Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerTen Years of Petition LawsMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2023-199-PET · Initiatives & referendums

Two-Thirds, Then Unanimous: The Land Use Referendum Rule

As introduced, S.B. 199 would have made any land use law passed by two-thirds of a council off-limits to referendum. The House narrowed it to unanimous votes.

Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

BillS.B. 199 (2023 General), "Local Land Use Amendments"
Primary sponsorSen. Michael K. McKell
Floor sponsorRep. Mike Schultz
Final votesSenate committee 4-1-1 (2/13/23); Senate 18-6-5 (2nd reading, 2/14/23) and 19-5-5 (3rd reading, 2/17/23); House committee 5-4-2 (2/22/23); House 55-15-5 after a floor amendment (3/1/23); Senate concurred 16-9-4 (3/2/23)
StatusIn effect · Signed 3/23/2023

Graded by the collective rubric

DOverall · Hinders
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerDRemoves the referendum check for a municipal land use law passed by a unanimous vote, with nothing in its place (S.B. 199 enrolled text (copy pasted by the publisher from le.utah.gov)).
TransparencyBHeard in committee in both chambers, with public testimony for and against, and the narrowing amendment is on the record (Senate committee minutes, Feb. 13, 2023; House committee minutes, Feb. 22, 2023; House Floor Amendment 1, March 1, 2023).
Financial accountabilityN/ANot applicable: the fiscal note shows $0 (Fiscal note).
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactDResidents lose the referendum option for unanimous decisions, which can include large developments (S.B. 199 enrolled text (copy pasted by the publisher from le.utah.gov)).

Grade as published in The Rules Keep Changing (Referendum docket). Published reason, wording corrected Oct. 19, 2026 to match the enacted text and the sponsor's quoted words; grade unchanged. A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. These are the same grades as on Ten Years of Petition Laws. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Quoted from the enrolled bill the publisher pasted from le.utah.gov (S.B. 199 enrolled text (copy pasted by the publisher from le.utah.gov)).

Utah Code 20A-7-602.8(2)(b) · lines 43–48 (enrolled)

(b) In addition to the limitations of Subsection (2)(a), a proposed referendum is not legally referable to voters for a: (i) municipal land use law, as defined in Section 20A-7-101, if the land use law was passed by a unanimous vote of the local legislative body; or (ii) transit area land use law, as defined in Section 20A-7-601, if the transit area land use law was passed by a two-thirds vote of the local legislative body.

Part (ii) was already law from H.B. 462 (2022) (S.B. 199 enrolled text (copy pasted by the publisher from le.utah.gov)).

Same subsection · lines 43–46 (as introduced)

(b) In addition to the limitations of Subsection (2)(a), a proposed referendum is not legally referable to voters for a land use law, as defined in Section 20A-7-101, or a transit area land use law, as defined in Section 20A-7-601, if the land use law or transit area land use law was passed by a two-thirds vote of the local legislative body.

The introduced version, before the House changed it (S.B. 199 as introduced).

Every version, and what changed

VersionDateWhat changed
IntroducedFeb. 8, 2023Any land use law passed by two-thirds: not referable (S.B. 199 as introduced).
Senate committee and floorFeb. 13–17, 2023Passed unchanged. During Senate consideration, Sen. Nate Blouin asked McKell whether he would raise the threshold "to a unanimous local legislative vote rather than a supermajority"; McKell said, "I'd be happy to consider that" (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?").
House committeeFeb. 22, 2023Recommended 5–4. Rep. Paul Cutler moved to amend, then withdrew the motion (House committee vote, Feb. 22, 2023; House committee minutes, Feb. 22, 2023).
House Floor Amendment 1March 1, 2023Offered by Rep. Mike Schultz. "a land use law" became "municipal land use laws" and "two-thirds" became "unanimous"; the transit two-thirds rule stayed (House Floor Amendment 1, March 1, 2023; S.B. 199 amended text).
EnrolledSigned March 23, 2023Chapter 504; effective May 3, 2023 (S.B. 199 enrolled text (copy pasted by the publisher from le.utah.gov)).

The votes

DateWhereResultRecord
Feb. 13, 2023Senate Economic Development and Workforce Services Committee4–1–1(Senate committee vote, Feb. 13, 2023)
Feb. 14, 2023Senate, 2nd reading18–6–5(Senate 2nd reading roll call, Feb. 14, 2023)
Feb. 17, 2023Senate, 3rd reading19–5–5(S.B. 199 (2023) bill status page)
Feb. 22, 2023House Political Subdivisions Committee5–4–2(House committee vote, Feb. 22, 2023)
March 1, 2023House, after Floor Amendment 155–15–5(House 3rd reading roll call, March 1, 2023)
March 2, 2023Senate concurs with the House change16–9–4(Senate concurrence roll call, March 2, 2023)

House committee: yes, Reps. Dunnigan, Gwynn, Loubet, Teuscher, Walter; no, Reps. Bennion, Cutler, Kyle, Lesser (House committee vote, Feb. 22, 2023). House floor: Rep. Brady Brammer voted yes; Reps. Kyle, Lisonbee and Thurston were absent (House 3rd reading roll call, March 1, 2023). Senate concurrence: no votes were Sens. Bramble, Fillmore, Harper, Johnson, Kennedy, Kwan, McCay, Wilson and Winterton (Senate concurrence roll call, March 2, 2023).

The timeline

  1. Aug. 1, 2022 A Spanish Fork referendum on the Modera rezone, a 668-unit development, is declared insufficient: it needed 6,013 signatures and had 870 (Spanish Fork City, "Referendum Z09-22"; Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?").
  2. Feb. 8, 2023 S.B. 199 introduced with the two-thirds rule (S.B. 199 as introduced).
  3. Feb. 13–14, 2023 Senate committee hearing and Deseret News coverage; McKell says the process is "being weaponized" (Senate committee minutes, Feb. 13, 2023; Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?").
  4. March 1, 2023 House narrows it to unanimous votes and passes it 55–15–5 (House Floor Amendment 1, March 1, 2023; House 3rd reading roll call, March 1, 2023).
  5. March 2, 2023 Senate agrees 16–9–4 (Senate concurrence roll call, March 2, 2023).
  6. March 23, 2023 Gov. Cox signs it (S.B. 199 (2023) bill status page).
  7. March 27, 2023 Mountain Green residents file a referendum on a Morgan County rezone passed 4–1 (Morgan County News, May 15, 2023; Morgan County News, March 30, 2023).
  8. May 3, 2023 Takes effect (S.B. 199 enrolled text (copy pasted by the publisher from le.utah.gov)).

How the rule changed on its way through

Built only from the records on this page.

flowchart TD
  A["Introduced: any land use law
passed by two-thirds
cannot be referred"] --> B["Senate passes it
unchanged"] B --> C["House floor amendment:
only a municipal land use law
passed unanimously"] C --> D["Transit-area two-thirds rule
from H.B. 462 stays"] D --> E["Signed March 23, 2023"]

In their own words

Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.

What's happening across the state is the referendum process is being weaponized to hurt developers and cities

— Sen. Mike McKell, primary sponsor, Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023 (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?")

We have an affordable housing issue in this state, and it's going to be really difficult to address

— Sen. Mike McKell, Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023 (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?")

What I want to do is make sure we really address this issue and give some deference to our local authorities.

— Sen. Mike McKell, on amending the bill, Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023 (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?")

Exercising this right that is guaranteed under the Utah Constitution should be made easier for the people, not harder,

— Jackie Larson, Spanish Fork resident, Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023 (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?")

Categorically, I oppose any limits on referendums,

— Sen. Karen Kwan, Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023 (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?")

If there is a supermajority (decision) ... we believe that speaks very loudly for the decision.

— Seth Perrins, Spanish Fork city manager, Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023 (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?")

What happened next

Where it fits

How this law builds on the ones before it, from How they stack.

Local land-use referendums

  1. 2016 H.B. 10 B−
    widened "local law" so residents can refer more kinds of local action
  2. 2019 H.B. 119 D
    added a step to decide whether a measure is "legally referable to voters," and land-use rules
  3. 2021 H.B. 23 C+
    changed the definition of a land-use law and same-year ballot timing
  4. 2022 H.B. 462 D
    some transit-area land-use laws not referable after a two-thirds council vote; higher signature counts for the rest
  5. 2023 S.B. 199 D
    introduced as two-thirds for any land-use law; passed as "municipal" land-use laws not referable after a unanimous vote
  6. 2024 S.B. 100 C+
    opened some revenue-bond decisions to local referendum

Where it ended up: It started wider in 2016. Since 2019, three of these laws (H.B. 119, H.B. 462 and S.B. 199) set conditions that keep some land-use laws off the ballot. S.B. 100 added a kind of decision that is not a land-use law.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Sen. Michael K. McKellPrimary sponsor (S.B. 199 (2023) bill status page)Referendum docket: The Rules Keep Changing
Rep. Mike Schultz (now Speaker)House floor sponsor; offered the amendment that changed two-thirds to unanimous (House Floor Amendment 1, March 1, 2023)Candidates 2026: HD-12
Sen. Nate BlouinAsked during Senate consideration whether McKell would move to a unanimous threshold (Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?")—
Rep. Jason KyleVoted no in House committee; absent for the House floor vote (House committee vote, Feb. 22, 2023; House 3rd reading roll call, March 1, 2023)Candidates 2026: HD-8
Rep. Brady BrammerVoted yes on the House floor (House 3rd reading roll call, March 1, 2023)Candidates 2026: SD-21
Sen. Karen KwanVoted no in Senate committee (Senate committee vote, Feb. 13, 2023)Candidates 2026: SD-12
Sen. Ronald WintertonVoted no on Senate concurrence (Senate concurrence roll call, March 2, 2023)Candidates 2026: SD-20
Spanish Fork Mayor Mike Mendenhall and City Manager Seth PerrinsSpoke for the bill in Senate committee (Senate committee minutes, Feb. 13, 2023)—

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Your city attorneyHas our city ever rejected a referendum because a land use law passed unanimously?
Your county attorneyDoes the S.B. 199 unanimous rule apply to county votes, since "municipal land use law" is not defined in 20A-7-101?
Your state senatorWould you support defining "municipal land use law" so residents know when they can and cannot refer a decision?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

22
sources listed
6
votes recorded
5
versions compared
6
statements quoted

Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Built from the S.B. 199 research packet and the enrolled bill and status page the publisher pasted from le.utah.gov.

Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: names on the Senate 3rd reading roll call (rate-limited); whether "municipal land use law" is defined anywhere in code; Jackie Larson's position on Feb. 22, 2023 (House minutes say "support," other records say opposition); the outcome of the Mountain Green petition.

Sources

Show all 22 sources
  1. S.B. 199 (2023) bill status page: https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/static/SB0199.html
  2. S.B. 199 as introduced: https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/sbillint/SB0199.htm
  3. House Floor Amendment 1, March 1, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/~2023/pamend/sb0199.hfap.01.pdf
  4. S.B. 199 amended text: https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/sbillamd/SB0199.htm
  5. S.B. 199 enrolled text (copy pasted by the publisher from le.utah.gov): https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/sbillenr/SB0199.htm
  6. Senate committee vote, Feb. 13, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/mtgvotes.jsp?voteid=27174
  7. Senate committee minutes, Feb. 13, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2023/html/00002006.htm
  8. Senate 2nd reading roll call, Feb. 14, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2023GS&voteid=699&house=S
  9. House committee vote, Feb. 22, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/mtgvotes.jsp?voteid=27897
  10. House committee minutes, Feb. 22, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2023/html/00002163.htm
  11. House 3rd reading roll call, March 1, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2023GS&voteid=1357&house=H
  12. Senate concurrence roll call, March 2, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/DynaBill/svotes.jsp?sessionid=2023GS&voteid=1752&house=S
  13. Fiscal note: https://le.utah.gov/lfa/fnotes/2023/SB0199.fn.pdf
  14. Deseret News, Feb. 14, 2023, "Have referendums been 'weaponized' against housing projects?": https://www.deseret.com/utah/2023/2/14/23599487/housing-market-crisis-referendum-weaponized-utah-bill/
  15. Spanish Fork City, "Referendum Z09-22": https://www.spanishfork.gov/news_detail_T17_R385.php
  16. Morgan County News, May 15, 2023: https://www.themorgannews.com/2023/05/15/435369/residents-file-referendum-petition-to-get-mountain-green-rezone-on-the-ballot
  17. Morgan County News, March 30, 2023: https://themorgannews.com/2023/03/30/430568/despite-intense-public-opposition-county-leaders-approve-rezone-in-mountain-green
  18. Utah Code 20A-7-101, 2023 copy (Justia): https://law.justia.com/codes/utah/2023/title-20a/chapter-7/part-1/section-101/
  19. Utah Code 20A-7-101, current copy (Justia): https://law.justia.com/codes/utah/title-20a/chapter-7/part-1/section-101/
  20. ULCT, "Charting Utah's Growth Legislation," Sept. 2023: https://www.ulct.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/Charting-Utahs-Growth-Legislation_FINAL_compressed.pdf
  21. Park Record, letter to the editor, July 11, 2026: https://www.parkrecord.com/2026/07/11/should-be-a-vote/
  22. The Rules Keep Changing, Part 2 (published grade): https://webercountyhive-coder.github.io/referendum/utah-referendum-law-history-part-2.html#rubric
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

People

Elsewhere on the Hive

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism