Bill Tracker · CASE 2025-277-REC · Public records
S.B. 277 ended the seven-member State Records Committee that heard public records appeals and gave the job to one director appointed by the governor. The plan to drop GRAMA's balancing test did not survive.
Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026
| Bill | S.B. 277 (2025 General Session), "Government Records Management Amendments" |
| Primary sponsor | Sen. Michael K. McKell |
| Floor sponsor | Rep. Jefferson Moss |
| Final votes | Senate 21–8–0 (Feb. 27, 2025); House 44–23–8 (Mar. 5, 2025); Senate concurred 18–6–5 (Mar. 6, 2025) |
| Status | Law · Signed Mar. 27, 2025; effective date not confirmed from the bill text |
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | D | A seven-member body with citizen and media seats was replaced by one official the governor appoints. Senate consent, a for-cause removal rule and district court review remain as checks, so this is a weakened check, not one removed with nothing in its place (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text; Utah News Dispatch, "Utah lawmakers look to dissolve, replace State Records Committee. Here's why that matters," Katie McKellar, Feb. 14, 2025; KUER, "Lawmakers give the green light to dissolve Utah's 7-member State Records Committee," Sean Higgins, March 6, 2025). |
| Transparency | C | The process was public: the bill had committee hearings in both chambers, every passage vote was a recorded roll call, and opponents were heard. The final bill kept the balancing test and added a performance evaluation of the director (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text; LegiScan, S.B. 277 (2025): history and roll calls; KUER, "Lawmakers give the green light to dissolve Utah's 7-member State Records Committee," Sean Higgins, March 6, 2025). |
| Financial accountability | C | We did not read the fiscal note, so we cannot say what the new office costs. Nothing in the text we read shifts costs to records requesters (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text). |
| Environmental impact | N/A | Not applicable. |
| Community impact | D | Members of the public lose the citizen and media seats on the body that hears their appeals. Early results reported in 2026 show faster decisions, with appellants winning about a third of the time (Utah News Dispatch, "Utah lawmakers look to dissolve, replace State Records Committee. Here's why that matters," Katie McKellar, Feb. 14, 2025; Salt Lake Tribune, "Utah's new public records chief is deciding cases twice as fast as the committee — but not everyone's happy," Robert Gehrke, Aug. 20, 2026). |
New grade, Oct. 19, 2026. The citizen panel was replaced by one appointed official, which weakens a public check, but the bill kept the balancing test and court review, and every passage vote was a recorded roll call. Average 1.5 = C−. A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.
Quoted from the enrolled bill (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text). Where the bill strikes the words "State Records Committee" and puts in "director," we quote only the words that remain.
General description
replaces the State Records Committee (the committee) with the director of the office,
The director is described as "an attorney with knowledge and experience relating to government records law" (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text).
Utah Code 63A-12-202(1)
There is created within the division the Government Records Office.
The division is the Division of Archives and Records Service (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text).
Highlighted provisions
requires the governor to appoint the director of the office, in consultation with the executive director of the department, and with the advice and consent of the Senate;
Utah Code 63G-2-403(11)(b), the balancing test
if the public interest favoring access is greater than or equal to the interest favoring restriction of access.
The director may order release of a private, controlled or protected record when this test is met. The bill as introduced would have removed it (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text; Utah News Dispatch, "Utah lawmakers look to dissolve, replace State Records Committee. Here's why that matters," Katie McKellar, Feb. 14, 2025).
Utah Code 63G-2-403(14)
may seek judicial review in district court
A party to a proceeding before the director keeps the right to go to court (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text).
| Version | Date | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| Introduced (Sen. McKell) | Feb. 13, 2025 | Would have replaced the committee with a director and removed GRAMA's balancing test (LegiScan, S.B. 277 (2025): history and roll calls; Utah News Dispatch, "Utah lawmakers look to dissolve, replace State Records Committee. Here's why that matters," Katie McKellar, Feb. 14, 2025). |
| 1st Substitute | Feb. 18, 2025 | Senate Government Operations and Political Subdivisions Committee, 5–0 to substitute. News coverage reported the balancing-test removal was pulled before this hearing (LegiScan, S.B. 277 (2025): history and roll calls; "Senate panel advances major change to Utah public records law" (syndicated copy on Yahoo News; outlet and date not shown on the copy read)). |
| 2nd Substitute | Feb. 26, 2025 | Substituted on the Senate floor, then passed 2nd reading 18–7 (LegiScan, S.B. 277 (2025): history and roll calls). |
| 3rd Substitute | March 3, 2025 | House Government Operations Committee, 11–0 to substitute (LegiScan, S.B. 277 (2025): history and roll calls). |
| 4th Substitute | March 5, 2025 | Adopted on the House floor by voice vote; the Senate concurred March 6 (LegiScan, S.B. 277 (2025): history and roll calls). |
| Enrolled | Signed March 27, 2025 | Keeps the balancing test; adds a performance evaluation of the director; repeals the committee (S.B. 277 (2025) enrolled text; KUER, "Lawmakers give the green light to dissolve Utah's 7-member State Records Committee," Sean Higgins, March 6, 2025). |
Vote counts are from LegiScan's copy of the Legislature's roll calls (LegiScan, S.B. 277 (2025): history and roll calls); KUER reported the same House count (KUER, "Lawmakers give the green light to dissolve Utah's 7-member State Records Committee," Sean Higgins, March 6, 2025). Names on each roll call were not pulled for this page. Every vote listed was recorded.
Built only from the records on this page.
flowchart TD A["Records request
denied"] --> B["Appeal to the
agency head"] B --> C{"Next appeal"} C -->|"Before 2025"| D["State Records Committee
7 members"] C -->|"After S.B. 277"| E["Government Records Office
1 director"] D --> F["District court"] E --> F E --> G["Balancing test
still applies"]
Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.
I think 156 days is way too long,
— Sen. Mike McKell, primary sponsor, on the committee's average decision time, Utah News Dispatch, Feb. 14, 2025 (Utah News Dispatch, "Utah lawmakers look to dissolve, replace State Records Committee. Here's why that matters," Katie McKellar, Feb. 14, 2025)
we need objectivity instead of subjectivity.
— Sen. Mike McKell, on his reason for removing the balancing test as introduced, Utah News Dispatch, Feb. 14, 2025 (Utah News Dispatch, "Utah lawmakers look to dissolve, replace State Records Committee. Here's why that matters," Katie McKellar, Feb. 14, 2025)
The Committee should be retained and strengthened, not abolished,
— Utah Media Coalition statement, Utah News Dispatch, Feb. 14, 2025 (Utah News Dispatch, "Utah lawmakers look to dissolve, replace State Records Committee. Here's why that matters," Katie McKellar, Feb. 14, 2025)
It's going to do irreparable harm to our open records statute,
— Jeff Hunt, First Amendment and media attorney, Utah News Dispatch, Feb. 14, 2025 (Utah News Dispatch, "Utah lawmakers look to dissolve, replace State Records Committee. Here's why that matters," Katie McKellar, Feb. 14, 2025)
These appeals are taking longer and longer to move through.
— Sen. Mike McKell, Feb. 18, 2025 Senate committee hearing, KUER, March 6, 2025 (KUER, "Lawmakers give the green light to dissolve Utah's 7-member State Records Committee," Sean Higgins, March 6, 2025)
I think the numbers speak for themself.
— Sen. Mike McKell, Salt Lake Tribune, Aug. 20, 2026 (Salt Lake Tribune, "Utah's new public records chief is deciding cases twice as fast as the committee — but not everyone's happy," Robert Gehrke, Aug. 20, 2026)
With the director, it feels more like he has his mind made up before the hearing
— Sydnee Chapman, Utah Investigative Journalism Project, Salt Lake Tribune, Aug. 20, 2026 (Salt Lake Tribune, "Utah's new public records chief is deciding cases twice as fast as the committee — but not everyone's happy," Robert Gehrke, Aug. 20, 2026)
I feel like I try to take each one on the merits.
— Lonny Pehrson, Government Records Office director, Salt Lake Tribune, Aug. 20, 2026 (Salt Lake Tribune, "Utah's new public records chief is deciding cases twice as fast as the committee — but not everyone's happy," Robert Gehrke, Aug. 20, 2026)
Bills that changed the same rule, oldest first. This bill is highlighted.
Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Enrolled bill read through a text-extraction tool. Vote counts and history from LegiScan. News articles read online. The balancing-test outcome was checked two ways: the enrolled text of 63G-2-403(11)(b) and KUER's report that the test remains.
Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.
None found yet.
None found yet.
Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism