Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
Education · ED 100.04← Education docket · ← Hive library (every repo)
Case file — Statewide · School libraries

How a Book Gets Pulled From Every Utah School

How one rule can take a book out of every public school in Utah, what the State School Board voted to do about library books, and who gives money to the people making these choices. All from public records.

Posted Oct. 31, 2026 · Updated Nov. 1, 2026 · Page look updated Nov. 2, 2026 · Updated Nov. 17, 2026: each step in the law, with its deadline and record

New to this? Read it in plain words About 600 words.
Short version
WhereEvery Utah public school district and charter school. Most early removals started in Davis School District.
WhoRep. Ken Ivory (H.B. 29 primary sponsor) · the Utah State Board of Education (can overturn a statewide removal) · Board Member Emily Green (library review addendum) · Brooke Stephens (president of RatedBooks.org; Utah Parents United in 2022–2024; National Book Rating Index) · Brian Barnett (Jordan School District board member) · Mike Green (sent the Aug. 4 survey draft)
Education pages (7) · tap to open
  1. Education docketEvery district we track, searchable
  2. In plain wordsThe short, simple version of the case files
  3. Tooele County SD: The Gemini deploymentGoogle AI contract, June 2026
  4. What 100 apps actually sendThe BYU study and H.B. 55
  5. Box Elder SD: three ways to borrowA failed bond, a petition, then certificates of participation
  6. How a book gets pulled from every schoolH.B. 29, the Aug. 6 board vote, and political giving
  7. Book removals in plain wordsThe short version of the book-removal case file

How a book gets pulled from every school

flowchart TD A["Someone files a challenge:
school employee, student,
parent or board member"] --> B(["District decides: clearly
breaks the rule (objective)
or a judgment call (subjective)?"]) B -->|Objective| C["A committee of 3 or more,
with at least 1 parent,
checks it against fixed
definitions in the law"] B -->|Subjective| D["A review committee
decides"] C --> E(["Removed in 3 districts,
or 2 districts + 5 charters?"]) E -->|Yes| F["Removed from EVERY
Utah public school"] F --> G(["State School Board
votes to overturn?"]) G -->|No vote| H["Stays removed statewide"] G -->|Votes to overturn| I["Goes back on shelves"]

In plain words: someone asks the school to take a book out. If the book clearly breaks the state’s rule, a small committee that includes a parent can take it out. If it’s a judgment call, a group of parents and staff (a review committee) decides. Once enough districts take the same book out, it leaves every public school in Utah.

Built from KSL’s description of H.B. 29 and the bill’s own summary (KSL; H.B. 29 bill page). Every bill behind this, with votes and grades, is on the Bill Tracker: Utah’s School Book Laws, 2022–2026.

Correction, Nov. 17, 2026: the “Objective” box in this chart first said “District administrators can remove it without a review committee.” That came from news coverage of H.B. 29. The State School Board’s rule says each district’s objective review uses a group of three or more people, including at least one parent (R277-628-3(1)(a)(v)), and that the people who bought the book and the person who challenged it may not serve on it (R277-628-3(1)(a)(vi)). The box, and the “In plain words” line under the chart (which said “district leaders can take it out on their own”), now match the rule. The step-by-step table below has the rest.

Each step, its deadline, and the record it leaves

In plain words: every step in a book review leaves a paper trail. This table shows who acts at each step, how long they have, what record it leaves, and who keeps that record. It follows the law itself, Utah Code § 53G-10-103 (in effect since May 7, 2025), and the State School Board’s rule, R277-628 (in effect since Aug. 7, 2024). A district’s own policy fills in details the law leaves open, like appeal deadlines.

Step and what happensDeadlineRecord it leavesWho keeps itWhere the law says it
1. Someone files a challenge
A district employee, a student enrolled there, a parent of an enrolled student, or a member of the district’s or charter school’s board. The challenge should come with excerpts and other evidence. A person whose challenges fail three times in one school year can’t start another until the next school year.
—The challenge and the excerpts sent with itThe district or charter school§ 53G-10-103(3), (4)(a)(i)
2. First look: is the claim believable?
Two or more district employees decide whether the challenge makes a plausible claim. If it does, the book is pulled right away from anywhere students can get it, and it stays out until the review is done.
Right awayThe first-look decision and the notice to pull the bookThe district or charter school§ 53G-10-103(4)(a); R277-628-3(1)(a)(iv)
3. Objective review (first test)
The committee from the chart above checks the challenged pages against three fixed descriptions of sexual content in the criminal code (arousal of genitals; masturbation, intercourse or sodomy; erotic touching of genitals). If the pages match, the book stays out. The district does not have to do the second review, and a second review could not change that result.
Not set in the lawThe committee’s finding, its member list, and the reasonsThe district or charter school§ 53G-10-103(1)(e), (2)(d), (4)(b); R277-628-3(1)(a)(v)–(vi); § 76-5c-207(1)(a)(i)(A)–(C)
4. What happens to removed copies
The copies are taken out of the school, the vendor or publisher is told, and the copies are legally disposed of. They may not be sold or given away.
—Letters to the vendor or publisher, and a disposal recordThe district or charter schoolR277-628-3(1)(a)(vii)
5. Subjective review (second test, only if the first test isn’t met)
The book is weighed under standards for material harmful to minors, pornographic material, or certain erotic touching of the buttocks or breasts. The review must include parents who reflect the school’s community. While it runs, a parent may give consent for their own child to read the book. That ends if the book is found sensitive.
Not set in the lawThe review’s finding and who sat on itThe district or charter school§ 53G-10-103(1)(h)(iii), (4)(c)
6. Appeal
Anyone who could have filed the challenge can appeal to the district or charter board, whether the book was removed or kept. The board votes in a public meeting and states its reasons and its finding on each standard. A board can’t make rules that stop it from looking at a decision again.
Set by each district’s policy, not the lawAgenda, minutes and recording of the board meetingThe district’s or charter school’s board§ 53G-10-103(5), (6)
7. Report to the state
The district sends the challenge, its final decision and its reasons to the state, on the state’s form.
Within 30 school days, or when an appeal endsThe report formThe district and the State School Board§ 53G-10-103(4)(d); R277-628-4(3)
8. Statewide removal
The state counts the objective findings. When three school districts, or two school districts and five charter schools, find the same book objective sensitive material, every public school must remove it. Findings from different school years count, and so do findings made before July 1, 2024.
State tells every school within 10 school daysThe state’s count and its notice to all schoolsThe State School Board§ 53G-10-103(7)(a)–(c), (e); R277-628-5(1)
9. The state board may undo it
A board member may ask, within 30 days of the notice, for a vote. The board may put the book on a public meeting agenda within 60 days and vote to overturn the statewide removal. If it does, districts may put the book back, and each district’s own finding still stands. (See item 7 under “What would make this clearer”: we found no record of such a vote.)
30 days to ask; 60 days to voteThe request, the agenda item, and the voteThe State School Board§ 53G-10-103(7)(d); R277-628-5(2)
10. Each year
The State School Board reports to the Legislature’s Education Interim Committee by its November interim meeting, including complaints and districts’ reasons for keeping books. People who can file a challenge can also report a district that isn’t following the law (rule R277-123). The Legislative Auditor General must audit every school district’s compliance before November 2028.
Yearly report by November; audits by November 2028The board’s yearly report and complaints; the auditor’s reportsThe State School Board and the Legislative Auditor General§ 53G-10-103(8), (10); R277-628-5(3); Audit 2025-11 (June 2025)

Can the public see these records? Under Utah’s records law (GRAMA), a government record is public unless a law says otherwise (§ 63G-2-201(2)). Some may still be held back, for example records about a student. A request goes to whoever keeps the record.

Read from the law and rule on Nov. 17, 2026. This is general information about the law, not legal advice.

The timeline

Tap a date to see what happened and where it comes from. Filled dots mark the key decisions.

Which books, and which districts

As of Sept. 28, 2026, 44 titles are on the statewide list. Every one was triggered by school districts; no charter school appears on any title. Davis School District is on 43 of the 44. Weber School District, Ogden School District and Box Elder School District do not appear on any title.

What about charter schools? Charter schools are public schools run by their own boards instead of a school district. The state’s yearly reports to lawmakers credit every statewide removal to school districts and name no charter school (USBE 2024 report; USBE 2025 report). State auditors visited 2 charter schools but said they did not review charter schools’ compliance, because the law only requires them to audit districts (state audit, Oct. 2025). A charter school can still take a book off its own shelves; that would not show up on any public list unless it counted toward a statewide removal.

How many of the 44 titles each district helped trigger (our count from KUER’s list):

Davis43
Washington32
Jordan22
Tooele17
Granite10
Nebo9
Alpine8
Cache2
Park City1
All 44 titles, with the districts behind each · tap to open
#TitleAuthorDistricts that removed it
1A Court of Thorns and RosesSarah J. MaasAlpine, Davis, Jordan, Nebo, Washington
2A Court of Frost and StarlightSarah J. MaasAlpine, Davis, Jordan, Nebo, Washington
3A Court of Mist and FurySarah J. MaasAlpine, Davis, Nebo, Washington
4A Court of Silver FlamesSarah J. MaasAlpine, Davis, Nebo, Washington
5A Court of Wings and RuinSarah J. MaasAlpine, Davis, Nebo, Washington
6Empire of StormsSarah J. MaasDavis, Jordan, Washington
7What Girls Are Made OfElana K. ArnoldAlpine, Davis, Jordan, Washington
8Milk and HoneyRupi KaurDavis, Jordan, Washington
9ForeverJudy BlumeDavis, Nebo, Washington
10TiltEllen HopkinsDavis, Tooele, Washington
11Fallout (Crank, Book 3)Ellen HopkinsAlpine, Davis, Washington
12Oryx and CrakeMargaret AtwoodDavis, Jordan, Washington
13BlanketsCraig ThompsonDavis, Nebo, Washington
14Living Dead GirlElizabeth ScottDavis, Tooele, Washington
15DamselElana K. ArnoldDavis, Park City, Washington
16Like a Love StoryAbdi NazemianDavis, Jordan, Washington
17TricksEllen HopkinsDavis, Tooele, Washington
18Water for ElephantsSara GruenCache, Davis, Tooele
19Thirteen Reasons WhyJay AsherNebo, Tooele, Washington
20Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the WestGregory MaguireDavis, Tooele, Washington
21Nineteen MinutesJodi PicoultDavis, Tooele, Washington
22The Perks of Being a WallflowerStephen ChboskyDavis, Tooele, Washington
23Bag of BonesStephen KingDavis, Granite, Jordan, Tooele
24BreathlessJennifer NivenDavis, Granite, Washington
25The Carnival at BrayJessie Ann FoleyDavis, Granite, Washington
26The Handmaid’s Tale: The Graphic NovelMargaret AtwoodDavis, Granite, Washington
27Red HoodElana K. ArnoldDavis, Granite, Washington
28Looking for AlaskaJohn GreenDavis, Jordan, Tooele, Washington
29Life Is FunnyE.R. FrankDavis, Jordan, Washington
30The HatersJesse AndrewsDavis, Jordan, Washington
31The Bluest EyeToni MorrisonDavis, Jordan, Washington
32People Kill PeopleEllen HopkinsDavis, Jordan, Tooele
33A Stolen Life: A MemoirJaycee DugardCache, Davis, Granite
34A Clash of KingsGeorge R.R. MartinAlpine, Davis, Jordan
35LuckyAlice SeboldDavis, Granite, Tooele, Washington
36Different SeasonsStephen KingDavis, Jordan, Tooele, Washington
37PushSapphireDavis, Granite, Washington
38House of Earth and BloodSarah J. MaasDavis, Jordan, Nebo
39IdenticalEllen HopkinsDavis, Jordan, Tooele
40Kingdom of the CursedKerri ManiscalcoDavis, Jordan, Tooele
41Me and Earl and the Dying GirlJesse AndrewsDavis, Granite, Jordan
42PerfectEllen HopkinsDavis, Jordan, Tooele
43Storm and FuryJennifer L. ArmentroutDavis, Jordan, Tooele
44The Invisible Life of Addie LaRueV.E. SchwabDavis, Granite, Jordan

Sources: KUER, Oct. 9, 2026 (list and districts); TownLift, Oct. 1, 2026 (the Sept. 28 additions). Districts in our Education docket that appear here: Tooele, Washington, Jordan and Granite.

How Utah compares to other states

Most states remove books one district at a time. PEN America, a group that tracks and opposes book bans, counted 11,982 school book bans nationwide from July 2025 to June 2026. Texas had 8,193 and Florida 3,212, district by district (Texas Public Radio; FOX 9).

Only a few states take a book out of every school at once:

StateHow it worksBooks removed statewide
Utah (H.B. 29, 2024)When 3 districts, or 2 districts plus 5 charter schools, remove the same book as clearly over the line, it leaves every public school. The State School Board can vote to put it back.44 as of Sept. 28, 2026; none added in October (The Globe)
South Carolina (State Board rule 43-170, 2024)A parent who disagrees with a district’s decision can appeal to the State Board, which votes on each book. A book with any sexual content comes out of every school, K–12.22 (21 removed, 1 restricted); none added since May 2025 (ACLU of South Carolina; SC Daily Gazette)
Tennessee (H.B. 843, 2024)A state commission can order a book out statewide.None so far (PEN America)

PEN America’s Utah page calls Utah and South Carolina “the only two states” with statewide bans (PEN America).

Utah: a few districts, and a few peopleKUTV reported 33 of the first 34 statewide removals were first removed in Davis School District. A parents’ group, Let Utah Read, found 24 of 25 challenges filed in Davis in the 2025 school year came from one person (KUTV). As of October 2026, only nine Utah districts had filed complaints that led to a statewide removal; Davis and Washington took part in 43 and 32 of the 44 (The Globe).
South Carolina: one parent, many challenges“One parent in Beaufort County has brought 14 of the challenges the state board has considered” (SC Daily Gazette, May 2025). PEN America says most of the books removed at the state level came from one woman who challenged 97 books in Beaufort County (PEN America).
NationallyA 2023 Washington Post review of more than 1,000 challenges found 11 people filed 60% of them (as reported by Book Riot).
What each side saysStephens told KUTV she does not remove books herself; review committees decide (KUTV). Her May 2026 newsletter says “the books themselves are the reason they are being removed,” “as agreed upon by multiple committees in multiple school districts” (a tip came in). The ACLU of South Carolina, which is suing over that state’s rule, says the state “is continuing to leave educational decisions for all students up to one parent” (WBTV).

How the board voted, Aug. 6, 2026

The State School Board has 15 members voters elect. At a meeting, a member makes a proposal (a motion), and other members can change it (an amendment) before the final vote. Here is every vote on the library plan, with names.

From the State School Board’s approved minutes (the official notes of the meeting), approved Sept. 4, 2026 and posted on the board’s website. The copy on the state’s public notice site is still an unapproved version that miscounts one vote (notice-site copy; earlier draft).

MotionWhat it didResult
Main motion (Joseph Kerry)Adopt the 2026 timeline plan, Draft 1, and use $60,000 from board discretionary funds.Amended, then adopted (final vote below).
Amendment (Amanda Bollinger / Cole Kelley)Adjust the timeline to an Aug. 10, 2026 start.Passed 15–0.
Amendment (Emily Green / Christina Boggess)Include the “USBE Library Review Addendum Revised, Member Green Draft 1.”Carried 10–5. Yes: Cole Kelley, Randy Boothe, Cindy Davis, Jennie Earl, Erin Longacre, Emily Green, Rod Hall, Joseph Kerry, Joann Brinton, Christina Boggess. No: Matt Hymas (board chair), Carol Lear, Amanda Bollinger, Sarah Reale, LeAnn Wood.
Amendment (Amanda Bollinger / Joseph Kerry)Change “include” to “consider.”Failed 6–9. Yes: Sarah Reale, LeAnn Wood, Cindy Davis, Carol Lear, Matt Hymas, Amanda Bollinger. No: Joann Brinton, Cole Kelley, Christina Boggess, Emily Green, Erin Longacre, Rod Hall, Jennie Earl, Joseph Kerry, Randy Boothe. (The unapproved copy on the state’s public notice site lists Jennie Earl on both sides and counts 16 votes; the approved minutes fix this.)
Amendment (Amanda Bollinger / Cole Kelley)Let staff adjust the timeline to meet requirements.Passed 13–0 (Cindy Davis and Matt Hymas absent).
Amendment (Emily Green / Joseph Kerry)Include the “Memorandum to the USBE Library Review Addendum Document – August 4, 2026.”Carried 13–1–1. No: Sarah Reale. Abstained: Matt Hymas.
Final motion, as amendedAdopt the plan with the $60,000, the addendum and the memo; the memo is included “for staff refinement and committee discussion, not as a final form.”Carried 11–2–1, 1 absent. No: Carol Lear, Sarah Reale. Abstained: Matt Hymas. Absent: Joann Brinton.

Source: USBE minutes, Aug. 6, 2026. The timeline plan grew out of a May 18, 2026 committee motion directing staff to bring back a timeline “for conducting a comprehensive review and audit” of school library practices (USBE action item). Two committees approved it before the full board: Standards and Assessment on June 5 (4–1 in that committee’s own summary, with Sarah Reale voting no; later documents call it unanimous) and Law and Licensing on July 14, unanimously (June 5 summary; July 14 summary).

What the review will look at

The plan is called the “School Library Materials Acquisition and Procurement Review.” Board documents describe three phases (KPCW/Salt Lake Tribune, Aug. 31, 2026):

  1. Money: a fiscal analysis of what schools spend on library materials.
  2. Supply chain: a technical review of how books are bought and the contracts behind them.
  3. Staff: a statewide look at library staff qualifications.

KUTV later reported the phases also cover regulatory steps and parent complaint logs, which show how districts respond when a parent challenges a book. The board’s library media specialist, Davina Sauthoff, said the aim is to understand the process “from the vendor perspective” (KUTV, Oct. 14, 2026).

What the board’s own timeline says. The plan staff posted runs 26 weeks in four phases: money (8 weeks), supply chain and buying (7 weeks), rules, training and complaint logs (7 weeks), and a final report (4 weeks). The first two phases use a sample of 12 school districts and 3 charter schools; the third covers every district and charter. It estimates 680 hours of state staff time and 789 hours of school district staff time. It does not mention paying districts for that time. Its first dates ran June 8 to Dec. 7, 2026; on Aug. 6 the board moved the start to Aug. 10 and shifted the rest to match (School Library Monitoring Timeline; USBE minutes). One line in the timeline lists 534 district hours for phase 3 but also describes it as about 3 hours across the whole state, so those two numbers don’t match.

Who signed up (board agenda for Nov. 6, 2026): superintendents got the sign-up form Sept. 30 and were asked to answer by Oct. 16. Superintendents in southwest Utah asked for more time, so the form was still open. As of the agenda, four districts (counting the Utah Schools for the Deaf and the Blind) and three charter schools had agreed to take part, out of 39 responses. The agenda also says “no official survey questions for the School Library Monitoring Review about purchasing or otherwise have been shared publicly,” and that Board Members Green and Brinton attended the southwest superintendents’ Oct. 14 board meeting about it. The Standards and Assessment Committee takes it up Nov. 6 (USBE Nov. 6, 2026 agenda).
Deadline: taking part is voluntary. Districts had until Oct. 16, 2026 to decide whether to join the data-gathering and survey. No date has been set for the review to finish (KUTV, Oct. 14, 2026).

In their own words

Emily Green, at the Aug. 6 meetingThe board needs to understand how vendors have access to public education: “we don’t understand that relationship” (KPCW/Salt Lake Tribune, Aug. 31, 2026).
Carol Lear (voted no), at the Aug. 6 meetingAsked whether Green was saying vendors intentionally sell pornographic materials to schools. Green replied that, framed politically, one could say “yes, that’s happening” (KPCW/Salt Lake Tribune, Aug. 31, 2026).
Emily Green, at a May 2026 meeting“So we don’t have to continue to be reactive to an industry that has full access to a minority population” (KUTV, Oct. 14, 2026).
Emily Green, on librariansSaid librarians could end up “in the hot seat,” and that she doesn’t think any board member wants librarians in that position (KUTV, Oct. 14, 2026).
Salt Lake Tribune editorial board (opinion), Sept. 4, 2026Called the project a waste of about $60,000 and more than 1,400 hours of staff time and said the board should drop it (Salt Lake Tribune editorial). Supporters’ case, in Green’s words above: books meeting the state’s definition keep reaching schools, so the board should understand where they come from.

Erin Longacre does not appear on the minutes’ list of members present at the start, but is recorded voting. Gov. Spencer Cox appointed her to a board vacancy in August 2025 (Salt Lake Tribune, Aug. 1, 2025).

Political giving: Brooke Stephens

Searching state campaign records for “Brooke Stephens” from 2018 through 2026 returned these contributions, all from Layton. No contributions under that name appeared for 2018–2022 or 2025.

DateGave toAmountWhat they ran forSource
Oct. 30, 2023Phil Lyman$50.00State representative at the time; he voted on H.B. 374 and H.B. 29Bill Tracker roll calls
April 2, 2024Cari Bartholomew$25.00State School Board, District 13, 2024 (Republican); lost the primaryBallotpedia
April 5, May 5 and June 5, 2024Austin Hepworth$26.35 each ($79.05)Utah Attorney General, 2024 (unaffiliated); lost the general electionBallotpedia
May 11, 2024Rod Hall$40.00State School Board, District 3, 2024 (Republican); won. Voted yes on the Green addendum Aug. 6, 2026Ballotpedia; USBE minutes
July 16, 2024Ken Ivory$50.00State representative; primary sponsor of H.B. 374 and H.B. 29H.B. 29 bill page
Sept. 13, 2024Diane Livingston$35.00State School Board, District 6, 2024 (unaffiliated); lost the general electionBallotpedia
April 6, 2026Nichole Beecher Isom$30.00State School Board, 2026 (Republican); lost the primaryWikipedia, 2026 USBE election
June 3, 2026Trevor Lee$50.00State representative; voted yes on H.B. 29, H.B. 473 and H.B. 197Bill Tracker roll calls
Total$359.05Ten contributions to eight people; four were State School Board candidates.
How to read this: these are small amounts. They are matched by name and city (Layton) in the state’s contributor search, not by any ID number, and the home address on the filings is left off this page. Rod Hall received $40 in 2024 and voted yes on the Green addendum in 2026; the two facts are listed side by side, and neither is a claim that one caused the other.

Groups and tools tied to Stephens in news reports: Utah Parents United, where she was curriculum director in 2022 (Salt Lake Tribune) and a leader in 2024 (Axios); ratedbooks.org, the site she set up (KUTV, 2022); and the National Book Rating Index, which KUTV says she created (KUTV, 2026).

What a tip showed

A tip came in with copies of emails between State School Board members and board staff from May to August 2026, and a second set of 2025–2026 emails between Rep. Ken Ivory, Brooke Stephens and Jordan School District board members. We don’t name the person who sent them. Below is what the emails say, checked against public records where we could. Personal contact details and private email addresses are left off this page.

May 5: a policy draft passed among three membersJennie Earl emailed Emily Green and Joann Brinton an “Updated Model Library Materials Policy Draft.” Public record check: a “Model Library Materials Policy – Member Earl – Draft 1” was posted with the May 18 and June 5 committee meetings (May 18 meeting notice).
May 18: Green asks whether it can be a formal auditBefore the committee meeting, Green emailed staff the motion she planned to make. That evening she asked the board’s chief audit executive whether it could become a formal audit, writing that she had “way more detail” on what she felt the state needed to understand. The next day, the chief audit executive answered that “a significant question is what is meant by ‘comprehensive review and audit,’” explained that an internal audit is an independent review under professional auditing standards, and laid out the formal route: a request form, then the board’s Audit Committee, then a full board vote on the audit plan. She listed seven audits already on that plan. Public record check: the motion text matches the board’s June 5 memo (USBE memo). We did not find a formal audit request in the public records we searched.
Aug. 4–5: the memo, and a paragraph taken outGreen sent her addendum and a memo to the board’s executive assistant and the board chair for the meeting packet. Her memo text matches, word for word, a copy of the final Aug. 4 memo that came in with the same tip, plus a last paragraph asking the committee to “approve a one-LEA pilot” (a test run with one district or charter). On Aug. 5, the assistant wrote that she had attached “the updated memo (removing the last paragraph)” after a phone call with Green. Public record check: on Aug. 6 the board voted 13–1–1 to include the “Memorandum to the USBE Library Review Addendum Document – August 4, 2026” (USBE minutes). The memo begins, “In June, the Board approved a 26-week review…” Public records show the June vote was by a committee; the full board voted Aug. 6 (July 14 summary).
Aug. 4: a survey draft from Mike GreenAt 10:25 a.m., Green emailed “Mike” the board’s June 5 timeline: “This is the timeline that has been created so far.” At 12:17 p.m., Mike Green replied with the subject “Survey Draft,” no message, and a Word file. The file’s properties read: author “Draft prepared for Board Member Emily Green,” last saved by “Un-named,” revision 1, created five minutes before it was sent. One question lists “Content-rating rubrics or sites (identify, e.g., RatedBooks.org)” as a source schools might use. At 4:57 p.m., Green sent a revised version to the board’s executive assistant and the board chair, with suggested memo text; by our recount, 12 of the 14 sentences in that memo text match Mike Green’s draft word for word apart from hyphens, and the other 2 are close; one leaves out the draft’s line about the pending H.B. 29 lawsuit. The RatedBooks.org line is in both versions. Public record check: Green’s State School Board biography says, “Her husband is Mike” (USBE biography). The emails themselves don’t say how the two are related, and they don’t show who wrote the draft or how.
Aug. 4: the survey goes to membersGreen emailed her survey questions to members in two emails, four minutes apart: first to Jennie Earl, Joann Brinton, Randy Boothe and Cindy Davis, then to Matt Hymas, LeAnn Wood, Amanda Bollinger, Christina Boggess, Sarah Reale and Carol Lear. Both said she was sending it “to all board members this evening.” In a separate email that evening she wrote, “Over the past several months, I have been working to develop a set of questions.” The tip did not include copies sent to Cole Kelley, Erin Longacre, Rod Hall or Joseph Kerry.
Aug. 2025: a lawmaker asks a board member to file a challengeOn Aug. 13, 2025, Brooke Stephens emailed every State School Board member, about 100 legislators and Attorney General Derek Brown from a Utah Moms for America address: “I am the founder of RatedBooks.org and the Laverna in the Library Facebook page.” She listed Utah schools holding Bag of Bones. On Aug. 14, Rep. Ken Ivory, from his Legislature address, asked her: “Have the auditors reached out to you yet for the new audit on content?” Twenty minutes later he asked Jordan School District board member Brian Barnett, with Stephens copied out of view, to “review and submit this book for challenge inasmuch as I am not considered a person authorized to challenge such materials.” He wrote that “it has been brought to my attention” the book was at Copper Hills, West Jordan, Herriman and Riverton high schools, and linked “an analysis performed by concerned parents.” Barnett answered that night: “I’m happy to submit a challenge to this book once I verify that it is on our shelves.” On Aug. 16, Barnett wrote that he had checked Copper Hills and West Jordan high schools and filed a request for reconsideration; the form lists him as “JSD Board Member.” Ivory forwarded it to Stephens, calling Barnett “our one and only really good school board member.” Public record check: H.B. 29 lets school employees, students, parents and board members file challenges; a legislator is not on that list (KSL). Bag of Bones was removed statewide in February 2026 after Davis, Granite, Jordan and Tooele removed it (KPCW). The emails do not show when Jordan decided. From a tip: Jordan’s own report to the State School Board marks the book a “FINAL determination” of objective sensitive material for grades 10, 11 and 12, with the rationale “The selection contained descriptions and depictions prohibited in 76-10-1227.” The form gives no decision date.
Oct. 2025 to Jan. 2026: the list and H.B. 197On Oct. 15, 2025, the day after the audit, an email signed Brooke Stephens sent Ivory’s campaign email account a list of 4- and 5-rated books in Jordan School District libraries. In November, Ivory forwarded the audit and the list to Jordan board member Lisa Dean and asked why parents had to search each school; Barnett replied that a district-wide catalog search exists. On Jan. 12, 2026, Stephens emailed Republican legislators “Reasons you should support HB 197.” Public record check: the audit report says its books came “from a list provided by a concerned legislator” and “The list we chose the books from is ratedbooks.org” (audit 2025-28). H.B. 197 passed the House 47–17 and died in the Senate (bill page).
April–May 2026: Stephens, Ivory and Board Member BrintonOn April 29, 2026, Stephens emailed the full board from a Utah Moms for America address: “Thank you for removing 2 more books. I have updated the link to include excerpts for the two new books that were removed… Keep up the good work!” Joann Brinton replied eight minutes later: “Thank you!!” On May 2, a RatedBooks.org newsletter (“April’s 27 New Book Reports”) went to Brinton’s board email; it asks for donations for “legal and website expenses” and promotes “Flag & Notify” letters for parents. On May 18, Brinton forwarded to Ivory and Stephens what the superintendent told her about a one-page guide on teaching the harmful effects of pornography that “you asked about,” and wrote, “I can propose that if you agree.” Public record check: the guide the superintendent named is posted on the board’s website. Brinton voted yes on the Green addendum (10–5) on Aug. 6 (approved minutes).
What agencies said when asked (records responses from a tip)Legislative auditors, Oct. 27, 2026: there is no separate copy of the 186-title list; it “can be accessed at ratedbooks.org.” And: “The text message containing the link to ratedbooks.org was deleted in accordance with Records Policy Appendix A, Retention Schedule.” The response does not say who sent the text.
State School Board, Sept. 14, 2026: a search found no emails with the board’s assistant attorneys general mentioning “RatedBooks,” and the June 5, 2026 committee summary does not mention it.
State Charter School Board, Aug. 11, 2026: no records about the Aug. 4 library review draft.
Legislative Research and General Counsel, Oct. 30, 2026: released one H.B. 197 drafting record with parts blacked out, and withheld another, because they would reveal a legislator’s plans before the bill was made public.
What members wrote backJennie Earl (Aug. 4, voted yes): “my overall impression is very positive,” and she was “especially grateful that schools participating in this study will be compensated for the time and effort required to collect and provide this data.” Public record check: the board’s posted timeline counts district staff hours but does not mention paying districts.
Carol Lear (Aug. 5, voted no): the questions are “extensive and technical,” many schools “do not have full-time or specifically trained librarians,” and “I completely support the document if it is offered as an optional planning guide for LEAs. I’m not sure I support it as a required document for all LEAs.” Taking part did end up voluntary (KUTV).
Amanda Bollinger (Aug. 5, voted no): “Is this document something you put together yourself or is this something that you have been working on with staff?” No reply is in the set.
Cindy Davis (Aug. 13, voted yes on Aug. 6): “I’m not able to load it. Could you send it in a pdf format?”

These are copies of emails, not public postings. We list what they say and what public records match; we draw no conclusion about anyone’s reasons.

How one book list moved

This follows one book-rating list from a website to a state audit, a school challenge and a State School Board survey. Each step names its record. Steps marked “from a tip” come from emails that came in with a tip; the rest are public records.

flowchart TD A["RatedBooks.org
nonprofit, president
Brooke Stephens"] -->|"Feb. 2024 open letter
signed by Ken and Becky Ivory"| B["Rep. Ken Ivory
H.B. 29 sponsor"] A -->|"list from a
“concerned legislator”"| C["State auditors
Oct. 2025: 22 books"] B -->|"Aug. 2025: asks him to file
(from a tip)"| D["Brian Barnett
Jordan board member"] D -->|"files challenge to
Bag of Bones"| E["Removed statewide
Feb. 2026"] A -->|"named as an example
in the survey draft"| F["Mike Green
Aug. 4 survey draft
(from a tip)"] F --> G["Emily Green
addendum and memo"] G -->|"Aug. 6, 2026
10–5 and 13–1–1"| H["State School Board
$60,000 library review"]

Lines show a step in the records, not a claim about anyone’s reasons. The audit report does not name the legislator who gave it the list.

What the records say about RatedBooks.org

Step by step

DateStepRecord
Feb. 22, 2024An open letter by Stephens and Gloria Vindas promotes booklooks.org and RatedBooks.org; Ken and Becky Ivory sign it.Deseret News
May 16, 2025RatedBooks.org registers as a Utah nonprofit; IRS letter follows Aug. 5 (exemption effective May 16).Registry; IRS
Aug. 14, 2025Ivory asks Stephens whether “the auditors” have reached out, and asks Barnett to file a challenge.A tip came in
Aug. 16, 2025Barnett files a reconsideration request for Bag of Bones.A tip came in
Oct. 14, 2025Auditors review 22 books from “a list provided by a concerned legislator”: ratedbooks.org. The link came by a text message the auditors later deleted under their retention schedule.Audit 2025-28; a tip came in (records response)
Oct. 15, 2025A Jordan list of 4- and 5-rated books goes to Ivory’s campaign email.A tip came in
Feb. 2026Bag of Bones becomes the 23rd title removed statewide.KPCW
April 29, 2026Stephens thanks the State School Board “for removing 2 more books”; Board Member Brinton replies “Thank you!!”A tip came in
Aug. 4, 2026Mike Green sends Emily Green a survey draft that names RatedBooks.org; she sends a revised version to staff.A tip came in; USBE bio
Aug. 6, 2026The board adds Green’s addendum (10–5) and memo (13–1–1) and approves $60,000 (11–2–1).Approved minutes
What these records do not show: who the “concerned legislator” is; who wrote the survey draft or how; whether Jordan School District itself removed Bag of Bones; or why anyone voted the way they did. Those are listed under Not confirmed yet and Questions to ask.

The State School Board’s District 2 seat has been empty since Joseph Kerry resigned in September 2026. The Nov. 5, 2026 agenda opens with the oath of office for a new member, not named on the agenda (Nov. 5 agenda). Emily Green, Christina Boggess and Cindy Davis leave the board in January 2027.

How the official records list Brooke Stephens

The same person shows up under different titles depending on the record. Each row is how that record itself names her.

DateRecordHow she is listed
March 2022Salt Lake TribuneCurriculum director, Utah Parents United
Jan. 23, 2024House Education Committee minutes (H.B. 29)“Brooke Stephens, Educator Director, Utah Parents United”
Feb. 9, 2024Senate Education Committee minutes (H.B. 29)“Brooke Stevens, citizen” (spelled that way in the minutes)
Feb. 5, 2025House Business committee minutes“Brooke Stephens, Utah Moms for America”
May 16, 2025Utah business registry, RatedBooks.orgIncorporator, president, director and registered agent
May 2026KUTV“civic education director for Utah Moms for America”

Committee minutes come from the Legislature’s posted minutes; copies came in with a tip. A different title in each record is not by itself a problem; it shows which group she spoke for each time.

How the survey got to the board

These emails came in with a tip. They show the path of one survey draft in the two days before the Aug. 6 vote. Times are Utah time.

flowchart TD A["Aug. 4, 10:25 a.m.
Emily Green emails Mike
the board’s June 5 timeline"] --> B["12:17 p.m.
Mike Green replies:
“Survey Draft,” a Word file,
no message"] B --> C["4:57 p.m.
Emily Green sends a revised
survey and memo text to staff
and the board chair"] C --> D["5:27 to 5:34 p.m.
She sends it to the other
14 board members
in three emails"] C --> E["Aug. 5, 2:34 p.m.
Staff send back formatted
copies; the memo’s last
paragraph is removed"] E --> F["Aug. 6
Board votes 10–5 to add
the survey and 13–1–1
to add the memo"]

Each box is one email or one vote in the records. The emails do not show who wrote the draft or how.

The memo text, sentence by sentence

On Aug. 4 at 4:57 p.m., Emily Green sent staff 14 sentences of suggested memo text. We compared each one with the cover memo in Mike Green’s 12:17 p.m. draft. “Same” means the words match, apart from hyphens.

The count: 12 of the 14 sentences are the same. The other 2 are close. Both copies came in with a tip.
#How the sentence startsCompared with Mike Green’s draft
1In June the Board approved a 26-week review of how library materials enter…Same
2The attached instrument is offered to strengthen that data collection.Same
3It is drafted for staff refinement and committee discussion, not as a final form.Same
4The instrument does three things the current outline does not yet do fully.Same
5First, it translates the review’s objectives into the industry’s own working terms…Close Same words; the memo uses a colon and adds “etc” where the draft uses dashes.
6Second, it follows the money in both directions…Same
7Third, it pairs nearly every question with a verifiable record…Same
8This approach extends the Office of the Legislative Auditor General’s 2025 work.Same
9The June 2025 performance audit of sensitive materials in schools…Same
10This review examines precisely that front end…Same
11The questions are deliberately neutral, factual, and grounded in Utah’s content standards.Same
12They ask what is bought, from whom, under what terms, with whose money…Same
13That drafting discipline protects respondents, produces comparable data…Close The memo stops before the draft’s ending: “which matters all the more with federal litigation over H.B. 29 now pending.”
14Requested committee action: review the sections below…Same

Matching words show where the text came from in the records. They do not show who wrote the draft or why.

Who gives money to the board

State School Board members run for office, and their campaigns must report who gives them money. We searched every campaign report on file for all 15 members who voted on Aug. 6, from 2018 to Oct. 31, 2026. The table shows how each member voted on Emily Green’s addendum, the groups (not single people) that gave them the most, and any ties to charter schools.

How to read this: getting money from a group does not mean a member votes the way the group wants. Groups often give to people who already agree with them. These are facts listed side by side, not a claim that money caused any vote. Most of each member’s money came from individual people, who are not listed here.
Board memberVote on Green addendumGroups that gave the mostCharter-school ties in the records
Cole KelleyYesUtah County Republican Party $4,000None found
Randy BootheYesGoverning Group PAC $15,425; Education First Utah $7,500; Utah Education Association PAC $6,100; Friends of Spencer Cox $3,700None found
Cindy DavisYesUtah Education Association $5,000; Education First Utah $2,000None found
Jennie EarlYesSEL Inc. $800; Shed Development LLC $500; Box Elder Republican Party $500Gave $300 to Utah Charter PAC (May 22, 2026)
Erin LongacreYesGoverning Group $974.27; Doers Network $500Carolyn Sharette $1,500 (Sept. 30, 2026)
Emily GreenYes (wrote the addendum)The Carolyn Sharette Trust $2,500 (her largest group gift); Bulloch Building LLC $300The Carolyn Sharette Trust $2,500 (April 8, 2022)
Rod HallYesDavis County Republican Party $15,000; Utah Republican Party $3,500; Weber County Republican Party $2,700; two realtor groups $2,500 eachk12 Management Inc. $1,000 (Oct. 23, 2024). A company by that name runs online charter schools; not confirmed it is the same one. Brooke Stephens gave $40.
Joseph Kerry (resigned Sept. 2026)YesWheel05 Management Inc. $500; Utah Forward PAC $500; Rep. Karianne Lisonbee’s campaign $245.15Carolyn Sharette $500 (2024), $261.28 and $1,000 (2026), plus $522.23 (2025) later taken off his reports; Kim Coleman, co-founder of Monticello Academy, $100 (2024)
Joann BrintonYesElect Mike Schultz LLC $5,000; State GOP $2,500; Iron County GOP $2,000; The Freedom Network $750Carolyn Sharette $500 (March 20, 2024)
Christina BoggessYesNo state campaign account found under her nameCarolyn Sharette $500 (May 2, 2024), on Sharette’s own donor reports
Matt Hymas (board chair)NoAdams Leadership PAC $5,000; Brad Wilson’s campaign $5,000; Education First Utah $5,000; Utah Taxpayers Association $3,700; Utah Association of Realtors $3,000Carolyn Sharette $500 (April 1, 2024); Envision Education LLC $2,500 (Oct. 12, 2020; see “Not confirmed yet”)
Carol LearNoEducation First Utah $4,500; Utah Education Association $3,700; Ruby Mt. Inc. $3,000None found
Amanda BollingerNoEducation First Utah $5,000; Governing Group PAC $1,000None found
Sarah RealeNoHer own past city council campaign $4,944.18; Education First Utah $2,000; Planned Parenthood Action Council PAC $1,500; Utah Tech Leads PAC $1,433None found
LeAnn WoodNoGoverning Group PAC $12,490.42; Education First Utah $7,541.89 (two entries); Davis County Republican Party $2,500None found

Carolyn Sharette’s giving, by date

State campaign records list Carolyn Sharette, superintendent of American Preparatory Academy, and The Carolyn Sharette Trust as giving to six of the board members who voted on Aug. 6. Here are the gifts in date order, with the vote marked where it falls.

DateBoard memberAmountVote on Green addendum
April 8, 2022Emily Green (from The Carolyn Sharette Trust)$2,500Yes
March 20, 2024Joann Brinton$500Yes
April 1, 2024Matt Hymas$500No
May 2, 2024Christina Boggess$500Yes
May 27, 2024Joseph Kerry$500Yes
April 15, 2026Joseph Kerry$261.28Yes
July 20, 2026Joseph Kerry$1,000Yes
Aug. 6, 2026: the board votes 10–5 to add Green’s survey questions
Sept. 30, 2026Erin Longacre$1,500Yes
How to read this: these are dates side by side, not a claim that money caused any vote. Matt Hymas got a gift and voted no. Erin Longacre’s gift is dated after the vote. In the state’s Oct. 9, 2026 export, her row is the only one without a “filed” mark; we have not confirmed what that blank means. A separate $522.23 to Joseph Kerry (2025) was later taken off his reports and is not counted here.

Source: Utah campaign finance exports (disclosures.utah.gov), selected rows. The 2022 and 2024 rows were captured Sept. 13, 2026; the 2026 rows Oct. 9, 2026.

What the table shows

The two lawmakers

LawmakerBillsGroups that gave the most
Rep. Ken IvoryPrimary sponsor of H.B. 374 (2022), H.B. 29 (2024) and H.B. 517 (2026)Utah House Republican Election PAC $35,500; House Speaker Leadership PAC $33,500; Wilson Leadership PAC $10,000; Goldback Inc. $7,500; Utah Association of Realtors $6,000. Brooke Stephens gave $50 (July 16, 2024).
Rep. Nicholeen PeckPrimary sponsor of H.B. 473 (2025) and H.B. 197 (2026)Tooele County Republican Party $3,100; Utah House Republican Committee PAC $2,500; House Speaker Leadership PAC $1,000; Utah House Republican Election Committee PAC $1,000; Republican Women Lead $1,000.

Source: each member’s and lawmaker’s campaign reports, downloaded year by year from disclosures.utah.gov on Oct. 31, 2026. Group totals add up every gift from that group in those reports; entries marked deleted are left out. Christina Boggess has no state campaign account under her name; her $500 comes from the donor’s own reports. Home addresses are left off this page.

Graded by the collective rubric

This isn’t a personal opinion. Every Hive case file asks the same five questions: Who holds the power? Can the public see what happened? Is the money accounted for? What does it do to the land and water? What does it do to the community? The law itself (H.B. 29) is graded separately. It is graded on the Bill Tracker page: C− overall. Here, the State School Board’s Aug. 6, 2026 action is graded on what the minutes show.

QuestionGradeWhy
PowerCThe full elected board voted on each change, with recorded names.
TransparencyDSeveral public checks are weaker than they should be, all from the record: the addendum and memo were added by amendment at the meeting, and we did not find either among the files on the meeting’s public notice (notice page); the memo is labeled “for staff refinement and committee discussion, not as a final form”; the board’s own Nov. 6 agenda says “no official survey questions … have been shared publicly” (Nov. 6 agenda); the copy of the minutes on the state’s public notice site is still the unapproved version, which lists one member on both sides of a vote (the approved minutes on the board’s own site fix it); and the memo says “the Board approved” the review in June, when the June vote was a committee’s. Why not an F: the item was on the posted agenda, every vote was taken in public with names, and the minutes and recording are posted, so we can’t point to a step the law requires that was skipped. (Copies of emails from a tip show a paragraph was removed from the memo before it was posted; that is not counted in this grade because it is not a public record.)
Financial accountabilityCThe $60,000 and its source (board discretionary funds) are stated in the motion.
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactCNot yet known who the review will survey or how; the plan was still to be refined by staff.
OverallC−Power C, Transparency D, Financial C, Community C: average 1.75, just under a C. It meets the basic requirements, but the public can’t yet see what the $60,000 review will ask.

A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions; N/A is left out. A grade can change when approved minutes or the final review plan are posted. Grades are the publisher’s rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What would make this clearer for the public

These ideas come from gaps in the public record, not from either side of the book debate. They would help people who want more books removed and people who want fewer, because both would be able to see what is happening.

1. One public list with dates and schoolsThe state’s yearly reports list which districts removed each book (USBE 2025 report). One running public list showing every school, the date it acted, and the book, including any charter school, would let anyone check how the statewide rule was reached. Who could do it: the State School Board.
2. Challenge counts for every districtHow many challenges each district gets, and from how many different people, is not posted by the state. KUTV found most removals start in one district (KUTV). Who could do it: each district, or the Legislature by law.
3. Name who made the 186-title listState auditors worked from a 186-title list that, KSL reports, an unnamed lawmaker made and rated (KSL). Knowing who made a list the state relied on is basic public information. Who could do it: the Legislature or its auditors.
4. Check charter schools tooThe state audit did not review charter schools, because the law only requires district audits (state audit). Charter schools are public schools paid with tax money. Who could do it: the Legislature, by changing the audit law.
5. Post the final survey before it goes outThe board adopted the addendum’s memo “for staff refinement and committee discussion, not as a final form” (USBE minutes). Posting the final questions, and what the $60,000 pays for, before districts answer would let the public see what is being asked. Who could do it: the State School Board.
6. Post the approved minutes everywhereThe board approved its Aug. 6 minutes on Sept. 4, 2026, and the approved version on its own website counts every vote correctly (approved minutes). The copy on the state’s public notice site is still an unapproved version that lists one member on both sides of a vote and counts 16 votes on a 15-member board (notice-site copy). The public notice site is where many people look first. Who could do it: the State School Board, by posting the approved version there.
7. A clear path to a “put it back” voteOnly the State School Board can return a book to every school. We did not find a posted process or schedule for how a book gets that vote, or a record of one ever happening. Who could do it: the State School Board.
8. Post what each book bill costsA fiscal note is the Legislature’s estimate of what a bill costs. Five of the six book bills have not had theirs read for the Hive’s Bill Tracker yet, so their money grades are blank. Who can help: the Legislature posts them on each bill page; the Hive will add them.
9. Show what the state pays to defend the lawH.B. 29 has the state cover claims against people who follow it, and a federal lawsuit over the law is underway (Deseret News). A public total of what defending the law costs would answer the money question. Who could do it: the Attorney General’s Office or the Legislature.
10. Say whether districts get paidAn email that came in with a tip has one member saying schools in the study “will be compensated.” The board’s posted timeline counts 789 hours of district staff time but says nothing about payment (timeline). Who could do it: the State School Board.

What the public still can’t see

Records requests were made for the steps in this story. This table shows what each office sent back, what it kept back and why. The responses came in with a tip.

OfficeWhat was asked forWhat came back
State auditors (Oct. 27, 2026)The list the “concerned legislator” gave them, and how it reached themNo original: the text message with the ratedbooks.org link “was deleted” under the record-keeping schedule. The response does not say who sent it or when.
State auditorsThe pool of books they picked from, and the shuffled listBoth exist and were withheld.
State auditorsRecords of how they received and used the listTwo records exist and were withheld; the office said releasing one “would interfere with audit efforts.”
Legislature’s lawyers (Oct. 30, 2026)Drafting records for H.B. 197 and its QR-code languageOne record released with parts blacked out; one record held back. Both, the office said, would show a legislator’s plans before the bill was public.
State School BoardEmails with its lawyers that mention RatedBooksNone found.
Jordan School DistrictThe Bag of Bones decisionIts report to the state gives a final finding but no decision date.

A record being withheld is allowed by law when it fits a listed exception. We list what was kept back so readers can see what is still unknown, not to suggest anything was done wrong.

Not confirmed yet

Words to know

Tap a card to see what it means.

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

You can ask these at a public meeting, by email, or in public comment. Find your State School Board member on the board district map, and your state representative and senator on the Utah Legislature’s website.

Your State School Board memberWhen an outside group asks a board member to act, how is that disclosed? Has the board ever voted to overturn a statewide removal? How does a book get on the agenda for that vote? Which districts said yes to the library review by Oct. 16? Will the final survey questions be posted before they go out? What will the $60,000 pay for? Who wrote the Aug. 4 survey draft, and will the review use content-rating sites such as RatedBooks.org? Will the board post its approved Aug. 6 minutes on the state’s public notice site?
Your local school boardHow many book challenges has our district received in the last two years, from how many different people, and how many were removed without a review committee? Did our district join the state’s library review?
The Governor’s officeWho are the three nominees for the State School Board’s District 2 seat, and when will the appointee be named?
Jordan School District boardWhat happened to the Bag of Bones reconsideration request Brian Barnett filed Aug. 16, 2025?
Your charter school’s boardHas our school taken any books off its shelves under the sensitive-materials law? Does it report those to the state?
Your state representative and senatorWho was the “concerned legislator” who gave state auditors the ratedbooks.org list in 2025, and who sent the text message with the link? Should texts that start a state audit be kept? Who compiled and rated the 186-title list the state auditors used in October 2025? Should a legislator be able to ask a school board member to file a book challenge the legislator can’t file? Should state auditors check charter schools too? Should the state post a dated list of every removal and which schools made it?
The Lieutenant Governor’s elections officeIs Utah Parents in Action PAC still active, and what has it reported? (Anyone can look up who gives to a candidate at disclosures.utah.gov.)

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

70
Sources listed
7
Board votes recorded
10
Contributions traced
17
Campaign accounts searched
6
Bills behind it

Posted Oct. 31, 2026. Public records and news reports only; no comment was requested from anyone. Campaign records searched Oct. 31, 2026. Updated Nov. 1, 2026: corrected the “include” vs. “consider” vote to the approved minutes (6–9), corrected the June 5 committee vote (4–1), and added “How one book list moved” and “How Utah compares to other states.” Nothing earlier was removed. Second update, Nov. 1, 2026: corrected the IRS letter date to Aug. 5, 2025 (it was listed as June 30, the date in the IRS file name; the letter itself is printed Aug. 5); recounted the memo sentences that match Mike Green’s draft (12 of 14, not 8 of 16); and added Jordan School District’s report to the State School Board on Bag of Bones, which came in with a tip. Update, Nov. 17, 2026: added “Each step, its deadline, and the record it leaves,” read from Utah Code § 53G-10-103 and State School Board rule R277-628; corrected the “Objective” box in the chart and the matching “Words to know” card to the rule (old wording kept in the correction note); added the Sept. 15, 2026 court ruling to the timeline; added two “Words to know” cards and seven sources. Nothing earlier was removed.

Sources (tap to open)
  1. Utah State Board of Education minutes, Aug. 6, 2026 (approved Sept. 4, 2026; board website)
  2. Aug. 6, 2026 minutes, copy on the Utah Public Notice Website (marked pending approval)
  3. USBE Standards and Assessment Committee summary of actions, June 5, 2026
  4. Office of the Legislative Auditor General, Report 2025-28, A Review of School Library Books, Oct. 2025
  5. Deseret News, open letter by Brooke Stephens and Gloria Vindas, Feb. 22, 2024
  6. H.B. 197 (2026) School Materials Amendments, bill page and status
  7. Utah Division of Corporations business registry: RatedBooks.org, S&S Apps, LLC, Utah Parents United (read Oct. 31, 2026)
  8. IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search: Rated Books, EIN 39-2728966 (read Oct. 31, 2026)
  9. USBE board biography, Emily Green
  10. The Globe (SLCC), Utah’s statewide removal list, Oct. 30, 2026
  11. Texas Public Radio, PEN America reports record school book bans, Oct. 9, 2026
  12. FOX 9, how many books were banned in your state, Oct. 16, 2026
  13. SC Daily Gazette, 10 more books must be removed, May 6, 2025
  14. ACLU of South Carolina, SCASL v. Weaver (updated May 29, 2026)
  15. WBTV, South Carolina leads nation after 10 more banned, May 7, 2025
  16. PEN America, The Bills Igniting Book Bans
  17. PEN America, Books banned in Utah
  18. Book Riot on the Washington Post challenge analysis, May 25, 2023
  19. Copies of 2025–2026 emails among Rep. Ken Ivory, Brooke Stephens and Jordan School District board members, from a tip (not public postings)
  20. Copies of April–May 2026 emails among Brooke Stephens, Rep. Ken Ivory, Board Member Joann Brinton and State Superintendent Molly Hart, from a tip (not public postings)
  21. Records responses from the Legislative Auditor General (Oct. 27, 2026), the State School Board (Sept. 14, 2026), the State Charter School Board (Aug. 11, 2026) and Legislative Research and General Counsel (Oct. 30, 2026), from a tip
  22. USBE action item, Sensitive Materials Model Policy Update and timeline
  23. H.B. 374 (2022) bill page
  24. H.B. 29 (2024) bill page
  25. KSL, Cox signs H.B. 29, March 18, 2024
  26. Deseret News, H.B. 29 committee hearing, Jan. 23, 2024
  27. Salt Lake Tribune, Utah Parents United, March 23, 2022
  28. KUTV, Davis mom challenges 27 books, Sept. 30, 2022
  29. Axios, Little Free Libraries, Oct. 4, 2024
  30. KSL, state audit of 22 books, Oct. 14, 2025
  31. KPCW, Bag of Bones 23rd statewide removal, Feb. 18, 2026
  32. KUTV, most bans trace to one district, May 1, 2026
  33. Salt Lake Tribune, statewide list at 36, July 13, 2026
  34. TownLift, seven titles added, 44 total, Oct. 1, 2026
  35. KUER, the 44 titles and their districts, Oct. 9, 2026
  36. Book Riot, Bag of Bones districts, Feb. 17, 2026
  37. Utah Lieutenant Governor, campaign disclosures (contributor search for “Brooke Stephens,” 2018–2026, Oct. 31, 2026)
  38. Ballotpedia, Rod Hall
  39. Ballotpedia, Cari Bartholomew
  40. Ballotpedia, Diane Livingston
  41. Ballotpedia, Austin Hepworth
  42. Wikipedia, 2026 Utah State Board of Education election
  43. KPCW/Salt Lake Tribune, $60K review, Aug. 31, 2026
  44. KUTV, $60,000 review, Oct. 14, 2026
  45. Salt Lake Tribune editorial, Sept. 4, 2026
  46. Salt Lake Tribune, Longacre appointed, Aug. 1, 2025
  47. Deseret News, ACLU of Utah sues over H.B. 29, Jan. 6, 2026
  48. Fox13, lawsuit’s first hearing, May 13, 2026
  49. USBE board meeting agenda, Nov. 5, 2026
  50. USBE committee meetings agenda, Nov. 6, 2026 (School Library Monitoring Review item)
  51. Utah State Board of Education draft minutes, Aug. 6, 2026 (earlier posting)
  52. USBE Law and Licensing Committee summary, July 14, 2026
  53. USBE Standards and Assessment Committee memo, Sensitive Materials Policy, June 5, 2026
  54. USBE, School Library Monitoring Timeline (Aug. 6, 2026 meeting packet)
  55. USBE Standards and Assessment Committee meeting notice, May 18, 2026
  56. USBE Aug. 6, 2026 meeting notice (attachments list)
  57. Copies of emails between board members and staff, May–Aug. 2026, from a tip (not public postings)
  58. USBE, 2024 Sensitive Instructional Materials Legislative Report
  59. USBE, 2025 Sensitive Instructional Materials Legislative Report
  60. Office of the Legislative Auditor General, H.B. 29 follow-up audit, Oct. 2025
  61. Utah Lieutenant Governor, campaign reports for 15 State School Board members, Rep. Ken Ivory and Rep. Nicholeen Peck, 2018–2026, downloaded Oct. 31, 2026
  62. Bill Tracker: Utah’s School Book Laws, 2022–2026 (all six bills, roll calls)
  63. Utah Legislature roll calls, read Oct. 31, 2026 (listed on the Bill Tracker page)
  64. Utah Code § 53G-10-103, Sensitive instructional materials (effective May 7, 2025)
  65. Utah Admin. Code R277-628, Sensitive Materials Review (effective Aug. 7, 2024)
  66. Utah Code § 76-5c-207, fixed descriptions used in the objective test
  67. Utah Code § 63G-2-201, GRAMA: records are public unless a law says otherwise
  68. Legislative Auditor General, A Performance Audit of Sensitive Materials in Schools, Report 2025-11 (June 2025)
  69. Caged Bird Legacy, LLC v. Brown, No. 2:26-cv-00010, memorandum decision and order, Sept. 15, 2026 (copy posted by Courthouse News)
  70. KPCW, Sept. 17, 2026: lawsuit can continue, judge says
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

This page states what public records and news reports say; it does not reach any legal conclusion.

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Education docket · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack