The version that failed was never heard in committee
By the time S.B. 78 reached its final form, it had been substituted four times. The final substitute — the one that repealed renter and homeowner credits and replaced existing abatements with an optional county program — never received its own committee hearing before going to the floor.
That matters for accountability regardless of how anyone feels about the policy: the public and other legislators were voting on, and reacting to, a version of the bill that never got the normal public vetting process.
From expanding relief to repealing it
The bill's substance shifted substantially between its original introduction and the final (S4) substitute that reached the floor:
| Original Proposal | Final S4 Proposal |
|---|---|
| Expanded renter credits | Repealed renter credits |
| Modified existing homeowner relief | Repealed homeowner credits |
| Modified existing abatements | Replaced them with an optional county program |
| Expanded existing deferrals | Created an interest-bearing lien structure |
| Statewide programs | County-by-county participation |
The final version's winners and losers
Who Could Benefit
- Some homeowners age 65–74
- Homeowners earning up to $75,000 seeking deferral
- Qualifying homeowners in participating counties
Who Could Lose
- Low-income renters
- Recipients of existing homeowner credits
- Residents of nonparticipating counties
- Reverse-mortgage holders
Where the final version fell short
| Category | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Direct tax reduction | Weaker |
| Access to deferrals | Broader |
| Protection for renters | Eliminated |
| County-to-county equality | Reduced |
| Transparency of process | Weak |
| Actual legal effect | None — bill failed |
Died on the House floor
The Senate passed an earlier version of the bill; the source record does not report that Senate vote's tally. The final House vote — on the S4 substitute that had never been heard in committee — failed 28–41–6.
S.B. 78 is a case study in how much a bill can change between introduction and its final vote. It started as an expansion of renter and homeowner relief and ended, four substitutes later, repealing both — replacing statewide programs with a patchwork of optional county participation, and creating an interest-bearing lien structure in place of straightforward deferrals.
The bill failed, so none of this became law. But the process itself is the story: the version that mattered most — the one lawmakers actually voted on — never got a public committee hearing.
When a bill's substance reverses this much between introduction and final vote, should the final version be required to get its own committee hearing before reaching the floor?

