Utah Hive Politics logoUtah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveThe people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not any party or special interest.
← All Follow the Deed cases  ·  Hive library ↗
FOLLOW THE DEED — CASE 02 · FD 500.01

The Backstop That Became a Bypass

A homebuilder used a family ranch, two landowner LLCs, and a 2024 state law to try to create its own town in Summit County. The bill that would have given the county a say failed in the Senate by a single vote.

Posted Sept. 5, 2026 · Updated Oct. 28, 2026

The short version

Read the plain-words version →

WHERE
Summit County · Browns Canyon · near Park City and Hideout · Statewide (Lieutenant Governor's Office, Utah Legislature)
WHO
  • Garff Rogers Ranch — Landowner; working cattle ranch in Browns Canyon, once 15,000 acres, now roughly 7,000
  • GRR-Lost Creek, LLC & E B R Management, LLC — Applicants of record; formed 8/25/2025, part of four near-identical "GRR-" entities
  • Matthew Garff — Ken Garff Automotive Group co-owner; family's named contact on state water-rights records
  • Ivory Development (Chris Gamvroulas, President) — Operator running the project; called the filing a "backstop"
  • Rep. Tiara Auxier & Sen. Kirk Cullimore — H.B. 510 sponsors (House and Senate); Cullimore voted yes, $1,000 Ivory Homes contribution on file
  • Sen. Lincoln Fillmore — Senate sponsor of H.B. 37 (2025); absent on the H.B. 510 vote; $500 Ivory Homes contribution on file
  • Rep. James A. Dunnigan — Primary sponsor of H.B. 37 (2025), which rewrote the incorporation-qualifications statute
  • Steve Waldrip — Gov. Cox's Senior Advisor for Housing Strategy; testified for H.B. 37 in House and Senate committees
00 — THE BILL

H.B. 510, "Municipal Incorporation Modifications" (2026)

Sponsored by Rep. Tiara Auxier (R-Morgan/Rich/Summit) in the House and Sen. Kirk Cullimore (R-SD 19) in the Senate.

In plain EnglishImagine a law that lets someone build a whole new town without ever asking the county for permission. This bill would have made them at least talk to the county first — but the county still couldn't say no.

H.B. 510 would have given counties a formal role before a "preliminary municipality" petition — the tool Ivory Homes used at Lost Creek and Philo Development used at Wasatch Highlands — could move forward. It did not give counties a vote or veto over whether the town gets created; that decision stays with the Lieutenant Governor's office either way. What it added was friction: a required coordination period, the right to commission a traffic study, and the right to audit and dispute the feasibility numbers.

68–0–7
House floor vote (unanimous among those voting)
14–12–3
Senate floor vote — failed, one Yea short

By the time it reached the Senate floor, the bill had already been narrowed by a substitute — see Section 03 below for what got stripped out before the vote that failed.

01 — WHO OWNS WHAT

The land, the LLCs, the developer

Lost Creek isn't Ivory Homes' land. It's a family ranch, held by two LLCs formed about four months before the paperwork was filed, with Ivory's own development arm running the project.

In plain EnglishA ranching family owns the land. Two paperwork companies were created just to file this request. A homebuilder is the one actually running the show.
8/25/2025
GRR-Lost Creek & E B R Management LLCs formed
1/1/2026
Preliminary municipality petition filed
2/5/2026
State declines — statewide cap already reached
2026
Ivory pivots to a standard county rezone request
8/7/2026
Rezone gets a negative planning commission vote

Tap any box below for detail.

The landowner
Garff Rogers Ranch (tap)
A working cattle ranch in Browns Canyon, Summit County — once 15,000 acres, now roughly 7,000. Matthew Garff (Ken Garff Automotive Group co-owner) is the family's named contact on state water-rights records.
The applicants of record
GRR-Lost Creek, LLC & E B R Management, LLC (tap)
Formed 8/25/2025 — four months before the petition was filed. Part of a family of four near-identical "GRR-" entities (Kamas, Lost Creek, Summit, Wasatch), same registered agent, same Salt Lake City address.
The operator / primary sponsor
Ivory Development (Chris Gamvroulas, President) (tap)
Not the landowner — the company running the project and speaking for it publicly. Gamvroulas has repeatedly called the preliminary-municipality filing a "backstop" in case the county's own rezone process wasn't "timely and predictable."
The filing
Lost Creek preliminary municipality petition (tap)
Filed 1/1/2026. 490.53 acres, Browns Canyon, near Park City/Hideout.
Timeline check: the water-rights lawsuit filed by an unrelated Garff-linked company, Mango-Spiral Jetty LLC, landed one week after this petition — 1/8/2026. No ownership link between the two has been established; noted here only because both surfaced from the same family's land dealings in the same short window.
02 — THE BID AND THE FALLBACK

What got filed, and what happened when it didn't work

In plain EnglishUtah only allows two of these town-requests per year, like tickets to a concert. Ivory Homes showed up after the tickets sold out.

Utah accepts only two preliminary-municipality petitions per year, statewide. Lost Creek was filed after that cap had already been reached — the state declined even to start a feasibility study.

490.5
acres, Browns Canyon
642
residents at full buildout (petitioned plan)
565
homes/townhomes/cottages proposed
2/yr
statewide cap Lost Creek fell outside of

Declined for a preliminary municipality, Ivory pivoted to something bigger, pursued the ordinary way: a standard Summit County rezone request covering up to 3,000 units across 407–600 acres, called the "Lost Creek Community Zone." That request received a negative planning commission recommendation on 8/7/2026, after 31 residents spoke against it at the hearing.

"It's a backstop — in case the county process isn't timely and predictable." Chris Gamvroulas, President, Ivory Homes — quote repeated consistently across Park Record coverage, Feb.–Aug. 2026

Tap any town below to see why it succeeded or failed.

🏘️
Wasatch Highlands (Philo Development)
ACCEPTED
Filed early enough in the year and met the technical filing requirements. Still moving forward.
tap for detail
🗺️
Bear Canyon (Ault family)
REJECTED
A mapping technicality — one boundary strip failed the statutory contiguity requirement.
tap for detail
⏱️
Lost Creek (Ivory Homes)
REJECTED
Filed after the state's 2-per-year statewide cap was already used up. Pure timing.
tap for detail
⏱️
Smooth Hollow
REJECTED
Same cap, also filed too late in the year.
tap for detail

None of these four outcomes turned on a county's opinion of the project. A filing-order quota and a map line decided three of them. Nothing has decided the fourth yet — and nothing currently in Utah law, including every version of H.B. 510 discussed below, would have given a county the power to decide it either. If Ivory Homes had simply filed a few weeks earlier, before the statewide cap filled, nothing on the books would have stopped Lost Creek — it would likely be sitting exactly where Wasatch Highlands is now.

What "preliminary municipality" actually means under Utah law

A 2024 state law (S.B. 258) lets landowners — one, two, or three of them, no more — petition the Lieutenant Governor's office directly to form a new town, bypassing the county's own planning and zoning process entirely. The state, not the county, decides whether the new town is "feasible."

Full statutory history, the four 2026 Wasatch Back applicants, and the fight over reforming this law live in the companion Bill-Tracker case file — see below.

03 — THE VOTE

One more "yes" would have added a county check. It didn't come.

In plain EnglishThe bill needed 15 yeses to pass. It got 14. One more yes, from anyone, would have changed the outcome.

H.B. 510 (2026) would have added friction to that process — a coordination period, a traffic study right, an audit-and-dispute right — but never gave counties an actual vote over whether the town gets created. It passed the House 68–0. In the Senate, it failed 14–12, one vote short of the 15 needed.

Four sitting senators who personally took campaign checks from Ivory Homes voted against the bill. A fifth didn't vote at all. Ivory Homes' own Senate sponsor for the bill voted yes.

Yea votes: 14 of 29 (15 needed to pass)
Click "flip" next to any Nay senator in the table below to see what one changed vote would have done.
How this is graded

This isn't a personal opinion of the bill. The grade below asks two questions, applied the same way to every bill in this series — not whether any one person likes the outcome:

1. Power: does it add or remove a check on power that the public, collectively, would otherwise have no say over?

2. Transparency: does it add or remove what the public can actually see about the process — posted studies, public hearings, disclosure requirements — regardless of who ends up holding the final decision?

Design and outcome are graded separately because a bill can be structurally sound and still fail to become law, or vice versa; collapsing the two into one score would hide which one actually happened.

If it had passed — the bill's design
C+ PARTIAL — ADDS FRICTION, NOT A VOTE

Even in its strongest form, this bill never gave the county a vote or veto over whether the town gets created — that decision stays with the Lieutenant Governor's office either way. On power, that's the core failure. On transparency, it does better: even the weakened Senate substitute kept the requirement that a county post the feasibility study online, and the original bill would have added a public traffic study and a formal dispute record. Real transparency gains — but they don't translate into anyone actually holding decision-making power over the outcome.

What actually happened — the outcome
F NO CHANGE FOR THE PUBLIC

Failed 14–12, one vote short of a majority. The underlying law is unchanged: up to three landowners can still bypass county planning to create a town, with no added county consultation, audit, or dispute right.

29 shown
SenatorVoteIvory Homes donation on file
Adams, J.S.YEANot individually checked
Balderree, H.YEANot individually checked
Blouin, N.YEANot individually checked
Buss, E.YEANot individually checked
Cullimore, K.A. — bill's Senate sponsorYEA$1,000 (12/27/2023)
Grover, K.YEANot individually checked
Hinkins, D.YEANot individually checked
Johnson, J.YEANot individually checked
McCay, D.YEANot individually checked
Pitcher, S.YEANot individually checked
Plumb, J.YEANot individually checked
Stratton, K.YEANot individually checked
Weiler, T.YEANot individually checked
Winterton, R.YEANot individually checked
Brammer, B.NAY$500 (9/20/2024)
Harper, W.NAYNot individually checked
Ipson, D.NAYNot individually checked
Kwan, K.NAYNot individually checked
McKell, M.NAYNot individually checked
Millner, A.NAY$2,000 total (2022–2024)
Musselman, C.R.NAYNot individually checked
Owens, D.R.NAYNot individually checked
Riebe, K.NAYNot individually checked
Sandall, S.NAYNot individually checked
Stevenson, J.NAY$1,000 (4/27/2022)
Vickers, E.NAY$1,000 (5/6/2022)
Escamilla, L.ABSENTNot individually checked
Fillmore, L.ABSENT$500 (7/19/2023)
Wilson, C.ABSENTNot individually checked

"Not individually checked" means that senator hasn't been run through disclosures.utah.gov for Ivory Homes donations specifically — it is not a confirmed zero. The House vote sequence and the weakened Senate substitute's specific text changes are in the companion Bill-Tracker case file.

What this does and doesn't show: it shows that senators who took Ivory Homes money voted against adding oversight to the tool Ivory Homes used. It does not show why any individual senator voted the way they did, and Cullimore — also an Ivory Homes donee — was the bill's own sponsor and voted for it. Any single vote switching would have passed the bill.
The gap

What would have actually made this better for the public

None of this was ever on the table in 2026 — missing from both the original H.B. 510 and the weaker Senate substitute that failed.

01
A binding county vote before incorporation
Every version of this bill left final approval with the Lieutenant Governor's office. Real oversight means the county's legislative body affirmatively approves — not just gets consulted, audited, or given a chance to object.
missing from both versions
02
A dispute that actually stops the process
The original bill's audit-and-dispute mechanism could pause the clock while a third-party evaluator reviewed a disagreement — but even a county that won that dispute couldn't block the town, only force a redo of the numbers.
toothless even in the original bill
03
No path around county land use authority at all
The most direct fix — and the one Wasatch and Summit counties are actually asking the Legislature for — is repealing the preliminary-municipality mechanism outright and routing incorporation back through ordinary county zoning, where "no" means no.
what the counties are asking for now
04
The $50K filing fee funding the county's side
As written, the fee only covers the state's own processing costs. It could instead fund the county's ability to hire its own experts to contest a feasibility study on equal footing with the applicant's consultants.
money already collected, pointed the wrong way
04 — THE NEXT STEP THIS LAW MAKES EASY

The same small ownership that bypasses zoning also makes a tax district trivial to form

Two separate Utah laws share the same structural quirk — and it isn't a coincidence worth ignoring.

In plain EnglishIf you and two friends own an empty field, you can vote to turn it into its own town. Then you can vote again — just the three of you — to add a tax bill to it. Nobody else ever gets a vote, either time.
🏘️
Form a town
≤3 landowners can petition the state to incorporate a preliminary municipality (§10-2a-502(2)(d))
=
🧾
Tax that town
100% of surface owners must consent to form a PID (§17D-4-201) — trivial when it's the same ≤3 people

A preliminary municipality, by law, can only be formed by one, two, or three landowners (Utah Code §10-2a-502(2)(d)) — that's what lets a company like Ivory Homes or Philo Development create one without going through a county at all.

Separately, forming a Public Infrastructure District (PID) — a body that can levy a special property tax on homeowners and issue bonds against it — requires a petition signed by 100% of surface property owners within the proposed district (Utah Code §17D-4-201).

In an existing neighborhood, getting 100% of owners to agree to a new tax on themselves is a high bar. On land that hasn't been sold to anyone yet — where the only owners are the same one, two, or three people who just formed the town — "100% consent" is nothing more than those same people signing twice. The preliminary-municipality law's small-ownership requirement and the PID law's unanimous-consent requirement fit together by construction: whoever controls enough land to form the town controls enough land to tax it, before a single resident ever gets a vote.

This is a structural observation about how two Utah laws interact, not a claim that Ivory Homes or Philo Development has filed, or intends to file, a PID on this land. Neither Lost Creek nor Wasatch Highlands has a confirmed PID on record as of this writing. The mechanism is available; whether it gets used here hasn't been shown.

The pattern is already live elsewhere in the same city: Heber City approved three PIDs on Sept. 1, 2026 for a separate, unrelated project — D.R. Horton's "The Highlands" — financing $22 million of a $40 million infrastructure cost through 31 years of special assessments on homeowners, in exchange for a non-binding promise to cut $40,000 off each home's advertised price.

05 — THE PID QUESTION: WHO ACTUALLY PAYS

Even a "straight" PID doesn't make the public whole

In plain EnglishA PID makes new homeowners pay extra property tax for their own streets and pipes. That sounds fair on its own. But it usually only covers what's inside the development's fence line — the county still has to pay for the road connecting it to everything else, and there's rarely enough left over to grow fire and police coverage to match.

There are two separate mechanisms people mean when they say "PID," and they matter differently here:

🏠
A "straight" PID assessment
An extra property tax, capped at 15 mills, paid only by homeowners inside the district. Funds bonds for infrastructure inside the district's own boundary. Doesn't redirect money away from the county, school, or fire district.
≠
↩️
Tax increment financing (TIF)
Freezes a base year, then redirects the growth in tax revenue above that baseline into a bond fund — instead of letting the county, school district, or fire district collect it. A real diversion. Not every PID has this; only ones structured with a tax-increment component do.

Here's the part that survives even if no TIF is ever attached: a straight PID typically pays only for infrastructure inside its own boundary. It does not typically cover the county road that connects the development to everywhere else, regional water-source development, or the added strain on countywide services like fire and sheriff coverage — those still land on whoever was already paying for them, unless every applicable impact fee gets fully assessed and actually collected.

Be blunt about what a TIF diversion actually does: when a county, school district, or fire district gets that growth revenue taken away, there are exactly two ways to close the gap — raise the tax rate on everyone who isn't inside the district, or cut the services that revenue would have paid for. There is no third option. In practice, both happen.

This isn't hypothetical. In Weber County's Nordic Village PID, an interlocal agreement pledges up to $30 million in future growth revenue from the school district and $6 million from the fire district into the PID's own bond fund. Neither entity gets that money back. They either serve the same growing population with less funding than they'd otherwise have, or they raise rates on every other taxpayer in the district — including people who live nowhere near the development — to make up the difference.

WHERE A DOLLAR OF NEW GROWTH REVENUE GOES — NO TIF
County 40%
School 40%
Fire 20%
WHERE IT GOES — WITH A TIF-BACKED PID (illustrative, based on the Nordic Village interlocal split)
Bond debt service 85%
10%
5%
County general fund School district Fire district PID bond debt service

Proportions above are illustrative, built to show the shape of the Nordic Village split (75% county / 50% school / 50% fire pledged to the PID) — not a claim that Lost Creek or Wasatch Highlands has this exact structure. Neither project has a confirmed TIF-backed PID on record as of this writing (see Section 04).

Wasatch County Manager Dustin Grabau said exactly this, on the record, about the Wasatch Highlands proposal specifically:

"That road has never been planned and does not have adequate right of way to accommodate a significant increase in traffic. If that's not included in the analysis, and they go ahead and proceed to build without making regional transportation improvements, that puts a burden on all the county residents to the benefit of three property owners." Dustin Grabau, Wasatch County Manager — Park Record, Clara Hatcher, 2/20/2026

Grabau also said the county has no adequate water/sewer infrastructure for this density and is under no legal obligation to build it, since the project sits outside the county's own projected growth area: "Honestly, I don't know that we would have the ability even if we wanted to." He separately noted that if impact fees like the Wasatch County Fire District's aren't assessed on the new development, "that may put a proportionate burden on the rest of the county through other tax sources to make up the difference of the increased service level."

The throughline: whether or not a PID or TIF ever formally attaches to Lost Creek or Wasatch Highlands, the same shape keeps showing up. New development creates real infrastructure and service costs. A PID assessment can cover some of it — the part inside the fence line. Everything outside that line, and everything a missed impact fee should have covered, gets paid by people who were already there, whether or not any tax-increment mechanism is ever used.
06 — THE THRESHOLD NOBODY NOTICED

A year before Lost Creek was filed, the statute's own floor moved

H.B. 37 (2025), "Utah Housing Amendments," rewrote the exact incorporation-qualifications statute the preliminary-municipality regime depends on to decide who's eligible — more than a year before the 2026 filing wave this case documents.

In plain EnglishA separate 2025 housing bill quietly lowered the population floor a piece of land has to clear to become its own town — the identical rule S.B. 258's fast-track process leans on. But a second, absolute floor buried a few lines down in the same statute was never touched, so the real minimum barely moved at all.

Rep. James A. Dunnigan's H.B. 37 was framed, and covered, as a housing-supply bill: density bonuses, moderate-income-housing reporting, a new state housing plan. Buried in Section 1, though, is a rewrite of §10-2a-201.5, "Qualifications for incorporation" — the statute that sets the population and density floor an area must clear to become a town or city, the identical statute S.B. 258 leans on to decide whether a preliminary-municipality petition qualifies. Senate/Floor Sponsor Sen. Lincoln Fillmore — one of the five senators already documented above taking an Ivory Homes contribution and sitting out the 2026 vote to add county oversight to that same regime — carried the final substitute.

100 → 75
Minimum population to incorporate as a town
5
Substitutes before passage

Confirmed directly from the Legislature's own tracked-changes comparison document for the bill (HB0037S04 compared with HB0037S05): the redline shows "[100] 75" — the old number struck, the new one inserted, exactly where the bill's own summary said it would land.

The catch, confirmed: the same statute keeps a second, separate rule a few lines down — Subsection (2)(a)(i), which flatly bars incorporation anywhere "the area has a population of fewer than 100 people." That line carries no strikethrough or bracket marks anywhere in the Legislature's own comparison document. This bill didn't touch it. Because that absolute bar controls regardless of the number in (1)(a)(ii), an area with 75 to 99 people still cannot legally incorporate as a town — the headline number changed; the real floor an applicant actually has to clear did not.

Steve Waldrip, Gov. Cox's Senior Advisor for Housing Strategy, personally testified in favor of H.B. 37 at both the House (Feb. 13, 2025) and Senate (Feb. 27, 2025) committee hearings — the same Waldrip now serving as state housing coordinator, and separately the subject of this Hive's reporting on his expanded statutory authority under H.B. 68 and the Aug. 2026 Wasatch County funding-threat episode. H.B. 37 took effect May 7, 2025; the Wasatch Highlands preliminary-municipality application (Case 01) was accepted eight months later, in January 2026 — the first of the four 2026 applications this case documents.

H.B. 37 didn't create the preliminary-municipality fast track — S.B. 258 (2024) did that. But it amended the same statute that fast track depends on to decide eligibility, more than a year before the 2026 filing wave. Two officials show up on both ends of this timeline: Sen. Fillmore, who sponsored the 2025 statute rewrite and then sat out the 2026 vote to add county checks on it, and Steve Waldrip, who pushed the same bill through committee in 2025 and was still defending the broader growth agenda it serves in 2026. Neither connection has been reported anywhere else.

07 — NOT JUST IVORY

Same law, same state, different family

→
The Chain Behind Wasatch Highlands
Philo Development used the same preliminary-municipality law on 2,700 acres near Heber — plus a separate 720-acre SITLA lease with a sitting Cox staffer on the board that oversees it. Read the companion case file.
§
CASE 2026-510: Municipal Incorporation Modifications
The full Bill-Tracker case files for H.B. 510 (2026, the reform that failed by one vote) and S.B. 258 (2024, the underlying fast-track law), each with their own rubric grading and complete vote records.

Questions to ask, and to whom

Updates since this was posted

Connecting stories

Sources (17 — tap to expand)
  • disclosures.utah.gov, Individual/Entity Contributions, 2018–2026 (Ivory Homes/Development/Southern, Kem Gardner, Christian Gardner, Clark Ivory, Ellis Ivory)
  • le.utah.gov, H.B. 510 official House & Senate roll calls, 2/27/2026 & 3/6/2026
  • le.utah.gov, HB0510-vs-HB0510S03 official bill comparison document
  • Utah Division of Purchasing, Wasatch Highlands Feasibility Consultant RFSQ #FB2630
  • Utah Division of Corporations, entity filings (Philo Development Group, Philo Venture Management/Partners, GRR- LLC family, Mountain Venture Studio Management)
  • OpenCorporates, officer/address searches
  • waterrights.utah.gov, address-change records (Exchange E5496)
  • Utah Code §10-2a-501 through §10-2a-511 (preliminary municipality statute); §17D-4-201 (PID formation)
  • Park Record, multiple bylines 2026 (Clara Hatcher)
  • KPCW, multiple bylines 2026 (Grace Doerfler)
  • SAM.gov, federal vendor registration (Garff Ranch Operations)
  • House Political Subdivisions Committee hearing record, 2/25/2026
  • Utah County Assessor / Summit County planning commission record, negative recommendation 8/7/2026
  • H.B. 37 (2025), "Utah Housing Amendments," enrolled bill text and HB0037S04-vs-S05 comparison document — le.utah.gov
  • House and Senate committee hearing records, H.B. 37, Feb. 13 & 27, 2025
  • Utah Code §10-2a-201.5, "Qualifications for incorporation," as amended
  • Office of Gov. Spencer Cox, staff/appointment records (Steve Waldrip, Senior Advisor for Housing Strategy / state housing coordinator)

The Weber County Hive — accountability journalism for Weber County, Utah. We report the filings. You decide what they mean.

Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism

The Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.

Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us

We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.

Follow the Deed shelf · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack