The governor picks Utah's judges, but the Senate has to confirm them, and every nominee goes through this seven-member committee first. In 2026 it is filling seats the Legislature itself created. Here's who sits there, what they asked, how they voted, how open the process was, and what the records show about the things said in the room.
Posted Nov. 13, 2026 · Updated Nov. 13, 2026
Utah does not elect its judges at first. A nominating commission screens the applicants and sends a short list to the governor. The governor picks one. Then the Utah Senate has to confirm that pick, and before the full Senate votes, the nominee sits in front of the Senate Judicial Confirmation Committee and answers questions under oath.
The committee's vote is a recommendation. The full Senate makes the final decision. For the two appeals courts (the Court of Appeals and the Utah Supreme Court), the committee holds two hearings: one for the nominee's personal statement, and a second for questions about judicial philosophy. The chair said so on the record on Nov. 10, 2026.
Three of the seven also sit on the Senate Judiciary standing committee and the Judiciary Interim Committee, the rooms that heard 2026's court bills (see CM 100.02 Judiciary). So some of the same senators who voted on how many judges Utah has, and how judges are evaluated, are now questioning the people picked for those seats.
| Name | Work (per the Legislature) | Also sits on | Why it matters here |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sen. Todd Weiler (R, chair) | Attorney | Senate Judiciary (chair); Judiciary Interim (co-chair) | Chairs all three Senate rooms a court bill or a judge nominee passes through. Sponsored S.R. 1 (2024), the last change to this committee's rules. |
| Sen. Brady Brammer (R) | Attorney | Senate Judiciary; Judiciary Interim | Primary sponsor of S.B. 233 and Senate floor sponsor of H.B. 540 (2026). His Utah Senators profile. |
| Sen. Kirk A. Cullimore (R) | Attorney | Senate Judiciary; Judiciary Interim | Senate Majority Leader. Same three-room overlap as Weiler and Brammer. His Utah Senators profile. |
| Sen. Don L. Ipson (R) | Businessman | — | Senate District 29 (St. George area), per his own introduction Nov. 10. |
| Sen. Karen Kwan (D) | Associate professor | — | One of two Democrats on the committee. |
| Sen. Daniel McCay (R) | Attorney / real estate portfolio manager | — | Said Nov. 10 he has served since 2012 and is retiring Dec. 31, 2026. |
| Sen. Stephanie Pitcher (D) | Not listed (said Nov. 10: defense attorney) | — | One of two Democrats on the committee. |
Members, parties and staff from the committee's 2026 page on le.utah.gov; work from the Legislature's member data file (legislators.json). Staff: Jonathan Adams and Jacqueline Carlton (staff attorneys), Lacey Johnson (policy analyst), administrative assistant.
From the governor's office notice of Sept. 15, 2026.
This grades the process only, from documents, using our standing transparency test: could the public see it, and is there a record of who did what? It does not grade the nominees.
| Question | Nov. 10 | Nov. 13 | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Was the meeting noticed in advance? | Yes | Yes | Notices created Oct. 29 (12 and 15 days ahead), per the PDF files. |
| Was an agenda posted? | Yes | Yes | Agendas 00003941 and 00003942 on le.utah.gov. |
| Did the agenda warn part would be closed? | Yes | Yes | Both agendas: "In accordance with Utah Code Section 52-4-205, a portion of this meeting will be closed to the public." |
| Was there a closed session? | Yes | Yes | Nov. 10 staff marker: closed "to discuss the characteristics and qualifications of the appointees." Nov. 13: the committee voted to close before Mareschal's questions. What was said is not public. |
| Was the vote to close taken in public? | Yes | Yes | Motions and votes to close and reopen are on the video (staff markers and captions). |
| Was written public comment taken? | Yes — Oct. 16 to Oct. 30 | Senate public comment notice. The number of comments was not stated; senators described it as more than usual. | |
| Did the public speak at the hearing? | No | No | No public testimony on the recordings we read. |
| Is each senator's vote on record? | No (voice vote) | O'Bannon No (voice) · Mareschal Yes (roll call) | Voice votes record only "passed" or "failed," not who voted which way. |
| Is video posted? | Yes | Yes | utleg.gov event pages, with machine captions. |
| Are minutes posted? | Not yet | Not yet | Nov. 10 minutes were approved Nov. 13 but were not on the committee page when we checked Nov. 13. |
Each card shows what was asked, what the nominee said, and how the committee voted. The ▶ links jump to that spot in the official video. We read the Legislature's machine captions and the staff's meeting markers; where they could be wrong, we say so. The official minutes will settle it when they are posted.
Bios from each nominee's own statement on Nov. 10, and for O'Bannon the governor's Aug. 15, 2022 release.
Weiler asked whether he would impose the death penalty if the facts and law called for it ("Yes") and whether there is any Utah law he would not enforce ("No"). Ipson asked him to rule promptly instead of granting continuances; Janzen said a good judge comes prepared and rules from the bench. Brammer gave a hypothetical (a statute that says 18 when everyone meant 21); Janzen said a judge follows the plain text and flags the problem to the Legislature through the courts' administrative office.
▶ Statement 0:01 · Weiler's questions 0:16 · Brammer's hypothetical 0:24 · Vote 0:35. A district court seat gets one hearing. The Third District gained a judge under S.B. 134.
He described his philosophy as separation of powers, with textualism and originalism as the tools. He said the Court of Appeals is bound by Utah Supreme Court precedent and he would write narrow rulings.
▶ Statement, Nov. 10 at 0:37 · Questions, Nov. 13 at 0:05 · Recusal 0:34 · Pitcher 0:38 · Vote 0:45
She described a step-by-step way of reading statutes: the text first, and only if it is truly ambiguous, a careful step outward.
Vote: The chair announced 5–2, with Sens. Brammer and McCay voting no. The machine captions show McCay as "yes" on the roll call itself, but McCay said just before the vote that he would vote no, and that he may vote yes on the Senate floor. We will confirm against the official minutes. ▶ Statement, Nov. 10 at 0:47 · Letters, Nov. 10 at 0:59 · David C., Nov. 13 at 0:04 · McCay 0:10 · Brammer 0:30 · Motion and comments 0:54 · Roll call 0:59
Nov. 10: Weiler and McCay in the room. Brammer left at the start for a court hearing and was back for Janzen's questions. Ipson and Cullimore joined online. Pitcher was in court at the start and later joined online (she said she was sick). Kwan was not heard on the recording. The vote to come out of the closed session was announced as 4–0.
Nov. 13: All seven took part. Ipson and Cullimore voted online. Weiler left near the end for another commitment and voted remotely.
From the captions; the official minutes will list attendance.
| Senator | Janzen | O'Bannon | Mareschal | S.B. 134 (new seats) | S.B. 233 (judge evaluations) | H.B. 540 (judge disclosures) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weiler | Voice | Voice | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Brammer | Voice (made motion) | Voice | No | Yes | Yes (sponsor) | Yes (floor sponsor) |
| Cullimore | Voice | Voice | Yes | Yes | Absent | Yes |
| Ipson | Voice | Voice | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Kwan | Not heard on video | Voice | Yes | No | No | No |
| McCay | Voice | Voice (made motion) | No* | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Pitcher | Voice | Voice | Yes (made motion) | No | No | No |
"Voice" means a voice vote where no one was heard opposing, so no individual vote was recorded. *Per the chair's announcement; the captions differ (see the hearing card). Bill votes are each bill's final Senate vote: S.B. 134 passed 21–8 (Jan. 26), S.B. 233 passed 18–7 with 4 absent (Feb. 24), H.B. 540 passed 20–6 with 3 absent (March 4), all from le.utah.gov roll calls.
Most of a confirmation hearing is philosophy, which no record can confirm. These are the facts, laws and cases people named, checked against the documents themselves. Each one is marked checks out, checks out with a note, or not checked yet. Nothing is marked false unless a record shows it. "Heard" says how we got the quote: machine captions (MC) with the video minute.
| What was said | Who / heard | What the record shows | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| The child welfare clock is 12 months, with two possible extensions, 18 months at most, and no way past that under the statute. | Mareschal and Brammer · MC, Nov. 13, 0:48 | Utah Code 80-3-409(7) allows a 90-day extension and one more 90-day extension; 80-3-409(13)(c) says the court must decide a termination petition within 18 months of removal. | Checks out |
| Utah was under a federal court order for over a decade because of David C. | Weiler · MC, Nov. 13, 0:04 | David C. v. Leavitt was filed in federal court in February 1993; the settlement was approved Aug. 29, 1994; an agreement to end the lawsuit was signed May 11, 2007; the case closed Dec. 31, 2008. | Checks out |
| National groups, including the federal Children's Bureau, have sent the states memos about timelines. | Mareschal · MC, Nov. 13, 0:06 | The Children's Bureau has issued guidance on the federal "15 of 22 months" rule, including a 2020 letter asking states to weigh termination filings carefully and Information Memorandum ACYF-CB-IM-21-01 (Jan. 5, 2021). She did not say which memo she meant. | Checks out |
| She took a father's case to the Utah Supreme Court, challenged even the standard of review, and Justice Lee wrote a unanimous opinion in her client's favor. | Mareschal · MC, Nov. 10, 0:53 | In re J.L., 2022 UT 12 (Feb. 24, 2022), opinion by Associate Chief Justice Lee; she is listed as the father's attorney. The court declined to change the standard of review, then affirmed in part and reversed and vacated in part. We have not yet confirmed the vote was unanimous. | With a note |
| A 2024 Utah Supreme Court decision took a broad view of who has standing to sue; Justice Durrant was the only dissent; four justices, including Justice Pohlman, were in the majority. | Brammer · MC, Nov. 13, 0:33 | He did not name the case. The one that matches is Planned Parenthood Association of Utah v. State, 2024 UT 28 (Aug. 1, 2024): Associate Chief Justice Pearce wrote it, Justice Pohlman joined, and Chief Justice Durrant dissented. The court called it traditional and third-party standing; Brammer called it associational standing. | With a note |
| Utah Code calls a parent's rights a fundamental liberty interest protected by both the U.S. and Utah constitutions. | Pitcher · MC, Nov. 13, 0:54 | Utah Code 80-4-104(1) and (4), and 80-2a-201(1), say exactly that. The "does not cease to exist" wording came in with H.B. 356 (2015). | Checks out |
| Foster parents' rights are not written into the code the same way. | Pitcher · MC, Nov. 13, 0:56 | This is a claim that something is missing from the code. We will not mark it until we have read the relevant titles in full. | Not checked yet |
| Nine years as director of Consumer Protection, then general counsel to Gov. Cox (over four years). | O'Bannon · MC, Nov. 10, 0:42 | The governor's Aug. 15, 2022 release names him general counsel starting Aug. 22, 2022, and says he had served nine years as Consumer Protection director. His years in Gov. Herbert's office are not checked yet. | Checks out |
| "Done five Supreme Court justices recently." | Brammer · MC, Nov. 13, 0:47 | Cox named Jay Jorgensen and Stephen Dent (June 2026) and Matthew Bell and Michael Menssen (Aug. 2026) after S.B. 134 and two departures. That is four in 2026; a fifth would be the appointment made in late 2025, which we have not matched yet. | With a note |
| Since her office started, the reversal rate in child welfare appeals went from single digits to double digits. | Mareschal · MC, Nov. 10, 1:05 | Needs court data we have not pulled. | Not checked yet |
| No appeals judge has had juvenile court experience since Judge Thorne. | Mareschal · MC, Nov. 13, 0:50 | Not checked yet. (Former Judge William Thorne filed a friend-of-the-court brief in her J.L. case.) | Not checked yet |
| About eight years on this committee. | McCay · MC, Nov. 13, 0:10 | Committee minutes list him as a member in 2023 (le.utah.gov). Earlier years not checked yet. | Partly checked |
These are plain facts from the record, listed so readers can weigh them. None of them, by itself, shows anything improper.
Grew the Utah Supreme Court from 5 to 7 justices and the Court of Appeals from 7 to 9 judges, and added district court judges. The governor's Sept. 15, 2026 nominee notice says the two Court of Appeals seats in these hearings "were created by the Legislature during the 2026 legislative session," and the Senate's Oct. 19 public-comment notice says O'Bannon and Mareschal would fill them.
Costs from the fiscal note on the 2nd substitute, the version the Senate passed 21–8. Full case file and grade on CM 100.02 Judiciary. One Utah State Bar e-bulletin gives a different reason for these two vacancies (two judges retiring Dec. 31, 2026); the governor's and Senate's own notices say they are the new seats.
Changes the certification standards for Court of Appeals judges and Supreme Court justices, and orders a study of reversal rates. These are the standards O'Bannon and Mareschal will be measured against if confirmed. Mareschal made timeliness a main point of her pitch; Brammer, the bill's primary sponsor, voted no on her.
Requires judges to file public financial and conflict-of-interest disclosures. Once these judges are seated, their forms become a public record we can read and grade, the same way we grade candidates. Kwan and Pitcher voted no on the Senate floor.
Would have required reporting on whether child welfare timelines are met, required reporting on child welfare appeals, and directed the courts to set up procedures so those appeals are decided on time. This is the same timeliness issue senators raised with Mareschal. The House committee did not consider it, and its enacting clause was struck on March 6, 2026.
For scale: the courts' own FY 2025 report says 52 of 73 decisions to end parental rights (71%) were made within the 18-month deadline.
Removed the requirement that the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel give each judicial appointee's résumé to the news media, and made technical changes to match the Utah Code. As a Senate rules resolution, only the Senate voted on it; its history shows it then went to the lieutenant governor for filing.
The Senate posts a public comment notice when each judge is appointed. This time comments were open for two weeks (Oct. 16 to Oct. 30). Comments go by email to senatejudicialnominees@le.utah.gov, or by mail to the Utah Senate Judicial Confirmation Committee, Utah State Capitol, Suite W210, PO Box 145210, Salt Lake City, UT 84114-5210. The Senate asks for your name, phone number and mailing address. Earlier, the nominating commission takes written comments on its list before the governor picks.
A roll call shows each senator's vote; a voice vote does not. The committee chair, Sen. Weiler, and its members can answer why some votes were by voice.
Senators described the volume but gave no number. Committee staff at the Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel handle the comments.
That was S.R. 1 (2024), sponsored by Sen. Weiler. He and the Senate Rules Committee can answer.
The full Senate's roll call will be posted on le.utah.gov. Your senator's office can explain the vote.
The bill's history shows it went to a House standing committee, was not considered, and was returned to Rules. The House Rules Committee and the sponsor, Rep. Pierucci, can answer.
Records read include three hearing recordings and their captions, two sets of staff markers, two notices, two agendas, four Senate roll calls, the S.B. 134 bill text and fiscal note, three bill histories, five Utah Code sections, two court opinions, the David C. case record, the courts' FY 2025 timeline report, and the governor's and Senate's notices. Claims and votes checked: 12 claims plus 42 senator votes (6 votes × 7 senators).
Hearing notes come from the Legislature's official video, its machine-made captions and the staff's meeting markers. Captions can mishear names and votes; where they conflict with what was announced, we say so and wait for the official minutes. Nominees and senators were not contacted for comment; this page relies on the public record only. Corrections welcome.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · JournalismThe Weber County Hive and Utah Hive Politics: the people's publication. We investigate what's best for the public as a whole, not for any party or special interest group. We report public records. You decide.
Send a tipTips we checkedSee a mistake? Tell us
We never name tipsters. When we correct a page, the fix and its date are shown on the page.
Committees Board · Master Index (Hive library) · Read on Substack