Bill Tracker · CASE 2021-115 · Annexation & incorporation
H.B. 115 (2021) added notice, a cost study and a public hearing before the county vote needed for a city to annex land in another county, gave mining-area and parcel owners consent and protest rights, and added a voter pamphlet before incorporation elections.
Posted Nov. 19, 2026 · Updated Nov. 19, 2026
| Bill | H.B. 115 (2021 General), "Municipal Boundary Modifications" |
| Primary sponsor | Rep. Steve Waldrip |
| Floor sponsor | Sen. Daniel McCay |
| Final votes | House 70-0-5 (2/16/21); Senate 28-0-1 (3/4/21) |
| Status | In effect · Signed 3/16/2021 · Laws of Utah 2021, Ch. 112 · Renumbered 2025 |
A simple sketch, not to scale. Built from the records on this page.
| Question | Grade | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Power | C | The county's approving vote on a cross-county annexation was already required; H.B. 115 kept it and added notice and a hearing before it. Adds owner consent for parcels and for mining protection area land. (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text; H.B. 359 (2020) 1st Substitute text) |
| Transparency | B | Written notice to nearby cities, a public hearing in the other county, more notice to landowners, and a voter information pamphlet before an incorporation election. (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text) |
| Financial accountability | B | A cross-county feasibility study must show costs and revenue for the county, cities, utilities and other entities; the applicant and county split the fee. The county may waive the study. (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text) |
| Environmental impact | C | No environmental review added. Mining protection area land stays under county rules unless the owner consents; the effect depends on the site. (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text) |
| Community impact | B | Landowners get more time and a second chance to be left out of an incorporation, and an incorporation cannot split a parcel without the owner's consent. (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text) |
Overall = the average of the five questions (A=4, B=3, C=2, D=1, F=0): 2.6, which is B−. A C means the record meets what Utah law already required. A B or A means it went beyond it, and the record shows it. D means something is vague or bundled, or a public check is weakened; F means something required is missing, or a check is removed with nothing in its place. Grades are the publisher's rubric applied to the record; they are not legal conclusions.
Quoted from the enrolled bill (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text).
Cross-county annexation, 10-2-402.5(2)(e) (now 10-2-805)
the legislative body of the affected county: (i) holds a public hearing in accordance with Subsection (4); and (ii) adopts the resolution described in Subsection (4)(a)(iii)(A).
Subsection (4)(a)(iii)(A) is a resolution approving the proposed cross-county annexation (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text).
Who counts as the "owner," 10-2-401(2)(a)(ii) (now 10-2-801(12)(b)): existing law, not new in H.B. 115
the lessee of military land, as defined in Section 63H-1-102, if the area proposed for annexation includes military land that is within a project area described in a project area plan adopted by the military installation development authority
This language was already in Utah Code before H.B. 115; it appears as existing law in another 2021 bill. It sits in a section H.B. 115 amended (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text; H.B. 235 (2021) introduced text (shows 10-2-401 as it read before H.B. 115); H.B. 368 (2025) enrolled text).
Feasibility study cost, 10-2-402.5(3)(e)
The applicant and the affected county shall share equally the feasibility consultant fees and expenses.
Voter pamphlet, 10-2a-210(4)(a)
the county clerk shall publish and distribute, before the incorporation election is held, a voter information pamphlet
| Date | Where | Result | Record |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feb. 5, 2021 | House Political Subdivisions (replace with 2nd Substitute) | 10–0–0 | (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page; House Political Subdivisions Committee minutes, Feb. 5, 2021) |
| Feb. 5, 2021 | House Political Subdivisions (recommend) | 10–0–0 | (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page; House Political Subdivisions Committee minutes, Feb. 5, 2021) |
| Feb. 16, 2021 | House, 3rd reading (3rd Substitute) | 70–0–5 | (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page; House roll call, Feb. 16, 2021) |
| March 1, 2021 | Senate Government Operations and Political Subdivisions | 7–0–1 | (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page) |
| March 4, 2021 | Senate, 2nd and 3rd readings under suspension | 28–0–1 | (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page; Senate roll call, March 4, 2021) |
House absent or not voting (5): Reps. Kera Birkeland, Jon Hawkins, Jefferson Moss, Mike Schultz, Doug Welton (House roll call, Feb. 16, 2021).
Senate absent (1): Sen. Evan Vickers (Senate roll call, March 4, 2021).
Every recorded vote was yes. The full lists of names are on the roll-call pages linked here. Numbers are yes–no–absent.
When a city wants to add land that sits in a different county. Built only from the records cited.
Does the county where the land sits have to approve?
Built only from the enrolled text (10-2-402.5, now 10-2-805).
flowchart TD A["Applicant sends written notice
to nearby cities in the other county"] --> B["Annexing city adds the land
to its annexation plan"] B --> C["90 to 180 days later: applicant
asks the other county to approve"] C --> D{"County waives
the study?"} D -->|"No"| E["Feasibility study: costs,
revenue, services.
Fee split 50/50"] D -->|"Yes"| F E --> F["County holds a
public hearing"] F --> G{"County vote"} G -->|"Approve"| H["Petition may be filed"] G -->|"Reject"| I["No petition"]
| Bill | Sponsors | Also on the record |
|---|---|---|
| H.B. 359 (2020) | Rep. Calvin Musselman (R-West Haven); Sen. Kirk Cullimore, substitute sponsor (H.B. 359 (2020) bill status page) | Drafting attorney Gus Harb. Developers' attorney Bruce Baird said he and his clients were involved in the process behind the bill. Our Mike Ostermiller page covers lobbying reported around the substitute (H.B. 359 (2020) bill status page; KPCW, Aug. 10, 2020) |
| S.B. 5004 (June 2020) | Sen. David Buxton; Rep. Steve Waldrip; Sen. Daniel McCay, substitute sponsor (S.B. 5004 (2020, Fifth Special Session) bill status page) | Drafting attorney Gus Harb. Senate 29–0, House 60–14 (S.B. 5004 (2020, Fifth Special Session) bill status page) |
| H.B. 6007 (Aug. 2020) | Rep. Calvin Musselman (Park Record); KPCW also reported Sen. Cullimore sponsored the repeal (H.B. 6007 (2020, Sixth Special Session) enrolled text) | House 65–10, Senate 28–1; the one Senate "no" was Sen. McCay (KPCW, Aug. 20, 2020) |
| H.B. 115 (2021) | Rep. Steve Waldrip; Sen. Daniel McCay (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page) | Drafting attorney Gus Harb. Worked on between sessions by the Utah League of Cities and Towns and the Utah Association of Counties (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page; Utah Association of Special Districts committee notes, March 1, 2021) |
| S.B. 213 (2021) | Sen. Daniel Thatcher; Rep. Steve Waldrip, floor sponsor (S.B. 213 (2021) bill status page) | Drafting attorney Gus Harb. Not passed; Summit County called it a backup to H.B. 115 (S.B. 213 (2021) bill status page; KPCW, March 22, 2021) |
| S.B. 258 (2024) | Sen. Curtis S. Bramble; Rep. James A. Dunnigan, final substitute (S.B. 258 (2024) bill status page) | Drafting attorney Thomas R. Vaughn. We found no record of who asked for the bill (S.B. 258 (2024) bill status page) |
| H.B. 37 (2025) | Rep. James A. Dunnigan; Sen. Lincoln Fillmore (H.B. 37 (2025) enrolled text) | Amended 10-2a-201.5, the section H.B. 115 and S.B. 258 share. Steve Waldrip spoke for it in committee, per our Unelected Power page (H.B. 37 (2025) enrolled text; Steve Waldrip (Unelected Power)) |
| H.B. 368 (2025) | Rep. Stephen L. Whyte; Sen. Lincoln Fillmore (H.B. 368 (2025) enrolled text) | Moved annexation law to new section numbers (H.B. 368 (2025) enrolled text) |
Gus Harb is a legislative staff attorney; drafting attorneys write bills for the sponsors. Appearing in this table together is not a claim that anyone acted together.
H.B. 115 marks rules H.B. 115 (2021) added. Built from the enrolled H.B. 115 and S.B. 258 2nd Substitute text (H.B. 115 (2021) enrolled text; S.B. 258 (2024) 2nd Substitute, the version passed).
| Rule | Adding land across a county line | Regular new town | S.B. 258 developer town |
|---|---|---|---|
| County where the land sits votes to approve | ✓ Required (before 2021 too) | — Not part of this process | ✗ No county vote |
| Notice to nearby cities and a county public hearing | ✓ H.B. 115 | — | ✗ Hearings are run by the Lt. Governor instead |
| Cost (feasibility) study | ✓ H.B. 115 County may waive it | ✓ Required | ✓ Its own study |
| Mining-area owners can say no | ✓ H.B. 115 | ✓ H.B. 115 | ✗ Not in S.B. 258 |
| No splitting a parcel without the owner's OK | — | ✓ H.B. 115 | — Every owner signs up front |
| Landowners can ask to be left out | — | ✓ Already allowed; H.B. 115 added more time and a second chance | — Every owner (no more than three) signs up front |
| Voter pamphlet before the election | — | ✓ H.B. 115 | ✓ When it becomes a town |
"Regular new town" means incorporating under Utah Code Title 10, Chapter 2a, Part 2. An S.B. 258 town is formed under Part 5, and S.B. 258 says Chapter 2, where the annexation rules are, "does not apply to a preliminary municipality" (10-2a-509(8)). S.B. 258 can't be used in Weber County, a second-class county (10-2a-502(2)(b)).
See the full S.B. 258 case file: CASE 2024-258.
Section numbers in 2021, and after H.B. 368 (2025) moved annexation law to new numbers (H.B. 368 (2025) enrolled text). A repeal bill has to use the new numbers.
The 2025 version of the cross-county section also says the county may approve regardless of what the study finds (H.B. 368 (2025) enrolled text).
| Person | Role in this record | Elsewhere on the Hive |
|---|---|---|
| Rep. Steve Waldrip | Primary sponsor of H.B. 115; House sponsor of S.B. 5004 (2020); floor sponsor of S.B. 213 (2021); spoke for H.B. 37 (2025) as the governor's housing adviser, per our Unelected Power page (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page; S.B. 5004 (2020, Fifth Special Session) bill status page; S.B. 213 (2021) bill status page; Steve Waldrip (Unelected Power)) | Steve Waldrip (Unelected Power) |
| Sen. Daniel McCay | Senate floor sponsor of H.B. 115; substitute sponsor of S.B. 5004 (2020); the one Senate "no" on the 2020 H.B. 6007 repeal, per KPCW (H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page; S.B. 5004 (2020, Fifth Special Session) bill status page; KPCW, Aug. 20, 2020) | |
| Rep. Calvin Musselman | Primary sponsor of H.B. 359 (2020); voted yes on H.B. 115 (H.B. 359 (2020) bill status page; House roll call, Feb. 16, 2021) | |
| Sen. Kirk Cullimore | Senate sponsor and substitute sponsor of H.B. 359 (2020); voted yes on H.B. 115 (H.B. 359 (2020) bill status page; Senate roll call, March 4, 2021) | Kirk Cullimore (Utah Senators) |
| Rep. James A. Dunnigan | Voted yes on H.B. 115; House sponsor of S.B. 258 (2024); primary sponsor of H.B. 37 (2025), which amended the same incorporation section (House roll call, Feb. 16, 2021; S.B. 258 (2024) bill status page; H.B. 37 (2025) enrolled text) | S.B. 258 (2024) |
| Sen. Curtis S. Bramble | Voted yes on H.B. 115; primary sponsor of S.B. 258 (2024) (Senate roll call, March 4, 2021; S.B. 258 (2024) bill status page) | S.B. 258 (2024) |
| Sen. David G. Buxton | Chief sponsor of S.B. 5004 (2020) (S.B. 5004 (2020, Fifth Special Session) bill status page) | |
| Sen. Daniel Thatcher | Sponsor of S.B. 213 (2021), the backup bill (S.B. 213 (2021) bill status page; KPCW, March 22, 2021) | |
| Bruce Baird | Attorney for developers Nate Brockbank and Josh Romney; said he and his clients were involved in the process behind H.B. 359 (KPCW, Aug. 10, 2020) | Mike Ostermiller (Unelected Power) |
| Gus Harb | Legislative staff drafting attorney on H.B. 359, S.B. 5004, H.B. 115 and S.B. 213 (H.B. 359 (2020) bill status page; S.B. 5004 (2020, Fifth Special Session) bill status page; H.B. 115 (2021) bill status page; S.B. 213 (2021) bill status page) | |
| Victoria Ashby | Utah League of Cities and Towns; spoke to the bill in committee (House Political Subdivisions Committee minutes, Feb. 5, 2021) | |
| Jake Garfield | Utah Association of Counties; spoke to the bill in committee (House Political Subdivisions Committee minutes, Feb. 5, 2021) | |
| Shelly Teuscher | Wasatch County; spoke to the bill in committee (House Political Subdivisions Committee minutes, Feb. 5, 2021) |
Posted Nov. 19, 2026. Public records only; no comment was requested from anyone. Enrolled H.B. 115 and the S.B. 258 2nd Substitute read in full as text extracted from the Legislature's PDFs. Bill status pages, roll calls, minutes and news articles fetched the same day. H.B. 368 (2025) and H.B. 557 (2026) read in part.
Other bills, people and Hive pages tied to this record.
Bills are listed when this page names them. People are listed by their roles in the legislative record. Appearing together here is not a claim that anyone acted together.
Utah Hive Politicsfrom the publisher of The Weber County HiveIndependent · Accountability · Journalism