Utah voters never pick a judge. They decide whether to keep one. Here is how a judge gets the seat, who grades them before you vote, what the grades mean, and the rules that changed in 2026.
Posted Oct. 17, 2026 · Updated Oct. 17, 2026.
Utah’s courts describe judge selection in four steps: nomination, appointment, confirmation and retention election. A nominating commission screens applicants and sends a short list; the governor appoints from that list; the Utah Senate confirms; then, at the end of each term, voters decide whether to keep the judge.
Judges are not running against anyone and generally do not campaign; the law does let a judge form one campaign committee (see money rules). More Yes than No votes keeps the judge; more No than Yes ends the judge’s service at the end of the term. Judges usually face voters every six years; Supreme Court justices every ten.
Utah voters almost always say yes. No Utah Supreme Court justice has lost a retention election since at least 1990, and justices have been retained with an average of 80.6% of the vote (Ballotpedia). In Weber County in 2020, every judge on the ballot was kept, with Yes votes from 73.5% to 83.7%.
The Judicial Performance Evaluation Commission (JPEC) has 13 members appointed by all three branches of state government, and has evaluated judges on the ballot since 2012. For most judges it surveys attorneys, court staff and other professionals who worked with the judge, and sends trained observers into the courtroom. Part-time justice court judges are not surveyed because too few attorneys appear before them; JPEC uses observers and, for some, short interviews with people leaving court.
Survey scores run from 1 to 5. The legal minimum is 3.6 in each scored area. JPEC also compares every judge with peers on the same kind of court and labels each area as well above, above, consistent with, below or well below peers. The commission then votes on whether the judge meets its standards.
The Hive’s collective rubric was built for bills, boards and campaign money, so judges get their own rubric. It uses the same letter scale and the same “C means meets the law” baseline, and it is applied the same way to every judge.
How to read the grades: A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means the judge went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means the judge passed JPEC’s minimum but JPEC rates that area below the judge’s peers; F means below JPEC’s legal minimum score of 3.6. Every grade is taken from JPEC’s own published wording, the same way for all 57 judges. No grade is based on how any case came out, or on who appointed the judge.
| Question | Record used |
|---|---|
| 1. Fair to people in court | JPEC procedural fairness |
| 2. Follows the law | JPEC legal ability |
| 3. Temperament & integrity | JPEC integrity and judicial temperament |
| 4. Runs the court well | JPEC administrative skills |
| 5. Public record | H.B. 540 financial disclosure (N/A until filed) |
| 6. Retention money | Reports to the Lieutenant Governor (N/A if no committee) |
Below 3.6 = F. Passes, but JPEC rates it below or well below peers = D. Consistent with peers = C. Above peers = B. Well above peers = A. Overall is the average of the graded questions, with a plus or minus, the same as candidate pages. Who appointed the judge and any public discipline are stated on each page but never graded. No grade is based on how any case came out.
Under Utah Code Title 20A, Chapter 12, Part 3, a judge may set up one personal campaign committee for a retention election. Each contribution must be reported to the Lieutenant Governor within 31 days of receipt. An interim report is due seven days before the general election (Oct. 27, 2026), and a summary report is due Jan. 10 of the next year. A judge who doesn’t file the interim report can be removed from the ballot. As of Oct. 17, 2026, the Hive had not found a retention committee for any judge on this ballot; this will be checked again after Oct. 27.
The Judicial Conduct Commission investigates complaints against Utah judges. Its proceedings are confidential; only recommendations of discipline sent to the Utah Supreme Court, and orders the Court makes public, are released. As of Oct. 17, 2026, none of the 57 judges on this ballot appears on the commission’s public dispositions list, which runs from 1997 to 2026.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism