When the confidentiality rule was tested in 2026
The confidentiality statute described above was tested in public this spring, and the Legislature changed the law in the same session.
The statute is explained in Part 1: Complaints about judges.
Spring 2026, in order
- Feb. 3 and Feb. 13, 2026H.B. 186, "Judicial Conduct Commission Amendments," passes the House 70–0–5 and the Senate 25–1–3. Primary sponsor: Rep. Jordan Teuscher. Senate sponsor: Sen. Brady Brammer. Both sit on the Judicial Conduct Commission.
- March 23, 2026Gov. Cox signs H.B. 186. It is set to take effect May 6.
- April 17–18, 2026After news reports on allegations against Justice Diana Hagen, which Utah News Dispatch described as allegations of an affair with an attorney, the Utah House releases the commission's complaint and preliminary investigation report to news outlets in response to records requests. The commission had dismissed the complaint; the investigator found "insufficient evidence of judicial misconduct."
- April 18, 2026The Utah Supreme Court: "Despite their protected status, records of the Judicial Conduct Commission were inappropriately released to the public." The court's statement says she was "recusing herself from further involvement" in the League of Women Voters' redistricting lawsuit, and that her last involvement in it was in October 2024. House Speaker Mike Schultz: "We followed the statute in releasing these records."
- April 20, 2026Teuscher and Brammer tell Utah News Dispatch they did not provide the records. Teuscher says the law barred the commission itself from releasing its records but was "super ambiguous" about others, which H.B. 186 would clarify by classifying them as protected records. The release came after H.B. 186 was signed but before it took effect.
- May 6, 2026H.B. 186 takes effect.
- May 8, 2026Justice Hagen resigns, saying she could not continue "without sacrificing the privacy and well-being of those I care about and the effective functioning and independence of Utah's judiciary." House Speaker Mike Schultz and Senate President Stuart Adams say they will not pursue the independent legislative investigation into the allegations that Gov. Cox and other Republican leaders had called for about three weeks earlier.
What H.B. 186 changed
More public
- The commission must report to the Legislature's Judiciary Interim Committee before Nov. 1 each year: complaints received, how they were resolved, and descriptions of informal resolutions and final orders
- An annual report of the commission's activities (the law doesn't say where it must be posted)
More protected, or newly required
- Commission records are now classified as "protected records"
- Annual reports may not identify a judge except through final Supreme Court orders
- Prosecutors and the Administrative Office of the Courts must file complaints in certain cases
The first annual report under H.B. 186 is due before Nov. 1, 2026. It may supply the complaint and resolution numbers that this piece could not read from the commission's scanned FY2023, FY2025 and FY2026 reports.
Added Oct. 17, 2026: Not found yet. On Oct. 17, the JCC's annual reports page listed reports through FY2026 and nothing labeled as an H.B. 186 report, and the Legislature's Judiciary Interim Committee page listed no meetings. The commission met Sept. 1 and Oct. 6, 2026, with a "Statistical Report" on each public agenda. The public handouts for those meetings are posted as scanned images and could not be read for this update. Sources: JCC annual reports; Sept. 1 notice; Oct. 6 notice.
Other 2026 court bills
Several other 2026 bills changed how Utah's courts work. Here is what each one does, in plain terms, and where The Weber County Hive has covered it.
S.B. 134: bigger courts, and the governor picks the chief justice
H.B. 392 and H.B. 366: three-judge panels for challenges to state laws
S.J.R. 5: the court rules that carry out the panel transfers
S.B. 233: timeliness standards and judge evaluations
H.B. 540: court records, audio and judges' disclosures
All passed in the 2026 General Session. Summaries from the enrolled bill texts on le.utah.gov.
Open-records law and the courts
Utah's Government Records Access and Management Act applies to the courts, the Judicial Council and the Administrative Office of the Courts. What the judiciary is not subject to is GRAMA's appeals process. Court records are handled under the Utah Code of Judicial Administration's own records rules, Rules 4-201 through 4-206. Separate statutes, like the one covering JCC files, make certain records confidential regardless.
So the accurate version of the claim is narrower than "exempt": the courts are covered by GRAMA, follow their own rules for records requests and appeals, and some oversight files are closed by other statutes.
Covered by GRAMA
- The courts
- The Judicial Council
- The Administrative Office of the Courts
Handled separately
- Records appeals, under court rules 4-201 to 4-206
- Judicial Conduct Commission files, closed by statute
- Federal FOIA: applies only to federal agencies
What the Utah State Bar is
The Utah State Bar says it "was formally established as an administrative arm of the judiciary, operating under the authority of the Utah Supreme Court" in 1931. It is registered with the Utah Division of Corporations as a nonprofit corporation, with a filing date of June 24, 1991. That is a registration date, not the Bar's founding. It operates under the Supreme Court's constitutional authority over the practice of law. The court sets the rules for admission and discipline, and lawyer discipline cases are decided by screening panels and the courts.
Where the public can look
| Record | Where |
|---|---|
| Public sanctions against judges | jcc.utah.gov/public-dispositions |
| Dismissals with warning (no names) | jcc.utah.gov/dismissals-with-warnings |
| JCC annual reports | jcc.utah.gov/annual-reports |
| Lawyer public discipline | opcutah.org/lawyer-public-discipline |
| Judge evaluations before retention votes | judges.utah.gov |
| File a complaint about a judge | jcc.utah.gov |
| File a complaint about a lawyer | opcutah.org |
| Court records rules | Utah Code of Judicial Administration, Rules 4-201 to 4-206 |
Grades, and what could be done better
Each part of the system is graded separately on The Weber County Hive's five standing questions: power, transparency, financial accountability, environmental impact and community impact. Grades reflect what the public record shows, not the conduct of any individual. Meeting a legal minimum is not treated as above average.
Complaints about judges (Judicial Conduct Commission)
Complaints about lawyers (Office of Professional Conduct)
H.B. 186 (2026)
Judicial selection and retention
What could have been done better for the public
Each option below addresses a gap already documented in this piece. None requires naming a judge or lawyer in an unresolved complaint.
| What the record shows | An option that keeps the same goal |
|---|---|
| Three recent JCC annual reports are posted only as scanned images | Post text versions that can be searched and read by screen readers |
| No reasons or categories are published for dismissed judge complaints | Publish counts by category, such as "disagreement with a ruling" or "insufficient evidence," with no names |
| Judge complaints rose from 85 to 183 with no explanation | Explain significant changes in each annual report |
| The JCC website posts no current member roster | Post the roster, with each member's seat type and profession |
| H.B. 186 was signed March 23 but took effect May 6; it passed 70–0–5 and 25–1–3 | Utah bills that pass by two-thirds of both chambers can take effect on signing; the records provision could have |
| H.B. 186 doesn't say where the public report must be posted | Require posting on the commission's and the Legislature's websites |
| Lawyer-discipline reports change categories from year to year | Use the same categories every year so years can be compared |
| 1,031 lawyer cases were dismissed or declined in 2025 with no public reasons | Publish counts by reason, with no names |
| Individual evaluation-commission votes on judges are protected records | Record each commissioner's vote, as legislators' own votes are recorded |
| People who file complaints learn outcomes but not reasons | A plain-language status and outcome notice for complainants |
What the system does do
- Public sanctions against judges are posted
- Warnings are posted, without names
- Both offices publish annual reports
- Non-lawyer public seats are required by law
- Every judge faces Senate confirmation and voters
- Evaluation votes on judges happen in public
Still unanswered in the record
- Why judge complaints rose from 85 to 183
- Why individual complaints were dismissed
- How the Hagen records reached the House
- Where H.B. 186's public report will be posted
Questions the public can ask, and who can answer them
Each question comes from a gap documented above. Asking in writing or at a public meeting puts the answer on the record.
Why did complaints about judges rise from 85 to 183?
Why are complaints dismissed?
Can the reports and roster be readable online?
Where will the new H.B. 186 report be posted?
How did the Hagen records reach the House?
Why are most lawyer complaints closed without a public record?
Should evaluation votes on judges be public by name?
Who should fill the Judicial Conduct Commission's legislator seats?
When will court audio be free to the public?
Where to direct questions
| Office | How to reach |
|---|---|
| Judicial Conduct Commission | 801-468-0021 · 1385 S. State St., Suite 401, Salt Lake City · complaint form at jcc.utah.gov/complaint-form |
| Office of Professional Conduct | opcutah.org/contact · complaint form at opcutah.org/file-a-complaint |
| Judiciary Interim Committee | Meeting schedule and members at le.utah.gov (committee "INTJUD") |
| Utah House, including the Speaker's office | 801-538-1408 · house.utleg.gov |
| Your state legislators | Find them at le.utah.gov |
| Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission | judges.utah.gov |
| Utah courts (Administrative Office / Judicial Council) | utcourts.gov |
Contact details from each office's own website.
What the record shows, and what's still open
What the record shows is public
- Public sanctions are posted on the JCC website
- Warnings are posted, without names
- Annual reports with complaint totals
- Lawyer cases become public once filed
- Judge evaluations published before each retention vote
- Senate confirmation and retention elections for every judge
What the public can't see
- Complaints against judges that are dismissed
- Why individual complaints were dismissed
- Lawyer complaints closed before a formal case
- Complaint totals for three recent JCC years, posted only as scanned images (the first H.B. 186 report, due Nov. 1, 2026, should help)
- How the commission's Hagen records reached the House
The law balances two interests here. Keeping complaints confidential protects judges and lawyers from public harm over complaints that turn out to be unfounded, and protects people who complain. The cost is that the public sees only the small share of complaints that end in public discipline, and has to trust the process for the rest.
Updates for this part
Records found online that bear on this part. All updates are in Part 1.
- Sept. 1 and Oct. 6, 2026The Judicial Conduct Commission held public meetings with a "Statistical Report" on each agenda, followed by closed sessions. Their public handouts are scanned images and could not be read for this update. The first H.B. 186 report, due before Nov. 1, 2026, was not found online as of Oct. 17. More in Part 2.Source: Sept. 1 notice; Oct. 6 notice
- Sept. 29, 2026 (memo for the Oct. 6 meeting)A staff memo for the Judicial Council on H.B. 540 recommends that lawmakers first see "the actual impacts of the changes from HB0540" before deciding on free court audio. It notes audio is available on request for a one-time fee of $10–$15. Whether the council adopted it was not found.Source: Judicial Council materials, Oct. 6, 2026 (text extraction)
- Aug. 28 to Oct. 6, 2026 (added for context)Gov. Cox appointed Matthew Bell and Michael Menssen to the Supreme Court on Aug. 28; the Senate confirmed both 26–2 on Sept. 16. The Judicial Council's Oct. 6 agenda lists Jill Pohlman as Interim Chief Justice. No governor-appointed chief justice under S.B. 134 was found in searches on Oct. 17.Source: KPCW, Sept. 17, 2026; Judicial Council agenda
Words to know
Tap a card to see what it means. More terms are at the top of Part 1.
Connected Hive work
Behind this piece
Posted Sept. 24, 2026. Updated Oct. 17, 2026: split into two linked parts, new layout and White & navy colors, larger print, a short version for each part, a plain-words page, updates since posting (the Nov. 3 retention ballot and JPEC's recommendations, the JCC's new FY2027 warnings list, the pending H.B. 186 report, the H.B. 540 audio memo, proposed lawyer-discipline rule changes, Supreme Court appointments), dated notes next to related items, words to know, questions to ask, links to related Hive pages, and links added for sources that had none. No earlier facts, numbers or wording changed.
Sources
- Social media post shared with The Weber County Hive, Sept. 21, 2026 (author not named).
- Utah Constitution, Article VIII, Sections 4, 8 and 9 (le.utah.gov).
- Utah Code 78A-11-103 (commission membership) and 78A-11-112 (confidentiality); 78A-11-110 and -111 (public sanctions and Supreme Court review), le.utah.gov.Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Utah Code 78A-11-103 on le.utah.gov
- Utah Judicial Conduct Commission, Frequently Asked Questions; Public Dispositions; Dismissals with Warnings (FY2022, FY2024, FY2025, FY2026 lists); Annual Reports FY2021, FY2022, FY2024 (jcc.utah.gov).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Public Dispositions; Dismissals with Warnings; Annual Reports (FY2021, FY2022, FY2024)
- Utah Judicial Conduct Commission, minutes, Nov. 10, 2025, Utah Public Notice Website (member list).
- Utah Supreme Court Rules of Professional Practice, Rule 1-561, "Accessing disciplinary information," effective Dec. 15, 2020.
- Office of Professional Conduct, 2024 and 2025 annual reports, in the Supreme Court's OPC Oversight Committee meeting materials (legacy.utcourts.gov).
- Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, Open Government Guide: Utah (GRAMA's application to the judiciary; Code of Judicial Administration Rules 4-201 to 4-206).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: RCFP Open Government Guide: Utah
- Ballotpedia, "Utah Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission" (membership limits).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Ballotpedia page
- Spaulding Law, attorney profile of Brady Brammer; Grant Miller for House District 24, campaign biography; Ballotpedia, "Jennifer Plumb"; Jordan Teuscher campaign biography (law degree).
- Utah Legislature, H.B. 186 (2026), "Judicial Conduct Commission Amendments," enrolled copy and bill status history (House 70–0–5, Feb. 3; Senate 25–1–3, Feb. 13; signed March 23; effective May 6, 2026).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: H.B. 186 on le.utah.gov
- Utah Supreme Court, "Utah Supreme Court releases statement on allegations involving Justice Hagen," April 17–18, 2026.Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Utah courts news release, April 17, 2026
- Utah News Dispatch, Katie McKellar: "Utah Supreme Court says affair allegations against justice were 'inappropriately' released," April 17, 2026; "Was the Utah House's release of a Supreme Court justice complaint 'unlawful'?" April 20, 2026; "Amid affair allegations, Utah Supreme Court Justice Diana Hagen resigns," May 8, 2026.Link added Oct. 17, 2026: April 17; April 20; May 8
- Utah Legislature, S.B. 233 (2026), "Judicial Performance Evaluation Amendments," enrolled copy, Section 78A-12-105 (closed discussion; public vote; protected individual votes).
- The Weber County Hive's collective rubric (power, transparency, financial accountability, environmental impact, community impact).
- Utah Judicial Conduct Commission home page (contact information); Office of Professional Conduct contact and complaint pages; Utah House contact information.
- The Weber County Hive, Judiciary committee page (committees repo) and Senate District 21 case file (candidates2026 repo).Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Judiciary committee page; Senate District 21 case file
- Utah Legislature bill records (le.utah.gov) for H.B. 392, H.B. 366, S.J.R. 5, S.B. 233, H.B. 540 and S.B. 134 (2026).
- Utah State Bar, "History and Purpose" (1931 establishment); Utah Division of Corporations registration record, entity #1125137-0140, filed June 24, 1991.Link added Oct. 17, 2026: Utah State Bar, History and Purpose
Added Oct. 17, 2026
- The Salt Lake Tribune, Jessica Schreifels, on how voters can learn about the 57 judges on Utah ballots, Oct. 12, 2026 (also republished by KPCW, Oct. 13, 2026).
- Utah Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission, judges.utah.gov (official site; it did not load as readable text on Oct. 17, 2026, so no figure on this page is taken from it).
- Utah Lieutenant Governor's Office, "Learn about Judicial Retention Elections," vote.utah.gov (more "yes" than "no" votes to keep a judge).
- Judicial Conduct Commission, FY2027 dismissals with warnings list (two entries, July 7 and Aug. 10, 2026). Read as text.
- Judicial Conduct Commission meeting notices, Utah Public Notice Website, including the Sept. 1, 2026 and Oct. 6, 2026 agendas. Their public handouts are scanned images and were not read.
- Utah courts, "Supreme Court Rules of Professional Practice – Comment Period Closes September 18, 2026," posted Aug. 4, 2026.
- Judicial Council, Oct. 6, 2026 meeting notice and agenda, and its meeting materials (Tab 7, H.B. 540 memo dated Sept. 29, 2026). Read via text extraction.
- Utah News Dispatch via KPCW, "Senate confirms 2 more Utah Supreme Court justices," Sept. 17, 2026.
Public records only. No comment requested.
