Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive

The people’s publication. We investigate what’s best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.

← Bill TrackerEducation: Who connects to whomMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2026-031-EDU · School money & public records

H.B. 31 (2026): School Spending Reports and Contractor Pay

Utah posts what schools spend on Transparent Utah. This 2026 bill would have kept pay that a private contractor gives its own workers off that list. It died. Here is what it said, what was going on at the same time, and how it grades.

Posted Nov. 2, 2026 · Updated Nov. 2, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words
Share on Facebook

Short version

  • Every Utah school district and charter school reports its spending to the state’s public website, Transparent Utah, so anyone can look it up.
  • H.B. 31, by Rep. R. Neil Walter of Santa Clara, would have set common job names for reports and made schools report employee benefits. Its rewritten version (Substitute 1) would also have said that pay a private contractor gives its own workers is not “public financial information” (Substitute 1 text).
  • At the same time, the State Auditor, Tina Cannon, went to court on Feb. 10, 2026, to get pay records from American Preparatory Schools, the private company that runs American Preparatory Academy. The company was paid about $31 million in public money since 2022. Its executive director, named in the contract, is Carolyn Sharette (Salt Lake Tribune, Feb. 23, 2026).
  • The company first opposed the auditor’s request. It later said it “intends to voluntarily comply” (Salt Lake Tribune).
  • Walter said the bill grew out of an audit of Alpine School District and was meant to make reports match. He said it was not tied to the charter school dispute (St. George News, Feb. 28, 2026).
  • The bill never got a committee vote. It died March 6, 2026.
  • Graded by the collective rubric: D+. Reporting benefits and using common job names would help. Taking contractor pay out of public records would hide where some public school money goes.

Where & who

WhereEvery Utah school district and charter school, statewide.
WhoRep. R. Neil Walter (primary sponsor, Santa Clara); State Auditor Tina Cannon; American Preparatory Schools, the management company for American Preparatory Academy, and its executive director Carolyn Sharette.

Graded by the collective rubric

This isn’t a personal opinion of the bill. It is graded on the same five questions used across the Hive: Who holds the power? Can the public see what happens? Is the money accounted for? What does it do to land and water? What does it do to the community? The grade is based on what the bill’s own words would do. Whether it became law is shown separately.

In plain words: C means it does what the law already requires. B or A means it does more for the public. D means it makes a public check weaker. F means it takes one away with nothing in its place.

BillPowerTransparencyFinancialEnvironmentalCommunityOverallOutcome
H.B. 31 (2026)
Rep. R. Neil Walter
CDDN/ACD+Died

The bill

H.B. 31 (2026): Local Education Agency Financial Reporting DIED

Primary sponsor: Rep. R. Neil Walter · No Senate sponsor listed · Died March 6, 2026 (enacting clause struck, filed) · Official bill page

In plain words: This would have made school spending reports use the same job names and show benefits. But it would also have kept the pay a private contractor gives its own workers off the public list. It never got a vote.

What it does (from the bill’s own words):

  • Requires common naming for jobs in school spending reports (original bill).
  • Clarifies what counts as “public financial information” for a school district or charter school (original bill).
  • Substitute 1: leaves out “payments a third-party contractor or vendor makes to employees of the third-party contractor or vendor.”
  • Substitute 1: requires schools to report employee benefits, and lets the State Auditor make rules about what contractors must disclose.
DateWhereResultRecord
Jan. 20, 2026House floor; circled (set aside)—Bill status page
Jan. 21, 2026Sent to the House Education Committee—Bill status page
Jan. 22, 2026House Education Committee: not considered—Bill status page
March 4, 2026House Education Committee: sent back to Rules—Bill status page
March 6, 2026Enacting clause struck; filed—Bill status page

There is no recorded vote by any lawmaker on this bill. The bill was ready for a House floor vote on Jan. 20 before it was set aside and sent to committee.

How H.B. 31 was graded: D+ overall
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerCThe State Auditor would have gotten rule-making power over contractor disclosure.
TransparencyDCommon job names and benefit reports help. Leaving contractor pay out of “public financial information” would hide some public school money from the public list.
Financial accountabilityDPublic money paid to a management company and then to its staff would have been harder to follow.
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactCApplies to every district and charter school the same way.

What was going on at the same time

The auditor’s court requestOn Feb. 10, 2026, State Auditor Tina Cannon asked a 3rd District Court judge to hold American Preparatory Schools in contempt for not turning over payroll, pay and spending records for public money paid to it since 2022. The company had given only yearly lump-sum totals (Salt Lake Tribune).
The company’s sideAmerican Preparatory Academy said its top administrators are paid by a separate private management company, and the school does not hold that payroll data (St. George News). The company later said it intends to comply voluntarily (Salt Lake Tribune).
The sponsor’s sideRep. Walter said the bill came from a legislative audit of Alpine School District that found job titles and pay were reported in different ways. He said it was not directly tied to the charter school dispute, and that it would not move forward (St. George News).
Where Carolyn Sharette fitsSharette is the executive director of American Preparatory Schools, named in its contract, and a founder of American Preparatory Academy (Salt Lake Tribune). Her ties to Hope of Utah and the book-list groups are traced on the Education page Who Connects to Whom.

What would make this clearer for the public

These come from gaps in the record, not from either side of the debate.

1. Post contractor pay for public schoolsWhen a private company runs a public school, posting what it pays its leaders out of public money would answer the question the auditor asked. Who could do it: the Legislature or the State Auditor.
2. Keep the good partsCommon job names and benefit reporting would make every district’s numbers easier to compare. Who could do it: any lawmaker, in a new bill.
3. Post the court outcomeA public update on the auditor’s case would show whether the records were turned over. Who could do it: the State Auditor.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Rep. R. Neil Walter (Santa Clara)Primary sponsor.—
Tina CannonUtah State Auditor; asked the court to enforce the subpoena.—
Carolyn SharetteExecutive director of American Preparatory Schools; a founder of American Preparatory Academy.Who Connects to Whom

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

You can ask these at a public meeting, by email or in public comment. Find your state representative and senator on the Utah Legislature’s website.

Rep. R. Neil WalterWill a new reporting bill come back in 2027, and will it include contractor pay or leave it out?
The State Auditor’s OfficeDid American Preparatory Schools turn over the records? Will they be posted on Transparent Utah?
Your charter school’s boardDoes a management company run our school? Does it report what it pays its leaders?

Behind this piece

5
bill actions read
0
recorded votes
2
news reports read
6
sources listed

Posted Nov. 2, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Bill actions and votes were read from the Legislature’s own bill data on Nov. 2, 2026.

Not confirmed as of Nov. 2, 2026: how the auditor’s court case ended; whether American Preparatory Schools turned over the records; the fiscal note.

Sources

Show all 6 sources
  1. H.B. 31 (2026) bill page: https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/HB0031.html
  2. H.B. 31 Substitute 1 text: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/introduced/HB0031S01.pdf
  3. Salt Lake Tribune, “This Utah charter school refused to disclose how much it pays top administrators,” Feb. 23, 2026: link
  4. St. George News, “Bill tied to Utah charter school pay transparency will not move forward,” Feb. 28, 2026: link
  5. Policy Risk bill status, H.B. 31 (2026): https://policyrisk.com/state-bill/UT-HB31-2026GS
  6. Transparent Utah: https://transparent.utah.gov/

Where this connects

Other pages, people and records tied to this one.

Bills it stacks with

People

  • Rep. R. Neil Walter, primary sponsor.
  • Carolyn Sharette, executive director of American Preparatory Schools.

Elsewhere on the Hive

Research tracker and docket

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell usWe never name tipsters.
Utah Hive PoliticsThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people’s publication. We investigate what’s best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.Independent · Accountability · Journalism