The Hive bee sealUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
Transparency · TR 300.18← Transparency home · ← Hive library (every repo)
The Hive Weber County
← Transparency: Accountability Case Files
Transparency · Courts & Oversight

Behind the Bench: What Utah Keeps Confidential About Judge and Lawyer Complaints, and What It Makes Public

Part 2 of 2: Records, the Bar, and what could be better

The Weber County Hive · Independent Accountability Journalism

CASE 2026-JUD-01 · Posted Sept. 24, 2026 · Updated Oct. 17, 2026 · Page look updated Nov. 2, 2026

New to this? Read it in plain words One short page for both parts, with simple charts.
Short version (Part 2)
Transparency pages (27) · tap to open
  1. Transparency docketEvery case file, searchable
  2. The 2026 Amendments · plain wordsAmendments A and B on your ballot
  3. Amendment B: Myth vs. Fact · plain wordsClaims checked against the record
  4. Amendment B QuizTest what you know
  5. Who Sits at the Taxpayers Association's Table · plain wordsIts leaders, lobbyists, sponsors and their money
  6. Weber Housing Authority · plain wordsA commissioner, his wife and the authority that pays their company
  7. What the Privacy Office Can and Can't Do · plain wordsUtah's Chief Privacy Officer
  8. Counting the Jobs · plain wordsJob promises and what was reported
  9. Matt Brower · plain wordsThe board seat that never came up
  10. Ten Days · plain wordsThe Nilson Foundation's 501(c)(3) claim
  11. One Vote, Four Checks · plain wordsS.B. 258 and preliminary municipalities
  12. The Land Counties Can't Zone · plain wordsTrust land and county zoning
  13. SITLA: The Land Nobody Zones · plain wordsWho answers for trust land
  14. Tyson Leaves Eagle Mountain · plain wordsFive years after opening
  15. Behind the Bench · plain wordsJudge and lawyer complaints in Utah
  16. Wrong Room, Right Message · plain wordsA housing adviser in Heber City
  17. Every Weber County Property Tax Increase Since 2019 · plain wordsThe full list
  18. A New Line on the Bill · plain wordsRoy and Riverdale fire annexation
  19. Paying for the Next Station · plain wordsHow Weber Fire District funds growth
  20. Weber County's New Sales Tax · plain wordsA public vote, but no vote by the public
  21. Bills That Did the Opposite · plain wordsBait and switch, 2018 to 2026
  22. The Blank Box · plain wordsThree disclosure forms, one pattern
  23. Utah's Campaign-Finance Enforcement Gap · plain wordsComplaints filed, few penalties
  24. One Lake, Two Money Pots · plain wordsThe Great Salt Lake Trust Council
  25. Wells at the Top · plain wordsPowder Mountain's water
  26. Then vs. Now · plain wordsEarlier plans and later approvals in Ogden Valley
  27. West Haven's 6% Energy Tax · plain wordsA new line on the power bill

When the confidentiality rule was tested in 2026

The confidentiality statute described above was tested in public this spring, and the Legislature changed the law in the same session.

The statute is explained in Part 1: Complaints about judges.

Spring 2026, in order

What H.B. 186 changed

More public

  • The commission must report to the Legislature's Judiciary Interim Committee before Nov. 1 each year: complaints received, how they were resolved, and descriptions of informal resolutions and final orders
  • An annual report of the commission's activities (the law doesn't say where it must be posted)

More protected, or newly required

  • Commission records are now classified as "protected records"
  • Annual reports may not identify a judge except through final Supreme Court orders
  • Prosecutors and the Administrative Office of the Courts must file complaints in certain cases
Watch For

The first annual report under H.B. 186 is due before Nov. 1, 2026. It may supply the complaint and resolution numbers that this piece could not read from the commission's scanned FY2023, FY2025 and FY2026 reports.

Added Oct. 17, 2026: Not found yet. On Oct. 17, the JCC's annual reports page listed reports through FY2026 and nothing labeled as an H.B. 186 report, and the Legislature's Judiciary Interim Committee page listed no meetings. The commission met Sept. 1 and Oct. 6, 2026, with a "Statistical Report" on each public agenda. The public handouts for those meetings are posted as scanned images and could not be read for this update. Sources: JCC annual reports; Sept. 1 notice; Oct. 6 notice.

Other 2026 court bills

Several other 2026 bills changed how Utah's courts work. Here is what each one does, in plain terms, and where The Weber County Hive has covered it.

S.B. 134: bigger courts, and the governor picks the chief justice
Expands the Utah Supreme Court from 5 to 7 justices and the Court of Appeals from 7 to 9 judges, and adds some district judgeships. The chief justice is now appointed by the governor with Senate consent, for an 8-year term, instead of being chosen by the other justices. Signed Jan. 31, 2026. Sponsors: Sen. Chris Wilson; House sponsor Rep. Casey Snider.Added Oct. 17, 2026: Gov. Cox appointed 5th District Judge Matthew Bell and attorney Michael Menssen to two Supreme Court seats on Aug. 28, 2026, and the Senate confirmed both 26–2 on Sept. 16 (Utah News Dispatch via KPCW, Sept. 17, 2026). The agenda for the Judicial Council's Oct. 6, 2026 meeting lists Jill Pohlman as Interim Chief Justice (Utah Public Notice Website). No announcement of a governor-appointed chief justice was found in searches on Oct. 17, 2026.
Hive coverage: Judiciary committee page, rated Harm.
H.B. 392 and H.B. 366: three-judge panels for challenges to state laws
H.B. 392 creates three-judge panels, drawn from different districts, for lawsuits claiming a state law is unconstitutional. Only the attorney general, the governor or the Legislature can ask to move a case to a panel. H.B. 366 adds a $1,500 filing fee and a backup "Constitutional Court" that takes over those cases if a court strikes down the panel law. Its judges are picked through a nominating commission appointed by the governor. H.B. 366 also lets the Business and Chancery Court choose which of its decisions to publish. Sponsors: H.B. 392, Rep. Matt MacPherson and Sen. Mike McKell; H.B. 366, Rep. Jordan Teuscher and Sen. Brady Brammer.
S.J.R. 5: the court rules that carry out the panel transfers
Amends Utah's civil procedure rules so the attorney general, the governor or the Legislature can file a notice within 45 days to move a pending case to a three-judge panel, and the assigned judge must transfer it. Parties can't move to disqualify the panel as a whole. It also requires a fast transfer to the Business and Chancery Court when a party asks within 21 days. Because it changes court rules, it needed a two-thirds vote of both chambers; it passed the Senate 21–7–1. Sponsors: Sen. Brady Brammer; House sponsor Rep. Jordan Teuscher.
Hive coverage: Senate District 21 case file. Not yet rated on the Judiciary committee page.
S.B. 233: timeliness standards and judge evaluations
Sets deadlines for how quickly Supreme Court justices and Court of Appeals judges issue opinions, lets evaluation reports include how often a judge is reversed on appeal for abuse of discretion, and changes the evaluation commission's procedures: it may discuss a judge in closed session, must vote in public, and keeps each commissioner's vote protected. Sponsors: Sen. Brady Brammer; House sponsor Rep. Karianne Lisonbee.
Hive coverage: Judiciary committee page, rated Mixed.
H.B. 540: court records, audio and judges' disclosures
Requires one public court-records website with 50 free searches and downloads a month; registering requires identity, address and citizenship status. Proceedings must be audio recorded, with copies available on request; the Judicial Council must report by Nov. 30, 2026 on whether to make audio freely available. Judges must file public financial and conflict-of-interest disclosures. Law firms suing a Utah government entity can't hire a departed judge for two years. Sponsors: Rep. Logan Monson; Senate sponsor Sen. Brady Brammer.
Hive coverage: Judiciary committee page, rated Help.

All passed in the 2026 General Session. Summaries from the enrolled bill texts on le.utah.gov.

Open-records law and the courts

Utah's Government Records Access and Management Act applies to the courts, the Judicial Council and the Administrative Office of the Courts. What the judiciary is not subject to is GRAMA's appeals process. Court records are handled under the Utah Code of Judicial Administration's own records rules, Rules 4-201 through 4-206. Separate statutes, like the one covering JCC files, make certain records confidential regardless.

So the accurate version of the claim is narrower than "exempt": the courts are covered by GRAMA, follow their own rules for records requests and appeals, and some oversight files are closed by other statutes.

Covered by GRAMA

  • The courts
  • The Judicial Council
  • The Administrative Office of the Courts

Handled separately

  • Records appeals, under court rules 4-201 to 4-206
  • Judicial Conduct Commission files, closed by statute
  • Federal FOIA: applies only to federal agencies

What the Utah State Bar is

The Utah State Bar says it "was formally established as an administrative arm of the judiciary, operating under the authority of the Utah Supreme Court" in 1931. It is registered with the Utah Division of Corporations as a nonprofit corporation, with a filing date of June 24, 1991. That is a registration date, not the Bar's founding. It operates under the Supreme Court's constitutional authority over the practice of law. The court sets the rules for admission and discipline, and lawyer discipline cases are decided by screening panels and the courts.

Where the public can look

RecordWhere
Public sanctions against judgesjcc.utah.gov/public-dispositions
Dismissals with warning (no names)jcc.utah.gov/dismissals-with-warnings
JCC annual reportsjcc.utah.gov/annual-reports
Lawyer public disciplineopcutah.org/lawyer-public-discipline
Judge evaluations before retention votesjudges.utah.gov
File a complaint about a judgejcc.utah.gov
File a complaint about a lawyeropcutah.org
Court records rulesUtah Code of Judicial Administration, Rules 4-201 to 4-206

Grades, and what could be done better

Each part of the system is graded separately on The Weber County Hive's five standing questions: power, transparency, financial accountability, environmental impact and community impact. Grades reflect what the public record shows, not the conduct of any individual. Meeting a legal minimum is not treated as above average.

Complaints about judges (Judicial Conduct Commission)

PowerCNon-lawyer public seats are required by law and the Supreme Court has the final word, but at least 6 of 11 current members are lawyers or judges, 4 are legislators who also write court laws, and the public has no role in outcomes.
TransparencyDComplaints and investigations are closed; no reasons or categories for dismissals are published; warnings are posted without names; three recent annual reports are scanned images; six public sanctions in six years are what the public sees. The commission's website posts no current member roster.
Financial accountabilityNot gradedThe commission's budget was not reviewed for this piece.
Environmental impactNot applicable
Community impactC−A person who files a complaint learns the outcome but not the reasoning, and the public learns almost nothing about complaints that don't end in a sanction.

Complaints about lawyers (Office of Professional Conduct)

PowerCThe Supreme Court sets the rules and courts decide serious cases, with no outside or public role in individual outcomes.
TransparencyDComplaints stay confidential until a court filing, and 1,031 cases closed in 2025 without one. Annual reports are public but use different categories from year to year.
Financial accountabilityNot gradedThe office's budget was not reviewed for this piece.
Environmental impactNot applicable
Community impactC−People who complain have limited visibility into what happens and why.

H.B. 186 (2026)

PowerCAdds required referrals from prosecutors and the courts' administrative office, but doesn't change who decides complaints.
TransparencyC+Design: a new annual report to the Legislature is a gain, but the same bill classifies the commission's records as protected and keeps judges' names out of the report, and it doesn't say where the public report must be posted. Outcome: the records release it addressed happened after it was signed and before it took effect.
Financial accountabilityNot gradedNo fiscal provisions reviewed.
Environmental impactNot applicable
Community impactCLegislators get new numbers; whether the public gets the same numbers depends on how the report is posted.

Judicial selection and retention

PowerB−A nominating commission, Senate confirmation and retention votes are three real checks on the governor's appointments.
TransparencyC+Evaluations are published and the evaluation commission must vote in public, but under S.B. 233 (2026) it may discuss a judge in closed session and each commissioner's vote is a protected record; only the final vote is disclosed.
Financial accountabilityNot gradedNot reviewed.
Environmental impactNot applicable
Community impactCVoters get an evaluation for every judge, but retention elections are unopposed yes-or-no votes.

What could have been done better for the public

Each option below addresses a gap already documented in this piece. None requires naming a judge or lawyer in an unresolved complaint.

What the record showsAn option that keeps the same goal
Three recent JCC annual reports are posted only as scanned imagesPost text versions that can be searched and read by screen readers
No reasons or categories are published for dismissed judge complaintsPublish counts by category, such as "disagreement with a ruling" or "insufficient evidence," with no names
Judge complaints rose from 85 to 183 with no explanationExplain significant changes in each annual report
The JCC website posts no current member rosterPost the roster, with each member's seat type and profession
H.B. 186 was signed March 23 but took effect May 6; it passed 70–0–5 and 25–1–3Utah bills that pass by two-thirds of both chambers can take effect on signing; the records provision could have
H.B. 186 doesn't say where the public report must be postedRequire posting on the commission's and the Legislature's websites
Lawyer-discipline reports change categories from year to yearUse the same categories every year so years can be compared
1,031 lawyer cases were dismissed or declined in 2025 with no public reasonsPublish counts by reason, with no names
Individual evaluation-commission votes on judges are protected recordsRecord each commissioner's vote, as legislators' own votes are recorded
People who file complaints learn outcomes but not reasonsA plain-language status and outcome notice for complainants

What the system does do

  • Public sanctions against judges are posted
  • Warnings are posted, without names
  • Both offices publish annual reports
  • Non-lawyer public seats are required by law
  • Every judge faces Senate confirmation and voters
  • Evaluation votes on judges happen in public

Still unanswered in the record

  • Why judge complaints rose from 85 to 183
  • Why individual complaints were dismissed
  • How the Hagen records reached the House
  • Where H.B. 186's public report will be posted

Questions the public can ask, and who can answer them

Each question comes from a gap documented above. Asking in writing or at a public meeting puts the answer on the record.

Why did complaints about judges rise from 85 to 183?
The commission's reports don't say.
Ask the Judicial Conduct Commission: "What explains the increase, and will future annual reports explain significant changes?"
Why are complaints dismissed?
No categories or counts are published.
Ask the Judicial Conduct Commission: "Will you publish how many complaints were dismissed for each reason, without names?"
Can the reports and roster be readable online?
Three recent annual reports are scanned images, and the website has no member roster.
Ask the Judicial Conduct Commission: "Will you post text versions of the FY2023, FY2025 and FY2026 reports and a current roster with each member's seat type?"
Where will the new H.B. 186 report be posted?
The law requires a report before Nov. 1 each year but doesn't say where the public version goes.
Ask the Judicial Conduct Commission and the Judiciary Interim Committee: "When will the first report be presented, and will it be posted online for the public?"
How did the Hagen records reach the House?
Speaker Schultz's office said it "followed the statute." Teuscher and Brammer said they did not provide the records. How the House obtained them is not in the record.
Ask the Utah House Speaker's office: "How did the House obtain the Judicial Conduct Commission's records, and which statute did it rely on to release them?"
Why are most lawyer complaints closed without a public record?
1,031 cases were dismissed or declined in 2025, with no public reasons, and report categories change from year to year.
Ask the Office of Professional Conduct: "Will you publish dismissals by reason and use the same categories every year?"
Should evaluation votes on judges be public by name?
Under S.B. 233, each commissioner's vote is a protected record.
Ask your state legislators: "Should individual commissioners' votes on whether a judge meets standards be public, as legislators' votes are?"
Who should fill the Judicial Conduct Commission's legislator seats?
The law reserves three public seats for non-lawyers but doesn't limit who fills the four legislator seats. Today at least 6 of 11 members are lawyers or judges.
Ask your state legislators: "Should the law address the balance of lawyers and non-lawyers across all seats?"
When will court audio be free to the public?
H.B. 540 requires a recommendation by Nov. 30, 2026.Added Oct. 17, 2026: A Sept. 29, 2026 staff memo in the materials for the Judicial Council's Oct. 6 meeting, listed as an action item, recommends that "the actual impacts of the changes from HB0540 be understood" first. It says audio is already available to the public on request for a one-time fee of $10–$15, and that making it free would mean shifting that cost to taxpayers. Whether the council adopted the memo was not found. Source: Judicial Council meeting materials, Oct. 6, 2026 (text extraction).
Ask the Utah courts' Administrative Office / Judicial Council: "What will you recommend, and when could free audio start?"

Where to direct questions

OfficeHow to reach
Judicial Conduct Commission801-468-0021 · 1385 S. State St., Suite 401, Salt Lake City · complaint form at jcc.utah.gov/complaint-form
Office of Professional Conductopcutah.org/contact · complaint form at opcutah.org/file-a-complaint
Judiciary Interim CommitteeMeeting schedule and members at le.utah.gov (committee "INTJUD")
Utah House, including the Speaker's office801-538-1408 · house.utleg.gov
Your state legislatorsFind them at le.utah.gov
Judicial Performance Evaluation Commissionjudges.utah.gov
Utah courts (Administrative Office / Judicial Council)utcourts.gov

Contact details from each office's own website.

What the record shows, and what's still open

What the record shows is public

  • Public sanctions are posted on the JCC website
  • Warnings are posted, without names
  • Annual reports with complaint totals
  • Lawyer cases become public once filed
  • Judge evaluations published before each retention vote
  • Senate confirmation and retention elections for every judge

What the public can't see

  • Complaints against judges that are dismissed
  • Why individual complaints were dismissed
  • Lawyer complaints closed before a formal case
  • Complaint totals for three recent JCC years, posted only as scanned images (the first H.B. 186 report, due Nov. 1, 2026, should help)
  • How the commission's Hagen records reached the House

The law balances two interests here. Keeping complaints confidential protects judges and lawyers from public harm over complaints that turn out to be unfounded, and protects people who complain. The cost is that the public sees only the small share of complaints that end in public discipline, and has to trust the process for the rest.

Updates for this part

Records found online that bear on this part. All updates are in Part 1.

Words to know

Tap a card to see what it means. More terms are at the top of Part 1.

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

19
Sources listed in the original page
38
Records and pages opened for the Oct. 17 update
9
Reader questions kept, with whom to ask
17
Searches run for the Oct. 17 update (estimate)

Posted Sept. 24, 2026. Updated Oct. 17, 2026: split into two linked parts, new layout and White & navy colors, larger print, a short version for each part, a plain-words page, updates since posting (the Nov. 3 retention ballot and JPEC's recommendations, the JCC's new FY2027 warnings list, the pending H.B. 186 report, the H.B. 540 audio memo, proposed lawyer-discipline rule changes, Supreme Court appointments), dated notes next to related items, words to know, questions to ask, links to related Hive pages, and links added for sources that had none. No earlier facts, numbers or wording changed.

Sources

Added Oct. 17, 2026

Public records only. No comment requested.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Transparency home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack