The short version
- In 2023, Keller Cattle Corporation, a 1959 Utah corporation now controlled by House Speaker Mike Schultz, applied for 556.70 acre-feet of new water rights (two applications of 278.35 acre-feet each, 13-4099 and 13-4100) on the Promontory Mountains, seven miles from the Great Salt Lake shore.
- The Utah Rivers Council filed a timely protest and Farmland Reserve Inc. filed a late letter. The State Engineer approved both applications on July 18, 2024, writing that "even though approval may impair existing water rights, the applicant holds those water rights."
- A hearing was held Dec. 14, 2023, in Brigham City, with a hearing report, notes and an audio recording on file. The signed July 18, 2024 Order states that a hearing was not held.
- On Aug. 21, 2023, four days before the applications were filed, Schultz voted as a Utah Inland Port Authority board member to create the Golden Spike project area in Box Elder County, with a $219 million incentive package. He did not recuse, and his 2023 UIPA disclosure lists board positions as "None."
- Schultz was the primary sponsor of H.B. 491, the state's Great Salt Lake water-policy bill. The process followed statutory notice and protest steps; the open questions are about what the signed Order says and does not address.
- Mike Schultz — Speaker of the Utah House since Nov. 2023; registered agent of Keller Cattle Corporation; primary sponsor of H.B. 491
- Keller Cattle Corporation — Utah corporation registered in 1959, acquired by Schultz; owner of both water applications (Roy)
- Teresa Wilhelmsen — Utah State Engineer; signed the July 18, 2024 Order approving both applications
- Witt Atkin — Regional Engineer; presided at the Dec. 14, 2023 hearing in Brigham City
- Zachary Frankel, Utah Rivers Council — Executive Director; filed the only timely protest
- Farmland Reserve Inc. — LDS Church farmland investment arm; holds senior 1940 rights in the same Promontory footprint; asked for scrutiny, did not oppose
- Kyle Palmer — Treasurer of House Speaker Leadership PAC; owner of Irish Elk LLC
What it is
Mike Schultz is the Speaker of the Utah House. He controls a company called Keller Cattle Corporation. It is an old Utah company, first registered in 1959. Schultz did not start it. He bought it.
In 2023, the company asked the state for new water. It filed two applications, 13-4099 and 13-4100. Each one asked for 278.35 acre-feet. Together that is 556.70 acre-feet a year.
The land is on the Promontory Mountains in Box Elder County. It is about seven miles from the shore of the Great Salt Lake.
Schultz was also the primary sponsor of H.B. 491, the state's own Great Salt Lake water bill.
What the records show
- Filed: Aug. 25, 2023. Approved: July 18, 2024, by State Engineer Teresa Wilhelmsen.
- Protests: The Utah Rivers Council filed on time. Farmland Reserve Inc., the LDS Church's farmland arm, sent a late letter.
- The reason given: The signed Order says that "even though approval may impair existing water rights, the applicant holds those water rights."
- The hearing: A hearing was held on Dec. 14, 2023, in Brigham City. There is a hearing report, two pages of notes and an audio recording. But the signed Order says a hearing was not held.
- A big well: One well is 16 inches wide and 540 feet deep. It is marked "Existing." Every other well is 8 or 10 inches. No well log is on file for it.
- Farmland Reserve: It holds older water rights in the same area, going back to 1940. Its letter warned some water might be counted twice. The Order does not answer that warning.
| 13-4099 | 13-4100 | |
|---|---|---|
| Water | 278.35 acre-feet | 278.35 acre-feet |
| Wells | 3 | 5 |
| Springs | 6 | 9 |
| Approved | 7/18/2024 | 7/18/2024 |
More from the record
- Golden Spike vote: On Aug. 21, 2023, four days before filing for the water, Schultz voted on the Utah Inland Port Authority board to create the Golden Spike project area in Box Elder County. It came with a $219 million incentive package. He did not recuse.
- Disclosure forms: In 2019, Schultz listed two board seats. His 2023 UIPA form and his 2026 form say "None," even though he served on the UIPA board in 2023.
- Business: His House bio says he stepped away from his home building company in 2023. His 2026 form still lists Castle Creek Homes LLC and Mike Schultz Construction Inc as owned and as income sources.
- The PAC: House Speaker Leadership PAC's treasurer is Kyle Palmer, who owns Irish Elk LLC. The page reported roughly $200,000 to Palmer and Irish Elk. A later check of the same filings found the correct total through the 2026 Convention report is $175,151.63.
Why it matters
Water near the Great Salt Lake is scarce, and the lake is in decline. When a state official approves new water, the public should be able to trust the paperwork.
Here, the signed Order has a fact wrong about the hearing. It also does not answer the warning from the neighbor with older rights. And the applicant is one of the most powerful people in state government.
To be fair: the state did follow its notice and protest steps. People could object, and they did. The questions are about what the final Order says.
What we don't know yet
- Why the Order says no hearing was held. It could be a typing mistake. That has not been shown either way.
- Who drilled the 16-inch well, and when.
- Whether the Chimney Rock hunting unit, where Sawmill Ranch guides elk hunts, sits on this same Promontory land. That has not been checked against the state's map.
- Whether any Schultz land sits inside or next to the Golden Spike or Stratos project areas.
Questions to ask
- Utah Division of Water Rights: Why does the Order say no hearing was held? Is there a well log for the 16-inch well? Was Farmland Reserve's warning reviewed?
- Box Elder County Recorder, UIPA and MIDA: Does any Schultz land sit inside or next to Golden Spike or Stratos?
- Utah House Chief Clerk: Must public board seats be listed on disclosure forms?
- Utah Division of Wildlife Resources: Does the Chimney Rock unit include these wells and springs?
Updates since this was posted
- Oct. 28, 2026 Correction: "chief sponsor" changed to "primary sponsor," and a street address was shortened to the city (Roy). (Hive correction)
- Sept. 13, 2026 Found after posting: The Salt Lake Tribune (Megan Banta, Great Salt Lake Collaborative, Feb. 8, 2025) separately reported that Keller Cattle Corp. received 556.7 acre-feet of new water rights a year on about 160 acres near Promontory Hollow, less than 10 miles from Spiral Jetty, and that Schultz's 2024 conflict of interest disclosure lists Keller Cattle Corp. as an organization where he is an "owner or officer" and received at least $5,000 in income. (The Salt Lake Tribune via Great Salt Lake Collaborative, Feb. 8, 2025)
- Sept. 13, 2026 A line-by-line re-check of House Speaker Leadership PAC's filed reports found that the earlier combined Palmer/Irish Elk figure counted $24,700 twice. The reconciled total paid by the PAC, 2024 through the 2026 Convention report, is $175,151.63: Irish Elk LLC $109,225.10 and Kyle Palmer personally $65,926.53. This is the figure the page's "roughly $200,000" should be read against. (House Speaker Leadership PAC filings, disclosures.utah.gov)
- Sept. 30, 2026 House Speaker Leadership PAC's September 30th report (June 12 to Sept. 25, 2026) lists $34,160 more to Irish Elk LLC and $352.03 to Kyle Palmer personally, plus $192,000 in "Political Support" to candidates across 19 checks. The report lists an ending balance of $331,461.49. (House Speaker Leadership PAC, 2026 September 30th Report, disclosures.utah.gov)
Connecting stories
- Case 03: More Lots, Same PlaybookAnother UIPA project area; Pat Burns sits on the board of the Northern Wasatch Home Builders Association, the group Schultz listed as a 2019 board seat.
- The Inland Port at the LegislatureShows how UIPA project areas like Golden Spike, the one Schultz voted to create, keep 75% of new property tax.
- Chris RoybalSchultz and his wife are Utah Forward PAC's largest identified donor ($12,000); the page also lists his UIPA board service ending Dec. 8, 2023.
- Dan HemmertExecutive Director of MIDA, the authority that approved the Stratos project area in Box Elder County; Schultz co-sponsored the 2020 bill that created Hemmert's commission.
- Mike OstermillerSits on the MIDA board, which approved Stratos in Box Elder County; the Speaker appoints one MIDA board member.
- Jefferson MossFollowed Schultz as House Majority Leader; the page lists Kyle Palmer and Schultz as directors of the House GOP Election Committee nonprofit (UHREC).

