Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive

The people’s publication. We investigate what’s best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.

← Bill TrackerEducation: Who connects to whomMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2024–2026-GRANT · State money to private groups

State Grants to Private Nonprofits, 2024–2026

Lawmakers can give state money straight to one private group by name. Here are the four bills from 2024 to 2026 about the rules for that money, how lawmakers voted, how each one grades, and how the rules work for one group, Hope of Utah.

Posted Nov. 2, 2026 · Updated Nov. 12, 2026: added both Hope of Utah payment dates

Short on time? Read it in plain words
Share on Facebook

Short version

  • Sometimes Utah lawmakers give state money straight to one private group by name. This is called a direct award grant. No other group gets to compete for it.
  • From 2024 to 2026, lawmakers tried four bills about the rules for these grants. Two became law: H.B. 335 (2024) and S.B. 324 (2026). Two died in the last hours of the 2025 session: S.B. 254 and H.B. 553. Both had passed the House with no one voting no.
  • H.B. 335 is the main rule book. A group must show a budget, promise what it will do, send reports, and agree that the state can check its books and take money back. The state may not pay it all at once, and the last payment waits for the final report (H.B. 335 enrolled text).
  • One group under these rules: Hope of Utah. Rep. Karianne Lisonbee asked for money for it two years in a row. In 2025 it got a $150,000 one-time grant. In 2026 lawmakers gave it $187,000 in a line that does not say “one-time,” the label the budget bill uses for money that keeps coming (COBI, 2025; COBI, 2026).
  • Both Hope of Utah grants came out of the state’s Arts & Museums grant budget. The 2025 grant was paid as $135,000 first, with a $15,000 last payment asked for after the spending report. That matches H.B. 335’s rule. The state’s payment record shows both were paid: Aug. 5, 2025 and June 22, 2026.
  • Graded by the collective rubric: H.B. 335 B+, S.B. 254 B, H.B. 553 B, S.B. 324 B. None of them gets an A, because none makes these grants compete or puts every grant report online for the public.

Where & who

WhereStatewide. These rules cover every state grant to a nonprofit or private group, in every county, including Weber County.
WhoRep. Val L. Peterson and Sen. Jerry W. Stevenson (H.B. 335 and H.B. 553, and the two budget bills); Sen. Luz Escamilla and Rep. Melissa G. Ballard (S.B. 254); Sen. Calvin R. Musselman of West Haven and Rep. Karen M. Peterson (S.B. 324); Rep. Karianne Lisonbee, who asked for the Hope of Utah money both years.

Graded by the collective rubric

This isn’t a personal opinion of any bill. Each bill is graded on the same five questions used across the Hive: Who holds the power? Can the public see what happens? Is the money accounted for? What does it do to land and water? What does it do to the community? Grades are based on what the bill’s own words would do. Whether it became law is shown separately.

In plain words: C means it does what the law already requires. B or A means it does more for the public. D means it makes a public check weaker. F means it takes one away with nothing in its place.

BillPowerTransparencyFinancialEnvironmentalCommunityOverallOutcome
H.B. 335 (2024)
Rep. Val L. Peterson
BB+A−N/ACB+Law
S.B. 254 (2025)
Sen. Luz Escamilla
CBBN/ACBDied
H.B. 553 (2025)
Rep. Val L. Peterson
CBBN/ACBDied
S.B. 324 (2026)
Sen. Calvin R. Musselman
CBBN/ACBLaw

How a direct award grant works

  1. A lawmaker asks. A lawmaker files a “request for appropriation” naming the group and the amount. The request is posted on the Legislature’s budget site, COBI.
  2. A budget committee hears it. For Hope of Utah, that was the Economic and Community Development budget committee.
  3. The group is named in the budget bill. Under H.B. 335, a direct award grant only counts if the budget bill’s words name the group.
  4. The state signs a contract. The group must give a budget and agree to deliverables, reports, audits and clawback (taking money back).
  5. The state pays in parts. No single lump-sum payment. The last payment waits for the final report.
  6. Anyone can see the payments. Payments show up on Transparent Utah, the state’s spending website.

The four bills

H.B. 335 (2024): State Grant Process Amendments LAW

Primary sponsor: Rep. Val L. Peterson · Senate sponsor: Sen. Jerry W. Stevenson · Signed March 14, 2024 · In effect July 1, 2024 · Official bill page

In plain words: This is the rule book for state grants. A group has to show a budget, say what it will do, send reports and let the state check its books. If it breaks the deal, the state can take the money back.

What it does (from the bill’s own words):

  • Requires a grant recipient to give a proposed budget and agree to deliverables, reporting, audit and clawback rules before it gets any money.
  • Sets how grant money is paid out over time.
  • Requires a review, after a set time, of any grant paid with ongoing money.
  • Sets separate rules for direct award grants and competitive grants. A direct award grant must be named in the budget bill’s own words.
  • Lets the Legislative Auditor General audit any grant.
DateWhereResultRecord
Feb. 8, 2024House Government Operations Committee, favorable7–1–5Bill status page
Feb. 20, 2024House, final passage71–0–4Bill status page
Feb. 26, 2024Senate Government Operations Committee, favorable3–0–5Bill status page
Feb. 28, 2024Senate, final passage22–6–1Bill status page
Feb. 28, 2024House agrees to Senate changes68–1–6Bill status page
March 14, 2024Governor signed—Bill status page

The names behind the 2024 floor votes were not pulled for this page. The bill status page lists the tallies.

How it shows up in the record: Hope of Utah’s 2025 contract (#260268) was paid as $135,000, with a $15,000 final payment requested on June 16, 2026, after its June 13, 2026 spending report, and paid June 22, 2026 (state payment record). That is the “no lump sum, last payment after the final report” rule at work. See the Hope of Utah timeline.

How H.B. 335 was graded: B+ overall
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerBThe Legislature has to name every direct award group in the budget bill, so lawmakers, not agencies, are on the record for each one.
TransparencyB+Budgets, deliverables, reports and performance measures are required in writing. The bill does not require those reports to be posted for the public.
Financial accountabilityA−Audit, clawback, paying in parts, and holding the last payment until the final report are strong money checks.
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactCDirect award grants still go to one named group with no open competition.

S.B. 254 (2025): State Grant Revisions DIED

Primary sponsor: Sen. Luz Escamilla · House sponsor: Rep. Melissa G. Ballard · Died March 7, 2025 (pulled back by the Senate and filed at midnight) · Official bill page

In plain words: This would have made lawmakers write the grant’s payment schedule, its promises and its reports right into the budget bill, where anyone can read them. It passed both houses with no one voting no, but the Senate pulled it back on the last night and it died.

What it does (from the bill’s own words):

  • Would have required the budget bill’s words for a direct award grant to include the payment schedule, deliverables, reporting rules and performance measures.
DateWhereResultRecord
Feb. 12, 2025Senate Economic Development Committee, favorable4–0–2Bill status page
Feb. 19, 2025Senate, final passage25–0–4Senate roll call
Feb. 28, 2025House Economic Development Committee, favorable5–0–5Bill status page
March 7, 2025House, final passage (with changes)72–0–3House roll call
March 7, 2025, 9:13 p.m.Senate votes to reconsider, sends it back to Senate Rules—Bill status page
March 7, 2025, 11:59 p.m.Enacting clause struck; filed—Bill status page

The bill record does not say why the Senate pulled it back.

How S.B. 254 was graded: B overall
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerCNo change to who decides.
TransparencyBThe promises and reports for each grant would have been written into the budget bill itself, which is public.
Financial accountabilityBThe payment schedule would have been set by law, not just in a contract.
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactCNo change to who can get a grant.

H.B. 553 (2025): State Grant Process Amendments DIED

Primary sponsor: Rep. Val L. Peterson · Senate sponsor: Sen. Jerry W. Stevenson · Died March 7, 2025 (no Senate vote) · Official bill page

In plain words: This would have stopped state agencies from keeping part of a direct award grant for their own office costs, unless lawmakers said they could. It would also have made groups say what other state money they already get. It passed the House with no one voting no, then died in the Senate.

What it does (from the bill’s own words):

  • Would have barred an agency from using direct award grant money for its own administrative costs unless the budget bill allows it.
  • Would have required competitive grant applicants to tell the state about other state money they get.
DateWhereResultRecord
Feb. 28, 2025House Revenue and Taxation Committee, favorable10–0–1Bill status page
March 3, 2025House, final passage74–0–1House roll call
March 7, 2025Filed at the end of the session; no Senate vote—Bill status page
How H.B. 553 was graded: B overall
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerCNo change to who decides.
TransparencyBApplicants would have had to show other state money they get.
Financial accountabilityBGrant money named for a group would have gone to that group, not to agency overhead.
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactCNo change to who can get a grant.

S.B. 324 (2026): Outcome-based Investment Grant Pilot Framework LAW

Primary sponsor: Sen. Calvin R. Musselman (West Haven) · House sponsor: Rep. Karen M. Peterson · Signed March 18, 2026 · Official bill page

In plain words: This sets up a test. When lawmakers choose, groups that compete for a grant must say ahead of time how they will measure results, and an outside reviewer checks if it worked. It does not cover direct award grants, like Hope of Utah’s, unless lawmakers add them.

What it does (from the bill’s own words):

  • Creates a pilot framework for awarding some grants based on measurable results.
  • Has the Legislative Auditor General set the standards for checking results.
  • Requires applicants in the pilot to file a plan up front and take part in an independent check.
DateWhereResultRecord
Feb. 26, 2026Senate committee, favorable7–0–0Bill status page
March 3, 2026Senate, final passage21–5–3Senate roll call
March 4, 2026House Education Committee, favorable9–0–6Committee minutes
March 5, 2026House, final passage (after a floor change)68–1–6House roll call
March 5, 2026Senate agrees to House change19–6–4Senate roll call
March 18, 2026Governor signed—Bill status page

At the House Education Committee, Legislative Auditor Kade Minchey answered questions. No one else spoke (committee minutes, March 4, 2026).

How S.B. 324 was graded: B overall
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerCLawmakers decide which grants go in the pilot.
TransparencyBPlans are filed before the money goes out, and results are checked by someone outside the group.
Financial accountabilityBPays for results that can be measured. Covers only grants lawmakers put in the pilot.
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactCDirect award grants are left out unless lawmakers add them.

The money: Hope of Utah and the Arts & Museums line

These are the budget items that put the grant rules to work for Hope of Utah and the other groups paid from the same line.

YearWhat was askedWhat lawmakers gaveRecord
2025 sessionH.A.R. 143, Rep. Karianne Lisonbee, for Hope of Utah: $58,000 one-time plus $250,000 ongoing. Heard by the Economic and Community Development budget committee Feb. 7, 2025.$150,000 one-time, $0 ongoing, through S.B. 3 (2025) Item 184, Arts & Museums Grants. The same item named Sistema Utah ($100,000), Latinos in Action ($250,000) and Sevier County Archives ($50,000).COBI · S.B. 3 text
FY2026 paymentsContract #260268, signed July 30, 2025. $135,000 asked Aug. 1, 2025.Transparent Utah shows $135,000 paid to Hope of Utah and $90,000 to Sistema Utah in FY2026.Transparent Utah
FY2026 payment dates$15,000 final payment asked June 16, 2026, approved the same day.The state’s payment record shows the $135,000 took effect Aug. 5, 2025 (cleared Aug. 7) and the $15,000 took effect June 22, 2026 (cleared June 30). That is $150,000 in all.State payment record, released by the Dept. of Cultural and Community Engagement Nov. 12, 2026
2026 sessionCarry-over permissionH.B. 3 (2026) Item 27 lets $125,000 of Hope of Utah’s money, and the money for four other groups, carry past June 30, 2026. Every group on that list got the same carry-over words. It is permission, not a count of money left.H.B. 3 text
2026 sessionH.A.R. 49, Rep. Karianne Lisonbee, “Local Community and Non-profit Empowerment” (Hope of Utah). Heard Feb. 2, 2026.$187,000 through H.B. 3 (2026) Item 210, for FY2027. The line reads “From General Fund,” not “General Fund, One-time.” COBI lists it as ongoing.COBI · H.B. 3 text

Hope of Utah’s request and every payment are traced, step by step, on the Education page Who Connects to Whom. The 2026 requests are also listed on our 2026 appropriation requests page.

Why this matters for the rules: H.B. 335 says a grant paid with ongoing money must be reviewed after a set time. The $187,000 for Hope of Utah is the only one of these grants listed as ongoing.

What would make this clearer for the public

These come from gaps in the record. They would help anyone see where grant money goes.

1. Post every grant report onlineH.B. 335 requires reports, but they are not posted. A public page for each grant’s budget, promises and reports would let anyone check. Who could do it: the Legislature or the agency that pays the grant.
2. Bring back S.B. 254It passed both houses with no one voting no. Writing each grant’s promises into the budget bill puts them where the public can read them. Who could do it: any lawmaker, in 2027.
3. Put grants in the right budgetHope of Utah’s request was filed with Public Education but paid from Arts & Museums. Paying a grant from a budget that matches the work makes it easier to follow. Who could do it: the budget committees.
4. Show the review for ongoing grantsWhen H.B. 335’s review of the $187,000 ongoing grant happens, post it. Who could do it: the Legislative Fiscal Analyst.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Rep. Val L. PetersonPrimary sponsor of H.B. 335 (2024) and H.B. 553 (2025); House sponsor of S.B. 3 (2025); primary sponsor of H.B. 3 (2026).—
Sen. Jerry W. StevensonSenate sponsor of H.B. 335 and H.B. 553; primary sponsor of S.B. 3 (2025); Senate sponsor of H.B. 3 (2026).—
Sen. Luz EscamillaPrimary sponsor of S.B. 254 (2025).—
Rep. Melissa G. BallardHouse sponsor of S.B. 254 (2025).School Book Laws
Sen. Calvin R. Musselman (West Haven)Primary sponsor of S.B. 324 (2026).—
Rep. Karianne LisonbeeAsked for the Hope of Utah money in 2025 (H.A.R. 143) and 2026 (H.A.R. 49).Who Connects to Whom

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

You can ask these at a public meeting, by email or in public comment. Find your state representative and senator on the Utah Legislature’s website.

Your state representative and senatorWhy did S.B. 254 die after passing both houses with no one voting no? Will it come back in 2027? Why was Hope of Utah’s grant paid from Arts & Museums?
Rep. Karianne LisonbeeWhat will Hope of Utah do with the $187,000 a year, and how will the public see the results?
The Department of Cultural and Community EngagementWill you post each grant’s budget, deliverables and reports online?
The Legislative Auditor GeneralHas any direct award grant been audited under H.B. 335 yet?

Behind this piece

4
bills traced
3
budget items read
2
funding requests read
17
sources listed

Posted Nov. 2, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Bill actions and tallies were read from the Legislature’s own bill data on Nov. 2, 2026.

Not confirmed as of Nov. 2, 2026: the names behind the 2024 H.B. 335 floor votes; the fiscal notes for all four bills; whether H.B. 335’s review of ongoing grants has been scheduled for the $187,000 Hope of Utah grant.

Sources

Show all 17 sources
  1. H.B. 335 (2024) bill page: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/HB0335.html
  2. H.B. 335 (2024) enrolled text: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/hbillenr/HB0335.pdf
  3. S.B. 254 (2025) bill page: https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/SB0254.html
  4. S.B. 254 (2025) introduced text: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/introduced/SB0254.pdf
  5. S.B. 254 Senate roll call, Feb. 19, 2025: link
  6. S.B. 254 House roll call, March 7, 2025: link
  7. H.B. 553 (2025) bill page: https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HB0553.html
  8. H.B. 553 House roll call, March 3, 2025: link
  9. S.B. 324 (2026) bill page: https://le.utah.gov/~2026/bills/static/SB0324.html
  10. S.B. 324 (2026) enrolled text: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/SB0324.pdf
  11. S.B. 324 House roll call, March 5, 2026: link
  12. House Education Committee minutes, March 4, 2026: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2026/html/00002062.htm
  13. S.B. 3 (2025) Appropriations Adjustments, introduced text: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/introduced/SB0003.pdf
  14. H.B. 3 (2026) Appropriations Adjustments, enrolled text: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2026/bills/enrolled/HB0003.pdf
  15. COBI, Hope of Utah request, 2025 (H.A.R. 143): https://cobi.utah.gov/2025/1/issues/23854
  16. COBI, Hope of Utah request, 2026 (H.A.R. 49): https://cobi.utah.gov/2026/1/issues/25336
  17. Transparent Utah, vendor payments: https://old.transparent.utah.gov/vendet.php

Where this connects

Other pages, people and records tied to this one.

Bills it stacks with

People

  • Rep. Karianne Lisonbee, who asked for the Hope of Utah money.
  • Rep. Val L. Peterson, primary sponsor of H.B. 335.

Elsewhere on the Hive

Research tracker and docket

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell usWe never name tipsters.
Utah Hive PoliticsThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people’s publication. We investigate what’s best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.Independent · Accountability · Journalism