Bill Tracker · CASE 2022–2026-BOOK · School libraries & sensitive material
From 2022 to 2026, Utah lawmakers tried six bills about which books belong in school libraries. Two became law and four died. Here is who wrote each one, how lawmakers voted, and how each one grades.
Posted Oct. 31, 2026 · Updated Nov. 2, 2026 · Updated Nov. 17, 2026
This isn’t a personal opinion of any bill. Each bill is graded on the same five questions used across the Hive: Who holds the power? Can the public see what happens? Is the money accounted for? What does it do to land and water? What does it do to the community? Grades are based on what the bill’s own words would do. Whether it became law is shown separately.
In plain words: C means it does what the law already requires. B or A means it does more for the public. D means it makes a public check weaker. F means it takes one away with nothing in its place.
| Bill | Power | Transparency | Financial | Environmental | Community | Overall | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| H.B. 374 (2022) Rep. Ken Ivory | B | B | — | N/A | B | B | Law |
| H.B. 138 (2023) Rep. Melissa Ballard | C | B | — | N/A | C | C+ | Died |
| H.B. 29 (2024) Rep. Ken Ivory | D | C | C | N/A | D | C− | Law |
| H.B. 473 (2025) Rep. Nicholeen P. Peck | C | B | — | N/A | C | C+ | Died |
| H.B. 197 (2026) Rep. Nicholeen P. Peck | C | C | — | N/A | C | C | Died |
| H.B. 517 (2026) Rep. Ken Ivory | D | D | D | N/A | D | D | Died |
A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); N/A and “—” (not graded yet) are left out; exactly halfway counts toward the higher letter with a minus. A grade can change when the missing record (such as a fiscal note) is read. Grades are the publisher’s rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.
In plain words: someone asks the school to take a book out. If the book clearly breaks the state’s rule, a small committee that includes a parent can take it out. If it’s a judgment call, a group of parents and staff (a review committee) decides. Once enough districts take the same book out, it leaves every public school in Utah.
Built from KSL’s description of H.B. 29 and the bill’s own summary (KSL, March 18, 2024; H.B. 29 bill page).
Correction, Nov. 17, 2026: the “Objective” box in this chart first said “District administrators can remove it without a review committee,” and the line under it said district leaders could take a book out on their own. That came from news coverage of H.B. 29. The State School Board’s rule says each district’s objective review uses a group of three or more people, including at least one parent, and that the people who bought the book and the person who challenged it may not serve on it (R277-628-3(1)(a)(v)–(vi)). The chart and line now match the rule. Each step, with its deadline and the record it leaves, is on the Education page: Each step and its record.
In plain words: This made pornographic or indecent books against state rules in public schools, and said parents from each school’s community must help decide which books cross that line.
What it does (from the bill’s own summary):
| Date | Where | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feb. 25, 2022 | House Education Committee, favorable | 11–2–2 | Bill status page |
| March 1, 2022 | House, final passage | 59–16–0 | House roll call |
| March 4, 2022 | Senate, passed under suspension of the rules | 23–3–3 | Senate roll call |
House no votes: Reps. Bennion, Briscoe, Collard, Dailey-Provost, Hollins, King, Kwan, Lesser, Matthews, C. Moss, Owens, Pitcher, Romero, Stoddard, Weight and Wheatley. Senate no votes: Sens. Escamilla, Iwamoto and Kitchen; Sens. Harper, Mayne and Stevenson were absent.
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | B | Adds parents from the school’s community to the decision on whether a book is sensitive material. |
| Transparency | B | Requires the State School Board to report compliance and complaints to two legislative committees. |
| Financial accountability | — | Not graded yet: the fiscal note has not been read for this page. |
| Environmental impact | N/A | Not applicable. |
| Community impact | B | Parents “reflective of a school’s community” must be part of each review. |
In plain words: This would have made schools finish every book review they started and tell the state about books that broke the rules. It passed the House but never got a Senate vote.
What it does (from the bill’s own summary):
| Date | Where | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feb. 6, 2023 | House Education Committee, favorable | 8–6–2 | Bill status page |
| Feb. 13, 2023 | House, final passage (5th Substitute) | 50–18–7 | House roll call |
| Feb. 22, 2023 | Senate Education Committee, favorable | 3–1–5 | Bill status page |
| March 3, 2023 | Filed at the end of the session; no Senate floor vote | — | Bill status page |
House no votes included Rep. Ken Ivory, along with Reps. Dunnigan, Hawkins, Kotter, Lee, Lisonbee, Lyman, Maloy, Musselman, Petersen, K. Peterson, Rohner, Schultz, Stratton, Strong, Thurston, Welton and Wilcox.
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | C | Keeps decisions with local districts; adds a duty to finish reviews. |
| Transparency | B | Districts must report material that breaks state law to the State School Board. |
| Financial accountability | — | Not graded yet: the fiscal note and vendor-contract cost have not been read for this page. |
| Environmental impact | N/A | Not applicable. |
| Community impact | C | No change to who sits on reviews. |
In plain words: This is the law that takes a book out of every public school in Utah once enough districts take it out. Only the State School Board can vote to bring it back.
What it does (from the bill’s own summary):
| Date | Where | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan. 23, 2024 | House Education Committee, favorable | 10–2–3 | Bill status page |
| Jan. 30, 2024 | House, 3rd reading | 51–16–8 | Bill status page |
| Feb. 9, 2024 | Senate Education Committee, favorable (substituted, amended) | 5–1–3 | Bill status page |
| Feb. 20, 2024 | Conference committee report | 6–0–0 | Bill status page |
| Feb. 20, 2024 | Senate, final passage | 19–8–2 | Senate roll call |
| Feb. 21, 2024 | House, final passage | 52–18–5 | House roll call |
Senate no votes: Sens. Blouin, Escamilla, Hinkins, Kwan, Pitcher, Plumb, Riebe and Winterton. House no votes: Reps. Bennion, Briscoe, Dailey-Provost, Dunnigan, Garner, Hayes, Hollins, Judkins, King, Lesser, Loubet, Matthews, C. Moss, Owens, Romero, Stoddard, Thurston and Wheatley.
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | D | A removal in three districts applies to every district, including ones that never reviewed the book; the only check left is a State School Board vote to overturn. |
| Transparency | C | Adds a Legislative Auditor General audit of compliance, but objective-material removals can skip the review committee. |
| Financial accountability | C | The state indemnifies claims arising from the law; the bill says so plainly, but no dollar amount appears in the bill summary. |
| Environmental impact | N/A | Not applicable. |
| Community impact | D | Parents and students in districts that never reviewed a book get no local review before it is removed. |
In plain words: This would have given parents more information about the book rules and a place on every district’s website to report a book. It passed the House but never got a Senate vote.
What it does (from the bill’s own summary):
| Date | Where | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feb. 28, 2025 | House Education Committee, favorable (substituted, amended) | 7–3–6 | Bill status page |
| March 3, 2025 | House, final passage | 54–14–7 | House roll call |
| March 7, 2025 | Filed at the end of the session; no Senate vote | — | Bill status page |
Who spoke at the House Education Committee, Feb. 28, 2025: Brooke Stephens spoke in favor, listed in the minutes as “Utah Moms for America.” Rep. Karianne Lisonbee is recorded as abstaining on all three committee motions; the minutes give no reason (committee minutes). Both appear in our Who Connects to Whom research.
House no votes: Reps. Albrecht, Barlow, Bennion, Chew, Dailey-Provost, Dominguez, Hayes, Hollins, G. Miller, C. Moss, Nguyen, Owens, Romero and Watkins.
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | C | No change to who decides. |
| Transparency | B | Parents get sensitive-material information at registration, in the state portal and on each district’s homepage. |
| Financial accountability | — | Not graded yet: the fiscal note has not been read for this page. |
| Environmental impact | N/A | Not applicable. |
| Community impact | C | Reporting tools are open to every parent; no change to who sits on reviews. |
In plain words: This would have made schools check every new book before adding it, and kept books removed statewide out of every school. It passed the House, then stopped in a Senate committee.
What it does (from the bill’s own summary):
| Date | Where | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feb. 12, 2026 | House Education Committee, favorable (4th Substitute) | 9–4–2 | Bill status page |
| Feb. 20, 2026 | House, final passage | 47–17–11 | House roll call |
| March 4, 2026 | Senate Government Operations Committee, held | 6–0–1 | Bill status page |
| March 6, 2026 | Filed at the end of the session | — | Bill status page |
Who spoke at the House Education Committee, Feb. 12, 2026: Corinne Johnson of Utah Parents United spoke in favor. Rep. Karianne Lisonbee made both committee motions, to adopt the 4th Substitute (13–0–2) and to pass it favorably (9–4–2), and voted yes on both (committee minutes). See Who Connects to Whom.
House no votes: Reps. Arthur, Cutler, Dailey-Provost, Dominguez, Fitisemanu, Hawkins, Hayes, Hollins, Matthews, Mauga, G. Miller, C. Moss, Nguyen, Owens, Romero, Stoddard and Ward.
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | C | Up-front review stays with each district; statewide removals reach further. |
| Transparency | C | No new public reporting in the bill summary. |
| Financial accountability | — | Not graded yet: the fiscal note has not been read for this page. |
| Environmental impact | N/A | Not applicable. |
| Community impact | C | No change to who sits on reviews. |
In plain words: This would have made the book law harder to challenge in court. People who sued to stop it could have had to pay the other side’s lawyers, and state courts could not block it. It never got a vote.
What it does (from the bill’s own summary):
| Date | Where | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feb. 13, 2026 | Sent to House standing committee | — | Bill status page |
| March 4, 2026 | House committee: returned to Rules | — | Bill status page |
| March 6, 2026 | Enacting clause struck; filed | — | Bill status page |
No roll call was recorded. Bill text read from the introduced version (H.B. 517 introduced text).
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | D | Strips state courts of power to block the law and bars class actions; people who sue to block it can be made to pay the other side’s fees. A harmed person can sue a school to comply, and the law’s validity can still be raised as a defense (lines 261–324). |
| Transparency | D | Claims could be moved into individual private arbitration instead of open court (lines 245–260). |
| Financial accountability | D | The state would cover enforcers’ legal costs and fees, but no money is appropriated and no cost is stated (lines 20, 222–227). |
| Environmental impact | N/A | Not applicable. |
| Community impact | D | Students and parents could be asked to sign arbitration agreements, and anyone challenging the law carries fee risk (lines 245–284). |
Votes are from the Legislature’s bill pages and roll calls, pulled Oct. 31, 2026. A vote like 59–16–0 means yes–no–absent. “3rd reading” and “final passage” are the last votes by the whole House or Senate. A “substitute” is a rewritten version of the bill. A “conference committee” is a small group from both the House and Senate that settles differences. A bill “filed” at the end of the session has died.
These come from gaps in the record, not from either side of the book debate. They would help anyone, for or against removals, see what is happening.
| Person | Role in this record | Elsewhere on the Hive |
|---|---|---|
| Rep. Ken Ivory | Primary sponsor of H.B. 374 (2022), H.B. 29 (2024) and H.B. 517 (2026); voted no on H.B. 138 (2023) (House roll call, Feb. 13, 2023). | Education: How a book gets pulled |
| Sen. Todd Weiler | Senate sponsor of H.B. 374 and H.B. 29. | — |
| Rep. Nicholeen P. Peck | Primary sponsor of H.B. 473 (2025) and H.B. 197 (2026). | — |
| Sen. Keven J. Stratton | Senate sponsor of H.B. 473 and H.B. 197. | — |
| Rep. Karianne Lisonbee | Abstained on all three House Education Committee motions on H.B. 473 (Feb. 28, 2025); made both committee motions on H.B. 197 and voted yes (Feb. 12, 2026). | Who Connects to Whom |
| Rep. Melissa Ballard | Primary sponsor of H.B. 138 (2023). | — |
| Brooke Stephens (Davis County parent) | Curriculum director of Utah Parents United in 2022 (Salt Lake Tribune); filed 27 book challenges in Davis School District by Sept. 2022 (KUTV); spoke for H.B. 29 at its House committee hearing: “We need this bill to protect Utah’s children when districts refuse to proactively follow the law” (Deseret News, Jan. 23, 2024). State records list a $50 contribution from a Brooke Stephens of Layton to Ken Ivory’s campaign on July 16, 2024 (disclosures.utah.gov). | Education: who she gave to |
You can ask these at a public meeting, by email or in public comment. Find your State School Board member on the board district map, and your state representative and senator on the Utah Legislature’s website.
Posted Oct. 31, 2026. Updated Nov. 2, 2026: added who spoke and how Rep. Lisonbee voted in committee on H.B. 473 and H.B. 197. Updated Nov. 17, 2026: corrected the “Objective” chart box, the line under it, the H.B. 29 summary note and the “Objective sensitive material” card to State School Board rule R277-628 (old wording kept in the correction note); added the Sept. 15, 2026 court ruling; added three sources. Nothing earlier was removed. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Bill summaries, votes and roll calls were read from the Legislature’s own bill data on Oct. 31, 2026.
Other pages, people and records tied to this one.
Utah Hive PoliticsThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people’s publication. We investigate what’s best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.Independent · Accountability · Journalism