The short version: The springs in Hansel Valley sit on active faults. The 1934 earthquake turned springs on and off there. Next door, groundwater pumping has been tied to a spring's decline. The water filing for this project argues that other water users won't be harmed. We found no study, in that filing or anywhere public, of what the project could mean for the faults, the springs over a full year, the valley's heat, its noise, or its weather.
What this file is not: It doesn't say the project will cause earthquakes, dry up the springs or make tornadoes. It lays out what the record shows and where the record is empty.
New to this? Read the plain-words version first. It covers the same findings in short, simple steps.
- The filing
- Map
- Springs and faults
- What the filing says
- Next door
- Heat and weather
- Air and noise
- What a regulator would check
- The laws
- Who checked
- The grade
- People
- Questions to ask
- Sources
01What is being asked
On Oct. 15, 2026, change application a55167 was filed with the Utah Division of Water Rights on water right 13-2. The right is owned by Bar H Ranch, Inc. The state record lists O'Leary Digital Utah DC Sub I, LLC as under contract to buy it and as responsible for the application.[1]
| Item | Today | Requested |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Salt Wells Spring Stream, Hansel Valley | Same, by "Pump drawing water from existing pond" |
| Amount | 4 cfs (1,712 acre-feet) | 4 cfs or 1,712 acre-feet |
| Water budget in the filing | Depletion from irrigation estimated at 918 to 1,038 acre-feet a year (2016–2025) | The developer's engineer projects 1,215.29 acre-feet a year diverted, about 228.74 returned and 986.55 used up. The application offers to cap depletion at 1,009 acre-feet. These are the applicant's estimates; the State Engineer hasn't ruled on them.[3] |
| Use | Irrigation, April 1 to Oct. 31 | "Wonder Valley Power," a steam power plant rated at 7,500 MW, plus a data center campus, Jan. 1 to Dec. 31 |
| Priority | Water used since 1904 | Change priority Oct. 15, 2026 |
Protest deadline: Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2026. Nov. 4 to 11 is when the legal notice runs in The Tremonton Leader; that is not the deadline. Protests are filed online on the Division of Water Rights "Protest of Application" page. The fee is $15 and isn't refundable, and you can ask for a hearing on the form.[1][2]
How we got here
| Date | What the record shows |
|---|---|
| March 25, 2026 | Bar H Ranch files change application a54385 on part of the same water (2.75 cfs, water right 13-4148).[33] |
| April 8–15, 2026 | Legal notice runs in The Tremonton Leader. Protest deadline May 5, 2026.[33] |
| By May 5, 2026 | The state record lists 3,678 protest entries on a54385 (our count of the dated entries on the record page).[33] |
| May 6, 2026 | H.B. 60 applies. It "limits the factors the state engineer can weigh."[30] On public welfare, the State Engineer "may only consider" a plan's effect on "the beneficial use of water" or "the quantity, quality, or availability of water," plus factors other laws direct.[40] |
| May 7, 2026 | a54385 is closed out as withdrawn. The company said it "fully intends to move forward with the project" with a new application.[33][30] |
| Sept. 3, 2026 | Water right 13-4148 is consolidated back into 13-2.[34] |
| Oct. 15, 2026 | a55167 is filed on all of 13-2 (4 cfs), with 196 pages of exhibits. Protests are due Dec. 1.[1] |
What a protest can address now. Since H.B. 60, the State Engineer "may only consider" a plan's effect on "the beneficial use of water" or "the quantity, quality, or availability of water," plus factors other laws direct when weighing public welfare. The State Engineer also may not reject an application on public-welfare grounds for a harm that is "better suited to be addressed by another regulatory agency."[40] The other tests in Utah Code 73-3-8 still apply, including whether the change would impair existing water rights. Protests that speak to water supply, water quality and harm to other water users fit what the State Engineer weighs. Heat, air and noise are handled, if at all, by other agencies (see section 08, "What a regulator would check").
Who else uses this water
The developer's hydrology report lists the other water rights at Salt Wells Flat. Besides Bar H's own rights, they include Bureau of Land Management rights for stock water and for wildlife and wetland enhancement, and small stock-water rights on Salt Wells Stream held by a private ranching company. The report says: "No wells have active or approved water rights with the exception of monitoring wells and cathodic protection wells." One of the eight parcels in the water right's place of use, 636 acres, is federal land managed by the Bureau of Land Management.[3]
02Where things are
Points are placed from the coordinates published in each record. They are approximate. Tap a point for its source.
Text version: Salt Wells Flat (GNIS 1432150) is at about 41.71°N, 112.73°W. The 1934 epicenter is listed at 41.7°N, 112.8°W. The National Weather Service lists two Aug. 16, 1984 tornadoes "between Tremonton and Snowville" at 41°49'N, 112°28'W and 41°39'N, 112°28'W, a 1985 waterspout on the lake at 41°33'N, 112°52'W, two Sept. 19, 1999 tornadoes 20 miles south of Park Valley at 41°37'N, 113°17'W, and the Sept. 10, 1991 Brigham City tornado at 41°31'N, 112°01'W.
03The springs sit on active faults
The water in Salt Wells Spring is groundwater coming to the surface. The developer's own hydrologist says so: "Groundwater discharges through springs," and in the mountains water moves "through permeable fracture zones... discharging to mountain front springs."[3] The older public record shows how those springs behave when the faults move.
flowchart TD A["Rain and snow on the
Hansel and North Promontory
Mountains"] --> B["Water moves through
fracture zones in the rock"] B --> C["Basin-fill aquifer
under the valley"] C --> D["Springs at the edge of
Salt Wells Flat"] D --> E["Pond 1 and Pond 2"] E --> F["Today: irrigation,
April to October"] E --> G["Requested: pumped year-round
to the power plant and
data center campus"] H["Faults: 1934 quake turned
springs and wells on and off"] -.-> B
Text version: Rain and snow in the surrounding ranges move through fractures in the rock into the valley's aquifer and come out at springs on the edge of Salt Wells Flat, where they collect in ponds. Today the water irrigates from April to October. The filing asks to pump it year-round for the power plant and data center. Faults run through this system; in 1934 an earthquake turned springs and wells on and off.
Earthquakes and springs on the record
How many faults does Utah have?
The Utah Geological Survey's statewide database (Map 193DM, 2003) "contains database entries for 212 faults, fault sections, and folds, and one historical surface-faulting earthquake in Utah." That one historical surface-faulting earthquake is Hansel Valley, 1934.[7] The three Hansel faults are rated Class A in the federal fault database.[8]
04What the developer's own filing says
The filing is 196 pages, with three exhibits: a hydrology report (Loughlin Water Associates, Sept. 16, 2026), a water-use report (Beairsto & Associates, Sept. 2026) and a project summary from O'Leary Digital. We read the application, its explanatory statement, and the geology, hydrogeology, field-work and summary sections of the exhibits.[3]
The explanatory statement assumes "fifteen (15) 500 MW combined cycle natural gas power plants." The developer's engineer describes "fifteen 500 MW reciprocating-engine blocks." Utah Clean Energy's estimates for a 9 GW gas buildout run about 1,857 tons of nitrogen oxides a year for combined-cycle turbines and about 12,000 tons for reciprocating engines.[3][13]
The explanatory statement gives its own reason: the developer "has not finalized its exact power generation plans," so "for purposes of the Application, it is assuming all fifteen (15) power plants will be combined-cycle natural gas power plants."[3]
The engineer: "Cooling Tower Evaporation Remains a Consumptive Component." The plan uses 61,024 gallons a day, including 10,171 gallons a day of blowdown. "If blowdown is routed to a non-returning disposal pathway or return-flow credit is not accepted, depletion would increase accordingly." The explanatory statement says the developer "may ultimately be able to treat blow-down water for discharge." The engineer's summary goes further: "Treated sanitary effluent and separately treated cooling-tower blowdown are presently planned for permitted surface-water discharge; the receiving water and final outfall remain to be confirmed." The engines run on about 2.87 million gallons a day of process water, about 90% recycled on site. The report is marked "ISSUED FOR PLANNING — NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION."[3]
The engineer's stated scope: "Potable water balance; irrigation and data-center cooling demand; engine process-water recycle and treatment losses; sanitary wastewater." Drinking-water demand is figured for "the full campus population of 4,850 employees." The project's development standards also allow hotels (the draft interlocal caps them at 150 rooms), restaurants, RV parks and homes in mixed-use zones. We found no line for those in the scope or summary pages we read; we did not read every page of the report.[3][27]
The hydrology report's geology section says: "The Hansel Valley and adjacent ranges are separated by normal faults. The offset across these faults is not specified by Doelling et al. (1980)." It doesn't mention the 1934 earthquake.[3]
The project summary describes "geotechnical soil borings across the Project area, an aerial LiDAR survey... and a master-plan overlay of the boring data that maps buildable versus non-buildable soil." Its list of physical impediments covers land, soil, water scarcity and construction disturbance. Faults and earthquakes aren't on it.[3]
The hydrologist measured stream and spring flows on two visits, in June and July 2026, and a single pond level from June 5 to July 15, 2026. "Not all locations were revisited in July 2026 due to health and safety concerns due to high forecasted temperatures." Groundwater depths in the report come from older drilling logs and Hood's 1971 study. The filing notes the work came "despite the 2026 snowpack being the lowest on record in Utah history."[3]
Citing Hood (1971), the hydrologist reports total spring discharge in the valley of about 5.5 cfs, "which includes 4 cfs from Salt Wells Spring group." Outside the growing season, about 2,400 acre-feet a year of unconsumed spring flow left Hansel Valley (Hood, 1971). The requested use runs all year.[3][9]
The power system "is modeled at continuous full-build operation, 24 hr/day and 365 days/year." The plan counts 4,850 employees and 11 data center clusters. A federal Title V air permit is "targeted for Q2 2027."[3]
05What happened next door
Curlew Valley, just north and west of Hansel Valley, has a longer water record.
The water level in the first irrigation well near Kelton "had declined about 25 feet (7.6 m) since the well was put into operation in 1954," by spring 1967. In the older rocks, "the abundant faults, fractures, and associated solution openings form the principal conduits through which water moves."[10]
"The State Engineer has placed a moratorium on approvals of any new application in the Curlew Valley," with no action on pending applications "until additional studies can be made and the effect of the present development be determined on the ground-water basin."[11]
A Utah Geological Survey study found that "a substantial increase in ground-water pumping for agriculture over the past 40 years, combined with lower-than-average precipitation during the past 10 years, are the most likely causes of the declining discharge at Locomotive Springs."[12]
06Heat and weather
Heat
USU physics professor Robert Davies has published back-of-the-envelope estimates of about 16 gigawatts of heat released in Hansel Valley at full buildout. Reported results range from 2–5°F warmer days and 8–12°F warmer nights (ABC4, May 7, 2026) to "as much as 28 degrees Fahrenheit" warmer nights (Grist, May 18, 2026). The Christian Science Monitor quotes him calling it one of the largest single-site heat sources on Earth. Gov. Cox and the project's backers have called his estimates inaccurate.[38] No heat study from the developer or a state agency has been made public.[14][15][16]
Already too hot to finish the field work. The developer's own hydrologist could not revisit every monitoring site in July 2026 "due to health and safety concerns due to high forecasted temperatures."[3] That was the valley as it is today, before any power plant or data center. The project plans 4,850 employees and power generation 24 hours a day. No study we found asks what added heat would mean for the people who would work there, or for the ranches and livestock around them.
The lake already shapes storms
A National Severe Storms Laboratory paper calls the Great Salt Lake breeze "a focusing mechanism for thunderstorms."[17] The National Weather Service says that before the Aug. 11, 1999 Salt Lake City tornado, "either an old frontal boundary existed or a convergence zone had developed" from "breezes from the Great Salt Lake meeting up with the southerly winds."[18] Radar researchers found the tornado formed as "an updraft formed over weak rotation along a pre-existing boundary layer convergence line."[19] That F2 tornado killed one person, injured more than 80 and caused about $172 million in damage.[20]
Box Elder's own tornado record
| Date | Where (as listed) | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| July 9, 1962 | Grouse Creek Valley | On the ground about 15 minutes |
| Aug. 14, 1968 | Near Collingston | Over 4 miles, into Cache Valley |
| June 5, 1970 | About 50 miles west of Hill AFB | Remote area, no damage reported |
| Aug. 16, 1984 | Between Tremonton and Snowville | Two tornadoes, four minutes apart |
| Oct. 22, 1985 | Great Salt Lake | Waterspout, about 700 feet high |
| Aug. 25, 1987 | Just west of Plymouth | Touched down briefly |
| Aug. 24, 1989 | Willard Bay | Waterspout, about 7 minutes |
| Sept. 10, 1991 | Southeast Brigham City, near 100 East and 400 North | About 20 trees uprooted or damaged, a shed destroyed, siding peeled off a house |
| Sept. 19, 1999 | 20 miles south of Park Valley | Two F0 tornadoes at once |
| May 3, 2009 | Willard | EF0, about a mile; trees uprooted, siding torn off homes |
| May 17, 2018 | Snowville | Funnel cloud reported |
| May 28, 2018 | Box Elder County | EF0 |
Sources: NWS Salt Lake City tornado climatology (through 2004), NOAA Storm Events data via TornadoPath, KSL.[21][22][23][24] The NWS list stops after 2004; later events may be missing.
What hasn't been studied: The lake already sets up the kind of boundary the 1999 tornado formed on, and Box Elder has its own tornado and waterspout record. We found no study of what adding a heat source of about 16 gigawatts near the lake's north shore would do to storms there. Tornadoes also need the right wind shear, so whether this setup would add to them is an open question, not a finding.
On Aug. 11, 1999, I took the kids I was caring for to the basement in Pleasant View when the Salt Lake City tornado hit. — Shauna Miller
07Air and noise
A study EmPower Analytics Group did for the Natural Resources Defense Council, reported Oct. 28, 2026, estimates up to 45 premature deaths a year and up to $690 million a year in health costs at a full, mostly gas buildout of about 9 GW. Gov. Cox has said Phase 1 won't exceed 1.5 GW.[25] In May 2026, the state's environmental quality director said a year of background air monitoring must come before an air permit application, and that the Wasatch Front "is already out of compliance with the Clean Air Act."[26]
On noise, the draft, unsigned interlocal agreement for the project area sets limits of 55 dB(A) by day and 45 dB(A) at night "at any residential home outside the boundary of the Project Area." No noise study has been made public.[27]
08What a regulator would check
The laws that changed the rules
From 2025 to 2026, the Legislature passed laws that change who reviews a project like this and what the public can challenge. Some narrow a check, some add one. The Legislature's own August 2026 handout is titled "No single agency approves a data center." It says MIDA "exercises land-use authority under its project-area plans and development standards rather than the ordinary municipal or county land-use process," and that "separately applicable state and federal requirements continue to apply."[49] Here is what each enacted bill says, from the bill text.
| Law (primary sponsor / Senate or House sponsor) | What it does | What it doesn't do |
|---|---|---|
| H.B. 60 (2026), Water Rights Amendments (Rep. David Shallenberger / Sen. Keven Stratton). Effective May 6, 2026. | On public welfare, the State Engineer "may only consider" a plan's effect on "the beneficial use of water" or "the quantity, quality, or availability of water," plus factors other laws direct. The State Engineer may not reject on public-welfare grounds a harm "better suited to be addressed by another regulatory agency." It also changes who counts as an aggrieved person for court review.[40] | It doesn't remove the other tests, such as whether a change would impair existing water rights. |
| S.B. 132 (2025), Electric Utility Amendments (Sen. Scott Sandall / Rep. Colin Jack) | Lets a large power user contract for all its electricity through a "closed private generation system." Those systems "are exempt from commission oversight or regulation as a public utility" and must stay separate from utility grids unless the Public Service Commission approves a contract.[41] | It's about utility regulation. Air, water and other environmental permits come from other laws.[49] |
| H.B. 76 (2026), Data Center Water Transparency Amendments (Rep. Jill Koford / Sen. Scott Sandall). Effective May 6, 2026. | A data center using 75 acre-feet a year or more, counting its cooling and its own power generation, must report expected water use 90 to 360 days before construction, then actual use every year. Water Rights publishes the withdrawal figures for each data center. Fines are up to $100 a day for missing reports.[42] | It's a reporting rule, not a study of whether the water supply holds up. Its notice step names city and county land-use authorities, not MIDA.[42] |
| H.B. 437 (2026), Environmental Permitting Amendments (Rep. David Shallenberger / Sen. Ann Millner) | Lets the Department of Environmental Quality and the Division of Oil, Gas, and Mining make rules for an expedited permit review done by certified "qualified reviewers."[43] | The agency still does a technical review and makes the final decision.[43] We found no record that this project has asked for expedited review. |
| H.B. 419 (2026) (Rep. Colin Jack / Sen. David Hinkins) | Adds certain Oil, Gas, and Mining permits to the "environmental action" rule. Under that rule, someone who asks a court to pause a permit must first post a surety bond, and pays damages if they lose.[44] | The bond rule covers court challenges to permits from Natural Resources, Transportation, Trust Lands and now certain Oil, Gas, and Mining permits. It isn't a fee for filing a water protest. |
| S.B. 316 (2025), MIDA and Other Development Zone Amendments (Sen. Jerry Stevenson / Rep. Val Peterson) | Lets MIDA make agreements with the state, including using revenue from outside a project area when the project area is on state land, and lets a MIDA-created public infrastructure district be a MIDA subsidiary.[45] | The enacted text doesn't make MIDA an environmental reviewer.[45] |
| H.B. 507 (2026) (Rep. Calvin Roberts / Sen. Kirk Cullimore) | Starting May 6, 2027, bars political subdivisions from giving incentives to large data centers, with exceptions. Deals made before then can continue. Creates a protected record category for "confidential economic development information."[46] Full breakdown: our H.B. 507 case file. | It doesn't ban incentives today. Whether it reaches MIDA's Stratos project hasn't been established. |
| H.B. 249 (2025) and H.B. 78 (2026), nuclear bills (Rep. Carl Albrecht / Sen. Ann Millner; Rep. Carl Albrecht / Sen. Derrin Owens) | H.B. 249 sets up "electrical energy development zones" and an investment fund. H.B. 78 creates a Nuclear Energy Regulatory Office and directs the state to seek expanded authority from the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission.[47][48] The project's draft standards list small modular reactors as a permitted use.[27] | Neither approves or licenses a reactor in Hansel Valley. |
More 2026 water and land bills, graded with the same rubric, are in our bill tracker.
Permit by permit
We read this the way an environmental investigator would: which permits and reviews would a project like this normally face, and what does the record show for each, as of Oct. 31, 2026? These are questions, not legal findings.
| Area (agency) | What the record shows | Open question |
|---|---|---|
| Federal land and federal review (BLM, U.S. Air Force) | 636 acres of the water right's place of use are federal land managed by the BLM.[3] The project area also includes about 1,279 acres of military and state land, part of the Utah Test and Training Range.[35] We found no federal environmental review (NEPA) started. | Will any federal approval, such as a right-of-way across BLM land, trigger a federal environmental review? |
| Air (Utah Division of Air Quality; Clean Air Act) | Title V permit "targeted for Q2 2027"; the developer also names Prevention of Significant Deterioration review.[3] DEQ said a year of background air monitoring comes first.[26] The filing names two different engine types. | Has background monitoring started? Which engine type is being permitted? |
| Wastewater discharge (Utah Division of Water Quality; Clean Water Act) | Treated sanitary effluent and cooling-tower blowdown are "presently planned for permitted surface-water discharge; the receiving water and final outfall remain to be confirmed."[3] Hood (1971) found dissolved solids in valley water from about 400 to 94,000 mg/L.[9] We found no discharge permit application. | Where would the discharge go, and what limits on salt and other minerals would apply? |
| Wetlands (U.S. Army Corps of Engineers; Clean Water Act Section 404) | The plan includes a 2.5-mile pipeline from the diversion toward the Great Salt Lake.[3] The hydrology report maps swamps and marshes in the Salt Wells Flat area.[3] We found no wetlands permit filing. | Does the pipeline route cross wetlands that need a federal permit? |
| Drinking water (Utah Division of Drinking Water) | The engineer: the owner-reported spring flow "is not a DDW-accepted dependable-yield determination."[3] The water plan serves 4,850 employees. | Has the state confirmed the spring can reliably supply a public water system? |
| Wildlife and birds (Utah Division of Wildlife Resources; U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service) | The Governor's FAQ says wildlife review comes after formal plans are filed.[36] The spring water feeds marshes on the flat and flows toward the Great Salt Lake.[3] | Who will study effects on the marshes and the lake's shorebirds before water is moved? |
| Fuel, chemicals and nuclear (DEQ, emergency planners) | The project's draft development standards list "large-scale fuel storage" and "hazardous material processing or storage facilities" as conditional uses, and small modular reactors as a permitted use.[27] | What fuel and chemicals would be stored on site, and what spill and emergency plans would cover them? |
| Gas line (federal and state pipeline regulators) | The developer says a "dedicated metering facility and lateral connection" to the 42-inch Ruby Pipeline "are being advanced."[3] | Which agency reviews the new gas line and its route? |
| Earthquake design (Utah Geological Survey, building officials) | The Survey was not contacted before approval.[28] No seismic hazard study is public. | Will a site-specific fault and seismic study be required before any power plant is built? |
| Worker safety (Utah OSHA) | The developer's crew cut short July field work over heat.[3] | What heat-safety review covers the 4,850 planned workers? |
The Northern Wasatch Front ozone nonattainment area covers all or part of Salt Lake, Davis, Weber and Tooele counties; Box Elder is not listed.[37] The NRDC-commissioned study says pollution from the project would reach the Wasatch Front.[25]
09Who checked the ground
What the record shows
- MIDA's spokesperson: "the development team did have preliminary geotechnical studies conducted before creating the project area boundary," with "many more studies" to come. Those studies aren't public.[28]
- The Utah Geological Survey said neither MIDA nor Box Elder County contacted it before approving the project. "The Utah Geological Survey is not a regulatory agency."[28]
- MIDA answered a records request for environmental studies by saying it had no responsive records.[29]
- The Utah Geological Survey had three wells drilled at Salt Wells Road in November 2025, two with flowing artesian water.[3]
- H.B. 60 (2026) narrowed what the State Engineer weighs as "public welfare" to effects on the beneficial use of water and on the quantity, quality or availability of water.[40]
- H.B. 76 (2026) added a check that applies to large data centers: report expected water use to the Division of Water Rights before construction, and actual use every year after. The state publishes the withdrawal numbers.[42]
What we couldn't find
- Any public groundwater or spring-flow study of Hansel Valley since 1971.
- Any study of how fault movement could change Salt Wells Spring.
- Lidar fault mapping of Hansel Valley. The Survey's 2026 summary lists it as still needed.[31]
- Any public heat, noise or weather study for the project.
- What the November 2025 Survey wells are monitoring, and whether they record water levels over time.
- Whether H.B. 76's notice step reaches this project. It tells city and county land-use authorities to notify Water Rights and Water Quality before approving a large data center. Here, MIDA is the land-use authority, and the bill's definition doesn't name MIDA. The developer's own reporting duty applies either way.[42][49]
10The grade
We grade every case file on the Hive's five standing questions, the same way every time. The grades are a fixed published standard, not the writer's opinion. This grade covers the a55167 filing and how the project is being reviewed.
| Question | Grade | Why, from the record |
|---|---|---|
| Power | D | H.B. 60 narrowed what the State Engineer can weigh as public welfare. MIDA and the county approved the project area without contacting the Utah Geological Survey. The protest right still exists, so the check is weakened, not removed. |
| Transparency | D | The full 196-page filing is public, a plus. But the "preliminary geotechnical studies" aren't public, the filing describes two different engine types, and the discharge outfall is "to be confirmed." |
| Financial accountability | D | Costs that could land on neighbors, such as the health costs in the NRDC-commissioned estimate and heat on nearby ranches, aren't addressed in the filing, and after H.B. 60 they fall largely outside the water decision. Who would pay is not stated. |
| Environmental impact | F | No public study of the faults, the spring over a full year, the aquifer, heat, noise or weather. The water review's public-welfare test was narrowed, and no agency has been assigned those questions in its place. |
| Community impact | Process C · Effect D | Process: public notice ran and anyone can protest. Effect: ranchers, Snowville and the planned workforce would carry heat, air and water effects that no study has examined. |
| Overall | D− | Average of the five, counting community impact by its effect. |
A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means the record goes beyond it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place.
How this could have been done better
- Publish the developer's geotechnical studies before the water decision.
- Measure the spring and the aquifer through a full year, not two summer visits.
- Ask the Utah Geological Survey for a fault and seismic review before approval.
- Name one engine type and the discharge outfall in the filing.
- Model the heat and its effect on nearby ranches and storms.
- Count water for every allowed use, including hotels, restaurants, RV parks and homes.
How a grade can change: If the studies are published, or the State Engineer requires them before deciding, we'll update the grade with the date.
11People and groups in this record
| Name | Why they're in the record |
|---|---|
| Bar H Ranch, Inc. | Owns water right 13-2 and most of the place-of-use land; signed its authorization for the filing. |
| O'Leary Digital Utah DC Sub I, LLC | Under contract to buy the water right; responsible for the application. Project developer for "Wonder Valley – Stratos" (Kevin O'Leary's project, per FOX 13).[39] |
| Loughlin Water Associates | Wrote the hydrology report (Exhibit A), prepared for Parr Brown Gee & Loveless. |
| Parr Brown Gee & Loveless | Salt Lake City law firm the hydrology report was prepared for. The same firm appears as a paid legal vendor in the No-on-Amendment-B committee's 2026 filings in our Transparency files; we found no connection between the two matters. |
| Beairsto & Associates (Satyam Arya, P.Eng.; reviewed by Dennis Hussey, P.Eng.) | Wrote the water-use report (Exhibit B), "Issued for planning — not for construction." |
| Teresa Wilhelmsen, State Engineer | Decides a55167. |
| MIDA board, chaired by Senate President J. Stuart Adams | Adopted the Stratos project area plan April 24, 2026. MIDA spokesperson Kristin Kenney Williams described the "preliminary geotechnical studies." |
| Rep. David Shallenberger and Sen. Keven Stratton | Primary sponsor and Senate sponsor of H.B. 60 (2026). |
| Adam McKean, Utah Geological Survey | Geologic Hazards Program Manager; said the Survey "is not a regulatory agency." |
| Robert Davies, Utah State University | Physicist whose published heat estimates are cited here. Gov. Cox and project backers have called his estimates inaccurate. |
12Questions to ask, and to whom
- Utah Division of Water Rights · State Engineer (protest by Dec. 1)Will the decision on a55167 consider fault behavior and how Salt Wells Spring flows over a full year, and not only during two summer visits in a record-low snow year?
- Utah Geological SurveyWhat are the three November 2025 wells at Salt Wells Road for, and will their water levels be published?
- MIDA board and Development Review CommitteeWill the developer's "preliminary geotechnical studies" be made public, and will a fault and seismic study be required before any plant is approved?
- Utah Division of Air QualityWhich engine type is being permitted, combined-cycle turbines or reciprocating engines? The filing describes both.
- Utah Labor Commission (Utah OSHA) and MIDAThe developer's own crew stopped some July field work over heat. What heat-safety review will cover the 4,850 workers the plan counts, if the valley gets hotter?
- Box Elder County CommissionHas the county asked for a heat, noise or weather study for the valley and the ranches around it?
- Anyone sharing posts about thisThe protest deadline is Dec. 1, not Nov. 4. Check the state record before passing a date along.
The public record ties Hansel Valley's springs to active faults, shows those springs changing when the ground moved in 1934, and shows pumping linked to a spring's decline next door. The water filing argues no other water user would be harmed. The record we found holds no study of the faults, the springs over a full year, the heat, the noise or the weather for this project.
Behind this piece
Sources and how each was read (49)
Records
- Utah Division of Water Rights, change application a55167 record Web page, read Oct. 31, 2026; protest end date 12/01/2026, publication 11/04–11/11/2026.
- Division of Water Rights, Protest of Application page Web page.
- Change Application a55167, 196 pages with Exhibits A–C (filed Oct. 15, 2026) Scanned PDF read page by page in the browser: form and explanatory (pp. 1–12), Loughlin report geology/hydrogeology/field methods (pp. 14–17, 32–40), Beairsto executive summary (pp. 140–141), O'Leary Digital report (pp. 185–188). Not every page was read.
- University of Utah Seismograph Stations, March 12, 1934 Hansel Valley (series) M6.6 Web page.
- USGS historic earthquake page, abridged from Stover & Coffman, Professional Paper 1527 (1993) Archived web page.
- Major Thermal Springs of Utah, Water-Resources Bulletin 13 (1970) Abstract.
- Black, Hecker, Hylland, Christenson & McDonald, Quaternary Fault and Fold Database and Map of Utah, UGS Map 193DM (2003) Product description.
- USGS Quaternary fault reports 2358, 2359, 2360 Text summaries; 2358 read for Class A, 1934 rupture and recurrence.
- Hood, Hydrologic Reconnaissance of Hansel Valley, Technical Publication 33 (1971) Figures as cited in the Loughlin report and in earlier Hive reading of the PDF.
- Baker, Water Resources of the Curlew Valley Drainage Basin, Technical Publication 45 (1974) Excerpts from the PDF.
- State Engineer, Curlew Valley policy meeting, Sept. 7, 1967 Web page.
- News release, "Geology and Ground Water Chemistry, Curlew Valley," March 30, 2009 PDF text.
- Utah Clean Energy, estimated emissions and water consumption from Stratos Web page.
- ABC4, May 7, 2026, Davies heat estimate Web page.
- Grist (Leia Larsen), May 18, 2026 Web page.
- Christian Science Monitor, Sept. 1, 2026 Web page.
- Vasiloff, NSSL/NWS, detection of the 3 May 2000 lake breeze with the Salt Lake TDWR PDF text.
- National Weather Service Salt Lake City, the Salt Lake City tornado Web page.
- Vasiloff & Dunn, "The 11 August 1999 Salt Lake City tornado," AMS 2000 Abstract.
- 1999 Salt Lake City tornado Web page; used for casualty and damage totals only.
- National Weather Service Salt Lake City, Utah tornado climatology Web page; the list ends in 2004.
- TornadoPath, Box Elder County (NOAA Storm Events data) Web page.
- KSL, "Tornado touches down in Willard," May 4, 2009 Web page.
- KSL, Snowville funnel cloud, May 17, 2018 Web page.
- KPCW, NRDC/EmPower report, Oct. 28, 2026 Web page; NRDC's own pages did not load.
- KSL, May 20, 2026, DEQ on air permitting Web page.
- MIDA, Stratos Interlocal Cooperation Agreement (draft, unsigned), §5(c)–(d), and Stratos Development Standards §3.03(A) Read from the MIDA board package Sept. 4, 2026. MIDA lists it as a draft, unsigned pending the referendum.
- KUTV (Brian Mullahy), May 15, 2026 Web page.
- ABC4, MIDA and environmental studies Web page.
- Standard-Examiner, May 18, 2026, on H.B. 60 Web page.
- Utah Quaternary Fault Parameters Working Group, 2026 summary PDF text, via research summary; check before quoting directly.
- GNIS feature 1432150, Salt Wells Flat (listing); 1934 epicenter coordinates from 1934 Hansel Valley earthquake Coordinates for the map only.
- Utah Division of Water Rights, change application a54385 record Web page, read Oct. 31, 2026; protest entries counted from the dated entries on the page. Names of protesters are not published here.
- Utah Division of Water Rights, water right 13-4148 record Web page, read Oct. 31, 2026.
- MIDA, Stratos Project Area Plan, effective May 4, 2026, Exhibit B (about 1,279 acres of military and state land) Read from the MIDA board package Sept. 4, 2026.
- Office of the Governor, FAQ on the Stratos Project PDF, via research summary.
- Utah DEQ, ozone overview and moderate-area SIP Web page.
- Utah News Dispatch, "Critics call for more details about Stratos data center in Utah's west desert," July 2026 Web page.
- FOX 13, "Kevin O'Leary's data center project re-files water rights application," Oct. 20, 2026 Web page, via earlier reading.
- H.B. 60 (2026), Water Rights Amendments, enrolled text Bill text on le.utah.gov, read Oct. 31, 2026 (Section 73-3-8(7)).
- S.B. 132 (2025), Electric Utility Amendments, enrolled text Bill text on le.utah.gov, read Oct. 31, 2026 (Section 54-26-504).
- H.B. 76 (2026), Data Center Water Transparency Amendments, enrolled text Bill text on le.utah.gov, read in full Oct. 31, 2026.
- H.B. 437 (2026), Environmental Permitting Amendments Bill page on le.utah.gov; long title read Oct. 31, 2026.
- H.B. 419 (2026), and Utah Code 78B-5-828 as amended Bill page and code section on le.utah.gov.
- S.B. 316 (2025), Military Installation Development Authority and Other Development Zone Amendments, enrolled text Bill text on le.utah.gov, read Oct. 31, 2026; searched for environmental review language.
- H.B. 507 (2026), State Coordination of Regional and Local Economic Development Projects Amendments, enrolled text Bill text on le.utah.gov (Section 11-41-202), read Oct. 31, 2026.
- H.B. 249 (2025), Nuclear Power Amendments Bill page on le.utah.gov; long title read Oct. 31, 2026.
- H.B. 78 (2026), Nuclear Regulatory Amendments Bill page on le.utah.gov; long title read Oct. 31, 2026.
- Utah Legislature, "No single agency approves a data center," August 2026 handout (Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment Interim Committee, Aug. 19, 2026) PDF, rendered pages read Oct. 31, 2026.
Public records only. No comment requested. Read Oct. 31, 2026.

