Who picks Utah's judges, who picks the chief justice, and who can move a lawsuit to a three-judge panel. What the Legislature changed from 2023 to 2026, with the votes, each side's own words, and how each change grades for the public.
StatewideCASE 2026-WD-02 · Posted Nov. 18, 2026 · Updated Nov. 18, 2026
From the Utah Constitution, Art. VIII (which requires at least 3 names), and Title 78A, Chapter 10a, as changed by the bills below.
| Decision | Who makes it now | What changed it |
|---|---|---|
| Who sits on the nominating commissions | The governor appoints all 7 on each; legislators can't serve | 2023 S.B. 129 |
| Who becomes a judge or justice | Governor appoints from the commission's list; Senate confirms | Utah Constitution, Art. VIII (unchanged) |
| Who is chief justice | Governor picks from the sitting justices; Senate consents; one 8-year term. The justices can still remove a chief from that role by majority vote | 2025 S.B. 1003 |
| How many judges there are | The Legislature, by statute and budget | 2026 S.B. 134 |
| Whether a lawsuit against the state goes to a three-judge panel | Any party to the case may ask (since Mar. 13, 2026); judges are drawn at random from different districts | 2026 H.B. 392, S.J.R. 5 and H.B. 366 |
| How judges are rated before a retention vote | The Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission, with new deadlines for opinions | 2026 S.B. 233 |
Utah has eight judicial districts. S.B. 134 added one district judge each in the Third, Fourth and Fifth. Weber County is in the Second, which got none.
Simplified map, not to scale. Districts are groups of counties.
Dark blue: districts that got a new judge under S.B. 134 (Third: 32 to 33; Fourth: 13 to 14; Fifth: 7 to 8). Full county maps are on Utah Maps.
| Year | Bill | What it did | Primary sponsor / floor sponsor | Votes / result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | S.B. 129 | Rewrote the judicial selection law. Each nominating commission has 7 members, all appointed by the governor to 4-year terms; no legislators. The governor must consider whether each pick would help the commission choose "without any regard to partisan political consideration." Reporting says it dropped the State Bar's two recommended members and the limit of 4 members from one party. | Sen. Kirk Cullimore / Rep. Karianne Lisonbee | Senate 20-6-3, House 52-15-8, Senate agreed to House changes 20-7-2. Signed |
| 2025 | S.B. 296 | Governor would pick the chief justice, reappointed every 4 years | Sen. Chris Wilson / Rep. Casey Snider | Senate 17-12, House 40-29-6. Vetoed by Gov. Cox Mar. 25, 2025 |
| 2025 (special session) | S.B. 1003 | Governor picks the chief justice from the justices, with Senate consent; one 8-year term. The sitting chief's term was set to end Apr. 1, 2028 | Sen. Brady Brammer / Rep. Casey Snider | Senate 22-7, House 58-15-2. Signed Oct. 14, 2025 |
| 2026 | S.B. 134 | Supreme Court 5 to 7; Court of Appeals 7 to 9; one more district judge in the Third, Fourth and Fifth districts. First-year cost $6,494,900, of it $4,676,800 ongoing (fiscal note, Jan. 26, 2026) | Sen. Chris Wilson / Rep. Casey Snider | Senate 21-8, House 57-18. Signed Jan. 31, 2026; took effect that day |
| 2026 | H.B. 392 | The attorney general, governor or Legislature may ask for a three-judge panel in a lawsuit challenging a state law; judges drawn at random from different districts; the Supreme Court hears appeals from panels; the attorney general may always join such cases | Rep. Matt MacPherson / Sen. Mike McKell | House 56-15-4, Senate 22-7, House final 55-16-4. Signed Feb. 13, 2026 |
| 2026 | S.J.R. 5 | Court rule changes to put the panels in place | Sen. Brady Brammer / Rep. Jordan Teuscher | Senate 21-7-1, House 54-14-7. Every no vote came from Democrats and the Senate's one Forward Party member; every Republican voting said yes (roll calls) |
| 2026 | H.B. 366 | Lets any party to a lawsuit against the state ask for a panel; sets a $1,500 fee to ask; the Business and Chancery Court publishes only the final decisions it finds valuable as precedent or in the public interest; a government body appealing an injunction against a state law doesn't have to post a bond; creates a three-judge "Constitutional Court," with an all-governor-appointed nominating commission, only if the panel law is struck down or blocked; changes retention ballot wording | Rep. Jordan Teuscher / Sen. Brady Brammer | House 66-2-7, Senate 23-6, House agreed to Senate changes 55-18-2. Signed Mar. 13, 2026; took effect that day |
| 2026 | S.B. 233 | New deadlines for judges' opinions (for justices: no more than 25% past 150 days, 10% past 210 days, all within a year); a study of reversals on appeal; commission votes on judges in public meetings, but members' conflict disclosures to each other are protected records and only the final vote may be released | Sen. Brady Brammer / Rep. Karianne Lisonbee | Senate 18-7-4, House 51-18-6. Signed Mar. 23, 2026 |
| 2026 | H.B. 540 | One public court-records website, free up to 50 searches or downloads a month (remote sign-up asks for "citizenship status"); audio of public court hearings, available on request (free to parties); yearly financial disclosures from judges, posted online. An earlier version (2nd substitute) would have barred law firms suing the state from hiring a former judge for two years; the final law does not include it | Rep. Logan Monson / Sen. Brady Brammer | House 57-11-7, Senate 20-6-3, House final 57-8-10. Signed Mar. 25, 2026 |
| 2026 (died) | H.J.R. 5, H.B. 424, H.B. 262 | H.J.R. 5 (constitutional amendment) and H.B. 424 would have let the governor appoint any qualified person, making the commission's list "advisory only" and dropping the governor's deadline. H.B. 424 would also have sent the appointee's application file to the Senate. H.J.R. 5's fiscal note: $767,900 to publish the amendment. H.B. 262 would have required at least 67% "yes" for a judge to keep the job, instead of more yes than no votes. The Utah State Bar opposed H.B. 262 and H.B. 424 | Rep. Jason Kyle | No final vote |
H.B. 392 let only the attorney general, the governor or the Legislature ask for a panel. Groups suing the state said that was one-sided. The ACLU of Utah wrote that the law let the state, and only the state, move civil cases it is part of to a panel.
A month later H.B. 366 rewrote the rule. Its text says "a party to a civil action may file a notice" for a panel in a lawsuit against the state or a state official that challenges a law, rule or executive order. Asking costs $1,500. If a court strikes down or blocks the panel law, H.B. 366 creates a separate Constitutional Court instead.
The panels were used right away. In February 2026 the state filed notices to move four pending cases to panels: the redistricting case, the abortion-ban case and two environmental cases. The redistricting case, then before Third District Judge Dianna Gibson, was assigned to a panel on Feb. 26, 2026, according to the League of Women Voters' court filing.
What H.B. 366's text sets up, only if a court strikes down or blocks the panel law.
In court, the Legislature's lawyer argued that it has authority to set rules for the courts and that nothing in the state constitution bars a three-judge panel. The Utah State Bar said the legislation "subordinates the judiciary," and on Mar. 4, 2026 it warned that last-minute changes to H.B. 366 "threaten judicial stability." Rep. Jordan Teuscher, H.B. 366's primary sponsor, said there can be disagreements in interpreting constitutional issues, and argued for routing those challenges through a three-judge panel (Deseret News, Mar. 4, 2026). The Utah Supreme Court heard arguments on Oct. 5, 2026. As of Nov. 18, 2026, we found no ruling.
| Justice | Appointed by | When |
|---|---|---|
| Paige Petersen | Gov. Gary Herbert | 2017 |
| Jill Pohlman (associate chief justice) | Gov. Spencer Cox | 2022; retained Nov. 3, 2026 with about 78% (unofficial) |
| John Nielsen | Gov. Spencer Cox | Confirmed Nov. 2025, replacing John Pearce |
| Jay Jorgensen | Gov. Spencer Cox | Confirmed June 17, 2026 (new seat) |
| Stephen Dent | Gov. Spencer Cox | Confirmed June 17, 2026 (new seat) |
| Matthew Bell | Gov. Spencer Cox | Confirmed Sept. 16, 2026 (Durrant's seat) |
| Michael Menssen | Gov. Spencer Cox | Confirmed Sept. 16, 2026 (Hagen's seat) |
Each item is graded on one question: is it good for the public as a whole, on transparency, financial accountability and environmental impact? Environmental impact doesn't apply to this part. Grades are a fixed published standard, not the writer's opinion. "Text read" means the Hive read the bill's full text; "1st look" means the official summary and record.
| Change | Grade | Why | The other side |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 S.B. 129 (who picks the commissions) | Hurts (text read, plus reporting) | One official now picks every member of the body that screens judges; the Bar and party-balance checks were dropped | Sponsor said it gives the governor discretion to pick the most qualified; the bill tells the governor to avoid partisan picks |
| 2025 S.B. 296 (vetoed) | Would have hurt | Moved the chief justice pick out of the court, with 4-year reappointment | Cox vetoed it, saying the 4-year term would make the chief depend on the governor and Senate |
| 2025 S.B. 1003 | Hurts (text read) | Moves a decision the court made for itself to the other two branches | Single 8-year term answers Cox's veto concern; justices can still remove a chief from the role |
| 2026 S.B. 134 | Mixed | More judges where caseloads grew, and a public fiscal note before the vote; but the court got 3 of the 8 district judges it asked for, plus 2 justices it said it didn't need, at $4.68 million a year ongoing | Supporters cited population growth and that most similar-sized states have 7 justices |
| 2026 H.B. 392 and S.J.R. 5, as first passed | Hurts | Only one side of a lawsuit could change how the court was set up | Random judges from different districts were meant to stop "judge shopping" |
| 2026 H.B. 366 | Mixed (text read) | Opened panels to any party, which addresses the one-sided problem; but adds a $1,500 fee, publishes fewer business-court decisions, and drops the bond for government appeals of injunctions | Reported as clarifying that more parties than just the state can ask for a panel (ABC4) |
| 2026 S.B. 233 | Mixed (text read) | Public deadlines for judges help accountability; members' conflict disclosures are kept from the public | Sponsors’ stated reasons were not in the records we read |
| 2026 H.B. 540 | Helps (text read) | Free records website, hearing audio, and judges' financial disclosures, for the first time | Caveats: the "citizenship status" sign-up question, and audio only on request |
| Rep. Kyle's bills (died) | Would have hurt | Would have removed the commission check on appointments | — |
| Request | Sponsor | Status (Nov. 18, 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Judicial Conduct Commission Amendments | Sen. Todd Weiler | In drafting (not numbered) |
| Committee bill file: legislative audit recommendations on the courts | Judiciary Interim Committee | Opened Oct. 2026 |
| Committee bill file: Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission Modifications | Judiciary Interim Committee | Opened Oct. 2026 |
Text isn't public until a bill is numbered. The Hive checks the 2027 list every day.
Where each person appears elsewhere in the Hive. Being named here does not mean anyone did anything wrong.
| Who | Why they are here | Other Hive pages |
|---|---|---|
| Gov. Spencer Cox | Appoints commissions, judges and the chief justice; vetoed S.B. 296; signed the others | It Happened Before |
| Sen. Chris Wilson | Primary sponsor, S.B. 134 and S.B. 296; Senate Majority Leader in 2027 | Utah Senators |
| Sen. Brady Brammer | Primary sponsor, S.B. 1003, S.J.R. 5 and S.B. 233; floor sponsor, H.B. 366 and H.B. 540 | Checks & Balances PAC |
| Rep. Casey Snider | Floor sponsor, S.B. 134, S.B. 296 and S.B. 1003 | Who Decides, Part 1 |
| Rep. Matt MacPherson | Primary sponsor, H.B. 392 | House Speaker Leadership PAC |
| Rep. Jordan Teuscher | Primary sponsor, H.B. 366; floor sponsor, S.J.R. 5 | Checks & Balances PAC |
| Sen. Kirk Cullimore | Primary sponsor, 2023 S.B. 129 | URSCC |
| Rep. Karianne Lisonbee | Floor sponsor, S.B. 129 and S.B. 233; Judiciary Interim Committee co-chair | Bill-Tracker |
| Sen. Mike McKell | Floor sponsor, H.B. 392 | Utah Senators |
| Rep. Logan Monson | Primary sponsor, H.B. 540 | Utah House |
| Sen. Todd Weiler | 2027 request on the Judicial Conduct Commission; Judiciary Interim Committee co-chair | Committees |
| Rep. Jason Kyle | Primary sponsor of the 2026 bills that died | GSL-Votes |
Tap a card to see what it means.
Posted Nov. 18, 2026. Not used: a quote we could not re-check against the original story, a reported reason for one justice's resignation, and an older figure for how many justices the governor "controls."
2023 S.B. 129; 2025 S.B. 296 (bill record and veto); 2025 S.B. 1003; 2026 S.B. 134 and its fiscal note (2nd Sub., Jan. 26, 2026); H.B. 392; S.J.R. 5; H.B. 366 (panel notice, Sec. 78A-5-102.7(2); $1,500 fee, lines 678–679; effective date, Sec. 48); S.B. 233 (lines 622–637 and 914–949); H.B. 540. Votes from each bill's le.utah.gov record. 2027 requests: le.utah.gov; committee bill files: Legislature interim highlights, Oct. 2026.
Utah News Dispatch, Jan. 22–30, Feb. 13, June 3, June 17, Aug. 28, Sept. 16 and Nov. 4, 2026; KUER, Mar. 25, 2025; KPCW, Oct. 7, 2025, May 25 and Sept. 17, 2026; Axios Salt Lake City, Feb. 24, 2023; Deseret News, Oct. 5 and Nov. 6, 2026; ABC4, Oct. 2026; ACLU of Utah, H.B. 392 page; Governor's Office release, June 2, 2026; NBC/AP, Jan. 31, 2026; Deseret News and Utah State Bar statement, Mar. 4, 2026; Utah State Bar bill positions (updated Mar. 3, 2026); League of Women Voters petition and briefs (Feb. and June 2026). Campaign gifts: Brady Brammer 2026 campaign reports, disclosures.utah.gov, as collected for the Hive (Sept. 12, 2026). H.J.R. 5, H.B. 424 and H.B. 262 bill records and text, le.utah.gov.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · JournalismThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.
Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us
Independent accountability journalism. Public records only. We report; you decide.
We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.
Transparency home · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack