)(b), introduced

is considered to allow critical infrastructure materials operations and mining operations as a permitted use

Applied to a city or county that missed the deadline (H.B. 502 as introduced).

Utah Code 17-41-102(2), enrolled

The division shall conduct a study of critical infrastructure materials operations and related mining.

(H.B. 502 enrolled text)

Every version, and what changed

VersionDateWhat changed
IntroducedFeb. 7, 2024Zoning mandate by Dec. 31, 2024; deemed-allowed rule; standards that "unreasonably" limit operations, including overlay zoning, would not apply; utility service required; county 20-year materials plans by Nov. 30, 2024 (H.B. 502 as introduced).
1st Substitute (Snider)Feb. 22, 2024Adopted in House committee 11–0–3. Replaced the mandate with a Division of Oil, Gas, and Mining study (1st Substitute H.B. 502; Compare: 1st Substitute vs. introduced; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024).
2nd Substitute (Cullimore)March 1, 2024Adopted on the Senate floor by voice vote. Added the $500,000 one-time appropriation, a final report by the 2025 session, a July 1, 2026 repeal date and an "any other issue" study item; moved initial findings to Nov. 1, 2024 (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov; Compare: 2nd Substitute vs. 1st Substitute).
EnrolledSigned March 12, 2024Study only (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov; H.B. 502 enrolled text).

The votes

DateWhereResultRecord
Feb. 22, 2024House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment: adopt 1st Substitute11–0–3(House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024)
Feb. 22, 2024Same committee: favorable recommendation11–0–3(House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024)
Feb. 26, 2024House, 3rd reading57–16–2(H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov)
Feb. 27, 2024Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment5–2–1(H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov; Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502))
March 1, 2024Senate, 2nd and 3rd readings under suspension (2nd Sub.)19–9–1(H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov)
March 1, 2024House concurs with Senate amendment54–17–4(H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov)

Senate committee: yes, Sens. Grover, D. Owens, Sandall, Vickers and Winterton; no, Sens. Blouin and Pitcher; absent, Sen. Buxton (Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502)). House committee absences: Reps. Jimenez, Schultz and Shipp (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024). Then-Sen. Mike Kennedy voted yes on Senate passage, as covered in the Hive's UT-4 case file (Candidates 2026: UT-4 Kennedy vs. Larsen (H.B. 502 section)).

The timeline

  1. Feb. 7, 2024 H.B. 502 numbered and made public (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov).
  2. Feb. 22, 2024 House committee hears seven witnesses, then adopts the study-only 1st Substitute (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024).
  3. Feb. 26, 2024 House passes it 57–16–2 (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov).
  4. Feb. 27, 2024 Senate committee hears nine witnesses, two in opposition, and recommends it 5–2–1 (Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502)).
  5. March 1, 2024 Senate adopts the 2nd Substitute and passes it 19–9–1; House concurs 54–17–4 (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov).
  6. March 12, 2024 Gov. Cox signs it (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov).
  7. July 1, 2026 The study section's repeal date (H.B. 502 enrolled text).

From zoning mandate to study

Built only from the records on this page.

flowchart TD
  A["Introduced
cities and counties must
allow mining by 12/31/24"] --> B["House committee hearing
Feb. 22, 2024"] B --> C["1st Substitute
DOGM study only"] C --> D["Senate floor
2nd Substitute adds $500,000"] D --> E["Signed March 12, 2024"] E --> F["Study section repeals
July 1, 2026"]

In their own words

Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.

We found no recorded statement from the sponsors about why the bill was needed.

What happened next

Where it fits

Bills that changed the same rule, oldest first. This bill is highlighted.

Bills that change the same rule

  1. 2024 H.B. 502
    Introduced as a statewide mining zoning mandate; passed as a $500,000 state study.
  2. 2026 S.B. 254
    Extracted Natural Resources Amendments: critical minerals zones (Bill-Tracker case file).

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Rep. Casey SniderPrimary sponsor; presented in both committees (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024; Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502))
Sen. Kirk A. CullimoreSenate floor sponsor; sponsor of the 2nd Substitute (H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov; Compare: 2nd Substitute vs. 1st Substitute)
Rep. Keven J. StrattonMoved the 1st Substitute and the favorable recommendation (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024)
Jeff Silvestrini, Mayor of MillcreekSpoke in favor of the bill in House committee (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024)
Justin Lee, Utah League of Cities and TownsSpoke to the bill in both committees (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024; Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502))
Linda Smith, League of Women VotersSpoke "in favor of the 1st substitute of the bill" (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024)
Jeff Salt, Utah Anglers CoalitionSpoke in favor in House committee (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024)
Mick Thomas, Division of Oil, Gas, and MiningSpoke in favor in Senate committee (Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502))
Dave Kallas, Critical Infrastructure Materials CoalitionSpoke in favor in Senate committee (Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502))
Shelley Thayne Rich and Deborah GardnerSpoke in opposition in Senate committee (Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502))
Sen. Scott D. SandallMoved the Senate committee recommendation (Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502))
Mike KennedyThen a state senator; voted yes on Senate passage (Candidates 2026: UT-4 Kennedy vs. Larsen (H.B. 502 section))

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Utah Division of Oil, Gas, and MiningWhere is the study's final report posted, and what did it recommend?
Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment Interim Committee staffWas the study presented in November 2024, and is the recording public?
Your county commissionDoes our county plan for gravel and other construction materials, and where can residents read it?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

11
sources listed
6
votes recorded
4
versions compared
0
statements quoted

Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Status page, introduced and enrolled bills, both compare documents, the 2nd Substitute fiscal note and both committee minutes read on le.utah.gov through a web text-extraction tool on Oct. 19, 2026. Senate minutes are marked draft.

Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: the 1st Substitute's full text was read only through the compare documents; the Senate committee meeting date is not printed on the draft minutes page (Feb. 27, 2024 comes from the status page); whether the study's final report was delivered and where it is posted; names on the House floor and concurrence votes were not re-read for this page.

Sources

Show all 11 sources
  1. H.B. 502 (2024) bill status page, le.utah.gov: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/HB0502.html
  2. H.B. 502 as introduced: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/hbillint/HB0502.pdf
  3. 1st Substitute H.B. 502: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/hbillint/HB0502S01.pdf
  4. Compare: 1st Substitute vs. introduced: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/hbillint/HB0502S01_ComparedWith_HB0502.pdf
  5. Compare: 2nd Substitute vs. 1st Substitute: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/hbillint/HB0502S02_ComparedWith_HB0502S01.pdf
  6. H.B. 502 enrolled text: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/hbillenr/HB0502.pdf
  7. Fiscal note, 2nd Substitute: https://le.utah.gov/lfa/fnotes/2024/HB0502S02.fn.pdf
  8. House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 22, 2024: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2024/html/00001854.htm
  9. Senate Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment draft minutes (H.B. 502): https://le.utah.gov/interim/2024/html/00001929.htm
  10. Candidates 2026: UT-4 Kennedy vs. Larsen (H.B. 502 section): https://weber-county-hive.github.io/candidates2026/mike-kennedy-jonny-larsen-ut4.html
  11. Bill Tracker: S.B. 254 (2026): https://weber-county-hive.github.io/Bill-Tracker/weber-hive-sb254.html
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

People

Elsewhere on the Hive

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism