Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County Hive
← Bill TrackerMaster index

Bill Tracker · CASE 2024-086-BND · School bonds & debt

A Cap and a Hearing for Bonds Voters Never See

S.B. 86 put a $200 million, three-year cap on local lease revenue bonds and required notice and a public evening hearing before big ones are issued. Voters still do not vote on them.

Posted Oct. 19, 2026 · Updated Oct. 19, 2026

Short on time? Read it in plain words

Short version

BillS.B. 86 (2024 General Session), "Local Government Bonds Amendments"
Primary sponsorSen. Lincoln Fillmore
Floor sponsorRep. Brady Brammer
Final votesSenate 19–5–5 (Feb. 14, 2024); House 43–23–9 (Feb. 29, 2024); Senate concurred 20–6–3 (Feb. 29, 2024)
StatusLaw · Signed Mar. 20, 2024; cap and hearing rules apply to bonds issued on or after May 1, 2024

Graded by the collective rubric

B+Overall · Helps
QuestionGradeWhy
PowerBAdds a dollar cap and a required public hearing on a kind of debt voters never approve; it stops short of requiring a vote (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).
TransparencyARequires a statement at a meeting, at least 14 days of notice, and an evening hearing, and spells out what a school district's notice must tell taxpayers, including the higher interest cost compared with a voter-approved bond (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).
Financial accountabilityBThe notice must say plainly whose money is committed: future property tax and income tax revenue. The cap is large ($200 million in three years), bonds of $10 million or less skip the hearing, and correctional facility bonds do not count toward the cap (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).
Environmental impactN/ANot applicable.
Community impactBTaxpayers get a hearing they did not have before on these bonds, held in the evening, but the governing body still decides; there is no vote (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).

New grade, Oct. 19, 2026. S.B. 86 goes beyond what Utah law required before it: a cap, a posted notice that tells taxpayers the cost plainly, and an evening hearing. It is not an A on Power or Community impact because lease revenue bonds still never go to voters. Average 3.25 = B+. A C means the record meets what Utah law requires, the status quo. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Overall = the average of the graded questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0); any question marked N/A is left out; letters sit on whole numbers, so 2.75 is B−, not B+. Where a grade was already published, the published letter is kept even when the average would round higher. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.

What the bill says

Quoted from the 3rd Substitute, the version the House passed and the Senate concurred in (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in); LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls). The enrolled PDF on le.utah.gov is a scanned image that our tools could not read as text (S.B. 86 (2024) enrolled text (image-only PDF; could not be read as text)), so these quotes were not checked word for word against the enrolled copy.

Utah Code 11-14-103(6)(a)(ii)

the total of all lease revenue bonds issued by a local political subdivision within any consecutive three-year period.

This is how the bill defines the "combined total" (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).

Utah Code 11-14-103(6)(b)(i)

may not issue a lease revenue bond if the issuance of the bond will cause the combined total to exceed $200,000,000.

Bonds for a correctional facility do not count toward the total (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).

Utah Code 11-14-103(6)(c)

Before issuing an applicable lease revenue bond on or after May 1, 2024, a local political subdivision shall:

An "applicable" bond is one over $10 million (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).

Utah Code 11-14-103(6)(f)(ii)(A)

shall be held beginning at or after 6:00 p.m.;

The public hearing on the bond (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).

Utah Code 11-14-103(6)(e)(iii), school district notice

Additionally, a lease revenue bond generally has a higher interest cost than a voter-approved general obligation bond.

The same notice must say the bond "commits money from future property tax and income tax revenue allocated to the school district" (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).

Utah Code 17D-2-501(2)

shall comply with the same requirements and is subject to the same limitations under Subsection 11-14-103(6)

Applies the same rules to a local building authority issuing a lease revenue bond on or after May 1, 2024 (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in)).

Every version, and what changed

VersionDateWhat changed
Introduced (Sen. Fillmore)Jan. 10, 2024The comparison document, read as plain text, shows separate per-bond limits ($30 million for school districts, $10 million for other local governments) and an exception for bonds approved at an election; no public hearing (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls; S.B. 86 1st Substitute compared with introduced bill (le.utah.gov)).
1st SubstituteFeb. 7, 2024Senate Revenue and Taxation Committee, 8–0. The comparison document shows one $90 million cap and a 12-month rule in place of the per-bond limits (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls; S.B. 86 1st Substitute compared with introduced bill (le.utah.gov)).
2nd Substitute (Sen. Fillmore)Not confirmedSet the $200 million combined total over any three years, the $10 million threshold, notice, and the 6 p.m. public hearing (S.B. 86 3rd Substitute compared with 2nd Substitute (le.utah.gov)).
3rd Substitute (Rep. Brammer)Feb. 29, 2024Adopted on the House floor. Kept the $200 million, three-year cap; adjusted the local building authority section and the school district notice wording (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls; S.B. 86 3rd Substitute compared with 2nd Substitute (le.utah.gov)).
EnrolledSigned March 20, 2024Applies to bonds issued on or after May 1, 2024 (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in); LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls; Daily Herald, "Alpine School District cancels public meeting on $175M bond for new high school," Carlene Coombs, March 18, 2024).

The votes

DateWhereResultRecord
Feb. 7, 2024Senate Revenue and Taxation Committee8–0–0 (substitute and recommendation)(LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls)
Feb. 12, 2024Senate, 2nd reading17–7–5(LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls)
Feb. 14, 2024Senate, 3rd reading19–5–5(LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls)
Feb. 21, 2024House Revenue and Taxation Committee8–1–4(LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls)
Feb. 29, 2024House, 3rd reading (3rd Substitute)43–23–9(LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls)
Feb. 29, 2024Senate concurs20–6–3(LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls)

Vote counts are from LegiScan's copy of the Legislature's roll calls (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls). The names on each roll call were not pulled for this page. Every committee and floor vote listed was a recorded vote.

The timeline

  1. Nov. 2022 Voters reject Alpine School District's $595 million general obligation bond, as later reported (Utah Taxpayers Association, "Alpine School District Plans to Ignore Voters and Defy Legislature," Malah Armstrong, March 7, 2024; Salt Lake Tribune, "Facing criticism, Alpine School District may back away from $175M lease revenue bond," Carmen Nesbitt, March 18, 2024).
  2. Jan. 10, 2024 S.B. 86 numbered (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls).
  3. Feb. 7–14, 2024 Senate committee and Senate floor pass it (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls).
  4. Feb. 29, 2024 House adopts Rep. Brammer's 3rd Substitute and passes it 43–23; the Senate concurs 20–6 the same day (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls).
  5. March 5–7, 2024 Alpine School District gives notice that it intends to issue $175 million in lease revenue bonds on March 19; the Utah Taxpayers Association reports the total with earlier bonds would exceed the new cap (Utah Taxpayers Association, "Alpine School District Plans to Ignore Voters and Defy Legislature," Malah Armstrong, March 7, 2024).
  6. March 18, 2024 Alpine cancels the hearing on the $175 million bond (Daily Herald, "Alpine School District cancels public meeting on $175M bond for new high school," Carlene Coombs, March 18, 2024; Salt Lake Tribune, "Facing criticism, Alpine School District may back away from $175M lease revenue bond," Carmen Nesbitt, March 18, 2024).
  7. March 20, 2024 Gov. Spencer Cox signs S.B. 86 (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls).
  8. May 1, 2024 The cap and hearing rules apply to bonds issued from this date (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in); Daily Herald, "Alpine School District cancels public meeting on $175M bond for new high school," Carlene Coombs, March 18, 2024).
  9. March 17, 2025 S.B. 188 (2025) is signed, with an exemption from this cap for certain bonds in dividing school districts (The Weber County Hive, Bait and Switch Part 3, Case 11 (S.B. 188 and H.B. 332)).

What a local government must do before a big lease revenue bond

Built only from the records on this page.

flowchart TD
  A["Bond over
$10 million?"] -->|"No"| B["No hearing
required"] A -->|"Yes"| C{"Would the 3-year total
go over $200 million?"} C -->|"Yes"| D["May not issue"] C -->|"No"| E["Statement at a meeting
14+ days before hearing"] E --> F["Notice posted
at least 14 days"] F --> G["Public hearing
at or after 6 p.m."] G --> H["Board decides.
No public vote."]

In their own words

Quoted exactly from the source named. A quote does not tell you everything a person thinks; it is what the record shows they said.

taking action on a lease revenue bond is not necessary at this time

— Kimberly Bird, Alpine School District spokesperson, Salt Lake Tribune, March 18, 2024 (Salt Lake Tribune, "Facing criticism, Alpine School District may back away from $175M lease revenue bond," Carmen Nesbitt, March 18, 2024)

The need for the high school remains.

— Rich Stowell, Alpine School District communications director, Daily Herald, March 18, 2024 (Daily Herald, "Alpine School District cancels public meeting on $175M bond for new high school," Carlene Coombs, March 18, 2024)

we don't even exactly know how much because they don't have to tell us

— John Gadd, Pleasant Grove resident running for the Alpine school board, Salt Lake Tribune, March 18, 2024 (Salt Lake Tribune, "Facing criticism, Alpine School District may back away from $175M lease revenue bond," Carmen Nesbitt, March 18, 2024)

What happened next

Where it fits

Bills that changed the same rule, oldest first. This bill is highlighted.

Bills that change the same rule

  1. 2024 S.B. 86
    Created the $200 million, three-year cap on lease revenue bonds and required notice and an evening public hearing for bonds over $10 million.
  2. 2025 S.B. 188
    Exempted certain lease revenue bonds for new school districts from that cap when voters in the dividing district rejected a general obligation bond.
  3. 2026 H.B. 332
    Would have required a public vote on a general obligation bond before any school district lease revenue bond. Held in committee; died March 6, 2026.

People in this record

PersonRole in this recordElsewhere on the Hive
Sen. Lincoln FillmorePrimary sponsor; the 2nd Substitute carries his name (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in); S.B. 86 3rd Substitute compared with 2nd Substitute (le.utah.gov))
Rep. Brady BrammerHouse sponsor; proposed the 3rd Substitute that became law (S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in); S.B. 86 3rd Substitute compared with 2nd Substitute (le.utah.gov))
Sen. Keith GroverPrimary sponsor of S.B. 188 (2025), which exempted certain bonds from this cap (The Weber County Hive, Bait and Switch Part 3, Case 11 (S.B. 188 and H.B. 332))
Rep. Tiara AuxierPrimary sponsor of H.B. 332 (2026), which would have required a vote first (The Weber County Hive, Bait and Switch Part 3, Case 11 (S.B. 188 and H.B. 332))
Kimberly BirdAlpine School District spokesperson, quoted on the canceled $175 million bond (Salt Lake Tribune, "Facing criticism, Alpine School District may back away from $175M lease revenue bond," Carmen Nesbitt, March 18, 2024)

Words to know

Questions to ask, and whom to ask

Your school district business officeWhat is our district's combined total of lease revenue bonds for the last three years, and when was the last public hearing?
Your city or county finance officeHas the city or county issued a lease revenue bond over $10 million since May 1, 2024? Where was the notice posted?
The Utah State Auditor's officeIs there one public list of lease revenue bonds issued by local governments since May 1, 2024?

Connected Hive work

Behind this piece

11
sources listed
6
votes recorded
5
versions compared
4
statements quoted

Posted Oct. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Bill text read from the 3rd Substitute web page and two comparison PDFs on le.utah.gov through a text-extraction tool; the comparison documents lost their underline formatting, so additions in them are less certain than deletions. Vote counts and dates from LegiScan's history page. News articles read online.

Not confirmed as of Oct. 19, 2026: the enrolled text word for word (the enrolled PDF is a scanned image our tools could not read (S.B. 86 (2024) enrolled text (image-only PDF; could not be read as text))); the le.utah.gov status page loads by script and was not read directly (S.B. 86 (2024) bill status page), so vote counts come from LegiScan (LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls); the introduced bill's terms are from a comparison document read as plain text, not the introduced bill itself (a fetch of it was rate-limited) (S.B. 86 1st Substitute compared with introduced bill (le.utah.gov)); the date and place the 2nd Substitute was adopted; names on each roll call. Whether S.B. 86 responded to Alpine's 2022 and 2023 lease revenue bonds ($31.8 million and $81.8 million): news coverage ties Alpine's bonds to the bill (Utah Taxpayers Association, "Alpine School District Plans to Ignore Voters and Defy Legislature," Malah Armstrong, March 7, 2024; Salt Lake Tribune, "Facing criticism, Alpine School District may back away from $175M lease revenue bond," Carmen Nesbitt, March 18, 2024), but we found no sponsor statement saying so, and the 2022 and 2023 dollar amounts were not checked against bond documents.

Sources

Show all 11 sources
  1. S.B. 86 (2024) 3rd Substitute, proposed by Rep. Brady Brammer (the version the Senate concurred in): https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/sbillint/SB0086S03.htm
  2. LegiScan, S.B. 86 (2024): history and roll calls: https://legiscan.com/UT/bill/SB0086/2024
  3. S.B. 86 1st Substitute compared with introduced bill (le.utah.gov): https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/sbillint/SB0086S01_ComparedWith_SB0086.pdf
  4. S.B. 86 3rd Substitute compared with 2nd Substitute (le.utah.gov): https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/sbillint/SB0086S03_ComparedWith_SB0086S02.pdf
  5. Utah Taxpayers Association, "Alpine School District Plans to Ignore Voters and Defy Legislature," Malah Armstrong, March 7, 2024: https://utahtaxpayers.org/?p=11869
  6. Daily Herald, "Alpine School District cancels public meeting on $175M bond for new high school," Carlene Coombs, March 18, 2024: https://www.heraldextra.com/news/local/2024/mar/18/alpine-school-district-cancels-public-meeting-on-175m-bond-for-new-high-school/
  7. Salt Lake Tribune, "Facing criticism, Alpine School District may back away from $175M lease revenue bond," Carmen Nesbitt, March 18, 2024: https://sltrib.com/news/education/2024/03/18/facing-criticism-alpine-school
  8. S.B. 188 (2025) enrolled text: https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0188.pdf
  9. The Weber County Hive, Bait and Switch Part 3, Case 11 (S.B. 188 and H.B. 332): https://weber-county-hive.github.io/bait-and-switch/bait-and-switch-part-3.html
  10. S.B. 86 (2024) enrolled text (image-only PDF; could not be read as text): https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/sbillenr/SB0086.pdf
  11. S.B. 86 (2024) bill status page: https://le.utah.gov/~2024/bills/static/SB0086.html
Want the short version? Read it in plain words

Where this connects

Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.

Bills it stacks with

  • S.B. 188 (2025): The Fix That Was Left to Die — Lease Revenue Bond Amendments

People

Elsewhere on the Hive

Research tracker and docket

Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their sponsor roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism