Behind this piece — counts are an estimate and will grow as research continues.
Opt-Out Series on Substack: Part 1, You're In Unless You Say No (Nov. 19) · Part 2, The Opt-In Draft That Never Reached a Recorded Vote (Dec. 3) · Part 3, Follow the Energy Money (December). Read on Substack
1. Start here: the basics
| Who | What they do |
|---|---|
| Rocky Mountain Power | Sells the power and sends the bill. Collects the new charge. |
| Public Service Commission (PSC) | Created by the Legislature in the Public Utilities Act of 1917 (signed March 8, 1917; organized April 3, 1917), first named the Public Utilities Commission of Utah. Made an independent state agency in 1983. Three commissioners, appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Utah Senate, serve staggered six-year terms; no more than two may belong to the same political party; the governor names the chair and can remove a commissioner only for cause. Regulates electric, natural gas, telephone and water/sewer utilities and sets their rates. Approved this program March 4, 2026. |
| Division of Public Utilities | State office that argues for the public interest at the PSC. |
| Office of Consumer Services | State office that argues for homes and small businesses at the PSC. |
| Utah Renewable Communities (legal name: Community Renewable Energy Agency) | A government agency formed by the participating cities and counties to run the program with Rocky Mountain Power. |
| Your city council or county commission | Voted in spring 2026 whether to keep its residents in the program. |
What is this program, and why are they doing it?
Updated Nov. 17 More exactly: you keep Rocky Mountain Power as your utility and get power through the same grid. The program adds clean energy resources over time, likely in phases through several projects (Rocky Mountain Power program page); it does not send a separate stream of renewable power to your home.
| Who | The reason they give, in the record | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Rocky Mountain Power's opt-out notice | To build new clean energy resources on the grid to reduce fossil fuel dependence, improve air quality and limit greenhouse gases. | Draft opt-out notice, Nov. 2, 2026 |
| The participating communities | Most adopted goals around 2019 of net-100% renewable electricity by 2030. The program lets a city act on that goal for its residents, through the power company everyone already uses. Salt Lake City's own goal dates to a 2016 resolution. | Utah Renewable Communities; Salt Lake City program page |
| Why "together" | A single home cannot build a large solar or wind plant. Pooling many customers' payments is meant to fund utility-scale projects. Program staff told a mayor the opt-out design was meant to let communities and smaller customers act collectively. | Kearns council minutes, May 29, 2026 |
| Why now | Federal production tax credits for new projects had deadlines (construction by July 4, 2026 under the 2025 federal law). The PSC cited those expiring credits when it approved the program right away. Updated Nov. 17 More exactly: under the 2025 law, wind and solar projects placed in service after Dec. 31, 2027 lose the credits unless construction began by July 4, 2026. Projects placed in service by the end of 2027 have a separate route, subject to other rules. | PSC order, March 4, 2026, p. 25 |
| Ogden's city staff | The city's municipal building would pay about $327 a month in the program, compared with $650 a month it was paying for Rocky Mountain Power's Blue Sky program. | Ogden work session minutes, April 7, 2026 |
Advocacy groups also said Rocky Mountain Power had slowed its own clean energy buying; that is their characterization, not a finding here. The 2030 goal was later relaxed — a 2024 law (S.B. 214) removed the requirement that communities adopt it.
What counts as "clean" — could this money go to nuclear?
| Question | What the record shows | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Is nuclear allowed? | Yes. The tariff's definition of a "clean energy resource" includes energy derived from nuclear fuel, carbon capture and storage. | Schedule 100 tariff; H.B. 241 (2024) |
| What has the program actually sought? | The first request for proposals sought solar, wind, geothermal and hydroelectric projects in Utah, Wyoming or Idaho. The two finalists are solar plus battery storage. | KSL, June 8, 2026; agency Resolution 26-08 |
| Does the power come to my house? | It goes onto the Rocky Mountain Power system, the same grid everyone uses. Your power still comes from the normal mix. | Utah Renewable Communities FAQ |
| Does it have to be new? | The law describes "incremental" clean resources developed for participants, and the tariff says resources are acquired for the sole purpose of serving participants. But an agency slide from fall 2025 says the clean energy counted toward the net-100% goal was proposed to come from both existing clean energy on the grid and new projects. | Utah Code 54-17-902; Schedule 100 tariff; agency "Fall 2025 Update" slides |
| Who owns the plants? | The first projects are being bought under power contracts with private developers. The agency's FAQ says future facilities could be owned by a developer or by Rocky Mountain Power. | PSC order, March 4, 2026; agency FAQ |
| What about the wires to reach the grid? | New plants need a grid connection. The agency flagged possible transmission problems, hired a transmission consultant, and one project was redesigned to add a battery to avoid costly grid upgrades. Who pays connection costs was one of the disputes the PSC left for later. | Agency minutes, Aug. 3, 2026; Oct. 5 packet; PSC order |
Open No record found says whether any future solicitation would include nuclear. The program's own documents describe adding resources "over time."
Rocky Mountain Power is already buying power from one nuclear plant, separate from this program. See section 9d.
Opt-in vs. opt-out
2. How it happened, step by step
(Community Renewable Energy Act)"] --> B["2020–2022: Cities and counties form
Utah Renewable Communities"] B --> C["2024: Law renamed Community Clean Energy Act;
'clean' now includes nuclear, storage, carbon capture"] C --> D["2025: Rocky Mountain Power asks PSC to approve;
agency asks developers for projects"] D --> E["Feb 2026: H.B. 238 — opt-in draft dropped;
opt-out check box added"] E --> F["March 4, 2026: PSC approves; sets $4/month"] F --> G["April 8 – June 2, 2026:
16 councils vote to stay in, 3 do not"] G --> H["Nov 2, 2026: Opt-out notices mailed"] H --> I["Jan 1, 2027: Charge starts on bills"] I --> J["May 1, 2027: Last day to leave
without an exit fee"] J --> K["2028–2030: First new project hoped online"]
3. What you pay
| Customer | Monthly charge | Fee to leave after May 1, 2027 |
|---|---|---|
| Home (most homes) | $4.00 flat — includes a $0.10 surcharge for low-income credits | $30 |
| Low-income home (Rocky Mountain Power Schedule 3) | $0.00 — a $4 charge offset by a $4 credit | $0 |
| Home with older rooftop solar (Schedule 135) | Not enrolled — excluded by state law | — |
| Home with newer rooftop solar (Schedules 136, 137) | $4.00 flat | $30 |
| Small business (Schedule 23), irrigation (Schedule 10) | 0.609¢ per kilowatt-hour + $0.12 | $30 |
| General and large business (Schedules 6, 6A, 8, 9, 9A) | 0.609¢ per kilowatt-hour + $0.12 | $6 per average kW |
| Street and security lights (Schedules 7, 11, 12) | 0.609¢ per kilowatt-hour, per lamp | $0.15 per lamp |
Updated Nov. 17 Source: Rocky Mountain Power's current Schedule 100 tariff (sheets filed Aug. 7 and Sept. 1, 2026; effective Nov. 2, 2026), which confirms these rates. Rates were set by the PSC order of March 4, 2026. (Earlier version of this line: "compliance tariff filing, Aug. 7, 2026 (proposed; final approval being confirmed).")
Why is there a fee to leave?
- The law requires a free window of at least three billing cycles. The PSC extended it to six months for current customers (through May 1, 2027) at the communities' request.
- No fee for: low-income Schedule 3 homes; customers who move out of a participating community; customers who close their account; anyone enrolled by mistake (who also get a refund of up to one year).
- An unpaid fee cannot be used to shut off a home's power (tariff special condition 3).
- The PSC can change the fee amount.
Who chose the $30, who approved it — and where the fee money goes
Updated Nov. 17 The agency drew up the fee amounts; Rocky Mountain Power filed them in its tariff; the PSC approves the tariff. Rocky Mountain Power not having the justification does not show that none exists elsewhere.
| Date | What the record shows | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Oct. 7, 2024 | Agency board adopts Resolution 24-08 setting the fee schedule: $30 homes and small businesses, $6 per average kW for larger businesses, $0 low-income. Moved by Silvestrini, seconded by Quinn, unanimous. Stated goals: encourage stable participation, avoid undue burden, and reflect larger customers' bigger effect on rates. A board member asked for the technical or financial analysis; none is recorded. | Agency minutes and board packet |
| July 2025 | Agency testimony: the fee should be high enough to discourage leaving but low enough not to discourage joining. No calculation given. | Christopher Thomas direct testimony |
| Oct. 2025 | Division of Public Utilities asked Rocky Mountain Power for the derivation of the fees. The company answered that the agency developed them and "does not possess the justification for the amounts." It also said it had not proposed any limit on how many times a customer can join and leave. | RMP response to data request 1.4, DPU Exhibit 2.2 |
| Aug. 2026 | Rocky Mountain Power changed the streetlight fee to $0.15 per lamp, the only fee with posted math (a usage workpaper). | Compliance tariff filing |
- Where fee money goes: The tariff counts fees as part of "Program Rates," which are spent in the set order (start-up, administration, low-income fund, resource fund). No record names a specific account for fee money. The agency's testimony said fees from people who leave would be available to help cover the costs of shutting the program down. The Division of Public Utilities said the tariff gives no more detail than that, and expects it in future reports.
- Where program money is held: Rocky Mountain Power proposed a balancing account earning interest, and two restricted reserve funds held in escrow by the agency, with a proposed 1.5% escrow fee. The PSC's March 4 order does not mention escrow.
- If participants don't pay a fee: The utility agreement says unpaid fees are not Rocky Mountain Power's obligation; they are recovered through program rates — meaning other participants.
To verify The "no account named" findings come from text reads of the documents; confirm against the rendered PDFs before publishing.
Why participating customers pay the program's additional costs
Updated Nov. 17 Heading changed from "Why doesn't the power company pay for it?" The first reason below is a general description of how regulated utilities recover approved costs; the records for this program show cost recovery from participants.
- Rocky Mountain Power's testimony says participants pay all of the extra resource and administrative costs.
- The projects are owned by private developers and bought under contracts, not built by Rocky Mountain Power. That is different from a company-owned plant, where the company can earn an approved return.
- Rocky Mountain Power's own costs to run the program — including a full-time administrator — are charged to the program, not absorbed by the company.
Open No record read shows Rocky Mountain Power contributing any of its own money, or earning a profit on the program. Neither is confirmed either way.
Can the amount change?
4. Am I enrolled? Try it
Updated Nov. 17 This checker gives a general answer for customers who had service when the program launched. It cannot tell whether you already opted out, or the dates for someone who started service later (they get their own 60-day notice period). Your Rocky Mountain Power notice and account are the official word.
What counts is where the meter is, not your mailing address. Power from a city-owned utility is not part of this program. This tool is a guide only — your opt-out notice from Rocky Mountain Power is the official word.
4b. How to opt out, and the two deadlines
Added Nov. 17
- By Dec. 31, 2026: opt out during the notice period (Nov. 2 – Dec. 31) and you are never charged. The charge starts on bills Jan. 1.
- Jan. 1 – May 1, 2027: you can still leave with no exit fee, but the months you were enrolled are billed. Leaving in this window is not free; it just has no exit fee.
- From May 2, 2027: exit fees apply.
Three ways to opt out
- Online: sign in at RockyMountainPower.net. On the Opt Out tab, select the service(s) to opt out and click Submit.
- Phone: 1-800-895-0614 (Rocky Mountain Power's program line).
- Mail: the completed opt-out form to Rocky Mountain Power, Community Clean Energy Program, PO Box 25308, Salt Lake City, UT 84125-0308.
More than one account or service? Check each one.
Exit fees after May 1, 2027, by account
| Account | One-time exit fee |
|---|---|
| Homes (Schedule 1) and homes with newer rooftop solar (136, 137) | $30 |
| Low-income homes (Schedule 3) | $0 |
| Small business (23) and irrigation (10) | $30 |
| Larger business (6, 6A, 8, 9, 9A) | $6 per average kW over the prior 12 months |
| Security and street lighting (7, 11, 12) | $0.15 per lamp |
| Traffic and signal systems, customer-owned (15) | $0.96 per average kW |
| Schedules 31, 32 and non-residential 135, 136, 137 | By the calculation method for that schedule |
Sources: Rocky Mountain Power Community Clean Energy Program page and Schedule 100 tariff (current version); Utah Renewable Communities FAQ. Business and government fees depend on the account's rate schedule; check Schedule 100 before estimating.
What hasn't been checked yet
- No audit of Utah Renewable Communities has been posted.
- Protecting customers outside the program: the project-valuation method that would show costs aren't shifting to them hasn't been approved. The Office of Consumer Services urged approving it before money was collected. It is in PSC Docket 26-035-38; Rocky Mountain Power's reporting plan is due Dec. 31, 2026.
- Where the reserve is held: Rocky Mountain Power proposed escrow; the PSC's March 4 order doesn't say.
- Money in vs. power built: no developer has been named and no power contract filed.
- Why opt-in was dropped: only a news report (KPCW) explains it; the committee video would confirm.
5. Who is covered — map and list
Markers show town centers, not boundaries. Blue = participating city or town. Navy squares = county (unincorporated areas only). Gray = chose not to join.
| Community | Ordinance adopted (2026) |
|---|---|
| Springdale | April 8 |
| Summit County (unincorporated) | April 15 |
| Salt Lake City | April 21 |
| Emigration Canyon | April 21 |
| Moab | April 28 |
| Park City | April 30 |
| Ogden | May 5 |
| Alta | May 13 |
| Francis | May 14 |
| Grand County (unincorporated) | May 19 |
| Salt Lake County (unincorporated) | May 19 |
| Castle Valley | May 20 |
| Holladay | May 21 |
| Millcreek | May 26 |
| Oakley | May 27 |
| Midvale | June 2 (last day) |
Dates as listed by Utah Renewable Communities. Did not adopt: Coalville, Cottonwood Heights, Kearns.
Open Magna, White City and Copperton: a 2024 state law (H.B. 35) turned Salt Lake County's metro townships into cities, and these three never joined the program. That suggests they are not part of "unincorporated Salt Lake County" — but no program record states it, and the boundary maps were not found. Salt Lake and Summit counties told the agency in October 2026 they were working with PacifiCorp on accurate unincorporated boundaries.
The three that said no — and why
| Community | Vote | Reasons stated |
|---|---|---|
| Coalville | Voted no May 26, 2026 | Automatic enrollment; the $4 charge and added business cost; rates regulators could change; not knowing where projects would be built. One council member said it felt like an additional tax. |
| Cottonwood Heights | Ordinance failed May 19, 2026 | Earlier council comments called it a voluntary rate increase and the opt-out "an illusion of choice"; one member preferred opt-in. Vote count not posted. |
| Kearns | Voted no May 11, again May 29, 2026 | Cost for a lower-income community; automatic enrollment. Mayor said residents were not ready. A council member asked why it could not be opt-in. |
Sources: KPCW (Coalville), Cottonwood Heights Jan. 20, 2026 minutes, FOX13 and Kearns May 29 minutes.
5b. Ogden: the Weber County piece
The May 5, 2026 vote (Ordinance 2026-7)
| Yes (6) | No (1) |
|---|---|
| Flor Lopez, Kevin Lundell, Shaun Myers, Ken Richey, Alicia Washington, Vice Chair Dave Graf (moved it; Lundell seconded) | Chair Richard A. Hyer |
- Public comment: the minutes list 23 people under support and 3 under opposition (Updated Nov. 17 read directly in the May 5 minutes). Those opposed raised the opt-out design, unnamed project partners and speculative projections.
- KSL reported Chair Hyer said the opt-out design relies on people who will never notice.
- Council Member Richey said outreach commitments largely answered his opt-out concerns.
- The minutes do not record Chair Hyer's reasons for his no vote.
What Ogden taxpayers have paid
| Date | Payment | Record |
|---|---|---|
| 2021 (Phase 1) | $35,738 to the agency | Ogden's program page |
| July 2022 (Phase 2) | $35,737.26 to the agency — 10.65% of all member payments | Agency treasurer's report |
| One-time | $51,774 to reimburse Rocky Mountain Power for mailing the two opt-out notices | May 5, 2026 council minutes Updated Nov. 17 (earlier version said "2027 (invoice expected Jan.–Feb.)"; that timing is not in the minutes) |
| Total | $71,475.26 to the agency, plus $51,774 for notices | Above records |
State law puts the cost of the notices on the participating communities, not the program. Open No Ogden budget line item for the $51,774 was found.
How Ogden got here
| Date | Action | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Dec. 3, 2019 | Joint resolution with Mayor Caldwell setting the goal | 5-2 |
| July 13, 2021 | Interlocal agreement joining the agency, with $35,738 | 5-2 (Hyer no, per the Standard-Examiner) |
| Nov. 14, 2023 | Resolution 2023-21 letting the mayor sign the agreement with Rocky Mountain Power | 5-1 |
| Jan. 12, 2024 | Mayor Nadolski signs the agreement | — |
| May 5, 2026 | Ordinance 2026-7 keeps Ogden in | 6-1 (Hyer no) |
Ogden's representatives on the agency board: Vice Chair Dave Graf and Sustainability Coordinator Lorenzo Long. Open Names behind the 2019, 2021 and 2023 votes other than Hyer are not yet confirmed.
5c. The agency and its money
| Money in | Amount |
|---|---|
| Member community payments | $722,084.20 |
| Bid fees from developers | $200,000 |
| Grants (Stewardship Utah $50,000; SustainEnergyFinance $50,000) | $100,000 |
| Total | $1,022,084.20 |
| Spent | About $969,938 |
From the agency's treasurer's report (Aug. 3, 2026 packet). A separate $118,879 state grant was paid directly to vendors. The October packet gives two different remaining balances ($52,146.27 and $39,588.52). Going forward, about $150,000 a year in agency costs is to be built into program rates. To verify these figures against the rendered PDF pages before publishing.
| Role | Who |
|---|---|
| Board chair | Dan Dugan, Salt Lake City Council |
| Vice chair | David Brems, Emigration Canyon |
| Treasurer | Cheri Jackson, Millcreek |
| Secretary | Emily Quinton, Summit County |
| Legal and technical counsel | James Dodge Russell & Stephens P.C. (Phillip J. Russell) |
| Technical consultants | Energy Strategies (Kevin Higgins, Brendan Acord) |
| Communications | Penna Powers (capped at $66,000) |
| Transmission studies | Options Transmission Consulting |
Salt Lake City backs about $902,185 in start-up costs, to be repaid from program revenue.
6. Where the $4 goes
Updated Nov. 17 More exactly: the template contract described in the approval case said it would not take effect until the reserve covered 12.5 years of production. Rocky Mountain Power's answers to the Division of Public Utilities call that an estimate of what a developer may want, open to negotiation, and describe it as the cost above the power's "avoided cost" value, not the plant's full price. The final contracts need to be checked for the actual requirement.
($4 home / per-kWh business)"] --> B["1. Start-up costs"] B --> C["2. Running the program
+ administrative reserve"] C --> D["3. Low-income fund
(lets Schedule 3 homes join free)"] D --> E["4. Clean energy resource fund"] E --> F["Backs contracts with private developers
who build and own the plants"]
Order of spending from the Schedule 100 tariff. Rocky Mountain Power was approved to hire a full-time program administrator, paid from program costs.
Which projects?
| Date | What happened | Record |
|---|---|---|
| May 22, 2025 | Agency asks developers for project bids | Resolution 26-02 |
| By July 2025 | 14 qualifying bids received | Board minutes, Aug. 3, 2026 |
| Feb. 2, 2026 | Short list of 6, then 4 picked to negotiate: code names PV+BESS_2, _3, _4, _7 ("PV+BESS" = solar plus battery storage). The resolution says this is not a winning bid. | Resolution 26-02 |
| Sept. 14, 2026 | Board picks 2 projects, PV+BESS_3 and PV+BESS_4, for final contract talks with PacifiCorp. No names, sizes or locations given. Any contract comes back to the board. | Resolution 26-08 |
| Oct. 29, 2026 | Salt Lake City says two solar projects were chosen; first projects expected on the grid 2028–2030 | Salt Lake City press release |
A news report said Rocky Mountain Power selected three developers. The public records found say four on the short list, then two.
Who owns the plants, and does Rocky Mountain Power profit?
Open Profit or return to Rocky Mountain Power — not addressed either way in the PSC order or testimony read.
How much money?
No yearly revenue total appears in the PSC order or Rocky Mountain Power's testimony. Rocky Mountain Power's 2025 projections (made before the PSC switched homes to a flat $4) assumed:
| Assumption in Rocky Mountain Power's 2025 testimony | Figure |
|---|---|
| Participating customers | About 203,403 |
| Homes assumed to opt out (share of electricity use) | 20% |
| Small and general businesses assumed to opt out (Schedules 6, 6A, 8, 10, 23) | 70% |
| Large high-voltage customers assumed to opt out (Schedules 9, 9A, 31) | 95% |
| Start-up costs | $820,169 |
| Yearly running costs | $1,014,847 |
| Projected reserve, end of 2026 | $6.54 million |
| Projected reserve, end of 2027 | $20.38 million |
| Projected reserve, 2030–2042 | About $40.8 million |
Salt Lake City's April 2026 presentation put start-up costs near $900,000, fronted by Salt Lake City and repaid from program revenue. The two start-up figures come from different documents and dates.
The three phases
| Phase | Years | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Build-up | 2026–2029 | Highest rates; savings pot is filled |
| Maintenance | 2030–2042 | Lower rates pay the extra cost of the clean power |
| Draw-down | 2043–2049 | Rates projected to go below zero as savings are paid back to participants |
If the program ends early, the PSC order says Rocky Mountain Power must decide whether ending or keeping each power contract is cheapest for ratepayers, and the reserve first covers what is owed to the developer.
7. The opt-in version that was dropped (H.B. 238, 2026)
Primary sponsor: Rep. Carl R. Albrecht. Senate sponsor: Sen. Evan J. Vickers. Each substitute is labeled "Carl R. Albrecht proposes the following substitute bill."
| Version | Date stamp | Opt-in or opt-out? | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original H.B. 238 | Feb. 5 | Did not touch the program | House passed it Feb. 5 |
| 1st Substitute | Feb. 10 | Did not touch the program | No vote found |
| 2nd Substitute | Feb. 11, 9:10 a.m. | Opt-in — "requires customers to affirmatively elect to participate" | No vote found; replaced next day |
| 3rd Substitute | Feb. 12, 2:03 p.m. | Opt-out kept — adds a simple opt-out method on the notice | Senate committee recommended 5-0-2 (Feb. 12); Senate passed Feb. 19; House concurred Feb. 20 |
| Final law (enrolled) | — | Opt-out | Took effect May 6, 2026 |
The exact change
| 2nd Substitute (opt-in) | Final law (opt-out) |
|---|---|
| A participating customer is one who has "affirmatively elected to participate." | A customer "may elect to not participate" and keep paying existing rates. |
| A customer "may elect to participate" by notifying the utility. | The notice must include "a simple method, such as checking a box or signing a statement," to opt out, with instructions for sending it in. |
| New customers who move in later may choose to join. | New customers who move in later are enrolled unless they opt out. |
Important: The House's Feb. 5 vote was on the original bill, which had nothing about this program. The House voted on the opt-out language only when it agreed to the Senate's version on Feb. 20.
The Feb. 12, 2026 Senate committee meeting
- The 3rd Substitute is time-stamped 2:03 p.m. on Feb. 12. The meeting was called to order at 2:09 p.m. Updated Nov. 17 The time stamp shows when the substitute was drafted, not when lawmakers or the public first saw it.
- Sen. David Hinkins chaired during H.B. 238.
- Rep. Albrecht presented, assisted by PSC Chair Jerry Fenn and Jon Cox (no affiliation listed in the minutes).
- Spoke in favor: Dan Dugan (chair, Utah Renewable Communities); Thom Carter (vice president of government affairs, Rocky Mountain Power); Nathaniel Johnson (Utah Rural Electric Cooperative Association); Cottonwood Heights Mayor Gay Lynn Bennion. Two residents spoke without a stated position.
| Motion (both by Sen. Nate Blouin) | Result | Yes | Listed under "Abs" |
|---|---|---|---|
| Replace the original bill with the 3rd Substitute | Passed 4-0-3 | Blouin, Hinkins, Sandall, Stevenson | Grover, Owens, Stratton |
| Pass the 3rd Substitute out favorably | Passed 5-0-2 | Blouin, Hinkins, Owens, Sandall, Stratton | Grover, Stevenson |
The minutes print "Abs" and do not say whether that means absent or abstaining.
Why was opt-in dropped?
To confirm Watch the H.B. 238 portion of the Feb. 12 committee video (linked in Sources) for Rep. Albrecht's exact words.
Floor votes
| Vote | Date | Result | No votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| House passage (original bill — nothing on this program) | Feb. 5 | 68-1-6 | Rep. Hansen |
| Senate 3rd reading (3rd Substitute) | Feb. 19 | 24-0-5 | None |
| House agrees to Senate version | Feb. 20 | 69-1-5 | Rep. Hansen |
Floor counts from third-party trackers (FastDemocracy, PolicyRisk); the official vote pages could not be opened. The governor's bill page lists H.B. 238 under March 25, 2026.
Background: this was not the first opt-in attempt
- 2019, H.B. 411 (primary sponsor Rep. Stephen Handy, Senate sponsor Sen. Daniel Hemmert): opt-in vs. opt-out was debated in committee. A 3rd Substitute by Rep. Kay Christofferson would have had existing customers elect to participate; the bill page lists it as not adopted. In the March 7, 2019 House committee vote, Reps. Albrecht, Chew, Christofferson and Stratton voted no. The House passed it 48-24-3 and the Senate 23-6-0.
- 2024, H.B. 241 (Rep. Albrecht, Sen. Owens): renamed the law and added nuclear, geothermal, pumped storage and carbon capture to "clean."
- 2024, S.B. 214 (Sen. Hinkins, Rep. Trevor Lee): removed the requirement that communities adopt a 100%-by-2030 goal. No change to opt-out.
- No other 2025 or 2026 bill was found that tried to change the program to opt-in.
8. Rooftop solar homes (net metering)
| Solar program | Who is on it | Credit for power sent back | Runs until | In the clean energy program? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Schedule 135 | Hooked up before Nov. 15, 2017 | Full retail rate | Jan. 1, 2036 | Homes excluded by law. Businesses not excluded. |
| Schedule 136 | Nov. 15, 2017 – Oct. 2020 | About 90–92.5% of retail | Jan. 1, 2033 | Homes enrolled, pay $4 |
| Schedule 137 | After Oct. 2020 (current) | Fixed rate, about 4–4.9¢/kWh | No end date | Homes enrolled, pay $4 |
The exclusion is in Utah Code 54-17-905(5). Open No record found so far explains why lawmakers excluded Schedule 135 homes, or what happens to them after 2036.
9. Who decided — and what the PSC said
The PSC order of March 4, 2026 (Docket 25-035-06) was signed by Chair Jerry D. Fenn, Commissioner David R. Clark and Commissioner John S. Harvey, Ph.D. No dissent appears in the order.
- Rocky Mountain Power, the Division of Public Utilities and the Office of Consumer Services recommended waiting until a power contract was signed. The PSC approved the program effective immediately, citing expiring federal tax credits.
- Rocky Mountain Power and the Office of Consumer Services opposed a flat fee for homes. The PSC accepted the communities' request for a flat $4.
- The PSC wrote that it is generally not its role to protect residents from the decisions of their local elected leaders. Updated Nov. 17 Context: the line comes in the PSC's discussion of how costs are split among participants, right after it accepted the communities' request for a flat $4 for homes instead of charging by usage. It adds that the PSC has no jurisdiction over city-owned utilities either. It is not a general statement about protecting consumers.
- The PSC found the record did not support Rocky Mountain Power's method for valuing projects, and left that question for a later proceeding.
What the state's consumer advocates warned
| Office | Concern raised in testimony |
|---|---|
| Office of Consumer Services (Anthony Sandonato, Oct. 2025) | Until a power contract is signed, the rate is speculative; recommended no notices or charges until then. Participants pay into reserves in advance, and a project could end early or never be built. Real costs could end up higher than estimated. Preferred charging by usage over a flat fee, saying a flat fee makes low-use homes pay more for what they get. |
| Office of Consumer Services (rebuttal, Nov. 2025) | Rocky Mountain Power had no defined way to value projects, so no one could check that non-participants were protected. |
| Division of Public Utilities (Robert Davis, Oct. 2025) | Gave "measured support." Warned opt-outs could create a revenue spiral. Said the program rested largely on hypotheticals. Doubted tax-credit deadlines could be met given equipment and grid-connection delays. Asked for a reporting workgroup and yearly accounting. |
| Division of Public Utilities (Timothy Lenell, Daymark, Nov. 2025) | Argued for a 2-year administrative reserve, which the PSC adopted. Warned that spreading costs evenly can still shift some year-to-year costs onto non-participants. |
The federal tax credit deadline
At the Dec. 16, 2025 hearing, Rocky Mountain Power's witness agreed developers needed to start construction before July 4, 2026 to keep federal production tax credits. That date comes from the 2025 federal law (P.L. 119-21). Updated Nov. 17 For wind and solar projects expected online after 2027, starting construction by July 4, 2026 was key to keeping eligibility for the federal clean-electricity credits; projects placed in service by Dec. 31, 2027 have a separate route, subject to other requirements (IRS Notice 2025-42). Open Whether either chosen project actually started construction in time is not shown in records found.
Still being decided at the PSC
- Docket 26-035-38 (reporting and how projects are valued): opened Aug. 25, 2026. The PSC ordered Rocky Mountain Power to file proposed reporting requirements by Dec. 31, 2026, with a comment period after.
- Oct. 26, 2026 order: the PSC approved a change so customers who move no longer carry their enrollment to the new address.
- Residential surcharge: a PSC clarification on June 12, 2026 set the low-income surcharge inside the $4 at $0.10 for homes. Ogden's May 5 minutes describe it as $3.88 + $0.12; the $0.12 figure now applies to businesses only.
Public comments to the PSC
The hearing transcript counts 41 public comments as of Dec. 16, 2025. Several comment files came through an online letter tool sent on behalf of people associated with the Sierra Club Utah Chapter, mostly supporting the program while objecting to parts of Rocky Mountain Power's plan. One commenter asked for a "will not exceed" rate so customers would know the most they could pay.
9b. Energy money: what our Ledger shows
People in this story who received PacifiCorp contributions
| Person | Role in this story | PacifiCorp contributions on file |
|---|---|---|
| Gov. Spencer Cox | Signed H.B. 238 (2026) | $105,000 (2018–2026) |
| Rep. Carl Albrecht | Primary sponsor, H.B. 238 (2026) and H.B. 241 (2024); voted no on H.B. 411 in 2019 committee | $500 (2018), $1,000 (2022) itemized; Ledger reconstruction lists $2,000 Updated Nov. 17 Not reconciled The $1,500 itemized and $2,000 reconstructed totals have not been reconciled; neither is presented as a verified total. |
| Sen. Evan Vickers | Senate sponsor, H.B. 238 (2026); voted no on H.B. 411 in 2019 | $3,000 (2018, 2020, 2021) |
| Sen. David Hinkins | Chaired the Feb. 12 committee during H.B. 238; voted yes; sponsor of S.B. 214 (2024) | $2,000 (2018, 2020, 2023, 2024) |
| Sen. Scott Sandall | Committee member; voted yes | $4,500 (2018, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2025) |
| Sen. Keven Stratton | Committee member; voted yes on final passage | $2,000 (2019, 2020, 2022) |
| Sen. Derrin Owens | Committee chair; voted yes on final passage; Senate sponsor of H.B. 241 (2024) | $1,000 (2019, 2020) |
| Sen. Jerry Stevenson | Committee member; voted yes on the substitution | $2,000 (2018, 2019) |
| Sen. Keith Grover | Committee member; listed under "Abs" | $500 (2018) |
| Sen. Nate Blouin | Made both committee motions | None on file |
| Rep. Colin Jack | Chaired the House committee that passed the original H.B. 238, 10-0-2 | $1,000 (2025, 2026) |
| Rep. Stephen Handy | Primary sponsor, H.B. 411 (2019) | $2,000 (2018, 2019, 2020) |
| Daniel Hemmert | Senate sponsor, H.B. 411 (2019) | $5,500 (2018–2020) |
| Rep. Kay Christofferson | Offered the opt-in substitute to H.B. 411 in 2019 | $1,750 (2018, 2020) |
Party and leadership committees
| Recipient | PacifiCorp total on file |
|---|---|
| Utah House Republican Election Committee | $59,500 |
| Utah Republican Senate Campaign Committee | $54,500 |
| Adams Leadership PAC (Senate President) | $25,000 |
| House Speaker Leadership PAC | $18,500 |
| Governors Leadership PAC | $11,000 |
Connections on the record
- Jon Cox presented H.B. 238 alongside Rep. Albrecht on Feb. 12, 2026; the minutes list no affiliation. In 2019 he testified on H.B. 411 for Rocky Mountain Power, and a 2021 PacifiCorp contribution in the state database lists the filer as "Jon Cox/Pacificorp."
- Thom Carter, Rocky Mountain Power's vice president of government affairs, spoke in favor of the 3rd Substitute.
- PSC Chair Jerry Fenn assisted in presenting the bill. The PSC is the agency that approved the program and sets Rocky Mountain Power's rates.
Rocky Mountain Power's registered lobbyists (from Hive lobbyist research)
| Lobbyist | Rocky Mountain Power registration | Other connections on record |
|---|---|---|
| Carl Cox — Utah Public Affairs / Bankhead Strategies LLC | 10/18/2016 to present | Also registered for the Utah Rural Electric Cooperative Association (since 1/16/2022), whose director spoke for H.B. 238 on Feb. 12, and for Kern River Transmission, EnergySolutions, TerraPower and Torus. Paid vendor to Gov. Cox's campaign, $16,682.75 in 2023–2024. Bankhead Strategies gave $15,000 to Lincoln Hill PAC. No record found on whether he is related to Gov. Cox. |
| Jeff Hartley — Sage Government Solutions | 1/2/2013 to 7/12/2022 | Co-founder of H3 PAC (created 2023, dissolved July 2026). |
Source: lobbyist.utah.gov client rosters as pulled in Hive research (Carl Cox, August 2026; Jeff Hartley, folder 1412048, October 2026). Not to be confused: Carl Cox the lobbyist is a different person from an Ogden jeweler of the same name, and from Jon Cox, who presented H.B. 238 with Rep. Albrecht.
Who is registered to lobby, on every side (pulled Nov. 6, 2026)
| Hired by | Lobbyist (firm) | Registered since |
|---|---|---|
| Rocky Mountain Power / PacifiCorp | Robert Jolley (RRJ Consulting) | 12/17/2012 |
| Jodi Hart (RRJ Consulting) | 12/16/2012 | |
| Christopher Bleak (RRJ Consulting) | 2/5/2013 | |
| Carl Cox (Utah Public Affairs) | 10/18/2016 | |
| Thomas Carter (Rocky Mountain Power; The Exoro Group) | 6/7/2022 | |
| Maizee Thompson (Lincoln Hill Partners) | 1/23/2026 | |
| TerraPower (builds the Natrium plant) | Carl Cox (Utah Public Affairs) | 7/21/2025 |
| Valar Atomics West (reactor company) | Harry Hansen (Valar Atomics West) | 6/17/2026 |
| Creekstone Energy (planned Delta data center campus; studying nuclear with EnergySolutions) | Stephen Styler (Foxley & Pignanelli) | 12/16/2025 |
| Frank Pignanelli (Foxley & Pignanelli) | 12/22/2025 | |
| Renae Cowley (Foxley & Pignanelli) | 12/22/2025 | |
| Melanie Robe (Foxley & Pignanelli) | 4/20/2026 | |
| Lincoln Shurtz (Lincoln Hill Partners) | 7/21/2026 | |
| Carl Cox (Utah Public Affairs) | 10/1/2026 | |
| NOVVA (data centers) | Lincoln Shurtz (Lincoln Hill Partners) | 8/21/2024 |
| Chase Everton (Lincoln Hill Partners) | 8/28/2024 | |
| Aligned Data Centers | Lincoln Shurtz (Lincoln Hill Partners) | 1/20/2026 |
| QTS Data Centers | Stephen Hunter (Hunter and Company Communications) | 1/8/2026 |
| Powering Prosperity (not yet identified) | Carl Cox (Utah Public Affairs) | 11/6/2026 |
| Utah Chapter Sierra Club | Maria Archibald (Sierra Club) | 1/16/2024 |
| HEAL Utah | Paul Gonzalez (HEAL Utah) | 1/14/2022 |
| Katelyn Balakir (HEAL Utah) | 1/3/2025 | |
| Utah Clean Energy | Kevin Emerson (Utah Clean Energy) | 12/5/2012 |
| Sarah Wright (Utah Clean Energy) | 12/19/2012 | |
| Joshua Craft (Utah Clean Energy) | 1/20/2017 | |
| Logan Mitchell (Utah Clean Energy) | 8/26/2022 | |
| Western Resource Advocates | Steve Barth (SB Strategies) | 2/7/2019 |
| Riley Wheeler (Western Resource Advocates) | 12/11/2024 | |
| Utah Renewable Communities | No registration found under that name | |
What the list shows:
- Carl Cox is registered for Rocky Mountain Power (since 2016) and for TerraPower (since July 21, 2025). That is about 10 weeks before Rocky Mountain Power filed its Oct. 3, 2025 notice of intent to buy Natrium's power. He was added for Creekstone Energy on Oct. 1, 2026, and for "Powering Prosperity" on Nov. 6, 2026. He also has earlier registrations for EnergySolutions (since March 2023) and Enyo Energy (May 2023 – Dec. 2024).
- Lincoln Hill Partners lobbyists are registered for PacifiCorp/Rocky Mountain Power (Maizee Thompson) and for three data center companies: NOVVA, Aligned and Creekstone (Lincoln Shurtz, Chase Everton).
- The environmental groups each have their own staff registered. No lobbyist is registered under Utah Renewable Communities' name.
- Being registered for two clients is legal and common. The list does not show that any lobbyist worked on S.B. 132, H.B. 238 or the Natrium contract.
Source: lobbyist.utah.gov, "Lobbyist lookup by Principal Organization" (Search/LobbyistByPrincipal), read through the live page in Chrome on Nov. 6, 2026. Only active registrations (no end date) are listed, plus the dated past ones named in the bullets. Creekstone description: ANS Nuclear Newswire, Dec. 17, 2025.
The Beehive Energy Alliance
H.B. 238's primary sponsor, Rep. Carl Albrecht, and Rep. Colin Jack, who chaired the House committee that first passed the bill, are both listed on the board of the Beehive Energy Alliance, a Utah nonprofit that says it connects private energy companies, investors and government, and hosts an invite-only legislative dinner. Its vice chairman is listed as Utah GOP chairman Rob Axson.
Source: Beehive Energy Alliance board page as recorded in Hive research, August 2026.
The other side: environmental groups
- The Sierra Club Utah Chapter runs a political action committee that says it supports endorsed candidates with direct contributions or volunteer campaigns. Its page gives no names or amounts.
- Its 2026 general-election endorsements include Angela Choberka (House District 9). Choberka earlier represented Ogden on the Utah Renewable Communities board and served as its vice chair; Ogden's council replaced her as its representative in December 2025. Endorsements are not contributions — whether money went to her or others is not yet checked.
- None of the legislators who carried or voted on H.B. 238 appear on the Sierra Club's 2026 general-election endorsement list.
Checked Nov. 6, 2026 Lobbyists registered for the Sierra Club, HEAL Utah, Utah Clean Energy, Western Resource Advocates and Utah Renewable Communities: see the table above. Member cities' own lobbyists are not listed, because city registrations cover all city issues, not this program.
Open Not yet checked: campaign giving by environmental groups that pushed for the program (Sierra Club, HEAL Utah; Utah Clean Energy is a nonprofit), the federal PacifiCorp PAC (FEC C00082800), and Ogden City Council campaign filings, which are filed with the city, not the state database. The project developers cannot be checked until they are named.
Source: The Weber County Hive Ledger, PacifiCorp itemized research file (disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search, 2018–2026, last cross-checked Oct. 3, 2026). To verify per-person totals against the published Ledger pages before posting.
9c. Who it helps, who it costs, and what could have been done differently
| Who | What they gain | What they risk or pay | What the record shows was done by the rules | What could have been done differently |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homes that stay in | New clean power added to the grid in their name; projected lower rates later and refunds around 2043–2049 | $4 a month before any power contract is signed; rates can change; $30 to leave after May 1, 2027 | Two notices required; six-month free exit; flat fee that is easy to check | A "will not exceed" rate, as one public commenter asked; waiting for a signed contract, as three parties urged |
| People who don't notice the notice | Same as above, without choosing it | Pay by default | Opt-out is what the 2019 law set; check box added in 2026 | Opt-in, as the 2026 2nd Substitute and a 2019 substitute proposed |
| Low-income homes (Schedule 3) | Join free; no fee to leave | Credits depend on available program funds | Credit built into the tariff | — |
| Businesses | Count toward clean-energy goals | Charge grows with usage; leaving fee by size. Rocky Mountain Power assumed 70–95% would opt out | In-person notice for the largest users | Clearer cost examples per business size in the notice |
| Customers outside the program | Nothing directly | Must not pay program costs — but the valuation method that protects them is not yet approved | State law bars cost shifting; PSC opened a reporting docket | Approve the valuation method before collecting money, as the Office of Consumer Services urged |
| Rocky Mountain Power / PacifiCorp | New clean power on its grid backed by customers' reserve, not its own capital; contracts with developers | A program to administer; no profit line found in records read | Opposed the flat fee and recommended waiting for a signed contract | Name the developers and publish projected costs |
| Developers (not yet named) | Long-term contracts backed by up to 12½ years of reserves; federal tax credits if deadlines are met | Contract not enforceable until reserve fills | Competitive bids; 14 bids, scored and narrowed | — |
| City governments (Ogden: $51,774 for notices) | Meet climate goals; city's own power costs may fall (Ogden's municipal building estimate: $650 to $327 a month vs. Blue Sky) | Taxpayer money for notices and agency dues; any city accounts left enrolled pay the charge | Public hearings, ordinances, public comment | Publish total city costs; say whether city accounts were opted out; post agency audits |
| The agency (Utah Renewable Communities) | Runs a first-of-its-kind program | About $970,000 spent; about $150,000 a year going forward from rates | Public board meetings, posted packets and resolutions | Post an audit; name developers when contracts are signed |
| Consultants and lawyers | Paid work (part of about $970,000 spent) | — | Contracts approved in board packets | — |
| Environmental groups | A policy goal they backed for seven years | — | Public comments, testimony | — |
| Legislature | — | — | Committee hearing, public speakers, floor votes | Vote on the opt-in version openly; record a reason in the minutes for dropping it |
| Public Service Commission | — | — | Hearings, public witness hearing, written order with reasons | Wait for a signed contract and approve a valuation method first, as Rocky Mountain Power, the Division and the Office recommended |
"Could have been done differently" lists only alternatives that appear in the records — proposals made by legislators, state offices, the utility or public commenters.
9d. Nuclear: what Rocky Mountain Power is buying, from the company side and the customer side
(owned by a TerraPower company)"] --> B["Sells its power to Rocky Mountain Power
(contract approved June 1, 2026)"] B --> C["Same grid, same poles and wires"] C --> D["Cost goes into every customer's regular rates
(price kept confidential)"] E["Power plant built for a data center
(allowed by S.B. 132, 2025)"] --> F["Powers that campus only"] F --> G["Grid customers don't get the power
and don't pay for the plant"]
What the record shows
| Question | What the record shows | Record |
|---|---|---|
| What plant? | Natrium, called Kemmerer Unit 1. It is a 345-megawatt reactor with molten-salt heat storage, so its output can run from 100 to 500 megawatts for up to 5.5 hours. It is owned by US SFR Owner, LLC, a TerraPower company. Rocky Mountain Power buys the power; it does not own the plant. | PSC order, Docket 25-035-55, June 1, 2026; Rocky Mountain Power notice, Oct. 3, 2025 |
| When does it run? | The Division of Public Utilities says it is projected online at the end of 2031. The federal construction permit came in March 2026, and construction began in April 2026. In September 2026 the lead builder, Bechtel, left the project; TerraPower said the construction schedule is unchanged. | Division summary testimony, March 2026; ANS, April 24, 2026; Cowboy State Daily, Sept. 21, 2026 |
| How was it chosen? | Rocky Mountain Power asked to skip the normal competitive bidding. The PSC granted the waiver, finding the plant "presents a unique, time-limited opportunity." | PSC order, June 1, 2026 |
| What is the price? | Not public. The power contract, a water use agreement and Rocky Mountain Power's own review memo were filed as confidential exhibits. | Settlement stipulation, March 13, 2026 |
| Who signed off? | Rocky Mountain Power, the Division of Public Utilities, the Office of Consumer Services and Western Resource Advocates signed a settlement. Utah Clean Energy, the Utah Large Customer Group, the Utah Association of Energy Users and Nucor Steel did not oppose it. No party opposed it. Commissioners: Jerry Fenn (chair), David Clark, John Harvey. | PSC order, June 1, 2026 |
| What protects customers? | The Division says the contract was designed to limit ratepayer exposure, including a clause that limits customers' total liability; the details are confidential. Rocky Mountain Power is keeping its Naughton units available, so it is not counting on Natrium to keep the lights on. Until the plant runs, the company must compare its plans with and without Natrium. After the first year of operation it must report on the plant's performance every year. | Division summary testimony; PSC order |
| Will it buy more reactors? | In 2022, PacifiCorp and TerraPower agreed to study up to five more Natrium reactors by 2035. That was a study, not a purchase. Grist reported in February 2026 that PacifiCorp has firm plans for only the one Kemmerer reactor. | Utility Dive, Nov. 2, 2022; Grist, Feb. 24, 2026 |
| Why not the Utah reactors? | None of the proposed Utah reactors (Brigham City, Green River) is licensed or under construction. No filing was found in which any of them offers to sell power to Rocky Mountain Power. S.B. 132 (2025) lets a company that needs 100 megawatts or more build its own power plant off the public grid. The Stratos data center materials describe "dedicated on-site power generation designed to meet the campus's needs without placing additional demand on the existing electrical grid." | Grist, Feb. 24, 2026; MIDA Stratos project materials |
| Who pays for data center power? | Under the first large agreement made under S.B. 132, Rocky Mountain Power says the data center customer covers the full cost of its service. The customer is not named. | Rocky Mountain Power release, Feb. 2026 |
Every side of it
| Who | What they gain | What they risk or pay | What the record shows was done by the rules | Still open |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Company side: Rocky Mountain Power / PacifiCorp | Up to 500 megawatts of carbon-free power that can run day and night. The plant uses the retiring Naughton coal plant's connection, so no new transmission upgrades are needed. It buys the power instead of owning the plant. | A first-of-its-kind design. The Division warned "Delays in the project are a possibility." The company is keeping Naughton units as a backup. | PSC review, a settlement with both state consumer offices, yearly reporting | The order read does not say how the cost will show up in rates |
| Company side: TerraPower (plant owner) | A long-term buyer for its first commercial plant; support from the U.S. Department of Energy's Advanced Reactor Demonstration Program | Builds and owns the plant; lost its lead builder in September 2026 | Federal construction permit, March 2026 | The amount of federal money was not found in records read |
| Company side: Data center companies | Their own power on their own timeline. Novva told Grist Rocky Mountain Power could not supply it until 2031. | If Rocky Mountain Power serves them, the law requires them to pay all the added costs of serving them. If they build their own off-grid plant, they pay for it themselves (see "Two routes" below). | S.B. 132 (2025); first large-load contract approved April 10, 2026 | Whether any extra power would be sold to the grid, and at what price |
| Customer side: All Rocky Mountain Power customers | Power from a plant that runs around the clock, starting about 2031. The state office for homes and small businesses signed the settlement. A confidential clause limits customers' total liability. | They pay through regular rates whether or not they are in the clean energy program. They cannot see the price. Delays are possible. | Public docket, public hearing (March 31, 2026), public comment open | What it will add to a typical home bill |
| Customer side: Clean energy program members (16 communities) | Same as all customers | The $4 a month program charge on top of regular rates | Program and Natrium approved in separate dockets | Will Natrium's power count toward the program's net-100% goal? The agency proposed counting existing clean energy on the grid (Fall 2025 slides). No record found answers this. |
| Customer side: Customers where data center plants are built | The plant's cost is not on their bills. The Office of Consumer Services director called S.B. 132 one of the "best ideas out there" for protecting ratepayers. | No power from those plants. Grist reported that advocates warn on-site gas generators could affect Wasatch Front air quality. | S.B. 132 sets the rules | Same surplus question as above |
2. Reactors built for one company. Their power never reaches the grid, so their cost doesn't reach your bill either way. Whether residents get anything from them depends on surplus-sale terms no record found has answered.
Data centers: the two routes under S.B. 132
(S.B. 132, 2025)"] --> B["Asks Rocky Mountain Power for service"] B --> C["Rocky Mountain Power must finish its review
within 6 months, then make an offer"] C --> D["ROUTE 1: Contract with Rocky Mountain Power
Data center pays all added costs
PSC must find other customers don't pay"] C --> E["No deal in 90 days, or deadlines missed"] E --> F["ROUTE 2: Another power provider,
or its own off-grid plant"] F --> G["Off-grid plant: not regulated as a utility;
no right for the grid to get its power"]
| What the law says | Exact words | Utah Code |
|---|---|---|
| Who it covers | Service "expected to reach a cumulative demand of 100 megawatts or greater within five years" | 54-26-101(12) |
| Rocky Mountain Power comes first | The utility has the "sole right" to serve these customers in its territory, with listed exceptions | 54-26-401 |
| Deadline | Review "in no case more than 6 months after beginning the evaluation"; a written offer within 15 business days after that | 54-26-202 |
| Who pays (Route 1) | The contract must "ensure that all large load incremental costs are allocated to and paid by the large load customer" | 54-26-301(3)(a) |
| PSC check (Route 1) | The PSC must find that "existing ratepayers do not bear costs justly and reasonably attributable to providing electric service for the large load customer" | 54-26-302(2)(c) |
| When a data center may go elsewhere | If the utility misses its deadlines, or the two sides "cannot agree to a large load contract within 90 days" | 54-26-402(1) |
| Off-grid plants | A "closed private generation system" is one "not connected to and operates independently from the transmission system." These are "exempt from commission oversight or regulation as a public utility" | 54-26-101(1); 54-26-504(2)(a) |
| Extra power | The utility "is not required to purchase or accept any power from a connected generation system," except under a PSC-approved agreement | 54-26-505(6) |
| Nuclear | Not mentioned anywhere in the law | — |
| How long | Covers service that starts "on or before December 31, 2034." The PSC must review the law "before October 31, 2027, and every three years thereafter" | 54-26-801; 54-26-802 |
Sponsors: Sen. Scott Sandall (primary sponsor) and Rep. Colin Jack (House sponsor). Took effect May 7, 2025. The PSC's rule putting it into effect, R746-318, was signed Oct. 31, 2025. It sends a data center's own grid-connection costs straight to that data center and requires separate accounting. Both sponsors appear in section 9b: PacifiCorp gave Sandall $4,500 (2018–2025) and Jack $1,000 (2025–2026).
The first data center contract (Route 1)
| Question | What the record shows | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Was it approved? | Yes, on April 10, 2026, by Commissioners Fenn, Clark and Harvey. The settlement was signed by Rocky Mountain Power, the Division of Public Utilities and the Office of Consumer Services. | PSC order, Docket 26-035-05, April 10, 2026 |
| Who is the customer? | Not named. The order calls it "the Customer." Rocky Mountain Power's Feb. 2026 announcement called it a data center customer. | PSC order; Rocky Mountain Power release, Feb. 2026 |
| How big? | More than 100 megawatts of firm service. The exact size is redacted. | PSC order |
| What is secret? | The price, how the price works, and the contract length are marked "regulator access only." The PSC denied the Utah Association of Energy Users' request to see them, saying the group "failed to demonstrate a clear and convincing need." | PSC order |
| What powers it? | At first, Rocky Mountain Power buys power on the market for this customer. It then has two years to add new resources, whose type is redacted. The Office of Consumer Services' testimony says that while the customer is served, coal and gas generation increase, market purchases rise, and wind and solar cutbacks fall. | PSC order; Office of Consumer Services testimony (Cameron Irmas), March 3, 2026 |
| How are other customers protected? | The PSC found "existing customers will not incur costs properly allocable to the Customer." The customer's use is removed from the formulas that split costs among customers. The new resources' costs are kept out of regular rates, and Rocky Mountain Power can't recover them later without separate PSC approval. A reservation charge covers fixed costs even if the data center uses less power than forecast. | PSC order; settlement, March 13, 2026; Office of Consumer Services testimony |
| What did the consumer office warn? | Benefits "will shrink" if certain redacted assumptions don't hold. Transmission costs should be reviewed case by case, and this case "should not be used as a template for future cases." | Office of Consumer Services testimony |
Who pays for the Natrium plant
| Who | What they put in | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Taxpayers (U.S. Department of Energy) | About $2 billion committed, under the Advanced Reactor Demonstration Program | WyoFile, Sept. 21, 2026; GeekWire |
| Private investors | More than $1 billion earlier, from investors including Bill Gates and South Korea's SK companies, plus $650 million more from Gates and NVIDIA's venture arm | GeekWire |
| Rocky Mountain Power customers | Buy the plant's power through regular rates from about 2031, at a confidential price, with a confidential cap on customers' total liability | PSC order, Docket 25-035-55; Division summary testimony |
| Total plant cost | About $4 billion | WyoFile, Sept. 21, 2026 |
| What happened | What the record shows | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Lead builder left | Bechtel, the lead engineering and construction contractor since 2020, said the companies were "unable to reach an agreement on the next phase of the project." No public record gives more reason. Bechtel is finishing the sodium test building, and TerraPower will rebid the main contract. Bechtel filed a notice on about 200 jobs, saying it was a legal requirement and that it expects to move workers to other projects. | WyoFile; Cowboy State Daily, Sept. 21, 2026 |
| Schedule | TerraPower hopes for an operating license in 2028 and full operation by 2031. It says the construction schedule is unchanged. | WyoFile |
| Meta deal | Up to eight more Natrium reactors (up to 2.8 gigawatts), the first two as soon as 2032, at sites not yet chosen. No record says any Kemmerer power goes to Meta. | GeekWire |
10. What an auditor would check
| # | Area | Question | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Legal authority | Did every community pass its ordinance on time, and did the PSC application include what the law requires? | Documented (dates from URC; PSC found application complete) |
| 2 | Governance | Who sits on the agency board, who are its consultants, and are there any ties to bidding developers? | Board and consultants documented · ties to developers open (developers not yet named) |
| 3 | Money in | Do bills match the tariff? Are the right meters enrolled? Do city-paid accounts pay the charge? | Open |
| 4 | Money out | How much goes to start-up and administration vs. new power? Where is the reserve held? | Open |
| 5 | Taxpayer costs | What did each city pay for notices, outreach and agency dues? (State law puts notice costs on the communities.) | Ogden documented ($51,774 notices; $71,475 to the agency) · other cities partly open · no agency audit found |
| 6 | Notice and opt-out | Were two notices mailed within 60 days, separate from the bill, with a prominent check box? Were opt-outs honored? | Rules documented · compliance open |
| 7 | No cost shift | Are customers outside the program protected from its costs, as the law requires? | Open — valuation method not yet approved |
| 8 | Contracts | Who bid, how were they scored, who was picked, and what do the power contracts say? | Process documented (14 bids, 4, then 2 code-named projects) · names and contracts not yet public |
| 9 | If it ends | What happens to money already collected? | Open |
| 10 | Results | How much new clean power actually comes online compared with money collected? | Not yet measurable |
11. Questions to ask — and who to ask
| Question | Who to ask |
|---|---|
| Did the city opt its own accounts (streetlights, buildings) out, and what will the city pay if it did not? | Your city council |
| How much did our city pay for notices, outreach and agency dues? | Your city council or finance office |
| Why was the opt-in version of H.B. 238 dropped? | Your state senator and representative; the bill sponsors |
| How much of the money has gone to administration so far? | Utah Renewable Communities board (public meetings) |
| Which projects were chosen, and what will the power cost? | Utah Renewable Communities; PSC dockets |
| Is my account enrolled, and did my opt-out go through? | Rocky Mountain Power customer service |
| Will power from the Natrium nuclear plant count toward the program's net-100% goal? | Utah Renewable Communities board; Rocky Mountain Power |
| What will the Natrium contract add to a typical home bill, and when will the price be public? | Public Service Commission (Docket 25-035-55); Office of Consumer Services |
| Will any data center power plant sell extra power to the grid, and at what price? | MIDA; the city council or county where the plant is proposed |
| Who is the data center customer in the April 10, 2026 contract, and what new power resources will serve it? | Public Service Commission (Docket 26-035-05); Rocky Mountain Power |
| How much coal and gas generation is added to serve data centers, and what does that mean for Wasatch Front air? | Utah Division of Air Quality; Public Service Commission |
| When the PSC reviews S.B. 132 before Oct. 31, 2027, will the public be able to comment? | Public Service Commission; Public Utilities, Energy and Technology Interim Committee |
12. Words you will see
- Tariff / Schedule
- The official price sheet the PSC approves. This program is "Schedule 100."
- Docket
- A case file at the PSC, with a number like 25-035-06.
- PPA (power purchase agreement)
- A contract to buy power from a plant at a set price for many years.
- Developer
- The private company that builds and owns the power plant.
- Reserve
- The savings pot built from customers' monthly charges.
- Net-100%
- Over a year, enough clean power is added to the grid to equal what participants use. Your power still comes from the normal mix.
- Unincorporated
- Areas outside any city, run by the county.
- Kilowatt-hour (kWh)
- The unit your power use is measured in on your bill.
- Production tax credit
- A federal tax break for clean energy projects, with deadlines.
- Termination fee
- The fee to leave after the free window closes.
- Behind the meter
- Power made on site for one customer, such as a data center, and not sent onto the public grid.
- Large load
- A customer that will need 100 megawatts or more, usually a data center. Covered by S.B. 132 (2025).
- Closed private generation system
- A power plant built for one large customer and not connected to the grid. Not regulated by the PSC as a utility.
- Natrium
- TerraPower's nuclear plant design. The first one is being built in Kemmerer, Wyoming.
- Substitute bill
- A rewritten version of a bill that replaces the earlier version.
Sources
Show all sources and how each was read
- Rocky Mountain Power, Schedule 100 tariff, current version (sheets filed Aug. 7 and Sept. 1, 2026; effective Nov. 2, 2026) — full text read Nov. 17, 2026 (rates, notice period table, exit fees)
- Rocky Mountain Power, Community Clean Energy Program page — live page read Nov. 17, 2026 (how to opt out, phone, mailing address, exit fees)
- PSC Order Approving Waiver, Docket 25-035-06, Oct. 26, 2026 — full text read Nov. 17, 2026 (moving customers)
- PSC Docket 26-035-T12, Rocky Mountain Power tariff compliance filing, Nov. 2, 2026 — docket page read Nov. 17, 2026
- IRS Notice 2025-42 and summaries (Crowe; Mintz) — wind and solar credit deadlines under P.L. 119-21
- Utah Renewable Communities, FAQs — live page read Nov. 17, 2026 (renters and landlords)
- H.B. 238 (2026), enrolled — opt-out notice wording read Nov. 17, 2026
- Rocky Mountain Power responses to DPU data requests (DPU Exhibit 2.2) — responses 1.4 and 2.10 read Nov. 17, 2026 (fees; 12.5-year reserve as an estimate)
- Ogden City Council minutes, May 5, 2026 — read directly Nov. 17, 2026 (vote, speakers listed, $51,774)
- KSL, Nov. 2026: Power customers in 16 Utah communities face fee hike — notices mailed; three ways to opt out
- PSC Order Approving the Settlement, Docket 25-035-55 (Natrium), June 1, 2026 — 3456232503555oats6-1-2026.pdf, full text summary
- Settlement stipulation, Docket 25-035-55, March 13, 2026 — 344332StlmntStpltn3-13-2026.pdf, full text summary
- Division of Public Utilities summary testimony, Docket 25-035-55, March 2026 — full text summary
- Rocky Mountain Power notice of intent, Docket 25-035-55, Oct. 3, 2025 — full text summary
- lobbyist.utah.gov, Lobbyist lookup by Principal Organization — live page read in Chrome, Nov. 6, 2026
- ANS Nuclear Newswire, Dec. 17, 2025: Creekstone Energy taps EnergySolutions to study nuclear-powered data center — HTML summary read
- S.B. 132 (2025) Electric Utility Amendments, enrolled copy — SB0132.pdf, full text summary; quoted sections confirmed
- S.B. 132 2nd Substitute (Salmon) — full text summary
- PSC proposed rule R746-318, Large Scale Electric Requirements, Oct. 31, 2025 — full text summary
- PSC Order Approving Settlement, Docket 26-035-05 (large-load contract), April 10, 2026 — full text summary
- Settlement stipulation, Docket 26-035-05, March 13, 2026 — full text summary
- Office of Consumer Services direct testimony, Cameron Irmas (redacted), March 3, 2026 — full text summary of the public version
- Rocky Mountain Power rebuttal testimony, Craig Eller, March 10, 2026 — full text summary
- WyoFile, Sept. 21, 2026: Lead contractor pulls out of Natrium — HTML summary read
- GeekWire: TerraPower signs deal with Meta for up to 8 reactors — HTML summary read
- HEAL Utah, Nov. 6, 2025: RMP Wants to Fast-Track Nuclear; Keeps Details Secret — HTML summary read
- ANS Nuclear Newswire, April 24, 2026: TerraPower begins construction in Kemmerer — HTML summary read
- Cowboy State Daily, Sept. 21, 2026: TerraPower replacing Bechtel — HTML summary read
- Grist, Feb. 24, 2026: Utah data centers turning to fossil fuels — HTML summary read
- Utility Dive, Nov. 2, 2022: PacifiCorp, TerraPower to study up to 5 more reactors — HTML summary read
- Rocky Mountain Power release, Feb. 2026: Operation Gigawatt large-load agreement — HTML summary read
- PSC Order Approving Program with Modifications, Docket 25-035-06, March 4, 2026 — 3441662503506oapwm3-4-2026.pdf, full text read
- Rocky Mountain Power compliance tariff filing, Docket 26-035-T09, Aug. 7, 2026 — 346371Trf8-7-2026.pdf, full text read (proposed version)
- Draft Schedule 100 tariff — utah.gov public notice file 1472471.pdf, full text read (marked DRAFT)
- Draft opt-out notice — utah.gov public notice file 1472473.pdf, search excerpt read
- H.B. 238 original — full text read
- H.B. 238 1st Substitute — full text read
- H.B. 238 2nd Substitute (opt-in) — full text read
- H.B. 238 3rd Substitute — full text read
- H.B. 238 enrolled — full text read
- Senate committee report, Feb. 12, 2026 — full text read
- House passage letter, Feb. 5, 2026 — search excerpt read
- Senate passage letter, Feb. 19, 2026 — search excerpt read
- House concurrence letter, Feb. 20, 2026 — search excerpt read
- Utah Renewable Communities: Meet the 16 Communities — search excerpt read
- Utah Renewable Communities: Program Timeline — full page read
- KSL, June 8, 2026: 16 Utah locales opt to take part — full page read
- KSL: Utah regulators OK program — search excerpt read
- Salt Lake City program page — search excerpt read
- Utah Clean Energy: Connecting solar to the grid — full page read
- PSC commissioners page — search excerpt read
- Senate NRAE Committee minutes, Feb. 12, 2026 — HTML page read; votes confirmed directly
- Senate NRAE Committee agenda, Feb. 12, 2026 — snae0212.ag.pdf, text extraction
- Committee meeting video page, Feb. 12, 2026 — page read; video not yet watched
- KPCW, April 17, 2026 (opt-in reversal report) — HTML summary read
- Utah Clean Energy session wrap-up, April 2, 2026 — HTML summary read
- FastDemocracy H.B. 238 roll calls — third-party tracker, HTML summary read
- Governor's bill actions page — HTML summary read
- 2019 H.B. 411 bill page and committee minutes — HTML summary read
- 2019 H.B. 411 3rd Substitute (Christofferson, opt-in) — text extraction
- 2024 S.B. 214 — HTML summary read
- Ogden City Council minutes, May 5, 2026 — 1444075.pdf, text extraction; vote and cost confirmed directly
- Ogden work session minutes, April 21, 2026 — 1436463.pdf, text extraction summary
- Ogden work session minutes, April 7, 2026 — 1428727.pdf, text extraction summary
- Ogden City program page (history and payments) — HTML summary read
- KSL, May 7, 2026: Ogden opts in — HTML summary read
- Standard-Examiner, Aug. 18, 2021 — HTML summary read
- Agency board packet, July 13, 2026 — 1459757.pdf, text extraction summary
- Agency board packet with treasurer's report, Aug. 3, 2026 — 1467549.pdf, text extraction summary
- Agency board minutes, Aug. 3, 2026 — 1491297.pdf, text extraction summary
- Agency board packet, Oct. 5, 2026 — 1495347.pdf, text extraction summary
- Agency Resolution 26-02, Feb. 2, 2026 (short list) — 1387795.pdf, text extraction summary
- Agency Resolution 26-08, Sept. 14, 2026 (two projects) — 1491303.pdf, text extraction summary
- Salt Lake City press release, Oct. 29, 2026 — HTML summary read
- OCS direct testimony, Anthony Sandonato, Oct. 10, 2025 — full text summary
- OCS rebuttal testimony, Nov. 13, 2025 — full text summary
- DPU direct testimony, Robert Davis, Oct. 10, 2025 — full text summary
- DPU rebuttal testimony, Timothy Lenell, Nov. 13, 2025 — full text summary
- RMP direct testimony, Robert Meredith, June 4, 2025 — full text summary
- PSC hearing transcript, Dec. 16, 2025 — full text summary
- PSC order, Docket 26-035-38, Sept. 14, 2026 — full text summary
- PSC Notice of Clarification, June 12, 2026 (3457722503506noc6-12-2026.pdf) and Order Approving Waiver, Oct. 26, 2026 (3476482503506oaw10-26-2026.pdf), Docket 25-035-06 — full text summaries
- KPCW, May 28, 2026: Coalville says no — HTML summary read
- FOX13: Kearns decides against — HTML summary read
- Cottonwood Heights minutes, Jan. 20, 2026 — HTML summary read
- Utah Renewable Communities FAQ — HTML summary read
- RMP responses to DPU data requests (DPU Exhibit 2.2), Oct. 10, 2025 — 342227DPUExhbt2.2RMPRspnsDRs10-10-2025.pdf, text extraction; data request 1.4 confirmed directly
- Agency board minutes, Oct. 7, 2024 (Resolution 24-08) — 1197763.pdf, text extraction; vote confirmed directly
- Agency board packet with Resolution 24-08 fee schedule — 1178447.pdf, text extraction summary
- Christopher Thomas rebuttal testimony, Nov. 13, 2025 — text extraction summary
- Craig Eller direct testimony, June 4, 2025 (balancing account, escrow) — text extraction summary
- Utility Agreement template (2023) — 1042355.pdf, text extraction summary
- Utah Admin. Code R746-314-306 (termination fee rule) — HTML read
- Sierra Club Utah Chapter political action committee page — HTML summary read
- Sierra Club Utah Chapter 2026 general-election endorsements — HTML summary read
- Congressional Research Service on 2025 tax credit deadlines — HTML summary read
"Summary" means the document was read through a tool that returns a summary of its text, not by viewing rendered pages. Figures marked "to verify" should be checked against the rendered PDF before publishing.
