- One grant line, two networks: in the 2025–26 budget year, the Legislature paid direct grants through the Department of Cultural and Community Engagement’s Arts & Museums line to Hope of Utah ($150,000) and to Sistema Utah’s “Youth Arts Access for Utah’s Future” ($100,000) (budget motions, Mar. 5, 2026; Sistema request).
- Who runs them: Hope of Utah’s directors are Ron Williams (chair), Jamie Renda and Al Jackson (vice chairs) (2025 IRS Form 990-EZ). Sistema Utah’s trustees are Carolyn Sharette, David Sharette and Catherine Findlay (its IRS Form 990-EZ and Utah corporation filing). Carolyn Sharette leads American Preparatory Schools, a charter school management company.
- Filed as education, paid as arts: Hope of Utah’s funding request form was filed under “Public Education,” directed to the State School Board. The Legislature heard it in its Economic and Community Development budget committee on Feb. 7, 2025, and paid it from the Arts & Museums “Pass Through Grants” line (Hope request; state budget record H.A.R. 143).
- Now every year: in 2026 Rep. Lisonbee asked again, and the Legislature gave Hope of Utah $187,000 a year, ongoing, starting July 2026 (state budget record H.A.R. 49; H.B. 3, 2026, Item 210).
- People in common: State School Board Member Joseph Kerry is listed as Hope of Utah’s “Former Co-Founder,” and Carolyn Sharette gave to his campaigns in 2024, 2025 and 2026. Cari Bartholomew sits on Hope of Utah’s advisory board and got 2024 campaign money from both Sharette and Brooke Stephens. Rep. Karianne Lisonbee asked for Hope’s grant and gave to Kerry’s campaign.
- The book link: Hope of Utah’s own affiliates page lists “Rate My Books” (ratedbooks.org), the book-rating site run by Brooke Stephens. Kerry voted for Board Member Emily Green’s library review addendum and co-moved her Aug. 4 memo. See How a Book Gets Pulled From Every Utah School.
- Still unknown: who received Hope of Utah’s $85,659.37 in pass-through money. Its state report does not name them.
The map, in three parts
Each arrow is labeled with the record it comes from. An arrow means “a record shows this.” It does not mean one person directed another.
1. The money: one state grant line
Arts & Museums grants line"] L -->|"$150,000
asked by Rep. Lisonbee"| H["Hope of Utah
Ogden"] L -->|"$100,000
asked by Sen. Cullimore"| S["Sistema Utah
Youth Arts Access"] H --- HD["Directors: Ron Williams,
Jamie Renda, Al Jackson"] S --- SD["Trustees: Carolyn Sharette,
David Sharette, Catherine Findlay"]
2. The people: who appears on both sides
2024, 2025, 2026"| K["Joseph Kerry
State School Board"] CS -->|"$520.87, 2024"| B["Cari Bartholomew"] K -->|"listed as
Former Co-Founder"| H["Hope of Utah"] B -->|"advisory board"| H KL["Rep. Karianne Lisonbee"] -->|"$245.15 to his campaign"| K KL -->|"asked for its grant"| H
3. The book link
ratedbooks.org"] BS["Brooke Stephens
runs RatedBooks"] --- R BS -->|"$25, 2024"| B["Cari Bartholomew"] GV["Gloria Vindas"] -->|"co-wrote 2024
RatedBooks letter"| BS K["Joseph Kerry"] -->|"voted yes, Aug. 6, 2026"| G["Emily Green’s
library addendum"]
The grant line: who else was paid from it
The Legislature puts some grants straight into an agency’s budget for one named group. These are called direct awards. In the 2025–26 budget year, the Arts & Museums grants line carried five named groups.
| Group | Award | Who asked | Filed under | Who runs it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Latinos in Action | $250,000 | Not found yet | Not found yet | Founder Jose Enriquez |
| Hope of Utah | $150,000 | Rep. Karianne Lisonbee | Public Education (State School Board) | Ron Williams, Jamie Renda, Al Jackson |
| Youth Arts Access for Utah’s Future (Sistema Utah) | $100,000 (asked $250,000) | Sen. Kirk Cullimore | Arts; Education and Research | Trustees Carolyn Sharette, David Sharette, Catherine Findlay; request contact Trina Christensen, co-director |
| Sevier County Archives and Heritage Space | $50,000 (asked $75,000) | Sen. Carl Albrecht | Arts | Director Elaine Wayland |
| Syracuse Museum Foundation | $50,000 (asked $100,000) | Rep. Karianne Lisonbee | Education and Research; Tourism | President Terry Palmer |
Sources: each group’s funding request on le.utah.gov; S.B. 3 (2025), Item 184; Executive Appropriations Committee motions, Mar. 5, 2026. Amounts for Sevier and Syracuse are from the Mar. 5, 2026 list.
Hope of Utah’s money, by date
| Date | What happened | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Jan. 31, 2025 | Rep. Lisonbee files the request: $58,000 one-time plus $250,000 a year ongoing. Ron Williams, listed as “Founder,” is Hope’s contact. | Request for Appropriation |
| Feb. 7, 2025 | The request is heard in the Economic and Community Development Appropriations Subcommittee. The final budget funds $150,000 one-time and $0 ongoing, through “Arts & Museums Grants » Pass Through Grants.” | State budget record H.A.R. 143; S.B. 3 (2025), Item 184 |
| July 30, 2025 | State contract #260268 signed. Jamie D. Renda signs as “Co-Founder.” Purpose: “FY26 Legislative Appropriated Funds.” | Grant contract |
| Aug. 1, 2025 | Payment request for $135,000, approved Aug. 4. The form notes the group would like to pick up the check in person. | Payment request #1 |
| Aug. 5, 2025 | The $135,000 payment takes effect. It clears the bank Aug. 7, 2025. The record does not say whether it was a check or a direct deposit, or who picked it up. | State payment record, released Nov. 12, 2026 |
| 2025–26 budget year | The state’s payment register shows $135,000 paid to Hope of Utah for the year. It shows no other payment to Hope. | Transparent Utah, read Nov. 2, 2026 |
| Feb. 2, 2026 | Rep. Lisonbee’s new request, “Local Community and Non-profit Empowerment” (H.A.R. 49), asks $187,000 a year ongoing for Hope of Utah, using the same description as 2025. Heard in the Economic and Community Development Appropriations Subcommittee. | State budget record H.A.R. 49 |
| Mar. 5, 2026 | Legislators let up to $125,000 of the grant stay available after June 30, 2026. Every group on the line got the same carry-over wording. | Budget motions |
| June 13, 2026 | Spending report signed by Renda and Williams (the final report was due June 1). It lists $47,210 personnel services; $85,659.37 pass-through; $2,539.80 out-of-state travel, “Travel to DC Woodson Center”; $4,577.98 rent, internet and advertising; $547.21 in-state travel; $9,606.50 other. | Spending report |
| June 16, 2026 | Payment request for the last $15,000, approved the same day. | Payment request #2 |
| June 22, 2026 | The last $15,000 payment takes effect. It clears the bank June 30, 2026. That brings the total paid to $150,000. | State payment record, released Nov. 12, 2026 |
| March 2026 | The 2026 budget bill funds it: a “direct award grant of $187,000” to Hope of Utah, ongoing, “for empowering local community leaders and nonprofits,” in the department’s Administration line. The state’s budget record lists it as $187,000 ongoing, $0 one-time. | H.B. 3 (2026), Item 210; state budget record H.A.R. 49 |
| Oct. 28, 2026 | Asked who received the personnel and pass-through money, the department replied that its records had already been provided. | Department email |
Grant, payment and report records came to the Hive from a records request; a tip came in. The dates on payment forms are request and approval dates, not proof of when a check was cut.
The “20+ non-profits”: Hope of Utah’s 19 listed affiliates
Hope of Utah’s final report to the state says, “We were able to help 20+ non-profits.” It names none. Its spending report lists $85,659.37 in pass-through money and names no recipients. Its 2025 tax return lists $48,050 in grants to “partner organizations” and names none. Asked who received the money, the state department said its records had already been provided.
Hope of Utah’s own website lists 19 affiliates, plus one marked “coming soon” (hopeofutah.org/affiliates, read Nov. 2, 2026). We searched every one in the Utah Division of Corporations business registry on Nov. 2, 2026.
| # | Affiliate | What it says it does | Utah registry (formed · agent · leaders) | Other ties to Hope’s circle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Youth For Liberty | “Empower young Americans to defend liberty, individual rights, and limited government”; speaks at schools about communism | Nonprofit #14581402-0140, formed June 10, 2025. Registered agent: Hope of Utah. Directors Gabriela Puckett (Cedar Hills), Andres Lopez Yero and Arturo Lopez Yero (South Jordan). Mailing address in Florida. | Puckett calls it “her own nonprofit” (Dissident Project speaker bio) |
| 2 | Urban Student Alliance | Teen leadership club at Ben Lomond High | Nonprofit #14584380-0140, formed June 18, 2025. Registered agent: Hope of Utah. Directors Delores Green, Rene Douglas and Marcus Carr (Ogden). | Marcus Carr is on Hope of Utah’s and Path Forward Utah’s advisory boards. Cari Bartholomew presented at its 2025 and 2026 programs. IRS lists EIN 39-2758760 with $0 in gross receipts. |
| 3 | Future Star Athletes | Football, mentoring, role models | Nonprofit #14586609-0140, formed June 25, 2025. Registered agent: Hope of Utah. Directors Travon Harvey, Cynthia McIntosh (Roy) and Keisha Green (Ogden). | — |
| 4 | Healthy Mind Happy Heart | Family mental health and “emotional resilience” | Nonprofit #14632485-0140, formed Nov. 20, 2025. Registered agent: Hope of Utah. Directors Silvana Romay, Vanessa Preiero and Jorge Araujo (Herriman). | A Florida nonprofit uses the same website (not confirmed to be the same group) |
| 5 | Cineverse Foundation | Trains youth in art and film | Nonprofit #14655912-0140, formed Jan. 29, 2026. Registered agent: Hope of Utah. Directors Luis Rivero and Luis Benitez; incorporator Eduard Dominguez (Salt Lake City). | IRS EIN 37-2219036, ruling March 2026 |
| 6 | Vibe and Rise Again | Open mics, shoe drives, “a space where people can come without judgment” | Nonprofit #14661949-0140, formed Feb. 15, 2026. Registered agent: Hope of Utah. | Founders listed on Hope’s page as Sam and Mason Klick |
| 7 | Hope Connecting Purpose | “Bring hope, confidence, and purpose to our youth” facing health crises | Nonprofit #14569385-0140, formed Apr. 29, 2025. Registered agent: Jamie Renda, at 2351 Grant Ave. Ste 102. President Murray Latson (Harrisville). | — |
| 8 | RW Champion Foundation | “Champion Transformation Program” to “overcome trauma, destructive patterns, and limiting beliefs” | Nonprofit #14553087-0140, formed Mar. 7, 2025. Incorporator and chairman of the board: Ronald Williams (Draper). Director Steve Cutler (Sandy). Registered agent Tonja Williams (Draper). | Hope of Utah’s chair is Ron Williams, who sells coaching as “Champion Life by Ron Williams.” The foundation was formed five weeks after he was named Hope of Utah’s contact on its Jan. 31, 2025 funding request. |
| 9 | The Valley 7s | Youth football plus community service | Nonprofit #14544735-0140, formed Feb. 12, 2025 (converted from an LLC of the same name) | — |
| 10 | WAMsafety | Safety tips and true crime; seeks a national three-digit number for reporting abuse and trafficking | Nonprofit #14582979-0140, formed June 16, 2025. Agent and chair Wendy Jensen-Nicholls; director Jason Nicholls (Perry). | Hope lists its contact under a different email name. WAMsafety led outreach for 2026 H.B. 411 (trafficking hotline), which the Association of Ministers of Utah also backed (Deseret News, Oct. 21, 2026). |
| 11 | Rate My Books (ratedbooks.org) | Rates books “so that parents and schools may choose wisely” | RatedBooks.org, nonprofit #14574510-0140, formed May 16, 2025. President Brooke Stephens (Layton). | State auditors used a list from ratedbooks.org in their 2025 removed-books audit. See How one book list moved. |
| 12 | Empower Parents Utah | “We empower parents to determine the best school option for their child” | Name closest in the registry: Empowered Parents, nonprofit #9699080-0140, formed 2016. Its office suite and two directors match those of Utah Parents United (state records). Not confirmed that this is the group Hope lists. | Utah Parents United is the group Brooke Stephens was tied to in 2022–2024 news reports. |
| 13 | Four1&All | Ogden family service: skate nights, free family photos, youth events “where they can meet leaders like Senator Mike Kennedy” | Only match: Four1&All, LLC, formed Oct. 14, 2020, administratively dissolved. No nonprofit corporation found. | Leaders Lorenzo Gutierrez, Antwain Harvey, Andre Garcia. Its 2023 donations were dropped off at Path Forward Utah’s office, 2351 Grant Ave., Suite 102 (Standard-Examiner, Aug. 4, 2023). Its site shows a “Path Forward” sponsor logo. The Hive reported earlier that Gutierrez spoke for Hope’s funding request in 2025. |
| 14 | Living & Aging with Pride | Program on aging | Living and Aging with Pride LLC, formed Dec. 26, 2019, plus a “.org” assumed name (2020) | IRS EIN 84-4910413 (Salt Lake City); founder James Brown; revenue $60,578 (2023), $21,547 (2024) |
| 15 | About Life Academy | Farm, water and technology education | Only a name reservation, “About Life Acadmey” (spelled that way), July 16, 2026. No corporation. | Works with Growing Unified Development, the group founded by Marcus Carr |
| 16 | Association of Ministers of Utah | “Coming soon” | No Utah registration found | KSL (May 3, 2026) says the group is affiliated with Hope of Utah and that Jamie Renda pushed to create it. It launched at the Capitol with Attorney General Derek Brown speaking and Rep. Karianne Lisonbee attending. It says it raised about $40,000; the article does not say from whom. |
| 17 | Mustard Seed Faith Ministries Food Pantry | Ogden food pantry | No Utah registration found | Pastor Juan Péna (Deseret News, Dec. 18, 2019) |
| 18 | United Storytellers | “Coming soon” | No Utah registration found | — |
| 19 | Latino Hope | No description | No Utah registration found | — |
People in common
| Person | Hope of Utah / Renda side | Sharette / book side | Records |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joseph Kerry | “Former Co-Founder” on Hope of Utah’s website. Listed as Path Forward Utah’s chair on its 2025 tax return, and moved to inactive on its state filing Aug. 24, 2026. | Carolyn Sharette gave $500 (2024), $522.23 (2025, later removed from his reports) and $1,261.28 (2026). Voted yes on Green’s addendum Aug. 6, 2026, and co-moved her Aug. 4 memo. | Hope website; Path Forward 990-EZ; Utah Division of Corporations; disclosures.utah.gov; USBE minutes |
| Cari Bartholomew | Advisory board of Hope of Utah and Path Forward Utah | 2024 State School Board race got $520.87 from Carolyn Sharette (Mar. 20, 2024) and $25 from Brooke Stephens (Apr. 2, 2024) | Both groups’ team pages; disclosures.utah.gov |
| Rep. Karianne Lisonbee | Asked for Hope of Utah’s grant (and Syracuse Museum’s) | Her campaign gave Kerry $245.15. She signed the Apr. 15, 2024 legislators’ letter asking state auditors to review removed books. | Funding requests; disclosures.utah.gov; auditor’s released letter |
| Gloria Vindas | Signed an Apr. 27, 2023 Deseret News opinion piece with Renda, Jaime Wadman, Bartholomew and Ron Williams (“part of Path Forward Utah”) | Co-wrote the Feb. 22, 2024 Deseret News open letter with Brooke Stephens that names RatedBooks.org | Deseret News, 2023 and 2024 |
| Trina Christensen | — | Sistema Utah’s contact on its grant request. Carolyn Sharette gave her two $250 contributions in Jan. 2026. | Funding request; disclosures.utah.gov |
Jamie Renda: pay and gifts
What her groups reported paying her
| Group | Tax year | Title on the form | Hours a week | Pay listed | Form |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Path Forward Utah | 2023 | President | 25 | $0 | 990-EZ, filed Jan. 17, 2025 |
| Path Forward Utah | 2024 | Founder | 40 | $18,500 | 990-EZ, filed Jan. 22, 2025 |
| Path Forward Utah | 2025 | President | 40 | $60,000 | 990-EZ, filed May 12, 2026 |
| Hope of Utah | 2025 | Vice Chair | 25 | $9,000 | 990-EZ, filed May 18, 2026 |
Money paid to Path Forward Utah by campaigns and political groups
| Date | Paid by (as filed) | Purpose (as filed) | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apr. 14, 2023 | Adams Leadership PAC | Donations | $1,000 |
| June 13, 2023 | “Adams, J” (campaign) | Donations | $500 |
| Aug. 16, 2023 | “Hall, Katrina” (campaign) | Other | $600 |
| Aug. 29, 2023 | Adams Leadership PAC | Donations | $1,000 |
| Sept. 18, 2023 | Weber County Republican Party | Donations | $999 |
| Dec. 1, 2023 | “Kennedy, Michael” (campaign) | Constituent Services | $100 |
All six are 2023 lines; a search of 2024, 2025 and 2026 found no campaign or PAC payments filed to Path Forward Utah or Hope of Utah. Path Forward Utah started as an LLC; its IRS tax exemption was issued in Sept. 2023, so the first three payments came before that. The filings show the payments, not what they were for beyond the purpose word.
Gifts from Jamie Renda and Rick Renda to campaigns
| Date | From | To (campaign) | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| June 17, 2024 | Jamie Renda | Phillip Lyman | $104.10 (listed twice on the same date; may be one gift entered twice) |
| Apr. 17, 2026 | Jamie Renda | Joseph Kerry | $10.76 |
| Apr. 17, 2026 | Rick Renda | Joseph Kerry | $10 |
| June 9, 2026 | Rick Renda | Nichole Beecher Isom | $100 |
| June 15, 2026 | Jamie Renda | Gloria Vindas | $250 |
Ogden ties
Each arrow is labeled with the record it comes from. An arrow means “a record shows this.” It does not mean one person directed another.
(Form 990-EZ)"| P["Phoenix Business Solutions Co.
owner Flor Lopez"] P --- F["Flor Lopez
Ogden City Council, Jan. 2026"] F -->|"registered agent
(state filing)"| L["LUPEC
Ogden Hispanic Festival group"] LL["Luis Lopez
former council member"] -->|"director and vice president
(state filing)"| L LL -->|"co-owner
(state filing)"| X["Xalisco, LLC"] KG["Kerry Gibson
registered lobbyist"] -->|"co-owner
(state filing)"| X N["Mayor Ben Nadolski"] -->|"hired as Community
Engagement Director"| LL KG -->|"lobbyist for Ogden City
since Jan. 19, 2024"| OC["Ogden City"] N -.->|"2023 campaign paid
$3,187.50"| X
| Link | What the record shows | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Hope of Utah → Flor Lopez | Hope of Utah’s 2025 Form 990-EZ lists Phoenix Business Solutions Co. of Ogden as its paid preparer. Flor Lopez is the company’s director, officer and registered agent. It started as an LLC in Nov. 2022 and converted to a corporation in April 2025. | Hope of Utah 2025 Form 990-EZ; Utah Division of Corporations #13111285-0142 |
| Flor Lopez → Ogden City Council | Won the District 1 seat in Nov. 2025 and was sworn in Jan. 13, 2026. | Standard-Examiner, Jan. 15, 2026 |
| Flor Lopez → LUPEC → Luis Lopez | LUPEC (Latinos United Promoting Education & Civic Engagement) is the Ogden nonprofit behind the Ogden Hispanic Festival, formed in 2015. Flor Lopez is its registered agent. Luis Lopez is a director and vice president. Its state status is “Delinquent” (renewal was due Aug. 31, 2024). | Utah Division of Corporations #9410737-0140 |
| Flor Lopez and Luis Lopez, in her words | On the city’s Ogden Way podcast, hosted by Mayor Nadolski, Flor Lopez called Luis Lopez a close friend and mentor. The mayor said Luis “has been a mentor for me too.” They share a last name; no record we found shows they are related. | Ogden Way podcast transcript (Ogden City) |
| Luis Lopez → Xalisco → Kerry Gibson | Xalisco, LLC (formed Nov. 28, 2022, active) lists three members: Kerry Gibson, Luis Octavio Lopez and David Lopez-Carrillo. The same Ogden address is listed for Luis Octavio Lopez on Xalisco’s filing and for Luis Lopez on LUPEC’s filing. | Utah Division of Corporations #13140947-0160 |
| Luis Lopez → Mayor Nadolski | Served two terms on the Ogden City Council. Nadolski, a former council colleague, hired him as Community Engagement Director in mid-2025. | Standard-Examiner, Jan. 21, 2026 |
| Kerry Gibson → Ogden City | His firm, Legislative Solutions, is registered to lobby for Ogden City starting Jan. 19, 2024. | Utah lobbyist register (lobbyist.utah.gov) |
| Gibsons → Nadolski’s 2023 campaign | Utah Forward PAC, with Katrina Gibson as CFO, gave Nadolski’s 2023 mayoral campaign $5,000. Katrina Gibson signed that campaign’s finance disclosure as “Secretary of Committee,” and the campaign paid Xalisco $3,187.50. Kerry Gibson became Ogden City’s lobbyist in January 2024. | Nadolski 2023 campaign reports (Ogden City); Utah Forward PAC reports (disclosures.utah.gov); see Laura Warburton case file |
| Path For Utah → Mayor Nadolski | Jason Coates, a director of Path For Utah (Renda’s third nonprofit), was among the donors who gave Nadolski’s 2023 campaign $5,000, the top amount. | Standard-Examiner, Aug. 31, 2023; Utah Division of Corporations #14657396-0140 |
Renda on the record
| Date | What the record shows | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Jan. 17, 2024 | House Education Committee, H.B. 261 (DEI): “Jamie Renda, Founder, Path Forward Utah, spoke in favor of the bill.” Also in favor: “Brooke Stephens, Education Director, Utah Parents United” and “Cari Bartholomew, UPU, Path Forward Utah.” The committee passed 1st Substitute H.B. 261 out favorably, 12-2-1. | House Education minutes |
| Jan. 22, 2024 | Senate Education Committee, H.B. 261: Renda (“Founder, Path Forward Utah”), Brooke Stephens (“Education Director, Utah Parents United”) and Cari Bartholomew (“Advisory Board Member, Path Forward Utah”) each spoke in favor. | Senate Education minutes |
| Feb. 7, 2025 | Economic and Community Development Appropriations Subcommittee, Hope of Utah’s request: Rep. Ariel Defay asked what the money would be used for. Renda answered, in part, “a lot of it’s going to be passed through, grants to these organizations” (about 43 minutes into the recording; quoted from the recording’s machine transcript). The written request had put $0 under “Other Charges/Pass Thru.” | State budget record (COBI), H.A.R. 143, hearing recording |
| Feb. 25, 2026 | Senate Education Committee, S.B. 312 (educator licenses): “Jamie Renda, Chair, Path Forward Utah, spoke in favor of the bill.” | Senate Education minutes |
| Sept. 14, 2026 | “Renda, Jamie” registered as a lobbyist. Her business is listed as Small Business Referral Pros (Ogden); her principals (clients) are Path for Utah (Ogden) and Owen Communications LLC (Salt Lake City). | Utah lobbyist register (pulled Nov. 2, 2026) |
| Read Nov. 2, 2026 | The state’s Transparent Utah site runs a page titled “Jamie Renda’s Utah Education Funding Dashboard.” It says, “We would like to thank Jamie Renda for her suggestion of this dashboard.” | Transparent Utah dashboard |
Speaking for a bill, suggesting a state dashboard and registering as a lobbyist are all allowed. The records don’t show any of them was tied to Hope of Utah’s state grant.
The book link
Hope of Utah’s own affiliates page lists 19 groups. One is “Rate My Books,” linked to ratedbooks.org. Utah corporation records list Brooke Stephens of Layton as the president of RatedBooks.org, a nonprofit formed May 16, 2025. State auditors used a list from ratedbooks.org in their 2025 follow-up audit of removed books. Its role in the State School Board’s library review is laid out in How one book list moved.
The 2023 opinion piece signed by Renda’s group lists a “Brooke Stevens,” Utah Parents United. The RatedBooks president’s name is spelled Stephens in news reports and state records. Both 2024 committee minutes for H.B. 261 list “Brooke Stephens, Education Director, Utah Parents United,” the same group named in the 2023 piece, speaking next to Renda. Official records use both spellings: the Feb. 9, 2024 Senate Education minutes on H.B. 29 say “Brooke Stevens, citizen.” So the same group, the same first name and two spellings in state records point to one person, but no record states it outright. We print the 2023 name as it appeared.
The affiliates page shows a listing, not money. No record we have shows Hope of Utah paying RatedBooks or any other affiliate.
Bills that touch these groups
These are the laws and bills that set the rules these groups work under, or that they spoke for. A vote shown here is only what the record says; blanks mean the vote was not retrieved.
| Bill | Primary sponsor | What it does | Ties to this page | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S.B. 3 (2025), Item 184 | Sen. Jerry Stevenson | 2025–26 budget: names Hope of Utah ($150,000) and Sistema Utah ($100,000) | Both grants on this page | Passed |
| H.B. 3 (2026), Items 27 and 210 | Rep. Val Peterson | Carries 2025–26 grant money forward; new $187,000 to Hope of Utah for 2026–27 | Hope of Utah | Passed |
| H.B. 335 (2024), State Grant Process | Rep. Val Peterson | Rules for state grants: written agreements, deliverables, no lump-sum payment, audits, money can be clawed back | The rules Hope of Utah’s grant runs under. Hope requested $135,000 of $150,000 within days of signing. | Law, July 1, 2024 |
| S.B. 254 (2025), State Grant Revisions | Sen. Luz Escamilla | Would have made budget language spell out payment schedule, deliverables and measures | Would have applied to direct awards like Hope’s | Died Mar. 7, 2025. Passed both houses with no no votes; the Senate pulled it back that night. |
| S.B. 312 (2026), Educator License (UPPAC) | Sen. John Johnson | Limits discipline on suspended educators to serious misconduct unless the board makes written findings | Educator-licensing reform is a Path Forward Utah issue. Senate Education minutes (Feb. 25, 2026) record “Jamie Renda, Chair, Path Forward Utah” speaking in favor. Lisonbee sponsored the House version and voted yes in committee and on the floor; Cullimore voted yes on the 15–14 Senate vote. | Signed Mar. 26, 2026 |
| H.B. 31 (2026), LEA Financial Reporting | Rep. Neil Walter | Would have kept pay made by a school’s contractor to its own employees out of public financial reporting | News tied it to the State Auditor’s court fight to get pay records from American Preparatory Schools (Sharette). Its sponsor said it came from an Alpine School District audit. | Failed |
| H.B. 215 (2023), Utah Fits All scholarships | Rep. Candice Pierucci; Senate sponsor Sen. Kirk Cullimore | Creates the private-school scholarship program | School choice; Cullimore also requested Sistema Utah’s grant. Lisonbee, Cullimore and Ivory voted yes. | Signed |
| H.B. 29 (2024) | Rep. Ken Ivory | A book removed by three districts comes out of every school | Brooke Stephens spoke for it. Lisonbee, Cullimore and Ivory voted yes. | Signed |
| H.B. 197 (2026) | Rep. Nicholeen Peck | Vendor and pre-review rules for school materials | Utah Parents United spoke for it. Lisonbee made both committee motions and voted yes. | Did not pass |
| H.B. 473 (2025) | Rep. Nicholeen Peck | Digital school materials | Brooke Stephens spoke for it (listed as Utah Moms for America). Lisonbee is recorded abstaining on all three committee motions. | Died |
| H.B. 261 (2024), DEI | Rep. Katy Hall | Bans DEI offices and DEI statements at public schools and colleges | The 2023 opinion piece signed by Renda’s group backed the earlier version, H.B. 451 (2023), which failed. Renda, Brooke Stephens and Cari Bartholomew spoke for H.B. 261 in both the House and Senate Education committees. Lisonbee, Ivory and Cullimore voted yes on H.B. 261. | Signed |
| S.B. 145 (2026), Lobbying | Sen. Brady Brammer | Defines lobbying to include trying to influence State School Board decisions | Groups that bring legislators and board members together | Signed Mar. 17, 2026 |
Sources: le.utah.gov bill texts, status pages and committee minutes; vote-tracking sites where le.utah.gov vote tables would not load. Full list with links in Sources.
What the records don’t show
- No record shows money moving between Hope of Utah and Sistema Utah, or between Renda and Sharette. Sistema Utah’s 2024 tax return shows it made no grants.
- Different legislators asked for the two grants. No record shows the requests were coordinated.
- No record shows campaign gifts changed how anyone voted.
- No record names who received Hope of Utah’s pass-through or personnel money.
- No news story we found names Jamie Renda and Carolyn Sharette together.
Not confirmed yet
- Whether Hope of Utah vice chair “Al Jackson” is former state Sen. Alvin B. Jackson, whose 2022 speaker bio says he sits on the Woodson Center board. The tax return gives only the name.
- Whether “Brooke Stevens” (2023 opinion piece) and Brooke Stephens (RatedBooks.org) are the same person. Both 2024 H.B. 261 minutes list “Brooke Stephens, Education Director, Utah Parents United,” the group named in the 2023 piece, and state minutes use both spellings (see The book link). No record says so in words.
- Who asked for the Latinos in Action grant, and why Hope of Utah’s request, filed under Public Education, was heard by the economic development committee and paid from the arts line.
- Whether the state gave written approval for Hope of Utah to pass grant money to other groups.
Whether the last $15,000 was ever paid. The state’s payment register shows $135,000 for 2025–26, and Hope’s final report says $150,000 was used.Answered Nov. 12, 2026: the state’s payment record shows the $15,000 took effect June 22, 2026 and cleared June 30, 2026. Transparent Utah, read Nov. 2, 2026, showed only the $135,000 for that budget year. The record does not say why.- Who picked up the $135,000 check, or whether it was paid by direct deposit. The payment request and the payment record do not say.
- Whether the department accepted Hope of Utah’s final report. Its status in the state’s grant system reads “Submitted.”
- Whether Hope of Utah’s other affiliates are registered Utah nonprofits.
Questions to ask, and whom to ask
Find your legislators on the Utah Legislature’s website and your State School Board member on the board district map.
Connected Hive work
Behind this piece
Posted Nov. 2, 2026. Public records and news reports only; no comment was requested from anyone. Grant records came from a tip. Cities only; no home addresses.
Sources (tap to open)
- Path Forward Utah (EIN 87-4336623), IRS Form 990-EZ for 2023, 2024 and 2025, via ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer (read Nov. 2, 2026)
- Hope of Utah (EIN 33-1592354), IRS Form 990-EZ for 2025, via ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer (read Nov. 2, 2026)
- disclosures.utah.gov Advanced Search: contributions by “Jamie Renda” and “Rick Renda,” 2022–2026; expenditures to “Path Forward Utah” and “Hope of Utah,” 2023–2026 (searched Nov. 2, 2026)
- Request for Appropriation, “Funding of Hope of Utah,” Jan. 31, 2025
- Request for Appropriation, “Youth Arts Access for Utah’s Future” (Sistema Utah)
- Request for Appropriation, Syracuse Museum Foundation
- Request for Appropriation, Sevier County Archives and Heritage Services
- Executive Appropriations Committee, Consolidated Motions for End of Session Budget Actions, Mar. 5, 2026
- S.B. 3 (2025), Item 184, Arts & Museums grants (le.utah.gov)
- State budget record (COBI), H.A.R. 143, Hope of Utah, heard Feb. 7, 2025
- State budget record (COBI), H.A.R. 49, Local Community and Non-profit Empowerment, heard Feb. 2, 2026
- Executive Appropriations Committee, Additional Proposed Funding Items, Mar. 5, 2026
- Transparent Utah vendor payments: Hope of Utah, Sistema Utah (read Nov. 2, 2026)
- Internet Archive Wayback Machine: hopeofutah.org, Jan. 23, 2025; hopeofutah.org/affiliates, Aug. 2, 2026
- Utah Department of Cultural and Community Engagement: contract #260268, payment requests (Aug. 1, 2025; June 16, 2026), funding report (June 13, 2026), final report, and Oct. 28, 2026 email. Records request copies; a tip came in.
- Utah Department of Cultural and Community Engagement, answer to The Weber County Hive’s records request, Nov. 12, 2026: state payment record for Hope of Utah (printed Nov. 12, 2026), both payment requests, the funding report and the final report. Nothing withheld; one personal phone number redacted.
- Hope of Utah, IRS Form 990-EZ, 2025 (ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer)
- Path Forward Utah, IRS Form 990-EZ, 2025; Sistema Utah, IRS Form 990-EZ, 2024
- Utah Division of Corporations: Hope of Utah (#14505669-0140), Path Forward Utah, Path For Utah (#14657396-0140), Sistema Utah (#10310583-0140), RatedBooks.org (#14574510-0140)
- Hope of Utah, Affiliates page and team page
- Utah Lieutenant Governor, campaign disclosures (Sharette, Stephens, Lisonbee contributions)
- Utah State Board of Education minutes, Aug. 6, 2026
- Office of the Legislative Auditor General: Apr. 15, 2024 audit request letter (released Oct. 27, 2026)
- Deseret News opinion, “Why DEI oaths undermine freedom of speech,” Apr. 27, 2023
- Deseret News open letter by Brooke Stephens and Gloria Vindas, Feb. 22, 2024
- Latinos in Action, IRS Form 990, 2023
- H.B. 3 (2026), Appropriations Adjustments, Items 27, 210 and 212
- H.B. 335 (2024), S.B. 254 (2025), S.B. 312 (2026), H.B. 31 (2026), H.B. 215 (2023), H.B. 29 (2024), H.B. 197 (2026), H.B. 473 (2025), H.B. 261 (2024), S.B. 145 (2026): bill texts, status pages and committee minutes on le.utah.gov
- Utah Division of Corporations business search: all 19 affiliates, and registered-agent searches for “Hope Of Utah” and “Jamie Renda,” Nov. 2, 2026
- Utah Division of Corporations: Phoenix Business Solutions Co. #13111285-0142 (and LLC #13111285-0160), LUPEC #9410737-0140, Xalisco, LLC #13140947-0160, Path For Utah #14657396-0140, and principal searches for “Flor Lopez” and “Luis Octavio Lopez,” Nov. 2, 2026
- Ogden City, Ogden Way podcast with Flor Lopez (transcript)
- Flor Lopez, Ogden City campaign financial disclosure, Oct. 7, 2025
- Standard-Examiner, “Flor Lopez sworn in as Ogden City Council member,” Jan. 15, 2026
- Standard-Examiner, “Luis Lopez makes return to Ogden city government in new capacity,” Jan. 21, 2026
- Standard-Examiner, Nadolski and Knuth mayoral campaign fundraising, Aug. 31, 2023
- Utah lobbyist register, lookup by principal (Ogden City), and full register pulled Nov. 2, 2026 (“Renda, Jamie,” registered Sept. 14, 2026)
- House Education Standing Committee minutes, Jan. 17, 2024 (H.B. 261)
- Senate Education Standing Committee minutes, Jan. 22, 2024 (H.B. 261)
- Senate Education Standing Committee minutes, Feb. 25, 2026 (S.B. 312)
- Transparent Utah, “Jamie Renda’s Utah Education Funding Dashboard” (read Nov. 2, 2026)
- KSL, Association of Ministers of Utah launch, May 3, 2026; Deseret News, H.B. 411 trafficking hotline, Oct. 21, 2026

