Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2023-188-WAT · Water

The Golf Water Report That Never Came

H.B. 188 would have made golf courses report their yearly water use to the state and post it online. A House committee held it, and it died.

Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

BillH.B. 188 (2023 General Session), "Golf Related Water Modifications"
Primary sponsorRep. Douglas R. Welton
Floor sponsorSen. Daniel McCay
Final votesNone — held in committee (1st Substitute held 9–2–3, Feb. 10, 2023)
StatusDied · Died: held in House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment committee Feb. 10, 2023; enacting clause struck and filed Mar. 3, 2023

Graded by the collective rubric

C+Overall · Neutral
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerCThe bill did not add or remove a public check on government power. It set a reporting duty on golf course owners and operators, public or private (H.B. 188 as introduced; 1st Substitute H.B. 188).
TransparencyBIt would have made golf water use public every year, posted by both the course and the state. No such reporting rule exists in current law. The 1st Substitute also kept data given to the university study out of GRAMA (1st Substitute H.B. 188).
Financial accountabilityCThe fiscal note for the 1st Substitute shows $30,075,000 one-time and $130,000 ongoing from the General Fund. The bill itself appropriated no money (1st Substitute H.B. 188; Fiscal note, 1st Substitute H.B. 188).
Environmental impactBYearly reporting, a study of water savings, and grants for efficient irrigation would have given the state real numbers on a large outdoor water use (1st Substitute H.B. 188).
Community impactCResidents gain information but no new standing. The hearings were posted and open. Two witnesses spoke against the bill and none for it (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023).

New grade, Oct. 19, 2026. The bill died, so this grades the design: the 1st Substitute, the last version the committee adopted. Transparency and environment earn a B because yearly public water reporting by golf courses goes beyond anything in Utah law. Financial accountability is a C: the $30 million grant cost is shown plainly in the fiscal note, but the bill itself did not fund it. Average 2.4 = C+. Outcome N/A (died). A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Quoted from the 1st Substitute, the version the committee held (1st Substitute H.B. 188).

Proposed Utah Code 73-1-22(3)(c)

beginning July 1, 2028, an owner or operator of a golf course or driving range shall report to the division

(1st Substitute H.B. 188)

Proposed Utah Code 73-1-22(3)(d)

The division shall publish the information reported under Subsection (3)(c)

(1st Substitute H.B. 188)

Proposed Utah Code 73-1-22(2)(a)

Utah State University shall study the use of water on golf courses or driving ranges in the state.

Findings due by June 30, 2026 (1st Substitute H.B. 188).

Proposed Utah Code 73-1-22(4)(a)

up to an aggregate total of $30,000,000, the division may issue a grant

(1st Substitute H.B. 188)

Every version, and what changed

VersionDateWhat changed
IntroducedJan. 9, 2023Reporting and website posting only. The general description reads: "This bill addresses the reporting of water use by golf courses or driving ranges." No study, grants or board (H.B. 188 as introduced). Fiscal note: about $4,000 to the Division of Water Resources in FY 2024 (Fiscal note, H.B. 188 as introduced).
1st Substitute (Welton)Feb. 10, 2023Adopted in committee 11–0–3. Added the USU study, a GRAMA exemption for study data, the $30 million grant program and the Golf Advisory Board; reporting starts July 1, 2028 (1st Substitute H.B. 188; Compare: 1st Substitute vs. introduced; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023).
2nd SubstituteNot adoptedListed on the status page as "Not Adopted" (H.B. 188 (2023) bill status page, le.utah.gov; 2nd Substitute H.B. 188 (not adopted)).

The votes

DateWhereResultRecord
Jan. 25, 2023House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment: motion to adjourn the meeting, made after the H.B. 188 testimony8–1–5(House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023)
Feb. 10, 2023Same committee: replace H.B. 188 with 1st Substitute11–0–3(House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Feb. 10, 2023Same committee: hold 1st Substitute H.B. 1889–2–3(House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Feb. 10, 2023Same committee: motion to adjourn (failed)5–6–3(House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Feb. 10, 2023Same committee: hold 1st Substitute H.B. 188 (made again)9–2–3(House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
March 3, 2023House: enacting clause struck; filedNo recorded vote listed(H.B. 188 (2023) bill status page, le.utah.gov)

Jan. 25 adjournment: yes, Reps. Bolinder, Chew, Jimenez, Kohler, Lund, T. Peterson, Shipp and Watkins; no, Rep. Brooks; not voting, Reps. Bennion, Owens, Schultz, Snider and Stratton (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023). Feb. 10 hold votes: yes, Reps. Bolinder, Brooks, Chew, Jimenez, Kohler, Lund, Shipp, Stratton and Watkins; no, Reps. Bennion and Owens; absent, Reps. Peterson, Schultz and Snider (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023). Rep. Schultz is listed absent for both full meetings (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023).

The timeline

  1. Jan. 9, 2023 H.B. 188 numbered and made public (H.B. 188 (2023) bill status page, le.utah.gov).
  2. Jan. 25, 2023 First hearing. Two witnesses speak against it. The committee votes to adjourn without acting on the bill (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023).
  3. Feb. 10, 2023 Second hearing. The committee adopts the 1st Substitute, then holds it (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023).
  4. Feb. 28, 2023 Returned to House Rules (H.B. 188 (2023) bill status page, le.utah.gov).
  5. March 3, 2023 Enacting clause struck; bill filed with bills not passed (H.B. 188 (2023) bill status page, le.utah.gov).

How H.B. 188 stopped in committee

Built only from the records on this page.

flowchart TD
  A["Introduced Jan. 9, 2023
reporting only"] --> B["Jan. 25 hearing
2 witnesses against"] B --> C["Meeting adjourned
8-1-5, no bill vote"] C --> D["Feb. 10 hearing"] D --> E["1st Substitute adopted
11-0-3"] E --> F["Held
9-2-3"] F --> G["Enacting clause struck
March 3, 2023"]

In their own words

Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.

We found no recorded statement from the sponsors about why the bill was needed.

What happened next

Where it fits

Bills that changed the same rule, oldest first. This bill is highlighted.

Bills that change the same rule

  1. 2023 H.B. 188
    Would have required golf courses to report and post yearly water use. Died in committee.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Rep. Douglas R. WeltonPrimary sponsor; presented the bill at both hearings (H.B. 188 (2023) bill status page, le.utah.gov; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Sen. Daniel McCaySenate floor sponsor; assisted at the Feb. 10 hearing (H.B. 188 (2023) bill status page, le.utah.gov; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Blake Bingham, Deputy State EngineerAssisted the sponsor at the Feb. 10 hearing (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Ryan Peterson, Golf Alliance for UtahSpoke in opposition, Jan. 25, 2023 (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023)
Randy Elliot, Davis County CommissionerSpoke in opposition, Jan. 25, 2023 (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023)
Rep. Steven J. LundRan both meetings, per the minutes; voted to hold (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Rep. Thomas W. PetersonMoved to adjourn the Jan. 25 meeting (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023)
Rep. Bridger BolinderMoved to hold the bill, Feb. 10 (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Rep. Keven J. StrattonMoved the 1st Substitute; voted to hold (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Rep. Gay Lynn BennionVoted no on holding the bill (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Rep. Doug OwensVoted no on holding the bill (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Rep. Walt BrooksCommittee chair on the roster; lone no vote on the Jan. 25 adjournment; voted to hold Feb. 10 (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)
Rep. Mike SchultzCommittee member; listed absent at both meetings (House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023; House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023)

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Utah Division of Water ResourcesDo you collect any golf course water use numbers now, even voluntarily? Are they public?
Rep. Douglas R. Welton's legislative officeDo you plan to bring a golf water reporting bill back?
Your cityIf the city owns a golf course, how much water did it use last year, and where can residents see that number?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

9
sources listed
5
votes recorded
3
versions compared
0
statements quoted

Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Status page, introduced bill, 1st Substitute, compare document, both fiscal notes and both sets of committee minutes read on le.utah.gov through a web text-extraction tool on Oct. 19, 2026. The witness and vote findings come from the minutes as read that way. The 2nd Substitute text was not read. A PDF copy of the Jan. 25 minutes could not be opened (site rate limit); the HTML minutes were read twice.

Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: what the 2nd Substitute (not adopted) contained; who prepared it; whether the committee audio adds anything to the minutes; the Salt Lake Tribune's 2022 golf water figures (not opened for this page). For the Jan. 25 adjournment vote, this page follows the minutes as read: Rep. Brooks voted no and Rep. Bennion is listed as not voting.

Sources

Show all 9 sources
  1. H.B. 188 (2023) bill status page, le.utah.gov: https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/static/HB0188.html
  2. H.B. 188 as introduced: https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/hbillint/HB0188.pdf
  3. 1st Substitute H.B. 188: https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/hbillint/HB0188S01.htm
  4. Compare: 1st Substitute vs. introduced: https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/hbillint/HB0188S01_ComparedWith_HB0188.pdf
  5. 2nd Substitute H.B. 188 (not adopted): https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/hbillint/HB0188S02.pdf
  6. House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Jan. 25, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2023/html/00000995.htm
  7. House Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment minutes, Feb. 10, 2023: https://le.utah.gov/interim/2023/html/00001962.htm
  8. Fiscal note, H.B. 188 as introduced: https://le.utah.gov/lfa/fnotes/2023/HB0188.fn.pdf
  9. Fiscal note, 1st Substitute H.B. 188: https://le.utah.gov/lfa/fnotes/2023/HB0188S01.fn.pdf
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

None found yet.

People

Elsewhere on the Hive

None found yet.

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism