Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Transparency Docket The Weber County Hive
CASE 2026-AMD-01 · ELECTIONS & BALLOT MEASURES · POSTED OCT. 7, 2026 · UPDATED OCT. 17, 2026

The Amendments on Your Ballot, and How We Got Here

Part 2 of 4: Amendment B and the numbers

CASE 2026-AMD-01 · Posted Oct. 7, 2026 · Updated Oct. 17, 2026

New to this? Read it in plain words One short page for all four parts, with simple charts.
Short version
Transparency pages (27) · tap to open
  1. Transparency docketEvery case file, searchable
  2. The 2026 Amendments · plain wordsAmendments A and B on your ballot
  3. Amendment B: Myth vs. Fact · plain wordsClaims checked against the record
  4. Amendment B QuizTest what you know
  5. Who Sits at the Taxpayers Association's Table · plain wordsIts leaders, lobbyists, sponsors and their money
  6. Weber Housing Authority · plain wordsA commissioner, his wife and the authority that pays their company
  7. What the Privacy Office Can and Can't Do · plain wordsUtah's Chief Privacy Officer
  8. Counting the Jobs · plain wordsJob promises and what was reported
  9. Matt Brower · plain wordsThe board seat that never came up
  10. Ten Days · plain wordsThe Nilson Foundation's 501(c)(3) claim
  11. One Vote, Four Checks · plain wordsS.B. 258 and preliminary municipalities
  12. The Land Counties Can't Zone · plain wordsTrust land and county zoning
  13. SITLA: The Land Nobody Zones · plain wordsWho answers for trust land
  14. Tyson Leaves Eagle Mountain · plain wordsFive years after opening
  15. Behind the Bench · plain wordsJudge and lawyer complaints in Utah
  16. Wrong Room, Right Message · plain wordsA housing adviser in Heber City
  17. Every Weber County Property Tax Increase Since 2019 · plain wordsThe full list
  18. A New Line on the Bill · plain wordsRoy and Riverdale fire annexation
  19. Paying for the Next Station · plain wordsHow Weber Fire District funds growth
  20. Weber County's New Sales Tax · plain wordsA public vote, but no vote by the public
  21. Bills That Did the Opposite · plain wordsBait and switch, 2018 to 2026
  22. The Blank Box · plain wordsThree disclosure forms, one pattern
  23. Utah's Campaign-Finance Enforcement Gap · plain wordsComplaints filed, few penalties
  24. One Lake, Two Money Pots · plain wordsThe Great Salt Lake Trust Council
  25. Wells at the Top · plain wordsPowder Mountain's water
  26. Then vs. Now · plain wordsEarlier plans and later approvals in Ogden Valley
  27. West Haven's 6% Energy Tax · plain wordsA new line on the power bill

Amendment B: 60% for citizen tax initiatives

S.J.R. 2 (2025). Primary sponsor: Sen. Lincoln Fillmore. House sponsor: Rep. Jason B. Kyle. Passed the Senate 21–8 (Feb. 5, 2025) and the House 55–17 (March 6, 2025).

An initiative needs at least 60% if it "includes" (A) a new tax, (B) an existing tax expanded to more items or transactions, (C) a rate increase, or (D) a property-tax rate that decreases less than current law would. It applies to votes after Nov. 1, 2026, and only to statewide citizen initiatives.

The question on your ballot:

"Shall the Utah Constitution be amended to require that citizen-proposed laws that increase taxes compared to existing law be approved by at least 60% of voters, instead of a simple majority?"

Ballot text as printed in the Davis County 2026 General Election Notice. Note the ballot says "increase taxes"; the constitutional text says "includes."

Part D note: under Truth in Taxation the certified property-tax rate falls as values rise, so Part D reaches initiatives that keep revenue higher than the falling rate would, not ordinary tax cuts.

WORKED EXAMPLE · ROUND NUMBERS, NOT A REAL DISTRICT

A district collects $1,000,000 a year on $1 billion of taxable value. Its rate is 0.100%.

Next year, values rise 10%RateDistrict collects
Truth in Taxation (current law): rate falls so revenue stays the sameabout 0.091%$1,000,000
A citizen initiative holds the rate at 0.100% to fund schools0.100%$1,100,000

The initiative never raises the rate, but the rate "decreases less than current law would." Under Part D it needs 60%. A district can collect the same extra $100,000 today by holding a Truth in Taxation hearing, with no public vote.

OPEN QUESTION

Who decides whether an initiative "includes" a tax? S.J.R. 2 does not say, and no record reviewed for this page answers it. "Current law" in Part D is also undefined. Both questions go to the sponsors (see Questions to ask).

Added Oct. 17, 2026: the impartial analysis in the 2026 Voter Information Pamphlet lists the same four items. A text read of the pamphlet on Oct. 17 did not find a named official or body that makes the call either. (pamphlet)

Full text, 23 claims checked, scenarios and related bills → Amendment B: Myth vs. Fact

In their words

What supporters and opponents have said, quoted from KSL (Jan. 30, 2025) and Axios (Oct. 7, 2026).

"How easy do you want it to be for your neighbors to raise your taxes?"Sen. Lincoln Fillmore, primary sponsor (supports)
A higher bar would "ensure that there is a broad consensus of agreement among the citizens that that's the right thing to do."Sen. Lincoln Fillmore (supports)
"Taxes should be hard to raise."Billy Hesterman, Utah Taxpayers Association (supports)
"The bar is being raised higher for us, but not for you."Kael Weston, former congressional candidate (opposes)
"If you want to raise your neighbors' taxes, you should have broad support from your neighbors."Sen. Lincoln Fillmore and Rep. Jason Kyle, sponsors (Axios, Oct. 7, 2026)
"Allowing 40% of the population to block some of these policies just doesn't seem right."Elizabeth Rasmussen, Utahns Protecting Our Constitution (opposes; Axios, Oct. 7, 2026)

What the record adds: the Legislature raises taxes by a majority of each house, and PID, MIDA and UIPA boards act with no public vote. See What vote does it take?

How and when you are told

How notice of A and B was actually published for 2026 is not documented on this page; it is listed under Questions to ask.

Added Oct. 17, 2026: The Salt Lake Tribune reported on Oct. 12, 2026 that both amendments on this year's ballot had to be published in newspapers, at an estimated cost of $1.4 million. The newspaper notices themselves were not found in news searches or Utah Public Notice Website search results on Oct. 17, so how and where they ran is still not documented here. (Salt Lake Tribune, Oct. 12, 2026)

Where the notice would run

Today (Constitution)If A passes (H.B. 481)
Who publishesSet by the Constitution; the Lt. Governor's office handles election noticesThe Lt. Governor
Where"in at least one newspaper in every county of the state, where a newspaper is published"A "class A notice": (1) the Utah Public Notice Website (utah.gov/pmn), (2) the Lt. Governor's official website, and (3) a physical posting in a public place "reasonably likely to be seen"
Newspaper?RequiredNot required by the class A notice law. Newspapers can ask for an automatic feed of Public Notice Website postings (S.B. 201, 2024).
How long"for two months""for 60 calendar days immediately preceding the next general election"
What is publishedThe proposed amendment"the entire text of the proposed constitutional amendment"

Sources: Utah Const. Art. XXIII, Sec. 1; H.B. 481 (2025) enrolled text; Utah Code 63G-30-102 (class A notice); Utah League of Cities and Towns summary of S.B. 201 (2024). The class A notice law ties website posting to public bodies with an operating budget of $250,000 or more.

In black and white

YES on A

  • Newspaper notice is no longer required by the Constitution.
  • The Legislature sets the notice method by statute.
  • Notice runs the 60 days before the election.

NO on A

  • The Constitution keeps requiring newspaper notice in every county for two months.
  • Changing the method later still takes a constitutional amendment.

YES on B

  • A citizen initiative that includes a tax increase, as S.J.R. 2 defines it, needs 60%: a new tax, a tax on more items, a higher rate, or a property-tax rate that falls less than current law would. Plain tax cuts still need a simple majority.
  • Initiatives with no tax still need a simple majority.
  • Lawmakers, counties, cities and districts are unchanged.

NO on B

  • Every statewide citizen initiative keeps the simple-majority rule.
  • The existing checks stay: legal review, cost estimate, 7 hearings, ~140,000 signatures from 26 of 29 Senate districts.
  • The Legislature can still amend initiatives afterward. Since July 2024, a change that impairs an initiative that reforms government must be narrowly tailored to a compelling government interest (Utah Supreme Court).

Sources: le.utah.gov, 2026 proposed constitutional amendments; S.J.R. 2 (2025); vote.utah.gov, "Instructions for a Statewide Initiative"; League of Women Voters v. Utah Legislature, Utah Supreme Court, July 11, 2024.

Corrected Oct. 7, 2026, after a reader comment: the YES column said "tax change," which could suggest tax cuts need 60%; it now says "tax increase, as S.J.R. 2 defines it." The NO column said the Legislature can amend "any initiative"; it now notes the 2024 limit on changes that impair government-reform initiatives.

The numbers, in charts

Six charts built only from the records cited on this page.

What vote does it take?

Share of the vote needed to approve, by who is deciding.

Citizen tax initiative, today
50% + 1
Citizen tax initiative, if Amendment B passes
60%
Legislature passing a tax
Majority of each house
Legislature putting an amendment on the ballot
Two-thirds of each house
PID, MIDA and UIPA boards: bonds, tax breaks, tax increment
No public vote at all
Appointed or developer-led boards decide

Sources: S.J.R. 2 (2025); Utah Const. Art. VI and Art. XXIII; S.B. 228 (2019); MIDA–Box Elder interlocal §6(a); UIPA Tooele project area plan.

Does a citizen initiative need 60% under Amendment B?

Follow your initiative down the chart.

flowchart TD S["Does the initiative
include a tax increase
or new tax?"] -->|"No tax at all"| M1["Simple majority"] S -->|"Only cuts a tax"| M2["Simple majority"] S -->|"Cuts one tax,
adds another (swap)"| R1["60%"] S -->|"Closes a loophole or
ends a tax break"| R2["60%"] S -->|"Makes someone pay
the same rate as others"| R3["60%"] S -->|"Keeps a property tax
rate from falling"| R4["60%"] S -->|"Costs money but
leaves funding out"| L["Simple majority,
but the Legislature
decides whether to fund it"] classDef red fill:#FDECEA,stroke:#B42318,color:#7A1A12; classDef green fill:#E8F5EC,stroke:#1E7B3C,color:#14532D; class R1,R2,R3,R4 red; class M1,M2,L green;

Source: S.J.R. 2 (2025), items A–D ("includes" a new tax, an expansion to more items or transactions, a rate increase, or a property-tax rate that decreases less than current law would). Who decides whether an initiative "includes" a tax is not stated in S.J.R. 2.

Test an initiative

Tick everything your initiative would do.

Simple majorityNo tax increase selected.

Based on S.J.R. 2 (2025), items A–D. Who makes the official call is not stated in S.J.R. 2.

Prop 3 (2018) against the line

Medicaid expansion, paid for with a 0.15% sales tax.

Yes vote
53%
50% today
60% under B
Passes today. Would fail under Amendment B.

Sources: Ballotpedia; Salt Lake Tribune, Nov. 7, 2018. The Legislature changed Prop 3 with S.B. 96 (Feb. 11, 2019).

Slide the vote

Drag to set the share of voters who vote yes on a citizen tax initiative.

53%
Today: PASSES
Under B: FAILS

Starts at 53%, Prop 3's 2018 result (Ballotpedia).

Decided with no public vote

Total debt or tax money committed by boards and officials. Bars are drawn to the same scale.

PID bonds issued statewide (as of Aug. 7, 2026)
$5.267 billion
Alpine School District lease revenue bonds, after S.B. 188 (2025)
$201 million
UIPA Tooele Valley: tax increment to the project (projected)
~$51.6 million

Separate, yearly: Weber County 0.20% sales tax, about $13.1 million a year, imposed by County Commission vote. (A yearly amount isn't drawn on the same scale as total debt.)

Sources: State Auditor Tina Cannon, public statement Aug. 10, 2026; S.B. 188 (2025) and Alpine School District bond records; UIPA Tooele Valley Project Area Plan; CASE 2026-STAX-01. Amendment B changes none of these.

How lawmakers voted to put A and B on your ballot

■ Yes   ■ No   ■ Absent / not voting

Amendment B (S.J.R. 2), Senate, Feb. 5, 2025
21 yes
8
Amendment B (S.J.R. 2), House, March 6, 2025
55 yes
17
3
Amendment A (H.J.R. 10), House, Feb. 26, 2025
70 yes
5
Amendment A (H.J.R. 10), Senate, March 7, 2025
29 yes

Source: Ballotpedia, March 10 and March 12, 2025; Ballotpedia measure page for H.J.R. 10. Amendment B: all 76 yes votes were Republicans; 6 Republicans and 19 Democrats voted no.

Who Amendment B could help, and who it could hurt

Effects of how the rule works, not anyone's motives. Only the two named groups have taken a public position.

Could help

  • Anyone opposing a new tax: 40% + 1 now blocks a citizen tax initiative
  • Businesses with tax breaks or exemptions (closing a break = 60%), e.g. data centers at 0.5% vs. 6%
  • The Legislature: keeps more control over tax policy
  • Well-funded campaigns against an initiative
  • On record, supports: Utah Taxpayers Association; Taxpayer Shield PAC, chaired by S.J.R. 2 sponsor Sen. Lincoln Fillmore (Axios, Oct. 7, 2026; state PAC filing)

Could hurt

  • Initiatives that fund a program with a tax: health care (Prop 3), schools, water and the Great Salt Lake, parks, transit, housing
  • People those programs serve
  • "Fair share" and loophole-closing measures, even when most residents' taxes go down
  • Small, volunteer initiative campaigns
  • On record, opposes: Utahns Protecting Our Constitution

Not affected

  • The Legislature, county commissions, city councils, school boards, PID, MIDA and UIPA boards
  • Initiatives with no tax, and initiatives that only cut a tax

Sources: S.J.R. 2 (2025); KSL, Jan. 30, 2025 (Utah Taxpayers Association); state campaign filings (Utahns Protecting Our Constitution); MIDA–Box Elder interlocal §6(a); Ballotpedia (Prop 3).

How we got here

Part 1: what happened to the 2018 initiatives.

flowchart TD A["Nov. 2018
Voters pass Props 2, 3 and 4"] --> B["Dec. 3, 2018
Prop 2 (medical cannabis)
replaced by H.B. 3001;
home growing removed"] B --> C["Feb. 11, 2019
Prop 3 (Medicaid, 0.15% sales tax)
changed by S.B. 96"] C --> D["2020
Prop 4 (redistricting)
replaced by S.B. 200"]

Sources: NORML, Dec. 6, 2018; Ballotpedia, Feb. 12, 2019; KJZZ, July 11, 2024.

Part 2: the courts and the amendments.

flowchart TD E["July 11, 2024
Utah Supreme Court, 5–0:
reform initiatives are protected
from unlimited repeal"] --> F["2024
Legislature places
Amendment D on the ballot"] F --> G["Sept.–Oct. 2024
Amendments D and A voided:
newspaper notice not published"] G --> H["Feb.–March 2025
Legislature passes
H.J.R. 10 (A) and S.J.R. 2 (B)"] H --> I["Aug. 2025
District court: Prop 4 repeal
unconstitutional"] I --> J["Nov. 3, 2026
Amendments A and B
on your ballot"]

Sources: KJZZ; FOX 13; KUER; Ballotpedia, March 2025 and Aug. 29, 2025.

Tap a year for the record

2018: Voters pass Props 2, 3 and 4

Prop 2 (medical cannabis) and Prop 3 (Medicaid, 0.15% sales tax) each passed with 53%. Prop 4 created an independent redistricting commission. (NORML; Ballotpedia; KJZZ)

Dec. 2018 – 2020: Lawmakers change all three

H.B. 3001 replaced Prop 2 and removed home growing (Dec. 3, 2018). S.B. 96 changed Prop 3 (signed Feb. 11, 2019). S.B. 200 replaced Prop 4 (2020).

Dec. 2019 – Jan. 2020: A citizen referendum stops a tax increase

S.B. 2001 raised the sales tax on food. Citizens filed 152,000 referendum signatures; lawmakers repealed it Jan. 27, 2020. (Ballotpedia)

July 11, 2024: Supreme Court rules on Prop 4

Unanimous: reform initiatives are protected from unlimited repeal. Justice Paige Petersen: "When Utahns exercise their right to reform the government through a citizen initiative, their exercise of these rights is protected from government infringement." (KJZZ)

Sept.–Oct. 2024: Amendments D and A voided

Newspaper notice was not published as the Constitution requires. Amendment D's ballot language was also found misleading. (FOX 13; KUER)

Feb.–March 2025: A and B referred to the 2026 ballot

H.J.R. 10 passed 70–0 and 29–0. S.J.R. 2 passed 21–8 and 55–17. (Ballotpedia)

Aug. 2025: Prop 4 repeal ruled unconstitutional

A district court struck the 2021 congressional map. (Ballotpedia, Aug. 29, 2025)

Nov. 3, 2026: Amendments A and B on your ballot

Both need a simple majority of voters to pass.

What voters passed vs. what the Legislature changed

Each 2018 initiative: what the law looked like before, what voters approved, and what happened after.

Prop 2: medical cannabis

Passed with 53% · No new tax

Before
2014 law let epilepsy patients possess certain CBD products, but "provided no legal in-state supply source" (NORML). In 2018, H.B. 195 allowed cannabis products for patients with "six months or less to live"; H.B. 197 (state growing) first failed 36–34 because it "needed 38 votes" (KSL), then passed later (NORML).
Voters passed
Home growing (6 plants) for patients over 100 miles from a dispensary; at least one dispensary per county; edibles; autoimmune disorders and "chronic or debilitating pain" as qualifying conditions. Fees were to cover about $1.4 million of ongoing costs; medical cannabis was exempt from sales tax (FOX 13, citing the Governor's budget office).
Legislature changed (H.B. 3001, Dec. 3, 2018)
No home growing; 5 licensed "pharmacies" with a pharmacist, plus a state central fill pharmacy; no edibles; flower only in blister packs; autoimmune disorders dropped and pain must last over two weeks without responding to conventional medicine; cities may zone pharmacies out of some areas (KSL; NORML).
Today
"Medical cannabis products are exempt from taxes, including the state sales tax" (Marijuana Policy Project).

Prop 3: Medicaid expansion

Passed with about 53% · 0.15% statewide sales tax

Before
2015: the House voted down Gov. Herbert's "Healthy Utah" plan. 2016: H.B. 437 covered "a little more than sixteen thousand Utahns" in extreme poverty (KUER, March 8, 2016).
Voters passed
Coverage up to 138% of the poverty level; federal government pays 90%, Utah 10%; a 0.15% sales tax for Utah's share.
Legislature changed (S.B. 96, Feb. 11, 2019)
Coverage cut to 100% of the poverty level from April 1, 2019; Utah's share under that plan 30%, not 10% (Jurist); the full 0.15% tax kept (Ballotpedia). Fiscal analysts estimated a "two-year cost of $49 million," about five times Prop 3's projected $10.4 million shortfall (Salt Lake Tribune, Feb. 4, 2019), while giving up $103 million (FY2019) and $407 million (FY2020) in federal funds (S.B. 96 fiscal note).
After
The federal government rejected the cap and would not pay 90% below 138% (Deseret News, Aug. 22, 2019). Full expansion began January 2020 with a work requirement, suspended April 2020 and later removed (healthinsurance.org). H.B. 15 (2026) ends expansion sooner if the federal share drops below 90% (le.utah.gov).

Prop 4: independent redistricting

Passed with 50.34% · No tax

Voters passed
An independent commission to draw maps and submit them to the Legislature; a ban on partisan gerrymandering.
Legislature changed (S.B. 200, 2020)
The commission became advisory, so the Legislature can ignore its maps; the partisan-gerrymandering ban was repealed (League of Women Voters).
After
July 2024: Utah Supreme Court protects government-reform initiatives from unlimited changes. Aug. 2025: district court rules the repeal unconstitutional and strikes the 2021 map (Ballotpedia). 2026: a Utah GOP-led initiative to repeal Prop 4 failed to qualify after signature withdrawals in Senate District 15 (Ballotpedia, March 28, 2026).

If Amendment B had applied in 2018, only Prop 3 would have needed 60%. B applies to votes after Nov. 1, 2026 and does not reach back.

The court in 2026

The citizen side of the ledger

Updates since this was posted

Updates about Amendment B found online on Oct. 17, 2026. The full list, including Amendment A, is on Part 1.

Words to know

Tap a card to see what it means.

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Questions readers can ask public bodies. The full list is on Part 4.

Sen. Lincoln Fillmore and Rep. Jason KyleWho decides whether an initiative "includes" a tax, and when is "current law" measured for Part D?
Lt. Governor's officeWould the office, the Legislative Fiscal Analyst or a court make the call on whether an initiative needs 60%?
Taxpayer Shield PAC and Utahns Protecting Our ConstitutionWho is funding each campaign, and how much has each spent? (Their reports are filed at disclosures.utah.gov.)

Connected Hive work

Related case files in this repo and other Hive repos.

Behind this piece

82
Sources in the full source list
44
Public comments checked
20
Fact-or-fiction claims
24
Taxes and tax tools on the record
19
Pages and records opened for the Oct. 17 update
16
Searches run for the Oct. 17 update (estimate)

Posted Oct. 7, 2026. Updated Oct. 17, 2026: split into four linked parts, new layout and colors, short versions, jump links, a plain-words page, a diagram for Amendment A, words to know, questions to ask, connected Hive work and updates found online. Dated notes were added next to the original text (voter pamphlet, newspaper notice cost, a quote check on S.B. 26). Wording fixes: "Chief sponsor" now reads "Primary sponsor" (twice), and the 60% marker line on the vote chart is now red instead of gold, so its caption says "red dashed line." No earlier facts or figures changed.

Sources (click to open)

Added Oct. 17, 2026

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism