Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
audits · AU 100.03← Full audits docket · ← Hive library (every repo)

OLAG REPORT 2026-19 · SEPTEMBER 15, 2026

The Work Got Done. The Paperwork Didn't Keep Up.

A legislative audit of World Trade Center Utah found the state-funded nonprofit met its contracts, but its main success number is self-reported and its spending reports fell short.

Issued by: Office of the Legislative Auditor General Audited: World Trade Center Utah and GOED Chief officers: Jonathan Freedman (WTC Utah) · Commissioner Jefferson Moss (GOED)

Posted Oct. 17, 2026 · Updated Oct. 17, 2026 · Page look updated Nov. 2, 2026

New to this? Read it in plain words About 500 words, with two pictures.

The short version

C
HOW THIS PIECE GRADES THE STATE'S OVERSIGHT OF THIS MONEY

The contracted work appears to have been delivered and no misuse was found. But for years the state paid without asking how the money was spent, and the one result number rests on what businesses chose to report.

What the audit found

World Trade Center Utah (WTC Utah) is a nonprofit, founded in 2006, that helps Utah businesses sell into other countries, brings in foreign investment, and hosts foreign delegations. It works closely with the Governor's Office of Economic Development (GOED), which oversees both of its state contracts.

Two legislative leaders' questions drove the audit: Are the state funds given to WTC Utah being spent efficiently and effectively? And are the fees WTC Utah charges to go on trade missions appropriate?

The auditors looked mainly at fiscal 2025, the latest complete year. Their answer to the first question was mixed. WTC Utah "appears to have carried out the activities required under these contracts and achieved the intended contract deliverables." But the auditors found four areas to improve, and wrote: "WTC Utah did not have processes in place that ensured reporting compliance, and limited oversight by prior GOED leadership allowed deficiencies to continue."

On the second question, the auditors "did not find that WTC Utah is charging fees in violation of its current contract."

$2.2Mstate money through two contracts, fiscal 2025
$7.2Mstate money in total, 2021 through 2025
5recommendations, all accepted

Where the state money goes

The state pays WTC Utah through two separate deals. The audit notes that state funding grew in 2023, when the GOED contract added work, and again in 2024, to open and run a trade office in South Korea.

How the money reaches WTC Utah

From the audit's description of the two contracts.

Utah LegislatureSets the budget
two separate deals
Pass-through grant$1.66 million in fiscal 2025
The Legislature names WTC Utah; GOED pays it out
GOED sole-source contract$525,000 a year
$2.35 million over 2022–2026, no bidding
about $2.2 million in fiscal 2025
World Trade Center UtahPrivate nonprofit, founded 2006
The state is about one-third of its money
WTC Utah reports back to GOED
What GOED getsCounts of activities (consultations, visits, grants) plus one result number: "new trade opportunities," reported by the businesses themselves

Neither contract says how the money should be split among the jobs. The splits below are WTC Utah's own, as the audit reports them.

Pass-through contract: how WTC Utah split $1.66 million

Fiscal 2025. Reported results: 394 consultations, 47 sales growth projects, 87 trade facilitations, 194 and 377 investment facilitations.

Foreign direct investment
$1,162,500
South Korea trade team
$300,000
Trade promotion
$200,000

GOED contract: how WTC Utah split $525,000

Fiscal 2025. Reported results: 43 inbound country visits, 2 trade missions, 5 trade shows with 39 companies, 81 grants awarded.

Diplomatic hosting
$200,000
Grant administration
$175,000
Trade missions
$150,000
Foreign direct investment
$0

Foreign direct investment shows $0 under the GOED contract because, per the audit, it appears in both contracts and WTC Utah pays for it only from the pass-through money.

Where all of WTC Utah’s money came from, 2021–2025

Average share of revenue. The audit’s rounded figures add to 101%.

Private (memberships, sponsors, services)
45%
State contracts
35%
Federal grants
21%

What WTC Utah spent it on, 2021–2025

Average share of expenses. The audit’s rounded figures add to 101%.

Staff wages and benefits
52%
Grants paid out
19%
Administration
16%
Programs, events, investment work
14%

The "new trade opportunities" number

Most of what WTC Utah reports to the state are counts of activity, such as meetings held or grants given. The audit calls these outputs. It reports only one outcome, a number meant to show results: "new trade opportunities," or NTO.

NTO adds together three things: actual sales, prospective sales and actual investment, as reported by businesses in impact statements and surveys after they work with WTC Utah. The audit found three problems with that:

The audit recommends WTC Utah follow up with businesses for proof of completed deals, and that GOED review whether its contract measures show whether the program is working.

What WTC Utah says about NTO

In its response, WTC Utah says reporting is voluntary in nearly all cases, that companies often can't share confidential financial records, and that pushing for them could discourage the reporting the number depends on. It also says NTO is "a success of a company, not an economic development organization," and that it tracks the number as a sign of program performance, not as its own standalone success.

It agreed to report NTO in three tiers: prospective, actual and publicly announced (backed by a press release, public filing or other public record). It also agreed to check in every year with every company that reported NTO. Its timetable: tier definitions by Oct. 31, 2026; the first full follow-up and 2026 numbers by tier by Dec. 31, 2026. The plan notes it is "subject to further discussion with GOED."

Three reports that fell short

The audit found three places where WTC Utah's reporting did not meet the requirements:

PASS-THROUGH REPORT

The contract requires WTC Utah to say "how Grantee used funds or will use funds." The 2025 annual report it gave GOED did not include those details.

GRANT REPORTING

The GOED contract asks for grant details. The quarterly reports listed the number of grant recipients, but not the grant money available, the number of companies awarded, or the NTO from the grants. WTC Utah says it reported some of this and folds grant results into its overall NTO on purpose, so the same deal isn't counted twice.

STATE AUDITOR FILING

Utah law requires nonprofits that get $25,000 or more in public money to file an accounting report with the State Auditor each year. The audit says WTC Utah met that threshold every year but had not filed since 2024. WTC Utah says it uploaded its past financial audits on July 28, 2026, and started a compliance calendar on July 30, 2026.

The audit names two causes: WTC Utah had no process to make sure the reports were done, and "prior GOED leadership provided limited oversight of pass-through funds and approved final payments to WTC Utah despite incomplete reporting."

WTC Utah says the gap happened during a change-over in its finance department, "did not involve the misuse of public funds," and that an independent accounting firm audits its books every year. GOED holds a seat on its board.

Trade mission fees

Some people the auditors spoke with questioned why WTC Utah charges people to join trade missions when the state already pays it to run them. One asked whether that meant WTC Utah was paid twice.

The GOED contract, as amended in 2023, says WTC Utah books and pays flights, hotels and fees for the Governor and up to two members of the Governor's team. Everyone else on the delegation, including state employees and elected officials, pays their own way, and WTC Utah "may also charge trade mission delegation members a participation fee." WTC Utah sets aside $200,000 of its $525,000 GOED payment for two trade missions a year.

The audit found no fee charged against the contract. But it says the new contract should make clear that state money and fees don't pay for the same thing twice. It also notes that in the 2026 General Session, the Legislature gave GOED $250,000 in one-time money for travel and lodging of executive and legislative officials on trade missions.

WTC Utah's response: "no activity, service, or cost is funded twice." It says its two state deals pay for different work.

The audit says the fee question is discussed further in the GOED audit, Report 2026-18. Read our case file on that audit.

The five recommendations

1.1 · GOEDReview the contract's performance measures for WTC Utah and use them to guide future funding.
1.2 · WTC UtahFollow up with businesses for documents confirming completed sales, investments and other results.
1.3 · WTC UtahStrengthen its process for meeting contract and State Auditor reporting rules, with regular management review.
1.4 · GOEDSpell out in the new contract how the money is to be spent.
1.5 · GOEDRequire regular expense reports tied to each key contract deliverable.

All five were accepted.

What WTC Utah and GOED said

WTC Utah (letter from President and CEO Jonathan Freedman, Aug. 14, 2026)
Accepted both recommendations aimed at it and said it plans to finish them by Dec. 31, 2026, "pending further conversations with GOED." It highlighted its public-private model and its weekly tariff briefings: 57 online sessions through June 30, 2026, with 440 different people attending. It cautioned that "highly prescriptive line-item budgeting and reporting" could slow its ability to shift resources when business needs change. Named contacts: Ben Kolendar, chief of staff (recommendation 1.2), and Heather Garcia, chief financial officer (1.3).
GOED (letter from Commissioner Jeff Moss, Aug. 21, 2026)
Accepted all three recommendations aimed at it. Deputy Commissioner Tara Rosander is named on each. GOED says it has already reviewed the measures and written new ones, that the proposed new contract says how money is to be spent (Attachment D), and that it requires quarterly reports on key deliverables (Attachment B). On all three, it says a draft contract has been provided and GOED is "attempting to execute a new contract."

Timeline

Notes on the report itself

Two things in the published PDF appear to be leftovers from other reports. Neither changes the findings, but readers comparing pages may notice them:

Graded by the collective rubric

Power · Transparency · Financial Accountability · Environmental Impact · Community Impact
PowerCBoth state deals went to WTC Utah without competition: one named by the Legislature, one a GOED sole-source contract. GOED holds a seat on WTC Utah's board. Neither contract said how the money should be split.
TransparencyCSpending details missing from the 2025 pass-through report, grant measures missing from quarterly reports, and no State Auditor filing since 2024. WTC Utah says the filings were brought current in July 2026.
Financial accountabilityCNo misuse of public money was found, and an independent firm audits WTC Utah each year. But the GOED contract never required expense reporting, and GOED approved final payments despite incomplete reports.
Environmental impactN/ANot addressed by this audit.
Community impactBThe contracted work appears to have been delivered, and private money covered about 45% of WTC Utah's budget. The one result number can't yet show how much real business followed.
OverallCReal work delivered under weak state oversight, with fixes promised or underway. Graded on what the audit documented, not on whether the fixes hold.

Common questions

Did the audit find money was misused?
No. It found the contracted work appears to have been done and the fees were within the contract. The problems were measurement and reporting.
Is this the same as the One World Trade Center in New York?
No. WTC Utah is a Utah nonprofit and part of a worldwide network of trade centers. It is not the New York building.
Why audit a nonprofit?
Because it receives public money. The audit was requested to check whether state funds were spent well and whether its trade mission fees were appropriate.
Does the state still fund WTC Utah?
Yes. The audit says the Legislature has typically given the pass-through money every year. GOED's contract runs through Dec. 31, 2026, and a new one was in draft when the audit came out.
Is this connected to the GOED audit?
Yes. Both reports came out Sept. 15, 2026, and both involve GOED's oversight of money it passes on to outside groups. This report points readers to the GOED audit for more on trade mission fees.

People named in the record

Jonathan FreedmanPresident and CEO of WTC Utah; the audit's designated chief officer for WTC Utah. Signed WTC Utah's response.
Jefferson (Jeff) MossCommissioner of GOED; designated chief officer for GOED. Signed GOED's response. The audit credits current GOED leadership with fixes and faults "prior GOED leadership." Hive profile.
Tara RosanderGOED deputy commissioner, named on all three of GOED's action plans.
Ben Kolendar and Heather GarciaWTC Utah chief of staff and chief financial officer, named on WTC Utah's two action plans.
Kade R. MincheyLegislative Auditor General, who sent the report to the Legislature.
Audit SubcommitteeSenate President J. Stuart Adams and House Speaker Mike Schultz (co-chairs), Sen. Kirk Cullimore, Sen. Luz Escamilla, Rep. Casey Snider and Rep. Angela Romero.

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

GOEDHas the new WTC Utah contract been signed? Will Attachment B (quarterly reporting) and Attachment D (how the money is to be spent) be posted publicly?
WTC UtahWere the three-tier NTO definitions adopted by Oct. 31, 2026? For 2025, how much of the NTO total was prospective, and how much was actual?
Your state legislatorsWill the pass-through grant continue in fiscal 2027, and at what amount? Should pass-through grantees have to report spending the way contractors do?
The State Auditor's officeAre WTC Utah's required financial reports now on file? (Anyone can search the State Auditor's reporting site.)

Updates since this was posted

New updates will be added here with their dates. Earlier entries are not changed.

Words to know

Tap a card to see what it means.

Behind this piece

42
Report pages read
5
Recommendations tracked
2
Response letters read
11
Dated timeline entries

Posted Oct. 17, 2026. Built from the full audit PDF (42 pages), read as extracted text and checked figure by figure. Charts that come from the audit's own figures use only the numbers printed in its text.

Sources
  1. Office of the Legislative Auditor General, Report No. 2026-19, "A Performance Audit of World Trade Center Utah: A Review of State Contract Fulfillment," transmitted Sept. 15, 2026. Full report (PDF)
  2. World Trade Center Utah response letter, Jonathan Freedman, Aug. 14, 2026, and Audit Response Plan. Appended to Report 2026-19.
  3. Governor's Office of Economic Development response, Commissioner Jeff Moss, Aug. 21, 2026. Appended to Report 2026-19.
  4. Office of the Legislative Auditor General, Report No. 2026-18 (GOED). Hive case file

Added Oct. 17, 2026, for the updates section:

  1. Online news search for coverage of Report 2026-19, Oct. 17, 2026: none found.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Audits docket · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack